Percy Jackson Characters In The Books VS In The Show!

[@TheAmagiYT]

Have an idea for a video? Submit it here: amagipublishing.com/idea-submission/the-amagi-idea-submission/

[@loganyamada-oq4my]

What if Titan cameraman sealed in Naruto

[@Hrbl_reagan]

Day 1 of asking what if naruto ate a chakra fruit

[@Hrbl_reagan]

Sure hasn’t even actually showed up in the Percy Jackson show

[@allisonfulbright132]

Nartuo in demon slayer part 2 pls

[@joytaylor6553]

the life of Mal ( descendants)

[@drchosen3649]

It’s not just some people being the wrong race, but every character doesn’t look how the book describes them

[@whateverwhatever4476]

Them being the wrong race doesn't matter as long as they can give the proper attitude to the character like Riordan said

[@yobud6637]

​​​​@@whateverwhatever4476 Race does matter here when you have to consider that they're all supposed to be Greek, who have generally more olive-tinted and lighter skin. I get that everyone needs to be inclusive and diverse or whatever these days, but there's nothing wrong with accuracy and sticking to the source material, especially when the physical characteristics are the first thing people notice about most characters, and if it doesn't look at least similar to what you'd expect, a viewer can find it distracting. For Zeus to be a bald black man is so jarring, because, while the realistic expectation is that we should see a northern Mediterranian man, we see someone different and it makes it harder to believe the character. Of course, for a character who doesn't have any established skin color from the books like Grover, seeing him as white, black, or anywhere between are all valid options, as long as the hair style and face structure match. Then there's Annabeth, whose physical features are described very often in the books. They mention her stormy, piercing gray eyes multiple times, but in this series, I don't see evidence of that. The only visually interesting part of her look is her hair, but even that is inaccurate. Long flowing strawberry-blond hair may be a "stereotype of beauty standards" or whatever so people want to change it, but even so, the character of Annabeth canonically has that feature, and for many (including myself), she can't look like anything other than that description, or else she is no longer Annabeth.

[@jatz9462]

@@yobud6637 wow imagine pressed cuz fictional characters and ppl from myth weren’t casted white in a tv show. Yes it is based on Greek myth specific to European culture but come on, there’s more important things in the world to be complaining and sooking about than characters not being casted white. At the end of the day it was Rick who had the last say in casting and as long as Rick got the casting he envisioned I don’t get what why ppl like you are so pressed. “She’s no longer Annabeth” just cuz the casting isn’t a strawberry blonde white girl with grey eyes, seems like microaggression to me.

[@yobud6637]

@@jatz9462 I never said they had to be white, I just said they should look like who they're described as

[@Electivedrop]

​@@yobud6637Oh they only swapped the race of those characters to be inclusive. I think everyone knows that deep down. It's not because these folks are better actors, it's because Disney is the Director of these movies. When they stray too far from the source material, not even bothering to dye that one dudes hair black then you know the series will flunk.

[@Nauni]

There’s a lot of differences, and while I do sort of wish it stayed more faithful to the series, it’s not bad. But they made Gabe kinda likable

[@jessiepayne9217]

I don't like that

[@NicholasJScott]

Creative liberties, which I don't mind. I actually rather it have some creative liberties.

[@THEINFINITIVERSESAGA]

Gabe Ugliano likable *that’s a MORTAL SIN* You take that damn back boi

[@whateverwhatever4476]

They didn't make Gabe likeable? He's just as scummy as he is in the book

[@whateverwhatever4476]

@@jessiepayne9217how's he more likable?

[@rinokumera5907]

Hope Rick Riordan made the right choises. Anabeth is a chase decended to swedish kings. Her ethnicity is important if they intend to make Magnus Chase

[@zerere_]

There were dark skinned vikings of african descent. The more you know

[@puterboy2]

@@zerere_Is there proof?

[@jsoren6595]

@@zerere_no, and if there where it would of been extremely rare

[@zerere_]

@@jsoren6595 why do you try to argue for things you know nothing about) Even if they were rare they still existed. Main characters are always special in a way, especially for children/young adult fiction. Fun and educational

[@jsoren6595]

@@zerere_ apologies if I was too blunt Just wanted to state what I know as I’m into Viking history To elaborate The most common place you would see people with darker skins tones in the Scandinavia during the viking era would be among slaves However it would still be rare to see them as slaves because vikings most commonly raided Britain, Ireland and Francia as it was easier then going Mediterranean. Thus, the vast majority of slaves where Caucasian. And it would be much rarer for slaves to be able to gain freedom and convince other Vikings to allow them to go on raids given it was socially acceptable to discriminate back then

[@masterchiefofhalo4525]

As a reader of the series as a kid I’m not a fan of how much has been changed. Or how fast paced it is. It’s cramping way too much in such a short time. It was kind of the same in the books but it was done better. Also it’s made by Disney so I have zero faith it’ll be good for long.

