Pakistan’s Open Secret I Transgender Documentary I Only Human

[@Godessy23.]

“If my fate were in my hands I’d be happy to be a dog just so I could live with my mother” that was deep 😢

[@KemeticKreations]

I know right ❤

[@kim.epurdy1644]

That quote struck me deep too 😥

[@faizasyed2525]

@@kim.epurdy1644 Likewise, heartbreakingly sad.

[@chompachangas]

Yeah, fuuuuuuuuuu.... that hit me. too.

[@nilsonbeth1]

With true respect because now it starts to get the real world we are living in as a part of the truth ❤

[@a.walters123]

I wish I could just hold Chahat and take away all her pain and regret. What a beautiful person with a beautiful soul and innocent heart ❤️

[@fidesign5924]

Admit it, you like them kind of people...

[@dorothyann-n2h]

Much Love 💕😘💕 to y'all trans

[@JacintaRebello-jm9gm]

Chahat seems to be a very good human being. I feel so sorry the way he has been created.

[@zarinekharshiing2047]

Same here

[@cyberovaries]

He's a man.

[@chompachangas]

Chahat looks like she hates her "guru" and I don't blame her. That person gives me the creeps.

[@jdubb5592]

The way he was kissing those kids gave me the creeps

[@dorothypierre754]

​@@jdubb5592Chahat was behaving like any Pakistani auntie.

[@dorothypierre754]

@chompachangas It's so needlessly hierarchical

[@mohitsharma9851]

I can tell chahat out of all is more than humans, she deserves a better version of life, her line to be a dog and to stay alongside her mother was touching, moreover amongst other i found her deeply depressed but still cherished in life and spreading the same, I'm not sure about others but she has my respect.

[@florenciaga216]

A dog Is a pure soul they are very loyal and justo spread love... I love animal they dont have anybody

[@hikareti9503]

I didn't buy her...I paid 30,000 rupees for her, sounds like buying to me.

[@KamalasNotLikeUs]

That's $107. 🤯

[@francianicoleencinares6885]

@@KamalasNotLikeUs only $107 lol

[@arthurfleck1554]

It is called 'nikah al-mut'ah (marriage of lust), the 30 thousand rupeees is a dowry.

[@Anandita_Sinha]

Inflation matters. You can't get much with 107$ in us but in these countries, 107$ means a lot​@@francianicoleencinares6885

[@H.R.Ssheikhg]

Don't misguide innocent people's ​@@arthurfleck1554

[@cj4607]

the slavery aspect to their culture is very problematic.

[@beingwambui729]

very disturbing

[@cantlieman]

And sadly, its in every sector of our country.

[@KamalasNotLikeUs]

It's not "problematic" in the US and Europe? 🙄

[@cj4607]

@@KamalasNotLikeUs it's problematic everywhere! but this is really problematic in that they are taking advantage of their own.

[@NachfahreeinerBauernmagd]

​@@KamalasNotLikeUsEs geht in dieser Doku um Pakistan und nicht die USA und Europa. Schön beim Thema der Doku bleiben.

[@fhp7032]

So the gurus are pimps.

[@maryam91423]

Exactly 💯

[@Aspirant24-uy3zp]

They are not gurus but muslim preachers

[@PANOTI-i3y]

Groomers

[@nanumahangma9774]

Feel sad for Chahat, hope she got people who unconditionally love her and welcome her in their lives 🙏

[@susancharles2555]

It's not she it's him

[@vicel_05]

@@susancharles2555 Bro is a hater

[@charmainemoodley2414]

Chahat deserves love and I hope she gets it. She has such an angelic face

[@charmainemoodley2414]

Chahat deserves love and I hope she gets it. She has such an angelic face

[@TheBeautifulOne_Charmaine]

❤

[@j4l472]

"Dreams don't come true for people like us"😢

[@Mr.Know-It-All-Day]

I felt that😢

[@Dreamer99297]

Be strong sis. It's not only you prople, trust me we are all suffering somehow. Life is not easy for anyone, afterall it's a temporary life. Just be happy and smile always. Life is very short and we are all gonna die. Sending much luv to you❤

[@zarinekharshiing2047]

Don't stop dreaming.. they do come true

[@europattt7299]

Ондай жаман елден қашып кетіңіз😢

[@Alessa_Maga_Cinzenta]

😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭

[@oceanchicns]

Guru's = Slavers

[@tanishqsharma7328]

Not really,but yeah exceptions are always there

[@hmj3547]

Stop Taking Gurus name in veins & for your own hatred towards Hindu terms...those Trans aren't even Hindus still they are using that term...so disturbing... 1st Learn the True meaning of GURU then talk...🙄🤡🖕🏼

[@selmahare]

The fact that they call themselves Gugus in a very feeble, nonsensical attempt of denying what they in fact are, slavers, is beyond insane.

