Pentatonix - Dance of the Sugar Plum Fairy - Reaction - Incredible arrangement!

[@michellebarry1555]

The members of PTX with their producer Ben Bram (considered the silent sixth member) do the arrangements. Ben has been with them since The Sing Off, he’s a genius!

[@amyerffmeyer4347]

Thnx for info!

[@kathyastrom1315]

Usually, their arrangements are done by the group, and quite often along with Ben Bram, their long-time collaborator and the guy who helped Scott assemble the group (Ben knew Avi and brought him to Scott’s attention, and was also the one who first saw Kevin’s “Julie-O” video and got Kevin’s phone number at Yale). Ben was the one who accepted this Grammy, since the group was in rehearsals for their performance at the televised awards show, an Earth Wind and Fire tribute with Stevie Wonder. There are a few excellent interviews of Ben out there, especially a two-part on a podcast called Recording A Capella.

[@jonathanwetherell3609]

Thanks fort that.

[@perfectkismet]

Ben has also been credited by the group with being the one who convinced Matt to audition.

[@rachelc.9570]

I literally screamed when you paused right before Mitch's note! It's consisted of a WTF NOOOOOOOO

[@susansisson366]

I keep saying this, but it's true. They, themselves, ARE the instruments! And, as others will no doubt tell you, Ben Bram is the sixth, silent, seldom seen, genius, who works with the person or persons, who propose a song. They hash the idea among themselves, play with it, try things out, and come up with the general outline of the song, then Ben comes in and polishes, finishes, and helps them make a masterpiece of each and every song. Others will mention that they won a Grammy for this, a song without words, by a group without instruments, but then again, they themselves are the instruments.

[@_MusicJunkie_]

Someone commented in another reaction video to this song the perfect description. A song with no words done by a group with no instruments(And they won a Grammy for it! That’s all you need to know about Pentatonix to know how amazing they are). Best a cappella group out there

[@elysebaker7368]

Funny Story… Last Saturday I took my 11 year old daughter to the Royal Alberta Ballet performing The Nut Cracker & when Dance of the Sugar Plum Fairy started she said “why are they dancing to Pentatonix?” 😆

[@ronswinford4952]

Take a group with no instruments, and a song with no words, and you get a Grammy performance.

[@keddiewye6517]

Your quote: “This isn’t just a bunch of people who get together and say Let’s Sing a Song.” That means it’s time for you to watch Superfruit, which is Mitch and Scott’s side channel plus Kirstie doing a Frozen Medley pretty much off the cuff in their apartment one night after having a few adult beverages. You will come to understand what they can do “Off the Cuff”.

[@vickipeterson9633]

Love this one! Your reactions are priceless. Avi's operatic and classical training really shine on this one. He sets you up for that major bass drop. And Mitch....love that sassy Mitch. Words? Who needs words? PTX did not foresee this as a problem, only an opportunity. I'm convinced they could sing the dictionary and it would be impressive. As far as Home Free, PTX members and the Home Free group know each other well. Pentatonix won season 3 of the Sing Off and Home Free won season 4. Pentatonix came back on season 4 to mentor Home Free and sing on the finale. Avi and Tim Foust with Home Free are friends and both now live in Nashville.

[@larryshair]

Thanks Vicki! So glad to have you in the group!

[@anessalyn1035]

Please react to my favorite Christmas song by PTX, the first Noel. The look on your face at Mitch's high note and Avi's super low note was priceless.

[@chrispavlich9656]

My favorite too❣️

[@rlhcat7662]

Mine, too!

[@Mahiahtree]

I knew your head would explode! Your reactions are so great. I love watching the joy and surprise on your face. Thank you very much for the reaction, and the shout-out. 💚 You got Mitch-slapped and Avi-attacked in the same song!

[@larryshair]

😊 thank you! They are incredible!

[@celiachristman104]

As has already been stated, Ben Bram is their arranger and co-arranger. If you want to see an interview with him, go to Jacob Restituto's channel (he is also a big PTX reactor) and watch Jacob's interview with Ben Bram.

[@maryparker9426]

They have said that they sit round a phone set to record and just sing a song, throw in everything they think of, then go back and pick out the best bits with Ben. They call it circle jamming. That was in the early days, I'm sure it's more streamlined now

[@jackiestevens-lock8664]

Such a great arrangement. Their talent is astonishing. I love your reactions…your enthusiasm is contagious!!

