Jamie Draws A Knife On Claire | Outlander

Jamie's not happy with Claire's decision about Jack Randall, in this clip from Season 2 Episode 5. The Official Outlander Channel: helping YOU survive Droughtlander!
Season 2 Episode 5: Untimely Resurrection: After the dinner party, Claire tends to Mary (and Alex), while Jamie deals with Charles' plotting. A visit to Versailles leads to turmoil for Claire and Jamie.
Welcome to the official Outlander channel. SUBSCRIBE to relive all the greatest moments from the show.
Outlander is internationally distributed by Sony Pictures Television.
#Outlander #ClaireAndJamie #SamHeughan #JamieFraser #ClaireFraser #CaitrionaBalfe

[@zeynepsude4367]

God why doesnt claire just tell him that if frank hasnt existed then claire wouldnt have came to scotland and wouldnt have met jamie?!?! Then jamie wouldnt touch him anyway

[@naylamuslima]

Right!!!???

[@naylamuslima]

She' so clumsy sometimes!

[@emarochela3942]

Zeynep Sude they do it for dramatic effect. To have conflict, to move the story along. It’s all a part of making it interesting.

[@diannebdee]

@@naylamuslima The show is clumsy because the source material is crap.

[@channie_edits]

She didn’t think about the consequences

[@shaun.shub2003]

"I can stand a lot more than most I've proven that much but must I bear everyone's weakness ,may I not have my own?" Goosebumps

[@helaasgard273]

True

[@barboraGR]

True, very true. How far must the man's pain comes, how much must one man bear.. And how much he must sacrifice, to give everything from himself, from his soul, from the very him for LOVE. This is devotion, passion, forgivness, honour, all the values which Jamie represents in this show. Really touching ❤️❤️ great actors 👏

[@pohordebbarma4505]

Love how Jamie gets angry, the character played by Sam really is very convincing, the accent, way of behaving, the way of thinking of that century Talented actor ❤️❤️

[@asmrsounds8345]

I've watched so many shows, had platonic feelings towards many main men characters but no one, NO ONE was and probably will be like Jamie...

[@oliva1745]

Same here.

[@DeeDiamond2981]

Ikr.

[@ylenia7834]

Jaime has an incredible charisma, he knows how to speak the language of the hearts

[@helaasgard273]

Agree. Love his character

[@bdarlene22]

When I saw this, I was afraid Jamie would not be able to forgive Claire for holding the debt of a life over his head. I really felt for Jamie here

[@helaasgard273]

Always. Claire wasn't right here. If fate wanted Frank to be born, he would've been born anyway. Plus, as it turned out, Frank was not even Jack Randall's descendant.

[@justineoneill1069]

Agreed

[@justineoneill1069]

@@helaasgard273 Claire was shocked when she found out that Mary Hawkins was carrying Alex Randall’s baby not Jack Randall.

[@emarochela3942]

This scene was so heartbreaking 😢

[@tsnhal9600]

I have a huge problem with this show!! I love it so much, because in scenes like this one, I can not take anyone's side!! For me, both Claire and Jamie have right!! Everytime they argue, they have their own point of view! And I like that!! That's why I love outlander!!! It creates and builds characters with pros and cons!! And of course perfect acting from Caitriona and Sam!!

[@helaasgard273]

They ARE right, not have!! Learn English

[@winnielynnie3907]

@@helaasgard273chill. What the hell is wrong with you?? Have you not considered that the person who wrote this comment might not be from a country where Englisch is spoken? And even if they are, it was a small mistake that could happen to anyone. I don’t get why you have to spread such negativity here? Your comment was just extremely rude.

[@therra1101]

@@helaasgard273 Seriously? Have you never made a mistake? Maybe the person is not a native speaker. Why be so nasty?

[@BrightNeonBrilliancy]

Seems a weird lapse in logic for me that Jamie wouldn't realize their entire life together would be erased in Frank didn't exist. She was only in Scotland BECAUSE of Frank. Surely asking to delay a man's life by a year is a small price to pay when it means losing Claire and everything they've done together? I know it's harsh and unfair, but I thought they'd at least MENTION this possibility.

[@piahubner8003]

But on the other hand poor Jamie was nearly killed by BJR and is still in pain, depression, sexual crisis and constant nightmares - The chance of taking revenge would be a great satisfaction and balm to his soul.

[@pilzhut7863]

2:55 this jesus, god claire is so good

[@barboraGR]

The video should contain also the part where Claire tries to touch Jamie and he says "Do not touch me." So moving - all this scene, so great piece of art from both of actors, so emotional. Hat off to Sam and Cait ❤️❤️❤️👍

[@lyzee9129]

After this Immaa rewatch the couple therapy, if you know what I mean

[@rosacosta8639]

That vid is so awsome hahaha sassenach winks

[@ediedarling]

« She spents a lot of time making sure Frank was born »

[@FacebookQueen]

I just watched that before coming here 😂

[@Vinylrecordsftw]

I recently watched this episode and this scene is really hard to watch. I hate when Claire and Jamie is fighting. Makes me feel sad.