[@plautus-jc8be]

what does discipline mean?

[@Famy-]

Doesn't mean it's your made up custom it doesn't make it slavery😮

[@Smiley_3997]

Chahat seems to have a kind soul

[@YuriKalutskii]

such a beautiful movie!! thank you for making it and revealing these personalities to us!

[@rohanrohan3405]

Wow! Ending was great. Tax collector, such a great initiative.

[@shreyatamang3606]

Chahat is such a genuinely kind person ✨🤍

[@Secularism25]

Those are the people who deserve asylum abroad but they are too poor to exit Pakistan to seek asylum overseas

[@alientourist4171]

Let’s be honest them hiring trans women to collect unpaid taxes is absolutely hilarious 😂

[@loveislove9211]

In india too this practice is there .

[@xendit1635]

​@@loveislove9211no there isn't z stop lying. India has legalised them ,giving them proper Jobs. A whole metro station in Noida run by them. They have reservations in government jobs in Many states. So, if you don't know ,stop writing wrong info

[@graysonwalker]

It works because no one wants them around...

[@galmlrssg210]

​@@loveislove9211it is?

[@derekdolcy5839]

😅😅😅😊❤❤❤❤yea agreed 💯😊

[@reyflaco1840]

" my bf left me he is marrying his cousin" ......oh Allah really

[@theoryofpersonality1420]

The cousin is probably a small child because that's what they do there

[@hardstuckplat3190]

I lost it

[@lilsophia101]

Can you set up a donation link so we can help Chahat??

[@halimamohamed4400]

Chahat should be normal then everything will be ok for him

[@Baebaehiba]

@@halimamohamed4400for her*

[@INDIANATHEIST526]

​@@halimamohamed4400Muslims should kearn humanity first

[@threads1879]

Do you really think somebody want to be like that or want that they will get this type of treatment​@@halimamohamed4400

[@emjay5425]

@@halimamohamed4400 There is no "normal" people are born this way. It is normal for them.

[@GiGiGoesShopping]

1,000 rupees is about $12.00 These folks need the chance at wholesome jobs.

[@Gusr404]

Is pakistan rupees, worth a lot less than indian rupees

[@saqibhussain9795]

people work for a month and make 25k Rupees.

[@abinashdash1347]

This is one of the best well documented videos I have seen in years. I like the courage & depth the team has put in this.

[@jevanahigh2764]

The way they’re walking with those vibrant colors in that town reminds me of the movie “To Wong Foo, Thanks for Everything! Julie Newmar”

[@bladeowens]

my FAVORITE movie

[@phoenixdavida8987]

Great movie.

[@charmainemoodley2414]

It’s so sad to see humanity in this way. I pray that one day all will accept each other as higher equals.

[@chilltarts]

Such a great documentary, but you skipped the conversation about where this starts-- how many were forced into a childhood as a "dancing boy", and now shunned from society and no longer desired by the perverts, this is the only life they have left to lead.

[@ls-sk5iv]

Such insightful yet sad stories. I pray Chahat and the other girls in this documentary are well. I wish there was a follow-up on what became of their lives. ❤🙏

[@JenniferWoodroff]

They are not girls.

[@deniseeugene1852]

Girls ???

[@aimakhan9004]

This is heartbreaking as a Pakistan I will always play my part and hopefully we new generation can bring change

[@friendnamedjane8686]

This! ☝🏻

[@abhilashbhardwaj5966]

Really feel bad for chahat...

[@NarnoldsMomma]

Right? He'd be a dog just to be with his mother..... so sad how lost and hurt he is

[@Rohi4123]

@@NarnoldsMomma he? Thats a trans woman

[@ginmill5280]

@@Rohi4123I cried for her,Chahat was so pure and loving

[@muzammil_pathan20]

​@@Rohi4123😂😂😂 he

[@TedKazinski642]

As per my knowledge India is friendly with transgender community. I been to India many times and I have seen they have reservations in several jobs. And one whole metro station runs by them.🇮🇳

[@dariansdoor7098]

Tell me more about India

[@TedKazinski642]

