Overanalyzing SMG4 - It's Gotta Be Perfect

[@CiblesYT]

Thanks for 10K Subscribers! Hope you enjoy the double upload^^ Join the Discord - discord.gg/AuVd8pGz7G

[@Edd_The_Cat]

Congratulations!

[@terrimama2174]

ciblesyt can u make who is parents smg3

[@codycolchdolc9395]

I love your videos man

[@JinSeiryuu]

What is scary about this is probably Luke might have already had this breakdown irl like I said his screaming at his friends sounded so real it's as if he truly experienced this routine before

[@OverDriver05]

This really speaks so much of how the SMG4 fanbase is so divided, it made Luke working so hard to the point of subtly lashing out on his haters without even doing one! That really speaks of Luke's professionalism and respect to his fanbase, and I respect him for that!

[@HeroTheHedgehog999]

Imagine blaming the fanbase for this…. it’s already pissing me off….

[@scratchblack6601]

i agree

[@yinyangyt8749]

I know how you feel Cibles. I am glad you relate to this. And I love your work a ton. You are loved by me and I will still support you. You will always be awesome in my eyes

[@Snt1_]

Its the Yin Yang Yt

[@GameMaster-sh7tr]

I’ve seen a lot of people drawing connections between SMG4 and Niles with their obsession with perfection. The similarities are there and while I don’t think SMG4 is being controlled I do believe he will go down a similar path to Niles. Becoming so obsessed and doing anything he can to reach his thought of ‘perfection’ he becomes a former shell of what he was. This can end up being figuratively or literally considering what we’ve seen with Niles.

[@hy2rochlor1c]

1:54 exactly! that’s what i was thinking! people keep talking about “oooh maybe its zero controlling smg4” or something but i feel like it would be a much deeper and more relatable arc if it was just smg4 and his own mental health. not every conflict needs a main villain.

[@scratchblack6601]

smg0? people been telling me that nightmare Fredbear is the one that is controlling him

[@hy2rochlor1c]

@@scratchblack6601 wtf

[@Shantae-June22002]

Agree, I keep saying to people that Zero is dead

[@RileysYourDreams]

@@Shantae-June22002 and besides it wasn't even zer0, Niles is dead too.

[@Shantae-June22002]

@@RileysYourDreams That’s what I was also saying, zer0 and Niles are both dead.

[@SlothRRYT]

The fact you uploaded 2 videos this day about it, you are such a hardworker and if you keep it up you won't fall and will remain amazing!

[@awesomeocelot7475]

Honestly my theory is that SMG4 was like overworking himself and going crazy over the perfect video and then went off on everyone during Mario Day and then due to his exhaustion and stress and mental breakdown the (very likely) entity was able to take control of him.

[@markgill346]

Like I have stated on other theory videos SMG4 is starting to act like Niles, the true villain of the Cosmology Saga (Genesis and Revelations arcs), Niles just wanted to make everything perfect for him and his friends but only made things worse, he accidently killed SMG0's avatar: Fred, turned SMG0 into an Eldritch God, destroyed SMG1 and SMG2's home (These two were oblivious to Niles existence and thought this was all SMG0's doing), turned Axol into a monster and tried to destroy Mario's world, possessed and manipulated Melony and tried to kill Mario and the others. SMG4 is starting to alienate himself from the others because he has been consumed by a similar desire, if this "Perfect Video" goes wrong, there will be chaos.

[@simpleviewer1334]

Fun Fact: SMG4 has acted in a similar way during the Stupid Mario Stupid Show he busts out of his room after supposedly working in there during an entire Mario game where he decidss to run the show in a similar attitude as the movie

[@RoastCM]

Smg4 may not be possessed by zero but he is becoming his own version of zero

[@hyhyd6135]

Wow.. I had a feeling this was the implicit meaning behind his movie/perfection arc but... this is a lot to think about. I hope your channel does continue to survive. You seem like a really nice person.

[@SMG001Nick]

This is a REALLY GOOD theory. Great job!

[@CiblesYT]

Thanks!

[@darrenavila3536]

This actually does seem true because there has been something I’ve noticed from last year. In early 2022, smg4 videos especially the Mario does things, we’re getting over 1 million views in less than 24 hours. But later in the year, (wotfi 2022, and the Mario does things being exceptions) the main Saturday episodes have been getting less views recently being at least less than 800,000 views in 24 hours. So I can really understand why he needs this video to be perfect.

[@Okeana_Aster]

Oof when you lay it out like that... It's relatable. A while ago, I made 3 big videos that concluded a lot of the ongoing developments of my characters in my SM64 Bloopers. The first one performed pretty well considering my number of subscribers, but the other two... not so much. These were my biggest videos ever, especially the last one, and the community, as small as it is, keeps asking for SM64 Bloopers, and when I gave these two them, they stopped caring pretty quickly it seems.

