Peanut Butter Ice Cream Tournament (Taste Test)

[@TwoBirdsASMR]

I was thinking Rhett and Link should have their own Ben and Jerry's flavour... although it would probably just be a pint of straight peanut butter...

[@EveryTimeIDavid]

Peanut butter with pb ribbons.

[@charcs_7624]

No cause this collab fits them so well

[@MommaMcMillz1]

@@EveryTimeIDavidpeanut butter ice cream with ribbons and pb cups 😝🤘🏽

[@PeanutButterFLs]

Chocolate base, peanut butter swirl, chocolate chip cookie dough without the chips 😂

[@b3dubbs72]

@@PeanutButterFLspeanut butter cookie dough

[@kenlangston3451]

I wish they had added a fourth category like say cereal so they could have a Final Four.

[@doughnutboy4209]

I agree

[@louishoey]

2 big brain idea😅.

[@owlfurever]

Missed opportunity

[@CreativeCarrah]

Would've been a good way to advertise their cereal again too since it'd be a cereal related video.

[@katesiebert39]

Or peanut butter entrees. There is a lot of main courses with peanut butter!

[@Haldir17]

Rhett’s opening monologue’s have been overlooked! They’re awesome! It takes some skill to do that!

[@lindathomas3142]

💯

[@pauletteplatt5109]

All 3 finalists mixed together would be so good

[@nickpurdy69]

Oooo if you blended them all up with some milk into a shake...omg

[@mistypedhi]

Should be the Rhett and Link peanut butter boyz ice cream. All 3 pb contest winners combined : mini pb cups, pb cookie dough and pb ribbons in chocolate based ice cream with nutterbutter cookie bits. Boom.

[@davidmoore349]

Not having Tillamook Chocolate Peanutbutter is a crime.

[@JoshMoorin]

This is a fact, they need to redo the video lol

[@Kitkat-bk8pe]

Now I'm going to have to try it! I love peanut butter 😋

[@tdiens420420]

My first thought that's my favorite by far.

[@nautygoesdeep]

If you look at the Sporked picture, it looks like its in the front, so they didn't vote it in.

[@DrDarkheart]

You can see they tried it in the first photo

[@Crunchatize_Me_Senpai]

Those cookie dough bites are delicious but in no world can edible cookie dough be categorized as candy, that round was so botched.

[@ash2marie]

Yessss my husband and I have been griping about this too

[@PadawanOfChrist]

Yup!!

[@marianarobles7735]

They're literally trail mix, they belonged to the snack category not candy.

[@jessewalks]

The peanut butter boyz continue their peanut butter takeover

[@JonO387]

They know nothing about peanut butter.

[@Just_Being_Honest]

@@JonO387How so?

[@Pappagiotto]

how did you not do a standard peanut butter taste test? missed opportunity

[@Bardock_UI]

They did one years ago for Link's birthday.

[@jasonmcgill3904]

Go to Sporked

[@TheNetflixNook]

That does feel like a strange oversight 😂

[@JuliaDouglasLove]

I think Sporked did it

[@MuffinCandle]

link Definitely smells the ice cream and then looks at Rhett to see if he saw it. 19:17

[@Random_Canadian00001]

He smelt the poop

[@zarazen8110]

Yep, he always tries to cheat his way but Rhett is RHETT. He always wins.

[@Superf1ex_]

Link: “you’re gonna regRHETT this”💀

[@BipolarGremlin]

18:37

[@Mr.February]

When Rhett said, "I've struck gold" with the peanut butter ribbons in the Häagen-Dazs... I felt that. 4:06

[@JaaronBrice]

0:47 Rhett's spitting! 😂

[@Oakbeetle]

HELPPP

[@erinumm1916]

He gave it his all ❤😂

[@matthewdarnell1183]

It's not reeeses failing the I've cream its breyers, their ice cream just isn't good comparatively to most brands

[@bubbledoubletrouble]

Arguably it _is_ Reese's failing for continuing to partner with Breyers

[@niseplank4527]

I'm so old, I remember when Breyer's wasn't bad

[@omegamkx588]

Breyer’s is just watery and meh. But at least it isn’t Turkey Hill, that stuff is straight nasty

[@appleprincess101]

Nothing hurts quite like seeing your go-to ice cream getting banished

[@Jamekiwi]

Right? But I have to remember they weren’t rating it on how much they like it. 😂

[@1coolcado]

PB & J vs PB on celery and PB on a pretzel and other “classic” Peanut butter snacks.

[@salacommander2674]

PB&J. No competition.

[@hannahcollins1816]

Ordered my triple-signed cookbook this morning!! So excited🎉😊

[@bridgetcook6773]

For once, Link's logic is actually more logical than Rhett's? Love that for him.

