Perfect - Ed Sheeran (Tagalog mix - Cover by 1ST.ONE)

#Perfect #EdSheeran #cover
#1STONE #FIRSTONE #FORONE
1ST.ONE x FOR.ONE
Forever ONE !
Offcial
Facebook: / 1st.oneofc
TiKTok : 1stoneofficial
Twitter : 1stone_offcial
I.G :1stone_offcial
Keep safe ForONE !

[@FirstOneOfficial]

Hello ! For.One and Friends ! we take your advice and will practice more to show better performance po ! all of your comment is always important to us. Keep safe from Corona! God bless you po S2

[@donprocopio2345]

@@jasperzachary1142 geabe naman comment mo, hindi constructive, more on hate

[@izaa3338]

We appreciate the fact that you took the time to read all of our opinions and advice. Sinasabi namin yun kasi mahal namin kayo at gusto namin na mag-improve yung 1ST. ONE as a group :) I really believe that you can improve. Gustong gusto namin na mag-succeed kayo. Mahal na mahal namin kayo at nandito kami para suportahan kayo hanggang sa dulo ♡

[@elynievas8050]

Hello 1st.ONE! Thank you for listening to our sentiments. We also appreciate that you value our opinions and comments. I'm really hoping and praying for you to achieve your dreams and goals as a performers. Just keep on practicing so you can improve more before your debut. Fighting lang! Kaya niyo yan! 💪😇 Always remember that for. ONE loves you and we are here to support you till the end. Keep safe and always take care! God bless you too 1st.ONE! Lovelots 💕

[@maeolaco9551]

Need to work more on your harmonization para di siya masakit sa tenga pakinggan.. Andami ding flats and sharps which is understandable naman since nagsisimula palang kayo to work on your vocals and dalawa Lang din ata sa inyo yung forte talaga yung pagkanta which is Si max & Ace Lang ata if I'm not mistaken, nagka clash din kasi yung mga voice nyo and feeling ko naglalamangan pa kayo dapat alam ng bawat Isa kung kailan yung tamang pasok sa kanta and one more thing is yung rap parts I'm sorry but di talaga siya maganda pakinggan yung pagkakaputol.putol ng words sa rap di siya tugma need to work on that too and Sana mas clear yung bigkas nyu ng words or enunciation nyo pangit kasi pakinggan na parang barok na English, Sana Mas mapag aralan nyu yung voice strength and weakness ng bawat Isa para alam nyu kung sino yung mas fit yung voice sa part ng kanta Hindi yung basta basta nyo nalang ipapasok. Last one is dapat intro palang maganda na yung pasok. Siya kasi yung magsiset ng mood ng kanta, Choose a member that will really fit his voice sa intro palang ng song. let's take SB19 as an example, Si Ken yung may pinaka unique yung voice for me and siya din yung taga intro palagi sa mge songs kasi bagay talaga sa kanya. Ayun Lang so Sana Itake nyo to as constructive criticism and make these things na something to work on and improve more. Everyone has always a room for improvement naman. God Bless!

[@rommelt5223]

Please focus on personality development and their communication skills also. Train these boys to be respectful to each other and be polite . Good manners is very important. Avoid KULITAN, ASARAN and CORNY jokes in front of the camera. Its tackless and comes off that they all have poor manners and lack professionalism. They can be better. Just saying.

[@zrngtl7628]

A legend one's said and i qoute: "PRACTICE WILL NEVER BETRAY YOU". Search those legends and you guys will know the results of there hardwork. Goodluck. And ps. Don't rush things.

[@mhaidhie_khenie8018]

Super agree po, yan talaga yon... 😄

[@coffeeenthusiast4533]

Our Dear Pinuno also said... "there is no short cuts" wag madaliin ang mga bagay-bagay lahat yan pinag aaralan at pinag ti-tiyagaan. Very true @soren gatil try to search those legends and you will learn a lot! GBU! ;*)

[@jay_on3977]

I absolutely agree with you. Keep it up guys but dont rush. I'll be waiting and watch you all until the day that you'll gonna GO UP too. Cheer up and God Bless!🤗❤

[@ailemcanapi3986]

I like that.. high five!!!

[@anzainal3615]

OMG YES 😭💙

[@kenzoff2097]

Sabi sa kmjs nag practice sila ng 3years I think yung pinractis lng nila is yung sayaw?

[@tintinsajona8677]

Thats what Im thinking too. If 3 years sila nag training dapat na polish na nila yung vocals and sa dance? I dont think so na prinactice nila yun ng 3 years because natural dancer na sila. Kasi when we say training dapat kasama vocals knowing Ppop Group ang binebenta ng company nila. So I doubt na 3 years i mean no offense pero kitang kita naman sa cover song nila.

[@shootoki]

@@abonillomaryrosev.184 means sayaw lng na napractice nila HAHA

[@laarnylymatienzo3148]

i don't believe they undergone 2 years training. maybe they were formed together in a span of two years but not rigid training like sb19. you can see a disciplined four-year training in sb19's physique even if they don't have a gym bodies, you can tell from stamina and body stance when they performed singing and dancing live. it's total discipline mapapaisip ka na lang, how showbt did it with the boys, we have no idea talaga. now looking at this group, they didn't have a sense of good posture while singing. huwag umasang gaganda ang boses just because you gained musical training. nope. what training can do is make your body flexible, make your mind conditioned, make you have a professional outlook and have total discipline. but voices, you can have breathing exercises, to tell you the truth, it won't make your voice at par but at the same time, you will learn to glide in harmony and understand music at least. but sila, I don't know if they ever study music or what. sorry...

[@tintinsajona8677]

I dont believe too that they undergone 2 yesars of training or 3 as they are claiming to. But based on my research they were a dance group who won back in 2019 then nakapag perform sa Seoul Music Awards after that ginawa na ata silang Ppop Group. Kasi if it is 3 years bakit nasa Star Music pa si Ace nung 2017-2018 as their artist? Hindi ako maniniwala na papayag ang Star Music na mag training si Ace sa company nila ngayon. So I doubt na 3 years sila nag training.

[@litom.salido1112]

@@tintinsajona8677 true my nagsabi pa daw na 4years shocks are they serious my goodness look at them,I don't want to drag them but action speaks louder than words.sorry,

[@jhoncarloalejo1206]

Siguro 2 or 3 years as a dance group pero not that type of group na talagang grabe Ang practice

[@tintinsajona8677]

@@jhoncarloalejo1206 but kasi theyre not a dance group, ppop band sila. sana prinactice nila ang vocal. when we say ppop band with dance and vocals yun. :(

[@jhoncarloalejo1206]

@@tintinsajona8677 yeah dapat balance siguro nasanay sila sa dance Kaya Hirap sa vocal

[@jarvisevangelista289]

Iba pa rin talaga ang power ni pinuno sa kanyang mga anak...parang maxado nagmadali ang group n to.... Gusto ko isupport lahat ng ppop pero sana ung malapit sa standard ng SB19 mataas kase maxado expectation ko sa susunod n ppop becoz of SB19... Sana mag improve p kau

[@nyebe6598]

Diko nagustuhan ang cover ng 1stone dito, pero, hinding hindi ko imemention ang pangalan ng ibang grupo para ikumpara. That's just plain rude and disrespectful. Just give your damn feedback and that's it. If I were the SB group, I'd feel embarrassed for having you drag my name here.

[@SolLunaTV]

Max doesn't deserve this group. He should be a soloist.

[@SolLunaTV]

autolike para no desaparecer xD

[@juliusmontabon827]

Hahahaha so funny exactly

[@jellysso3255]

Josh has the weakest voice in SB19 pero pagdating sa harmony lumilitaw yung boses niya. Dun kayo kulang. Harmony guys. Need more practice sa vocals.

[@hannahmarie6147]

This is why Im proud being an A'tin we accept constructive critism and we are vocal about sa weakness ng Idol namin..that's why sobra ang naging improvement ni Josh bcoz nakikinig sya sa suggestion ng Fans...Im so proud of our Josh...

[@glend.2309]

I feel cringe. Sana po wag masyadong magpa cute sa cam. And the harmonization, there's still room for improvement po. Don't rush things. Take time to practice. Because "Practice will never betray you"

[@karlomoonblade]

san ka ba makakahanap ng pop group na hindi pa-kyut?

