PanchaMtantra - One Tune, Four Perspectives

[@ranamitra9261]

PANCHAM - The PLATINUM PERSON in the BOMBAY music industry - it is a fact that there will not be an another RAHUL DEV BURMAN in the next 100 years - what a conception & command over the music - just enthralling.

[@abhijitrai8611]

Truely said. Anil Biswas had described R D Burman as the 'Last of the Mohicans". The last of the great masters. An era came to an end with his demise.

[@chandrashekhardamle4739]

Absolutely right sir

[@ravindrachauhan744]

Kishore kumar + Pancham da = 🔥🔥🔥

[@mandolinjournal]

You did explain it very well! It’s indeed a very talented teamwork ….. hats off to the original mandolin player. Mr Kishore Desai!!!! He and late Mr Ravi Sundaram were both great contributors to RD’s music..,, best wishes,

[@praveensaxena6582]

इस प्रकार की जानकारी देकर आप पंचम दा किशोर दा की महानता को और ऊँचाइयाँ तो दे ही रहे है साथ ही मां सरस्वती की सेवा भी कर रहे हैं। आप शानदार हैं ।

[@rishudwivedi739]

Pancham Da one the greatest personalities in history of music

[@pantangisrinivas5224]

NO ONE CAN REPLACE KISHORE DA ULTIMATE SALUTE FOR DIVINE VOCAL, BEST IN THE WORLD, NO ONE CAN REPLACE KISHORE DA NEXT @2000 YEARS, BILLIONS OF FANS ADORE HIM TRIBUTE TO HIM LEGENDARY SINGER ACTOR, ALLROUNDER, PLEASE GIVE DADASAHEB AWARD ATLEST, KEEP BEST SINGER NATIONAL AWARD ON HIS NAME, ONLY WE CAN DO THIS, WE LOVE HIM , SRINIVAS HYDERABAD

[@sandipyagnik7612]

This song was turning point of kishore kumar because his song was more liked than rafi by music lovers same song same composition,we missed more than 25 years of kishore kumar singing because he sang not much

[@NishantSharmaMusicUnlimited]

Very well explained sir👍🏻, Jai Pancham 🙏🏻❤️

[@naveensinha6570]

Thank you so much for awakening me to such nuances! RD, Kishor da and Rafi saab! Super awesome music giants!

[@girishkukadia9916]

Great videos. Can you please decode the the song Roop Tera Mastana. That is, which instruments are being played and by whom (Kersi Lord, Monhari Singh, etc???). Many thanks.

[@subratanag9044]

Wonderful analysis of the four songs in different situations.Kudos for bringing out the nuances of the musical background.

[@sanjaychatterjee8010]

I salute-- Only Possible by Panchamda--- The entire song has changed with the arrangement--- Same song, but classic changes🙏🙏pranam Pancham da.

[@mohammedalinaik2186]

Superrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrbbbbbbbbbbbbbb. I never heard these four versions earlier to understand the genius of Pancham Da. Thanks my dear for sharing so beautifully and explaining so much in details. Thank you once again.

[@pn3348]

Great Sir, Your Masterly commentary enhanced the Beauty and the magic of the song multifold. Love and salute, what a beautiful presentation.

[@kulbhushansingh1192]

Agreed. You are great sir

[@livefully1959]

I cried listening to the sad version of the song by Kishore Da

[@kulbhushansingh1192]

Thank you Maddy Sir. RD Burman the legend👆 ,ये इंस्ट्रूमेंट्स का सलेक्शन सिचुएशन के हिसाब से क्या कमाल का किया है। Same song 4 different versions. Thank you so much for such a precise presentation of showing each instrument with timely emphasis. Desperately want to congratulat you on phone

[@surajmahanta5935]

Pancham ji always no.1 music director ❤️❤️❤️❤️

[@arunachouhan8557]

Pancham da Kishor Kumar Rafi and Shashi Kapoor great combination...

[@dipakkonkar9516]

Great analysis of this song and four versions which were unknown to call mulich lovers.Rafi and Kishoreda both are great singers and we are listening them at the ahe of 70 +

[@vidyeshwarprasad6895]

So beautifully explained!👌👍All the four versions underscore the creative supremacy of RDB ..n stupendous versatility of Mohd Rafi n Kishore Kumar. I remember, in our teens how my classmates n I would debate on the versions of Kishore Kumar n Mohd Rafi. Truly ICONIC song.. the magic of the amazingly gifted RDB in multiple hues.. a rarity in Hindi film music.

