50 Years of Fall of Dhaka | How Much Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto Was Responsible?

مشرقی پاکستان کو بنگلہ دیش بنے 50 برس ہو گئے ہیں۔ پاکستان میں 1970 کے انتخابات کے بعد پیدا ہونے والے سیاسی بحران کا نتیجہ دسمبر 1971 میں سقوطِ ڈھاکہ کی صورت میں نکلا تھا۔ اس بحران میں پیپلزپارٹی کے بانی ذوالفقار علی بھٹو کے کردار پر بھی سوال اٹھتے رہے ہیں۔ ان پر لگائے جانے والے الزامات کی حقیقت کیا ہے اور کیا پاکستان توڑنے کے ذمّے دار بھٹو بھی تھے؟ جانیے وائس آف امریکہ کی سقوطِ ڈھاکہ کے 50 سال مکمل ہونے پر خصوصی سیریز کی پہلی قسط میں۔

[@rajibsarkar9910]

Thanks freedom fighters and Indian soldiers for liberating us from Pakistan.

[@personenkenzahl]

It was not the fall of Dhaka, it was the fall of Pakistan.

[@mmhasankhan5281]

We always wanted to live as proud Pakistani since the partition in 1947. But you guys need to go back what you did to us!! 23 years of oppression! You never treated us as Pakistani. Your leaders and military dictators always treated us differently in all aspects. We had no option except independence led by Father of the Nation Bangabandhu Sheikh Mujibur Rahman. Joy Bangla. Long live Bangladesh 🇧🇩 🇧🇩 🇧🇩

[@Dua1512]

You are right!

[@miansarwar7568]

Can't call you wrong being PAKISTANI. But we in PAKISTAN have big time problem's with the same INDIA which destroyed half of PAKISTAN. BANGLADESH is also under INDIAN gunpoint the day they want to take over they will just keep that in mind.

[@signalsystems]

I apologise for the racist attitude of our feudal lordship. We urdu speaking mohajirs, even today still face great political problems because of them.

[@muhammadibrahimmuhammadibr4390]

Salaam. bro. we born after this bad situation. but we can live as brother. Pakistan Bangladesh Zindabad.

[@abdulhaseebkhanafridi]

PPP should be ashamed for what they did to Pakistan. Why Bhutto didn't give a chance to Sheikh Mujeeb ur Rehman to form government ?

[@ashishverna4016]

Blaming sheikh mujeeb for raising his voice for injustice towards east by west😂 what a hypocrite people. He did what he had to for his people. It was west Pakistan who did injustice towards bengali from the beginning. Still now they didn't apologize what they did rather justifying themselves by blaming mujeeb😂

[@minarahossain874]

Good did, now we both countries are independent.🇧🇩

[@sailazamandal491]

Why Pakistan has been crying for the loss of East Pakistan? Bengali muslims(bangladeshis) are not at all showing emotions not being part of Pakistan except some like minded pakistanis in Bangladesh but at present their p. c. is very low. Pakistanis arrogancy, high handed and step- brotherly behavior and illtreatment against bengali muslims are responsible for the present situation. Instead of crying Pakistan should mind her own business.

[@piyushdas079]

ek plot haath se nikal gaya ...zameen ka greed

[@mrpakistan721]

جیالے جیالے ہوتے ہیں۔چاہے جتنے بھی unbaised لگتے ہوں۔ سانحہ مشرقی پاکستان کے ولن تو تینوں ہی تھے مجیب، یحییٰ اور بھٹو۔ لیکن اگر ان کی درجہ بندی کی جائے تو بھٹو اس سانحے کے سب سے زیادہ ذمہ دار تھے۔

[@Isqa-uw5se]

very true

[@zafaransari6015]

سب سے زیادہ گناہگار فوج /80/پرسنٹ ہیں کیونکہ حکومت فوج کر رہی تھی 20 / پرسنٹ بھٹو بھی گناہگار ہیں کیونکہ فوج کسی کی بھی گانڈ بند کر سکتی تھی

[@useressuseeess]

بھائی بھٹو سو فیصد پاکستان کو توڑنے کا بنیادی اور مرکزی کردار تھا۔

[@matt_canadian]

There were many wrongs committed by Establishment in Pakistan after 1947. The Military did blunders and politicians were serving their own interests. There was a huge communication gap between people of East and West. The differences were never reconciled. In the end 1970 elections were held, only fair elections in united Pakistan, AL won, it was necessary that results should have been accepted and power should have been transferred to Sh Mujeeb unconditionally, that's parliamentary democracy.