[@elalalaenene7299]

@@karlomoonblade SB19 tall

[@dinagatnon5519]

I love them like that

[@carltechviews605]

Exactly practice lng 1st one

[@shainaalgamde657]

@@elalalaenene7299 hindi naman sila SB19 at isa pa practice lang ata yan pangalawa kahit magpapa cute pa sila hindi naman sila cute hahaha si Jayson lee lang talaga cute sa kanila for my opinion lang po hahaha Si jayson bias ko ang cute niya😍😍😍

[@Aleina_dy]

May panahon pa po para mag-isip. 'Wag madaliin ang debut. It is not a race. Take time to improve. Kasi kung ganto po ibibigay niyo samin, sure po ba kayong may bibili ng Album niyo. Sorry not sorry. Just my opinion ☺️

[@litom.salido1112]

Sorry natawa ako sa may panahon pa "para mag isip" The struggle of a dance crew to become a boygroup?

[@moniquem7384]

Watch their Wish Bus Performance of their song Ttak Maja Nuh as well as their latest Mv 'OH' , you can see their improvements po... Salamat

[@chilimansipancitcanton9393]

So after watching their mv debut, KZbin led me here. I'm no professional sa singing field but i can clearly say na napaka gulo nitong cover nila. Actually even sa you're the one mv, may mga part dun na mapapansin talaga yung "not so good na diction nila". Another one is yung harmonization na napaka gulo. Sapawan ng boses which is not a good thing. Dinig na dinig din na andaming flats. Thumbs up sa dancing skills niyo lalong lalo na sa mv niyo, napaka ganda ng transition, location niyo sa pag shoot and all pero sa singing niyo siguro more practice pa. Also sana whenever u guys are in front of the cam for some interviews or what, please act naturally. Wag trying hard magpa cute and pa pogi. I dunno if it's just me or cringe yung mga vlogs/interviews niyo. Anyway, practice. practice. practice. U can do it.✊

[@moniquem7384]

Kindly watch their Wish Bus Performance kzbin.info/www/bejne/enKpdpmMnKmtbdU and also their latest mv 'OH' kzbin.info/www/bejne/h6bVpmZmp5eIncU You can see their improvements po, I think. Salamat po!!!

[@Skdndnsmsm]

Here's a simple tip , stop acting cute on cam and start being setious on every kind of this vlog para rinig nyo lahat ang dapat i-workout as a group

[@joefrybachoco2130]

Yun din pansin ko masyado nilang iniimpose yung "cuteness" nila na parang mga pabebeng artistang kumakanta sa tv dating tuloy di na kita talent, pa cute na lang. Unlike sa Sb19 serious sila and shino showcase nila yung talent nila and Hindi yung charisma nila.

[@pkpop19channel83]

Yun din napapansin ko.. Hindi sa pang babash pero parang nagpapansin sila at satingin ko parang hindi yon yung normal personality nila

[@louiefonim8552]

@@joefrybachoco2130 true.. Ang SB19 kasi walang pake sa mukha Lalo na sa mga vlogs nila 🤣 hndi nagpapa cute sa cam..

[@D.O14]

Para silang group na individually performing. Medyo nagsasapawan sila. Kay medyo off din iyong harmonization nila. Yong brother ko, hindi niya pinatapis itong panoorin, kasi hindi niya raw nagustuhan.

[@neriesalonga904]

I agree po ... they should sing more passionate and stop acting cute when you are singing romantic song ... well actually you can sing romantic while acting cute but in this video it looks ahmmm i don't know ... i just get distracted

[@jnnhpl]

Jannah was here!

[@JustForCute]

Guys wag niyo irequest tong video na toh sa mga foreign reactors,, nakakaiya

[@cjcua7928]

Awesome! Love you guys! Its awesome as ever

[@anamarieabejo100]

HAHAHAHA tanginang basher yun nakaaway pa ako dahil daw mas magaling pa daw sila keysa sa SB19 dapak. ito na na yun? I’m not a basher pero I’m here kasi sabi niya magaling daw, pero to be honest di ko type to naka lip sync sila mas maayos sana pag indi para makita natin yong totoong boses. And the harmonization isn’t that good but they’re trying naman pero let me tell you this sana ganon ka lilins yong harmonization tulad ng SB19 TILALUHA

[@ryangarcia6250]

Ang daya no ang tagal naghintay ng SB19 magtrend tapos umabot sa point na magdidisband sila tapos etong group nato nakakuha ng recognition dahil sa TV show? Sorry ha pero as an ATIN fanboy sobrang unfair.

[@anamarieabejo100]

Oo nga eh. ang bilis tuloy nila naka gain ng fans/ social media followers. hays! yan talaga ang buhay minsan ang unfair, pero di natin alam baka mas magiging successful pa SB19 in the future kasi pinaghirapan nila ang lahat ng na achieve nila ngayon. Sayang nga eh di ko sila nakilala agad don sa Tilaluha era.

[@ryangarcia6250]

@@anamarieabejo100 pabayaan na lang natin kapatid maghintay na lang tayo ng comeback ng SB19 at sa grupo nato good luck na lang sa inyo!

[@anamarieabejo100]

Ryan Garcia kitakits nalang sa twitter dahil papatrend natin yong comeback ng SB19 kung kailan mn yon.💙 HAHAHA *btw fanboy spotted👀

[@anamarieabejo100]

taenaaaaa ambilis dumami ng subscriber nila wahhhh last time mga 30k pa yun ah! Iba talaga nagagawa basta na featured sa KMJS.

[@nathnath4616]

cringy, wag na magpacute kung di naman cute :(((((((((

[@Charlene_fea]

A LEGEND just set the PPOP STANDARDS so highhhhh.. I don't want to compare but I can't help it.. I'll just keep my comments to myself tho.

[@moniquem7384]

Kindly watch their Wish Bus Performance of their song Ttak Maja Nuh as well as their latest Mv 'OH' , you can see their improvements po... Salamat po

[@annecastillo512]

Please give them more training before putting them in front of the camera. The enunciation is horrible. Maybe English lessons will help. No harmony. They sing too loud (yell is the right term). Maybe make up helps. Too oily. The guy with cap on the left is so lost. Did you find them on the streets or they auditioned??? Do they hear themselves? Why do they seem to enjoy jamming off tune?

[@reimicaiah1010]

🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@moniquem7384]

Kindly watch their Wish Bus Performance of their song Ttak Maja Nuh as well as their latest Mv 'OH' , you can see their improvements po... Salamat po

[@jobiefeythvaler4516]

❤️

[@valderamaaira4367]

Nagtataka kayo kung bakit maraming harsh and negative comments e sa standard ba naman na niset ng mga Legendary Filipino singers sa tingin n'yo hanggang saan aabot ang cover na to ? Then y'all have the audacity to compare this group to SB19 ???? Sana ays lang keu

[@moniquem7384]

Kindly watch their Wish Bus Performance of their song Ttak Maja Nuh as well as their latest Mv 'OH' , you can see their improvements po... Salamat po

[@blush07]

Mukha more on dance group lang sila kesa vocal baka madaan sa autotune.

[@mikeymaanyag28]

The one legend said..."Practice Will Never Betray You" Just keep practicing. Support P-Pop Rise

[@melizaaceveda4044]

Merong magaling merong may flat..please keep on practicing..coz PRACTICE WONT BETRAY YOU....

[@marvin3866]

Hey guys, just like yung mga comment dito, di minamadali amg mga bagay bagay. It needs a lot of patience, perseverance and practice. Based sa cover nyo ng perfect, your voices doesnt suit well sa isa't isa at yun ang dapat nyong hanapin yung voice distribution kung sino kakanta ng high part sino sa low part. Unlike SB19, na they know their voices very well na kahit bigyan mo sila ng random songs nakaka harmonize sila agad agad. Kaya dito kayo mag concentrate. This is not bashing, this is an advice, besides dala dala nyo na ang PPop and we want the world to recognised PPop, di ba?

[@moniquem7384]

Kindly watch their Wish Bus Performance kzbin.info/www/bejne/enKpdpmMnKmtbdU and also their latest mv 'OH' kzbin.info/www/bejne/h6bVpmZmp5eIncU You can see their improvements po, I think. Salamat po!!!

