Pakistani civil servant's 1971 warning | 'میں بتا چکا تھا کہ فوج کے پاس صرف چھ مہینے ہیں' | VOA Urdu

امریکہ میں مقیم اسکالر اکبر ایس احمد 1971 میں اس وقت کے مشرقی پاکستان میں بطور اسسٹنٹ کمشنر تعینات رہے۔ وہ ان حالات و واقعات کے عینی شاہد ہیں جو بنگلہ دیش کے قیام کا سبب بنے۔ وائس آف امریکہ کے نمائندے عبدالعزیز خان سے بات کرتے ہوئے انہوں نے 50 برس قبل کی یادیں اور مشاہدات بیان کیے ہیں۔

[@hakunamatata3935]

Thanks for being fair and speaking the truth. It is unusual for a Pakistani 💖

[@TSchem]

The Pak army especially it's Generals were the real culprits of those masacer. We had been kept in dark by imposing censored over the reality and history of 1971 . We had remain in darkness until we aware Army Generals and their barbarian policies

[@Gorkhali_01]

This is by far the most honest Pakistani veteran of 1971 war I have ever listened to. Thanks for speaking out the truth...!!!

[@richardsking]

Sindh and Baluchistan still suffer from this.😢

[@mmhasankhan5281]

We always wanted to live as proud Pakistani since the partition in 1947. But you guys need to go back what you did to us!! 23 years of oppression! You never treated us as Pakistani. Your leaders and military dictators always treated us differently in all aspects. We had no option except independence led by Father of the Nation Bangabandhu Sheikh Mujibur Rahman. Joy Bangla. Long live Bangladesh 🇧🇩 🇧🇩 🇧🇩

[@humanscare3328]

You are absolutely right my brother.we did wrong with you in every aspect.its not the fault of people of West Pakistan.its totally due to Pakistani asstablishment.i m sorry to you and all Bangladeshi people.forgive us.love you my brother.love from Pakistan 🇵🇰❤️💚💙💜🤎🇧🇩.God bless you my brother

[@sayarahmad1145]

Absolutely correct. Still keep love with each other bcz of being muslims.

[@MaulanaUmerHasanQadri]

We the people of Pakistan are sorry to All Bangladeshi brothers and people for the genocide from the bottom of our hearts. Joy Bangla. Joy Mukti.

[@matt_canadian]

You are right. West Pakistani Establishment and military is soley responsible with the help of some shortsighted politicians for the breakup. Military should have done the right thing by sending Mujeeb and Bhutto to the assembly and sort out things there as PM and Leader of Opposition respectively ... but alas military killed them both. As a West Pakistani I apologize to people of East Pakistan, all the best people of Bangladesh. Joy Bangla 🇧🇩 and Pakistan Zindabad 🇵🇰

[@shamsi4481]

I don’t know why people are not able to think criticality the background reasoning for all of this and people who know the reasoning keep telling the lies because they cannot tell the truth. I believe they should just keep quiet instead of giving false reasoning.

[@AbdulWahab-lz2hu]

Excellent Interview God blessed Akbar sb A true story of East Pakistan

[@MuhammadAslam-ue2dj]

Sahibzada Yaquib Ali Khan very brilliant personality.

[@shamimahmmed1172]

Very nice species dear ftom your true story.. From Bangladesh

[@fslurrehman]

So far the most promising and positive interview.

[@saifinbutt]

The first person who spoke the truth fairly and clearly. We must say sorry to our Bengali brothers and sisters. We're sorry. ❤️🙏❤️

[@monirmalick4016]

He is Stooge of Military,Why say Sorry ,it is good they got separated.

[@pksharma7183]

@@monirmalick4016 yah why say sorry….that’s why ur a jahil jihadi third class country

[@AsadKhan-ii3es]

Don't regretted...As a professional Army Pakistan Military doing same thing as any Nation's Army will have to doing if their nation get under threat..

[@baborali2276]

Learn to speak English before commenting, this goes to show uou have sgit for brains

[@MuhammadAhmed-yy9es]

​@@AsadKhan-ii3es By Killing own People ??

[@masoodurrehman8598]

بہت اچھا اور متوازن تجزیہ ہے۔ خوب صورت گفت گو ۔۔۔۔!