@@dariansdoor7098 GEOGRAPHY India is part of the continent of Asia. Most of India forms a peninsula, which means it is surrounded by water on three sides. The world's highest mountain range, the Himalaya, rises in the north. The southeast is bordered by the Bay of Bengal, and the southwest is bordered by the Arabian Sea. India's terrain varies widely, from the Thar Desert in the west to jungles in the northeast. A fertile area called the Ganges Plain covers much of northern India. This formation was created from soil that was deposited by rivers running from the Himalaya. In some places, this layer of silt is over 25,000 feet (7,620 meters) deep. PEOPLE & CULTURE Society throughout India is divided into social ranks, called castes. Caste is determined by birth and there is almost no way to change it. High castes include priests, landowners, and soldiers. So-called Untouchables have no caste and do the most menial jobs. India is a very spiritual country. It has no official religion, but more than 85 percent of Indians are Hindu. About 6 percent are Muslim. Other religions include Buddhism, Sikhism, and Jainism, which all began in India. NATURE For thousands of years, since the Hindu religion first evolved, respect for animal life has been an important part of Indians' beliefs. Cows in particular are sacred and cannot be harmed. They are even allowed to wander through city streets, which often causes traffic jams! India's varied climate zones support about 65,000 animal species, including elephants, pythons, river dolphins, and rhinos, and 12,000 types of flowering plants. It is the only country in the world with both lions and tigers. It's also a bird watcher's paradise. On the coast of the Bay of Bengal is the Sundarbans, the world's largest mangrove forest. Here, tigers swim in the same rivers as dolphins, sea turtles, sharks, and saltwater crocodiles. This unique landscape is constantly under threat as sea levels rise and humans hunt illegally and clear trees for firewood. The Himalaya mountains provide a home for some of India's rarest animals and plants. The most elusive animal is the snow leopard. Bears and black buck live lower down, and in the northeast, the tiger and one-horned rhinoceros can be found. HISTORY India's earliest known civilization arose about 5,000 years ago on the Indus River in what is now Pakistan. Archaeologists uncovered the remains of two huge cities with brick houses, piped water, and sewer systems. Nobody knows why, but these cities, called Harappa and Mohenjo Daro, were abandoned in 1700 B.C. The Aryan people were farmers from Central Asia who arrived in India around 1500 B.C. They spoke Sanskrit, one of the world's oldest known languages. The Vedic Scriptures, writings that form the basis of the Hindu religion, were written during the Aryan reign. In the 200-year reign of the Gupta Empire, starting in the fourth century A.D., arts, crafts, and sciences flourished. During this time, the Indian astronomer Aryabhatta determined that the Earth revolved around the sun. This was long before the Western world accepted the theory. Beginning in the 16th century, following a series of invasions by Muslim forces, a Mongol leader named Babur founded the Mongol Empire. The Mongols oversaw a golden age of art, literature, and architecture in India between 1527 and 1707. They built roads, mosques, gardens, and enormous tombs, including the grand Taj Mahal. In the late 1400s, Europeans arrived in India and began setting up trading companies. In 1757, Britain gained control over most of the country. Uprisings against British rule began in 1856. In 1920, the famous Mahatma Gandhi began nonviolent protests to push the British out. In 1947, India had independence. This is what i know madam.

[@derekdolcy5839]

😅😅😅😊❤❤❤❤❤nice 🙂👍🏿👍🏿 tedkazinski.642.

[@derekdolcy5839]

😅😅😅😊❤❤❤❤❤India 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳

[@factspoken9062]

sharia law se nahin chalte@@dariansdoor7098

[@Armistead_MacSkye]

This is so sad. Excellent work. Bravo 🎉

[@bimm43]

I think Chahat has touched the hearts of many viewers.

[@leviticusemmanuel4421]

Human beings are weird. Humanity isn't getting better either.

[@winros]

Once you give a pigeon a crumb, he's yours forever!!!

[@zoem6609]

The GURU’s are literally pimps, it’s a sad way of life…Chahat, I pray your story ends differently.

[@alienpov]

What an awful place for anyone.

[@Ayesha______]

im pakistani and not really. America is much worse. Ive lived in both places

[@theoryofpersonality1420]

@Ayesha______ you're a liar

[@mandelzweig5453]

البلدان الإسلامية مكان جميل للناس الطبيعية وليس لمن عنده ميول غريبة

[@manish7897]

​​@@Ayesha______ yeah sure 🤡

[@NachfahreeinerBauernmagd]

​@@mandelzweig5453Dann bleibt bitte in euren schönen Ländern aber ohne westliche Technik. Und bitte holt eure Leute aus dem Rest der Welt zurück. Wir wären sehr dankbar.

[@semirabdu4408]

It's good documentary I like it, but when the women speaks in English I mean the one who make this film the background music are so loud I think u don't notice that.