[@dareusliamdeleon4778]

Hindi nakakaharmonize agad agad ang sb19 except the power three. Pero lamang sb19 kasi they really practice, kinocompensate nila weaknesses at strengths ng bawat isa, tama ka sa line distribution, well planned lahat. O josh dito ka kasi bagay sa boses mo, then sa part na to humming ka, o eto kaunting Linya ng growl.. kasi when you cover a song maicocompare ka talaga sa original lalo na original instrumentals pa gagamitin mo, the safest way to cover a song is to give it a whole new arrangement, kahit gitara lang basta mailayo mo sa original kahit kaunti

[@pinckyalvarado4698]

Jusq po intro palang ni Ken himlay na kaming A'TIN kaya suggestion kapag nag-iintro kayo dapat una pa Lang hatak na.

[@celestinatolentino2739]

HAHAHAH UWI NA TAYO

[@pinckyalvarado4698]

@@celestinatolentino2739 Tara po🤣 nagalit na ata yun🤣

[@zeryn9102]

@@pinckyalvarado4698 haha korek ka dyan kapatid

[@stellberryshortcake7999]

Uwi sa manukaaaan 😂😂😂

[@pinckyalvarado4698]

Umuwi na tayong lahat🤣

[@jojochannel6713]

Bakit need sabihin sa fb live nyo na live na live yan after nyo magbigay ng sample ng song. Alam po namin yun di ba mas masarap marining kung sa iba manggagaling ang comments na wow live sila kumanta. Minsan kasi hindi rin maganda ang sobrang salita. From my observation parang si Max ang Walng halong yabang at mukhang mabait.

[@upabove6506]

Napansin ko rin yun. Nadisapoint nga ako eh. Like wth may gustong patunayan? Na maganda ang vocals kahit live? Haays minsan nakakaoff rin attitude nila at pagsasalita eh. Inistan ko pa naman group na to.

[@jojochannel6713]

wala pa kasi akong narinig na singer na nagsabi na live po yan after nila kumanta. Mayron pero they are referring to other singersz

[@tintinsajona8677]

Oops 🤭

[@tintinsajona8677]

I do stan Max siya lang talaga. Di ko makitaan ng yabang and may humility. Yung the rest parang scripted na lang pagiging "humble" nila lalo na sa vlogs nila.

[@shootoki]

Halatang lipsync ito haha kay joker halatang halata

[@BunchOfRandomness]

Hindi ako fan nung isang ppop boygroup but they got my respect and admiration( esp with bakit ba ikaw & tilaluha) bcoz : 1. Malinis ang vocals (3out of 5) nila esp when they harmonise. 2. Hindi sila pa cute, awkward or camera conscious. When they face the camera they are themselves but still acts prepared, mannered& dignified. To be honest the guy in red or maroon is the most pogi looking (siya lang ang pogi ata dito) yet he appears to be the most awkward. 3. They sing the words of their songs clearly & with correct feelings. ~The guy wearin cap shouldve practiced his pronounciation & enunciations. Yes, kasama po sa voice lession yun and proper singing. Maraming super galing kumanta na hindi fluent sa language ng song na kinakanta pero maganda pa rin ang outcome, this one is soo cring(e)y 4. They are not half cooked. They were let out prepared and well packaged. What these aspiring guys need: Practice. Perform. Repeat perf in needed. Til makuha ng maganda. Everyone starts at some point. Pero sana they were groomed to be at par sa contemporary nila. They were definitely not trained & groomed enough. Like this video, bago man lang sana inupload ito ay chineck nila, crinitisize at inedit. Im thinking tuloy if mataas lang ba ang standard ko sa music at perf or di lang tlga maayos. i once read, HARDWORD is another word for miracle

[@moniquem7384]

Kindly watch their wish bus Performance and their latest mv 'OH'. Nagiimproved na po sila, i think. Salamat po

[@dareusliamdeleon4778]

Agree

[@marygracebercilla310]

For those people na laging idinadahilan yung pagiging Newbie nila everytime na sinasabihan silang kailangan pa nilang mag improve Fact in the Philippines. "Ok lang kahit hindi pa sila ganon kagagaling kase Newbie pa lang naman yung group nila e" one of the reason kung bakit hindi umuunlad ang ekonomiya ng Pilipinas. Wag nyo sabihin na OA yung mga tao na nagsasabi ng totoo sa group na ito na kailangan pa nilang mag improve. Hindi porket sinabihan sila na hindi sila ganon kagagaling at kailangan pang mag improve yung pagiging NEWBIE nila ang idadahilan nyo, then sasabihin nyo na OA at masyadong harsh yung mga nagcocomments ng ganon? The fact na nag debut sila ibig sabihin lang non handa na sila sumabak sa mundo ng Pilipinong musika na kung saan balak iparating sa buong mundo. The fact na nag debut sila dapat magagaling na talaga sila from the start, kase kung hindi pa sila ganon kagagaling dapat hindi muna sila idinebut at pinatagal pa sana ang training. Para kang sundalong sumabak sa gyera na hindi pa handang makikipagbakbakan at sumagip ng buhay. Kapag namatay ang taong dapat sasagipin mo hindi maaaring idahilan mo na kase hindi pa sapat yung oras at ensayo na naranasan nung sundalo. Kase yung fact na isinama ka sa gyera ibig sabihin lang nun handa kana. So hindi nyo pedeng idahilan yung pagiging newbie nila, lalo na kapag sinasabihan silang hindi ganon kagaling at kailangan pang mag improve. Hindi rin maiiwasan ang ganong mga comments lalo nat pag dating sa PPOP mayroon ng standard na grupo. Hindi sinasabi na kailan nilang maging katulad ng grupo na yun to the point na babaguhin nila yung sarili at ugali nila. Kung gusto talaga nila makahakot ng maraming fans kailangan nilang pumantay dun sa group na yun or better mahigitan yung group na yon. But as of now, wala pang nakakahigit or nakakapantay sa group na yun so kailangan pa nila ng matinding ensayo.

[@tintinsajona8677]

To be really honest. May room for improvement kahit sa SB19 magaling na sila pero dapay iimprove pa din sila. Dito kasi sa 1st. One parang sinabak lang ng basta basta kasi matunog ang Ppop ngayon. I tried to comment before sa mga videos nila na wag muna silang idebut since hilaw pa even sa dance. Yes mahusay na pero on some part parang nagsasapawan pa din paao pa kaya kapag nag live vocals sila. Sa isang group kasi hindi pwede na gumawa ka lang dapat ibuild up yung chemistry and di ko marandam sa kanila yun. If 3 years silang nag-practice kuno, dapat kahit medyi flawless okay na. Pero parang hindi ata sila 3 years nag training.

[@marygracebercilla310]

Kaya nga e. Ang sakin lang naman dapat matuto silang tumanggap ng mga harsh comments sa mga idol nila. Kase yun yung way para mamotivate at mas gumaling pa yung mga idol nila. If yung main goal nila is to dominate the world dapat ready na sila sa mga harsh comments na matatanggap at hindi na sinasabihan ng OA. Even kpop trainee nakakatanggap ng mga harsh comments mula sa mga producers para mag excel pa yung talent skills nila. Like for example, in ILand Show na popular ngayon as a survival show to be an idol. Their are trainees na nakakatanggap talaga ng mga harsh comments from the producers, it is not because they want to embarass them but to improve their trainees talent skills. Yung ibang trainee na yun wala pang taon na nag tatrain at every time na nagkakatanggap sila ng mga harsh comments never kong nakita yung mga fans nila na sinabing OA yung producer na bakit sinasabihan sila ng mga harsh ay babago pa lang naman silang mag training. Just like 1st one, dapat yung mga fans nila ready tumanggap ng mga harsh comments hindi yung tatanggap nga sila ng harsh comments pero lagi nilang binibigyang kasunod na "Kase newbie pa lang sila, kaya ganon" If they want for global domination hindi pepwedeg sinasabihan nilang OA yung mga taong nagsasabi lang ng tototoo. It was just my opinion lang naman.

[@shootoki]

Feels like months lng sila nagpractice ni dipa nila kayang magsing live tulad sa music and letters tf nagllipsync na nga di pa maayos lmao

[@tintinsajona8677]

@@shootoki nag guest sila sa music and lyrics? in all honestly, i was supporting them kaso nung nakita ko and how their management handle the situation lalo na nung naglapag yung SBT ng plano for SB19 para na butt hurt ang 1st. One management at naglabas ng statement and the statement was puro yabang lang.