[@khalidlatif8930]

History repeats itself

[@qazihussain497]

Nothing was learnt from the 1971 tragedy. The similar type of mistakes were repeated in Karachi operation of early 90's. Gen. Babar did in Karachi exactly what Tikka did in the former E. Pakistan. Thanks to Gen. Moinuddin Haider for timely intervention!

[@faizaziz289]

I am myself from Karachi, Gen, Babur did the right thing eliminating MQM terrorists.

[@waseemnoor8829]

Mashallah Mashallah Very Nice Real Speak

[@talhashahid3596]

Thanks for such insightful Interview.

[@chandanhalder2850]

Pakistan should take care their Baloch, Sindhi other minority people..need to give their right and stop genocide.otherwise time will be repeated like us🇧🇩... if Pakistan government like us..they asked apologize to us officially..but they didn't... JOY BANGLA 🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩

[@aachowdhury7503]

Sir you talk true.i respect you

[@imranch999]

Great views 👌

[@GurdipSingh-pr7ob]

Very nice interview and truth speaking by you Sir. Atleast you have accepted some of the wrong doings by the people like Bhutto. I feel he was the real culprit of this tragedy of breaking of Pakistan n he has been fully punished by the God. Anyway it's time to retrospect. Nice video.

[@boblimits753]

Thank you sir for being so truthful.. finally feel very emotional to hear the truth in Urdu… As a proud bangladeshi we feel blessed that we separated from Pakistan .. i wouldn’t be living the life of luxury in USA or in Dhaka for that matter - if bangladesh wasn’t born as this gave my father a fair chance in life 😎

[@siftainbutt9693]

He is absolutely right 👍

[@thomasedison5577]

Thank you sir ❤️ nice video 👍 Joy Bangla

[@MuhammadHassan-uq6zb]

Bangladeshi was real Pakistani

[@hakunamatata3935]

We are not your brothers. Brothers do not kill each other. Stay away from us

[@mohammadshah2608]

Well said.sir.

[@noahh6291]

Good man Pakistan zindabad from sylhet, Bd

[@nadeemanwar3762]

Allah bless u sir,

[@zahidraza7136]

آج بلوچستان اور پختونخوا میں وہی ہو رہا ہے۔

[@kafeespondon1608]

It seems good that at least one Pakistani accept that they did wrong with us.. If you accept your fault it doesn’t mean you are looser,it means you have humanity.. But alas!! Still lots Pakistani don’t accept this truth..and the truth is we were victim. My uncle was killed by Pakistani army...

[@humanscare3328]

I really accept that we did not give rights to bangoli people.i m assumed on it.but it's not the fault of West Pakistan,s people.its due to Pakistani asstablishment.brother I am very sorry to you and all Bangladeshi people.love you my brother.love from Pakistan 🇵🇰❤️💚💙💜🤎🇧🇩

[@Junaid-Jutt236]

well done you are telling the truth

[@zahoormiran1882]

Booht dukh hota h ya sun k

[@bengalibabu46]

True speech ❤️

[@fareedgee4485]

بیوروکریسی آفسر گراؤنڈ ریلٹی کو اس وقت نہ سمجھے ۔ اب یہ غصہ ختم ھونا چاھئے دونوں طرفہ آگے بڑھ کر دونوں ملکی تعلق بنائے جاے

[@arifhossainrubel4791]

We are moving forward and we don't need you to get along with us. You see yourselves.

[@sherfazal288]

In my view making west n east pakistan was a political mistake which appeared in 1971 Dhaka fall,,,,it should had been right from the binging ,,,,,there should be two countries,,,,,pakistan n Bangladesh in 1947,,,,,any how now we have brother Islamic country Bangladesh we love n respect them n wish them all the best,,,,.

[@PerwezAbdulMalick-gm9jo]

I am a Pakistani and I will say that's our habit not to go for merit only dirty nepotism.

[@mohammadshah2608]

General Musharraf did have words of sorry.when he went to Bangla Desh.thx

[@shahiduzzaman501]

True depiction of background.

[@vetdoc95]

Pakistan must unconditionally apologize to the people of Bangladesh for the atrocities committed by the Pakistani army.

