Penrose Conference Field Trip - Western Idaho Shear Zone

[@bryanbradford2742]

Here we are, in the mountains of Idaho - observing a group of geologists in their natural habitat😊

[@qcislander]

Strangely... no territorial or mating behavior is observed (well, not demonstrated, at least). :-)

[@stephenshort839]

It's GREAT to see so many minds coming together to share the knowledge and experiences with each other.

[@loveistheanswer8137]

Very interesting. The geologists are very articulate in explaining their theories. Thanks for bringing us along Nick.

[@yukigatlin9358]

👀Wow, This IS you, Nick!😃✨💛Excellent interviews, awesome outcrops!! I can feel your joy of recording this fieldtrip. I can tell the joy from the reactions of the geologists whom you were interviewing... Just so natural!!💗✨Forget the Starlink, this is YOU, Nick!!😘✨💗Thank you for inviting us, wow!!

[@vinmansbakery]

Gene Humphries was impressive in the way he wanted to get his views to work with others. Sounds like there was a lot of that going around. Thanks for sharing this!

[@Siletzia]

Yes, that was impressive. The openness and willingness to listen to other ideas and incorporate where possible seems to be at the root of this conference. Basil is a rock star for that.

[@Ponderosa5678]

What a delightful afternoon. Thanks to the geologists willing to share their insights and their work with humor. Great interview, Nick.

[@richardstephens3642]

WOW that shear zone is amazingly beautiful

[@timroar9188]

A lot of hand and arm communication. It is amazing how they can tell a story just looking at the rock. Very interesting. Lovely rocks. Thank you for posting.

[@Poppageno]

#1 like! Very Impressive! Thanks Nick, some beautiful country.......

[@catherineleslie-faye4302]

Lovely rocks & good people... I so want to attend one of these conferences.

[@TheBobservations]

yes. thanks to you all for your contributions and insights, and thanks to you Nick.

[@SShellbee]

can’t wait to travel this path, thank you to all who made this destination available to those who follow

[@robertfarrimond3369]

Thanks Nick, Looks like it was a very successful conference !!

[@sharonseal9150]

Great fun to see the geologists out in the field, and to actually see a portion of the Western Idaho Sheer Zone! What a joy it is to see people passionate about their profession, curious minds together trying to read the pages of stone. Thank you for sharing the field trip with us Nick!

[@jamest2101]

They are so excited...

[@Rachel.4644]

It's just fascinating to see geologists reading the complicated rocks! It's exciting to know the participants want to learn and find ways to resolve the conundrums of this model. Such diverse knowledge all in one spot; it's major kudos to Basil, Stacia and Ellen for the tone of the conference. And you, Nick, for making it possible for us to be a part of it all and learn, too. This in-the-field component is so enticing! Thank you so much.

[@mikeweeks4669]

Thanks again Nick.

[@douginorlando6260]

I did not realize geology as a profession has so many types of specialization. I liked how the geologists work together to piece geologic history together; each one bringing something special to the table, sometimes from their knowledge of the rocks in Alberta, sometimes from their knowledge of a technique. For example, seeing in action how someone who’s an expert in magnetic field lines frozen in rocks can offer key clues to the overall story. It never occurred to me these outcroppings could have anything to do with supervolcanoes but with the right specialization, the eye sees a massive quantity of lave/magma was required and how to tell if it all happened at the same time, which is similar to what’s required for a super volcano. Nick: you must have a million things in mind as topics but here’s two more to consider. 1st… An overview of the different specializations in the field of geology, what’s involved in each and how they all work together to corroborate a more complete consistent story. 2nd… An overview of the different techniques used to date rocks and events, and an overview of the techniques used to identify rocks/formations occurred from the same event that formed another distant rocks/formation

[@paulbugnacki7107]

This field trip is amazing. Hearing from so many talented people is pretty special. Thank you for letting us tag along.

[@Siletzia]

Ericka's work on the Gold Beach terrane in Oregon should be fascinating. Looking forward to the results on that project.

[@mrtony1985]

Been a while. Did a hike across Spain this summer. Got a lot of catching up to do on my Zentner content. 😅

[@5USgRWFH]

The humility of these knowledgeable people is really a testament to their love of our natural world.

