Pakistan Must Look Forward Beyond Kashmir: Shabbar Zaidi | Amber Zaidi | India-Pakistan Relations

[@vivekanandbillore8399]

अम्बर जी आप समझदार वक्ता को ले कर आई है शानदार विवेचना की है इन सज्जन ने 👏👏👏👏

[@Rohit_M_S_1991]

One of the Most humble and knowledgeable person in pakistan Namaste from Bharat Shabbar Zaidi sir hat's off to you Kaash pakistan me aap jaise log Orr ho to Pakistan har tarah ki mushqil se bahar nikal sakta hai Sir pls thoda jyda interviews diya kare aap taki logon me knowledge Orr humbleness Orr badhe aapko dekhkar/sunkar Namaste sir 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻

[@Redm.Dealer]

*How easily they fool you* *Don't forget what they believes* *Kafeer Hi Zalim He*

[@sushilkumar1400]

पानी, हरियाली और औरत से जनत बनते हैं मुस्लिम लोग 😂😂😂❤❤❤😂❤❤❤

[@financialplannermandar1138]

Pakistan's stance change due to risk of split, Sindhu River dispute and muslim umma ka Chumma bam gaya hai isliye.. otherwise these lunatic and Illisionatic people would have very agreesive like Benezir..even though they lost every war they started

[@swamisundaram]

Zaidi to Zaidi, Jai Shri Ram Jai Hind! 🎉

[@pankajbhardwaj5525]

Amber puttar u may not understand now but u r part of history, which will be written in future. Sir Shabbar ji is from few sane mind in Pakistan. Sir with due respect u r one who is respected in India with open heart. Thanks for coming Sir.

[@riazakram1]

Majority in Pakistan is sane, plz don't compare Pakistanis with their state's policies.

[@hrishikesh101]

Great chat zaidisab and Amber. Keep up the good show.

[@AmberZaidiOfficial]

Thanks for listening

[@codenameFourtySeven]

I am impressed by Mr. Shabbar Zaidi! Brilliant analysis by him on Pakistan and some logical conclusions he has drawn. Mostly, Pakistanis will denounce him for that as there is no place for logic for "Jazbaati" kaum.

[@malikawais3416]

Yeah lot of Pakistanis will deny him .... But people listen to this man and people like him too much .... Specially nowadays ..... Pakistani people are generally not that dumb ..... Lots of people think they are not that sensible .... It's a wrong perception ..... I am Pakistani I also use to think that but I am actually very surprised how sensible my people are ..... I hope our situation will be better ..... Regarding from pakistan ....

[@codenameFourtySeven]

@@malikawais3416 That is great! If you guys start to introspect yourself and your actions will definitely speak louder than words. Majority of your population still think India is your enemy but Poverty / inflation / corruption is not ? No one is your enemy , we are not taught in India that Pakistan is enemy. Infact only time our text books mention Pakistan is in the context of 1947. That is all

[@financialplannermandar1138]

Pakistan's stance change due to risk of split, Sindhu River dispute and muslim umma ka Chumma bam gaya hai isliye.. otherwise these lunatic and Illisionatic people would have very agreesive like Benezir..even though they lost every war they started

[@AnilSinha-s2h]

@@malikawais3416 Pakistani people are very clever and very sensible -- and in my experience, polite and friendly people. BUT -- and it's a big BUT -- the Army wants to keep every Pakistani thinking that India is going to "eat up" Pakistan; India is going to "harm" Pakistan etc. etc. The Army also keeps sending "contract killers" to kill and hurt Indians across the border. By doing this, Pakistan Army gets a lot of money & resources from the Govt. Creating bad sentiments against India is good for the Army's business. This is the real sad part of the relationships between Indians and Pakistanis. People are good on both sides. Indians NEVER think of Pakistanis in a bad light -- but "terrorists" and "contract killers" sent by the Army ARE bad, hurtful, harmful.

[@07legendalive]

You are no less Jazbaati. Whenever a Pakistani criticizes his country and supports India's point of view, we innocent Indians become Jazbaati.