[@SebDa125thGojiGamer]

Ye, that’s a GREAT theory, so it can be one or two things: 1. SMG4 is growing obsessed (and slowly insane) to make this ‘perfect video’ that he just wants to focus on that, and not anything else. 2. Maybe there IS another dark entity driving SMG4 slowly insane, and maybe that ‘perfect video’ might play a part in bringing that entity to their physical world, and it might be either 0 or something else far more powerful. Hyped for the movie, and a fantastic video!❤❤❤❤❤

[@RedbearRickyYT]

1:53 there was an outside source, a lurking evil corrupting SMG4 causing him to act that way. but it was was lead-up to by an over-obsession that caused him to lock himself in his room, away from others that don't understand him and causes him to get angry at everyone.

[@Chipleyinahole]

Thankyou for this

[@TPRules17]

SMG4 is turning into Niles! Don’t worry Cibles, I’ll always be there for you!

[@CSX64]

Great video love your deep analysis

[@CiblesYT]

Happy to hear it!

[@liamconnollyst]

Interesting theory since Luke mentioned this year will be different starting with this movie in which SMG4's "perfect" video will be revealed and this does relate to some other online video makers I sometimes feel like Luke/SMG4's mental health might have some minor change into the series as a whole but I still think the OC's corrupted by Niles/SMG0 or maybe he's out of his own mind to make the video

[@starcam...7680]

Or possessed by someone else

[@scratchblack6601]

or Maybe its a new villain

[@starcam...7680]

That's what I think too

[@Skypatroller_BenCD]

Honestly I'm already in a mentality that NOTHING can be perfect but the most important is that you enjoy what you're doing, also as a KZbinr myself i don't care if my videos does great or not as long that I'm doing what i love well i don't care about what people think

[@Charaster]

At moments like these I always wish I had teleportation powers so I could just give you a hug

[@cubecueb]

0:39 that channel was you???😭😭😭

[@luxury_nightmare]

What’s funny is, the force that corrupted smg4 didn’t make an appearance until he was passed his lowest point. Whatever it was, it was taking advantage of what was already there

[@demixjon]

For the movie i think that SMG0 is back Niles specifically because in this arc they both have something in common "Perfection".SMG4 wants to create the perfect video whereas Niles wants to create the perfect universe and what do you need to create a new universe in the SMG world an avatar and mario is the avatar and Niles had already had his shot to get mario as the avatar but what if Niles possessed SMG4 to manipualte him into creating the perfect video with potentially the meme energy to create a new avatar and try to erase the old one.

[@Shantae-June22002]

Zero is dead along with Niles

[@amazingboisbackup]

2:02 to 2:15 that hit hard for me because as a youtuber my self I relate to that

[@GamingRedBirb]

Honestly yeah i agree. Sometimes I get upset when i put my heart and soul i to a video im super proud of and it gets like 2 views Then when i make a short rushed video it gets a good amount of attention every now and then, its dismotivating sometimes

[@DeviemTwen]

Guys I think this video’s gotta be perfect.

[@SRim91]

As a content creator, i can relate to how you feel, basically 2022 was the year i got to shine, i used to get like 500 to 1k views per video with 100 subs but now my videos sometimes barely hit 100 views even at 300 subs and combine that with school and personal stuff, it just puts me into depression

[@shadowfollower117]

You could also say that this is a cry for the hate for the lawsuit arc, not to mention the character redesigns, and that this mini arc is inspired by said events(tbh that's unfortunate if so) but give or take as you see fit with a grain of salt.

[@TARISLAYS]

Wow…I didn’t think about it like that, I feel the same sometimes but I didn’t fully get it, nothing has to be perfect. In fact, flaws are what make things better. You’re human. And it doesn’t matter if it’s perfect or not. That’s an opinion!

[@OscAiko]

Don’t worry Cibles! I still love your SMG4 theories!

[@jeffersonsilvarodrigues9329]

3:20 an end of a poem

[@Theplushyshow69]

Good job hitting 10,000 subscribers I love your channel man you are awesome. I will stick around for a while I love your content I hope you read this

[@feistypetmeme]

I swear I saw a weird thing in the corner of the stream and for the life of me I can’t find it

[@MajorLeagueGamingTrap]

I feel like that

[@CatKun10]

As a person who used to be a KZbinr I gotta say i’m glad I kind of stopped because I might’ve gone a little bit insane trying to one up myself

[@SonicEXEProductions]

I think smg4’s desire to be perfect made the monster along with the keyboard

[@vanessamaesuleiman1475]

Wow!! Really good job is theory PERFECT!!

[@breadlorde1095]

i think this arc would be called the tv arc.

[@minipz9thebastfiiter509]

Finally something that isn't related to cosmology lore!!!!!

[@kashsnyder6541]

I mean it’s only been 14 minutes and it has 146 views. So pretty good

[@scratchblack6601]

as a youtuber myself i understand

[@BurningR3d]

So Is this what happends to me when I grind gets me to mad

[@unmemevivente2551]

Still the best part of Puzzlevision saga hands down

[@texus835]

Less advertisement might help, I mean he has a new thing every video as far as I noticed.

[@dootdoodle569]

Damn girl you good???