[@user-fy8sp3vw3h]

Right on. I noticed it too 👍

[@jeffreyzain]

14:16 - Their BIGGEST enemy is themselves. Instead of helping each other, they pressure novices to slave for them. Another example of LGBT’s numerous problematic contradictions 🔥

[@DanaMoon-uo8uz]

It’s not lgbt, it’s bad people

[@asmamunir5206]

That sad face of Chahat...kitna drd hai us k dil main😔

[@akbar8477]

Watching this film forces me to see how different our American culture is and even though there are lgbtq similarities there are major differences in thought and politics. I wished I could have an airling I would work out a deal with the major airlines for trainning and hire them to work my private plane. I would hire Maggie and hopefully she could become a trainer of Sky Hostesses in the future.

[@mandelzweig5453]

ابق في أمريكا وساعد المتحولين عندكم ليرجعو إلى طبيعتهم و يمكنك مساعدة المشردين في أمريكا فهم يستحقون هذا

[@panjandrum.conundrum]

@@mandelzweig5453 It's a natural phenomenon, and present in every society. It's not a fad.

[@mtwwb168]

I hope they get to visit countries where they will be accepted.

[@derekdolcy5839]

😅😅😅😊❤❤❤❤yea true facts 👍🏿👍🏿👍🏿

[@Blisteryn]

To be prostitutes anyway????

[@amesblitz339]

I'd rather have much more of them than just one of you, Donnell.

[@yte549]

This world is not only for yours

[@Allen-w9r]

​@DonnellOkafor-ig3ovand they don't need more people like you either,

[@angelagenerini9638]

I am italian women. I visit pakistan in agost 2011. I can say this wit all my dil: EVERYONE in pakistan...womens...mens...transgenders....EVERYONE respect for me!!!! And i RESPECT EVERYONE!! I REMEMBER ALL LIFE MY DAYS IN PAKISTAN!! VERY THANX PAKISTAN!!!! INCHALLAH I BACK! VERY MISS ME PAKISTAN!!!❤🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🤝🤝🤝🤝🤝🤝🤝🤝🤝🤝🤝🤝🤝

[@gabrielamaramures289]

Poverinaaa... dovevi andare in Pkistan per essere rispettata?

[@DerekDolcy]

😊❤❤hi 👋 there angelagenerin.9638. Much love ❤️ to u dear

[@kunzangdolma634]

This is so sad Pakistan Government should give them identity card.

[@ilovecairo]

Right?! It's not too much to ask for

[@archerpondevida9529]

it's likely that the Pakistan govt sees them as a threat to state-held moral standards. If this group gets rights, starts to get legitimized in the public eye, what other flaws in their society will they be forced to rethink? @@ilovecairo

[@ilovecairo]

@@archerpondevida9529 that makes sense

[@sadafwessels]

😢they have id cards now

[@younghokim1994]

These women are so strong. I can feel the dedication to become better when she's applying to become a hostess. It's touching how despite these circumstances, these women are striving for progress.

[@nicole4659]

They are not women

[@jacqueline8559]

​​@@nicole4659 Correct!! They have XY Chromosomes. They are genetically MALE. It doesn't matter what these people, the whole world over, choose to do, How they dress or apply make up, if they even have Surgery.!! YOU ARE EXACTLY AS YOUR GENETIC CHROMOSOMES DECREE

[@annenelson5656]

They don’t even try to look feminine. They just wear dresses, beg, prostitute or grift. They will never be women. And considered how badly women are treated there, they’re lucky to even be alive. So if they want to cosplay as women then they’re taking their own fate in their own hands. Their gurus are just pimps. These cosplaying “women” can have a much better life if they just accept biology.

[@tammytan2635]

@@nicole4659based on living life with your disability, I’d think you’d be much more empathetic to people who have a different life path than the norm.

[@theanonymousnobody8509]

@@nicole4659 oh yeah, another uterus warrior

[@Nefla22]

One thing I’m curious about… I notice with a lot of South Asian languages they mix English words in. Are they just multilingual or are they loan words?

[@RimalAkram]

Asian people study their subjects in English. English is preferred as it's international language. So some of them can speak it fluently while others use some words while doing conversation in national language "Urdu".

[@xhedpidlaoan5696]

Majority are multi lingual

[@gaeig]

The British ruled the subcontinent india Pakistan Bangladesh for more than 2 centuries in most parts. Ofc the local languages have adapted english words!

[@riyabiswas7035]

Chahat is very kind soul❤ feeling sad for Maggie 😢

[@dinasun3]

Why do parents abandon them as these people were born from these parents who were created this way so they should fault themselves not the transgender. They are born this way.

[@enlilly2405]

There is no fault in being transgender or giving birth to them. Shame on you. If you believe in God, then why not understand they are also your god's children? How will God create a mistake?

[@FransceneJK98]

God didn’t create them this way. God has order and no confusion. Satan is the one that confuses people bout their gender.