[@rabindrasingh4735]

The great social reformers of Pakistan and India We Indians are very proud of you

[@deepak_tahilramani]

Shabbar Zaidi Sir.... Salute

[@gururaj1944]

Zakir Naik is not wrong ....he is quoting from the holy book.... He is a peaceful man from peaceful community

[@NiranjanBandekar-oc5mg]

Yes of course....He is....A gentleman from Gods House!!

[@nytionbasumatary94]

@@NiranjanBandekar-oc5mgBelongs to 72 hoors 😅😂

[@contemporarymatters8106]

The most rational explanation of jiddat and subsequent jannat. Keep up such programmes.

[@sachinkumarparsai9077]

Sabbar Zaidi Sir The definition of heaven you gave Since then I have become a fan of yours.

[@VinayKumar-dq1fd]

Shabbar Zaidi sahab is one of the most intellectual of Pakistan!! Always feel good to listen him !!!

[@M_R___974]

Quite noticeable. Mere Namaskar from SZ did not satisfy his greetings, so he added Bismillah as an afterthought. While AZ did a normal Namaskar. Would hv felt odd with "Hinduana" way of greeting.

[@SanjayGupta-jk7hl]

Thanks for inviting Shabbar zaidi sir...

[@AnilSinha-s2h]

I’ve learnt something significant today -thanks to Shabbar Zaidi Saheb. Arabian thinking on - obsession with - women: far too many women in Hell and 73 hoorain per (good) man in Heaven - because there was a scarcity of (i) women (ii) water and (iii) greenery in Arabia. In Islam’s Heaven all three appear in abundance. In contrast, several millennia earlier, over two thousand miles to the east, the Sindhus (=Hindus), who were blessed with plenty of water and greenery, populated their universe with Mother Goddesses such as Durga (the warrior goddess) , Lakshmi (the goddess of wealth and prosperity) and goddess Saraswati (the goddess of learning and arts). To this day, numerous beneficent (Mother) goddesses form of the daily lives of all Sanatani Hindus (=Sindhus).🙏🙏

[@primordialarchetypes2927]

meanwhile gndutvagiri on Cdn soil

[@financialplannermandar1138]

Pakistan's stance change due to risk of split, Sindhu River dispute and muslim umma ka Chumma bam gaya hai isliye.. otherwise these lunatic and Illisionatic people would have very agreesive like Benezir..even though they lost every war they started

[@winfriedsebald]

Love this guest. Mr. Zaidi brilliant and optimistic. Such a rare combination.

[@bhushansharma1702]

quran teachings are responsible not zakir naik

[@primordialarchetypes2927]

we in IN need Advaita vedanta, not gndtva kattarpanti (ahamkar)

[@JaishreeRam-ge6wh]

Shabbar jaidi ek dam thik bol rahe h pak ko kasmir bhul kar aage badhna chahiye ❤

[@anilmalhani6904]

I started respecting Mr.Zaidi...sensible view

[@ashwwal3409]

It is really good to hear Mr Shabbar Zaidi who has views different from others Pakistanis .

[@simplejain9394]

Shambar sahab is one of the sane voices in pak. Always speak his heart out

[@Vinay_Acharya]

Shabbar + Ambar = Shambar? 💯 😂😂

[@SatishSharma-cx4oc]

Its always nice to hear Mr Zaidi, he makes sense, bring him back

[@krupadave1975]

Iran-India pipeline ka dushman USA hai. USA will never allow this to happen. During Manmohan regime, then petroleum minister Mani shankar Ayyer was almost ready with Iran-Afghan-Pakistan-India pipeline blueprint. Suddenly, he was removed from the minister-ship and that project got shelved.

[@SomnathDe-h7d]

You are right.

[@BABLUYASHUAYODHYA]

Nice news namaste Regards Rajesh Kumar Singh Gonda Ayodhya India

[@amitavasinha4543]

This same person in a podcast with a Pakistani anchor had said that revocation of Article 370 has been his biggest mistake and this will come to haunt Mr Modi in days to come. Surprising in light of his observation today.