[@hidesertmusic]

I’ve followed PTX since their inception at “Sing Off”. I’ve watched every single video and listened to each song multiple times. It’s great to watch your honest reactions to just this one song with the original group. Your expressions and the amazement you show at their talent reflects what I feel each and every time I’ve seen and heard them. I hope you follow up and listen to all their music. It will give you, as it did to me, incredible joy.

[@wilmavpijkeren-raayen4482]

Love your reactions and your appreciation for every little detail. You mentioned Bohemian Repsodi?... well if your in for a treat, they covered that one also it's mind blowing 🤯 😉

[@gailseatonhumbert9199]

If you want to look at Homefree start with a "bridge". Avi Kaplan is on their "Ring of Fire" for their first record after Sing-Off to boost the sales by putting Avi on it and it worked for them. The basses were all pretty good friends. Rumor has it that Tim taught Avi the growl technique (or in Europe it is called "fire-breathing") for a couple very low notes for effects - listen or better yet WATCH Pentatonix do "Natural Disaster". Kevin's inspiration initially for the song. Avi, in return, taught overtone singing (also known as Mongolian Throat singing) to Homefree. Avi, Tim and Austin all live in Nashville now which is a very collaborative music scene. Adam Chance, who is Homefree's baritone, was with Streetcorner Symphony prior to Homefree and Avi Kaplan was supported by all of Streetcorner Symphony on his first tour when he began touring again after Pentatonix with his solo music. Kaleb Thomas Jones of Streetcorner Symphony plays bass and sings high tenor in Avi's live appearances and has co-written a couple of songs with Avi that have not yet been released. Another big name in acappella is Peter Hollens. You can find him collaborating with Avi Kaplan on "Black is the Color of My True Love's Hair" with the layering technique Peter uses. He has also collaborated often with Tim Foust (Homefree's bass) and with all of Homefree on a couple of occasions. Avi brought the idea of adapting Dance of the SugarPlum Fairies for acappella performance to Pentatonix. He and Kevin brought more extensive experience in the classical music forms to the band.

[@denisehart7104]

❤Another Grammy winning song is their cover medley for DAFT PUNK. Made at home for $400. You must give it a try ! Thanks for your reactions ! DO check out their GOD REST YE MERRY GENTLEMAN, and also their BOHEMIAN RHAPSODY !!!

[@jonathanwetherell3609]

Some artists need their own scale to be measured by (a Pentatonix Scale?) and on their scale this is near the top! Musically, visually both tops and add in the humor, wow.

[@justlinsu]

Oh Larry I had to quickly go back and rewatch it again...I loved your 'reactions' I had the same one the first time I saw this...lol Brilliant. Loved PTX when Avi was in it. He has a classical background as a Basso Profundo My ear is always tuned into the bass sound. The editing is a visual masterpiece too. Ben Braum and Avi helped form their own A Capella Academy.

[@lorilapid1209]

Great reaction! Funny that you mentioned Queen. Wait until you hear their version of Bohemian Rhapsody!

[@dalebuck7168]

You mention Bohemian Rhapsody...if you haven't seen PTX's cover of it yet...it is the ultimate cover!

[@mikeross641]

Hi there. I'm really enjoying your reactions to Pentatonix, and your journey through their music! My Suggestion for another wintery season one would be their version of "Once Upon A December"

[@Bonofox1]

PENTATONIX IS BRILLIANT this was their 2nd Grammy WIN!!🌟

[@madenabyss6981]

U got mitch slapped now u can see why this won a grammy

[@kiryukaimemorial127]

You mention they look like something out of Bohemian Rhapsody. Can't wait until you get to their cover.

[@SLove84711]

They normally sit in a circle (of sorts) and just jam, throwing out ideas till it sounds the way they like it, then record it into a phone and sends it to Ben “who fine-tunes” or adds a polishing finish for the recording time:-) they did this one live on one of the late night shows and sounds just as good if not better:-) PTX always acknowledges Ben for his talent within the group. They’re a good team!

[@amazinggrace5692]

Watch the “Making of Evergreen” to see some of the recording methods and decision making they do as a group and with their arranger Ben?