[@Anushka.9305]

​@@FransceneJK98No one wants to be shunned in society. They're just born this way. You think they don't want to be like normal people, playing with people their age,grow up like a normal child would do,be happy? If God creates us,then surely these people were also created by Him? Ask Him about this,then. Why blame Satan?

[@maxm3295]

@@FransceneJK98nah your god trash homie.

[@maxm3295]

@@FransceneJK98if you really wanna worship something great you should worship deez

[@isaiahgimlewicz8298]

So sad, made me cry inside for them.

[@ioroman]

I've seen this documentary under a different name. Hope that Chatah, a beautiful human with a beautiful soul has found a way out of the situation in which he was.

[@Happytobeehere]

My biology professor made us watch this as she is pakastani

[@gabrielfrost9134]

Chahat* and it's she* don't misgender trans people.

[@gabrielfrost9134]

Pakistan*

[@ioroman]

@@gabrielfrost9134 I understand, I did not mean to offend. Chatah can teach more than a bit of humanity to many. Nice human being, very deserving of happiness.

[@a.walters123]

@@gabrielfrost9134”it’s a she”. ironically, you calling her an “it” is also misgendering her.

[@mostafijurrobin867]

Chahat you just broke my heart. 💔

[@SabaKhan-ge6jh]

Sad for Chahat 😢

[@youhavebeenhacked88]

Truly

[@SarahSayed-dy7be]

As a Muslim, i want y'all to understand it, IN ISLAM WE MUSLIM DON'T JUDGE ANYONE AND THERE'S A HADITH WHICH REMINDS US THAT WE DON'T HAVE TO HATE OR COUNT HER DEEDS OR EVEN JUDGE A WOMAN EVEN IF SHE'S A CALL GIRL. ONLY ALLAH KNOWS WHAT'S IN THEIR HEARTS, AND KNOWS IF THEY ARE BETTER THAN YOU!...Islam never allows to judge someone by their looks or deeds...we muslims never see them in that way but we helps them (not talking about those who r muslims by name but haven't understood their own religious book). You can read any authentic hadith and Qur'an you'll get your answers.

[@devaabhir8884]

Your Islam is crooked… any religion which treats human as animals and slaves is crooked. And it may that Islam is not that bad but its followers are so wicked and nasty that they have tainted Islam.

[@devaabhir8884]

You treat non followers as Kafirs… you call for jihad against nonbelievers…. You guys love violence and hate against followers of other sects… you reek of hatred.

[@jillhebert4551]

Your own Religion by nature ours down women and makes them less than human. It teaches hate for those who aren't Muslims and offers no comfort to those who suffer at the hands of it' "spiritual leaders" Women have no place in Muslim society or its religious beliefs. They are there for two reasons only. 1 to please the man and the second to have kids.

[@user-fy8sp3vw3h]

Absolutely correct

[@afrozairin8438]

Are you Sunni? Which Hadees you are talking about?

[@Northmountainranges]

You are paving the way for future transgenders. You are showing them the courage to live their life as they feel they should. You are all very courageous despite the mountains you need to climb. God bless you all.

[@theoryofpersonality1420]

God doesn't bless sinners or even hear their prayers. The prayers of a sinner are an abomination to God.

[@theoryofpersonality1420]

Before you ignorantly argue it's written in scripture

[@Northmountainranges]

@@theoryofpersonality1420 Sad to hear that your god is such.

[@Northmountainranges]

@@theoryofpersonality1420 Is that how you christians are? calling others abomination, ignorant etc. The God that I know loves everyone and everything. Love you my fellowman. 🙂

[@mandelzweig5453]

لقد دمرتهم بلداننا بأفكاركم هذه ،لكن الحمد لله الشعوب ترفض هذه الأفكار

[@DBayonetta]

They will be forever: movie stars! Respect

[@jonathantv269]

If anyone see chahat anywhere please give her lot's of love🤧

[@syed5623]

41:39 " Do you have any teenage girls ? Oh my gosh , what is wrong with these men? Apni biwiyoun ko parda karane may to number one par hote hain aur khud ISLAM kay basic rules follow naik karte , lanat hay in par

[@emergencyambulance2017]

teenage to bohot zyada boldiye , mene suna hai 9 years and 10, 11, 12 years waalon k saat bhi tapa tap tapa tap hota hai. peso ka chakkar babu bhaiya peso ka chakkar !!!!! yahan india me bhi hota hai, aur khatarnaak large scale me, after all hamara india in cheezo me maahir hai !!

[@ranjittyagi9354]

​@@emergencyambulance2017 India me 9, 10....12 saal wali larkion k saath kahan ho raha ha?