[@wendygerrish4964]

Very impressive, and great to listen to the interactions and ideas being juggled around.

[@sandythixton4611]

That was absolutely awesome and fascinating! And yes, you have a true talent for bringing out relevant and important information during an interview.

[@colleennobbs7218]

Wow! This was amazing. The energy was wonderful. Thank you Nick for taking us along and letting us see and hear. Looking forward to see how the information coalesces in the future. Thank you so much Nick. 🎉❤

[@redskybeach]

Thank you, Nick, for creating a spark with me that led to a serious interest in geology. You get the credit for creating sort of an obsession in me for finding answers to why in both the observable and that cause and effect that is the essence of geology.

[@tadpolefarms631]

Atta Boy Nick. I am embarrassed to say how long it takes me to get to the end of your tapes; I must stop watching to Google new words, technical phrases and the like. What an interesting learning path you are leading us on!

[@WyldHorseValley]

How great to spend an hour with you Nick, the illuminating company of these specialists and some really twisted rocks! I was hoping you'd have a chance to catch-up with Erin Donaghy and what she's up to. Hope her PHD is going well - she was always a great guest on your channel.

[@bernadettelamarca591]

Hello from Marysville.

[@dippyanddakota]

Nick you are blowing my mind again!!! Keep it up!

[@grandparocky]

Thanks for this installment which we can all experience!

[@robertwhite6939]

Cool rocks. Nicely done.

[@fernie5128]

This makes me so happy NIck. To see so many folks engaged, coming from all over, to continue the discussion and exploration of Baja-BC! I wonder if you knew, oh so long ago, when you were first thinking about Baja-Bc, that one day you would be meeting with interested people in Western Idaho. Can't wait for more. Cheers!

[@Outdoors901]

Love this stuff Nick. I am not a geologist nor do I have any affiliation with the work, but I find the work fascinating and the enthusiasm infectious. Thank you for doing what you do.

[@glenncarr1947]

This interview is fascinating! Wow!

[@GregInEastTennessee]

That was really super, Nick! There really is a sense of comradery there. It's great to network, meet new folks, and exchange ideas. Kind of gives us an idea of how geology really works. Thanks for you effort! 😀

[@craighoover1495]

Thank you. Most gratifying to see what has been referred to.

[@runninonempty820]

Wonderful job, Nick. So much to absorb, I just may have to watch this one again!

[@jscottmaclean226]

Hi Nick, can't wait

[@pmgn8444]

Thx Nick and Basil for letting us in! What do you call a big group of geologists? A Lode! 🤣

[@DonnaCsuti-ji2dd]

Wow quite impressive and very interesting thanks for letting us be a fly on the wall so to speak. That was fun

[@OdinsChosen208]

idaho geology is amazing and just driving through it seems like every 20 minutes the landscape changes

[@Grantos1ea]

A geology conference in the raw. Unraveling the mysteries in beautiful country. All in pleasant company.

[@johnjunge6989]

The folds and rocks are beautiful and so much better than any I have seen. Makes Maine, NH, and NY look simplistic that I saw while traveling. Great stuff. Makes me wish I could be a Fly on the Wall there.

[@johnplong3644]

What I see here..I see a lot of Extremely Intelligent people who are all about the per suit of knowledge trying to figure out what has happened .What is the story there All are seeking answers to an e credibility complex subject.I am able to follow along only because I watch the BaJa BC series A-Z I have also have learned basic geology from Nick’s teaching the last 3 years.I also have a greater appreciation for these spectacular beautiful places .Leaning something like geology was and is completely new to me .I am 65 A person is never to old to learn something new and get a new passion.For myself geology is my new passion.I get excited about this stuff.I also have a passion for history Geology tell the history of this planet ..This is great stuff .