[@ambergarner8471]

Yes, Ben Brahm is considered the silent 6th member of PTX and is responsible for arrangements. For something fun and different, check out the video below. It's almost 20 minutes long but is so fun to watch. It's all backstage footage, tour bus, and hotels showing them being silly and working on arrangements. kzbin.info/www/bejne/fZvLlYhnp9Cnpsk

[@patriciajohnson9654]

Made my day again! Needed that. Thank you Chris! 😊 Patti. Have a blessed day!!!

[@Wizzard3921]

A Capella with no words or lyrics ???? Pentatonix "Hold MY BEER !!!!

[@wildapples6549]

Great next reaction! They also won a Grammy for arrangement on Daft Punk...the academy changed the category just so they could be included and they won! They also won a Grammy for a Country collaboration with the fabulous Dolly Parton. Both are MUST watch! Hope all is well with you & yours!

[@alicegibson685]

Arrangements usually done by the group and Ben Bram.

[@xymonau2468]

They arrange them together. All are professionally trained.

[@kayecastleman6353]

I know Ben Bram is their official arranger, but from interviews with the members it seems to be mostly a collaborative effort, especially what songs they take on, who sings which parts, how to organize the harmonies, etc., and ideas for their signature PTX innovations. The group works through those details as an ensemble. I'm not sure how much of that includes Ben, probably different for different songs, but I understand his wizardry is applied most consistently in polishing the final product. From everything we know about PTX, they are a very democratic group, and there's so much musical training and talent in each member, everyone's ideas are valuable. Sometimes you can tell certain songs are more heavily influenced by one member or another. "Dance of the Sugar Plum Fairy" has Avi written all over it!

[@johnrodrigues5974]

They got their 2nd Grammy for this song. The 1st was for Daft Punk. Their 3rd was for Jolene with Dolly Parson.

[@texasgirl907]

Love your reactions. These folks are so talented. Love home free also, especially Love their collaboration with avi kaplan in ring of fire

[@davidphillips4476]

Grammy best Instrumental, then with Dolly Parton Best Duo or Country group Performance, then the "Daft Punk Medley"...crazy talent..my theory stands till disproved.....aliens.

[@sandihannig9836]

Loved your reaction! This video is very similar and fun as Dance of the Sugar Plum Fairy. Enjoy! Pentatonix - God Rest Ye Merry Gentlemen (Official Video) - KZbin

[@MidnightAutoPainter]

Congrats on 10k subs

[@smurfrise]

You should watch the interview between Jacob Restituto and Ben Bram, which answers your questions! Here's the link: kzbin.info/www/bejne/q3XGo4B9oKhkn6c

[@ruthking7884]

I love PTX, but I prefer the ones with Avi....Matt is good...but I still think Avi was better.

[@karenamicarella7036]

Love watching you react to them. I think you just got slapped by all🤣💜

[@АлександраБакульманова-у8п]

Just so you know, Dance of the Sugar Plum Fairy is not a song, but music for one of the dance performances from the classical ballet The Nutcracker by Russian composer Pyotr Tchaikovsky.

[@Eric1SanDiego1]

Noooooo, he paused *just* before he got Mitch-Slapped! But we saw his reaction regardless. I think he's getting used to them now. Cant wait until Daft Punk and Bohemian Rhapsody.

[@hcroussette]

I really hope you do 12 Days of Christmas. One of my favorite PTX Christmas song to watch people react to.

[@BladeCPL]

Hi Larry. Great reaction as always. When you want to back up the track try just hitting the 'LEFT Arrow' once or twice instead of messing with the mouse! May I suggest reacting to what I think of as the sister piece to this track, "God Rest Ye Merry Gentlemen" kzbin.info/www/bejne/oaaaoJuLZq56otU Also there are some very good live versions of this track but the camera work can be dodgy as they tend to jump to Kirstie for the high notes when as we know it is usually Mitch!

[@ecook382]

Another reactor, Jacob Restituto, has an interview with Ben Bram on his KZbin channel. I think you would enjoy hearing Ben talk about the arranging.

[@martinhafner2201]

It depends on the song, but one or two of them will put a song together. The group works it over by voice and gets it close. Then Ben Bram works it over. It may have to cycle around a few times. Daft Punk was written mostly by Kevin and Avi, but I gather Ben Bram did some things to it also. He is referred to as the 6th Pentatonic.

[@diannecardenas9866]

These songs they do without any movement of the body really kills Scott. You notice how he's holding his hands, I don't know the name for it, but he has to contain himself from moving his body. He does it in Say Something. He was digging his fingers into the chair to keep from moving.