[@explorewithahsann]

boht afsos hota hai sunn kar k kitne kharab faislay kiay gye 71 mein.

[@amvedin]

Every statement that he makes is honest and true. It is a pity that a sophisticated, polished, and able person like him was relegated to insignificance. The same trend is now happening in Baluchistan.. I am sure this province will also go the Bangladesh way.

[@amitmazumder7416]

Nice and intelligent Pakistani...

[@sasmac1829]

The irony is that both Bhutto and Mujib were murdered and their murders were also murdered

[@bannuhackar7280]

Kash esa na hota

[@khayrulislam7445]

Very important interview but I can,t understand due to unknown of Urdu. Please broadcast this type of interview with subtitle in Bangla/English.

[@BenAAlawi]

Officers were behind Someone's wife This was character of Pakistani officers in Bengal Bhutto was the main person behind Pakistan's trajedy.

[@shermohammad3544]

کیا ھم نے بنگال کی آزادی سے کچھ سیکھا نہیں اج پھر چھوٹے صوبوں کے ساتھ بڑا ظلم ھو رھا ھے۔

[@shahanulislambhuiyan6538]

Bengal is not a small Province. Bengali Pakistan ka 56% Population thi

[@ibrahimsyed7387]

Mr AC did you read the books of binnerje & boras ?

[@sayedfarhad5017]

Pakistanis were not capable to to keep the country United.. haha because of the beurucracy..

[@Isqa-uw5se]

Bhutto lovers must watch this video and listen about him.

[@silenthill1035]

Unfortunately our establishment has not learned an iota from the tragedy. Had they learned anything, they would not have killed Akbar Bugti. Just because the establishments gets away with such crimes, they find use of force as the most effective tool when they are not having their way.

[@aamirsaeed6927]

جب فوج عوام کو مارے تو نفرت ہی پیدا ہوگی۔ لیکن آرمی کو کون سمجھائے۔ انکی عقل تو گٹوں میں ہوتی ہے۔

[@HassanAmin77]

Pakistan army was defeated politically and militarily on East and West in 1971.

[@badruzzamanqamaruzzaman4082]

It's true

[@mshoaib9764]

یہ کب ریٹائرڈ ہویے؟

[@rajivranjan6373]

Pakistan was created on the foundation of hatred in 1947 and it broke on the bedrock of hatred in 1971. There is a historical consistency, may be, that this brilliant scholar failed to mention or even failed to recognize. He yearns for Bangla Pak meeting of hearts again, but the broader question of Hindu Muslim enmity or brotherhood is still in his blind sight. As the French are apt to say - the more it changes, the more it remains the same.

[@tauheedullahbabar1038]

Awami leage secured 161 seats in national assembly y Session of Assembly was cancelled by yahya khan ZABhutto jumatislami Sheikh Mujeeb was compeled to say good by to islamabad he was true leader

[@MuhammadHassan-uq6zb]

Yeh inka haqq tha

[@rightvoice7405]

what was Agartalla conspiracy ? Is it was fake or real.? Are mujeeb speaches and activities revealed the direction of independence and seprate country bangladesh? what was autonomy &and six points ?

[@imrannaikawadi2856]

Pakistan divided because of injustice and barbarism to east pakistan.

[@eagleeye111pindi7]

Bilkul 100 percent true 👍 punjabi establishment nay hi Bangladesh banaya bhutto ghaddar tha usko use kya aur pindi main phansi di

[@Khalifa-by6kr]

This biggest loss to Pakistan was due to poor strategy of Pakistan military establishment and Pakistan was divided into two parts. curse on the Pakistan army generals, which caused such a huge loss to Pakistan

[@atifali4194]

سولجرز لڑتے تھے کیوں کہ وہ ہتھیار نہیں ڈالنا چاہتے تھے باقی یہ بات بھی ٹھیک ہے کہ پاکستان کی آرمی کا بنگلہ دیش میں لڑنا ٹھورا سخت تھا لیکن مسئلہ فوجی سے زیادہ سیاسی تھا اور بھی پورا ذمہ دار ہے

[@mohammedbelalahmed7062]

No I don’t think so after 50 years Pakistan weak up for friendship to much rape killings distroy our country 1971 we do remember what Pakistan done in Bangladesh

[@syedishfaq560]

Ap A.c. tay aur Deputy commissioner ko bulay

[@moidalam6275]

The whole interview is about "Me Me Me". Jesus, have some shame.