[@sebastianjo752]

I feel the same, a lot of important scenes were changed and rushed.

[@priceyboy8369]

They should have let a different company produce this like legendary pictures

[@vi-who-sims]

I understand things were changed but Rick is on the writing staff of the show all changes had to go though him unlike the movies. Rick said he would fix mistakes he made in the books as well as make the changes we wanted to make in order to make the sorry better.

[@THEINFINITIVERSESAGA]

2:28 Even my mythologically Space Percy Jackson-like OC look more accurate to the books than the series version

[@TheAmagiYT]

Who else loves Percy Jackson?

[@BBGFLIX]

Me

[@lydelllarue2695]

Me and W video

[@booradley123321]

Loved how it ended

[@pluto1980]

ME

[@Nauni]

Greatest book series

[@TheAmagiYT]

What do you guys think of the Disney+ show?

[@ANIMEACTION-_]

Very good ❤

[@BBGFLIX]

Can you make a video of what if Naruto died during pain invasion

[@masterchiefofhalo4525]

Would have hope but it’s probably gonna end up woke like every other show out there now

[@BSP435]

Why is annabeth white

[@masterchiefofhalo4525]

@@BSP435 Her father was the descadent of people of European descent. Is it not logical to conclude then that she would also be of European descent given that she’s half god and half human? And that both the god and human are Caucasian?

[@powmia9668]

On the Topic of Annabeth Chase, here is Book 1 Chapter 5’s Description of her. “She was probably my age, maybe a couple of inches taller, and a whole lot more athletic looking. With her deep tan and her curly blond hair, she was almost exactly what I thought a stereotypical California girl would look like, except her eyes ruined the image. They were startling gray, like storm clouds; pretty, but intimidating, too, as if she were analyzing the best way to take me down in a fight.” That is Pulled from the book. Not once is she said to be White

[@ats8377]

“With her deep tan and curly BLONDE hair” not to mention “stereotypical California girl” being associated with a blonde girl? Cmon dude. Everyone immediately thinks of this image of some white preppy chick in bel air or some shit. Stop beating around the bush. She was without a doubt white in the books

[@THEINFINITIVERSESAGA]

3:07 why she lowkey look like a black version of Brenda song which is funny n weird in its was cause that’s who I imagined would play annabeths step mom in live action

[@OneBrokenDove]

Theres 3 characters that I believe the movies did right -- Chiron from the first movie, Gabe and Dionysus.

[@ethanluttrell]

I know they cast the show Annabeth bc she fit the personality of the book, however she only fits the personality of book 1 Annabeth, i dont see this girl being able to change and become the emotionally vulnerable and love interest with Percy that happens in the book

[@-._.-What-Is-Up-._.-]

And To Me, Leah (New Anna-Black-Beth Actress) is not even fit to Annabeth's Personality 💀

[@harisstauridis7277]

I am greek and AI chiron is literally my dad

[@ashleighstratmann7783]

I actually liked how the Minotaur dropped to its hands and hooves before stampeding at its targets. I wish I thought of doing that with some of my fanfictions

[@StraymrJ]

Ai zues looks like drake😂😂

[@THEINFINITIVERSESAGA]

6:47 I speak for Poseidon when I say *DAAAAAAAAAAAAAYUM* 😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮 “ proceeds to almost jump into the screen”

[@daurydavis3983]

Funny how with the movies people complained about how Annabeth didn't have blonde hair, but in the show both her skin color and hair color are wrong and people are okay with it lol

[@zerere_]

Nah there are more loud racists this time around

[@daurydavis3983]

@@zerere_ some may be racists, but others just want complete book accuracy

[@zerere_]

@@daurydavis3983 I would understand if they foamed about percy also, and clarissa, and luke. Clarissa is supposed to be a very bulky redhead, luke is supposed to be blond, gabe was abusive and a piece of shit, percy's mother shouldn't be a karen, percy isn't supposed to be stupid, annabeth shouldn't be a stonecold bitch but that has nothing to do with her skin colour. Actors have always metamorphised into their roles, this actress was chosen by the author. I actually really didn't like the adaptation but not because of some little girl.

[@zerere_]

@@daurydavis3983 and what you said is that no one cares and says anything which is not true in the slightest

[@daurydavis3983]

​@@zerere_ I also didn't like Annabeth's attitude in the show either

[@Lupinemancer87]

I'm not a fan of what they did to Annabeth, I don't care if there are people of different races in movies and TV shows, cuz that's totally fine, but I don't approve of race swapping at all. Regarless of which it is. I don't like that she looks nothing like how she is described in the books. Some minor changes I'm fine with, but this is too much. I don't get why Disney is having a wierd fetish for blackwashing characters recently. When it comes to Asian, African, Hispanic etc, they are so dedicated to make sure they stay this race, but white? Nah, just make them black. I can't be the only who think they are basically insulting their white fans.

