Peanut Butter Candy Taste Test Tournament

In day 1 of our Peanut Butter Tournament, we're determining the best peanut butter candy! GMM # 2567
Subscribe to GMM: kzbin.info...
We’re going on tour!! Visit goodmythicaltour.com for info & tickets!
Watch today's GMMORE: • Ranking The Cringiest ...
Click the bell icon so you'll know when we add a new episode!
Want more GMM? Check out these playlists:
Season 23 - • Season 23 | Good Mythi...
Good Mythical Summer 2023 - • Good Mythical Summer 2...
Will It? - • Will It? | Good Mythic...
Taste Tests! - • Taste Tests! | Good My...
Check out Mythical's new cereal! - eatmishmash.com
Check out Sporked, Mythical's website dedicated to helping you find the best food on the shelves! - www.sporked.com
Get a copy of our novel, The Lost Causes of Bleak Creek @ www.bleakcreek.com
Pick up official GMM and Mythical merch at mythical.com
and www.amazon.com/mythical
Don’t miss our weekly podcast, Ear Biscuits: applepodcasts.com/earbiscuits
Join the Mythical Society: www.mythicalsociety.com
Follow Mythical:
Instagram: / mythical
Facebook: / mythical
Twitter: / mythical
TikTok: / mythical
Website: mythical.com
Check Out Our Other Mythical Channels:
Mythical Kitchen: / mythicalkitchen
Rhett & Link: / rhettandlink
Good Mythical MORE: / goodmythicalmore
Want to send us something? mythical.com/contact
Submit your Wheel of Mythicality video here: bit.ly/GMMWheelIntroSUBMISSIONS
Intro Motion Graphics by Fantoons www.fantoons.shop/
Intro & Outro Music by Rhett & Link
In the spirit of minimizing food waste associated with the filming of this series, Mythical is donating to the Hollywood Food Coalition ( hofoco.org ) who provide daily, nourishing meals to underserved communities in the Los Angeles area.
Get the GMM Set Gear!
(As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases from paid links below)
* Apple AirPort Extreme: amzn.to/2NnIvvk
* Apple iPad Pro (12.9-inch, Wi-Fi, 64GB) - Space Gray (Latest Model) - MTEL2LL/A: amzn.to/2NnKXlw
* Guardian Industrial Products DH-CP-4 3 Channel Rubber Cable Ramp (Straight): amzn.to/2NdshoR
* Cartoni Focus HD Fluid Head with 3 Tube Ultra-Light Tripod, Mid-Level Spreader and Soft Case - Black: amzn.to/2X4i7X8
* ARRI SkyPanel S60-C LED Softlight (Blue/Silver, Edison): amzn.to/2YgM3km
* Chef-Master 90050 Professional Heat Lamp, Silver: amzn.to/2Xa1Wwr
* Samsung UN40H5003 40-Inch 1080p LED TV (2014 Model): amzn.to/2NdMU4e
* Sony LMDA170 17" Production Video LCD Monitor, 16:9 Native Aspect Ratio, 1080p Resolution: amzn.to/2YlB9tH
* Behringer Xenyx 1002 Premium 10-Input 2-Bus Mixer with XENYX Mic Preamps and British Eqs: amzn.to/2Yeeqzl
* Elgato Game Capture Card HD60 S - Stream and Record in 1080p60, for PlayStation 4, Xbox One & Xbox 360 (Renewed): amzn.to/2NdOBP6
* Pyle Universal Speaker Stand Mount Holder - Heavy Duty Tripod w/ Adjustable Height from 40” to 71” and 35mm Compatible Insert - Easy Mobility Safety PIN and Knob Tension Locking for Stability PSTND2: amzn.to/2JcCpce
* JBL EON612 Portable 12" 2-Way Multipurpose Self-Powered Sound Reinforcement: amzn.to/2Ndluvm
* Bolt 500 XT 3G-SDI/HDMI Wireless TX/RX: amzn.to/2J1OeSk
* Voigtlaender 17,5/0,95 Nokton 17.5 mm-17.5 mm Lens: amzn.to/2JjUCEP
* Blackmagic Design Micro Converter SDI to HDMI (with Power Supply) BMD-CONVCMIC/SH/WPSU: amzn.to/2J6iw6y
* Panasonic H-HSA35100 F2.8 II ASPH 35-100mm Mirrorless Micro Four Thirds Mount POWER Optical I.S. LUMIX G X VARIO Professional Lens: amzn.to/2RAhIul
* PANASONIC LUMIX Professional 12-35mm Camera Lens G X VARIO II, F2.8 ASPH, Dual I.S. 2.0 with Power O.I.S., Mirrorless Micro Four Thirds, H-HSA12035 (2017 Model, Black): amzn.to/2J9WH5S
* Decimator Design DMON-12S | 12 Channel Multi Viewer with HDMI SDI Outputs: amzn.to/2J9Xkwg
* Decimator MD-HX HDMI and SDI Cross Converter with Scaling & Frame Rate Conversion: amzn.to/2Ymj52c
* PANASONIC LUMIX GH4 Body 4K Mirrorless Camera, 16 Megapixels, 3 Inch Touch LCD, DMC-GH4KBODY (USA Black): amzn.to/2WZjlD6
* Blue Microphones Mouse Microphone Kc: amzn.to/2Ybu12I