[@diannebdee]

I hate when Claire makes Jamie do things that goes against his ethics. Face it without Claire coming to Wentworth, Jamie wouldn't have had to give himself to Randall.

[@franciswinston1040]

She goes to this extent to save Frank and yet people think she doesn't love Frank?? She even lost a baby trying to save Frank. If that's not love, I don't know what is.

[@iunn0]

Wait how exactly again I forgot omg

[@deepthiambati4217]

Great point!!!

[@nessyness5447]

She loved him that much and yet she didn't care about letting him suffer wondering about her sudden disappearance during their vacation ( i mean, all her things in their room, the car alone in the middle of a road..., I would think the worst options) so she could be happy with jamie.

[@kylephantom4]

@@nessyness5447 tbf she didn't know how the time travel thing worked. Like she wouldn't know if the stones would have taken her back to the moment she left or not

[@nessyness5447]

@@kylephantom4 she seemee pretty sure of it before she decided jamie was hot enough to just give up and stay there.

[@slee7996]

Incredibly well played!!👏🏻

[@AnyelaVega]

I agree! Perfection

[@camillabarclay4049]

Please please someone somewhere gibe sam heuggan an award he really is Jaimie

[@camillabarclay4049]

Of course she is utterly brilliant also

[@lauroandrea3241]

Catriona is such an excellent actress. She is is more dimensional than Jamie in many scenes. She carries all her scenes be her mere presence alone

[@aleksandarzdravkovic8149]

Give us season 6 !!!

[@salua9922]

Corona virus 🙂💔

[@gracepuerom2779]

Yessss🤩🤩

[@dabors2sm29]

Can't wait!

[@sandraviktoria4623]

It’s coming early 2022.

[@ninonino7252]

22.09.2021

[@piahubner8003]

This clip ends to soon, we want to see Jamie kissing the sword!!!

[@raoullevan6550]

She asked something impossible. Sure she never thought one second, that Jonathan W. Randall might not be Frank's REAL ancestor. Jamie accepte her demande because hé loves her. What better sign of true love?

[@mimyeko894]

She had no way to know it firstly And that's not impossible, if he killed him there, he would have never met Claire It's just really hard that he has to wait for his revenge but well...

[@user-mo7el3sw9i]

I mean, Frank literally has Jack's face, of course she never thought that they are not directly related

[@franciscaestrada6086]

at the end, Claire is the one making the future stays as they known.

[@dominiquebottega9386]

Quel désespoir dans sa voix Claire plaide la vie future de Franck c'est émouvant et Sam accepte par amour pour elle c'est tellement beau 😍

[@rosaroldan1420]

No me entero de nada porque está en inglés pero con verlo a el me basta,es perfecto 💘💋💜🌄😃💘🔫⚔️😘💋😍💙💞💥👄👄👄

[@KAriedoll]

How is it that no one talks about poor Fergus? If Jamie had taken Randall's life at the time, Fergus would not have been hurt a little later on. But it's a shame Claire wouldn't have known at the time that Frank wasn't actually...

[@aliasmarg8ta127]

If Jamie never took Fergus into his family, Fergus would not have been in that room with Black Jack Randall, Jamie would not have challenged BJR to a duel and Claire would not have lost her baby. It's a domino theory

[@Touichi-pc8ct]

She traveled through the stones because Frank and her were in Scotland .Frank showed her the stones

[@juliadeoliveirasp]

YES! That's the point. I hate that she doesn't know at time...

[@giuliapicchiotti]

I understand both of them !! ; They both have a point !!! .

[@user-vr1bw8uv3q]

Актёры великолепно играют! 👏👏👏❤

[@calibreman]

Caitriona Balfe, a beautiful woman and an amazing actress. Hubba, hubba.

[@chriss1672]

Ikr she's makes brianna fraser actress seem really bad

[@v9mpire651]

I realized claire is the reason why everything happened. Idk its like a loop and she still doesnt get it lol

[@elisabetshavez4648]

Por favor.. para cuando la 5 temporada en Mėxico.?? La sigo esperando en Netflix!!! 😢

[@tania38513]

la montarón en fox premium

[@Amylou690]

What did Jamie say in Gaelic???

[@samgrey5597]

Beautiful ♥️😥

[@sandrabarbosa459]

Sandra do Recife adoro vocês dois🥰👍🙏❤🥰🥰

[@sisterspoof23]

1:57 god hes being so dramatic

[@simoneknospe954]

Sie hätte besser recherchieren müssen denn dann wäre es klarer gewesen das Frank von Randalls Bruder abstammt.Und so wären viele Dinge nicht geschehen

[@zahoza9578]

Plz quel season ? épisode ?

