P1 - Animal Rights!! Brother Mansur & Vegan Girl | Speakers Corner | Hyde Park

[@easyak]

Black muslims brother we need more of him very knowledgeable brother.

[@peelfreshvita3199]

He lacks patience, didn't let other people finish their sentence, keeps repeating his first words until the other people stopped. The girl is the same. No matter how knowledgeable he is, if his words can't get through, there's no point in debating or any discussion in the first place

[@bilaal3488]

@@peelfreshvita3199 He got confused a lot with what the girl was saying, and so did the girl. It seemed to me both weren't listening too keenly. It was hard to watch as a third party.

[@rayandaas1695]

Gary babatunde, Brother in Islam Black or White are the same, Prophet Mohammed (PBUH) forbade any type of discrimination because of race 1400 years ago

[@easyak]

Rayan Daas shut up man who is discriminating you weirdo. Im bigging him up and saying we need more of the knowledgeable brother.

[@ShehryarShaheen]

@@easyak black brother mate... Black or white brother is brother that's what he meant

[@AmericaFirstFree]

The lady said, you should avoid more suffering. Accord to her, killing a cow/animal cause more suffering then killing plant. The real question here is, how do you know which one is more suffering when you kill, a animal or a plant. The answer is you don't know. She said she don't believe in morality, in other word she don't believe something is bad or good. If this is the case, why is she arguing anything in the first place.

[@greatliar]

If lions cannot know what is right or wrong, they the do not have to chase and run around for food. They can just eat grass and be like cows. If lions do not know what is wrong, they can befriend the crocodiles and swim in the lake together. What a reason!

[@TamilanMalayali]

@@greatliar What is she saying ?? what if we injected some drug to an animal to not feel any pain while killing, is that okay ??

[@helsharidy123]

@@TamilanMalayali then they would say no because it's not about pain or suffering. They're just emotional for these animals and all of these arguments are scape goats to the real problem.

[@karankapila6450]

Well....plants do not say don't eat us...we are in pain but apparently animals defend themselves just like you would if i were to cut you and eat you....

[@AmericaFirstFree]

karan kapila then that give me more reason not to eat and cut plant because they are handicap by not speaking.

[@gilgameshlfx7006]

Obviously lack of protein.

[@SolarLight11]

Nice one

[@ozozturk8177]

Haha the world's strongest animals are plant base diet. It's a myth like Santa. Don't believe the hype. Public Enemy!

[@thothtrismegistus929]

science today shows that plants also feel the pain. So, basically vegans can't eat anything.

[@peace8655]

Maybe lack of vitamin B12, DHA and EPA

[@fayezgd9990]

There will be protein in vegan diet ,it’s a healthy diet,how ever meat shouldn’t be restricted ,a lot of vitamins could be defechint ,Vit B12 Vit D3 Ca

[@saiydsbasix2884]

I actually think ants are more intelligent than some humans.

[@slingshot5520]

Agreed

[@SF-jf3xv]

Ageeed

[@saedm2359]

Okay that's far fetched, don't be silly lol

[@wardatulim]

Actually they are 😂

[@Amin-yz4bo]

including her

[@everyisofficialme1868]

She's not there to talk, she just came to 'Have Fun'. Never Sincerily Listening ~

[@x7p7p]

@Hanaldai Munamana interesting question we need to ask the scholars

[@SummeRain783]

This entire video just made me crave a big juicy steak. That’s all I could think about. InshaAllah tomorrow

[@AL77727]

Loool

[@exclusive8260]

I broke my fast to MANY different kinds of JUICY MEAT FROM ANIMALS, LOADS OF MEAT. Very delicious, i thank the animals for the sacrifice for the MEAT they provided my family. Such JUICY meat of many different animals. Now im hungry so i shall eat chicken and beef.

[@Maf99_]

Ami Khan it’s Ramadan please, stop teasing us with steaks.

[@ShehryarShaheen]

It's ramadan jeez....

[@suehashim9577]

😂😂😂😂😂

[@Basalat]

She keeps switching her views after every minute, man!

[@dorian2112]

you have to when you are asked ridiculous questions that are bouncing all over the place. adjust accordingly.

[@semiribrahim8956]

@@dorian2112 not really... everything the brother says is completely logical and correct.

[@KryptonKr]

Ted Striker2112 All of these muslims’ questions in that video is ALL relevant to what those vegans believe in. They’re pointing out that their beliefs are completely nonsensical. Their beliefs has no ground to stand on, as if it came out of nowhere. It’s YOU, that don’t understand the questions. Do you know why you don’t understand? You don’t listen FIRST, and then THINK about the question and respond to it logically. If you HAD listen and understood what those muslims were saying, you wouldn’t disagree with them at all. Guess what? Everyone HAS an EGO. They, including you and me don’t like to be wrong especially in public since that is what they were preaching. It will embarrass them if they were wrong. It’s all about EGO in the end of the day. If ONLY people start to be more humble to themselves more, the world will be a better place.