[@tintinsajona8677]

I am not really sure talaga if nag train sila ng more than 3 years because I doubt e. Hindi ganitong skills ang pinapakita ng newbie knowing nagtraining sila.

[@julaiachuchu3865]

Dito swerte ang sb19 kay Sejun, napakateknikal nya sa vocals, alam nya ang proper distribution, alam nya kelan maghaharmonize at hindi, alam na alam nya ang weakness at strengths ng bawat isa sa sb19. We all know na struggling sa pagkanta si Josh, sya lage napupuna sa bakit ba ikaw, pero sya ang lumamon sa big bang cover sa asap, why? Because di porke magaling ka kumanta akma na sayo ang bawat genre. Given sa 1st one nasa tono naman kaso may super lamang, may super ano din (i dont want to use a bad word so ill leave it to you guys). They need vocal coach kasi kelangan ng proper distribution lang, di pwede sabay sabay huy. Polish muna sana bago upload, saka na iupload ung mga behind the scene.

[@tintinsajona8677]

kung sa musicality lang naman at pag gawa ng kanta kay sejun pa din. makakagawa ng ibang kanta ang iba na astigin at maganda tune pero pagdating sa lyrics na hindi cringe at malalim ang kahulugan kay sejun pa din talaga. hopefully sa next comeback ng SB19 hiphop na maaala Bigbang ang gawin nilang kanta.

[@calmsunflower3128]

Naalala ko tuloy yung birthday message ni Jah para sa kanya lalo na yung part na sinabi ni Jah na nung trainee days nila, tinuturuan daw siya ni Sejun kumanta lalo pa't wala talaga siyang background pagdating sa singing even though kelangan din ni Sej magpractice. And I think even until now ganun parin siya. Yung Your Love na cover ni Jah, si Sej din tumulong sa kanya, vocal-wise. Wala lang, nasoft lang ako sa pinunso 👉🏻👈🏻

[@felicitymae9677]

@@calmsunflower3128 uy grabe si Pinuno🤧❤️ mas Lalo ko tuloy minahal

[@felicitymae9677]

@Lothlorein Avila hehehehe 💙

[@trixie_kaye6422]

No amount of training would otherwise make someone's vocals an instant professional singer. Natural voice comes with every human as a gift through birth. Because training cannot make miracles and go against Law of Nature and Science (genetically). What training can do? Is teach you the proper manner and usage of your voice, and not to become someone whom you are not.

[@jaslising2827]

Can't fathom how some A'tin chose this group over SB19 😂 STAN TALENT, STAN SB19!!! 🔥💙

[@EGM1425]

Hala weh?😆 Baka di naman talaga totoong A'TIN yun, kunware lang kaya naging transformer kasi hinihintay talaga itong group na to?

[@alexanicobon6074]

Mga transformerrrssss beh

[@gemini7273]

They stan because of the BEAT and QUALITY of the mv. Yun lang HAHAHHAHAHA na excite ng todo

[@engr.j2261]

Yepp diko din get bakit ang bilis nung iba magstan? Hahahaha. Ako nga bago ko naging fan ng sb it takes weeks. As in sinuri ko muna tlga sila from talent, charm, personality, live performances, song quality, interviewss, vlogss lahat hahahaha. Tas ung iba nacutan lng sa isang member stan na lols hahahha

[@jaslising2827]

@@engr.j2261 True. Realquick. Makikita naman sa vocals and attitude palang wala na silang binatbat sa SB19.

[@reynanvaliao]

Advise, wag kayong masyadong magfocus sa pagpapacharm. Focus on your craft then charm will follow.. Sing like it's not being recorded. Chances kase, nap'pressure kayong magpaimpress kaya siguro nagkakaroon ng sharps and flats just to prove your vocal ability. Pronunciation din, syllabication, song choice din.. Maybe it's not the song to showcase your talents. Like yung rap part.. Harmonizing is pretty good naman. But again, wag mapressure sa camera kase it's like you're harmonizing just for the sake of harmonizing.. Just sing your parts then it will turn out natural. Kaya niyo yan!

[@moniquem7384]

Kindly watch their Wish Bus Performance kzbin.info/www/bejne/enKpdpmMnKmtbdU and also their latest mv 'OH' kzbin.info/www/bejne/h6bVpmZmp5eIncU You can see their improvements po, I think. Salamat po!!!

[@reynanvaliao]

@@moniquem7384 ahhh oo.. Mas naappreciate ko nga live Ttak Maja Nuh sa Wish.. 👍👍👍

[@ChristadelleBazar]

Thank you for trying but that is Ed Sheeran's song you just murdered. Super fan ako ni Ed since kinanta nya yung OST ng Desolation of the Smaug, The Hobbit Trilogy. This is before sumikat yung Thinking Out Loud nya. It seems there is potential but please respect the artist by doing good cover naman po... hayyyssss... doesn't have to be as good as Ed's version pero naman po.. Please raise our flag by rehearsing the song and executing it properly. Sana nag pacute na lang kayo since yun naman inatupag nyo buong bidyo.

[@anjcruz1408]

Dapat hindi na nilagyan ng rap kasi maganda na ang song.More practice manood kau ng Live Performance ng SB19 sa MYX lalo na ang Bakit Ba Ikaw makakakuha kayo ng tips dun. Saka kumanta din kau ng LIVE wag puro dance.

[@alishad.4396]

Hindi niyo naman masisisi mga harsh comments. Ano ba sila? Trainees? Mas mauunawaan pa namin yun eh. Pero potaena, paano nakapag debut ang mga to? HAHAHAHA

[@lendahandful]

preach! i think wala namang nag-expect sa audience na perfect yung vocals nila, pero sobrang dami lang ng palya dito na mapapaisip ka kung bakit na-approve 'to for posting lol

[@cassandra2220]

I think, they should be stable enough bago mag debut, kase debut palang yun e. What if live performance na, sila din mag i-struggle

[@AtheneHeart]

Need need more more practice, sa totoo dapat nasa training pa sila. They don't work as a group daming sapawan na nangyayari ang mostly hindi pa marurunong kumanta. Di tayo pwedeng di pumuna kasi mas di sila tatangkilikin ng mga manonood kung ganito ang e offer nila. Just saying lang po ito, go back in training di pa po kayo handa. No short cut in success. Real talk lang malayong malayo pa kayo sa SB19. Gawin nyo silang inspiration para mas gumaling pa kayo. I hope makita namin sa inyo so much passion and dedication ng SB19 sa kanilang craft.

[@trixie_kaye6422]

MISMO. Exactly my point is.

[@random1861]

Ilang months na yan

[@jenniferjoiedizon7641]

d ako singer pero ndi ako nagandahan lalo na kapag nagsasabay sabay kau ndi siya magandang pakinggan aww more practice pa at much better panoorin niyo abg sb19 para makakuha kau ng mga tips 😍

[@imnotok3073]

I don't know. The rap is a mess, please work on it.

[@justpassingby6546]

Totoo. Yung J maganda ang flow needs improvement n alang. Yung dalawa sorry di talaga maganda pakinggan.😭

[@jhoncarloalejo1206]

Same cguro maganda if walang rap part change Melody nalang Sana or nag mash up NG konti

[@theanicolerodriguez9378]

now I know why people always react to esbi live singing na 'lip sync raw', they are promoting ppop and here you are showing this, proving people about lip sync thingy. And you have the guts to put live huhuhu I'm sad.

[@primabacarro4239]

Di po lip sync ang esbi, ano ba naman yung iba haha. Napanood ko yung sa isa nilang performance and nagkaron ng problem sa kuryente ata kaya nawala yung back up nila(not sure kung yan ang term) pero tuloy tuloy parin ang kanta, yung halata talagang kumakanta din sila. Part ni Stell yun e, chorus ng tilaluha yata. So yun lang po, sorry if not connected sa video:)

[@jillagon1492]

Not a fan or hater pero umpisa plang bagsak na yung boses tapos nagsunod sunod na yung flats at sharps parang domino effect ang nangyari. Meron din mispronunciation Awkward din yung angle ng camera For me,3 voices lang maririnig ko out of 7 na taong kumakanta ( ewan ko sa ibang nakarinig) Nasobrhan din sa paglaro ng kanta kaya nasisintonado . D ko sure kung sino main nio jan ಥ_ಥ Practice lang ng practice idol . Looking forward to be one of the best performing group not only in ph :D

[@ealicer81]

sana hindi ganito ang harmonization nyo sa mga live performances nyo kundi patay tayo jan

[@cjcua7928]

You all too cute. Your voices as re awesome

[@rommelt5223]

You can easily spot that they need more practice and polish their harmony.. a bit cringey .. somehow theres something lacking with them. Connection and impact with the audience maybe.

