Patriotism, History Books And Pakistan’s Identity Crisis | TCM Explains

Culture or religion; what is more important for a country to identify themselves? Is ethnic diversity a problem for the state? Have we taught the wrong history in our school books? TCM sat down with artist Adeel Afzal to find answers to why Pakistan is going through an identity crisis and why leaving is a good option.
To Watch the Full Episode of Talha Ahad Podcast: • Cultural Fusion in Pak...
TCM’s five-year journey has been about telling stories that people want to hear which mainstream media has been neglecting for decades. We want to disrupt the status quo by delivering engaging content which empowers impassioned voices and impacts social change. We are defined by integrity, grit and ingenuity and this is what makes us do what we do.
Support independent journalism in Pakistan and get exclusive access to the full-length version of our videos: / thecentrummedia
-------------------
Subscribe to TCM Original: bit.ly/2A3pOXz
Subscribe to TCM: bit.ly/2Tu6AkW
-------------------
Follow us on
Facebook: / tcmoriginalsofficial
Facebook: / thecentrummedia
Facebook: / centrumenter. .
Tiktok: / tcmoriginals
Twitter: / thecentrummedia
Instagram: / thecentrummedia
-------------------
Join our Facebook community: bit.ly/35oeLVs
-------------------
Website: thecentrummedia...
-------------------
About The Centrum Media
The Centrum Media (TCM) has the credit of Pakistan’s first digital news operation specializing in visual storytelling. Being a premier online platform, TCM strives to enhance the online experience of the new generation, ranging from hard news to feature stories. TCM creates original content and curates simultaneously from multiple sources.
We will take you where the real stories happen but often go untold and unseen in the shortest possible time having more information. Unlike the traditional media, TCM aims at sharing diverse stories across multi-platforms aimed at the people who consume news through mobile and social stream. We take up the challenge in the digital arena to present the news in the most imaginative and innovative ways.
Your on-the-go lifestyle forces us to bring the news directly to your pocket devices.
#tcmnews #adeelafzal #pakistan

[@vivektripathi9515]

i would like to correct you guys that our patriotism is not based on hatred against pakistan it is only based on love for the motherland

[@fareehakhalid295]

Absolutely not Dono taraf hate hai

[@Hiraeth1992]

@@fareehakhalid295 Difference hai, in India the hatred began after 26/11 in the backdrop of previous wars, while in Pakistan hate has been there since its inception

[@PriyankaSingh-ok3xn]

​@@fareehakhalid295 Pakistan is just 75 years old ..... We are one of the oldest civilization of the world ..... Our existence is not based on Pakistan hatred ..... Instead Pakistan is nuisance for India ..... We tolerated so many wars and terrorist attacks .... Jao thoda padho Indus-saraswati valley civilization ke baare mein

[@Vinay_Acharya]

Rightly said. 👍 Totally disagree with the guy saying if u remove Pak, there is no essence in Patriotism for Indians. We existed even before Islam was invented, let alone the nascent child called Pakistan. We have always been patriotic inspite of being poly theist and multiple customs. These Pakistanis do not have that level of imagination. So for them, whatever they dont know.... Doesn't exist at all.

[@guruharinder5678]

I dont know why in Pakistan people feel that the same amount of importance is given to pakistan, that is given by pakistan to india ! No body cares enough to hate !

[@yasinbutt6064]

I am from Pakistan.During the education of sixteenth years.I have thought that the amount of money our state has spent on keeping people uneducated and ignorant has not been spent on anything else

[@SyedaSamanGulzar]

Don't give sweeping statements. Better explain it in specific words.

[@sourabhsingh3530]

@@SyedaSamanGulzar ​ ​ Brother, even before the birth of your monotheist man, Hindus used to live here in India, for which there are so many scientific evidences are available today and you cannot change the fact that your forefathers were also Hindus by taking the name of Zoroastrianism or any other religion. They were forced to wear salwar due to the fear of sword and they converted to Islam. Later muslim Invadars thought of ending Sanatan history by breaking Nalanda University (which was established in 450AD)they also set fire to thousands of years old scriptures installed there,but sadly in Pakistani history books the same robbers ,rapists and murderer Invadars were presented as heroes and only hatred was spread about Hindu religion🙏🙏

[@SyedaSamanGulzar]

@@sourabhsingh3530 Zoroastrianism the oldest religion of the world not that disgusting caste based filthy religious ideology. Hinduism was creation of Aryas who converted you people and made you people shudras and outcast. There's nothing wrong in being converted. Everyone's forefathers are converted from something. People of subcontinent converted because of the inhumane caste system and baseless shallow religious philosophy of so called Hinduism.

[@SyedaSamanGulzar]

@@sourabhsingh3530 moreover every Pakistani Muslims and other Muslims are more than happy with their Muslim identity. We welcome all others who are still coming to light and converting.

[@svgodan]

​@@sourabhsingh3530 yasin butt - bhai ye to kashmiri pandit he ... Sirname butt laga rakha h abhee bhee convert hone k babjud bhee . Butts were aayurvedic vaidya in kashmir . En logon k dimaag me hindus k liye bachapan se hi hate bharee jati h ..

[@zunairdar6996]

I’m a 32 year old man. I played this video on KZbin on a common TV in lounge and my father started abusing me. 😂 But everything said in this video is based on facts. My Pakistani fellows are far away from facts. We don’t live in reality, we live in ideological fantasy.

[@dinozaurpickupline4221]

that's because they live in pakistan & mostly abroad are well settled living quality lives,only place the true pakistani knows is the common laborer that is working on saudia roads,uae construction or in west,he knows the true value of the curse that is pakistan there is nothing pak about it

[@Mstfshaloo]

Economical independence hasil ke hoti toh apko koi aisay zaleel nahi karta

[@nadeem2764]

Idealogy only serves our inflamed egos

[@faseehmirza23]

What have you done to get this nation out of those fantasies?

[@DWAGON1818]

What facts? Can you please prove that Mehmood Ghaznavi destroyed the mandir?

[@aeymed]

One thing Adeel said about, the representation of Hindus in our books. I totally agree to that. I've so many Hindus n Christians in my class and trust me I feel much embarrassment when such topics were taught in school. Then we say we're tolerate towards our minorities. Lol weren't 💔

[@parthsarthi9806]

That is tolerance that some hindus, sikhs, christians have survived.

[@aeymed]

@@parthsarthi9806 Yes n same goes for the Muslims n Christians in India. Yesterday I saw a video where Hindus were assaulting a Muslim guy and were forcing him to pray to a Cow.

[@indipacifician3693]

Pakistani idea of tolerance is not killing some of the minorities. Pakistanis think they are tolerant when they dont chop heads off

[@travellingaxis2741]

What are u being taught??? Quote specific example.... Avoid sweeping statement

[@Edward4Plantagenet]

You felt bad by reading it means you are Human, not Muslim. Goodluck.

[@SirKasim666]

5:55 You are correct, in India, we don't have Dual Citizenship. Only thing for Indian born foreign citizens is, OIC cards, which allows holders to come to India without a visa and live indefinitely if they wish, only thing they can't Vote or Buy Agricultural land. 😊

[@bankingmadeeasy363]

OCI Cards bro.... Overseas Citizen of India....it was PIO first then they were merged.

[@SirKasim666]

@@bankingmadeeasy363 Thanks Bro. I knew I was getting the damned abbreviations ass ways & when writing couldn't double check. 😆🤣😂

[@DoooBeeDoooBeeDooo]

I'm 40 , tried to talk about the country's 'halaat' to a 26 year old, He stopped me midway saying "please stop , all that has nothing to do with me cuz its not my mess, why should I bother?"

[@razaali4254]

KEEPING THE ELITE ASIDE, at this age we middle class or lower middle class youngsters are very much concerned now a days. The inflation has broken our back, your era was much easier to accumulate wealth and buy property meanwhile we are working our asses off to keep up the expenses with multiple jobs and still that is not enough. It has become a dream for us to build our house, "NANGA NAHAYE KIA NICHORE KIA"

[@DoooBeeDoooBeeDooo]

@@razaali4254 dude what wealth?! your victim rant aside, fyi it's never been easy. my gen scraped n paid their dues for 2 decades n counting!! the 40% devaluation aside, tax hikes have devastated the private sector. I can pass on the buck to the previous gen as easily n so on. 120K+ ppl just left pak inside the last 3 months making the number close to a mil. comparative suffering gets u nothing , this country's always been for the 1%. only difference is that for the first time the upper mid class is taking the hit.

[@DoooBeeDoooBeeDooo]

@Student of Klaus Schwab sir we are a nation raised on lies. state approved govt books showcasing men who never were our leaders but puppets. the state has never allowed anyone directly from the people to rise. and for those who think Imran Khan is any better or different is a fool. Your hero is highly against the 18th amendment, he wants an even stronger punjab n other provinces even more weaker. he gave land owners total tax exemption , gave fuel subsidies that triggered the inflation hike. please think critically and don't cling to savior thinking.

