Performing Artist Reacts to JIMN - Black Swan (BTS), MMA, Contemp Dance & I Need U SOLO (VOICEOVER)

[@Koko3op]

*PLEASE READ* As you can tell my mic DIED AND I HAD NO IDEA! All my reactions with Merv are MUTED!! So I had to voice over and add commentary on top, I hope you enjoy it. My heart bleeds. I'm quitting youtube!!!! I'll judge how these do, if they're awful then I'll just purge the rest :( * ALSOO, please notice, I RIDE hard for Jimin and eventually we won Merv over LOL so please, no disrespect in the comments. None of this is personal! JOIN My Discord server here : discord.gg/bqzExFfwand my Patreon for more exclusive content here: patreon.com/koko3op

[@hjban2977]

It is unfortunate that happened but thank you for your efforts, trying to remember & explaining what he was saying at that time. I understand what Mr. Merv was trying to say about extensions of arms, legs & torso & flexibility of spine & that is why when Jimin had first came to BigHit as trainee, he had a lot of difficulties adjusting his muscle memory from contemporary dance movements to Kpop/Hiphop dance movements. Pls, next time, would you asked Merv to explain about different of muscles usages & muscle memory between contemporary dance to Kpop/Hiphop dance? Also that video of young Jimin doing contemporary dance was taken when he was 1st year of high school(15 years old), which was about 1 year after he has started to learn contemporary dance & in my opinion it shows how remarkably gifted & dedicated Jimin is as a dancer that he has mastered that much contemporary skills & built that much dancer’s physics in such short periods of times & I think that is why all of his high school dance teachers were so against Jimin auditioning to become kpop idol instead of choosing to become a classical/contemporary dancer. Anyway, may I suggest you to show him this combine performance video posted by HYBE < I need you + I’m fine - kzbin.info/www/bejne/qmTSpWiebshrg6s > which shows BTS’s full performance more clearly just like dance practice video.

[@juliq1097]

Did you get the chance to show him kai

[@jnwhalien]

Thank You for the voice over! Don't quit! HAHAHA it's okay as long as we see more of Merv's reactions in the future. ☺️

[@sariel8406]

Get Merv to demonstrate while dancing on WATER. Otherwise he can take all the criticisms back. Thank you.

[@ItsMeAnn628]

All I have to say is that I’ve never seen Merv’s name in lights or heard of millions of people around the world scrambling to see him dance! Could it be he is a bit jealous of Jimin??? Bottom line, no one really gives a crap what Merv thinks…

[@KaityJanee]

I think it’s also important to remember that Jimin had to give up a lot of the contemporary technicalities to his dancing in order to blend well with the group since BTS’ choreography majorly consists of hip-hop movements. And he’s spoken about how difficult it was for him to unlearn that style and re-learn hip-hop dance. However, I think it’s really amazing that they still give Jimin room to have solos where he can refer back to his previous contemporary training.

[@Koko3op]

This is such a great point! Love it and also adds to the discussion to what’s changed! It adds to his versatility too.

[@lelali387]

They don't make it for him, but it's fits with his contemporary dancing style better so ofc jimin is the one who has contemporary & modern dance background.

[@amytakiguchi4390]

@@Koko3op Yes, I agree that it's different when Jimin has to work with the other members as they are not trained and yet it needs to look cohesive. Jungkook did a fantastic job, but I'm sure Jimin had to adjust himself in his performance since JK is not formally trained. Also, the comments about the clothing being restrictive and I think the timing of the MV could be factors. Jimin also has to practice the choreo of the other dances and he is not able to practice contemporary full time. I have heard other dancers say that it's a small percentage of dancers who can merge hip hop and contemporary and go back and forth as it uses different techniques. So glad you did not give up in showing how our Jimin shines. I think he's one of a kind!

[@elise9355]

And even the things that they don't have a contemporary/ modern choreographer that follows when, even if good the director choreographer that follows when know just idol hip- hop. Jimin just did two years of contemporary and stopped doing it whe debuted to completely making his own way in bts choreographys. Of course he is carrying some of things he did previously not just contemporary but even material arts or popping and for moves with technique like leg extensions he even needs another eye that knows about those things to correct him because you could see that in his years of school he had it.is clear and understanding that he lost some of his flexibility but i am very impressed that he was so good in just two years of school or that he has some of technique evn 8 years later without working in those moves

[@marinal.]