[@kj8451]

Lack of brain cells due to nutritional deficiencies i guess.

[@SouravMondal-rc7io]

Yes it happens when you are asking questions from a book not from the real world.

[@SillyTubereal]

I remember when these vegetables used to say that veganism is about "causing NO harm." Now they've realized that they do cause harm so now they say "causing LEAST harm".

[@hamzayounis4085]

yep, will be dangerous to follow their paths, eventually it will be outside what was intended!

[@arshad_nazran]

shifting the goal post...

[@mohammedabdulahad3918]

dont argue please stay hungry if you are so compassionate . simple as that

[@vasifarshad3362]

Complete protein sources include: Meat Seafood Poultry Eggs Dairy Products Being a Doctor

[@drcheekyisback]

Wasif Arshad 😂😂😂😂

[@tapandutta9385]

Human flesh too is a source of protien. I will eat meat too if it comes from muslims

[@muhammadmafaz8530]

@@tapandutta9385 according to your own objective morality you can eat human. But our objective morality based on creater who prohibited eating humans.

[@allylude1672]

Legend has it that this man is still saying, "that's why!"

[@kennethwhite8045]

*BABBLING JANE* The western women love to argue and create unnecessary contention.

[@davidgara3004]

shes not even western

[@davidgara3004]

she does not have a mental illness and plants dont have a complex nerves system like we do so they dont really feel pain

[@davidgara3004]

you really just embarrassed your self with this comment first of all im not a vegetarian secondly like i said before plants dont have complex nervous systems like mammals or other creatures i did not say they dont feel pain i just said they dont feel the kind of pain we are able to feel, they cant feel complex pain. same thing with fish they cant feel pain like we do and thats why people cut open fish and lobsters while they are still alive because they cant feel complex pain....... havnt you ever seen some one throw a live lobster into a boiling pot of water? Its not because that person is inhumane its that lobsters dont have the kind of pain receptors as we do so it dosnt matter and the same thing goes with plants.....so its funny how your trying to tell me to get knowledge when you are the one that is clearly lacking...

[@davidgara3004]

when did i ever say anything about respecting animals wishes? you just made that up because i eat meat..... and i never backed peddled i said that plants dont have a complex nervous system and they dont really feel pain meaning they dont feel the the kind of pain that we know....... and they are not like us is an argument you idiot the kind of pain plants feel isnt suffering pain that animlas can feel plants dont have a nervous system or brain so this is literally impossible they only react via stimuli..... the reason we feel pain is that we can avoid that source and stay away plants cant move so it would make no sense that a plant would feel pain like us that would just be torturous to the plants.....

[@suehashim9577]

If you are worried about animals n plants feeling the pain don't eat n go hungry.for good 😂😂😂😂

[@SankiKingOfficial]

She doesn’t know how to stay quite for a second!

[@servantofallahthemostmerci7725]

Dear Vegans keep eating Veges There's nothing wrong with that as long as you keep it to yourself. But do not talk about others food choice. Nature is designed that way.

[@sohrabg6228]

Bro ur literally killing an animal who doesnt want to die for ur taste buds? How in the world are we forcing an opinion while u are forcing a knife at someones throat? Are u delusional or something or just dont grasp the point here?

[@pessimistkai5569]

patience of mansur is incredible!

[@pulscorn2076]

mr shabir yusuf would destroy their argument in 5 min....

[@bo_kandar]

Vegan is a religion now I guess😂 bruh....

[@zeke1145]

Obviously it's a wya of life brother.

[@muhammadhnooh9560]

No, it's a sect in Atheism

[@SouravMondal-rc7io]

Yes, you can also be a vegan. Show some love for animals 😥

[@SouravMondal-rc7io]

@Asad Ahmad Brain washed . Be open to outer world. Don't feel the universe in a book.