[@AlphaZuluKilo]

​@@DoooBeeDoooBeeDooodude first let's do the maths correct, how on earth is 120k equivalent to 1 million

[@DoooBeeDoooBeeDooo]

@@AlphaZuluKilo the total number's close a million since mid 2022. the 120k is just the last qaurter.

[@itschintoodear9802]

No bhai we sindhis are not confused with our identity we very well know our history but it's been tried to vanish our history from the birth of pakistan. We believe Hemoo and hosho are our heroes in spite of their religion. Therefore we are taught about Hemoo and hosho from childhood.

[@kashutosh9132]

Who are hemoo and hosho Can you Elaborate more

[@itschintoodear9802]

@@kashutosh9132 hoshoo was a slave to mir's of hyderabad in sindh he fought against british army and hemoo was a middle class hindu resident of sukkur.

[@jaibholenath6900]

But isn't Mir Qasim your hero and Raja Dahir villain?

[@itschintoodear9802]

@@jaibholenath6900 no we sindhis don't accept qasim as a hero . qasim was a invader and he looted sindh's wealth. Raja dahir was and will be our hero because he fought for us in spite of his religion.

[@rishuasthana1086]

​@@jaibholenath6900 Dude religion and culture are different thing.

[@tahaumer6930]

Being a part of gen z Pakistani it is very confusing for us to understand everything. But I do think Pakistani people have now started questioning and challenging everything. They are not getting brainwashed anymore. We also need raw and authentic conversations like this to help us figure out the loopholes.

[@RAMTA_SLAYER]

Gen Z and that too Pakistani?😮 Too fatal.😆

[@SyedaSamanGulzar]

And funny thing is that gen Z in India has also changed. They are walking bombs. Full of hatred against Pakistan and Indian Muslims. India is the only country in the world that choooses a terrorist as their primary minister. Such a filthy people.

[@Sobanhassan1761]

No need to be confused brother. Humans are a product of their outlook on life. Those who are vocal about Pakistan's supposed 'identity crisis' like these these two guys in the video mostly have secular post Westphalian worldview which is based upon ethno-geographical considerations. To the contrary, most Pakistanis primarily associate with their religious identity and therefore this identity thing is a non issue for them. Now I personally think that there is no such 'crisis' and I can go to details of my reasoning if you are still confused.

[@saidalavim9988]

I am a indian. Itna acha aur sacha interview me isse pehle kabhi nahi suni. Aap ko meri lakh lakh Salute sir.

[@muhammadhussain5854]

​@Student of Klaus Schwab 23:13 why does this men on video has problems with becoming extra muslim. Our ancestors had embraced islam and truth and islam is part of our culture and values

[@munishbhardwaj1884]

Bhai, sacha to ek hee hai, doosra to typical jehadi hai.

[@munishbhardwaj1884]

​@@muhammadhussain5854 tera forefather bhee Ram Lal hee hoga.

[@munishbhardwaj1884]

@@muhammadhussain5854 apne baap ke baap ka to khyaal rakh. Tu bhee sanatani kee aulaad hai chutiye

[@Hexed_Precinct]

accha bey.....

[@ManusRex]

Some bitter truths /hard to swallow liquids: 1) Hindus are not obsessed with Muslims/Pakistanis. We dont get up everyday and say -"we have to be better than or compete with Muslims/Pakistanis and one up them today".Trust me, if a Hindu thought like that he would be mocked endlessly by other Hindus. You dont get better by scraping the bottom of the barrel. We are busy competing for jobs & business at a global level so we have to be that good, or miss out, simple. Our concerns with Muslims/Pakistanis are related to our security given the past and contemporary history. 2) Problem is Islam, there is no way of sugarcoating it. Islam is the extreme Machiavellian way of life not suited for individuals who want to live like humans and not rabid hatred filled animals. Even if the last Muslims were on an island they will butcher themselves because a Sunni barelvi cannot live witth Deobandis and vice-versa, unless they are butchering Hindus, Shias, and Ahemadiyas together. A recent example is how a dreaded gangster named Atique Ahmed in the Indian state of UP, who terrorised and killed Hindus at will for decades, was mourned and called a Ghazi by Muslims , after he and his gang was finally shot dead by Police, simply because he was a practising Muslim, who according to Quran is better than the best of 'Kafirs' because every crime will be forgiven except Shirq, and Islam declares Shirqers to be the worst of creatures. He stole from common Hindus, raped Hindu women, robbed and seized properties of Hindu businessmen, killed Hindu politicians who dared to fight elections against him and his brother, and donated to madrassas with the money he robbed. This is enough for Indian Muslims to celebrate him and start rioting against Hindus because they are relieved his reign of Terror is finally over. What kind of civilized humans would behave like Muslims do ? 3) Most Hindus are not practising Hindus anyway. They are so deracinated, they can be least bothered about religious affairs. Their concern is prosperity, education of their children, job security, and well being of their family. The last of which is majorly threatened by Muslims both inside India and on the borders. Hindus are simply tired of decades of Muslim identitarian politics of appeasement because Muslims are treated as a votebank who vote for a party/candidate en block, based on religious considerations. While Hindus never voted in a united way. Until 2014. And even in 2014, the Hindu vote was still largely fractured. Still the entire narrative of 'Hindutva extremism' propaganda was created, because Hindus for the first time even if a small percentage, voted together for the same cause. Muslims have been doing that since the idea of Pakistan was first created. 4) Muslims in India have the street veto, ie Veto of Violence. Case in point large scale rioting and violence against CAA, NRC, and farm/agriculture reforms. 99/100 Hindus wont even be bothered if Muslims exist or not, if their security& safety of their families, was not threatened by Muslims who run rampage and riot even for events happening outside India. For eg issues like Rohingyas, Palestine etc. The propaganda that they feed Pakistani audiences that Muslims are persecuted in India is hilarious. Reality is completely opposite. For every single case of Hindu on Muslim violence there would be several dozen cases of Muslim on Hindu violence. You merely have to scratch the surface to unearth the truth. India media ecosystems is to be blamed too, because they are Congress loyalists more or less and help keep the Muslims perpetually victimized so that they can vote en-block, therefore such cases seldom make it to national news. Search for provisions of Waqf Act, and RTE act, to know how much power Muslims hold over Hindus - all through laws enacted by Congress over decades. Here is a primer: kzbin.info/www/bejne/i5eWe6yHprSCpJI&ab_channel=TheJaipurDialogues 5) There is a famous long enduring myth about how Muslims stayed back in India because they rejected the 'Do Quami Nazariya'/Two-nation-Theory. Reality cannot be further from the truth. Fact is, read or listen to Sharjeel Imam's speech during anti CAA riots. He openly and boldly accepted that Muslims who stayed back in India made the sacrifice for Islam, to see India finally made Dar ul Islam one day. He was merely quoting what Maulana Maudoodi wrote in his 'famous' speech/discourse 'Jihad-fi-sabiullah'. This is the truth of Muslims of the subcontinent, like it or not.

[@Sanjay_Singh_Bisht]

You are spitting facts which porkis can't read or understand.

[@madeehafarooq5216]

Please critisize the people the culture not the religion . And if you have learned about islam from aajtak than you have to correct the source and if you are trying to take things out of context please refrain from it . And a question why is islam always the villain why . If a extremist did something wrong it not all 500 million muslims ...

[@Sanjay_Singh_Bisht]

@@madeehafarooq5216 Islam is the key, that's why Bangladeshi and Pakistani muslim Hate India. Nepal, Myanmar and Sri Lanka didn't hate Hindus. It's corrupt religion Islam.

[@ManusRex]

@@madeehafarooq5216 I already said it's gonna be bitter.

[@arifnoor100]

😆 You don't even know the ABC of Islam ۔۔۔۔۔۔

[@krishnadwivedi3880]

i am an indian & its even more relevent for us hope we never repeat similiar mistakes as pakistan did.

[@shazainbaloch2538]

You already creats mess in India

[@sitarampradhan8488]

Ye kasmir ko Pakistan me dikha rahe hai. Khud propaganda kar rahe hai

[@sharadskywalker]

u r falsely assuming that Hindu values r the same as Islamic values. Hinduism is polytheistic and a Hindu by nature is all-accepting of other faiths. That's not the case with Muslims who divide humanity between believers and kaafirs. Ur Hindu background allows u to be an atheist and gives u the freedom to bash Hindus themselves. That's not the case with Muslims.

[@Sanjay_Singh_Bisht]

comparing a Barbaric cult with Sanatani values is dumb take. India with Hindus can never become Porkistan.

[@sahilsingh6048]

​@@sitarampradhan8488 gawar jab tu pakistani channel pe akar dekhe ga to tujhe wahi ke chize melingi na

[@TheMohak7]

Wow what an Interview. As an Indian this is one of the first times that I’ve seen a Pakistani speak on the indigenous cultural impact of Hindus in the region.

[@mithunkartha]

Yes. India does not allow dual nationality.

[@ISHITA_PRATEEK]

Yes true , no dual nationality in India.