[@cashmoneycockburn9502]

Link takes pride in his peanut butter 😂

[@brettbass6742]

Agreed, I feel like the ice cream was a big upset

[@thomziq]

"it's dippable" - this is very important to Link :P:P

[@Rayan.7]

Watching this while fasting 😗

[@anthonyk247]

how fast?

[@JustMamba]

​@@anthonyk247must be pretty fast because the video was just posted.

[@Naynaymikay]

Ramadan mubarak! I've been watching GMM during suhor and my "lunch" breaks at work.

[@literallypickled]

ramadan mubarak 🩷

[@jrbarnett2453]

That must have some tantric implications there! Lol

[@jessallaround13]

Ok, but did you know there are DOUBLE STUFFED Nutter Butters???? They are perfect.

[@joddle23]

i plan to buy some immediately!

[@sharons9221]

O.M.G. 😍

[@ryanlamont5669]

Sad to see that Tillamook chocolate peanut butter wasn't a contender 😂

[@sukai121]

One of my faves! Always in the freezer

[@USMCRL]

I’ve never had Tillamook, Ben and Jerry’s or Häagen-Dazs ice cream😂. Literally not a single flavor of any of them have touched my tongue

[@matthewdonovan5569]

The best.

[@Dro210]

@@USMCRLsame m

[@BadAcidStudios]

😊

[@critical.19]

0:46 there we go again 😂

[@kristinecolebank5084]

And part 3 begins!! Yay!! I’ve been home the past 3 days in extreme pain from a torn muscle, and can’t sleep. This always perks me up. And makes me smile.

[@USMCRL]

Pain is weakness leaving your body😂

[@lindamorrison9755]

Prayer for a rapid healing

[@eb5x_789]

Feel better soon, beastie ❤

[@strasznyy]

I’ve been home bc my Crohn’s disease is flaring up badly :( here’s to swift healing for both of us 🤞

[@kristinecolebank5084]

Oh dear that’s not good!! :( quick recovery to you as well!!!

[@jenerehunte7310]

As someone who absolutely hates peanut butter, the past three days have been interesting to experience.

[@susucattayls4679]

I love PB, just not touching anything but bread! Or sitting on a Ritz cracker.

[@melbapeach162]

As a vegan who is also not American.. I feel like you're getting a taste of my experience watching them taste things I have no real opinion of 😅

[@zippyxann]

I’m semi allergic so if I have too much it feels like I’m eating peanut butter tooth paste 😢 tingly stinging on any food that takes the flavor away from it

[@lifedealwithit2759]

As someone who is naturally selected a.k.a allergic to nuts, I would love to see a video of them reviewing peanut butter substitutes given that they are the peanut butter boys.

[@TakenTook]

That is a very good idea!

[@emilystorm8624]

Thisssss ^^

[@smo202]

Double stuffed Nutter Butter cookies are even better...so good.

[@jhardman1876]

What does Giant Deborah think about the Little Debbie's placement in this tournament?

[@drawingfreak9936]

Rhett’s intro was impressive 😮

[@PhobosPlace]

im only a minute and half into the video and im liking it just for that intro of rhetts.

[@itsatrap8476]

The Reese’s disrespect in this tournament is unreal!

[@k7l3rworkman97]

💯Facts

[@CactusJohn5]

Reese in the US is so bad these days, it is NOTHING like it used to be. It doesn't deserve to be in the top of anything these days.

[@lisajackson5134]

Yes, and, They chose LITE, only on both Reeses brand, not a fair comparison like it was done on purpose

[@Awarevv0lf]

It might be 5am where I am.. But dang I want ice cream now. 😅

[@memelitteredgames4960]

Missed opportunity to call it the ‘beezlebubs tub’

[@sinandtonic2029]

I was thinking "beelzetub"

[@bilowik123]

In the northeast we have Stewart’s and Peanut Butter Pandemonium is by far my favorite peanut butter ice cream across the board. Little peanut butter cups, peanut butter ribbons, and smooth vanilla base that doesn’t detract from the peanut butter and some chocolate swirls as well so it’s not just one note but lets the peanut butter still shine

[@Marykarnett]

Oh my gosh I was going to say this! But I’m from Ohio and only went to school up there for a couple years hahaha that was my favorite Stewart’s flavor!

[@silverblaze1995]

I wish they would try Turkey Hill ice cream...so good. Their chocolate peanut butter flavor is amazing.

[@AustralianPhenomena]

You had me at peanut butter ice-cream!

[@tazman474]

Rhett loves the peanut butter ribbons, yet, Tillamook peanut butter isnt part of this. It has so much peanut butter ribbon in it. 4 Ben and Jerry flavors and one of them isnt really a peanut butter flavor, C'mon. Tillamook and Haagen-daz are the best in my opinion.