[@squidproxy136]

@@SouravMondal-rc7io sorry to say but you accuse us of something that you should do your self "Be Open"

[@ilmunaifi]

Some people just love argueing , know matter the subject 😂

[@romanrejapov8376]

So much emotion coming out of this girl

[@umairmodi]

Really sick sadist woman 🤣👌👍

[@zantonio1310]

She said that killing animals are wrong. And she said that killing plants are like nothing...well i'll say that people like this woman are making the animals suffering. I wanna ask you guys...where do animals live? In the jungle, savana, forests and woods. Now...do the woods, forests and jungles have plants? I say yes...so if killing plants is nothing and you dont care if there is no plants...then you are cruel and you are the cause of the animals suffering...the want their HOME!! So they are taking animals world...so that means she and those people that have that kind of ideology are WRONG!!! May Allah guide us all...inshaallah

[@bryanspoty]

Fresh-Cut Grass Smell is Your Lawn’s Shriek of Despair, Science Says

[@Soloman827]

There are 20 to 23 types of amino acids and most of them are only found in meat not in other foods

[@SouravMondal-rc7io]

Then you should eat human flesh. It contains more nutrition ☠️

[@Soloman827]

@@SouravMondal-rc7io Well I hope you agree that humans are superior to animals.Plz don't compare humans to animals.Thats not a valid comparison as humans are conscious,intellectual creatures who can brainstorm,debate,think intellectually so that is a false notion

[@SouravMondal-rc7io]

@@Soloman827 yes humans are superior because we have humanity which contains common sense. So if you have a common sense that animal feels pain too, then stop killing them.

[@SouravMondal-rc7io]

@Asad Ahmad yes killing plants hurts you. But killing animal hurts them.

[@Kashur9891]

@@SouravMondal-rc7io how do you know it doesn't hurts plants???

[@sulemanpatel]

The basis of her argument is that why would you choose to inflict pain on another living creature if you don't have to? This has nothing to do with religion, this is a question about your individual moral compass. Logically, there really is no argument because she is right! The main reason we continue to eat meat is because we enjoy it, it tastes good and we've grown to expect it. In many cultures having some kind of meat on the table is a sign of wealth. Islam does not ban the consumption of meat, but the Prophet (SAW) said it was “food of the Kings”, which implies meat consumption should be treated as a luxury and not the main part of a dish. Nowadays if the wife cooked a meal with no meat on the table the husbands get annoyed an ego takes over saying, "I work all day and you give me vegetables". Ultimately, the argument is simple. The Qur’an reveals that all living animals are sentient beings, just as human beings are. “There is not an animal on earth, nor a bird that flies on its wings - but they are communities like you.” (Qur’an, 6:38)

[@MSA_madi]

Death is a natural thing, which might be hard to accept for humans, but it's a fact of life that no one can deny.

[@fasahm642]

With her Logic not eating animals like cows sheep chicken... why would farmers breed these animals They will be left to Fend for themselves

[@corvoadam5598]

So if i live in the desert and there are only animals who eat grass, iam to die with hunger instead of eating them?

[@noureyahhussein1284]

corvo adim i guess you could eat the grass according to her

[@deserteffect1001]

looooool

[@corvoadam5598]

XD and just to point out, they proved that plants do feel pain.

[@sapienthought1103]

according to her eat grass man or die

[@alexxela7596]

hhbp3 Or smoke it like I am sure they do.

[@mateen2007]

Vegetarians give me headache and make me go have steak 🥩 yummy

[@TrueSuccess7]

Tapan Dutta people like you give me headache and make me more stupid if I continue to read stupid and ignorants comments like yours.

[@TrueSuccess7]

Believers of the nonsensical world where it is impossible living because there is no harm and so there are no new lives and there are immortal people that never die, right? Death is suffering because it cause sufferings to the people that were his close friends and family members.

[@blackberry5908]

Did you know that. Vegetarians and vegans may have an increased risk of stroke The types of stroke were also analyzed, including bleeding into the brain (hemorrhagic stroke) and nonbleeding stroke (ischemic stroke). Compared with meat eaters: rates of heart disease (such as angina or heart attack) were 13% lower in pescatarians

[@narayanlaxmi4990]

Propaganda

[@blackberry5908]

@@narayanlaxmi4990 Facts will remain true whether you like it or not.

[@wardatulim]

She's one of the reasons why global warming happens with her logics

[@drakoontag]

"I haven't heard a single argument from you lot", BECAUSE YOU ARE TALKING OVER EVERYONE!! May be that's the reason you can't hear!

[@AbuTaher-tb7xf]

A bit misleading with the title... Brother Mansur hardly spoke

[@sadatanwar7611]

How is suffering measured? If we don't eat chickens and the chicken is allowed to live longer, how do we measure its suffering in terms of years of accrued stress/fear due to weather and avoiding predators, and its ultimate death due to being eaten by a predator or it simply dying of illness? Is dying of old age/sickness easier and more comfortable for the chicken than being killed slaughtered by a human? How do we know this exactly?