[@muhammadmahd6429]

That's why 1-3 million people drop their nationality every year

[@DoobyChef]

Toh tujha kya hai ? It's their choice

[@DoobyChef]

​@@muhammadmahd6429 what about Pakistan?? How they are doing aata hai ?😂

[@mithunkartha]

@@muhammadmahd6429 That doesn't matter people always move for better opportunities within and between countries. We do not have an American PR wala NSA or Generals who are busy getting dual citizenship for kids in Canada.

[@BoomShiva55]

Somebody finally speaks the truth...lots of respect and love from India 🇮🇳

[@commentor9002]

Bro you should visit Haridwar. Guaranteed you’ll find written transcripts of your ancestors with possibly their signatures. You can contact the local pundits who are maintaining books from centuries. Trust me you’ll be surprised and in a good way

[@gmail7894]

If you do, I'd be happy to host you or at least hang out with you or help out in whatever I can as I live sometimes close by

[@essee3984]

Possible only if you know your surname, gotra and ancestral village.

[@commentor9002]

@@essee3984 you’ll be surprised

[@essee3984]

@@commentor9002 my uncle is a Panda in Haridwar :)

[@commentor9002]

@@essee3984 I was talking about the other side. Pakistanis having some semblance of their ancestry, especially the Sindhis

[@SalmanKhan-rz3mc]

India s Pakistan Nikal do to Indians k paas phr p aik historical civilization he to be patriotic about. This statement would be more true for Pakistan k if Hindu hatred aur Indian enmity hata do to aadhe s zyada Pakistanio ko pata b nhn k wo hai kya. Bcz they think they are not native to subcontinent but Arabs.

[@vinsin328]

That is called identity crisis.

[@SalmanKhan-rz3mc]

No we don't have identity crisis. It has been artificially created bcz the state doesn't want to acknowledge the national identities and languages. Those of us living in this region without denying our national identity don't have a problem of national crisis. It's for those people who want to change Pakistan to Al-bakistan

[@subashdalai8893]

Pakistani Kabhi sudhar nehi sakte

[@shaheer_04]

Bro I always see people saying this bullshit. WHO ARE THE PAKISTANIS WHO CLAIM TO BE ARABS BRO?? LIKE LITERALLY WHERE? Majority of Pakistanis are proud of their Punjabi/Pashtun/Sindhi/Balochi heritage. Literally all these ethnicities take alot of pride in their identity and here you are saying Pakistanis think they are Arabs regurgitating RW Indian talking points?

[@AbdullahKhawar262]

We ain't arabs turks or modern day indians ... just cuz we lived together doesn't mean we're same. And btw indus Valley civilisation was originated in modern day Pakistan so it belongs to us not u guys

[@newguyat77]

Maharaja Ranjit Singh did not convert the Badshahi mosque into a horse stable. With the permission of the Muslim priest (Mulla or Maulana or Imam) and the Muslims, Ranjit Singh was allowed to use the outside courtyard as stable whereas the rooms (study rooms) around the outer boundary of the mosque as accommodation for his troops. The actual mosque or the interior section of the mosque where Muslims gathered to pray was never offended. Therefore, Muslims weren’t offended. The Pakistani narrative exaggerated this event, creating a distorted history. Their history relates to the reported inaccuracy of some Pakistani textbooks and the existence of historical revisionism in them. The content of Pakistan's official textbooks have often been criticized by several sources including many within Pakistan for sometimes promoting religious intolerance and Indophobia, leading to calls for curriculum reform. What they ignore is that: 1.Ranjit Singh constructed at least two other mosques in the city of Lahore. 2. Ranjit Singh handed over Sunehri Masjid, back to the Muslims, after it had been converted into a gurdwara prior to his rule. 3. Ranjit Singh built Mai Moran Masjid, named after his Muslim wife, where the mosque still continues to operate under the same name. 4. Ranjit Singh built impressive structure situated in a vast garden, with a mosque next to it, during the lifetime of Gul Begum, his second Muslim wife, who outlived Ranjit Singh and was buried here after her death. The mosque constructed here is also functional to this present day. There is a mausoleum of Gul Begum, within the Miani Sahib graveyard, a historical graveyard in the area of Mozang. 5.According to historical records, Ranjit Singh’s youngest wife, Maharani Jind Kaur, donated her imperial collection of handwritten copies of Quran to Data Darbar, which added to the stature of the shrine in the city.

[@AlphaZuluKilo]

While the other things you stated are right, Ranjit Singh did desecrate Badshahi Mosque and there is no record of having permission. It is common sense that no Muslim or Mullah would permit an animal desecrating in a mosque, hence such claims defy common sense. Similarly, Nur Jehan's tomb marble was plundered under the Sikh rule for the Golden temple, he did spent night with Moran Sarkar in one of the minarets of Wazir Khan Mosque, etc etc. In essence, Ranjit Singh was shrewd who appropriated religious symbols you mentioned for political gains just like the Deen-e- lIlahi concept of Akbar. So let's not act like the ones which this video is trying to stop us to become. 😂 However, we Pakistanis still erected Ranjit Singh's statue in Lahore Fort.

[@impkroy]

​@@AlphaZuluKilo 😅😅😅 pakka ye Pakistani history book ko padhane wala jahil insaan hai...

[@sgerardpandian]

The final line of the interview literally gave me goosebumps. Love you bro from India. I will pray your next generation gets better with my heart..

[@yashvardhanbhatt2329]

Deshdrohi

[@Hari-th7bv]

Pakistan will be broken into pieces by the end of the decade

[@StrategyGaming1]

We dont love mushrikeen kuffar arn't our freinds.

[@user-wg9bd1kz4q]

😂😂😂 abey chootiye ho tum yeh log sirf views ke liye aisa bolte hain

[@mrweed9178]

​@@yashvardhanbhatt2329 radicals ki soch badal sakta h adeel jaise bande yr isse india ka bhi fayda hoga

[@NitinKataria-nf4sq]

The Aryasamaj temple he is talking about was very important for my ancestors and our Khatree community in the Undivided India era. My paternal grandmother used to tell me about Quetta cantt and Quetta city. My paternal grandfather was an L.A.O there. My father was born there in 1946. It was a great place till the time the WW2 was going on as per the people of South Delhi who had to leave it to avoid becoming muslim by force.

[@desiaadmi9539]

Even as an Indian from Himalyan region I feel more proud in being a Pahari than Indian, however I love my country in my heart . This is because I'm thankful to my country for letting me feel proud about my pahari culture first and love my own pahari language and follow my own pahari religion/Gods(which are different from Hindu Gods) . I'm thankfull to be part of India for letting me follow my own culture in my own way . No one stops me from following my own ethnicity that's why I proudly say I'm an Indian . Jai hind. 🇮🇳 Edit: I can say this I wouldn't have got this much freedom anywhere in Globe other than India , this is the difference between India and rest of the world. And this credit goes to MK Gandhi and Mr. Ambedkar for writing such a beautiful constitution that gives freedom . It is a human nature to die for freedom . You can enslave every animal forever but never a human. Humans will always revolt.

[@okbyebye9586]

Lol even before gandhi and ambedkar bhartiyans never forced their beliefs on other it is the beauty of sanatan dharma not our constitution. Log achhe hai isliye bother nahi karte agar bure hote to islam ki tarah kab ka maar kaat ke convert kar diya hota. Gandhi was the curse for India. Even dr ambedkar was against him specially against his decision of keeping muslims in bharat.

[@colourblack4704]

Konsay pahad say hai bhai jahan god diffrent hai hindu god say lol or pahadi saray phelay indian honay prr proud feel kartay hain firr pahadi honay pay sab say jada loog pahad say jatay hain indian army mai agar per state percentage dekhay

[@desiaadmi9539]

@@colourblack4704 I am from spiti district of himachal pradesh. We are not hindus nor Buddhists but our culture resembles Buddhism. Our land is already claimed by Chinese government as we are ethnically closer to them than to a common Indian. We are peacefully people .

[@kashutosh9132]

​@@okbyebye9586 Ambedkar was against him bcuz he was his political rival,till Gandhi was alive ambedkar can never lead lower caste in politics Gandhi was there - that ensured that Hindu votes did not split between other peeps such as ambedkar and Jan sangh Curse kis baat ka ki wo teri tarah mullo se nafrat nhi karta thaa? Phir to Bose,ras behari Bose,bhagat singh tere liye kiya huwe?

[@kashutosh9132]

​@@desiaadmi9539 Can you tell me more about your culture and religion I mean what is the name of your religious gods and cultural practice ,I find that interesting Also rather than China,you may be taking about tibet,that place above you us Tibet

[@monirodacosta6074]

Love how much weightage this podcast has, very much backed by facts , no biases and false propagandas.Kudos to your channel .

[@mental9453]

Mughal's court language is Persian. It is already proved that most of the Mughal kings did not speak local language.

[@mohdwahid5746]

Common Language of mughal india was persian only

[@-rate6326]

​@@mohdwahid5746 Mughals were vassals of Persia in start as babur was being paid by Persians to control Fergana. He was Persian puppet. Persian was totally foreign language with foreign writing system. That's colonization of language. Same was done by Brits. China doesn't use some foreign language. Common language should have similarities with most existing language in nation.