[@sherebangla142]

Yes Bhutto did a show off in UN.

[@syedabdulwahidsohaily493]

Everybody talks after any the turmoils, nobody does, in or before the happenings 🤭🤔

[@mohammadshah2608]

Obligation to any always pays.

[@Pakistani-1947]

بنگلہ دیش جیسا بھی ہے اب بھی ہمارا ہے کیوں کہ وہاں ماشااللہ آج بھی مسلمان بستے ہیں باقی پریشانی کی کوئی بات نہیں آخر علیحدگی تو ہوتی ہے جب انصاف نا ملے جب نفرت بغض حسد ہو ایک دوسرے سے باقی الگ ہوکر بنگلہ دیش نے ماشااللہ بہت ترقی کی ہے اور مجھے خوشی بھی ہے اور ہمیں بنگلہ دیش کو اور اس کی آزادی کو دل کی گہرائیوں سے تسلیم کرنا چاہیے ہمیں ان سے برادرانہ تعلقات قائم کرنے چاہیے تاکہ ہم ترقی کے میدان کردار دا کرے دنیا کے نقشے بنتے اور مٹتے رہتے ہیں تاریخ پہلی ختم ہو جاتی ہے نئی شروع ہو جاتی ہے ہمیں بنگلہ دیش کو چھوڑ کر بلوچستان کی فکر کرنی چاہیے سندھ کی فکر کرنی چاہے پنجاب کی فکر کرنی چاہیے گلگت بلتستان کی فکر کرنی چاہیے خیبر پختون خاں کی فکر کرنی چاہیے کشمیر کی فکر کرنی چاہیے یہی پاکستان کو ترقی مند اور رقبہ دلا سکتا ہے

[@jawadahmed355]

They earned it back then .. and now they are doing the same with remaining pakistan. Only to save their DHAs

[@salimm97]

The main reason for the partition of Pakistan is the caste discrimination of Pakistanis

[@wamiqhussain5395]

مجھے اس بات کا 100فیصد یقین ھے کہ کچھ عرصہ بعد یہ دوریاں ضرور ختم ھوجاینگی بھائیوں میں لڑائی تو ھوسکتی ھے لیکن ماں باپ کا رشتہ جوڑ ہی دیتاھے اور ہمارے جوڑنے کا رشتہ اسلام ھے

[@bengalibabu46]

Never

[@ibrahimsyed7387]

InshaALLAH

[@Pakistani-1947]

بے شک آپ نے سچ بات کی ہے

[@Pakistani-1947]

​@@bengalibabu46یہ سچ ہے مسلمان صرف ایک بھائی بھائی نہیں یہ ایک جسم ہے اور جس دن یہ احساس پیدا ہوگیا تو یقین مانے بنگلہ دیشی خود کہے گیں ہمیں پاکستان کا حصہ پھر بنائے اور یہ اسی دن ہوگا جس ہم میں اسلام زندہ ہوا جس دن ہم میں صوبہ پرستی ذات پرستی اور فرقہ پرستی ختم ہوئی جس دن ہم میں ایمان اتحاد تنظیم انصاف پیدا ہوگیا اور انشااللہ دکھ اس بات کا نہیں بنگالی علیحدہ ہوگے دکھ تو اس بات کا ہے بنگالی ہمیں بھول گیں ان کو چاہیے تھا بنگلہ دیش کا نام بنگلہ دیش نا رکھتے بے شک وہ اپنی کرنسی لین دین پاکستان سے علیحدہ ہو جاتے مگر اس خطے کا پاکستان ہی نام رہنے دیتے اور نظریہ پاکستان زندہ رکھتے مگر بنگلہ دیش میں آج بھی دو قومی نظریہ زندہ ہے بنگلہ دیش کا نام عوامی جمہوریہ بنگلہ دیش کے بجائے اسلامی جمہوریہ بنگلہ دیش ہونا چاہیے

[@bengalibabu46]

@@Pakistani-1947 write in english u dumb

[@khawarkhan9594]

All truth akbar sab said but only one thing I want to say.. The words UDAR TUM IDHAR HUM were never said by bhutto, these were the words of journalist ABBAS ATHER LATE who clearly said that it was his estimate about bhutto mind but bhutto didn't say this, it was just to make a thrilling news.