[@miansarwar7568]

Yes 100% correct but BANGLADESHI PEOPLE SHOULD UNDERSTAND HINDUTIVA RSS INDIAN GOVERNMENT WILL TAKE OVER BANGLADESH ON GUN POINT. WHEN EAST/WEST GERMANY COULD REUNITE WHY NOT PAKISTAN/BANGLADESH. THEN BANGLADESH WILL BE A ATOMIC COUNTRY AS WELL.

[@matt_canadian]

@@miansarwar7568 I highly doubt India could do that. If they could, they would have captured Bhutan and Nepal. Plus, they had to vacate and handover East Pakistan to AL in 1971. Plus China and Pakistan as neighbors it would be very difficult.

[@matt_canadian]

@@miansarwar7568 East and West as one country is not practical and viable being 1000 miles apart. In fact, original Division of India had called for two Muslim States, however in 1940 Lahore Resolution deleted 's' from States. At best there could be a loose Confederation, being so apart and with different weather, geographical conditions and economic environment, it is best to have system which suits each part the best .... we even cannot have Defence together.... may be Visa Free Confederating Units ...

[@miansarwar7568]

@@matt_canadian THIS IS WHAT MAJORITY OF PAKISTAN WILL DISAGREE ON. DEFENSE IS WHERE BANGLADESH WILL BE Looser AS PAKISTAN IS MUCH ADVANCE IN THIS FIELD. TWO STATE POLICY WILL BE OF NO USE TWO UNITS IS POSSIBLE. EVERYONE SHOULD UNDERSTAND THAT BANGALI PEOPLE FOUGHT WITH THEIR OWN ARMY IN 71 NOT THE PEOPLE OF WEST PAKISTAN SO IT WAS NOT CIVIL WAR IT WAS LAW AND ORDER SITUATION BECAUSE OF INDIAN SUPPORT TO ANTI PAKISTAN BANGALIS. BANGLADESHI PEOPLE HAVE TO USE THEIR MINDS WHAT'S COMING THEIR WAY FROM HINDUTIVA RSS. GENERAL ZIA UR REHMAN KNEW THIS AND WANTED PAKISTAN TO SUPPORT BANGLADESH AS A FRIEND COUNTRY. BUT AWAMI LEAGUE GOT INDIAN SUPPORT AND ZIA UR REHMAN WAS MURDERED.

[@kalamuddin4253]

Thankx to the muktees

[@miansarwar7568]

AITZAZ BHAI NO PAKISTANI WILL AGREE WITH YOU ON THIS. BHUTTO LOST THE ELECTIONS IN 1970 AND MUJIB WON THERE IS NO THIRD ARGUMENT. WHY WAS THE SESSION DELAYED. WHY DID BHUTTO NOT SIT AS A MINORITY LEADER IN THE PARLIMENT. WHAT WAS KASURI ASKING THEN. ANYTHING HAPPENING AFTER MARCH 1971 IS WHO'S MISTAKE.

[@shafquatzamankhan5932]

To put Bangabandhu Sheikh Mujibur Rahman on the "Blame List" is laughable! It just goes to show how arrogant and how devoid of morality Pakistan's attitude still is.

[@sheikhramimislamdip]

joy Bangla 🇧🇩🇧🇩♥️🇮🇳🇮🇳♥️🇷🇺🇷🇺

[@matt_canadian]

What happened in East Pakistan was very unfortunate and sad. India was given a golden chance to intervene, due to our mistakes and shortsightedness. Brothers fought unnecessarily and under wrong perception. People, government and military of West should accept that more wrongs were done by them and hence apologize to people of East Pakistan. As one from West, I personally tender my regrets and apologies to my brothers in East🙏. Today you are Bangladesh and I wish you all the best. And I pray to Allah that a day comes soon when we are brothers and sisters again. Joy Bangla 🇧🇩 and Pakistan Zindabad 🇵🇰

[@Offical_Rehman274]

So nice of you MY OPENIEAN KIA HM PHER AK BAAR MIL KR NAHIN REH SAKTY YANI EAST PAKISTAN AND WEST PAKISTAN

[@piyushdas079]

Bhutto the Sindhi was the convinient fall guy for the Pkai Punjabi Army

[@amo6030]

Politicians and Armed forces always have played with the fate of the nation. Their experiments with the nation continue un abated till date...