[@sushanth1689]

​@@mohdwahid5746 which madarssa taught u this avdol😂

[@mariamtee]

@@mohdwahid5746what ignorance!

[@xoundful]

Thank you for teaching the true history to the public. Hope us Pakistanis can relearn

[@shazainbaloch2538]

--------------ہندو کون تھے؟ - - - - - - - - - - آریان جنہوں نے تقریباً 2000 قبل مسیح سے 1500 قبل مسیح کے درمیان ہندوستان پر حملہ کیا، اور سنسکرت زبان اور ہندوتوا نظریہ کو برصغیر میں لاۓ، جسے آج ہندو کہتے ہیں۔ آریاؤں کے پاس بہترین فوج اور جنگی ساز و سامان تھا اور وہ ایک اندازے مطابق موجودہ ہندوستان کے شمال سے داخل ہوئے تھے ۔ اس وقت کے ہندوستان کے باشندے بہت پرامن تھے اور وہ سورج اور چاند کے پجاری تھے، وہ جنگ اور جنگی ساز و سامان سے بے خبر تھے،وہ بہت زیادہ مذہبی نہیں تھے۔ آریاؤں نے ایک بڑے لشکر کے ساتھ ان پر حملہ کیا اور ان کا قتل عام کیا،چونکہ آریائی جنگجو قوم تھے سو انہوں نے بآسانی جنگ جیت لی، عورتوں کے ساتھ زیادتیاں کی گئیں اور بچوں کو سنسکرت اور ہندو تعلیمات زبردستی سیکھنے پر مجبور کیا گیا، آریاؤں نے مقامی لوگوں کی ثقافت، مذہب اور زبان کو مکمل طور پر تباہ کر دیا، جس نے سنسکرت اور ہندو مذہب کو قبول کیا اسے زندہ چھوڑ دیا گیا اور جس نے مخالفت کی اسے زندہ جلا دیا گیا۔ راکھی گڑھی تہذیب اور سندھ کی تہذیب دونوں کو آریائی حملہ آوروں نے تباہ کر دیا تھا۔وہیلر، جو 1944 سے 1948 تک آرکیالوجیکل سروے آف انڈیا کے ڈائریکٹر جنرل تھے، موہنجو داڑو آثار قدیمہ کے بالائی سطح پر پائی جانے والی کئی بے دفن لاشیں دریافت کیں جو کہ اس بات کا ثبوت تھیں کہ وہ ایک خون ریز جنگ کا شکار ہوئیں تھیں۔نوکیلی طرز کی بکھری اشیاء جو کسی ہتھیار سے مماثلت رکھتی ہیں، ان کے ٹکڑے بھی دریافت ہوۓ. دریافت شدہ ثبوتوں نے یہ ثابت کیا کہ پرامن ہڑپہ کے لوگوں کے خلاف گھوڑوں اور زیادہ جدید ہتھیاروں کا استعمال کر کے، آریاؤں نے انہیں آسانی سے شکست دی ہو گی۔ کیونکہ ابھی تک انڈس سویلائزیشن کے لوگوں کا اپنے دفاع کیلئے استعمال ہونے والی کوئی چیز دریافت نہیں ہوئی. سو غالباً وہ کسی بڑی جنگ کیلئے تیار نہیں تھے. جب بھی حملہ آور کہیں بھی حملہ کرتے ہیں تو وہ اپنی ثقافت، مذہب اور روایات بھی ساتھ لے کر آتے ہیں۔ آریائی رگ وید، زینڈ-اویستا، اور الیاڈ اور اوڈیسی لاۓ. - - - - - - - آریائی ثقافت اور شناخت----------- برہمن شمال سے آریائی حملہ آور تھے اس لیے وہ اپنی زبان سنسکرت کو برصغیر میں لاۓ۔ آریائی اپنے ساتھ اپنی زبان، مذہبی عقائد اور سماجی نظام جو لے کر آئے اسے جبراً مقامی لوگوں پر مسلط کیا. آریاؤں نے ایک ایسا سماجی نظام تیار کیا جس کا ہندوستانی ثقافت پر دیرپا اثر پڑا۔ اس وقت کے ہندوستان میں بھی کئی زبانیں رائج تھیں جو مکمل تباہ نہیں ہوئی مگر اپنی اصل شکل میں بھی نہیں رہیں. موجودہ ہندوستان میں رائج زبانوں کا رسم الخط تو پرانا ہے مگر الفاظ سنسکرت اور مقامی زبان کی ملاوٹ ہے. -------قدیم ہندوستان کا مذہب کیا تھا؟------- ویسے تو یہ ابھی تک ایک راز ہے. مقامی لوگوں کا صحیح مذہب کیا تھا نامعلوم ہے. لیکن کچھ ماہرین کا خیال ہے کہ برصغیر کے مقامی لوگوں کا مذہب کی طرف زیادہ رجحان نہیں تھا بلکہ وہ سورج اور چاند کی پوجا کرتے تھے یا آگ کی پوجا کرتے تھے۔ وہ فلاحی ریاست بنا چکے تھے جہاں فیصلے اکثریت کی حمایت سے ہوتے تھے. وہ مختلف قبیلوں میں تھے اور ہر قبیلے کا ایک سردار ہوتا تھا. بعض آثار سے یہ تاثر ملتا ہے کہ عورتوں کو بھی سردار بنایا جاتا تھا. یعنی ایک طرح سے وہ سوشلسٹ تھے. مگر آریاؤں نے نہ صرف ان لوگوں کا ظالمانہ طریقے سے قتل عام کیا بلکہ پوری تہذیب کو تباہ برباد کر دیا۔ جنگ میں زندہ بچ جانے والوں کو زبردستی ہندو بنایا گیا، خواتین کی عصمت دری کی گئی اور انہیں غلام بنایا گیا۔ اب تک کی دہائیوں کی تحقیق سے ایسے آثار قدیمہ دریافت نہیں ہوۓ، جس سے یہ کہا جاسکے کے ہندوتوا یہاں کے باسیوں کا اصل مذہب تھا لیکن اس کے خلاف ٹھوس شواہد موجود ہیں. اس بات سے دائیں بازو کے انتہا پسند ہندو رہنما اس تحقیق کو بار بار رکوانے یا بدلنے کی کوشش کرتے رہتے ہیں. حال ہی میں رکھی گڑھی سے ملنے والے انسانی ڈھانچے کے دی این اے ٹیسٹ نے ہندو انتہا پسندوں کو مذید مشتعل کردیا کیونکہ اس کا ڈی این اے موجودہ ہندوستانی ڈی این اے سے میچ نہیں ہوا. اس پر خود ہندوستان کے انڈیا نیوز کا مندرجہ ذیل آرٹیکل موجود ہے. یہ 2018 میں شائع کیا گیا. ⬇️⬇️⬇️⬇️⬇️⬇️⬇️⬇️⬇️⬇️⬇️ راکھی گڑھی سے 4500 سال پرانا ڈی این اے ایسے شواہد ظاہر کرتا ہے جو ہندو قوم پرستوں کو پریشان کر دے گا. www.indiatoday.in/magazine/cover-story/story/20180910-rakhigarhi-dna-study-findings-indus-valley-civilisation-1327247-2018-08-31 ______________--------------______________ جھوٹ اور غلط معلومات کچھ ہندو مورخین نے یہ ثابت کرنے کی کوشش کی کہ آریائی ایران سے ہندوستان پر حملہ آور ہوئے جبکہ آریائیوں نے درحقیقت موجودہ ہندوستان کے شمال سے حملہ کیا۔ ہو سکتا ہے کہ آریان نے موجودہ ایران پر بھی حملہ کیا ہو، لیکن اس نظریہ کا کوئی ٹھوس ثبوت نہیں ہے۔ وہ تمام تر شواہد جو ہندو خود انڈس، راکھی گڑھی سے منسوب کر رہے ہیں جعلی اور بے بنیاد ہیں. مندرجہ بالا تحقیق اور شواہد سے یہ بات ثابت ہوتی ہے کہ ہندتوا برصغیر کا مقامی مذہب نہیں، دیگر مذاہب کی طرح یہ بھی یہاں آکر پھیلایا گیا نہ کہ بنایا گیا. ہندوؤں کے 9 ہزار سالہ کی کوئی تاریخ نہیں ہے، وہ اکثر مسلمانوں کو Converted کہتے ہیں جبکہ وہ خود Converted ہیں.

[@DWAGON1818]

How do you know it's the true history? Can you please point towards where you got the facts? Or maybe it's the history that you want to hear.

[@xoundful]

Because he's talking about the lived experience of millions

[@DWAGON1818]

@@xoundful hes telling lies about Mehmud Ghaznavi

[@soubhagyadas7978]

​@@shazainbaloch2538 matalb kuch v ?? 😂😂 .. hindhu aur hindutva Yugo Yugo se hai ..Satya yug se ab kali yug ho gaya .aur ye bol raha hai ki 2000 saal pehle Hindu dharm ka utthan hua tha .😂😂.