[@kingkrudho8601]

The collective laughter to Rhett’s joke to the collective groan and sigh to links joke is amazing and Emily laughing at that fact makes it 100x better

[@squaidinkarts]

yeah i really appreciated that, we were so in sync

[@cooliostarstache5474]

Rhett makes a weird joke The crew: 😂😂😂😂 Link makes a weird joke The crew: 😮😮😬😬😱😱😨😨

[@TraceyC875schannel-oq6sb]

My fav part!

[@cameronhoke14]

THE COLLECTIVE GROAN when Link called her “damp,” I am GOBSMACKED, LMFAOOO. 💀💀💀

[@BrickTamlandOfficial]

when?

[@kaylak6522]

​​@@BrickTamlandOfficial 13:33

[@ethanblust188]

Gobsmacked is crazy

[@rebeccarackley7047]

Are you a twenty one pilots fan? Your use of gobsmacked would make more sense 😂

[@breadvulture462]

@@rebeccarackley7047first thing I thought when I read the comment

[@alexiscurb4364]

Emily as a homicidal peanut is strangely comforting in the morning 🤔

[@k7l3rworkman97]

Issa whole vibe 💯😆❤️

[@alexr.138]

Seconded

[@tison7208]

in the mourning

[@pinker812]

No she was implying she was married to Mr peanut.

[@tss3393]

They ought to borrow Chanse from Smosh for a day so he and Emily can do a bit as Mr. and Mrs. Peanut

[@alecadabra_]

Rhett: “let me just say before you bite into it” *Link immediately bites into it and starts coughing over him talking*

[@P747]

Yeah, Link is not very bright.

[@HelloSydney97]

@@P747smarter than you peanut

[@thedenntist]

​@@P747 that ain't it

[@Ulix_Music]

Shoutout to all beater fungers 4:25 ‼️🔥

[@weakw1ll]

Finally someone had the heart to say it 🗣️🗣️

[@KatherynX]

​@@weakw1ll love your hivemind pfp ❤

[@victorramos839]

Beater fungers unite !

[@manny41p]

How he switched the “U” and the “I” in Butterfinger, I have no idea 🤣

[@BackstreetsAngel7]

😂😂😂 hey!

[@natedetailscars]

"She was damp..." *Crickets*

[@FienX_]

“She was damp 😏” *everybody hated that*

[@mrsmoo818]

The groans of disappointment 🤣🤣

[@FienX_]

@@mrsmoo818 💀💀

[@crloscee]

emily's laugh after the groans when link said "she was damp" was adorable

[@erics2091]

Reese’s Peanut Butter Eggs are my favorite. The Bats and Trees are good too, but the Eggs are the best.

[@jascadet]

I was just commenting that. I love all the peanut butter in them compared the to cups, and they are softer. I also love the Giant XL bar. Oh, have you tried Nutrageous and Crunchy Peanut bars? So good!

[@stacyragland3123]

Yesss! They're my all time favorite candy 🍫🥜🧡

[@DJColdCutz_]

I've suggested they do a Reese's holiday shapes taste test to see which is best hahaha

[@giannad27]

I was just thinking the same exact thing lmao Idk why they’re better in egg form than in original form, but they just are.

[@missadissa1]

​@@giannad27they put vanilla flavoring in the shapes but not the original!

[@777luckyme]

You know It’s going to be a funny episode when Emily is involved

[@Cynthia-wj3hf]

Emily could not even save this! Thanks for trying Emily.

[@edwardmclaughlin719]

So true.@@Cynthia-wj3hf

[@matthewanderson1916]

@@Cynthia-wj3hflmao you didn't enjoy the episode?

[@aroundtheblockwithbrock4799]

Who’s Emily I think it was Mrs peanut 😂

[@weakw1ll]

@@aroundtheblockwithbrock4799SMART GUESS 👉

[@SnailLagoon]

Okay, I'll say it. Frozen cookie dough with frozen peanut butter cups is not a candy. That's like calling an M&M McFlurry a candy. 😂

[@sykokitty84]

I came to say the same thing, they would fit better in the PB Snack category. Definitely NOT a candy.