[@kaboomer]

I miss the OG munch madness. They should redo it since it’s been years

[@samanthabarratt9953]

Please do an Easter egg tournament and get the cast to do an Easter egg hunt. For GMmore, talk hidden Easter eggs in films :)

[@Digigames17]

Yessss good morning y’all

[@shawnamchugh272]

Great show. I love the tournaments. Cinabon has a lot of products now. If you guys read this somehow please do a Cinabon tournament

[@josephgadsby-haner6608]

I LOVE that the tie breaker involved using actual tasting skill. It allowed Rhett’s superior palate to make the final (and correct) call

[@KieraPerkins-pk1fu]

Throwing a mythical party featuring 3 courses from the new cookbook and modified versions of my favorite games! I cant wait!! :)

[@willsmith6779]

Why not just eat peanut butter with a spoon? Nothing would beat that by their logic lol

[@atriix]

The BEST peanut butter ice cream I’ve ever had is Hudsonville Triple Peanut Butter Cup. It’s a peanut butter flavored ice cream with peanut butter swirls and peanut butter cups. It has such a good, strong flavor and always hits the spot when I’m craving peanut butter 🤤

[@niseplank4527]

Oh, my goodness, we have that here!!!

[@wilsonkelman986]

Links logic in the last round is crazy

[@ellis.paul.]

its 6:40 am and im making pasta. i have yet to sleep but good mythical morning! love you guys!!!!

[@rhythmdivine2]

8:32 "I have a butt. im not gonna tell you until we taste it" LOL

[@shantibelike4355]

This video is so silly 😂love it

[@MonsterBurn74]

Dang all the best peanut butter stuff lost in these competitions 🫠

[@oofmydude8173]

I feel ya but I think they're selecting more for what tastes the most like peanut butter, not the overall best tasting

[@zgillet]

​@@oofmydude8173Nutter Butter tastes nothing like peanut butter

[@oofmydude8173]

@@zgillet i know but that was link and emely deciding really, and i really like both of them, but link is inconsistent and emely probably was just like "ooh these are tasty" and not thinking about it like they have been

[@mr.bluesky1735]

Idk that Hagan daaz is my absolute favorite

[@mitchelltheawesome1]

13:59 might be the coldest moment in GMM history.

[@erics2091]

What did you have for breakfast today? Peanut Butter Ice Cream! And lots of it!

[@Clanmackenzie]

Jeni’s salted peanut butter with chocolate flecks is truly the best peanut butter ice cream. I worked there for 6 years and ate at least a bite of that every day and never got tired of it

[@madlad85]

Good Morning Mythical!

[@h7opolo]

Link's shirt reminds me of a visual I intuited while metabolizing a particular tryptamine.

[@Kristene.L]

Good Mythical Morning🙃🙂

[@EttoyaN]

I haven't watched the last two episodes yet because I was waiting very anxiously for the third installment so I can watch them all in succession lol

[@inzane2427]

Good morning mythical beasts!!!

[@sthrnbll2u65]

Ok so all of this peanut butter stuff made me crave. So i have now bought a jar of peanut butter, a box of nutty buddy, an reeses peanut butter pretzels

[@allisonchains174]

Love the tournament episodes!

[@draghag]

I just got my copy of the Mythical Cookbook ❤❤❤❤❤❤ i absolutely love it and this morning my kids and i made Fruity Pebble Pancakes!!! Thanks Chef Josh🎉🎉🎉

[@Coinable]

Good morning Mythical Beasts!

[@Alteronx]

As a peanut butter lover, these recent vids have given me joy

[@gechuzhao2178]

I don't know if it's available in the US but Haagen Dazs' peanut butter crunch is so much better than the peanut butter chocolate, it is all about the PB, PB ice cream with PB ribbons and crunchy whole peanut

[@runawayfaeIX]

Okay, I'm on board with that... 🤤

[@Attickyy]

For fellow peanut butter fans in the comments See’s Candies has really good Peanut Butter Bites that taste like a warm pb cookie. Enjoy!

[@noahsmith5719]

18:29 “I don’t want the tie breaker either!!” He said, trying very hard to justify the tie breaker 😂

[@Nephu.]

Love this series - a peanut butter lover

[@Various_forms_of_Doormamu]

Is this the first series of tournaments that the number one seed has always lost? It feels like it is.

[@AdrianRobles19]

Sometimes I miss GMM episodes but I never miss the March Madness of KZbin! 😤😤💪🏼

[@jackie3429]

peanut butter madness really is going on strong!

[@its_tend_o]

7:48 - Link I see you looking at the audience for some validation here - I gotchu my crunchy boo.

[@Acepilot8Gaming]

Goooooood mythical morninnnnnng everyone

[@overdose420]

i’m so glad that the häagen-daz chocolate peanut butter got some love in this episode cause that was mine and my dad’s favorite when i was little, still love it to this day too. We’d always have a problem with trying not to eat the entire container. the Tillamook one is so good as well being a very similar make and it’s just soooo good. They got my vote on that one.