[@nileshtbhartiya3854]

Amazing...just so mesmerising...issiliye Pancham aaj bhi humare dillo me zinda hain.

[@AHumanVoice123]

Pancham kind of person used to dip themselves in the oceans of music, lived in music, drink music, eat music and dreamt about music. True, there is no other musician born like him until now. Great man!

[@prakir3590]

Kishore Kumar's sad version is best.. True sad feelings expressed.. Madhubala's loss had great impact on Kishore's singing.. Majority of Kishore's Sad songs have emotional connect..

[@ravindrasuryawanshi549]

100% true✌✌

[@imkaran7]

What are you talking about. He didn't even used to visit her during her last days. He had 4 marriages. You can read about it.

[@prakir3590]

@@imkaran7 You read abt Kishore. I have read a lot about the legend.. Kishore first marriage was mutual divorce, Second one with Madhubala ended with her death, Third marriage wife Yogeeta Bali left him for Mithun & 4th marriage was successful till the legend's death.. It takes guts to marry a dying female.. Kishore knew abt Madhubala condition and gave her love and happiness by marrying her... People require some sense of maturity to understand Kishore..

[@sankau9212]

@@prakir3590 truly said..... level of geniusness is difficult to understand easily.

[@nandkumarkhedekar2951]

It's a great say by Karan sir. It's a truth that he loved so much to Madhubala.

[@Pradeepsingh-lj9yq]

So well articulated on all the four perspectives!! Lovely..lovely insights!! First time hearing second versions of both Rafi Saab & Kishoreda!! No wonder they LoRD was WAY AHEAD HIS TIMES!!

[@vishwaschhatre7509]

Immortal RD & his great mind-blowing compositions are destined to live thousand years without loosing a bit of it's sheen & sweetness

[@shuklarajeshsrtrajesh3535]

it is a magic of great panchamda my salute to rdb and his team

[@riechkpinto4498]

Pancham all the way, Rest in Peace

[@Modijansabha168]

लाजवाब किशोर दा ❤️🙏👍

[@hanumannanayakdoraiprofess7619]

How magnificent performances, creativities these are !!! Hats up to RD RD saheb ' s genius..he is a magical musician..thanks to this video maker ..Dr.Dorai , hindustani singer..

[@rrajsekharb]

What an explanation about song versions. 👍 great. Highly professional 👌. Unnecessary people are fighting which singer is best. Both are legendary singers.

[@praveenpande4786]

Many thanks for the video............the genius of the great RD was never really appreciated fully...........even now after he has gone we are still uncovering the complexity and genius of his music sense.

[@arnubsEars]

The Rarest of the Rare, rather the one and only unique diamond R D Burman

[@RD-wl7sb]

Too good. Have learnt so much from this analysis. Thanks.

[@stanleeraja1670]

All 4 Versions are Excellent !!!!!! Heard the Kishoreda Sad version for the first time, loved it.

[@ranamitra9261]

What a voice !!!!!!! It is an eternal fact that the ALMIGHTY has showered all HIS Blessings to the voices of such miracle singers - it is a fact that there will not be any such voices in the next 100 years.

[@rlballi7525]

King always a king 💖 Pancham Da🙏🙏🙏

[@sobhanmukherjee3177]

Pancham Da Great Creator Pancham Da You Are A Genius Forever,Myself Thanks To God That I Personally Meet You And Oversrved Your Cratuion. At Film Centre Studio Mumbai, I Belive In And I Had Seen My God My Own Eyes, I Also Feel Very Proud When I Touch His Feet.

[@madanvaid2477]

Really,great,the best, Kishore da's version is just out of world.

[@AzadBhagatSingh]

Superb analysis thank you Sir 🙏❤👏👏👏💯

[@devendragawande8335]

Fantastic analysis .... Always great Our R. D. Burman sahab

[@yogeshsangle9105]

सर बहुत ही सुंदर जानकारी दी है आपने इसलिए धन्यवाद। आदरणीय पंचमदा, किशोर कुमार जी और रफी साहब दर्शक श्रोताओं के लिए अनमोल रतन रहे है। हम सभी को इन्होंने इतना सब कुछ दिया है कि पूरी जिंदगीभर हम इनकी कला का आनंद ले सकते है। इन महान हस्तीओं के चरण में कोटी कोटी प्रणाम!

[@RajKumar-wy7bv]

Exciting to watch style of your presentation. Rd is always be greatest music director.