[@mohmmadfarhanakhtar620]

PPP power k ley Kuch bhe kr sakti ha

[@waqasshaikh4365]

Bhutto did not tear the Poland Resolution, He tore the notes he made during the UN Session. This is misleading story.

[@ashishverna4016]

Lol keep justifying.

[@abdulmoyeen9578]

Even after 50 years Pakistanis telling lies.shukur alhamdulillah.

[@fahmad7194]

Bhutto got greedy and some of the blame of 1971 debacle sticks to him but the generals were the main culprits

[@ibrahimsyed7387]

Bhutto Ko Paida Hotay He Shaheed Ho Jana Chaheay Tha. Ya phir 1971 say pehlay to ho he jana chaheay tha.

[@kafeespondon1608]

It feels sad that Pakistan still don’t accept their fault about what they did with us. Your discrimination, underestimated was the cause of 1971. But Alhamdulillah we separated from Pakistan. Now we are More develop country than Pakistan. Bangladeshi 1 taka= Pakistani 2 rupees. Our economic, financial, education conditions are far better than Pakistan. Now Bangladesh is 45% richer than Pakistan.. Alhamdulillah.. Allah help us..Allah always help the victims.. And we were victims.. But Pakistan never accept Their fault. It seems like that there are no humanity exists in Pakistan..

[@miansarwar7568]

What did INDIA gain by doing OPERATION BLUE STAR they lost OCCUPIED PUNJAB.

[@bigsmoke903]

@@miansarwar7568 who told you india lost Punjab 😂😂😂😂

[@santoshchoudhury1210]

BHOTTO 100% responsible

[@md.zahidurrahmansardar694]

Bhutto defeated in election 1970. It was not provincial election..

[@AzimKhan-py7fs]

Aitazaz left Bhutto party, he was Punjab Minister because he was a member of punjab provin from Gujrat.

[@talhashafeque]

Bhutto and army both are responsible shame on them

[@AzimKhan-py7fs]

Hussain Naqi is correct.

[@tariqmahmood7404]

Yes bhutto was involved also to break up my beautiful country i think he was pushed in to it

[@shakibshah7598]

🇧🇩

[@worldofenjoy514]

Mojeeb ur rahman aj k Imran khan ki trn thay

[@shankarganguly6407]

Agar ek Banda na rehta to mulk nahin toot ta and that was Mr Jinnah

[@Janjan-xb9io]

Bhutto aur mujib rehman ne quaid e azam ka Pakistan Thora, Allah insaf krny Wala Hy 2no ko badtareen saza b di. Rest in peace Quaid r azam♥️

[@vendora01]

How !! Mujebor raham win election why not handover power?.now same happen with Imran Khan 🇧🇩🙏

[@sharjeelsohail1650]

takat ki khawahish bara zaleel karwati hai

[@rehan_khan955]

Asal Qasoorwar Bhuttu hain Mujib haqdar thy hakumat bana ne k. Aaj muhajiro ko achoot kiyu samjha jata hai???

[@AsifAli-cy6bk]

😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢

[@ihteshamali186]

Mujeeb ka koi kasoor nai Only yahiya

[@kashifali-ix9ep]

Aitzaz bay sharm , ab to siasat na karo laanti

[@Isqa-uw5se]

is k bayan is ke bayshrmi show kartay ha

[@user-cv6jw9wl4u]

Bahi Jan Poland ki qrardad ko q phra or Pakistan tote gya koi apni he gar ko ag lagata h ager ap ka haq ho or m na d 10:28 on to ap Kiya kro gy mujab ny thk kiya bhto ny mujab ko q reha Kiya beghar kisci condition

[@SocialTarka]

اللّٰہ جل جلالہ اس شخص سے راضی ہو جائے جس بندے نے میرا چیینل سبکراب کیا، آمین...