[@emergencyambulance2017]

gaon khedo me, wo jo nange baba ghoomte hain aur unki pooja karte hain log, unke yahan dekha mene, aur massage centers me chale jao wo options dete hain iss age k saat tapa tap karna hai to itna pesa, aur iss age k saat karna to itne pesa etc..... me to anjaan tha in cheezon se jab pata chala to me bhi shocked tha k ye sab bhi chalta hai, aur to aur kuch gareeb hain to peso k liye karte aur kuch willingly karte hain because unko lagta hai religion ka kaam karrahe , bewakoof purane soch k log. @@ranjittyagi9354

[@mandelzweig5453]

اهتم ببلدك و المصائب التي توجد فيها، أنتم آخر من يتكلم عن الإسلام، أنتم لا تعرفون الإسلام

[@Hud.Alexdavenston]

I hope the pakistan rules on them will change & they will get a better life, Amen✝️❤️

[@fargeri]

That’s Christianity ✝️ love and respect for all human beings. Thank you

[@mandelzweig5453]

نحن نعرف ما يوجد في التوراة والإنجيل، الشذوذ الجنسي لا يجوز وهو ذنب، لعلك لا تعرف كتابك؟

[@mandelzweig5453]

​@@fargeri يا صغيري، اذهب وتعلم دين المسيحية جيدا ،الأمر ليس كما تعتقد

[@theholygospels3409]

​@@mandelzweig5453 Here we are talking about those people who are eunuchs by birth, not about those who are homosexual men and women.

[@theholygospels3409]

​@@mandelzweig5453 we know Christinity very well by both Holy Bible and Catechism of the Church but 1st you need to know isalm very well because it is not that much peaceful in which people define it

[@Harmoncamoonster]

The last scene made me cry 😢

[@haristahir3472]

I hope some foreign company sponsors Maggie because here in Pakistan it's very unlikely.

[@abdulKhan-qp3li]

मैं तो यह समझता था कि पाकिस्तान इस्लामिक देश है लेकिन हकीकत कुछ और ही है लानत है पाकिस्तानी पर और निज़ाम को बरबाद करने वाले पर

[@aryanhassan4659]

Tu gawaar hai..chu...

[@tdddddd7408]

Muslim call it haram but in islam slave is halal,what a hypocrisy 😅😅

[@najahhassan8890]

I think you did not know any think about so don't make your self like you did both transgender and slave are haram in islam .islam is only regions that harams slave trade الحمد لله الحمد لله الحمد لله الحمد لله الحمد لله على نعمة الإسلام الحمد لله الله اكبر

[@chilltarts]

What this documentary conveniently decides to not address is the fact that many of the men living this way now started out as "dancing boys" who were kidnapped or sold into the position. Then, when they get too old to be "desirable" they are released but have nowhere to go. They are rejected from society because of their past, and so they form little communities to support one another. Completely understandable, but it shouldn't have happened to them in the first place. It was the sexual assaults and trauma they endured as children that are key contributing factors to they way they live as adults. THIS is why it is called haram, because it starts from a place of evil thoughts and lustful designs, with no respect for the difference between child and adult, or men and women. It is using the body for the opposite of what it is designed and preying upon the most vulnerable to accomplish those dark goals. This is the exact opposite of the love Christ challenged us all to show to one another 😢

[@visibleowner]

Slave is halal in islam? 😂 which verse saying that? Did you know that slave is absolutely forbidden in our religion?

[@NickanM]

​@@visibleowner *_Go to Dubai, watch the slavery IRL, how they treat Indian and Filipino people. Muslims are the most hypocritical people on the planet._* 🙄

[@Melissa-ur3qd]

​@@visibleowner yes slave slave is hala in islam i'm ex Muslim and i know slave is halal find the mulk el yamin = slave Maria el kabtia she is a slave sexual of mohamed search search carefully and you will be shocked There is not a single verse that forbade slavery I have given you one of the verses that talks about slavery under the name mulk el yamin ملك اليمين

[@PrashantKumarPrashant708]

For those who don't know, not giving money to transgenders is considered as bad Omen in South Asia culture , so hiring them as Tax collector is a smart move .

[@yanniiboy1961]

So many pains in transgenders life. God has to bless and save them. One percent efforts are for government to make their life better. God bless you all. Take care.

[@XMorbidChaosX]

The viewers deserve to see what has become of Chahat. No one should feel that alone.

[@iwillexplain6802]

2:30 the woman destroying her own words "I don't believe they're born this way" by saying "chances of this is 1 in 100,000" ... 🤔🤔

[@mijuajua4820]

It is sad that people just can’t be excepted for who they want to be. As long as they are hurting anyone else.😢

[@Ayesha______]

@DonnellOkafor-ig3ovyou said the truth

[@soniaess28]

Women and girls are harmed when men pretend to be women.