[@-._.-What-Is-Up-._.-]

Fr 🔥

[@Electivedrop]

If they want a bunch of actors with different races then white they should make a *new* story, im sure everyone would love that. Instead they just decide to ruin old stories by straying far from the original script.

[@bloodybunny3060]

I love Percy Jackson !!

[@P7RO1]

I have red every book by Rick from the Lightning Thief to Serpents Shadow. Its hard to watch ngl, as I hate plot differences, and there is a hell ton.

[@Hate_JJYT]

I really love the show I can’t wait for episode 3

[@WafflaFN]

Fr

[@disneyvision19]

2 videos in one day!!!

[@Lizardkid10]

Wouldn’t Disney be able to play around with the god characters? They can change their humanoid form anytime they want, from any form they wanted?

[@Kapitalsaint]

i loved reading Percy Jackson

[@MysteriousFluid]

What if Naruto was the vessel of sukuna

[@fasinehconteh3433]

Does the AI Grover remind you of Tyler Posey?

[@The_Dragon-Human_hybrid]

New show vs Old movies

[@THEINFINITIVERSESAGA]

Even my mythologically Space Percy Jackson-like OC look more accurate to the books 2:23

[@antonycepeda1839]

I wish the cast of Percy Jackson well

[@brandedaheretic3526]

What if idea: what if Naruto had the eikons from final fantasy 16 instead of the tailed beasts?

[@Maris_Likes_Games]

I love Percy Jackson 💜😊

[@evflasevfla4147]

Dionysus roman counter is the god of party as well

[@Invincible566]

I watched the show when it came out it’s amazing

[@Redfield_Bloodline]

Day 5: what if Vergil from Devil May Cry was in Naruto

[@LawltheJester]

Clarisse isnt ugly enough

[@goldenwither1014]

It’s racial pandering and people are just making excuses and it’s funny to watch

[@disneyvision19]

what do you mean?

[@goldenwither1014]

@@disneyvision19 look at anything Disney has done in the past year and you have your answer, and don’t argue just cuz Disney is all you got left in this world, Disney adults need to grow up and be functional human beings not these hollow people that think a black little mermaid or dwarves that aren’t people with dwarfism. It’s the same case with this show it’s based on Greek mythology nowhere in there have you seen half of the ethnicities involved, like actually how the fuck is a satyr gonna come out lookin like his parents got fired from the scam center in deli? It’s just idiotic

[@maytalacedo2942]

I don't think the actors and actress are the problem i feel like the make up artist are so lazy. For walker they cldve died his hair black and he wldve been book accurate, same with her playing as Annabeth die her hair blond and use her natural curly hair in the first season that wld work fine without dismissing diversity from an actress. I've seen people like her died their hair blonde while being natural with their hair with their culture and their race that wldve been amazing.

[@trenchcoatjohn]

HEY YALL

[@designvatsa8348]

Zeus from show is just disappointing

[@priceyboy8369]

Im sorry to ask, but how the hell did disney get rights to precy Jackson

[@YourboyStink]

I like the movie best

[@MysteriousFluid]

This is a idea for your videos

[@Hate_JJYT]

Love the show!

[@KileyMoore-z8w]

🪻🌷

[@BucketWarrior]

What if naruto was born on another village

[@johnnyd3158]

I’ll just stick the original five books, and even the two live action films, than to watch this “woke” crap of an adaptation by Disney.

[@Hikari_Uzuamki123]

Hi guys

[@animeedits15484]

Tea is chai

[@Sebastian-ju5zh]

what of naruto ate sukana finalger

[@Hrbl_reagan]

Hades hasn’t either

[@Icepick2024]

I think he’s using the heroes of Olympus description because I’m pretty sure Anabeth got the pendant after the last Olympian

[@Hrbl_reagan]

Neither has poseidon

[@josephsdream3820]

hi

[@Thirteenfan]

Hi

[@meatdagod8872]

They turned Anna Beth black to make y’all mad 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@THEINFINITIVERSESAGA]

Meaning

[@CyberneticGamer]

Im a bit early

[@BruceWayne-hr7vm]

There's no way you're this ignorant on how a video like this with all the followers you have will continue to contribute to the backlash the kid actors have gotten and the hate they've been receiving

[@disneyvision19]

He said only positive things…

[@toxicheadshot360]

Bruh shut up Disney should stop making these woke bs and just stick to the source material

[@cloversgood_luck9290]

Damn you really gonna cry over that?💀

[@whateverwhatever4476]

@@toxicheadshot360get your head out of your ass, buddy

[@angelicagaldos]

The show is doing a better than both films ever did. I don't mind the race change on three of the main characters.