[@djenebasidibe468]

"Stripy Zebra" is definitely a new favorite on my best technical terms list. Absolutely loving it. :) Such a wonderful atmosphere, it really seemed like quite a nice crowd to hang around with :) :) - thanks Nick for taking us along part of the journey. Reminds me of quite some conferences and workshops I attended during my time at university. And the one person in your video (I forgot his name) was definitely right: the smaller ones are the better ones, because it's easier to connect with people. Often you get to talk with more people at a smaller conference than at a big one which might seem contradictory at first. So thanks again, Nick, for uploading

[@briane173]

Blown away by the geomorphology there. Gorgeous area and a gorgeous specimen. Part of what makes what you're doing so important is that you get to listen to the pros and the students and it peels away the common stereotype of scientists and students as nerdy Poindexters with no social skills who aren't comfortable anywhere but in front of a microscope. I'm drawn to brilliant people, whether academics or not, just by virtue of their ability to process mountains of data in their minds and formulate a plausible story that can be defended by the data in front of them. But just as important is seeing these brilliant people as _approachable,_ confident yet modest, who have a human sense of what matters and can connect with anyone regardless of their intellect or education. That matters to people like me who perhaps _aren't_ as "social" or "sociable" or even as intelligent, but still enjoy the company of people with the street cred to defend a different POV without being sanctimonious. The community you're building exemplifies this and it's good for the profession and good for the school, at a time when post-secondary ed has an image problem driven mostly by politics and corporate group-think. Important to show that there's still important work going on behind all the BS and baloney taking place.

[@noelwade]

THANK YOU to all of the scientists and researchers who agreed to talk on-camera! Its awesome to see and hear experts express what they know, as well as admit what isn't known (i.e. that there are mysteries and puzzles still out there for people to work on solving). It takes courage to be on-camera, and to be raw/open on the spur-of-the-moment; but its inspiring for both the general public and for potential future geologists!

[@davec9244]

GOOD JOB, ALL thank you stay safe

[@jamest2101]

WOW, just wow. So many very knowledgeable people working together from so many different directions to answer the questions on our planet, how it got to where it is now, what were the processes, are they finished, is there more that is not being seen... wow

[@oscarmedina1303]

Wow. Just wow! It's great to watch science in progress.... the interaction of brilliant minds. Thank you for bringing us along.

[@sdmike1141]

Nick, I had to watch this twice, just to sort out new terminology. The rocks!! Wow! On my second time through,I noticed that you had Karen Sigloch and Steven Johnston in frame while while doing a great interview with Ellen Nelson. Wow!! This could be your best work! Thanks Nick.

[@t48wolf]

THANK YOU, Nick, AND ALL SO MUCH!!! Just outstanding seeing the openness and cooperative thinking Mother Nature has given you all a real puzzle to unravel, and it will take losts of inputs from many brilliant minds to figure it out.

[@johnnash5118]

There must be seismic tomography with enough resolution to resolve the makeup of what’s between the Siletz Terrane and the .706 line in WA and OR under the CFB plain. I suspect meta-oceanic Terranes similar to or connecting the Klamath and Blue Mtn. Terranes.

[@AKUSUXs]

I lived In Idaho all my life, Southern, Eastern, Western and now Northern. My favorite areas are Central and East Central, Idaho. I will never look at this area the same! I have just a little geology knowledge KZbin Geology😂 from watching channels like yours. It would be very interesting to just be around groups like this and just listening.

[@ziggstah5307]

WOW those rocks are crazy cool

[@peacenow4456]

Excellent interactions and so nice to see the geologists come together to answer their questions and learn from each other, best of all to have you to record and share w us.

[@katemcclain8405]

Awesome and so satisfying to be in on this working out of our geo story! What a gift!

[@bearbait49]

I worked on the WISZ in the mid 80’s and have a bit of core left from building the dam at Orofino. So incredibly jealous of you guys on this trip and how far our collective understanding has come. Thank you for sharing.

[@time2getwise-b2v]

I especially like hearing the geologists talk about the rock outcrops and what they were seeing in them.

[@PaulHigginbothamSr]

Wow your final speaker was the one who put this all together. Very low key person who was studying exactly the right area and stress deformation zone to lead all these people to look and wonder why the devil is all this exactly 91 million years old. Baja BC. Tut tut Nick, no way and this magma was down deep being stretched from the side then turned in compression. Heavens to Betsy.

[@pennynealeigh6557]

WOW!!!

[@TarisSinclair]

Awesome collection of moments and interviews!