[@GaneshMishra-he8kq]

Mr Zaidi, you have made a serious U turn in connection with KASHMIR , we in India do firmly believe that you have started sweetening the POISON. We firmly believe that PAKISTAN HAS ALWAYS CONSIDERED INDIA AS YOUR ENEMY IS STILL OPENLY DECLARING Gazwa e Hind, do you expect us to believe you😉

[@devisomaya7080]

Partly agree with you Ganesh, but opinions of people change and i doubt powerful military will listen to people like Sri Zaidi Or Dr Bangali, one of the best economist in Pakistan, who have been crying hoarse from years to reduce defense and government expenditures. Pakistan's army is untrustworthy as Kargil war exposed them and will stab India and even China whenever opportunity arises, the way they did with USA and KSA. This is true of pakistani politicians as well, hence I agree with you. ​@@GaneshMishra-he8kq

[@jorhatkar]

Both the Anchor and the guest avoided touching upon the issue of Pakistan-bases terrorists and terrorism plots.

[@jorhatkar]

EAM Jayshankar summed up beautifully: NO Terrorism, NO Separatism, NO Extremism. Until Pak, especially ISI stops stokingb terrorism, India Pak can not normalise relations.

[@rajvashisth4567]

बीस मुल्ला + एक रहमान + एक रहीम = बाईस

[@ajitdesai-i1v]

😂😂😂😂😂

[@gururaj1944]

Im happy now ..... i was confused....but he cleared my doubts.......... Holy book and Prophet Mohammad

[@aniltripathi7819]

It's all a pleasure to listen to Sabbar Zaidi.

[@bhuvanmittal4977]

Shabbar Zaidi is one exception in Pakistan who accepts the whole truth a reality and speaks straight forwardly with open dare.

[@NarinderKumar-k1z]

Good Luck Amber Jaidi God blessed you

[@cab9197]

Fair minded person from Pakistan, Mr. Zaidi.

[@Ash-ep1nz]

I haven't seen a more beautiful muslim woman than Amber Zaidi. She should be protected at all cost.

[@sanjaydoshi7968]

She is in India so naturally protected

[@ajitkumar6371]

I agree, she is beautiful and very talented. God bless her. Pride of Bharat. 🙏🇮🇳🙏🇮🇳🙏🇮🇳🙏🇮🇳🙏🇮🇳🙏🇮🇳🙏

[@ajitkumar6371]

I bet you if you go back years you both are related. Both very open minded and tells the truth. Two great people.

[@KaramjitSingh-yv6tj]

Shabbar sir,People listen to you in India, but in Europe as we listen to you in England. Everything you say is right and to the point. We pray for Shabbar that God gives you long life And we will always listen to you

[@subodhsingh9533]

Shabbar Saab is one among the rare breed of Pakistan.salyut to him.

[@girwarsingh9777]

Sabbar jedi sahab ko sunana hamesa acha lagta h..

[@Bbjhff123]

Always love you shabbar bhai❤❤🇮🇳

[@varadarajandharmalingam3224]

Shabbar zaidi idea is good for pak & people of pakistani, pak should come forward and become a progressive state with help of india

[@ArunKumar-h6c5j]

Mr Zaidi is an Economist and a Realist . ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

[@mangilalgodara1978]

Shabbar zaidi sab is a very logical man and with fact idea I listen yi

[@lalmeer9741]

❤Amber u r so cute❤ from KPK ❤Pakistan ❤

[@rajanrg]

superbly analysed by Army Major sir. thanks

[@cx4vr1dh4j]

Zaidi Madam is so honest❤❤as the Expert Guest Zaidi Sir❤

[@vcr1761]

Amazing personality Shabbar sb. Truly informative and sensible video. Thanks Amber ji for having this wise person on your show. Sorry to say but Seldom does one come across a person with such high level intellect from across the border.