[@imanatheistaskmeaquestion5999]

Sadat Anwar Apply this same reasoning to killing a child and you might see the problem

[@darkchocopuff1510]

@@imanatheistaskmeaquestion5999 What is the REAL reason for us to take a child's life? People kill animals for consumption, there is a reason there. Unless your brains got damaged that you can't tell apart the differences between a chicken and a human child or having a delusion to think it was your mom or sister getting milked when you saw a dairy cow, I pity you, although I know you Vegans love to put yourself on same level of animals. Well if you really think we are on same level of animals then go copulate and defecate in open like a cow then. Walk on four, get naked, eat from dirt, fight and kill each other, incest with your family, rape like a duck, etc. The only reason we would see a human as animal or treat human like an animal is when he@she acts like an animal. So don't try play your delusional vegan game saying it is a 3 year old children get roasted instead a pig on the grill because a humans is 100000× different than an animal.

[@imanatheistaskmeaquestion5999]

Dark Chocopuff There are many factors involved in morality: suffering, necessity, consequence, sanctity of life, hierarchy of life, potential for life, intent, awareness etc. In every situation, we're trying to find what is the moral thing to do. The point you're missing is there is a sanctity to human life that we adhere to, but you're rejecting the sanctity of all life, suffering, to name two. Your point was the REAL reason to take the life of an animal is consumption, but this reason is void since we can be healthy eating veg. So then it becomes a choice. You seem to be rejecting some of the principles that dictate our moral actions like, suffering, sanctity of life, hierarchy of life, necessity etc. You're free to do so, all we're trying to do is show the inconsistency in your moral principles

[@noelkurupp5648]

Morality is based on one's Greed ,hatred and delusion. These are the fundamental reasons for immorality.

[@noelkurupp5648]

What are you trying to tell ?

[@belogical2396]

What is the name of tha brother with shades? I mean who is wearing brown shade classes and is addressing that women in the video? Who raised the question that are all species equal.? Plz tell me his name ! He is really intelligent

[@SP-nn2zi]

"I am healthy"--vegan jokergirl she is literally the skinniest girl i've ever seen

[@begoodtoyourself9591]

Where is part 2???!!😓

[@sislam9633]

Vegans need to learn to integrate in KFC.

[@azizrampage]

lol

[@serazvictoria9845]

whos this black man? i like what he spoke.. anyone knows name of this brother?

[@stanfrollpans1569]

If it's not wrong, then what's the problem? If it is wrong, then why is it wrong?

[@r2ak786]

That woman is a smart woman may Allah guide her to Islam. What she is saying is true we are allowed to eat animals but it’s a choice the way we consume meat now days is over excessive and disgusting it is more noble to the lord if we choose not to make them suffer. Her point is very valid. Even prophet Muhammad saw said we shouldn’t eat meat too much. Ali as said an addiction to meat is like an addiction to wine and look now a days cattle are being crowded up and slaughtered in mass numbers and that is injustice in itself they are being born to be eaten. As Muslims we should be able to survive on the produce that Allah swt has provided us with and we should eat meat on special occasions. So what she’s saying is from a sincere heart.

[@hamzi123-d9z]

The vegan way is not the right way: 1- because if we don’t eat animal (i’m not saing that we have to eat them all the times) then we will have a over growth of the number of animal, there for we have to kill more plants and animals that lives in thoses plants ( ants, ....) to feed those animal ( if someone gonna respond but we still have to kill plants to feed animal in order to eat them : yes but if we didn’t eat animals we will have less plants then animal and we need plants to leave more then animal it is a survive instance) 2- if you want to stop the suffering of animal then you have to kill the other animal that causes other animal from suffering. 3- she said killing plants is less suffering then killing animals ( who told you so ) Finally my question is if you are in a place where there is no food and you have in front of you an animal would you eat it to live ? So when it’s not a question of causing suffer it’s a question of serving then you can eat it ? If you stand by what your saing you have to not kill it and you have to die both of you cause the animal will die also cause there is no food ( according to you you are not superior to the animal so why you should eat it even for living he have to live also ? )

[@ubaidshah1910]

Hamza Arazi 1.) the only reason there is so much cattle is because of overbreeding for meat demands. If meat demand disappears, so will the animals. 2.) i dont know what you mean by that 3.) plants dont have a brain, they cant feel pain Im a muslim, but i was on a vegan i dont agree with them but we need to stop giving sht srguments

[@diefaust4252]

Does anyone know the black Brothers name?

[@farhathasnain515]

Dying naturally is also painful..isn't that suffering...