[@Katie-Didn-t]

This isn’t very well known but they cover one of my favorite Disney songs, it’s from Anastasia called “Once Upon a December”. You should check it out, it was a beautiful haunting song to begin and they took and just went “yeah, let the professionals handle this”

[@coz_DS]

Ben Bram, Scott, and the others as far as I have seen Scott interviewed with arranging and writing down the music. Something like "are you that somebody" Kevin did a tiktoc version then the group, aka scott, ben bram arranged it although kevin had the largest role. according to Scott.

[@elizabethfelet4743]

On the official video, someone made the funniest comment about the section from 3:24 to 3:33 - This is the response when you ask your friends whether you should do something possibly sketchy....

[@kibaklaw538]

I know it isn’t a Christmas song, but if you get the chance, you should check out their video for Imagine.

[@kbbeers4274]

You made to 10k! 🎉 Thank you for sharing your time with us. ☮️

[@larryshair]

Thank YOU, KB ; )

[@Maerahn]

You're going to do 'Mary Did You Know?' at some point, yes? I haven't seen it in your playlist yet, so I'm assuming it's coming - but that's another must-hear!

[@larryshair]

Yea and no. I tried to release it and it was blocked. I have a few ideas, but it might not make the cut. So sad because that was probably my favorite one so far.

[@RobBellSpeaks]

Your Christmas reactions are fantastic. I hope you continue reacting to the many Pentatonix masterpieces after the Christmas holiday. Please do check out their rendition of Bohemian Rhapsody. You're going to LOVE IT. Thanks

[@rebapuck5061]

I've seen an "authentic" presentation of The Nutcracker. It's not the cartoon we saw as kids. It's scary!

[@clarekendrew7367]

They have done Bohemian Rhapsody too.

[@bfly5990]

They all contribute to arrangements. Including Ben Bran. Who has been their silent member all along. Thank you for your reaction. PTX. Expect the unexpected.

[@morganjohnson2869]

They have a producer his name is Ben beam but sometimes they group comes up with stuff their own very few times though but yes mostly Ben helps

[@sandwitch4300]

Best BUM! Ever! 🍑👍🏻

[@grandmalizzy77]

Great reaction! This is one of my fav PTX arrangements. I think you would love God Rest Ye Merry Gentlemen, also an amazing arrangement! ❤️🎵

[@pamscarr8696]

I have no idea who arranged this, but Ben Bram has been a great arranger for them over the years. Ben is the gentleman Scott called when he was looking for a bass before the A Capella Sing Off. Ben told him about Avi and Scott called Avi. I think the group was 2 days from the sing off beginning. Avi left the L.A. Opera offer and took the chance. Avi had wanted to begin the A Capella training academy for young people and presented the idea to Ben Bram and Ben jumped in. Avi is a prolific and fabulous writer and Ben is a great arranger and along with one other gentleman, they became the "Daddies" for the youth who have come and gone from the Academy. Avi wrote a fabulous song "The Seed" and the Academy Choir performed it their first year. Here is the video of that performance. A Capella Academy Choir The Seed (Kaplan) kzbin.info/www/bejne/joubanV-oreZrdU Not really for a reaction, but to give you an idea of the depth of Avi and to introduce you to the choir. Pretty sure that is Ben Bram directing.

[@Mahiahtree]

I love watching what the Academy comes up with every year. Those kids are so talented.

[@elainecourteau6231]

Your delighted laughter is so infectious. I love the arrangements and videos. So clever. 🤗

[@larryshair]

Thanks Elaine! You're so kind!

[@lrex4706]

Mad world is something different. There is a part where the singing sounds like an organ

[@NerdyNanaSimulations]

Glad you got to see it, it's one of my favorites. Home Free has some pretty good Christmas songs also, and that's a heck of a compliment from someone who avoids country...lol

[@katherineeasteal662]

Fun watching you having fun with this ballet piece. I wish Pentatonix would adapt further classical instrumental pieces and operas etc. What about excerpts of Gilbert and Sullivan's Mikado, a bit like the Wizard Of Ahhhs?

[@parrottm76262]

This is one of PTX vids that I am always amazed at, even though I've seen it way too many times. It is freaking great! Their ability to arrange, produce; just amazes.

[@marymichele340]

Fun!

[@yogaplacee2]

wow!