[@MUHAMMADASLAM-bt7df]

Hmmarry log history nhi janty hai aur ap jaissy channels k propaganda mai a jatty hain.. Jin logo ny mil kr Muslim league bnnai thi wo sb Ali garh university k teachers thai.. Us ka idea aik bengali nawab khuwaja samiullah ny diya tha jin ka poorra khandaan 1971 ki war mai bangladesh chor kr Pakistan a gaya tha.. Kaha ki battyn krty hain ap??army ko blame mt karryn kuon k army k pass sirf hatyaar hota hai wo sirf apny mulk ki hiffazat krti hai.. Pakistan aur bangladesh k politiciana ny mil kr jo gnd phailaya us ko end pr army k hissy mai dal dainna sb sai bari bai-imaani hai.. Urdu k naam pr banny walli muslim league aur phr us ko pakistan mai convert walli zuban ko bangalio ny accept krny sai inkaar kr diya.. Kabhi province ka msla tu kabhi zuban ka.. Islam k naam pr aik honny wally log is barry mai kb sai sochny laggy.. Jis din paihlly bangali k dil mai islam ko chor kr yai khayal a gaya tha k wo bangali hai, us ki zuban bangali hai ussi din in ko separate kr dainna chahiye tha.. Kuon k ab un k aur hmmarry drmayan koi wjha baqqi nhi thi aik raihnny ki..

[@NaseemIslahi-kd7eu]

Our army is not patriot

[@imtiazdar7787]

*یہاں نارتھ امریکہ میں بنگلہ دیش کے چند بزرگان سے بہت پیار محبت والا ماحول ھے سب فوج کی معافی چاھتے ھیں وزیر اعظم وغیرہ کی شاید نہیں قبول کرئینگے،* 🇵🇰 🇧🇩

[@GGG-io1br]

Bangal's people's are our brothers BUT for any reason if one brother opt to get support from a common enemy the results will increase disputes and break trust.

[@sundeepborade6359]

Nahi! Tum log bhikari ho.😂😂😂

[@AliHossain-kn6kf]

Many things are very easy to say but the reality is very difficult. Pakistan will have to pay 200 billion dollars to Bangladesh for compensation in 1971. Secondly, the president of Pakistan, the chief of the army of Pakistan, and the prime minister of Pakistan should apologize on behalf of the people of Pakistan.

[@syedraza7299]

S Akbar praising himself....in his entire interview...

[@TSchem]

پاکستانی فوج کے چیف کو بنگلہ عوام سے اپنے کئے پر معافی مانگنا ضروری ہے۔ یہ فوجی جرنیل جب تک اپنے اس گناہ کو تسلیم نہیں کر لیتے۔ بنگلہ عوام کے دل سے ظلم و جبر کا وہ دور محو نہیں ہو سکتا۔

[@Afalam9085]

اردو زبان و ادب اور تہذیب و ثقافت پورے برصغیر میں اعلیٰ ترین مقام پر ہے..متروکہ سندھ پر مشتمل کراچی صوبہ زندہ باد. .. آفتاب عالم خان

[@thelearningchannel3014]

Cruel army 🙏

[@akmalkhangekhankhan4556]

Story rivers

[@n2201]

Please keep the title in English, many in our generation cannot read Urdu

[@alphamale451]

Where are you from brother?

[@omairkhan4747]

Go to English Channel for English Title

[@mughalabid502]

Stupid Pakistan National language in urdu.mind your own business.