[@ThereWillBePeace1]

In the animal world as soon as the number of predators reduce the number of other species below the predator increases. E.g when the number of foxes fall the numbers of rabbit increase almost exponentially. This we have all learnt at secondary school. And we have also learn when things like this occur it disrupts the food chain as a whole so these rabbits will have more babies and they would destroy more food in farmland. As humans we are part of the food chain, if we stop eating for example beef, the number of cows would increase without natural management an the grass of our land would be completely exhausted. When there is no grass the risk of landslides would increase and number of smaller creatures that feed on grass would die off. The livestock, if left alone, will inevitably becomes a pest. Pests in the sense that the large quantity of animals would need food and eat crops from farmland which would legislate the 'culling' of these animals for the sake of protection of crops. This would lead to an unethical killing of sheep's, lambs, cows through culling. As we see in nature some animals can only eat meat for example Lions, Leopard and Wolves these animals can never become vegen, and these rules cannot be applied to them. If we did apply these vegen rules on them we would be at war with nature, and ultimately doing greater harm than good. I can understand why vegens do what they do, and in Islam and most religions we believe to not cause unecessary suffering but applying the strictness of vegenism would create more harm than good in society as a whole. There are places in the world were animals are killed for no reason only that they have exceeded in number where some genuine harm is caused to the ecosystem. Therefore these creatures have to be put down to prevent harm to the environment. When they are put down they are neither eaten nor any benefit to anyone. This is definitely more morally wrong that something is killed for no reason. animal dies with no reason not even to be eaten. Please look at the Camel crisis is Australia. A world which is purely vegen would result in more deaths to animals from the process of culling rather than eating. The former (culling) is worse than the later, as at least the latter is helping another specie survive. Nowadays I can understand, even in Islam, that because of the many companies wanting to increase profits animals are kept in very harsh conditions and given antibiotics and growth hormones. In Islam this form of farming we understand to be harming animals and causing suffering and in the religion should not do. I think rather a campaigns to stop this is the priority and Christians Muslims and all belief system will agree to this fact that we should stop harming animals like this, as e.g battery hens suffer a lot. I respect vegen as they care but in the long term vegenism most possibly fail. However more should be done on the conditions of livestock nowadays.

[@weldjibla6425]

Why in the hell don't you listen woman !? I guarantee that she's having some problems in her relationships :D But let's go and have a nice juicy burger to eat, as my sister Iram said in the comments, it'll fix things up so well :)

[@blackberry5908]

Did you know that. Vegetarian women had some degree of iron deficiency anemia - 60% were mildly anemic and 40% were moderately anemic. Non-vegetarians experienced far less iron deficiency anemia, with 47% mildly anemic and only 7% moderately anemic.

[@RealSyedHaq]

*I'm pretty sure Ants & Dogs are smarter than her unlike she claimed otherwise*

[@khalidm2667]

امل منكم الترجمه الى العربية ... جزاكم الله خير ايه القائمين على القناة

[@saiydsbasix2884]

I am sure she is inflecting suffering on vegetables every day I am sure of that.

[@Recham]

13:40 she killed an insect

[@_us.m.an_]

Now I'm gonna consume just meat for a whole month!

[@SouravMondal-rc7io]

This is the example of, Not being able to pass even after studying for the whole year.

[@vasifarshad3362]

What about the essential amino acids and medical aspect of the consuming meat.....?

[@syedsayeed4639]

As salam alaikum WRWB, you people can explain her by taking example of our Carnivores teeth...

[@imanatheistaskmeaquestion5999]

syed sayeed But we can't eat raw meat, so we need more than what our body has to eat meat. i.e. a cooker/microwave/fire. If we use your principle that if you have naturally evolved to eat it, it's okay, then we gotta rule out meat no?

[@obaid.h]

That's not a good argument.

[@fasahm642]

I bet she uses make-up on all the products that have animal fats in them

[@mohammedfaraj308]

I'm wondering why she's taking the higher moral ground here?

[@PATRIOTICBRITAIN42]

Assalam alykum First time I seen brother mansurs vlog and buy chance came across on one that brother mansur didn't make any sense as it seemed to me and it felt he was undereducated and should not be at speakers corner and should learn more but then I watched more of his vlogs and know it seems he is very intelligent and understanding. So jazak Allaha khair

[@mks7198]

Brugh she is waffling all over the man, brother check your shirt she might have spit the green saliva virus on your shirt.

[@farmu4535]

brother mansur became little bit dark i guess

[@soul2soulibelieveinkarma661]

Tell them lady ,massive respect to you. Big you up everyday

[@الحمدلله-ذ9ز1ل]

She lost the argument

[@curiosone8843]

I suffered a lot on Halloween night. I had to do extra hours at my work because it was so busy. It is a restaurant.