[@NiazHJafri]

❤❤❤ Sincere prayers for the everlasting peace between India, Pakistan, & Bangladesh !!! 🤲🤲🤲 Aameen, Elaahi Aameen

[@IndraKumar-md9ut]

Assalaamalaikum Shabbar Zaidi saab. It is nice hearing you. I hope there are many more such nice people like you from Pakistan, so that we can really look forward to a bright future for both of our countries. By the by, I like old Pakistani films of the 1950s and 1960s, and classical music. These are just like mirror images of ours in India. With good senses prevailing on both sides, let us endeavour forging a harmonious relationship. For example look at France and Germany. If they can today become best of friends and allies, after centuries of bitter conflicts and many wars, why can't we do the same here? With all my best wishes and regards, Allah Hafiz... And my regards to Amber Zaidi for anchoring this heart-warming talk show...

[@Redm.Dealer]

*Amber Ye Shambar Tera Ristedaar He ? India Me Ye Sirf Tujhe Hi Interview Deta He, Indian Media Pr Kyu Nhi Aata ?* *Amber Zaidi You are an asset of Enamy* *Thank God, Tujhe B.J.P. Ne Hakal Kr Nikal Diya*

[@RakeshSharma-v7y]

Beautiful analysis

[@manojsathe5416]

U r right person at wrong place sir u r my guru

[@santiyalpuneet4729]

Wow, खूब जमेगी जब मिल बैठेंगे दो proud zaidi ❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@konarraja4021]

Excellent logical discussion ❤❤❤

[@AmberZaidiOfficial]

Thank you

[@arif_nathoka]

Very nice analysis by shabbar zaidi... Glad to see

[@AmberZaidiOfficial]

Thanks for liking

[@arif_nathoka]

@@AmberZaidiOfficial keep inviting them for the podcast.

[@mchandrashekar7366]

Well said shabberzaidi

[@KashifAli-qv1xo]

Plz ask question about future (will be /Should be ) of POK.. According to Zaidi sab..? Jay hind Love from Pok🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳

[@SomnathDe-h7d]

Good interview.

[@AMBUJPRASADSINgh]

AMBER DIDI aap BHARAT and PAKISTAN ko sath baithane ki baat karte hai when INDIA ke MUSLMAN sath nahi hai if PAKISTAN ke Zahil MUSLMAN bhi sat AA jaega to INSANIYAT khatra me aa jaegi. Jay hind jay bharat, bharat mata ki jay ho, Bande mataram, Jay jaban jay kishan, Jay BJP🇮🇳🙏

[@singhkulwant21]

Everything is okay but who will counter fundamentalist?

[@ramlovevanshi2065]

Two Zaidi good analysis ❤❤❤

[@arabindabhattacharjee424]

But what about pakistan establishment?

[@RahulSingh-sy7vu]

Decent conversation 🎉

[@P.Nath.Y]

Salame Hindustan shabbar sir.

[@ArunKumar-bj9yg]

After Barrister Bashani, Shabbar Zaidi is another pakistani who I respect for his in depth knowledge of regional geopolitics. Both are factual, always. Both know what they are talking. Both speak softly and gentlemanly, ie, no free fund ki foo-faa, no showbazi. Thank you for inviting him, Amber.

[@snathan3198]

I insist Pak should first get all of Kashmir before trading with India.😂

[@omprakashchoudhary8965]

Jai Hind Jai Bharat Amber 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳

[@mrramanpoonam]

Two Zaidis are in talk. Great going AZ. If possible also invite Lubna Zaidi. She is also excellent....

[@AmberZaidiOfficial]

Noted

[@binodapatra7001]

Good analysis , Thanks .

[@AmberZaidiOfficial]

Glad you liked it!

[@vatvanginevihar]

I love your attitude madam

[@divyeshparekh6562]

Shri SHABBAR ZAIDI has spoken really honestly and correctly. Need such people like him in power in Pakistan. But it’s a distant dream.

[@imgn8r715]

One of the few people online who has never said anything that I've disagreed with. 100 people who think like him could push Pakistan out of its current deplorable state.

[@shekharpawar8205]

Shabbar sir.... 🙏

[@virenderjoshi3456]

Very good conversation between Zaidis

[@AmberZaidiOfficial]

Thank you 😊

[@virenderjoshi3456]

@@AmberZaidiOfficial To the point, time valuable conversation by both of you

[@spsharma4406]

Respected Shabbar Zaidi Saheb... is the most important economic authority in Pakistan. He headed Pakistan Central Bank and knows what challenges Pakistan is facing. He has been telling Pakistan authorities at the top of his voice and in very clear and transparent way..but entire Pakistan Govt and deep state is always in denial mode since the creation of Pakistan. Already defaulted state.