[@angelariedle5030]

Agreed. It's a dessert yeah, not a candy

[@megan5867]

Thank you!!!

[@aitanamassey9988]

I’m so glad I’m not the only one who thought so. Definitely more of a snack than a candy 😂

[@SkyrozzB]

I can agree on the cookie dough but the peanut butter cups are candy if every other peanut butter cup is considered candy as well

[@collinball7443]

“Bursting with softness” is such an incongruous phrase.

[@mikkii505]

thanks for the new word! i had to look it up and definitely will be adding that to my vocab :)

[@sadcat520]

@@mikkii505 Explain it

[@bray.mar69]

I like the way you talk, funny man

[@thrashtildeth247]

Word-of-the-day calendar vibes

[@ldude]

it's not a bot?! 🤣

[@joeb2]

The intros to the March Madness tournaments are the best lmao

[@TheSmallestFan]

I need a Smosh and Mythical crossover between Emily‘s Mrs. Peanut and Chanse’s Mr. Peanut. Immediately!

[@superstarawesome624]

Emily's Mrs. Peanut is actually 🔥

[@thegiacobra]

Pleeeeeeeeeeeeeeease

[@davidatkinson531]

You have no idea how much I need that video😂

[@TheBluerayxx]

Omg yes. Thise two in any video would be insane. These characters would just be cracked.

[@tss3393]

DO EET!!!

[@danidarkoxo]

Link throwing the pb m&m’s down the peanut butter gutter with snarky enthusiasm cracked me up 😂

[@k7l3rworkman97]

Same 🤣❤️

[@KyleWheeler-eb8sv]

“preKOMbucha.” “”Coming on the back.” “She was DAMP!” 😂 😂 Keep this up! These are the laughs we preKOMbucha to this channel for.

[@KiinggKongg]

peanut butter boys are back in town🥜🔥

[@jeremya3120]

They are hanging down at dinos

[@jacobjuarez9950]

Morning fellow insomniacs!

[@Purpley170]

Yo

[@owenbaldwin385]

Glad to be here

[@niahb5088]

hey yall

[@jenlhandy]

Oh, rest assured. I am going back to bed.

[@spoosh7751]

Morning!!!

[@msanchizzle]

Side-eyeing these choices 😮‍💨

[@kennethstrickland6251]

that "!!GOOD NUT!!" was just perfect honestly

[@annabella7253]

Very surprised they hadn’t done this yet💀

[@nihlify]

They have in some form

[@priuskiller426]

@@nihlifynot peanut butter ones specifically. Especially for Link sake. Like on his bday or something.

[@itsmrhunter]

💀💀🤪🤪😂😋🤔

[@ReallyNotThatFunnyy]

They did best chocolate peanut butter snacks in October 2021 (I would know 👀)

[@kevinmeeks5169]

How tf does Reese's not make it to the final two in a peanut butter tournament but pretty much wins any other one 😂😂😂

[@si_quest]

Reese is gross to be honest. Americans don’t know how to make proper PB

[@Halshawaf1]

Science

[@adamf894]

Spoiler alert 🫣

[@highasduck5282]

​@@adamf894 naw

[@TheBrandonGrose]

@@adamf894maybe watch the video before looking through the comments

[@bigtimechunk723]

The slander of my favorite candy of all time peanut butter m&ms, is crazy

[@Potterfann]

But the winner.. isn’t even a candy.. Come on guys.

[@GerritCoulter]

IKR. Who allowed a frozen treat in the candy tournament?

[@slvr323]

butterfinger in the context of gmm inevitably reminds me of "enjoy my finger, almond boy!" 😂🤣💀

[@Hawkeye_Gough]

Beater Funger was my nickname in highschool.

[@Nibblestreams]

😭😭😭

[@BackstreetsAngel7]

I was waiting for that lol

[@cosetterolfes4100]

Mrs. Peanut's Butterfinger joke.. I am DECEASED 🤣💀

[@_OmKudale]

15:39 stevie 😂😂😂

[@ThatCrippledArtist]

I love the direction GMM is headed these days with comments like that lol

[@samipod4878]

And nobody laughed like I went back cuz I knew I heard it and I was like wait how did nobody else

[@eyespliced]

The best peanut candy ever were the *_"Butterfinger BB's."_* Those things were SSS+ Tier.

[@jijitters]

Agreed!

[@anonymousYTviewer69]

PB max was 100000000x better

[@2700JayOfficialPage]

Yes!!!!