[@pathwaytojannah1]

Thats what happens when you get further away from Allah, veganism or whatever "ism" people join lately is only an instinct act to fill the Lack of Islam in their hearts, these type of people will never find rest until they find Islam, May Almighty Allah guide them & Praise be to Allah Who already blessed us with Islam.

[@imanatheistaskmeaquestion5999]

Pathway to Jannah When the very act of logical reasoning against your belief system are used as evidence to support it, you're stuck in very dangerous territory my friend

[@pathwaytojannah1]

@@imanatheistaskmeaquestion5999Huh? you're delusional mate, you people believe the Universe created itself basicaly saying something came from nothing & yet you wanna talk about logical reasoning?! Smh

[@imanatheistaskmeaquestion5999]

Pathway to Jannah Ah the first cause argument, very well, your answer is this organised, complicated universe was created by something organised and complicated, way to answer the question, and BTW I don't think you're delusional and respect your view as a human being. Peace :)

[@pathwaytojannah1]

@@imanatheistaskmeaquestion5999 telling others "they're stuck in a dangerous territory" isnt the way to go my friend, i could have just replied by the same but i didnt. May God guide you to his straight path.

[@imanatheistaskmeaquestion5999]

Pathway to Jannah Unfortunately you missed the point, rather than have some rational reply to the lady's points, you saw the very act of disagreeing with your world view as a sign that she is wrong. And this is dangerous territory, because if you happen to be wrong you would will never have the opportunity to confront your beliefs and change if whoever approaches you with views that oppose yours are rejected immediately simply because they oppose you. Not only that, it is a sign for you that your view is correct. It's a pretty twisted way of thinking, I hope you can consider peoples views not on their mere position but on the facts they bring to you and the merit of those facts. If there is a god, I hope he guides us both, and if there isn't I wish you well in life :) peace

[@HenryTownsmyth]

First fight for ending human suffering than animals.

[@sighuddini2867]

Wow.. I found both of them really annoying. Both babbled

[@habiburrahaman8157]

Black panther with a longer beard😁😁

[@shameemnassiree2780]

There's actually no point in discussing animal rights and all that with vegans. Every creature has given food habits. So being Non Veg is not something bad. There are so many creatures. But we consume on large scale certain animals due to our natural food habits like cow, lamb, chicken , goat. Moreover when Allah has permitted us to eat certain animals then actually there is no point in discussing. You can't say it is bad to be Non Veg. when the creator said you can eat meat.

[@deserteffect1001]

indeed

[@imanatheistaskmeaquestion5999]

Shameem But if the creator said it is not okay to eat meat you wouldn't eat it right? So in what sense are you making any moral decisions at all?

[@shameemnassiree2780]

@@imanatheistaskmeaquestion5999 What is moral and immoral in eating Non Veg? Didn't you realize that the ball is in your court?

[@imanatheistaskmeaquestion5999]

Shameem It's really simple, its about unnecessary suffering. 1)there are plenty of stories in Islam about showing benevolence to animals and relieving their suffering. 2)God will not punish you for just eating veg, Put these 2 points together and as a MUSLIM it makes sense to be vegan no?

[@shameemnassiree2780]

@@imanatheistaskmeaquestion5999 the point the lady is making that eating meat is bad and killing to consume is immoral. This is where I have problem. How can you say it is immoral when your system is testifying to the fact that you can have both vegetables and meat. Our body has enzymes that can digest meat and also our Set of teeth is there to have meat. You gotta understand nature.

[@TamilanMalayali]

What this irrational lady saying ?? What if we injected some drug to an animal to not feel any pain while killing, is that okay 😂😂

[@Shayed.]

You're calling her "irrational", but claim you do not understand what she is saying? What an irrational thing to say. And, no, it would not be okay to inject an animal to not feel pain before slaughter, because you are doing something unnecessary and against their consent.

[@syedshakaibanwar2698]

ARIF But here's the thing pious guy, I don't give a flying shit about it, it tastes great and the animals is too dumb to launch a rebellion against me, so yeah, i will eat it 'til I explode, and for every buck/camel/bull/buffalo I eat, I have at least 10 of his progeny in reserve for my dietary pleasure and there is nothing grass eaters can do about it.

[@Shayed.]

@@syedshakaibanwar2698 You are a very vile individual. Calls other animals "too dumb", yet shows the very same ineptitude in not being able to use reason and control his emotions to not unnecessarily harm other sentient beings. Pathetic.