[@gulonyotalaga]

parang mga pasaway lang na di sumunod sa lockdown na pinakanta sa presinto bilang parusa

[@mshaninah4513]

LOL

[@hintmE1000]

Huy 🤭

[@cassandra2220]

WTH AHSHAHAHHAA

[@Rheda-el2lv]

Pang videoke party lang hahaha kulang na lang bucket of san mig and pulutan ... not only more more practice bur also more more meetings and know each other weaknesses and help each other to improve mukha kasing nagsasaoawan kayo kaya nawawala sa alignment kung group kayo move as a group ... my opinion so pag andyan kayo sa larangan na to accept different kinds of criticism from different kinds of people

[@imnotok3073]

Vocals are unstable and rap is not that clean, like you need to work on the flow. And improve the pronunciation too, it affects the perf so much. I hope you could consider this before your debut.

[@pattys5934]

True. I hope di paspasan ang debut nila. Kasi nako po! Kamote!

[@estleniones162]

I agree. I noticed on how they pronounce each words . It sounds awkward to me. They need to practice a lot and guys are more attractive/handsome/cute with a decent look. I understand because they are new as a group.

[@hushbunn-etc8012]

Yes I agree, they are all over the place. Kailangan nila talaga nang GUIDE or TEACHER para i-correct yung mga kailangang itama. Parang over-all polishing kumbaga. Kasi whether they like it or not, ma ikukumpara tagala sila sa ibang gropo na may na set na na standard. Kaya ninyo yan! Rise PPOP!!!

[@spyvljhn]

MAGANDA NAMAN E!!!

[@Sugarmhobi_Jin_V_Jiminkook7]

True... Di kasi Alam ng iba ang apat na boses or SATB... Hindi sila ng unison lang or ung soprano na boses lang. Akala nila flat ung naririnig nila. Nasanay kasi sila sa cover na ang gamit na boses ay soprano lang o kaya ung soprano saka ang 2nd voice na alto... Kelan ko lang napanood mga panlalait ng iba sa cover na ito...grabe sila... Eh now nasa Warner music na ang 1st.One...💜

[@cath8924]

THE CRINGE LEVEL AND SECOND HAND EMBARRASSMENT OF THIS WHOLE COVER , BOYS PRACTICE MORE. YOUR VOICES TOGETHER LACK CHEMISTRY AND HARMONIZATION

[@moniquem7384]

Kindly watch their Wish Bus Performance of their song Ttak Maja Nuh as well as their latest Mv 'OH' , you can see their improvements po... Salamat po

[@maeolaco9551]

Sorry but I think you just need to watch SB19's myx live performance of tilaluha & bakit Ba ikaw their vocals & harmonization there are all perfect & on point 👌 Swear!! By just watching them You can get an ideas and techniques on how to improve your performance. This is just a suggestion. Thank you.

[@densmonday8031]

Oo nga wala naman sigurong masama if you will look up to your seniors diba? Para gawin silang role model...😊

[@damielreyes]

Parang walang nag babass na tone sa kanila puro high notes tapos parang nagtatagisan sila at hindi nagbleblend yung harmonies nila unlike sb19

[@imanoob7920]

OK sama ako sa inyo !

[@enen9058]

Kailangan talaga nila matutunan ang Dynamics ng music in terms of harmonization(ism) para mas maganda pakinggan walang nahuhuhuli, walang nangingibabaw. Alamin din nila kung kailan ang tamang pagpasok ng isa pagkatapos kumanta nung nauna. Pakinggan din nila kung saan nababagay boses nila para walang sapawan na nagaganap pag nag harmonize na. ( atin here )

[@maryjessagalarion9248]

buti naLang taLaga nauna SB19.

[@paolohadap3725]

sakit sa tenga daming sharp at flat tapos ung mga runs and rift ang sagwa di manlang tumatama sa nota

[@darknight7417]

✔️

[@ejkyuttkyutt8432]

Edi wag ka manood

[@shainaalgamde657]

Masyado kasi nagmamadali e hahahhahha tapos sino yung isa hahahha buset hahahhaha

[@aizaabag2989]

@@shainaalgamde657 kanina pa kita nakikita sa comment section HAHAHAHAHA

[@shainaalgamde657]

@@aizaabag2989 kaya nga po eh HAHAHA

[@john2355]

Not that perfect, there's some flats and they need more practice but I was proud because they do their best and I love the rap part

[@MsAikofficial]

Rap part is 👏

[@wafukira03]

True ka dyan john pero proud parin kc pinoy yan dapat proud tyo more practice lng yan sabi nga ng sb19 practice never betray you!

[@lennethcruz2996]

Dpat tlga sila ung sinusupport mga opm

[@jaeemaguilar6396]

kung gusto mo perfect yun original na kumanta nalang pakinggan mo😁

[@gairingengmei3267]

This is a rough recording yaar ...u know low bugget u know ...still a starter

[@cjcua7928]

You guys sound beautiful

[@abbeybercasio2283]

Uhm. This song is a wedding song (hint: when I saw you in that dress). The lines in the rap parts are not appropriate at all to the entirety of the song’s message. Also, unless you can spit sick bars, please don’t attempt to add rap part into an already beautiful song. For a group that’s just starting and members not equally proficient in singing - SIMPLE IS ALWAYS BEST. You just added too much into the song when you could have just sang it as is. It would have made the performance better. The leader (the one in the middle) & the blond guy have some vocal ability but the rest need serious training on melodic singing and DICTION. Diction is REALLY important when you’re singing a song in English - without proper diction it would sound as if you’re singing Karaoke. Please practice some more and tone down the performances a bit. Find an arranger who would arrange songs for your group given the limitations in vocal ability. Maybe start with Tagalog songs - I think you’d be more comfortable singing them. Don’t rush things. And please please please watch your performance before you post it on social media.

[@moniquem7384]

Kindly watch their Wish Bus Performance of their song Ttak Maja Nuh as well as their latest Mv 'OH' , you can see their improvements po... Salamat po

[@pattys5934]

You guys need more practice. I dont hear one band singing. Sapawan. That rap is good but a little off. Also, you guys need acting skills. I mean, be presentable when the camera is rolling. Some of the boys are too smug on this video. Wear some class and be romantic. Also Create your individuality since madami kayo sa group. Anyway, I hope you guys improve tho. Make us proud. #PPOPRise

[@moniquem7384]

Hello ate

[@pattys5934]

@@moniquem7384 hiii

[@strie_ke103]

Try to form your own identity as a group, be your self guys all the comments here are not to bash but to improve you as an IDOL.

[@maryfayeramos196]

I have a simple tip for you 1st one, stop trying hard sa pag papacute kasi feeling ko mas na focus kayo sa pag papa cute tapos yung nasa kaliwa ni max parang sobra yung self confidents nya like kayang kaya ko to basic lang to ganyan yung feeling ko habang kumakanta sya sobrang tumaas ang self confidents hindi ko sinasabi na masamang mag ka self confidents pero sumobra kasi hahahaha and one more thing medyo nakaka cringe yung pag ha harmonized nyo kasi nag sasapawan kayo dapat yung mind nyo laging naka focus na isa kayongg group at kailangan ng pag kakaisa..siguro kailangan nyo pa ng more training masyado kasi kayong nag madali unlike sb19 makikita mo yung passion nila sa kanilang craft atsakaa yung hard working nila.. a legend said "practice never betray you" and all A'tin knows who is that legend and another one "no shortcut in succes" if you guys didnt know who is that legend better search it... PS.THIS IS JUST MY OWN OPINION

[@moniquem7384]

Kindly watch their Wish Bus Performance kzbin.info/www/bejne/enKpdpmMnKmtbdU and also their latest mv 'OH' kzbin.info/www/bejne/h6bVpmZmp5eIncU You can see their improvements po, I think. Salamat po!!!

[@Sugarmhobi_Jin_V_Jiminkook7]

Yung pinagtawanan nila ang cover na ito at may ilan pa na personal atake na ang ginawa. Tapos si Ed Sheeran is secretly nagustuhan pala ito. What if one day, maybe someday magcocollab ang 1st.one at si Ed Sheeran... kasi dinig ko ung SATB voices sa part na they sing together...