[@pradeepsogani8137]

AADAAB ARZ HAY REGARDS PRADEEP SOGANI JAIPUR

[@SkarPuku]

Very good analysis

[@mukeshsharda187]

Nice analysis amber bitya

[@raghukol2086]

Both r Zaidi nice to see

[@arabindabhattacharjee424]

Exactly

[@mariashashkova2978]

Great Show👏🏻

[@prakashgajjar9996]

Zaidi to zaidi...nice

[@VinayPareenja-ew5ss]

Very well said by. SHABBAR ZAIDI

[@bluntbob6723]

37:43 Absolutely agree 😂

[@AmberZaidiOfficial]

Hilarious it was

[@bluntbob6723]

@@AmberZaidiOfficial Yes 😂

[@dineshmeena8835]

Shandar lagi raho sister❤❤❤❤❤

[@RahulSingh-sy7vu]

RPS likes it 😊

[@madanmohanchandra3754]

A sane soul in Pakistan!!!

[@JawwadHussain-vp5fp]

AsalamAlaikum Amber ji, app bohat acha show karti hain apko bohat sara pyaar Pakistan 🇵🇰 sai ❤❤. Allah apko sehat aur tandursti kai saath lambi zindagi ata kare. Ameen.

[@AmberZaidiOfficial]

Shukriya

[@JawwadHussain-vp5fp]

Amber please invite Dr.Ishtiaq Ahmed in your show.

[@Ravi-k7h7o]

Both Pakistan and India should jointly withdraw the UN Kashmir Resolution in the next few weeks .A practical suggestion as a Next First Step . Jai Hind !

[@AnilSinha-s2h]

From India to Pakistan -- with love:.💚💚 ye nahīñ hai ki tujhe maiñ ne pukārā kam hai mere nāloñ ko havāoñ kā sahārā kam hai is qadar hijr meñ kī najm-shumārī ham ne jaan lete haiñ kahāñ koī sitārā kam hai dostī meñ to koī shak nahīñ us kī par vo dost dushman kā ziyāda hai hamārā kam hai 😀😀

[@mannatjaral7949]

Nowadays I can say that pakistani muslim are thousand times aware then Indian muslim love you pakistani muslim

[@PrinceKumar-cl9iq]

😊😊😊😊😊

[@peterdhan8777]

Whatever existing wealth , social living better enduring in Pakistan.. Provided respect each other territory along border line differences....After long experience,Question may not arise towards hostile talks and relationship. Thanks🙏

[@alokeprasad9343]

Very good discussion and appreciate your views . Thanks to zaidi saheb . Incidentally , are you both related ? 😂❤ Some forgotten common ancestors .

[@jagsingh1477]

Amber Mam you are good bright girl pls do something other than only Pakistan There are so many different stuff going on in India and world

[@kamalnarayan33]

According to your comments, half of indian Muslims should be in Pagalkhana.

[@sarsau]

Shabbar Zaidi had said he wished his grandfather didn’t move to Pakistan from Delhi

[@chandreshpandey4061]

Jab samne wala apni baat puri kar le tab aap apne baat kahiye ambarji❤

[@sanjaydoshi7968]

Pakistan is running in reverse gear . It can never look forward😅

[@rajraina2914]

Ram Ram to both of you specially to shabber zaidi God bless both of you.zaidi sahab is a good person but sometimes he shows double standards may be due to some restriction.

[@AshwaniKumar-d6j]

Brilliance of the sanatani DNA of two 'Zaidi' media superstars is clear in this talk show. But 'n' number of debates cant solve our problem, as the root cause is the prescription of the text of a certain book, which promotes false superiority and separatist ideology. Amber beti, you face this problem daily on our TV debates. Ab uska kya karein jo samasya ka mool kaaran hai ?