[@ItsKimOlson]

I need to know Sporked's reasoning, because R&L's Top 2 were the 7 & 8 seed.

[@Driffguy]

I really, really, really, love Rhett's commitment to this thing 😅

[@majorbigtime]

This was the perfect episode for Moochelle to return from the afterlife via the bucket and be in charge of the bracket board. 😢

[@gteddywap6555]

every tie breaker i just go with rhetts decision lol

[@muhammadwahyuhidayat21498]

Happy Friday in March Madness of Peanut butter snacks edition!!! This is final match!!!

[@Patexer]

EXCUSE ME??? Reese’s ice cream with chocolate swirl is elite

[@lisajackson5134]

The big mistake they made, only both reeses were LITE, so whoever shopped only bought LITE for the Reeses. Not a fair test for them. We need to write in.

[@Sleepingsparklegirl]

Should of had Klondike Reese bar.

[@erinerinbobearin]

These are SO good, thank you for reminding me of them!!

[@SpaceMetal3]

Rhetts intro is my absolutely fav part of this series!

[@mjwtruth]

This is the round the Ben and Jerry bites should've been in

[@wbennin]

Agree to disagree. Cookie dough is not ice cream

[@mjwtruth]

@wbennin not inherently but it was a frozen treat. It shouldn't have been in candy

[@marianarobles7735]

No, they should have been on the snack category because they're pretty much a trail mix.

[@chipclampitt3596]

Rhett putting in some Work! You go boooyyyyy🎉

[@ZombieFarmboy666]

Fasting this while watching 😮

[@Justtriedandhurgry]

Good mythical morning everyone ❤️😁🌞~!

[@youdontneedtoreadthis]

Wait, you're choosing the most pb forward and not the best tasting? How does that make any sense?

[@erinerinbobearin]

Because it’s the peanut butter tournament, not ice cream

[@youdontneedtoreadthis]

@erinerinbobearin exactly, I thought they were choosing the peanut butter snack that is the best. That's what they said - best pb snack tournament lol

[@JKane1281]

Rhett doing that intro is in my top 3 favorite things of Mythical lol

[@mellybelly5334]

Why is there so much Ben and Jerry's when there are so many other amazing brands?

[@jakereese845]

I love how Links glasses have changed and I just roll with it bc he has looked good in every pair

[@TheOfficialKeon]

Ben & Jerry’s for the win to me.

[@brettbass6742]

Of the 3, i think yall made the right choice in the end. I will also say that may be bc the Ice Cream and Candy rounds were big upsets imo.

[@bree4174]

Honestly the best is turkey hill. Basically frozen PB!

[@laurorrichie7788]

Turkey Hill is so good I love their cookie dough ice cream

[@jaredransom]

Good Afternoon, Good Evening, Good Pint….it was right there!! 😂

[@mohdbassam]

Ramadan Mubarak

[@kayesdigginit1519]

Lol Rhett is using a serving spoon and Link has tea spoon 😂 Rhett is really making sure to get those good sized bites in 😂😂

[@danihellings5508]

I am so mad at especially Link for not taking a stand for Reeses. These guys lucky I love em so much and that I was still around for good mythical chia Lincoln

[@lisajackson5134]

THE CRAZY THING IS, WHY DID THEY ONLY DO LITE ON BOTH REESES BRANDS, ITS ALMOST LIKE IT WAS ON PURPOSE. I WAS UPSET. WHOEVER BOUGHT THEM ONLY BOUGHT LITE FOR REESES.

[@oh_kay2954]

I can’t believe bassets peanut butter swirl wasn’t here 💔 it’s just delicious vanilla ice cream with ribbons of yummy peanut butter. It’s so good.

[@ashleymarkulin1663]

Last night I had a dream that Link got a tattoo(?)/engraving on his front two teeth that said “I eat ass, it’s 2024.” Just wanted to share.

[@h7opolo]

3:15 "gobs"

[@jasmineminor325]

that’s what the label says

[@benhaselhuhn4512]

I feel like they rig it to have a tie breaker no matter what. There’s no way link chose B&J over Hag after all that talk

[@directorjake]

I find it hard to believe knowing that the crew has their own predictions going on for what Rhett and Link will choose.

[@troginator]

Not even he admitted he liked that one better but he said the other one had more peanut butter which is the point of the vid

[@fashionablechangeling2003]

It is very suspicious that every single one of this tournament videos has a tie-breaker of some kind

[@Joaquin-xq5wo]

@@directorjakei also felt that last time as well. Like idk the way they have to have a tie breaker is kinda seen

[@raybeaudry463]

Have you guys never watched link before this is totally happening 😂

[@jazlynmanning8326]

The best thing I love about this tournament has been being from Vermont (born and raised) Love B&J🖤🖤