@@Koko3op yes

[@hjban2977]

Since Mr. Merv has pointed out about Jimin’s wrist, arms & legs are not extended fully & most fans in this comment section has only talked about Jimin’s contemporary dance skills, as a Korean, I am going to explain more detail of what other genres of dance skills that Jimin is utilizing in his dance movements to make his own unique dance style. The reason that Jimin’s wrists, arms & legs are not fully extended is because he is not just using contemporary dance technique but he is also using Korean traditional dance techniques that he has learned while studying in BuSan high school of Art as well as his Hiphop(Popping & Locking) techniques. For example, Jimin’s MMA ‘I need you’ dance performance is not only contemporary dance but it is also a modern interpretation of Korean traditional dance call ‘SalPuRi(살풀이)’. < SalPuRi, the Korean traditional dance - kzbin.info/www/bejne/q3iuk4uXnJVkfMU > And if you watch this video & many other Korean traditional dance performances, you would notice the similarities between many of Jimin’s dance movements & those of Korean traditional dancer’s movements, especially his hands, wrists, arms & shoulders movements.(also the way he some times raise tip of his foot, like in his solo dance in ‘Black Swan’ which is very typical Korean dance movements.) It is because Jimin is also combining a lot of Korean traditional dance techniques in his dance as well. For Contemporary/classical dance techniques, most of the time, the dancer’s arms, legs & torso are extended fully to create beautiful posture of body & dance lines in various discipline movements, but in Korean traditional dance, it is more about expressing & describing emotions through every parts of limbs with fluidity, water(like ocean wave)like movements & every movements are done with dancer’s breathe while using special breathing techniques call ‘DeulSoom(들숨: In hailing)& NalSoom(날숨: exhaling)’. Wrist & Arm movements dominate the Korean traditional dance, while they naturally grow from breathing, which in Korean philosophy is linked with spiritual energy (ki). Thus the focal point is on the chest and lung area, while the dance appears as a physical manifestation of a deep, personal emotion. Here is a video of Korean traditional dance lesson for basic Arm movements with breathing technique < kzbin.info/www/bejne/hX7daGSroLV-oLc > & dancers major in Korean traditional dance reacting to Jimin’s dance performances < kzbin.info/www/bejne/q6CzlI2hl7Boi80 > And that ‘Wrong’ jump in ‘I need You’ performance that Merv has pointed out is actually a dance technique which is based on Korean traditional dance movement that become a Korean B-boy/Hiphop/Modern dance technique call ‘Ja-Ban(자반)’! < ‘JaBan’ dance movement in Korean traditional dance ‘SaMoolNolyee’ - kzbin.info/www/bejne/bILcZ4ingb-GbJI > < learning’JaBan’ movement w/ Korean dance instructor - kzbin.info/www/bejne/gZnElYSXa7uHqZI > If we remember BTS’s 2018 MMA ‘Idol’ performance with spectacular intro, this particular jump movements was shown in that intro of Korean traditional performance to show fans & audiences that some parts of BTS’s ‘Idol’ choreography are actually based on ‘SaMoolNolYee’ dance movements, one of the well known Korean traditional dance.

[@daexrs]

This is so educational, and I think it adds so much to what we know and what we don’t know. I’m hoping they see this and can get a better grasp on why these movements are executed this way, it’s important to note that different cultures approach techniques in various ways, and some take on their own. Thank you for sharing this! 💜

[@kerryholland4822]

This is all excellent info!!! Thank you! I will also like to add, not all contemporary actually uses the pointed foot exclusively. I trained in contemporary also (in Britain) and even though some of the more technically advanced styles like Graham and Cunningham will have divisive point or flex foot, many more somatic and release styles will prefer a more relaxed approach. Same with wrists and hands.

[@hjban2977]

@@daexrs Glad to be of help. ☺️💜

[@hjban2977]

@@kerryholland4822 Thank you for sharing your contemporary dance knowledge! 🙏🏻 BTS are giving us chances to share each other’s knowledge in different fields & cultural backgrounds & making our lives more rich, interesting & exciting! 💜

[@kerryholland4822]

@@hjban2977 exactly! I think what people may not realise that in any one dance style there is more than just one technique. Like I’m trained in Graham, Cunningham and release but not say Horton. As a Western dancer, I’m interested how similar or different contemporary is in the East. It defiantly will have been merging in the last 50 years due to media. I’ve watched Jimin’s old contemporary videos and he does look like a lot of the traditional technique I’ve grown up with but I found it VERY interesting that when BTS reacted to their Black Swan video, with the other dance company, that Jimin did not recognise who the person was quoted at the beginning. Martha Graham is one of the biggest icons in Contemporary dance and someone who studied contemporary over here would at least know her name. Made me so curious to know what techniques were studied and who was I missing out on!!