[@MasterHayate]

... I totally forgot about those, and you're right, those were god tier.

[@frickinpope]

Holy heck I forgot those existed lol.

[@jenicazeta4881]

Mrs. Peanut 🥜 made this episode special😂 i love her

[@extexdf82]

Emily makes any skit she’s in.

[@scuzzellbutt]

She is Ms. Peanut, thank you.

[@rowanmcbrearty9041]

THEY KEPT UP THE TRADITIONAL MUNCH MADNESSES!!!

[@SullyReviews5000]

Reese’s FAST BREAK is by far the best peanut butter candy on the market. It’s not even close.

[@xanderblackstone]

It's all preference, but I like peanut butter snickers. Fast break are great, though

[@JonahNelson7]

I agree. Unbelievable

[@ronmellen-stier1081]

Reese’s Outrageous is the best.

[@dantheyankee]

wow i was thinking the same thing that's my favorite candy bar

[@groguwelding]

3:22 they’re in sync 🤣🤣🤣

[@nancymathews521]

We need more bracket episodes! These are fun!

[@MrJos597]

give me a double elimination bracket!

[@snowflakehunter]

We need more shuffleboard, international taste test, smellathon, what am I swimming in......are you a newbie?

[@jijitters]

These are among my least favorite 😭

[@masquinongy4652]

What we need are more smelling bees

[@snowflakehunter]

@@masquinongy4652That's what I meant by smellathon! 😆🤣🤣😆 That was my mistake!

[@deutscheinfacher]

0:51 I love it when Rhett does that hahah

[@Frogman5125]

Link needs to relinquish his title as a Peanut Butter Boy after saying he doesn’t like Butterfingers or Peanut Butter M&Ms.

[@weedman0824]

12:15 Her face sent me 😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@weedman0824]

MARCH MADNESS IS BACKKKKKKKKKKK 😂😂😂

[@pb_and_nutella]

Emily is such a riot whenever she’s on, morrreeee EMILY!

[@tonyschannel7438]

The best peanut butter candy items from Reese's are the seasonal items, the pumpkins, the christmas trees, the easter eggs!

[@cynthiasmith9336]

Yes! They have great peanut butter ratio and the chocolate is so smooth.

[@shaunamusser7198]

Agreed!!

[@WingRocka]

For Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups to finally be more available in Taiwan, man, am I glad to see this.

[@nothingnothing3036]

gmm!!! never awake at this time I'm so excited haha

[@shannonshackelford7253]

That celebration at 12:05 was just too freaking cute 🤣🤣🤣🫶🏻 I love them so much

[@JoeKlenk]

Is cookie dough, Candy; should be the next Hotdog isnt sandwich Episode. especially the keep frozen aspect. the price difference. It'd be fun to see a mythical crew interviews after these tournament results. like a post game interview

[@brookemollett]

The peanut butter boys are wild this episode!

[@25Colten]

Burst with softness is also the way to describe Chase ripping an apple in half.

[@davidbryce1985]

Best start to a GMM march madness. Peanut butter for the win!

[@5centsmedia]

This tournaments gonna be nuts

[@gracejohnson6684]

yay! more character work from Emily!!!

[@BrittneyStAubin]

Y’all really chose violence with this one.

[@__aida__1]

13:34 not the silence then the gasp lmao 💀

[@TacTar]

13:34 woah there Link 😳

[@S.Shea2432]

Rhett, & Links obsession/addiction to Peanut Butter. 🤣🤣

[@danaewright1069]

i know we tell y’all this all the time but i’m so happy to continue to “grow old” with y’all, thanks for being you and putting it on the internet🖤🖤

[@AARONANCE]

11:09 Rhett dissing the Dollar Store is blasphemy 😂

[@stacylynn1821]

I love how Emily gets into character every time! She does such a good job!!💖

[@PtxXtp]

How can they have butterfinger and not have 5th avenue? If you like butterfingers, try 5th avenue bars. They’re like a butterfinger but so much better. The chocolate and the inside.

[@jimmyhennessey3658]

the whole sequence about 8th grade starting at 13:13 😂😂😂 these guys make me laugh like nothin else

[@givejah610]

i am so happy they brought LTAT back. I've missed it so much!

[@chickita2008]

Ugh. I LOVE Emily and her characters.

[@solanuskc4303]

Good mythical morning!!!

[@zatchstar90]

"good afternoon, good evening, and good... nut" haha. the emphasis on nut was funny

[@TheEnlightenedVoice]

The intro was amazing 😂😂😱😱🔥🔥

[@I_Drop_Mythics]

You know Rhett, and Link woke up like 2 kids on Christmas knowing that they were doing a peanut butter taste test.