[@slbellue6874]

As a Christian, I do not accept this lifestyle, but the people in these communities do not deserve to be mistreated either.

[@soniaess28]

Women and girls suffer tremendous harm when men pretend to be women.

[@panjandrum.conundrum]

@@slbellue6874 It's not a lifestyle. It's a natural phenomenon. Sapolsky has a lecture on trans-sexuality, easy to find.

[@Leosmommy19]

Poor Chahat... She just looks to be so over this life.

[@mickwilliamnation-3.049]

The earth is round and flat at the same time...

[@mariyanaatanasova2931]

Estegfirullah!Subhan Allah!I cannot understand how in a Muslim country like Pakistan, there can be such people who do not even know what they are - men or women?!😢

[@aryanhassan4659]

It's an old culture of south asia,..our culture is 5000 years old...

[@Гость-щ1л]

Их надо изолировать от общества !!

[@ishanimiddya2914]

I am just praying to God pls give those men some good intention in life ... its really scary

[@zarinekharshiing2047]

Chahat has very sad eyes...I hope that she will find happiness

[@brutarie225]

Wich year is this documentary made ?

[@Leosmommy19]

I'm guessing 2010-2011, it was released in 2011.

[@AkinbouChang]

Guru is like a wolf in sheep's skin.

[@vimalkumarsharma5848]

Chahat's pain of being deprived of love is very deep

[@chaitanyar5982]

The issue is not of Pakistani’s being transgender, the issue is there shouldn't be prostitution.

[@shicc4008]

How else do you think they're gonna survive when they can't get normal jobs?

[@TheBeautifulOne_Charmaine]

​@@shicc4008then let them move in with you while having " clients" in and out of your house and dropping them off and picking them up from your house, since You have no issue with prostitution 🤷🏽‍♀️😐

[@shicc4008]

@@TheBeautifulOne_Charmaine when I say I'm okay with someone doing dairy business that doesn't mean I'll tie Buffaloes in my own backyard, dumass.

[@yvettejones4249]

Please do not do the surgery. It is absolutely unnecessary and many times unsafe. Just keep your original parts and wear dresses.

[@kostasveronis5882]

From the whole documentary, the only thing surprised me most is how dirty are the streets in Pakistan!

[@markeugenelee2083]

No sewerage System either The place stinks

[@anandadaquino3604]

I was thinking about it, and thinking at the same time how using "ecobags" sound stupid now. Not that we shouldn't do our part, but some people hink that they are saving the world 😂

[@TheSujitKDas]

Amazing video, though very sad 😢.

[@ganesankuppusamy8343]

When I asked the Almighty for peace, The Almighty showed me the Earthians living among religious menace, When I asked the Almighty for strength, The Almighty gave me many problems to face. When I asked the Almighty for happiness, The Almighty showed me the sufferings of poor. When I asked the Almighty which religion to follow, The Almighty showed me madness of religious slaves. When I asked the Almighty for wealth, The Almighty showed me Politicians and god-men. When I asked the Almighty for favour, The Almighty showed me corruptive Earthians. When I asked the Almighty to save the Earthians from distress. The Almighty blessed the Earthians to live with love and affection. Finally, the Almighty gave me nothing or anything, But the Almighty showed me the right path to live without religious menace.

[@sagarlinganur5672]

every life is valuable......everyone should live a degnified life

[@mandelzweig5453]

الحياة الكريمة هي مساعدة هؤلاء للرجوع إلى الطبيعة و معالجتهم

[@Lin6055m]

Education is so important!!!

[@jaiyabyrd4177]

WOW, but I can't stop remembering a movie called "The Crying Game". 10:47 , 11:23 The transgender rites of passage is to be owned by another in the group‼️ Slavery

[@mariahiller]

Yeah, that movie stays with you.

[@nanni8629]

26:56 the sadness in her eyes 👀…

[@halimamohamed4400]

His

[@refilweseeletse5770]

The ministry of utmost happiness ❤

[@wlfbd]

This guru uses members of his community as slaves 😢 As humans, we live in multiple realities and it does not only depend on the will of mens or Gods. It depends above all on us as living beings and on tolerance of our different beliefs. Without respect, there is no peace for the human spirit. Reality is creation of our mind. Like Gods is an human creation. So if you believe in god you can understand that Transgender women are women. There is not just one way to move forward, there is one for every person on earth. I believe in you, like god believes in me. Peace and freedom ✌🏼

[@Smiley_3997]

Yeah thats very cruel to buy someone and have them as a slaive

[@AngeloBenitto]

Chahat just broke my heart …..