[@OBSIDIANSTAR02]

Pretty sure why jimin didn’t extend his back and lifted his leg higher was because of the water and the shoes their wearing. If he fully extended, the force from the kick over might cause him to slip and hurt himself and jungkook in the process!! You have to sacrifice some momentum when water is in the picture because your shoes can’t get the friction it needs.

[@chaosinyoursoul6580]

Good point~

[@CAMC4955]

I agree. I don't thinkvhe even noticed that they were in water

[@Ariadna74-]

Es lo que pienso cada vez que analizan esa presentación en particular, él mismo expreso lo difícil que era bailar con esos zapatos y con agua. Estaba bastante disconforme. Pero siguen reaccionando a esa presentación

[@donnamartinez6201]

I"m not gonna lie, I was a little disappointed not being able to hear the "live" reaction from Merv, however, that being said, you did a great job with the voiceover. :)

[@Koko3op]

Yaaaay. Thank you, that’s all that matters. I literally had a panic attack cos the reactions are so good.

[@LM-hd5wm]

A Korean dancer said Jimin’s dance with white fabric is part of traditional Korean dance style. And a ballet dancer reactor said it’s actually really hard to dance with floaty fabric. And shoes and suit! He should watch Jimin’s solo Black Swan in MOTS O:N concert. I think Jimin and Jungkook pas de deux (between two males who are not trained in ballet) is pretty remarkable and unprecedented. And they did it beautifully. It should be in the history of firsts.

[@icantjimout4298]

Jimin actually learned ballet !

[@lux3358]

I appreciate the fact that he is giving a honest reaction but to the people in the comments, I THINK he is giving his analysis based on a contemporary dancer point of view wich of course it's ok BUT we know Jimin isn't just a contemporary dancer, he's one of the most versatile dancers of the industry and he also uses his skills in various martial arts in his dancing. When he says something Jimin did in his dance is "wrong" it's wrong based in the contemporary stand of point, if a dancer wants to judge Jimin's way of dance fairly he should take in count all Jimin's background and remember that just because in some style of dance that's wrong in the other it's not and Jimin mastered both. Jimin's versatility it's what makes him so special and the best in the eyes of many people, he isn't just a box he's the whole package and I wish you all could have the eyes to see it because it's beautiful

[@inguid1]

Perfect

[@jimin13love]

Well said 🤍

[@DEE-305]

Jimin did lock pop for most his teens & then did modern dance & contemporary for like just 1 year. He was obviously really good at that time bcoz that was his only focus & he had time for just contemporary. He obviously would have been extremely refined if he would have just done that especially given how quick his progress was. But he instead chose to be a Kpop star. Then he had to fit into the kpop style of dancing that is basically a fusion of alot of things, plus it's group choreography. Also i was actually surprised to see how much just Jimin retained of his contemporary training after so many years when the I need U piece & Black Swan came out & how much flexibility he did retain. Bcoz i feel like nothing works in his favour here. He doesn't just has time for contemporary, he needs learn & practice group choreography & it's mostly hiphop fusion. And add to that he most likely doesn't even have time for just dance, he is a singer too, they hve photoshoots, interviews, promotions, recording, performances, TV appearances, MV shoots, touring & just alot. The costumes don't help either, coz he tends to wear tight & thick pants, especially fitted at hip & he wears those chelsea boots. There's no way the fabric & fit like that won't provide resistance to his leg extensions. Also his style is definitely a fusion itself now which is unique to him. Bcoz he has had both hiphop & contemporary training fused with the kpop style & the acrobatics he tends to add r more from his martial arts & tumbling background & Korean traditional dances. The first acrobatics he did for I Need U are common aerial spins in Korean dance. So i feel like he has his own performing style now that borrows certain techniques from different styles of dancing & martial arts and uses that but also adds glam that kpop needs.