[@sneccik4902]

Saison 2 épisode 6

[@eflatunbeyaz3543]

I started to watching outlander in the last month i am in the season 5 now but i miss young claire and jamie already 😩😩 they have aged them so quickly.. and i didnt like to watching america’s story.. i have interested story of scots and characters in the first two seasons

[@Veritas1164]

What does Claire mean that she saved Jamie twice. Unless she means that after saving him she brought him back from suicidal thoughts. Also at end of S1 she thought Black Jack was dead so that would mean Frank was too. Though in the end we know that it doesn't matter if BJR is dead where Frank is concerned.

[@krislanc1239]

I think she knew he wasn't dead but said so to Jamie to calm him. She knew he died in Colloden and not by the bulls, even told Jack how he was going to die

[@veroniquenarbonne3429]

It is acted with such maestria! ... but it's also the scene which convinced my husband he couldn't watch anymore of it: he can't stand Claire's behaviour!

[@lucialveroy]

WHAT. She's the most reasonable. He wants to do something that could put him in jail when they are already searched in the UK, only to get revenge as if that would erase the suffering he has from his trauma. Jaime should be THANKFUL for having such a partner that does SO MUCH for him. They both do, they're an amazing team.

[@ISangaloUnofficialFR]

@M it's different here. She didn't know black jack randall wasn't frank direct ancestor........if there is no frank, there's no claire and jamie, since he is the reason they travelled to scotland in the first place.

[@INTHESALLOW]

Then your husband didn't understand anything ma'am...

[@irisgomez5089]

Keeping score and demanding the impossible from Jamie is a true low point in Claire's behaviour. How selfish of her to choose Jamie and yet bargain for Frank. Say what you will but Claire has been truly selfish in France...so sad that she had to lose Faith in order to realise the consequences of her actions. Notice how Jamie didn't contradict her when she said the whole Faith incident wasn't even BJR's fault bit her own..he quickly forgave her.. meaning she is responsible....

[@veroniquenarbonne3429]

@@irisgomez5089 I agree!

[@normanbates569]

He knows how to treat a woman. If he's not drawing a knife he's spanking her. A man's man.

[@dr.classylife2471]

In conclusion through out the show everything happens as it is supposed to happen something called fate , Frank was BJR's brother's son so he would have certainly existed but the events would have turned out in some other way , Claire couldn't change the future during the entire course of the show ,so what's to happen will happen with or without Claire 🤣🤣 **The logic of the book is very poor hence all this confusions 😆

[@helaasgard273]

Never liked Frank and I was absolutely on Jamie's side on this one, too. Jamie's always right. Claire only a few times.

[@darhkblu]

I mean the thing is tho no matter how much we may or may not like Frank him not exsisting just for the sake of getting rid of their imidiate problem of Jack breaks time as its Claire marrying Frank and going on that trip thats the reason Claire even ended up in the past...

[@channie_edits]

I think it's unfair that she asks him that. He want to recover the peace and those by killing Black Jack Randall. Her husband now is Jamie not Frank. She couldn’t ask him that. It’s unimaginable ! Furthermore, if Claire leaves Jamie killed Black Jack, Faith will be still alive

[@Heidiklemp]

But remember that it was on Frank and Claire's second honeymoon she went through the stones. She probably wouldn't have been in Scotland, if it wasn't for Frank. And therefore, Frank was the reason that Jamie and Claire met in the first place...

[@ceciliafattori5413]

Exactly Heidi, and we saw how illegal it was dueling in France, If Jamie killed BJ there he would be in prison forever and Claire wouldn’t be able to save him

[@lucialveroy]

You're definetly not saying that Claire's miscarriage was her own fault, are you?? Revenge will not save Jaime from PTSD

[@channie_edits]

Luci Alveroy no

[@adoragrayskull]

If frank was never born, they never would've met

[@juliadeoliveirasp]

Man... If she'd already known that Frank wasn't a direct descendant of Randall, or even if she didn't care about him and let Jaime get his revenge right then... Fergus wouldn't have been attacked. This makes me very angry with her.

[@yaminoonna3218]

This is the moment where I truly disliked Claire.. she irritates me in this scene. She doesn't realize that future/time can never be changed. By her asking Jamie to spare Randall's life, that's already what happened in history.. that's how he ends up dying in culloden. Because from the beginning, claire spared his life even before she falls through time. Time is like a loop and very complicated.

[@crystalawen]

? She’s a disgrace

[@kristine8338]

What a stupid conversation. Overacting all along…

[@Telly5strartist]

She doesn't act like a nurse. little logic

[@normanbates569]

Correct. She has empathy and is insufficiently callous. Good try though.