[@carlaemerson1195]

Avi ❤ They are all fantastic but Avi ❤❤❤

[@jeangoodwin1856]

Larry, you are fast becoming one of my favorite reactors. They are so multitalented and so humble. Thanks for doing PTX Christmas 💕

[@larryshair]

Thank you so much, Jean. You are so kind :)

[@jeidyandres7607]

We need a reaction to ~heathens~ by aurora her new song, yess

[@baskervillebee6097]

New this year : Combination of Christmas Time Is Here and Pure Imagination. Superb

[@nikkibanning176]

Love this so much. You got what we call Mitch slapped with his high note. Avi shines here with his classical tone. He was headed to L.A. Opera when he got the call for The Sing Off with Pentatonix.

[@ryanje8147]

goodness....so many inconvenient pauses

[@stacynn7556]

Definitely one of my faves!

[@floriangrogoll5206]

a big respect to the video editor. it was definitely shot on green screen and each person was shot individually and then stitched together. But... timing the keyframes in the act of music and the fading to it is a lot of work. RESPECT

[@buddasquirrel]

Loved your reaction. Thank you.

[@larryshair]

Thank you Budda!

[@ruth2141]

If you want to see PTX working on an arrangement, here's a link to one of their tour vlogs from 2014 (not to react but for you to watch). The second half, starting around 3:20, shows them working on an arrangement. At the end, they record a version they are happy with. My understanding is that they then send the video to Ben Bram, who fine tunes it a bit and converts it into sheet music. Then I'm sure when they are ready to perform or record a piece there are some last-minute discussions and changes. kzbin.info/www/bejne/enmkdGxrl7yhn8k

[@vidsorama2]

I enjoyed your reaction to this awesome Penttonix video. Thank you. I loved seeing your smile spread across your face during certain parts. This one won them their second Grammy for arranging. All 5 of them and co-founder/co-arranger, Ben Bram, do the arranging.

[@kiracattan4624]

Your expression says, "Mind Blown!" when he pulled that High note. I LOVE this version.

[@danielcarter837]

In my opinion PTX along with Ben Bram are the best arrangers of the last decade. Why they don't win the arrangement Grammy every year is a mystery to me.

[@ms_scribbles]

LOL yeah, that note from Avi is one of those that makes me always go, "Oh yeah, he definitely trained in opera." (It was actually his major in college.)

[@larryshair]

Cool back story! That makes sense.

[@ladyingreene1]

Ben Bram. And the five singers too

[@jcs1025]

One of their documentaries goes into how they arrange, and it’s much ‘simpler’ than you would think. One of them usually comes up with an idea, the 5 have a session where they relatively quickly throw ideas around and come up with a rough arrangement, and then Ben Bram, who has been with them since almost the beginning, works with the group to polish and finalize. I’m sure it’s slightly different when they do collaborations, but that’s generally how they describe it.

[@rachelc.9570]

The cover Bohemian Rhapsody is AMAZING

[@becca2383]

Great reaction! Would highly recommend God Rest Ye Merry Gentleman 🙂

[@ehcimocs2364]

I love watching you enjoy these amazing people sing. Your laugh is great and makes me smile. Wonderful Christmas season!

[@danielcarter837]

A song without words sung by a band without instruments. Second Grammy.

[@grazynawikert-unger2122]

They won Ģrammy in the category: Best Arrangement, Instrumental or a Capella. The arranger is Ben Bram, the producer and arranger who has been with them from the very beginning. The piece is a ballerina's dance from the ballet The Nutcracker by Tchaikovsky.

[@gailseatonhumbert9199]

The Grammy was for arrangement and 6 people were listed. Every Pentatonix member and Brn Bram. I recommend that you listen to some of their interviews about the process. For example, Avi would come up with the bass line and Kevin with the percussion and the 2 of them would plan out how and when Avi would take over the percussion so Kevin could breathe.

[@grazynawikert-unger2122]

@@gailseatonhumbert9199 Yes, they received Grammy for arrangement in Best Arrangement, Instrumental or a Capella category so it goes without saying that Ben also got it. :)

[@ronaldschweitzer1110]

I just knew that this would be your reaction to this. I did too. Perfection!!