[@vargkvinnan]

Me, seeing a new food related episode: "Yesss!" Me, seeing Emily in this new food related episode: "YESSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS!"

[@_sch_eme_]

Sameeee this was so good i needed it today lmao

[@ashleygosse13]

The peanut butter m&ms are my absolute favourites. They are SOOOOO good!!!! I usually relate to Link all the time but definitely not with that😂

[@Tennisplayer123]

No Reese’s in the final?!?! What alternative universe are we in right now

[@Tiffanyhall556]

I would have put the Reese’s outrageous in place of the butterfinger 👍🏼

[@ervintester1168]

The temporary Reese's big cup with caramel was awesome

[@lolitslisa562]

It’s temporary? Noooooo it’s so good

[@IrisEscobar]

Yes! I love the result!!! 🎉

[@guccii_daddyy]

Watching GMM calms my anxiety in the morning. Thank yall so much 🙏🏼

[@Henchman1977]

I'm team Rhett but slowly rotating Link is funny AF.

[@HelloSydney97]

It’s not a competition dear

[@BackstreetsAngel7]

The pb gutter = aaaaaaaah!!! 😂

[@Jo3.b.1]

Much Love Mythical ones, and MTFBWY!

[@slabsofdabs6585]

Love gettin fried and watching this in the morning

[@shake9662]

haha same exact morning right now

[@mitchellhill4851]

Evening on my end, but samesies 9:20pm

[@k47w]

lowlife

[@k47w]

lowlife@@shake9662

[@_sch_eme_]

Oof hugs everyone. Keep strong! You got this shite.

[@d.m.badger2155]

I'm sorry, but how did ICE CREAM win in a CANDY tournament??!

[@HelloSydney97]

It’s not ice cream tho. It’s peanut butter cookie dough

[@WiryTripleDs]

​@@HelloSydney97 It is meant to be frozen so I don't see it as a candy

[@defnotisaiah3210]

best birthday present was this peanut butter episode totallllly all for me :)

[@snap3hunt3r]

Two Jacob's and two Bailey's. I'm one of those Jacobs!! We made it!! :)

[@benwaymire1594]

they’re living my dream 😟

[@mistermleko4256]

It's kind of insensitive of Rhett to make "flat" jokes, they're probably insecure about it already 13:31

[@MissPoland77]

That’s a good idea for merch!!!! The Good Ol’ Peanut Butter Boys! or just ‘The Peanut Butter Boys!’ P.B.B!!!! 🥜😂😉 just a thought. Love you guys!

[@goodlookinghost8364]

Best way to decompress after a 12 hour shift ❤

[@nefarious8066]

The butterfinger cups are fire in their own way tbh

[@nellutterback]

the what now?

[@rebekahtyler7693]

The Reece's with potato chips is my favorite

[@weakw1ll]

1:55 LMFAOOOO I am jumping up and down

[@keastep8797]

Butterfinger is WAY better than Ben and Jerry's.

[@vitapuniskyte2552]

This is Rhett and Links best day!

[@dontknowjack596]

Emily is always a joy to watch and lsugh with.

[@Queen_of_Hearts-Sharnell]

She’s the “it” girl.

[@BoilingKoolaid]

Thank you, Emily, for existing! You are great!

[@rachelnorton9394]

Pb m&ms are pretty dang amazing. I can't believe the classic went away so quick!

[@Frosty-xf9wp]

however many likes this comment gets ill eat 1 jar of peanut butter

[@Justmeokbob]

Liar

[@TexasCoffeeBeans]

Nice try

[@markkamara6360]

No do a push up

[@1nonlybadass]

Video proof or it didn't happen

[@BlyatGaming17]

Stop begging for likes

[@jasonmanuel509]

Reese’s Pieces for the win!

[@roofdogblues7400]

Love them Reese's Pieces Eggs!

[@used2jimnasiumm]

favorite episode by far 😭😭😭

[@mikeydix1999]

Rhett’s March Madness intros are goated 😂🐐

[@ytst0rm448]

GOOD MORNINGG!!!’

[@kmjc1213]

I'm convinced that Link had to say he didn't like Peanut Butter M&Ms just so they could have a tie breaker in the episode. Peanut Butter M&Ms are perfect.

[@MelissaMasters]

14:01 not Link roasting himself 😂

[@YouAKoolCat]

Man, I still really love these guys!

[@rockinserge]

Cookie dough bites are always grainy. Butterfinger should've won round 1

[@jessj2530]

I haven’t had that experience with those

[@walmartsucks1995]

rhett's energy at the beginninf was too aggressive for any morning ever