[@syedshakaibanwar2698]

ARIF Yeah, I am a superior being, I order meat and a dumb animal who can't even survive without humans, is killed off for my pleasure, it also fills up my belly and the bellies of the butchers, meat sellers, cattle herders and land owners, and I don't have to wait for months so a fruit falls down to eat "ethical" stuff either ;)

[@syedshakaibanwar2698]

You are one dumb bastard if you think animals are equal to humans, even if you are an atheist, there is no doubt that humans indeed are the superior species on this planet and animals are just another form of dietary pleasure for us, if you want to just survive, leave civilization, start living in the woods, eating berries and one day get mauled by a bear.

[@syedsayeed4639]

Carnivores teeth is given by Allah to whom He permitted to eat meat....for example this teeth you will not found in vegetable eating animal(I.e sheep bufflow etc)only will found in flesh eating animal(tiger, Lion etc.....)

[@imanatheistaskmeaquestion5999]

syed sayeed just because we have something doesn't mean using it is good, We can only survive in certain climates but we cover ourselves and spread to warmer and hotter areas. What we have may not be useful, or needed, or enough

[@alhamdulilahyarab7205]

The brother is speaking logically she’s speaking from a emotional position

[@soenantohambari3583]

assalamualaikum semoga admin dalam lindungan ALLAH SWT. Seperti biasa min. teks(subtitel bahasa indonesia)

[@MakenshiCritiques]

This chick was hoping that her inane nattering would get them to drop the flaws in her argument.

[@imanatheistaskmeaquestion5999]

Makenshi Critiques I see it the other way, her point that it's unnecessary suffering was continuously rejected,

[@riseofasia7683]

Veggies held a protest after the debate. Holding placards saying WHY ME? WHY NOT MEAT?

[@RyuFan1999]

I don't get her logic wallah.. she shouldn't be walking outside because she's killed at least one insect by walking outside.. HOW DARE SHE KILL UNCLE BOB THE WORLD RENOWNED ANT THAT WAS LOVED BY HIS FELLOW KIN OMGGG THEY ARE SUFFERING!!!!!!!! her logic bare weak

[@TheWorld-bu3bp]

Hahaha good one bro

[@truthbomb2184]

Lool

[@blackberry5908]

Did you know that Compared to animal-based protein, plant proteins have reduced digestibility and bioavailability.

[@msmashik]

She has no idea wt she's talking!

[@SouravMondal-rc7io]

The problem is you can't understand what is she talking about

[@msmashik]

@@SouravMondal-rc7io yea u maybe right cz she's giving a illogical and contradictory arguments

[@abdullahiidrismohamed8638]

Someone tried to tell her killing animals is evil and she was like no no not evil, she’s protecting evil cuz she worship Shatan😈

[@thedonkilluminati96]

Halal is cruel, i beg a muslim to comment and tell me im wrong. 🙄

[@thedonkilluminati96]

@@ixxrossorxxi6291 so explain why slaughter a animal by slitting its throat? Where are the pain receptors in a animal? In the spine so therefore the animal will still feel pain.

[@qassim7252]

@@thedonkilluminati96 is killing animal by electric shock or throw from high better

[@thedonkilluminati96]

@@qassim7252 anything better then halal, you guys try justifying it, but go back to your own country, in the middle east they slaughter animals in the most cruel way ever. Go check eid festival and kurbani.

[@stephen42red27]

@@thedonkilluminati96 drop in blood pressure quickly would cause the animal to lose consciousness. but also, draining the blood from the jugular and carotids would cause all the microorganisms in the blood to be spilt thus making the meat cleaner. so halal is painless and clean

[@thedonkilluminati96]

@@stephen42red27 stop making stupid excuses, your religion is evil a religion that has a guideline to kill is a barbaric religion. Ask yourself if you was to die would you prefer having your throat slit or would you prefer to be beheaded.

[@SMS-]

If you think killing animal or plant is cruelty then you should not eat anything which would have harmed anything anywhere.

[@SMS-]

@shoe laces These are defined by us(Human) and its not definite.

[@UsmanMughal-lm8pp]

She is drunk and just nah nah and nah... She is just want to talk 🐂 💩

[@usamaboii6380]

I think when someone is trying to make their point, she tries to avoid it. And she starts talking too much and it's not like we can hear her or anything? She starts talking long enough for her to think of a response.