[@SorielHDTBers]

Cibles is willing to say “fuck off” on KZbin, but he has to say “unalive” because KZbin doesn’t like “kill”. Makes sense

[@sharkanenoa5928]

This insanity is going to manifest something horrible, something that could potentially be worse than the SMG0

[@vova_gladchuk]

Smg minus one

[@ThatoneTset]

The Insanity Arc

[@PixilFalls]

I feel this

[@nateclone3828]

If there is some kind of demon of dark force causing Luke to be like this, I will actually get legitimately upset. The team has an opportunity to spread the message that the urge to make something your best work can cause you to isolate yourself. This movie shouldn't have a villain. Hell, this entire movie could be set inside SMG4s room. Not to get poetic here, but if they take the right steps forward and present the right message, this WILL be a perfect video.

[@AnEnigmaOnYoutube]

Mario and SMG3 will have to team up to face the eldritch monstrosity that SMG4 has become. No Niles, no SMG0, it's all in SMG4's head, and he will be the main villain of this movie.

[@Joshua_Reyes_Productions]

I like it ☺️

[@NathanOfADown]

cool

[@gkuniverse3181]

Damn this got real deep

[@Vinsalazar19]

If this was the case in the movie, then it will be one of the new best modern SMG4 video ever but not just modern it will be the Second best smg4 video (number 1 being the Da Glitch)

[@Mr.encore]

Yey I think this movie and this arc will represent smg4 feelings on the fanbase but also how old toxic fans complain about how they want old smg4 and also smg4 just having a crissis about if hes even good to began with because theres also people saying how smg4 is overeated and is says how hes like south park and even make rant vidoes and also make pardies of currnt smg4 and thinks this is what Luke is thinking cough cough beenxie

[@Mr.encore]

And theres a youtuber Adamcartoons and he's does review but with the smg4 ones he doesn't get what makes smg4 smg4 he says about how he wants old smg4 back and complains about how smg4 cant take itself seriously kike awalys and the comments falsely agree with him without actually doing research and even made 3 vidoes and in his third vidoe really pissd me off the most he said how smg4 sub will nearly hit 7 mill by the time glitch hits 2 mill and says how his view had less and he just laughing like he wants it to fail and I know he's a kid but still and even now he pertend that he's invested because of the voice lines and he's not adamcartoons If your heraing this fuck you

[@Mr.encore]

Like seriously he was laughing about how smg4 sub will nearly hit 7 and laughing and smiling that smg4 has less views sometimes like he's he's psychopath old smg4 fan that wants it to fail just like what the other toxic old fans like

[@hybridvenom9]

GO INGTO PERFECT

[@zero2oot]

To be honest, the movie kinda disappointed me. It was good and I enjoyed watching but I really expected it to be kinda like a mental journey for smg4. This could've been something that could have a big effect (ik we lost the castle but still hear me out) like smg4 going to therapy to gain his sanity back fully. Smg4 being possessed isn't a bad plot line but it's happened over and over where someone gets possessed and they either die or is about to die. A cool concept that he could've used was the black eye shit could've been smg4's meme energy being out of control due to him losing his mind. Alot of missed opportunities but I really loved it non the less

[@SMG0763]

Yo I hope SMG4 is Okay.

[@MrBallerinakaka]

First Movie Was Released In Leap Day 2020 Now We're Getting 4th Movie Now! (Like Bamse They Getting Another Movie This Year) :)

[@epick_420]

I subscribed

[@Skull_studio706]

I hope smg4 doesn't die like the others 😰

[@SIoth_boi]

I swear to god if they bring zero back there basically milking Zero.

[@michelk.8008]

Zero is Dead. We won't see him again

[@Carsonrr2]

True :(

[@esmax3000]

Bruh I thought that smg4 said "it's GONNA be perfect"

[@ChoosingBerry]

EVERYONE GET THIS GUY MORE VIEWS ON HIS VIDS!!! I understand the hard doings of content creation as I am one myself and it feels so repetitive so help This man get more views on his work for (IT'S GOTTA BE PERFECT)

[@wrorl]

Yes I really understand this but does it makes all youtubers have to ask to subscribe only for money? money isn't important and don't do "work" for money..

[@jameshenry9157]

👁️

[@MarioFanYT]

*Pat pat* man

[@jerrysolomon8140]

Falnz😔😢

[@Julio_Man_Gamer]

Its niles controlling him its not smg4

[@lukey6970]

Proof?

[@michelk.8008]

Niles is dead and you know it

[@Julio_Man_Gamer]

@@michelk.8008 no then why he become evil?

[@denysvision]

@@Julio_Man_Gamer smg4 doesn't become evil, get yourself the definition of evil, smg4 is just obsessed with he's perfect video

[@Redder_Creeps]

Sorry if i may be dumping this on whoever sees this comment, but honestly i can safely say that i've never related to a video THIS much, especially content-wise due to how much my channel has flopped last year

[@G1nshi]

Yeeeeeeeeees first

[@seraphinax20]

Yippee second 🥈

[@tarbamichaelwijesunderajr]

We Kill The Lore Is Sometimes|You Lore/Canon Series MWJRCU/Michael Wijesundera Jr Cinematic Universe Series

[@tarbamichaelwijesunderajr]

Replace SMG4 Called Dr Straw Replace Dr Bright Called Dr Elias Shaw

[@kenzonPower]

I'm also a KZbinr