[@rnw7929]

Adeel Afzal is at some another level

[@P.Babrah58]

This debate is truly a bonanza....simply Splendid....no words to praise ...at least there are some Pakistanis still possess the love for land..not only Islam. This is fact that Maharaja Ranjit Singh asked his Prime Minister Faqir Aziz-ud-din's brother foreign minister Syed Nur-ud-din to prepare a Qaeda ( booklet) titled Noor and he distributed 5000 copies of Quaida so that people can learn Gurmukhi, Shahmukhi ,Urdu,Persian and Sanskrit. When Britishers captured the Punjab ( Sikh Raj) ,the very first action they took,they confisticated all the Qaedas ( booklets) and offered Rs 2/- per Qaeda for depositing it with the administration whereas Rs 1/- per Gun was given to deposit guns. This is how Britishers alienated us from our roots. Our recorded civilization is 5000 years old, unrecorded goes up to may be 10000 years old. Maharaja Ranjit Singh was a true hero of Punjab....a secular in it's true spirit. He treated all the religions in equal manner.....he was used to say -"perhaps this is the reason that Waheguru gave him ONE eye. Remember, he was blind from one eye. Here's a link ,if you want to know more about Maharaja's educational system . www.peepultree.world/livehistoryindia/story/people/ranjit-singh-educator

[@nikhilbabar]

In parts of Rajasthan and Gujarat , Hinglaj temple hold very holy place among Charan community.

[@jaibholenath6900]

Hinglaj Mataji & Sharda Peeths are both Shakti Peeths

[@ganeshviswanathan4128]

I was in disbelief after hearing the most-matured conversation between Talha Ahad and Artist, Adeel Afzal - particularly, the clear, fearless, truthful and the indepth knowledge exhibited by Adeel Afzal. So far, I have heard countless people recently, on KZbin - mostly young who are fairly, highly educated and coming from within the Pakistan's existing (or non-existing) educational system. I also heard and hear many senior citizens who have been living abroad for a number of years now, who, too, have come out and speak with frankness and boldness. Of all, Adeel Afzal sounded absolutely genuine. I was carried away by his closing remarks and the reply he gave in response to a question whether he wants to continue to live in Pakistan. I hope, every Pakistani turn into an Adeel Afzal! Good luck to you Adeelbhai on your high level of maturity and the clear understanding and knowledge you possess. Good luck and wishing you further knowledge of the history and culture of the people living there. The people living there for thousands of years and even before, as you rightly mentioned, were and are Indians. There was nothing called Pakistan and Pakistanis (at least before 1947 when it was created artificially and unnaturally for geo-political reasons by the Western powers).

[@AbdullahKhawar262]

NO... we aren't same dude. Just cuz we lived together doesn't mean we're same this land was and is too diverse .. and I'm not saying cuz of religion but bcuz of looks and everything

[@9Rehankhan19]

Omg! All this praise for him because you people think all Pakistanis and their land is actually India lol 😂 . Then why don’t u say the same about Bangladesh?

[@asimayub7215]

what a wonderful & thought provoking discussion...... Salute to you both...... keep up the good work bro

[@ramv7314]

Nations cannot form based on religion.. else why would there be so many diff countries in the middle east..so many diff countries in Europe.. patriotism comes from the concept of motherland.. janmbhoomi and Karmbhoomi... The place where you are born and the place you do your duties..

[@jaibholenath6900]

Not that nations cannot be partitioned on basis of religion......but the partition should be clean Not like what Mo Gazi and Lehru gave us

[@balakverma2611]

I commend you for such mature discussion. I am an overseas citizen of India.

[@ShwetaGupta-hd6yk]

2:31 "Agar Pakistan na hota to kya tu patriotic hota?" YES. Hum tab bhi patriotic hote. Jab Pakistan nahin tha, hamare paas tab bhi aise log the jo matrabhumi/motherland ki baat karte the. Hamara patriotism 10000 saal ki civilization se aata hai 75 saal purane Pakistan se nahin.

[@jyatimali2033]

Correct. These converted Pakistanis wont understand

[@parthachatterjee1498]

Very well said.

[@debankanmitra2425]

Couldn't agree more

[@RkRk-xu1ww]

Vande Matram was slogan used way before creation of Pakistan. ❤

[@sabahnargis9767]

Agree..but aap baat ka matlab galat samjhi.

[@AtishPatange-eu7bh]

As an Indian, the most beautiful point by him is "apni jindagi main koi inqualab nahi lata"

[@shoaibmukhtar7544]

He is ignorant from historical facts. In last fifty years, what happened in South Africa, and in Iran.

[@monologuemania9730]

Amazing discussion! Clear cut logic. I was glued to the video all throughout! Salute from Kolkata, India.

[@ahmedafb]

Interestingly, first phase of correction is "realization" Glad that young generation understands the reality.

[@arunsar7893]

Accurate.

[@nomanonroad]

This is probably one of the best podcast I have ever heard from pakistanis..if more were enlightened like these people Pakistan would prosper enormously..

[@fahadhussain66]

The enlightened ones are drowning near Greece. Because they know that there is nothing in Pakistan.

[@ravenchunter]

The word you are looking for is extremism. The dilemma is this "patriotism". Samuel Johnson famously said "patriotism is last refuge of scoundrels." That is correct, Indians have to surrender their nationality to get another nationality.

[@muhammadasad1878]

thats soo true! thats what we nwwd to think of

[@KingKong-lb3vh]

@@muhammadasad1878 The Pakistani awaam have a sheep like mentality and will follow anybody who makes the loudest, flatulent noises (aka CHOORAN that seem pleasant to their bewaqoof ears)- be it 'mulk ka wajood' 'islam' 'kashmirion ka haq' - all opiates for the sheeples, so both the civilians' and the generals have sold this chooran (said opiates), and had a relaxed 75 years at the expense of AND SUPPORTED BY the said sheeples. Quran majeed "JAISI AWAAM, WAISE HI hukumran"

[@shazainbaloch2538]

Indian History Aryans Never Invades in India Mughals Never Ruled on India 🤪😂 "Britishers Never Comes to India" Coming Soon

[@dollartreeshark6786]

@@shazainbaloch2538 Kuch bhi…do not project lies in your history books onto Indian books. You work on your own problem.

[@mr.curious6872]

​@@shazainbaloch2538 it's already proven that there is no sign of any invasion . The Aryan invasion was a theory which was already debunked, archeologists believe in Aryan migration not invasion. (2) Mughal never ruled all of the sub-continent, they never ruled India if you believe in partition.Because there was no Mughals in 1900s. (3)British not only ruled present day India but they also ruled present day pakistan. So your ancestors were also servants of Britishers in that era. (4) Don't mock Hindus without knowing anything about there stuff , since they are oldest living civilization still taking breath in this world and they are your ancestors too. So please think before mocking.

[@ganeshviswanathan4128]

Dr Pervez Hoodbhoy, writing an article in 'The Dawn' on 22nd April 2023 candidly and boldly concluded: "For stability and prosperity, Pakistan will have to shed its illusions and become a normal country. This means that its diverse peoples must be held together consensually through shared needs and interdependence, not through some ideological diktat. The hyper religiosity promoted through state institutions and the toxic education in our schools is not getting us admiration anywhere. Instead, it is producing a wild, uncontrollable population. Even our friends now fear us." Dr Hoodbhoy, a Gujarathi from Karachi, is an Islamabad-based physicist and writer. His closing words are the daring yet boldest comments.These words will haunt anyone for ever. He cautioned about the "wild, uncontrollable population [indoctrinated by years of wrong history taught from the earliest stages of school]. Dr Hoodbhoy is not alone today. Adeelbhai and Dr Hoodbhoy and scores of others like them are beacons in the midst of a dark ocean. These are OUR people. These do not claim their origin from a foreign genealogy like Arabic, Persisan or Turkic. It is fashionable to proudly, but falsely without any basis, claim origin from Mohammad-Bin-Qasim who came to Sind from Arab in 712 and remained for about two years or half-Persian Ghazni or Khilji/Tughlak or the Uzbek Babur instead of the lowly "Indian" because one does not want to be associated with "Indians." But truth cannot be hidden (Mohammad Ali Jinnah's mother, who was a Gujarathi Lohana and Zulfikar Ali Bhutto's mother, who was a Sindhi Summa Rajput were Hindus). Even after 10,000 or 50,000 years, one can never become an Arab/Persian/Turkic and will ever remain "Indian." If one is ashamed of their Indian origin, then, one should forego the Indian last names (like Cheema, Sidhu, Bajwa, Chourdhary, Malik, Seth, Chouhan, Bhatti, Rathore, ), leave the Indian culture, traditions and practices, leave the Indian food, and leave the Indian dress and leave the country and go elsewhere to that country -Arabia,Iran or Turkey- where they think they belong to. People who think that they are Arabic/Persian/Turkic but who are not are destroying the country.