[@markedwards7109]

The ultimate injustice you can do to any being is killing it when not needed. The guy behind said at the end if you forget to feed your pet for 3 hours it suffers that's barley at all comparably to taking its life because it taste nice. Our instinct isn't to harm. Take this sernario I am with loads of people in the forest there is no animal food too eat but every vegan options that are in the supermarket I see a cow walking past and I chase it down and get a sharp blade and cut its throat I garuntee the vast vast majority of people would stop me an say are you crazy you have thoudands of things to eat but you rather end this animals life because you feel for that taste. This is the response I get when I ask people who eat meat about this scenario. When we go into the supermarket this is our choice pay for someone else to end the animals life or choose out of the many many options where that doesnt have to happen

[@abdelhadielh]

When cattle get older, they really suffer while doing anything, for example: 1_ The structure of the lower jaw changes due to the daily rumination process , and this makes chewing difficult as they age. which

[@Cut3Sku11]

May Allah reward you brother Mansoor and the black brother. who is he?

[@SouravMondal-rc7io]

Is there a award system in ISLAM to kill animals.🤣

[@CxMooMs]

She doesn’t believe in evil she said, so... What is evil about eating animals...?

[@dorian2112]

is this guy cruelty free or not? i have watched a few of his vids but i still do not know. the guy with the hat.?

[@carmonaalmeida8437]

I love this lady. Master Jedi level. where can I find more from her activism? any one knows her name?

[@huzairimat9421]

name "queen of know nothing"

[@08Daim]

I bet she wouldn’t say no to a juicy lean tube steak

[@assil110]

The vegan lady reminds me of the christian women who was crying during the whole "debate" with brother Mansur (tears of faith). I guess the she is kind of the smiley version

[@anes4375]

Part 2 ?

[@Eadyt87]

For an honest this is not a really good argument given by my Muslim brothers there They supposedly just saying "Animals created for human purposes some are for test as forbidden like for pig, other for guards like dog, some are for soothes us like cat, some other for transportation like horse and other for FOOD like cow, lamb, chicken, etc. And if talking about suffering then NO ONE SHOULD RIDE A HORSE too, since in humanity perspective that would-be caused suffering to make a horse carrying our self or our loads"

[@peelfreshvita3199]

In the distant future, where mankind is able to digest air as food, a debate between plant vs air will take place

[@manusiaberuntung891]

In the future i guess we will be able to absorb cosmic energy

[@angeligarcia6487]

she said, egg comes first the who would take care of the egg if there are no adult chicken to take care of it??

[@زكريارويانغ]

They commit all the lawful things from Shirk intercourses abortion,more than that they trying to forbid what the creator made lawful,that's what they trying to make their desires and whims as gods,I'm a no longer A Muslim if I made what Allah permit as sin as forbidden he's the creator and he's Allah the one that giving our purpose what should do and what shouldn't As the prophet peace be upon him say No Obedience To The Created In Disobedience To The Creator Allah says As for those who disbelieve and reject Our signs, they will be the residents of the Hellfire. O believers! Do not forbid the good things which Allah has made lawful for you, and do not transgress. Indeed, Allah does not like transgressors. Eat of the good, lawful things provided to you by Allah. And be mindful of Allah in Whom you believe.

[@deficrypto1234]

Is it possible to remove morality from becoming a vegan?

[@SupreemSPGamer]

It is actually true that you can gain stuff from meat that you can't from plants

[@samuelalselim6782]

Nothing exists with out a opposites there is no peas without suffering nor is there fullness without emptiness

[@abdelazizkorichi_dz]

ممكن ترجمة للعربية في هاذ الاشرطة ؟

[@najwa_ni3118]

في نسخة من هذه القناة باللغة العربية مترجمة كل فيديوهات ....

[@EpikMunk]

What if I wait till the cow is old and coming to the end of its life, to save it from suffering from old age issues, I kill it. Is it ok for me to eat it after that?

[@ndhikaatube]

should be aight

[@EpikMunk]

@@ndhikaatube is that according to a vegan?

[@ndhikaatube]

@@EpikMunk both ways bro

[@EpikMunk]

@@ndhikaatube in that case then a vegan who would say it would be ok really should rethink their whole outlook.

[@diefaust4252]

But it's not as juicy

[@hurry2reason899]

Without suffering there can be NO GROWTH NO PAIN NO GAIN VEGANISM INHIBITS GROWTH AND GAIN PHYSICALLY MENTALLY PHYSIOLOGICALLY

[@alfphaboy6859]

yay animal have rights....then why do lions violate the rights by eating antelope

[@mtvnbp]

I wish i had known this vegan lady's name. anybody know her name?????

[@drcheekyisback]

Mani vas Vegan McFeminist - probably claims to be gender neutral until there’s a heavy box to lift then it’s “damsel in distress” time

[@mtvnbp]

@@drcheekyisback whats her name?

[@ILoveThisGame778]

What she gonna say when GOD will ask her about her beliefs

[@dawahtv5648]

لا توجد ترجمة إلى العربية