[@chandrashekharmohan2284]

Words cannot Express the joy in listening to the technical details, and the songs...RIP pancham da

[@shakirhussain5060]

Aap ko hindi nahi aati

[@premsethi1601]

Tum bin Jaun kahan karaok

[@sundersharma4857]

Ye baat wo Tripura wale keJaan neka jaroori hai

[@sam10036]

Boss is Boss, only Panchmda we can call him music composer otherwise rest are music directors

[@jayaprakashbalan2510]

Certain songs even when sung by all the great legends, one particular version turns out to be the best. For this song, Rafi version is the best.

[@ghalibmahmudlaskar5980]

Coincidentally Legendary Kishore Kumar and Bharat Bhusan acted together in film Ladhki released in 1953 when both of them were very much in their prime.This film became a huge commercial success at the box office 🙏

[@ashokbrahmbhatt518]

Great Panchamda, Kishorda and Rafi sab, salute to all.

[@deepakashtekar7394]

RD could create magic because he was the son of the great legendary music composer Sachindev Burman . RD was the real gem in the music industry . He made possible the comeback of Kishore da . Sir your presentation is also pleasing .... your voice so soothing and your knowledge of musical instruments is noteworthy . You look to be a decent singer also . We liked this very much . Kindly continue research like this for people like us who value simplicity and talent . Thanks

[@shankarekambaram7561]

Great composing by RD Burman for a single song on different occassions in the same film. Probably, this was possible only because of musical talent surpassing the present technology.

[@shakirhussain5060]

To naushad shahab kya hai jo western music chori nahi ki

[@nitinkumarmahajan5035]

Nice information leads to fall more in Love with RD😊😊😊🤗🤗🤗🙏

[@manojchaudhry2399]

Kishorda' is Don Bradman of Indian film industry No body can challenge him in field of Popularity

[@shettyshetty1412]

ITNA BADA HONOUR MATH DENA SINGER CLIK HONEY MEY MUSIC DIRECTORS KA BAHUTH BAHUTH BADA HATH HOTHA HEY . BRADMAN KO HOI GURU NAHI THA WO APNI TALENTS SEY KAMYAB HOGAYA

[@PawanKumar-kf1gn]

Never Before Never after 🎺 PaNcHaM da for ever

[@santc2678]

Kabhi kabhi ye lagta hai ki 'R D' Burman ye koi 'time traveller' thae, jo kisi bhavishya yug se apne yaha aye thae.Aj bhi har dhun aur gana 'evergreen ' hai,kitno ki toh 'career'ban gayi inke karan.R D ji ko.🙏👍 Shashi Kapoor was truly 'romance' embodied.

[@LoansenseLoans]

Waah . Never heard the 4th version. Thanks

[@MAU9820.]

No one is like YOU SIR HON R D BURMAN SIR.😇🙏💐🌼🌻🌺🥀🌹🏵🌷

[@nayanguha699]

Great RD. We really love him. No word for him just He is God of Music.

[@babooch100]

You must listen music internationally then you will be able understand how many tracks this man burman had stolen.utter copy cat

[@nayanguha699]

@@babooch100 Not copied. Those were inspired and this type of inspired art is found in literature, music, art and in many other fields.

[@babooch100]

Shame on you to call it is inspired.... A modern word hide the fact.each and every song of him is from western music and call it inspired?

[@nayanguha699]

@@babooch100 Feeling very sad for you as you are not so enriched to converse.

[@babooch100]

I feel pitty.doesn't know the meaning of copying and inspiring.I salute to Indian musicians work that doesn't had any inspiration and mix from western world

[@anilpurohit3855]

Ever best kishore da u r great, really melodious sound, song,

[@anjanabanerjee1452]

Hattsoffto. Lyricist. Hattsof. To. Md Rafi. Hatsoffto kisorekumar Hatsoffto. Filmdirecter. Artists. And. Hatsofto. Masterpiece. Rahul devBurman......

[@vipintyagi9281]

There won't be another Pancham now ! Treasure these memories 💖

[@ART_INDIA]

❤️❤️❤️ RD Sir.....🙏🙏🙏

[@kamalmafhoum8775]

عملاق الموسيقى والاغاني الساحرة بامتياز Rahul dev Burman

[@bimalkrishna6155]

Pancham Da was crafty and highly intelligent person, the narrator has befittingly explained this song... Original version of this song is Bengali by Kishor Da " Ek din paakhi ude jaabe je aakaashe, phirbena se tau aar kaaro akaashe" that's much better than these versions except Rafi Saheb who sung it in different way, that's very nice indeed...