[@discoverywithjaffery]

More than half of the comments on Pakistani living abroad are biased and factly wrong. You need to have more in-depth research about Pakistanis living abroad. Most of the Pakistanis living abroad don't live willingly there, they live to support their family back home in Pakistan. Saying, that they are hypocrites shows your lack of knowledge in this matter, so please recheck your fact and then comment blatantly like this. People living abroad deserve the right to vote in Pakistan because it is because of them, that you are still able to sit and have this podcast. Please show some respect here.

[@SaltLake180]

Loved Adeel Afzal’s sensible approach to this topic.

[@VaibhavSharma-je6bg]

Adeel afzal is a very kind hearted person love you sir❤

[@vkishan2089]

This was very insightful. We need such discussions in India.

[@anushkapandey4756]

Wowww, finally the Pakistani people are getting aware of the narrative that has been imposed on them since 1947. I hope there'll be more people like this over there .

[@muhammadjunaidsaeed1373]

you people should also get aware of your fake media and fake historical and religious stories .

[@tarunupadhyay2219]

Fantastic discussion.

[@shahidmehmood7762]

Not understood what was he trying to explain. As a listener it was just a generic cribbing done by any citizen in any country.

[@anukha3563]

Agree report it

[@jasmineworld2750]

Agree

[@dineshjoshi136]

In Muslim ruler monuments Persian,Urdu,Punjabi.,Hindi are manufactured language to simplify arbi,Persia,. Hindu ancient language was Sanskrit.of Aryan Harrappa and sindu ghati civilization.

[@aamirhussain5982]

Great, thankss for this great conversation #Pak India♥️

[@adityarajsingh8110]

I'm really glad that this subcontinent is going through such revolution beyond religious identity but based on etgnic and cultural ones

[@sunnybarua6028]

I have to disagree my friend, the real discussions are happening in India, the above discussion in Pakistan is only happening in elite circles, if you look at the distribution of viewers for the video, I'm confident 40 to 50% will be from India, the average Pakistani citizen is highly radicalized, the average Bangladeshi is highly Radicalized, you can't have opposing thoughts in Abrahamic culture, the Inquisition was an example of Radical Christianity, and the current "Sar Tan Se Juda" sentiments, compared to that Jai Sri Ram is tame, because it's an expression of Religious Identity not a war cry or threat.

[@mad4790]

​@@sunnybarua6028agree with you 💯%.. Trying to overcome the religious ideology will put Pakistan in existential crisis

[@iftekhar7266]

Deeply thought-provoking poscast indeed! I am at loss of words to comment further. Please keep it up; and take care.

[@rajneeshsharma9049]

Thank you for the partition. This is the best thing that happened to Indians

[@1525boy]

Partition, along with British colonization, is the absolute worst thing to ever happen to Bharat 🇮🇳.

[@KingKong-lb3vh]

yes as a minority I agree...........would prefer to live in India than ANY islamic nation in the world

[@1525boy]

@@KingKong-lb3vh Even Turkey 🇹🇷, Malaysia 🇲🇾, United Arab Emirates 🇦🇪, Oman 🇴🇲, Qatar 🇶🇦, Kuwait 🇰🇼, Bahrain 🇧🇭, and Morocco 🇲🇦 just to name a few?

[@wewillmakeyouaplaceforthew5793]

@@1525boy they probably haven't been to those countries, their knowledge comes from media all media lies

[@mukundha7621]

​@@1525boy no I don't want to be killed as Hindu by a Muslim gazi while they are defended by liberal muslims

[@abolishkhg-uh]

We are not Punjabi Sindhi Balochi pathaan we are Pakistani ❤🇵🇰 we all are united and working for prosperity of Pakistan

[@Ikhwan101]

Haan but in liberals ko kon samjhaye inn logo toh bas India ke samne apne numbers badhane hain. Aur koi Muslim Ranjit ko apna hero taslim nahi kar sakta.

[@Abubakr10008]

Main to hun punjabi mujhe apni Qom pe fakhar hai mujhe apne aba o ajdad ki tareekh pe fakhar hai. 1947 se pehle kya thay?

[@Abubakr10008]

@@Ikhwan101 zaruri nhi ranjit singh ko hero mano. Tum logo jo shayad apne ab o ajdad ki tareekh pe fakhar na ho mujhe to hai. Tum chaho jitne jhut banao ke tumhare ajdad arab se aye thay turkey se aye thay 😂 main to fakhar se kehta hun mein indus valley civilization ke logo ki aulad main se hun. Jinhon ne duniya ko tehzeeb sikhai thi. Meri tareekh 1947 se ya 711 se nahi 7000 sal pehle se shuru hoti hai.

[@AmanKumar-bp1zf]

India lacks patriotism 😂 Bro we respect our motherland more than our religion meanwhile you guys don't consider your region and boundary

[@DoobyChef]

Nope you guys are extremist not patriotic that's why you Burned a srilankan man, harass minority Hindu and Punjabi pick oh sorry kidnap their girls. From which angel you are a patriotic? Your own media channels praise india have you ever seen an Indian sitting in Pakistan channel praising pakistan

[@wewillmakeyouaplaceforthew5793]

lmfao, dude har cheiz me apna dunning kruger narrative ghusana lazmi hai? stop with this chauvinistic remarks and listen to the guy for a while

[@DarkKnight-db1dy]

by Indians he meant the muslim section of Indians😂😂

[@riffataligohar8415]

I clicked because of TCM...! Content shared is without evidenves....! INDIVIDUAL OPINION & STATE ISSUES are two different things to speak about! Thier talk is full of uncertainities....!

[@ARR1058]

Indians cannot be dual nationals but they are allowed to be non resident Indians with an ID. It does not give them right to vote but they pretty much have all the rights of an Indian citizen

[@vinsin328]

So they can become PM of India?

[@ARR1058]

I think they would need to surrender their foreign passport and acquire full Indian citizenship. I believe this was the case with Sonia Gandhi when she entered politics she had to rescind her Italian citizenship

[@RealRandomVideos]

@@vinsin328 cannot vote itself means cannot participate in elections. To become PM they have to participate and win elections. No they cannot. And they cannot buy agricultural land too.

[@vipint3694]

​@@ARR1058 one can only be citizen of India and not like Pakistan

[@ARR1058]

I know that. I don’t think you actually read my comment. They can get an NRI card which is not dual nationality but allows them many rights similar to Indian citizens such as property ownership, businesses etc but does not give them voting rights

[@nareshshingote8081]

In Pakistan Arabic Islam is more important than patriotism of land of Pakistan. As Islam forbids to love and believe our land as our God

[@afuncalledcricket9724]

Brother A very good analytical approach. I had worked with many Pakistani Police and paramilitary personnel at Kosova in UN Mission 2005-06. I was astonished to learn that they didn't know much about their history. They were taught to believe that there was no history or great empires before the spread of Islam in this region i. e. Undivided India. They were practically ignorant regarding Hadappa &Mohan Jo daro civilisation nor about Taxila University. I told them, see brothers you are the real owner of that heritage as it is now in your territory and be proud on it. We the Indian living 1000-1200 miles from these places still boast of our ancient heritage and progress but you living over it are denying this legacy. It was a shattering experience for me. My Pakistani brothers, we as a whole nation were torch bearers for other civilisations Accept it and be proud.

[@jamalhasan3192]

True. Unfortunately most of us dont even know our own history. History starts from land where we were born. We have confused our land history with religion. From 🇵🇰

[@ime8902]

Pakistanis should promote such true voices.. n come to India n have dialogues on different issues.. learn new things

[@jagdishramanathan2091]

Artists are generally free thinkers .they don't become politician !

[@None12768]

sahi baat hai.. we cannot be dual national ... if we attain a passport of another country then we lose indian citizenship. it is an obligation and cannot be challenged. rahul gandhi presented his british citizenship proof in uk in 2006 and acquired 60% shares of a british company named blackops . the firm was dissolved in 2009. hopefully he will also be kicked out of politics soon

[@saddozaiproduction]

Comparing Mahmud with Ranjit by itself is a contradiction

[@Ikhwan101]

Haan kafir ka Muslim ke sath koi comparison nahi hain.

[@harshvardhanmaurya7158]

​@@Ikhwan101 yhi soch se toh yeh haaal h tumhare Sikh ki income vs apni income dekh le do do Pakistani kharid skta h ek Sikh.

[@khurshid2773]

Harsh vardhan maurya aik Muslim ki income Vs aik Sikh ki income dykho Sara Hindustan Kharid sakta hy aik muslim ab yeah nae kehna konsa Saudi UAE Qatar etc. may muslims hi hyn jahan tumlog job Kay liay jatay ho

[@ennnceee]

Good discussion. Bring more like this one.

[@sanjver]

Its but natural that the entire Pakistani population did not come as invaders, 90% of Pakistani's forefathers were originally Hindus/Buddhists and were forcefully converted. But the current generation celebrate the invaders as their hero's and damn their original roots. Really strange.