[@justpassingby6546]

Oh di ba nakikinig sila sa criticisms, they look neat here. Sa kanta naman practice pa sa harmony mejo magulo. Hehe Sa rap part yung si J ok ang flow for me. Keep on improving pa, you need a lot to work on. I wonder if paano kayo magperform dancing while singing.

[@teresaa.2079]

Ikr ? Mga mukang nagsuklay at nakaligo sila. Hindi na nglilimahid as Pawis ! Lol ✌ good job guys❣

[@justpassingby6546]

@@teresaa.2079 trueee. Hahaha di na rin super dark outfit nila.. Maaliwalas na hahaha

[@atinjes8937]

Yung huling nagrap hindi nakasabay sa music. Listen to it carefully

[@victorui2944]

I'm not professional in regards to this, but I'll just want to attach my comments here. May flats talaga, kasi natataasan sila sa music, totoo naman ding mahirap tong kanta na ito. Na try na ba nila'ng mag acapella? Then hindi stable yung pag hold nila ng note. Hindi sabay mag start even mag end. Iidentify kung saan mag sosoft or strong and magpalakas or magpahina ng boses. 0:13 dive right in, di ko alam kung gusto ba ikulot pero di lang makuha... Pwede namang plain lang na dive (~\_) ito kasi narinig ko ( ~\/) 0:34 pag transit ng nag solo di ako sure kung nahihirapan sya, pero kung oo, dapat hindi na lang sumali sa pagsabay... Nasisira kasi, kung hindi naman nahihirapan, huwag lang lakasan ang boses. 0:43-0:45 di ko alam kung harmony ba dapat dito o dapat bang may umangat na boses and note. 2:13 ibahin, ang pangit sorry sa word. 3:01 ibahin din, baka kaya ni max. Sa harmony, dapat sigurong ihiwalay yung matataas at mababa na boses... Like ace and max matataas, practice.x lang, tama para sa solo. Yung mga nag rap, mababang boses ok naman. Tapos dapat sigurong yung mouth naka o form, kaya sigurong may umiiba na pronounce kasi naka smile. Pwede naman look like smiling, lift mulang yung cheek and eyes mo while naka ow form yung mouth, kung di pa pro. And May iba na hindi sure sa next word. kaya may mga mmmmmm akong naririnig This are just my observation. Im not bashing them cause I'm also one of the person here, looking forward na sumikat din sila. ☺️

[@alyssacarlem-filipino7562]

Lol i cringe so much

[@marie-zl8hx]

Not so perfect but i love it there's a chemistry of each member....but the the boys wearing white shirt is a bop when he is rapping.please be more confidence..💙💙💙💙 jayson i see you..dont be shy ok !

[@edithabaldonado9488]

HELLO KSWA NA KAU PURO COMPARE SA SB19..PURO MORE PRACTICE ANO BE NEMEN YEN..PURO PG DA DOWN GNAGWA NYO SA GRUPO TNKFUL NLANG TAU NABI2GYAN CLA NG CHANCE MY WORK CLA NA NKA2TULONG SA PMILYA NLA..GYA NLANG NI JASON NG DHIL SA #KMJS NDISCOVER CYA SO TNKFUL NBAGO BUHAY NYA KHIT MSAKIT MPALAU SA NANAY NYA DHIL SA GRUPO TIIS2 LNG PRA LNG SA FUTURE NLA...OA NYO NMN SA GRUPO....

[@moniquem7384]

Kindly watch their Wish Bus Performance of their song Ttak Maja Nuh as well as their latest Mv 'OH' , you can see their improvements po... Salamat po...

[@keyboardwarrior495]

Astig kinilabutan tlga ako sa pgka cover 👊 Nang bakit ba ikaw ng SB19 😘😍🥰

[@marinolramos2883]

HAHAHA LEGIT LAUGH 😂😂 KAPSS

[@aprilflores7316]

HAHAHAH

[@scablet]

ok na po sa sayaw pero need more training po s vocals. okay naman po yung Music Video nyo...pero alam nyo kung saan dumami at nakahatak ng maraming fans ang PPOP legends natin? sa live performances ....most especially live vocals nila. so yon lang tip lang. konting training pa.

[@moniquem7384]

Kindly watch their Wish Bus Performance kzbin.info/www/bejne/enKpdpmMnKmtbdU and also their latest mv 'OH' kzbin.info/www/bejne/h6bVpmZmp5eIncU You can see their improvements po, I think. Salamat po!!!

[@emceeb5289]

Papogi>Skills

[@teresaa.2079]

Sana binigyan nila ng mas mahabang time mag training ang mga to . Mas mahahasa mga skills nila . . Sayang kasi e. Pnupush ng sb19 ang PPOp Rise ! Pero qng balik putchu putchu nanaman ang performance wla din. 😔 😔 aminim man natin o hindi makikita tlg ang difference between sa nag training ng ilang taon kesa sa buwan LNG. Pero goodluck prin sa debut nyo . At sana sinama nyo nlng sa line up si gift . Pra hindi sya lulubog lilitaw sa mga content nyo. Para syang Saling ketket e. Chos. ! Push nyo na yan na 7 kyo. ✌ Goodluck

[@moniquem7384]

Kindly watch their Wish Bus Performance kzbin.info/www/bejne/enKpdpmMnKmtbdU and also their latest mv 'OH' kzbin.info/www/bejne/h6bVpmZmp5eIncU You can see their improvements po, I think. Salamat po!!!

[@claribelargibiador4006]

Not ganna lie this is the WORST I EVER HEARD like what is this? Intro palang basag na really? Hindi niyo po masisisi ang mga harsh comments. NEVER EVER RUSH. Halss qiqil niyo ko

[@moniquem7384]

Kindly watch their Wish Bus Performance of their song Ttak Maja Nuh as well as their latest Mv 'OH' , you can see their improvements po... Salamat po

[@Yumicotv]

I think they should not do a mix with tagalog not making sense to me. I can see also that they need to do voice lesson some of them sounds sabog do to improper singing thats why they were missed notes. And the second guy to the left that opening look si a shade. Remember its a group and you need to leave the personal issues behind.

[@leesooyoung299]

Mico Bullangay they are trying to imitate sb19 adding rap but its doesnt fit🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️ So cringy😩😩 di ko kayang tapusin sorry😭

[@Yumicotv]

Like if they wanted to really shine they need to he innovative something original. Not we have seen before..

[@brandonkitkitan2272]

Nag cringe ako sa unang rapper putek hahaha

[@spyvljhn]

Unique talaga boses ni kuya regalo. Mas maganda at sweet naman kay ace mahal. At kina kuya max, j, joker, jayson, and alpha ay masarap sa tenga'ng pakinggan.

[@erinpeyton6929]

Saan na si gift?

[@Haru-wf7qb]

Mga bugok yan

[@joefrybachoco2130]

Here's my opinion for your improvement: - You still gotta need to work on your harmonization. May ibang parts na pagsabasabay lahat sinasabayan ng high notes. Dapat may nagsusupport din ton each other. - May mga parts na masakit din sa tenga due to flats. - Yung pronunciation dapat i-practice. Nagtutunog may mali kasi tapos sasabayan pa ng flats so panget pakingan na. Sabog. Still looking forward for your improvement.

[@justpassingby6546]

Dun din sa rap parts di maganda pakakaputol sa words. ✌️

[@chilltengco1100]

Kulang ba sa base tama ba kaya pag sabay sabay na di masyado timpla

[@justpassingby6546]

Paano pa kaya while performing na ng sing and dance noh? I wonder if they can do it live

[@joefrybachoco2130]

@@justpassingby6546 exactly especially pat may sayaw. Di ganun ka stable pa voice nila and from what I've heard e June na debut. Masyadong minadali.

[@justpassingby6546]

@@joefrybachoco2130 I just wish them the best. They only have 2 months to prepare, kahit atleast sana sa dancing they do good sa synchronisation

[@밒-i4m]

Aysuin niyo naman hamonization niyo. Wala ba diyan electric fan? Mukhang init na init kayo diyan ah

[@litom.salido1112]

Lol lt

[@darknight7417]

😂😂😂

[@spyvljhn]

PARA SAKIN OKAY 'TO.