[@konakanchivenkatasubrahman4417]

Very interesting and thought provoking! However Kishore Kumar's rendering is very captivating. Very rich voice!

[@no_one_160]

Thank you Sir for bringing out the nuances for laymen like me... as for the great RD - words can't express the admiration..

[@sanjeevmenon650]

Geniuses ka team work 🎻🎹🎷🎸🎺🎤🎧📻😷.fan RD g

[@kamaltiwari4996]

Excellent analysis...I was always mesmerised by the arrangement of the song on different occasions; though all the versions are exceptional, the version on the piano stir your emotions beyond explanation...True a great work of the Genius and his musicians...

[@hearttoheartgautamsmusic1206]

Beautifully analysis yes yes yes. Lucky to comment thank you God. After death I wish to born as RD

[@nandkumarkhedekar2951]

Well explained the romantic, force, sadness and softness in first Bharat Bhushan's song in one version. RD sir is a gem of music world. I am his not only fan but great lover of his music. RD sir is great composer.

[@prakashkandwal9810]

RD Burman Sahab ne Kishor Kumar Sahab aur Rafi sahab se itna Sundar kam karvaya Jo itihaas mein Amar Ho Gaya ❤️♥️🌹🌹🙏🙏👌👌👌

[@RAJENDRA160660]

Really it is the Greatness of RD, Rafisahab and Kishor da....👍🙏

[@prikshitasstprofessorg.cti8973]

Some how came across this beautiful and informative channel.... Only thing that made me sad is that useless and shit channels have million subscribers and here this gem of channel has only 4K subscribers... Most people have no understanding of the things called " Classic"...

[@kittosing6639]

Thanks very much for sharing the song with all 4 versions and superb visualization of great music master's , great singers ....one composition can have so many aspects ...only a work of GENIUS ....

[@pradiptasengupta]

just enthralled and have no words to appreciate well explained. He was a genius and will remain one, no one can beat.

[@labeeb241]

Great use of Pancham with the tune and using two legends in these well explained four versions. Thanks for putting up. Last version of Rafi was is unmatchable.

[@PrashantBhaskarBhosle]

After long time ... but worth waiting ... AMAZING !!!!!!

[@bombaytalkies6836]

Wah! Kya kamal hai music agreement ka! Pancham ek sagar hai, aur unka ek ek geet ek qutra ya boond- lekin is boond ko samjhane ki samajh har kisi mei nahi- thanks for ur expectation🙏

[@ChanduKale]

BB is tapping the mandolin as if it were a keyboard.

[@dheerkumarkothari1681]

Incredible Pancham. Brilliant insights into the thought processes of a composer

[@tuhinsubhraraut3852]

Sad version of Kishore Da is the best among others ...

[@prakashkandwal9810]

Real music director on the one Pancham da ♥️♥️🌹🌹🌹🌹👌👌👌

[@pialidasgupta]

Amazing song and absolutely fabulous compositions by my favourite RD and team 👍👏🙏🙏❤️

[@abhishekchatterjee6162]

There can't be a greater singer than Kishore

[@MB-tx6di]

Dear Maddy, a truthful and amazing analysis of great Panchamda. I bless you that you go ahead with more analysis of Panchamda's creation because the entire world is yet to realise what a composer He was! Thank you. 🙏

[@haroonphd]

Wowwwwwww 👌💕 Great legends 👍 Great job by you 😊

[@ranju56]

Authentic amazing analysis . Your videos are not only informative but also enlightening . Panchamda was always a conceptualiser and visualiser as a composer and he and his ever competent team created the magic that still enthralls

[@sunildeshmukh2053]

A genius is born once in lifetime

[@anjanabanerjee1452]

Thankyou. Vai jo. Upne. Itna. Pyarse. Sare. Sundarta. Dikhaye. Is. Ganekovi. RD Burmanke. Capability pe. Kisi. Ko koivi. Pride. Hona. Hotahae. Or upsabke. Sraddha. Jo. Unko. Ajj vi. Ak. Super. Artist. Singer. Musician. Or. Person. Mae to unbap. Betako. Vagaban. Mante. Hae .Thank you. So. Much. Yugyug. Unkanam. Rosan. Rahe

[@sanjaydhamdhere3708]

Nicely explained god bless you 🙏🙏

[@lakshmivishwanath3400]