[@akshayvinchurkar6073]

He is exactly saying the truth

[@mrashikhan19]

Islam doesn't promote destruction of any religious places. If someone did that he has done wrong 😭

[@ahmedejaz]

sir very good episode, thanks for your efforts

[@bilalchohan6524]

God bless us with education firstly and then countless successes ameen 🤲 by the amazing conversation guys keep it up 👍🙌

[@Edward4Plantagenet]

Bro, aap log kab convert hue??

[@Curiosityoffsite]

I appreciate unbiased discussion and neutrality of yours.

[@HotelGoldenTree]

What a powerful vlog.😮 Salute to both the Artist and journalist for speaking and questioning Pakistani state. This is soul searching effort for all of yhis sub continental people

[@afterburner2828]

Such discussion is great for Pakistan, bearded guy is deep...👍👍👍

[@saqichaudary7573]

Bhai jaan school books to har jaga hi aisi hoti Hain. In India they are removing Muslim history in their school curriculum. Each country has its own narrative of history.

[@delhipropertiesandplots209]

mughals never controlled whole of india. They couldn't even extract taxes from vast majoirty of zamindars of malwa and bihar - each zamindar had his own army - it was not simply black and white a presented. Even aurangzeb didn't control whole of india- not even half despite most of his life spent in military campaigns

[@gamesandfun5110]

Parizaad me inka character bahot achha hai 👌👌👌 Nice Discussion ✔👌👌👌🇮🇳

[@hammadqureshi1763]

Kaali ma was a low caste woman who rose to queen status by killing high castes. Brohi is a Dravidian language that has survived in our parts. India has at least a dozen Dravidian languages.

[@abhinavkumar9c017]

Nigga what? Kaali maa is the wife of Shiva and same as Parvati

[@vishalsingh-yj8bk]

3:04 The word that you are looking for is Jingoism/Jingoistic Nationalism.

[@chandanstudies]

Jinnah was the eldest of seven children of Jinnahbhai Poonja, a prosperous merchant, and his wife, Mithibai. His family was a member of the Khoja caste, Hindus who had converted to Islam centuries earlier and who were followers of the Aga Khan

[@zarakkhan7571]

It is super easy to point out mistakes in Khan. What you and most of you on the left don’t see is the change that is happening around us. Rather than helping democracy you would rather stand on a side and pass comments. Please note that you are standing on which side of the history today.

[@dilbagsingh6406]

Very good fair and unbiased conversation

[@JM-tn6bw]

Mughals were not indigenous people migrated from Central Asia and plundered India at a great extent

[@dilkhozaimarwat3479]

nor were the most of the people they plundered, aryans and others came as invaders as well. The thing is mughals stayed here and became part of india, they didnt take away the plundered things somewhere else.

[@dollartreeshark6786]

@@dilkhozaimarwat3479 They came as migrants, not invaders. History does not throw up a single invader’s name before Islamic invaders.

[@essaadeel3676]

​@@dollartreeshark6786 Babur was most certainly an invader and so were the ghaznavids

[@dollartreeshark6786]

@@essaadeel3676 correct. Any invader before islamic invaders? May be Alexander the plunderer?

[@essaadeel3676]

​@@dollartreeshark6786 there were major pre Islamic invasions by Sakas (Scythians) and Shweta hunas (white Huns) but unlike Islamic invaders these Scythians and Huns assimilated into indian society and followed indian religions such Hinduism, Buddhism, Jainism. Before Alexander there were the Achaemenid Iranians who managed to conquer Gandhara during the rule of Darius the great, the Achaemenids were known for their tolerance of the conquered people's religion and culture, Darius also conquered Macedonia.

[@prasad7553]

Pakistan was carved out of India on the basis of Islam and Hindu hate. The logical end is further disintegration of Pakistan. A number of Pakistanis donot like Punjabi dominance.

[@Umranii]

Waah, Great analysis on Balochistan 👏👏

[@user-bb9zm6xv2q]

One thing is for sure ,as an Indian i say this a Pakistani intellectual is a force to reckon with ,i wish you luck in your sincere endeavours to break the shackles of bigotry and mental enslavement 🙏 good luck 🙏

[@faizanayub1367]

You guys are absolutely 💯

[@shazainbaloch2538]

--------------ہندو کون تھے؟ - - - - - - - - - - آریان جنہوں نے تقریباً 2000 قبل مسیح سے 1500 قبل مسیح کے درمیان ہندوستان پر حملہ کیا، اور سنسکرت زبان اور ہندوتوا نظریہ کو برصغیر میں لاۓ، جسے آج ہندو کہتے ہیں۔ آریاؤں کے پاس بہترین فوج اور جنگی ساز و سامان تھا اور وہ ایک اندازے مطابق موجودہ ہندوستان کے شمال سے داخل ہوئے تھے ۔ اس وقت کے ہندوستان کے باشندے بہت پرامن تھے اور وہ سورج اور چاند کے پجاری تھے، وہ جنگ اور جنگی ساز و سامان سے بے خبر تھے،وہ بہت زیادہ مذہبی نہیں تھے۔ آریاؤں نے ایک بڑے لشکر کے ساتھ ان پر حملہ کیا اور ان کا قتل عام کیا،چونکہ آریائی جنگجو قوم تھے سو انہوں نے بآسانی جنگ جیت لی، عورتوں کے ساتھ زیادتیاں کی گئیں اور بچوں کو سنسکرت اور ہندو تعلیمات زبردستی سیکھنے پر مجبور کیا گیا، آریاؤں نے مقامی لوگوں کی ثقافت، مذہب اور زبان کو مکمل طور پر تباہ کر دیا، جس نے سنسکرت اور ہندو مذہب کو قبول کیا اسے زندہ چھوڑ دیا گیا اور جس نے مخالفت کی اسے زندہ جلا دیا گیا۔ راکھی گڑھی تہذیب اور سندھ کی تہذیب دونوں کو آریائی حملہ آوروں نے تباہ کر دیا تھا۔وہیلر، جو 1944 سے 1948 تک آرکیالوجیکل سروے آف انڈیا کے ڈائریکٹر جنرل تھے، موہنجو داڑو آثار قدیمہ کے بالائی سطح پر پائی جانے والی کئی بے دفن لاشیں دریافت کیں جو کہ اس بات کا ثبوت تھیں کہ وہ ایک خون ریز جنگ کا شکار ہوئیں تھیں۔نوکیلی طرز کی بکھری اشیاء جو کسی ہتھیار سے مماثلت رکھتی ہیں، ان کے ٹکڑے بھی دریافت ہوۓ. دریافت شدہ ثبوتوں نے یہ ثابت کیا کہ پرامن ہڑپہ کے لوگوں کے خلاف گھوڑوں اور زیادہ جدید ہتھیاروں کا استعمال کر کے، آریاؤں نے انہیں آسانی سے شکست دی ہو گی۔ کیونکہ ابھی تک انڈس سویلائزیشن کے لوگوں کا اپنے دفاع کیلئے استعمال ہونے والی کوئی چیز دریافت نہیں ہوئی. سو غالباً وہ کسی بڑی جنگ کیلئے تیار نہیں تھے. جب بھی حملہ آور کہیں بھی حملہ کرتے ہیں تو وہ اپنی ثقافت، مذہب اور روایات بھی ساتھ لے کر آتے ہیں۔ آریائی رگ وید، زینڈ-اویستا، اور الیاڈ اور اوڈیسی لاۓ. - - - - - - - آریائی ثقافت اور شناخت----------- برہمن شمال سے آریائی حملہ آور تھے اس لیے وہ اپنی زبان سنسکرت کو برصغیر میں لاۓ۔ آریائی اپنے ساتھ اپنی زبان، مذہبی عقائد اور سماجی نظام جو لے کر آئے اسے جبراً مقامی لوگوں پر مسلط کیا. آریاؤں نے ایک ایسا سماجی نظام تیار کیا جس کا ہندوستانی ثقافت پر دیرپا اثر پڑا۔ اس وقت کے ہندوستان میں بھی کئی زبانیں رائج تھیں جو مکمل تباہ نہیں ہوئی مگر اپنی اصل شکل میں بھی نہیں رہیں. موجودہ ہندوستان میں رائج زبانوں کا رسم الخط تو پرانا ہے مگر الفاظ سنسکرت اور مقامی زبان کی ملاوٹ ہے. -------قدیم ہندوستان کا مذہب کیا تھا؟------- ویسے تو یہ ابھی تک ایک راز ہے. مقامی لوگوں کا صحیح مذہب کیا تھا نامعلوم ہے. لیکن کچھ ماہرین کا خیال ہے کہ برصغیر کے مقامی لوگوں کا مذہب کی طرف زیادہ رجحان نہیں تھا بلکہ وہ سورج اور چاند کی پوجا کرتے تھے یا آگ کی پوجا کرتے تھے۔ وہ فلاحی ریاست بنا چکے تھے جہاں فیصلے اکثریت کی حمایت سے ہوتے تھے. وہ مختلف قبیلوں میں تھے اور ہر قبیلے کا ایک سردار ہوتا تھا. بعض آثار سے یہ تاثر ملتا ہے کہ عورتوں کو بھی سردار بنایا جاتا تھا. یعنی ایک طرح سے وہ سوشلسٹ تھے. مگر آریاؤں نے نہ صرف ان لوگوں کا ظالمانہ طریقے سے قتل عام کیا بلکہ پوری تہذیب کو تباہ برباد کر دیا۔ جنگ میں زندہ بچ جانے والوں کو زبردستی ہندو بنایا گیا، خواتین کی عصمت دری کی گئی اور انہیں غلام بنایا گیا۔ اب تک کی دہائیوں کی تحقیق سے ایسے آثار قدیمہ دریافت نہیں ہوۓ، جس سے یہ کہا جاسکے کے ہندوتوا یہاں کے باسیوں کا اصل مذہب تھا لیکن اس کے خلاف ٹھوس شواہد موجود ہیں. اس بات سے دائیں بازو کے انتہا پسند ہندو رہنما اس تحقیق کو بار بار رکوانے یا بدلنے کی کوشش کرتے رہتے ہیں. حال ہی میں رکھی گڑھی سے ملنے والے انسانی ڈھانچے کے دی این اے ٹیسٹ نے ہندو انتہا پسندوں کو مذید مشتعل کردیا کیونکہ اس کا ڈی این اے موجودہ ہندوستانی ڈی این اے سے میچ نہیں ہوا. اس پر خود ہندوستان کے انڈیا نیوز کا مندرجہ ذیل آرٹیکل موجود ہے. یہ 2018 میں شائع کیا گیا. ⬇️⬇️⬇️⬇️⬇️⬇️⬇️⬇️⬇️⬇️⬇️ راکھی گڑھی سے 4500 سال پرانا ڈی این اے ایسے شواہد ظاہر کرتا ہے جو ہندو قوم پرستوں کو پریشان کر دے گا. www.indiatoday.in/magazine/cover-story/story/20180910-rakhigarhi-dna-study-findings-indus-valley-civilisation-1327247-2018-08-31 ______________--------------______________ جھوٹ اور غلط معلومات کچھ ہندو مورخین نے یہ ثابت کرنے کی کوشش کی کہ آریائی ایران سے ہندوستان پر حملہ آور ہوئے جبکہ آریائیوں نے درحقیقت موجودہ ہندوستان کے شمال سے حملہ کیا۔ ہو سکتا ہے کہ آریان نے موجودہ ایران پر بھی حملہ کیا ہو، لیکن اس نظریہ کا کوئی ٹھوس ثبوت نہیں ہے۔ وہ تمام تر شواہد جو ہندو خود انڈس، راکھی گڑھی سے منسوب کر رہے ہیں جعلی اور بے بنیاد ہیں. مندرجہ بالا تحقیق اور شواہد سے یہ بات ثابت ہوتی ہے کہ ہندتوا برصغیر کا مقامی مذہب نہیں، دیگر مذاہب کی طرح یہ بھی یہاں آکر پھیلایا گیا نہ کہ بنایا گیا. ہندوؤں کے 9 ہزار سالہ کی کوئی تاریخ نہیں ہے، وہ اکثر مسلمانوں کو Converted کہتے ہیں جبکہ وہ خود Converted ہیں.