[@rantomori5930]

Agree,and can’t say it better that you did💜

[@ll3328]

ha Jimin spent a year being the top in dance..his teachers PAID for him to go because he couldn't afford it and then he has the shortest amount of time with training to be in BTS the last to be excepted and yet Jimin is the one who jump started BTS in the direction they went in to now become the group they are now. Even RM credited him with being what started everything. It took all 7 of these multi talented men to get to where they are but Jimin lit the match and as a fan who was here from 2016 and before then cant deny that's what started it all ...you would have heard about park jimin regardless of BTS. With his work ethics and talent that you can't even teach what jimin can do with dance..and his voice?! he is a rare unicorn among legends

[@CAMC4955]

I'm shocked it took that much convincing for him to see Jimin's talent. Also shocked he picked Tae over Jimin, Jhope and JK. That puzzled the hell out of me because I think Tae is not as precise as 3J and can be a bit spastic in his leg movements. Yes he's animated in his facial expressions and they are all synchronized but don't understand how he can be so critical of Jimin then think Tae is da bomb....(over 3J!) I don't get it. 🤦🏽‍♀️

[@ranirani7312]

💯

[@candicesmith-mackenzie6303]

I think it is important to realize that it is a different culture. In the last dance and in Black Swan the jumps and certain moves are inspired by Capoeira, Kendo and Taekwondo. The jumps he does are performed brilliantly and are meant to have bent legs. I think it is a shame that your friend can't realize that Jimin is brilliant in many different styles not just contemporary. And he has a black belt in Taekwondo and considered one of the tops in Kendo, which is remarkable on it's own. I know you love Jimin 😘💜

[@hjban2977]

That jump is base from Korean traditional dance movement & become a Korean B-boy/Hiphop/Modern dance technique call ‘Ja-Ban(자반)’! < ‘JaBan’ dance movement in Korean traditional dance ‘SaMoolNolyee’ - kzbin.info/www/bejne/bILcZ4ingb-GbJI > < learning’JaBan’ movement w/ Korean dance instructor - kzbin.info/www/bejne/gZnElYSXa7uHqZI > If you remember BTS’s 2018 MMA ‘Idol’ performance with spectacular intro, this particular jump dance movements was shown in that intro of Korean traditional performance to show fans & audiences that part of BTS’s ‘Idol’ choreography is actually based on ‘SaMoolNolYee’ dance movements, one of the Korean traditional dance.

[@promisejm1037]

Since his bias is a non dancer, there is no need for him to react to a proffesional dancer - Jimin, that is praised by other proffesional dancers and even olympic gold medalist ice skaters who learn their tehnice form jimin.. He can stick to reacting to V's videos and his "vibe".

[@jk09012]

Oh damn, i mean ur not wrong

[@hellodolly2551]

Super fans are the worst

[@raymbngsm9015]

Oh thanks

[@raymbngsm9015]

I'm on my way to click "don't recommend this channel" because of that

[@purpleheartofficial]

This is good.. what i can only tell is our commentary to jimin dancing is based only to what we saw in his performaces, but only jimin knows what he is really capable of, so I'm hoping that one day Hybe will let him do a solo project,song or performance where he can showcase his full capability as a dancer. Because i don't think he already show us his 5th gear..

[@Koko3op]

Honestly we need a Jimin solo. I’ve been saying this forever. I’d LOOOVE to see him develop his own vibe and explore other styles dance wise. I’m praying haha

[@maryannsavage3724]

I love it when Jimin takes center. Fire, Idol and Dope are epic! 🔥

[@maryannsavage3724]

@@Koko3op You should react to some of his hip hop dancing. He's the #1 male Kpop dancer in the world.

[@marinal.]

@@Koko3op nods

[@violetss1248]

I don't think your friend will ever change his mind because he clearly isn't judging fairly. To each his own I guess. As a dancer myself I think Jimin is an exceptional dancer and performer in the kpop industry, in fact seeing his performances got me into kpop.

[@anaisc8733]

He only made constructive remarks - without bashing - and on TWO gestures by Jimin on a 19-minute video. Seriously, calm down.

[@Koko3op]

He got me into KPOP too!

[@Koko3op]

Thank you!

[@maryannsavage3724]

Jimin was voted as the #1 male Kpop dancer in the world. You should check out some of his AMAZING dance videos. That man can dance his ass off! 😉

[@macadamialove1013]

@@btsyf7467 now I wonder how this guy is qualified to comment about dancer skills to JIMIN. If he said V is a good dancer🤣 At least, that is the first time I heard.

[@Mashka14]

Jimin is a incredibly 💜 talented and gifted Dancer Artist Singer and Preformer especially when He danced in the Black Swan Video

[@shaunastock7940]

I’m curious if he thought the fact that they were dancing on water in the MMA 2020 performance may have affected his positioning (I’m thinking of what he said about his back and his slightly bent leg during the kick over JK). I know they were having issues with slipping on the wet surface from the behind the scenes, so I’m curious if that may have played a role at all, at least mentally.