❤❤❤nothing can be beat music world........ Kishore ji, pancham da... We always remember you through your music 🙏🙏we never miss you. We are lucky 🥰🙇‍♀️

[@swarupchatterjee5284]

It's really amazing tune of r.d.b

[@josephraviraj1304]

Excellent, awesome Fantastic superb 👏👏👏👏👏👍👍👍👍🙏🙏🙏🙏

[@bharatbhaipatel8102]

Pancham da kishore kumar 👌👌👌👌👌

[@scvermautube]

आपका नाम तो नही जानता लेकिन क्या research की है आपने। Hats off to you first of all. Actually it is a research paper submitted in form of video on you tube. बारीकियों का क्या जबरदस्त observation है आपका। Just incredible....... अब वो पंचम कहाँ, वो किशोर और वो रफी कहाँ। हम इन सब को मिस तो करते हैं लेकिन ये सब जो संगीत के रूप में अपनी धरोहर छोड़ गये हैं, वो हमारे लिए gems of life हैं। मुझे इस बात से कोई दुख नही कि अब वैसा music नही बनता है, मुझे इसमें ही बहुत संतोष है कि जो ये लोग हमारे लिए छोड़ गए हैं that is enough for our life time listening..........

[@PanchaMtantraDecodingRDBurman]

My name is Madhav. Friends call me Maddy. Thanks for the comment.

[@rajeevjosh]

Had heard that the last arrangement was done by Pyarelal of LP…not sure if this was the time when RD-Pyarelal pairing was developing before SD Intervened against RD pairing with anyone. Not sure about the real truth but if you hear the last arrangement again there is some substance to this argument as you can clearly hear Pyarelal style of orchestration and not really from the RD school of thought ( though he didn’t have boundaries). 2 cents…

[@kmskunduyt]

You missed the bengali virsion sung by Kishore Kumar ek din pakhi ure jabe

[@rathijitdey]

What a powerhouse of Talent. MOZART of Bollywood, Prince of music RD Burman is like Haley's comet that comes once in 1000 years. Our beloved Pancham da was 1000 years ahead of his time. He is an institution of music and creative art. My favorite musician since my childhood. He rightly deserves Bharat Ratna posthumously. 🙏🙏🙏

[@nprakashan5686]

Hats off to you sir... आज पेहली बार हमने आप के जरिये इस गाने के चार अलग अलग मूड को सुना है l मुव्ही न देखने की वजह से हम जैसे श्रोताओ ने इस गीत को रफी साहब और किशोर दा के आवाज में दो मूड के ही गाने सुने थे l आपने इस एकही गीत के इन चारों मूड के गानों का सुंदर विश्लेषण करके हमारे ज्ञान में वृद्धी की है l 👌🌹🙏🏻🌺👍

[@bhilaibabu]

Wah Maddy - kya baat There’s a Bengali version too, by Kishore - Ek din paakhi ude jaabe je akashe / Firibe na se to aar karo aakashe. It’s softer, has yodelling, and lyrics - typical Bengali philosophical pathos. The harder notes of yodelling are modulated to suit softer under current of the song. But who am I to underline the beauty, but an admirer at 78? Would love to hear from you about the fifth version. One day.

[@imranMalik-lc5mr]

VERY GOOD....EXCELLENT PRESENTATION 😊👍

[@rocketshoot3027]

Rafis version is just superb without discrediting kishores. It is not just musical arrangements. Rafi is the only singer who can bring dramatic modifications to any song without changing the tone and the tune. Normally, a sad version of any song is sung by reducing the speed. That did not happen here. No wonder RD has himself admitted, Rafi is the epitome of singing. Rafi rightfully is called wonder boy of india. RD hardly had played any role in grooming Rafi. That was left to Naushad, SD, SG, OP, RAVI, ROSHAN and many others. Later LP joined. Rafi is surrounded by no less than 50 top notch composers. It had to be. For 25 years, a male chauvinistic society need Rafi more than any other singer. Asha or sadhna or Saira or madhubala never sat with Lata or Asha. It was Rafi that brought Shammi, Rajendra, Dev, Joy etc....... into recording rooms. Rafi was like Dulha surrounded by hope. As if bailing out chocolate heroes for quarter century. He was the hope of musicians.

[@mukimoo]

Excellent description of the different arrangements.. exceptional work by exceptional people

[@bhaskarchatterjee2647]

Thank you Mr.Realise the innate difference and an unknown angle of the background effect of the music From Balurghat, West Bengal.