[@wownews1426]

غدار ہی تھا مجیب ۔

[@vendora01]

Now same happen with Imran Khan 🇧🇩

[@Sardar.Asad77]

Hindustan should have divided into 3 countries! Pakistan India Bangladesh Than nothing should have happend

[@nirachoudhury3826]

শতভাগ ঠৗক কথা

[@ghafoorhussain5905]

Kistan gvr kadhi bhi mafi nahi magay ga be cose ego of hard

[@waqasshaikh4365]

Good interview but one thing I must point out. Bhutto never said "IDHAR TUM IDHAR HUM,:" These comments were taken out of context to malign Bhutto. The editor of the news paper who first published these comments later retracted them and apologized for the journalistic error. kzbin.info/www/bejne/mnmpZah9na5prJo

[@AmanUllah-tk9yd]

یہ جو بتا رہا ہے یہ حقیقت کے برعکس ہے ایسا نہیں ہوا تھا ۔نیو فیدنگ ھے۔معاملات کچھ اورتھے۔ ہم نے بنگالیوں کے ساتھ زیادتی کی تھی۔ ان کا حق مارا تھا۔

[@piyushdas079]

Eventually Punjabi ego will break up pakistan

[@rightvoice7405]

You are in abroad.Be rightful say right .You enjoyed AC ship in East pakistan. but what you did to unite pakistan.You not say about any conspiracy of mujeeb india.we heard that exercise of sepration was started since 1967 by conspiracy of mujeeb india.

[@muhammadakram848]

بھٹو میں ھزارخوبیاں ھوں۔ لیکن اس کی ایک شامی ھرخوبی کوکھاجاتی ھے۔ وہ یہ ھے۔کہ جرنیلوں نےبھٹوکومجیب الرحمن کے خلاف استعمال کیااور۔بھٹواستعمال ھوابھی😊

[@MuhammadHassan-uq6zb]

Bhutto khud nahi bachaya Pakistan ko

[@ashugautam9688]

VOA use wrong image regarding india .correct it next time

[@MuhammadHassan-uq6zb]

Bangladeshi ws real democracy man

[@subratamallick9353]

Pakistan should be grateful to India that Madam Prime Minister Indira Gandhi gifted 93000 POWs back to Pakistan without facing trial for the crime against humanity. Otherwise Bengali Multi Bahini would've taken their skins off. Pakistan should be broken into following parts: 1. Independent Balochistan 2. Independent Sindhudesh 3. Independent Pakhtunistan 4. West Punjab, PoJK, PoGB should be taken over by India

[@waqasshaikh4365]

Your comments are very rude and shows that you love to hate Pakistan. India could have not kept POWs because they had to feed 93000 men everyday. India cannot feed their own people. How could they fed POWS. There are also certain international laws that cannot ignore: 1. Geneva Convention 2. Vienna Convention 3. UN Charter 4. International Court of Justice. Also, how would you like a Pakistan says that India should be divided as follow: 1. Punjab 2. Khalistan 3. Nagaland 4. Bihar 5. Bengal 6. UP 7. Hyderabad I don't wish bad for India because I feel most of the Indians are good people except people like you .

[@waqasshaikh4365]

@Fatima Khan Pakistani political leaders never had the power to govern he country/ Why do you hate them? Military establishment is ruling Pakistan since after the death of Khan Liaquat Ali Khan.

[@sonusworld5357]

@@waqasshaikh4365 Bro the sad thing Pakistan for some reason Never gave Democracy a Real chance. Now think about it - 4 Martial Laws in 75 years -- From Ayub to Yaya to Zia to Musharraf. Liaqat Ali Khan was also Shot dead by an Afghan militant while giving out a speech in Rawalpindi - What say ??

[@sb7109]

@@waqasshaikh4365 you don't know the map and taking balls

[@waris8807]

Still the same people; no one will say sorry. Same people. They have even isolated rest of pakistan from each other.

[@sayarahmad1145]

You failed to stay with banglasesh how come kashmir.

[@shahidminhas1682]

بھٹو صاحب نے کہا کہ پاکستان کو بچالیا گیا اسی وجہ سے مارشل لاء کو شکست ہوئی ۔کہتے ہیں سیاسی وجوہات کی وجہ سے شکست ہوئی۔ 1958 سے 1971 تک تو مارشلائ حکومت رہی تو شکست کو مارشلائ شکست کیوں نہیں کہتے۔ مغربی پاکستان میں 5 ہزار مربع میل رقبہ دشمن نے قبضہ کر لیا یہ کس کی سازش تھی؟