[@Jancoulson]

Ollaborate arrangement

[@thechomiji]

This should answer some questions - PTX Recording and Arranging Compilation: kzbin.info/www/bejne/jpPbgaGYeJ6ppM0 Also: Jacob Restituto's interview with PTX arranger Ben Bram: kzbin.info/www/bejne/q3XGo4B9oKhkn6c

[@sjc9121]

Thank you for this reaction! I love the way you do this.

[@larryshair]

Thanks so much!

[@carolemonahan6068]

Outstanding 👏🏻

[@barbarabishop9362]

Thank God you back up a few seconds before you restart after interrupting, because frankly, every time you paused the video to offer a remark, you INVARIABLY paused right before they did something mind-blowing, like Mitch's shocking note, or Avi's descent into the depths. It drove me nuts. But if you hadn't backed up a bit to restore the flow of the piece, I would have had to close the video. There's one or two reactors who pause, say something, then just hit "play" and it seriously bothers me. With PTX especially, the flow of the arrangement is just as important as their harmonies, and when the flow is chopped up into non-continuous chunks, it can totally spoil the listening pleasure. Not for your audience, I mean for YOU, which is going affect how you respond to the piece. Well, a little for your audience, too, though generally speaking we're already totally familiar with their original video. That said, I very much enjoy your reactions - your deep elation with what you hear is very pleasing to watch. Just keep going down the PTX wormhole. Though you might also want to branch a bit into their solo music, and Superfruit (Scott and MItch) had some phenomenal videos. From my understanding, very early on they agreed that any of them were free to do their own thing, as long as they agreed that Pentatonix needed to come first. Superfruit, in addition to their hilarious vlogs, put out one music album "Future Friends" and every track on it is AMAZING.

[@larryshair]

Pausing is pretty important in order to avoid copywrite blocks. And since I have never heard these songs, it's hard to know when you stop or not. Thanks for your honesty with me!

[@barbarabishop9362]

@@larryshair I'm sorry, I do in fact understand the need for pausing (though it appears to be very arbitrary whether they block or not - I watch 20-30 reactions to the same video, and some people just watch it through without issue and some have to go through cirque du soliel tricks - there doesn't seem to be a consistent rule about blocking.) My comment was really a back-assward form of praise, as I'm truly GRATEFUL that you back up a bit before hitting Play. It was pure coincidence that you pause at such high points each time. Amusing on the one hand, really annoying on the other :D I can only hope that you take the three to five minutes needed after your record your reaction to play it for yourself, just so you can simply enjoy these videos as a member of the audience. They are worth it!

[@sandrawalkerhaliburton1884]

Watch The Making of EVERGREEN. They did 14 tracks in 14 days and this shows a lot of how they work together

[@megjones7860]

Hello Larry. Great reaction. At one point you stopped just before Mitch's high note and I thought "oh no - you are going to miss it" but you backed up and you caught it, your expression was priceless. Other comments below have explained the process of how PTX works their arrangements, and songs, with them individually or collectively coming up with the idea, original or cover, working on it together, deciding the parts, building the layers, and with master arranger Ben Bram cleaning and polishing. We need to re-define how PTX is described. Yes, they are an A Capella group which implies singing with no musical instruments. However, their vocal cords are their musical instruments. In addition to singing the words, or in the case of Sugar Plum Fairy singing the "da da dums", I have heard the musical instruments from their vocal chords. Kevin - a full drum set with even cymbals clashing (The Prayer, Hallelujah, O Come All Ye Faithful) and the trumpet /fugle horn (Havana); Matt (and Avi before him) with the bass guitar; Matt and Kirstie with the drone of bagpipes (Amazing Grace); Mitch with the electrical guitar (Bohemian Rhapsody); and Kirstie, Scott and Mitch with bell notes and piano sounds. Not to mention using their hands in the clapping, snapping, swishing, slapping and beating as they did in I Saw Three Ships. Sugar Plum Fairy was indeed a masterpiece and a well-deserved Grammy! Looking forward to following your reactions of PTX Christmas songs and in January you can do some older pieces such as Can You Feel the Love Tonight (Elton John), Imagine (John Lennon), Can't Help Falling in Love (Elvis Presley), and originals like Sing, Happy Now, Coffee In Bed. Then do some recorded vs live comparisons of Aha, Havana, Attention, Hallelujah. Absolutely PTX works hard but look at some of the videos where they are in fact just sitting around or standing around singing - like the cover of Gold by Kiara or an impromptu rendition of Daft Punk caught on someone's camera phone.