[@jamxd8791]

Pinag mamayabang Ng fans nyo na di kaya Ng SB19 makipagsabayan HAHAHAHAHA tapos kayo pala tong ...aytsss baka pag nag unsubscribe Yung mga A'tin malagas kayo HAHAHAHAH

[@co-atinandjpopfanatic2067]

Uy, 'wag ganun😢 Remember what our PINUNO said?

[@trialanderror841]

Just an advice okay? ☺️ Tryna record your own voices first then pakinggan nyu sarili nyu individually. Then enhance ang part na dpat eh enhance. Importante kasing marunong Kang making sa sarili mong boses wag Yung push lng ng push. Also, Yung harmony... Pakinggan nyu Yung isat isat. Medjo damjng flat and Sharp then shaky minsan and unstable. But, I know guys that u can do it in time. Practice more and comeback stronger okay? ☺️☺️ Me as an A'Tin will be waiting for that moment. ☺️☺️ Keep going guys ❤️☺️

[@jhoncarloalejo1206]

Nag try din ako mag record NG boses ko jusko delete agad 😂😂😂😂

[@auroragrace4151]

@@jhoncarloalejo1206 lol same 😂

[@wynbd]

Hello po ang masasabi ko lg focus po kayo sa timing sa pagkanta and sa pagble-blend ng voice since madami kayo basta more more practice cause practice will never betray you. Goodluck!

[@kontwo]

Impressive naman yung MV nila to be honest and no question about the dancing. But they really need to work on their vocals. Medyo sablay talaga. At wag sana silang ma-offend if they are compared with the other senior group. Actually, they should be expecting that and they should have been prepared for that. The question is, are they ready to take that challenge? The expectation is high. But goodluck regardless.

[@dollyjaneantalan9885]

Paano nalang kung live na sumasayaw na sila at kakanta, akoy nag aaalala, sana ma figureout nila yan baka ma criticize sila lalo😭😭 Masyado kasi mataas ang ginawang Standards na ginawa ng SB19 alam ko namang walang perpekto sa mundo, pero practice will neve betray you talaga

[@c0rpsecr0iX]

@@dollyjaneantalan9885 yan una kong naisip. Sablay na dito, papano pa kung live na tapos sumasayaw pa. 🤦

[@maryfayeramos196]

@@dollyjaneantalan9885 true sb19 is a king of ppop...sb19:indured? No problem,3 mics? No problem,singing acapella?no problem Thats how professional sb19 they set a high standard for ppop..the only problem i see in this group masyado silang kampante siguro akala nila madali lang ang mga gagawin nila becouse of achievements of sb19..but they are wrong andaming hard ship ang pinag daanan ng sb19 and sacrifices you will see the passion of there craft and the hard work kaya kudos for sb19 and for 1st one they need more training

[@miratan3782]

@@maryfayeramos196 my kulang pa sa pep interviews TILALUHA 2 mics gamit nila doon

[@rainsdump]

@@dollyjaneantalan9885 Sa choreo ng You Are The One, kinakabahan ako para sa kanila, ang hirap at energetic masyado ng choreo nila dun at dito na nga medyo sablay na, so what if pa sa live performance

[@charliemannpiego7691]

Akala ko naman kung ano na....... Sila ba ang reason na kino-compare sa SB19 yung video raw ng song nila better daw sa "Go Up" LOL tawa na lang ako. Tapos kinu-compare niyo visual ng SB19 over them????? Una sa lahat, yung visual, it changes kasi tumatanda tayo. People grow, people changes physically. But what makes us memorable is how people would remember you as an artist. May talent, hindi ibig sabihin marunong lang sumayaw o basta maka-kanta lang. Iba yung marunong kumanta at sumayaw doon sa mayroong artistic quality. Eh hindi nga magmeet yung mga boses nito sa harmony pa lang hahahahha Sorry super obvious. Lakas magharmony mga sintunado naman. Lipsync na lang 'to hindi pa magkasundo. Akala ko naman, kayabang ng korean promoter asus, kumuha ka ng kayang bumenta ng album niyo. Ung may boses. O kung hindi photo album na lang i-release. Kahit photo album pa yan hindi ako bibili.

[@maryfayeramos196]

True kino comper nila to sa sb19 sa visual? Eh kung visual lang din ang pag uusapan lamang na agad ang sb19 kahit nung nag uumpisa palang sila hanggang ngayon consistent sila sa mga performance sila atsaka always humble sila..di tulad nitong 1st one na wala pang nararating yung asta ng mga kilos atsaka ng expression ng muka nila makikita mo na ang taas agad ng confidents mga sintunado naman...pagiging boygroup dapat nababalance ang pag sasayaw at kanta di pwedeng sayaw lang hindi din pwedeng kanta lang..kung maging kalang sa pag sayaw mag dancet kanalang pag sa pagkanta kalang magaling mag singer kanalang..they need more more practice wala pa sila sa kalingkingan ng sb19 eh...sb19 makikita mo talaga ang passion nila sa kanilang craft and hindi nag sasapawan kasi group yang pinasok nyo eh you need to be as one in group...atsaka sa sb19 makikita mo ang hard work and de dication nila..just saying hihihihi

[@jhoncarloalejo1206]

Kalma 😊 SB19 set the standard really high

[@burgerkasaken295]

Apaka layo talaga HAHA first debut ng SB19 7M HAHA wala talagang bagay na nadadala sa madalian dapat lahat talaga pinag igihan tas sasabihin nila gagalingan nila dapat umpisa palang nag workhard na sila jusko

[@hintmE1000]

Kalmahan Lang po

[@justbehappy8346]

Lets just support them both without any hate!! They are doing their best too just like SB19!!🥰🥰🥰🥰

[@foronerosebelleeguia1920]

Hey di nmn lahat tayo ay perfect tlga mag song...nagkkamali din wag husgahan agad,,malay mo kinabahan,,or something else,,nagsisimula plng nmn yn cla,,malay mo mag improve yn cla eh di mihiya tayo nyn,,,,sbe nga nila dont jugde him by itz cover

[@spyvljhn]

don't judge the book by its cover nga daw hehe. yeah right. saka may improvements naman na talaga~

[@Sugarmhobi_Jin_V_Jiminkook7]

Kung ito na pinaka perfect imperfection ng 1st.One, well maganda pa din kina labasan ha... Hindi kasi unison or soprano lang ang ginamit nilang voice dito sa part na they sing together. SATB or four voices...ang husay nga eh. Mahirap umawit with SAB or SATB na wala kang binabasa na may musical notes...

[@RKY99966]

Bakit ganito sila full of confidence, over confidence. Pero keep it up wag sana lumake ulo niyo guys.

[@louiefonim8552]

Hahaha true.. Lalo na ung leader.. 🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️

[@alexapalalay1209]

Just my opinion, there are some parts na maskit sa tenga. Y'all shouldn't rush anything, keep training. "Practice will never betray you". And be a little bit more humble. Also work on the charisma and style. Sana mag change rin yung iba ng hairstyle yung mas neat tignan. Y'all should really practice more and have something unique about your group and be original.

[@bernadethsomer7207]

I can see average talent and visual ....it may be harsh but todays boyband should be more competitive

[@moniquem7384]

Kindly watch their Wish Bus Performance of their song Ttak Maja Nuh as well as their latest Mv 'OH' , you can see their improvements po... Salamat po

[@spyvljhn]

J's rap is good! Wag kayong nega hehe.

[@katrinaroque]

Grabe improvements nyo HSKSJHEJSJ

[@alycapsify]

After watching their SHOUT OUT MV i rewatched this video and they really improved alot! Keep it up guyyyyys ypu can do it never give up!

[@myrnavergonio661]

How to be member Ng fans Ng 1st one..64 n..senior n

[@dareusliamdeleon4778]

Mahirap kasi yung kanta , may runs and riffs yan pag di ka maalam sa placement at di ka vocally agile, kaunting sablay andumi dumi na... Im very sure na marurunong tong mga to lalo si Max at si Ace, power vocals tonv mga to e 🤗 wrong choice of music lang. Very good na nagupload kayo nito kasi you can look back how far youve improved. Avoid unnecessary raps din. Just because you can doesnt mean you have to, kailangan isipin kabuuan ng kanta hindi yung "dapat lahat may spotlight" kahit back up vocals ka lang, ang laking part nun sa kabuuan ng song ha!