[@wesmahan4757]

I felt like a fly on the wall. (Though I'm not a fly, and the wall is more like a "floor"!!) Wonderful stuff.

[@geoffgeorges]

Great video Nick, content, well done editing, great visits with geologists, I am so grateful to be allowed into this world. Did I have a Erin D. Sighting?

[@mikepallister3037]

Blessed for being allowed into your community

[@laurafolsom2048]

I’m so busy in summer that I can’t watch videos like I do in winter. I miss the leisure time that winter provides. I look forward to everyone on line again in a couple months.

[@fallinginthed33p]

So the WISZ also contains remnants of the magmatic fireworks from Siletzia's subduction and accretion? This sounds like a good video topic by itself.

[@kdubate1974]

I love listening to and learning from smart people. Nick, you're literally the Neil de Grasse Tyson of Geology. Oh ya..On Wisconsin and Go Badgers!

[@davidniemi4051]

Looking at the folding and intrusions starting about 27:00 could their be variable plasticity of the different rock types at depth and temperature? Something like the folding occurred then the temperature or pressure increased such that the intrusions were pretty much liquid which resulted in the other rock type was able to release the folding or other stresses by cracking, thereby allowing the melt to intrude.

[@SCW1060]

I really don't understand the secret sqaurl aspect to this conference I know Nock it's not you but it's our tax and tuition dollars that pays these guys you would think there shouldn't be a problem for us to hear what's going on. There's no problems having so many Geologists on your videos which I really love Thank you for covering what you could

[@geoffgeorges]

I am so grateful for this inside view that would not happen if Nick was not driven to share it. I get what you are saying. But Nick did say the closed format allows the freedom to speak without friction, thus allowing it to be maybe more effective and creative. Just seeing this with Basil speaking made me want to see it all . Maybe Nick can help make these public. The one where he is kinda lurking at Banks lake is great also for it’s insider perspective and insights.

[@iancraigie7033]

Any chance of some GPS co-ordinate for some of those sites - all in the pursuit of geologic observation of course and in no way to be taken as an excuse for a motorcycle ride in the Idaho mountains.

[@deecaputo1480]

This is GREAT!!!

[@OdinsChosen208]

i live in boise and fish up there alot where in the yukon do these rocks match?

[@willbradley7450]

Some people climb mountains for the view. Others climb mountains for the fresh air. Still other folks may climb mountains for protection or for sport or even for spiritual reasons. Geologists climb mountains to look at the rocks. You gotta love 'em~!

[@benwinkel]

Gneiss! And it gets even nicer. But no matter how nice it gets the Lichen don't seem to mind, they like it just the way it is.

[@hestheMaster]

Exposed examples of what Nick was calling "ribbon candy" rock. I took his word for such rock ( very old and under high heat and pressure far beneath the Earth 's surface) until actually seeing a kind of it exposed here in this video from Idaho. Do see that connection from others describing SOME of the folding patterns in the plutonic zone. Of course there are other types of motions to been seen in the rocks so listen to Nick starting at 38:06. Seeing a lot of promise with the newest generation of geologists investigating this particular area from central and western Idaho.

[@eSteve-1]

Geologist Rock!

[@adamcollegeman2]

excellent

[@daltongrowley5280]

Does the accretion of a volcanic arc always cause that weird effect where the plate delaminates because of the new subduction area taking the place of the old and suchlike?

[@JimArnoldPhoto]

I would love to see some thin sections of that igneous rock 27:31

[@FollowerOfClay]

You must have felt like a kid in a knowledge candy store there :)

[@malcolmcog]

Whats the defention of two geologists - A disagreement !

[@nelssorenson5073]

wow, Margi Rushmore knocks it out…mind blown

[@stevenverhaegen8729]

😄 All the geologists talking with their hands 👐😊

[@whitby910]

A 'thank you' (everybody), doesn't seem sufficient.

[@paulbrallier7028]

did you give coordinates for this area?

[@josephkaiser800]

Still with ya. Salmon ID

[@lauram9478]

❤

[@rwilson1125]

OMG Basil has legs.😊

[@ChrisAnnasMom]

😮