[@kireniarodriguez6382]

The government is to blame, many do not want to do those jobs but are given no other option, why deny them an identification card? what is the reason why?

[@theoryofpersonality1420]

What a gross place.

[@halimamohamed4400]

Yeah they should have lock them up

[@Fatoumamouddj]

The slavery is still exist 😢 those gurus are evil in flesh

[@theempresss2020]

Wishing they get jobs so they won't be working on the streets!!

[@Austrian_blood]

I hope these ladies can find peace in a judgemental society.

[@nicole4659]

They r not women

[@jacqueline8559]

They are NOT LADIES. What is wrong with you? This World is becoming sicker and sicker. An affront to God.....may Jesus return soon 🙏

[@tammytan2635]

@@jacqueline8559 oh honey. People have been saying that for two thousand years. He’s not coming.

[@sarahhumphreys3980]

They are men

[@dazeyknows6736]

@@tammytan2635sad for you but us Christians believe he is

[@kriskabin]

So where are the Transgender males in this documentary?

[@sissyrayself7508]

Lol. They were all the guys pretending to be female..they were all males.

[@Clairsmith123]

14:47 did this Swine just Burp??! Also Chahat looks Desperately unhappy 😢😢

[@RitaKapia]

Yes😂😂

[@annesamson5489]

Well yes, leave a family of children alone with one unsupervised. Those kids will be destroyed.

[@evilladollyz7602]

I like the religious guy who has answers for everything. That's why third world countries never change and never move forward.

[@mandelzweig5453]

وإلى أين وصل بكم التقدم؟ إلى الآن ما زال أحدكم يفكر هل هو رجل أم إمرأة؟ أنتم لا تعرفون إلى الآن الفرق بين الرجل والمرأة 😅

[@NachfahreeinerBauernmagd]

​@@mandelzweig5453Warum nutzt du westliche Technik? Heuchler.

[@gabrielamaramures289]

@@NachfahreeinerBauernmagd Ipocrit ești tu și chiar mai mult!...Ce legătură are tehnologia occidentală cu aceste creaturi și cu promiscuitatea promovată de unii??? Dacă toți ar fi fost ca ăștia , azi n-ar fi existat nici tehnologie nici occident!

[@dev9100-luv-the-world]

Very informative ❤

[@squeakel11]

They say they can't get ID cards but they have ID cards with their male names on them. Any of them could find work as men and trans out in their off time if they wanted to. I'm a woman, but if I needed to not wear makeup or feminine jewelry to find work I would.

[@flamingpi2245]

Are you trans? If not, I don’t think you’re qualified to imagine what it’s really like

[@Jones-w5i]

True😊

[@theanonymousnobody8509]

You don't even understand what dysphoria is and how does it work, yet try to blame others. Very common among TERFies

[@ashrafsiddiqui194]

Really speechless

[@tamayugoth632]

I am wondering if there are any transgender men, or is the term only for transgender women ?

[@Ayesha______]

trans woman refers to biological men who act like women and trans men are biological women that act like men.

[@Nutmeg142]

True. How many women had to dress like men back in the day to work? They can just be themselves without makeup during the week and then dress how they want to at night and in the weekend unless they are scared someone will recognize them.

[@soniaess28]

All of the men featured in this film are men.

[@anni700]

​@Nutmeg142 that doesn't make any sense, how does that has to do with anything?

[@muhammadaamir754]

Im speechless 😢 I have no words 😢😢😢😢😢

[@TheIHVPNetwork]

SF, Thailand, and Pakistan. Ok. Noted. I must admit, I'm shocked to discover Pakistan. Goes to show---you dont know what ya dont know---AND what you think you know---and even after you think you know---ya dont know sh**! WOW!

[@CyberMachine]

Add Iran to the list too

[@kim.epurdy1644]

Religion can be the biggest life stealer, the transexuals in this documentary are amazing individuals, thank you for sharing your life journey, hope all are safe and well. 🥰

[@mandelzweig5453]

بسبب رفضكم للإسلام توجد فوضى في العالم، لا يمكن الخروج من هذه الفوضى و الرجوع إلى الطبيعة إلا في الإستسلام لله

[@slbellue6874]

They’re not amazing, they’re just humans like everyone else.

[@NachfahreeinerBauernmagd]

​@@mandelzweig5453🤮

[@hassanshirazi-k3o]

واقعا چقدر این گروه مظلوم هستند. امیدوارم در تمام دنیا این گروه ال جی بی تی به حقوق اجتماعی و مدنی دست پیدا کنند .❤

[@Гость-щ1л]

Вот и забирайте их себе

[@Гость-щ1л]

Шиитка