[@maeolaco9551]

Need to work more on your harmonization para di siya masakit sa tenga pakinggan.. Andami ding flats and sharps which is understandable naman since nagsisimula palang kayo to work on your vocals and dalawa Lang din ata sa inyo yung forte talaga yung pagkanta which is Si max & Ace Lang ata if I'm not mistaken, nagka clash din kasi yung mga voice nyo and feeling ko naglalamangan pa kayo dapat alam ng bawat Isa kung kailan yung tamang pasok sa kanta and one more thing is yung rap parts I'm sorry but di talaga siya maganda pakinggan yung pagkakaputol.putol ng words sa rap di siya tugma need to work on that too and Sana mas clear yung bigkas nyu ng words or enunciation nyo pangit kasi pakinggan na parang barok na English, Sana Mas mapag aralan nyu yung voice strength and weakness ng bawat Isa para alam nyu kung sino yung mas fit yung voice sa part ng kanta Hindi yung basta basta nyo nalang ipapasok. Last one is dapat intro palang maganda na yung pasok. Siya kasi yung magsiset ng mood ng kanta, Choose a member that will really fit his voice sa intro palang ng song. let's take SB19 as an example, Si Ken yung may pinaka unique yung voice for me and siya din yung taga intro palagi sa mge songs kasi bagay talaga sa kanya. Ayun Lang so Sana Itake nyo to as constructive criticism and make these things na something to work on and improve more. Everyone has always a room for improvement naman. God Bless!

[@justpassingby6546]

Honestly speaking sobrang hilaw pa nila for debut but I wish the best for them. Sana di minamadali yung debut. Clover naman kulang sa dancing but vocals and rap ang ganda pakinggan.

[@maeolaco9551]

@@justpassingby6546 Kaya nga eh parang sumabay Lang talaga sa agos ng kasikatan ng p-pop ngayun.. Aminin Mn natin o Hindi SB19 paved the way talaga for p-pop.

[@justpassingby6546]

@@maeolaco9551 kaya nga kaso sa sobrang fresh pa ni esbi ngayon palagi silang ikukumpara sa mga bagong magdedebut kasi sa totoo ang taas ng standard vocals pa lang, lalo na sa dancing.

[@maeolaco9551]

@@justpassingby6546 TRUE. Kaya pressure talaga sa mga new groups ngayun either dapat nilang mapantayan or higitan ang SB.

[@micah9208]

I agree on everything hahaha. Hindi na halos marinig yung melody dahil overpowering yung back up vocals. The rap parts are cringey in my opinion. They have a lot to improve and I hope they will improve.

[@Yangkai18]

Maraming nagandahan sa MV nyo, pero upon watching this vid, I realized na you need to work on your vocals which I know would require so much time. I know you will be lip syncing sa mga guests nyo from here on. What I wanna say is, this what makes SB19 superior. They know their game.

[@c0rpsecr0iX]

Sa mv p lang nila rinig na dun na kulang sila sa practice sa vocals. Then napanood ko toh. Ano na lang pala kung live performance. 🤦

[@hushbunn-etc8012]

@@c0rpsecr0iX idag-dag natin ang pronunciation ng English words. Sorry but nag-cringe talaga ako doon. Kahit we put SB19 out of the equation, ang mga spectators mismo ang matataas ang standards. And SB19 not only passed that criteria, but they gave more than the expected standard. Hopefully may GUIDE sila to point out some of the things that needs to be corrected. :-)

[@moniquem7384]

Kindly watch their Wish Bus Performance of their song Ttak Maja Nuh as well as their latest Mv 'OH' , you can see their improvements po... Salamat po

[@arquelyap8079]

ONE THING IS FOR SURE, HINDI KAYO NABUO SA PAG AUDITION, MAG BABARKADA SIGURO YANG MGA YAN.

[@tintinsajona8677]

Yup. They were dance group lang before na ginawang boygroup kaya siguro ganito. Mas maganda talaga kung nafilter e.

[@lunaamalthea1490]

I can't wait to hear their voices and to see them again. I hope that someday I can see them personally and I can see that they will be really successful.

[@hakdogmamamo9759]

Yung naka itim lang maganda boses yung iba puro pacute HAHAHHA

[@maeolaco9551]

It's good but needs a lot of improvement. Sorry but I think I need to cleanse my ears with SB19's Vocals & harmonization!

[@mimilim345]

Bat po parang mas nag focus sa pagpapacute? Cringey po. But still youve tried your best naman.

[@spyvljhn]

madami pa palang nadaan dito yieeee

[@fordalico6569]

I think kaya pumatok yung rising ppop boygroup na nauna sainyo kase may legit na training sila, hindi sila nagmamadali, and well-groomed sila. Im not a fan of SB19 pero malinis silang tingnan. Yung isang member ng group na to trying hard magpaka "hot/cool/ guy. Try nyo muna yung gentleman look baka bumagay. And one thing, lip-sync na nga lang hindi niyo pa mapractice ng maayos

[@allison_innit8328]

@mimi kim I agree sayo.

[@mayannsaet5696]

@mimi kim HAHAHAHAH..I AGREE WITH U..

[@patricjames5784]

@mimi kim no sis, they need those criticisms and accept it to be more better than before. Criticisms really means a lot especially to those artist who's just starting but they shouldn't be bashed.

[@dollyjaneantalan9885]

3 years sila nag train pero ewan ko bakit walang chemistry. Sana pag nag tagal na magustuhan ko din sila.

[@mbldnd]

@mimi kim 3 years? So it appears they just focused more on their dancing skills rather than balance everything and also hone their vocals. Kung 3 years na sila, tapos ganito parn kumanta hmmmm mukhang baka dapat 5 years bago sila nag debut

[@crazy_keightie]

I hope you have more training and not less than a year. Please learn from Kaachi. They are being criticized bec they werent in sync and the vocals needs improvement. Please debut after 2 years instead so you could have train better. Kaachi also do covers and even had a bit training in 1M dance studio. The vocal harmony should be perfect or almost perfect and the dance should be sync. Pls. Reconsider.

[@shobiemontecalbo4219]

Hahaha nakinig ako expect the unexpected pala..di ko narinig yung tmang blending .ansakit sa tenga ng harmonizing promise po..keep on praktis po.

[@maeolaco9551]

TRUE nagkaclash yung voice nila! Sakit sa tenga

[@shobiemontecalbo4219]

Yah puro nasa highnotes na di maabot tas pataasan pa..walang sumusuporta sa mababa para makita yung blending ng voice parang sumabog yung mic dahil sa di mgandang harmonize.more,more improvement..try nyo din po kaya yung 1000 times nyo gawin malay natin maabot nyo na yung pinilit nyo ihighnotes..hahaha just saying..

[@maeolaco9551]

@@shobiemontecalbo4219 I think kulang nila is bass, yung tulad nung Kay Ken ng SB19 ,siya yung nagbabalance sa harmonization eh.

[@shobiemontecalbo4219]

Yah .nalinis ko na tenga ko dahil kay jah at ken..hahaha Dapat di puro rapper kasi di naman okay yung iba eyy.di tuloy nag blend.dapat may dating yung pag harmonize.. hays

[@maeolaco9551]

@@shobiemontecalbo4219 TRUE haha

[@iamme2872]

Sana Hindi ko na lang pinlay to... Nawala tuloy yung pagkawow ko sa mv nyo huhuhu.. You need more practice with your vocals mga kuya... Next time pag kanta kyo wag nyo muna I upload.. Pag-aralan nyo muna... I'm really looking forward to seeing your improvement...

[@dawn8112]

Hoy pastilan, mura mog nagpresent sa classroom..

[@kwapdrz3071]

Perfect na sana naging imperfect pa.

[@charliemendoza3269]

HAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAH PINAKAHAVEY PO ANG COMMENT NITO!!!!

[@kwapdrz3071]

Charlie Mendoza ay havey po ba? Hehe sorre po ah. Napagutusan lang po ako na mag comment e. Weak po kasi kaibigan ko :)

[@juvelyx9654]

Hahaha Best comment hanep! Puro pa cute sila habang kumakanta wala namang Harmony.. Confidence level nila sobrang taas🥵 Cringe naman ..

[@neknosus9064]

HAHAHAHAHAHHA para naman pong perfect boses nyo 😂

[@lifewithjotv9977]

Bakit po parang pacute sana natural lang