[@jurisgenius.]

Phir tou is baat py bhi question krna chahiey why Hazrat Ibrahim AS broke idols?

[@reactionwala1691]

Sir Salute hai aapko I'm From India ..❤❤

[@cpafcma]

Great conversation.

[@dheerajnarang6667]

Hat's off to all the truth speaking Pakistanis

[@jaibholenath6900]

Hope we redraw borders and exchange populations of Muslim and non Muslims peacefully.

[@Vikaskumar-cl9js]

Want these type of podcast by Pakistanis more

[@sohambhatt6504]

Wrong map of Pakistan has been shown here

[@sanjaychauhan1116]

2:34 kunal ki wahi ijjat hai india me jo bilawal ki Pakistan me hai .Indians ko patriotic hone k liye Pakistan ki jarurat nahi hai .Jab Pakistan nahi bana tha to kya indians patriotic nahi thee ? Bhagat singh ,Subhash chandra bose ,Shivaji maharaj ,Rana pratap ,Prithviraj chauhan ,APJ abdul kalam ,Vikram sarabhai ,Dr homi bhabha etc ye log kon thee jo desh ki liye lade aur kaam kiya.Humare pass proud hone k liye heroes ki kami nahi hai ,humare yaha nationalism shikhate nahi hai vo humare blood me hai .India is first then religion comes for us .Kunal jaise leftist chutiye does not represent whole india

[@danishalam3270]

But BjP uses pakistan for Patriotism proofing.... Where are you man Accept the truth

[@vaniganapathi830]

@@danishalam3270 At the end of the day it's a political party which need to win elections to do things. People say BJP is pro Hindu . No they make people like Nupur disappear or make them go into hiding but make people like Zubair , Owaisi roam freely, even give Padma vibushan to Mulayam Singh. It is just another political party . Only thing is they are less corrupt pro development. Just like Congress before independence.

[@subashdalai8893]

Yeh sach hai DNA mein 😂 koi Kuch bolega to Humhara Khoon kholega jai hind

[@Piyushgathalaiitb]

According to me, people in India Getting to watch this interview about some of Pakistani people's thoughts has done more good to people to people ties between India and Pakistan, than Pakistani military and political apparatus has ever allowed.

[@neerajsjpr]

Just imagine if Hindu and Hindustan hate, landlords are removed from Pakistan, what remains the reason of Pakistan 's existence. India is also diverse in nature with so many languages, religions and cultures, but still love the country.

[@HassanAli-xl8kr]

Just imagine if Pakistan hate removed from India and Indians then their shall be no Indian union left in world map because it's the Islam and Pakistan hate has kept north south and north east or western India together this long other Indians of north hate Indians of south and northeast Indians are standing no where they are always treated as outsider with in India so let's imagine if Pakistan hate removed from India will Indian survive ? I don't think so because in reality India was never a one country it was always small states so in next five to ten years there shall be no India left on world map

[@neerajsjpr]

@@HassanAli-xl8kr lol, it's not India's loss if you are getting defaulted. Keep the hate burning in your hearts forever as you wanted to bleed India with thousand cuts. Jinnah wanted land for muslims and he got one, now it's upto you what you want to do with it. Your religion does not allow diversity, it believe in converting whole world. Just try to think why Bengal revolted?? Just try to think why Baloch , Pakhtoons, Sindhis are different in nature. You imposed your Punjabi rules and Indian language Urdu on them. Loss is yours dear friend, India is decades ahead of you and will grow more, you are cursing in hate for 75 yrs and has it helped you??

[@mmeettwwoo]

Any society, people dont change...generations change...

[@ravinigudkar6112]

FANTASTIC! great talk, I learnt a lot, being an Indian I had no information on all the points

[@personenkenzahl]

gehri aur karwi baatain, glad that you've invited adeel afzal to your show

[@ParissaKhoury]

I visited Pakistan last year and my favorite part was the Gilgit Baltistan region. I thoroughly enjoyed my time with the Kalash people. To me that's diversity and it should be protected AT ALL COSTS !!! Also, I hope that the barbaric Taliban get completely kicked out of Pakistan.

[@sushilpatil5353]

Pakistan needs persons like you. 👍

[@sushilpatil5353]

🙏

[@Edward4Plantagenet]

Listen to Christine Fair. She is Pakistan expert in USA.

[@karama709]

ISI will definitely torture Adeel Afzal now,only the Allah can save him now

[@rollsroyce4249]

That means nobody can save him

[@rekido8542]

2:28 "What is India without Pakistan?" . Lol. India is IVC, Maurya , Gupta, Chola, Vijayanagara, Ahoms , Marathas and many more. India is the home of Hinduism, Buddhism, Jainism and Sikhism. India is the land of the Upanishads and the Jatakas and the Bhakti literature . India is the land of Carnatic and Hindustani, or Bharatnatyam, Kathak and Ras Leela , of the Great Living Chola temples , the Jagannath temple, the Padmanabhaswamy and the Kamakhya , the Shakti Peeths and the Jyotirlingas, Bodh Gaya and Sanchi, Mount Abu and Ranakpur, the Ajanta and Ellora caves, a 5000 year archaeologically continuous living civilization. With due respect for genuinely curious liberal Pakistanis, you need to stop projecting your identity crisis onto us. India was a globally recognized great civilization before Islam even existed. The real question is not what India is without Pakistan, but what Pakistan is without India .

[@tanishqmairal]

I never watch any Pakistani podcast on KZbin infact i download them and watch it so that views don't increase as they always seems to be biased and with an narrative. This is the first time i subscribed liked, shared and commented on a Pakistani podcast.... Amazing i never knew this much about baloch people and Balochistan...

[@apoorvashekhawat6741]

Bro the lengths u go just so ppl who hv diff views from u don't get profit ,astounding.

[@muhammadrabee6307]

Alhamdulliah mentality change ho rhi hai ahista ahista ❤

[@ennnceee]

Very very interesting talk. I loved this. It was such an honest talk. God bless you.