[@siddiquikhalil6104]

آپ کے چینل میں کچھ لوگوں نے مشرقی پاکستان کی علیحدگی کا الزام مجیب الرحمٰن پہ لگایا ہے۔ لیکن انہوں نے مجیب الرحمٰن کی اس تقریر کا حوالہ نہیں دیا جس میں مجیب الرحمٰن نے جے بنگلہ کے ساتھ جے پاکستان کا نعرہ بھی لگایا تھا۔ اس سے صاف ظاہر ہے کہ مشرقی پاکستان کی علیحدگی کے سب سے بڑے مجرم بھٹو اور اس وقت کی آرمی اسٹبلشمنٹ تھی غدار مجیب نہیں۔ تھا۔ بھٹو اور آرمی تھی

[@NawabsajjidaliKhoso]

Jeay bhutto

[@zakirshah416]

Bhutto sab say bara mujrim. Yahya ko b sadarath ka lalach dia

[@quddusquddus136]

The man who created Bangladesh is the man who created Pakistan. Enter Aristotle. "A little mistake in the beginning at the end becomes a big mistake." The founder of Pakistan loved Shakespeare. Had he shown an interest in history especially the history of nation-states, he would have reason to give a pause to the most absurd idea of the world and that was tow nations theory. Not just the history of Europe. How about history of the wretched Indian subcontinent? Regionalism was real. So real that it took Punjab to hang the Sindhi feudal lord via judicial fiat.

[@akhtarzaidi9454]

Pakistani 🇵🇰 ruler, army of Pakistan 🇵🇰 and Z.A.Bhutta are equally responsible 30% each and the rest 10% are it’s peoples too for the lost of East Pakistan 🇵🇰 understand mister.

[@abdulsattar-ox5rv]

Ayub khan gen yahya or bhutto Pakistan k torny k zimadar hen.

[@ibrahimsyed7387]

Farrukh Sohail Gawandi Jhoot Holtay Hayn.

[@MuhammadKhan-oj5vi]

R90

[@kakaramanmusaxai]

Bhutto ka khya ta sub tu boat mama nyy halat karahb khyy a.

[@khurramqazi3687]

Y na hoty to in ki jaga py koi or hota bat qanoon ki h jis ka right tha us ko government di jay ki

[@drmap5194]

General Yahya and bhutto both were responsible for this tragedy and even today people are dying to be in power to loot this country 😢 may Allah protect Pakistan till the last day of the world and I hope Pakistan should move forward in a positive direction

[@zakirshah416]

Hazrath shami estt ke sooch say bahir nahi nikaltha

[@mshoaib9764]

اگر بھٹو مغربی پاکستان کی سب سیٹ جیت جاتا تب بھی وزیر اعظم نہیں بن سکتا تھا کیونکہ بھٹو نے مشرقی پاکستان میں اپنا امیدوار کھڑا ہی نہیں کیا

[@ibrahimsyed7387]

Aitezaz Ahsan Sahab Jhoot Boltay Hayn

[@Iqbalkhan-sp5eq]

Chach bolo iqtedaar KO hawks me milk good dia

[@afaqanwar2500]

Bhutto broke pakistan

[@goutomk]

Pakistani Political Leaders and Military officials, Have a look and realise a bit, Did Pakistan forget what her cruel and brutal military did in Bangladesh in 1971 ?? Ask your military high officials, what and how they committed massacred and genocide in Bangladesh. What was the fault of Bangobondhu Sheikh Mujibur Rahman?? His party All Pakistan Aoyamee League had achieved absolute majority in parliament election in 1970. Bangobondhu Sheikh Mujibur Rahman was elected as majority party leader of entire Pakistan. He could have been the next Prime Minister of entire Pakistan. But yours most corrupted leader Julfikar Ali Bhutto played a offensive - dirty beastliness game and he collaborated Pakistani Military Officials ( Eahiya Khan,Tikka Khan) to commit unprecedent genocide on innocent Bangali People. Pakistani military burned our country, raped our mothers and sisters and destroyed our Bangladesh in the name of Islam and Allah. How could Pakistani Military did it as practicing Muslim ? Are they real muslim? Was Pakistan a really Islamic country ?? Are they man or beast?? Now, at present days,after 53 years of our Independence we made our country as a developing country Little by little on the tumbledown land because, Bangobondhu Sheikh Mujibur Rahman is our great father of the nation and his beloved daughter people’s leader Sheikh Hasina is our strong leader. In every matter, in each case we are exceeded the Pakistan according to the UN standard. On the other hand, your Pakistan became one failed state in fact. Pakistan defeated again and again by Indian Military in all battle of 1947, 1965, 1971, 1999 and lost her Land like East Pakistan and Kargil ( Kashmir). Your people are now very poor and hungry . Pakistan have not much foreign currency moreover no export, no capacity to import even medicine and baby food Now Pakistan is treated as a "failed state" in world midea. But your Military officials till now are living aristocratic life and bought elit houses in Dubai, USA,Canada, London, Europe. That is not our concern. But your country is getting foreign money in the name of "anti terrorism" operation nevertheless your Pakistan is known as a "home of terror ". Pakistani military are continuously helping Afghanistani Taliban militants - those who are treated as an idiot, stupid, religious blind, narrow, fanatic terrorist of the world civilization. Pakistan borrowed billions and billions doller loan from China but couldn’t pay of those loan. Now Pakistan is in a " Loan Trap of China". Our prediction, Pakistani Military will have to pay of "China Loan " by selling their "Nuclear Bomb"(Islamic Bomb) in future and would became a faithful slave of Red China. However, Don't torture your Baluchistani people like East Pakistan. If Your military stands against Beluch People, that day will come soon - you would Lose again your holly land like East Pakistan ( Our beloved Great Bangladesh). So, dear friends of Pakistan, beg apology to Bangladesh Government and 165 millions of innocent Bangali People. Beg apology to martyred 3 millions souls who are brutally killed in 1971 of Bangladeshi liberation War. Me was a " War- Shredded Children "- who was disengaged from parents and relatives and was bound to living alone within a refugee camp 9 months inside a deep forest Assam in India in 1971 Liberation War. How could i forget that painful days?? I left the thousand questions to the Pakistani Army supported government and to conscientious Pakistani people, to world civilization. People of Bangladesh till today never did believe Pakistani military or Pakistani people at all. My doctor grand father was brutally killed by pro- Pakistani Rajakar militia. How i forgive and forget that brutality??? We demand, (1) Repay and give back our due fair dues since 14th August'1947 to 15th December'1971 (2) Give the Pakistani citizenship of 33,00000 Bangali community in Pakistan and give them proper honor and all human rights, facilities as they expect from a Islamic Republic -- just as Bangladesh has been providing services to the remaining Pakistani citizens staying inside Bangladesh since 1971. Goodbye... Stay Well...Stay safely. Allah Hafej. Joy Bangla. Joy Bangobondhu. Joy Sheikh Hasina. Long live Bangladesh.

[@furqanshaikh7796]

Ppp murdabad

[@AnilSharma-ch2lj]

Pakhtunistan and Balochistan are next

[@ibrahimsyed7387]

Too He Aag Hay Iss Dunya Ke. Raakh Ho Jay Ga.

[@eagleeye111pindi7]

Bhutto ghaddar tha mujeeb sucha pakidtani tha agar hamari fouj zulm na karti to nufrat na ho ti punjabi establishment nay hi Bhutto ko istimal kya aur phir usko phansi di aur ab karachi aur balochistan main yea hi ho raha hay

[@Iqbalkhan-sp5eq]

Bhutto he zumedaar thaa

[@anwarparvez3982]

It's not fall off Dhaka. It's fall off great Pakistan. What a shame.

[@Gamingboy07397]

Ppp ne dord pakistan

[@ibrahimsyed7387]

Khawar Naeem Hashmi Jhoot Holtay Hayn.

[@useressuseeess]

تاریخ نے بھٹو کے تاریخ کے ساتھ انصاف نہیں۔ کیا سقوط پاکستان کے حوالے سے۔ بھٹو کے جرائم زیادہ تھے اور سزا کم تھی۔ بہتر تھا کہ قتل کے علاوہ بھٹو پر غداری کا مقدمہ چلایا جاتا۔۔

[@user-on5rx6rp9u]

اب سارا ملبہ ذوالفقار علی بھثو پر

[@furqanshaikh7796]

Bhutto ghaddar