[@EclipsedJT]

I’m not him but I’ve been a dancer for the most part of my life and I can tell you the main reason for all the “lack of” extensions is mostly bc jimin is no longer an actively practising contemporary dancer. People underestimate the amount of time and effort + consistency needed to maintain flexibility and posture. So imo, jimin is doing a pretty darn good job for the fact that he’s not doing this genre every day now. But yes, the water could be a factor to cutting short movements as well, especially if they don’t get many chances to practise with that condition.

[@maggan2808]

​@J T Could also be the clothing he is wearing. They're not exactly allowing him to have full movements.

[@Launibu]

I understand his comments. Jimin was more precise in that pre debut video at his school. He does not practice just Contemporary alone anymore. Jimin's style is a mix now

[@Koko3op]

Agreed!

[@asanlay9620]

Pls stop inviting this dude for reactions

[@kkaddy5327]

Please let's be mature. This is objective critique. It leads to improvement.

[@purple9713]

Not that we need his approval...But thanks for being so persistent. He needs to get out of his box n realise idol choreos are diff than classical contemporary choreo..As good as that routine that he did in school was not many ppl wud enjoy it..i do agree wid a couple of things he said abt the technicalities...But typical contemporary dancers find it very difficult to do diff styles becos their body is really set with their style.It all depends on what part of ur body is activated more acc to the style you're performing.Certain parts of the body is utilised more than the other n its diff for each dance style.Almost all ARMYs know how difficult it was for jimin to adapt to the diff styles than what he was trained in from childhood.for eg The extension,flow,body control that contemp or ballet asks for doesn't work for hip-hop.I have not seen merv dancing but I'm pretty sure that even if he's really good at contemporary he may find it difficult to do a dance number like Idol... I appreciate his feedback tho n if he sees this I just wanna say we r really not saying anythin from a negative space.He doesn't have to be scared.We have just known their journey from the start n we have seen everythin for 8 years n we know that a 20 min video won't do justice to wht any of them is capable of..

[@loquelagenteprometecuandos3140]

I think Jimin is an exceptional dancer and an incredible performer. I would love to know the dancing background and training of your friend. Please let us know next time.

[@Baddiesc7gn]

He began studying dance in middle school, he attended the dance academy. He entered Busan High School of the Arts as the top student academically and in dance. Contemporary dance. This is Korean scarf dancing. Salpuri. Jimin is a phenomenal dancer. He is able to do what Martha Graham said was essential as dancer. He conveys his feelings his passion and he is able to evoke emotions. “Great dancers are not great because of their technique. They are great because of their passion” Martha Graham 💜

[@SnorriSnibble]

I really like Mervs breakdowns of the movements, it's super interesting what he has to say from a contemporary dancers view! He's right that Jimin doesn't extend his arms/legs as much as a contemporary dancer usually does, but that's totally understandable since he's not a full on contemporary dancer anymore. Actually that's one of the reason why I love Jimins style so much - because it's unique. He has that contemporary background and mixed it with Hip-Hop Idol dance. I also agree with what Merv said (in the very first video) about him liking Jimin more in ON-type choreos. I adore Jimins contemporary dance (Black Swan really is that bitch) but my favorites are the powerful choreos (ON, Idol, Fire,...) because he pulls of the powerful movements really precise and sharp while still maintaining the contemporary elegance and gracefulness. It's mesmerizing.

[@AndruNinaGo]

IT's so frustrating.... ''artist'' that loves V and try to get down the dance line always, now he saw all the imperfections, but in the other reactions he didn't said a thing about the incomplete moves of V, his bad lines , how unclean he is or his poor flexibility. Fake Love and BST the 3 j's were soo clean and perfect that it's so frustrated that an ''artist'' of .... didn't recognize that. This reaction it's too much.

[@watashi_no_proxy]

I wouldn't say v has bad lines but yes he does incomplete steps. I was bothered about how he doesn't appreciate the 3js and notices the detailed choreography. And yet here he does which I felt could be due to a bias But if you're being asked as a pro dancer to comment , you should not only look for " vibes" but look at the precision which somehow he does here. Ironically he doesn't get the emotions or "vibe" behind jimin's dance in the black swan solo but nit picks each hand gesture . He already seems to have an opinion about jimin before reacting

[@alldiva7507]

Ok… hmmm 🤔. Well if ALL he did was dance that would be one thing. He has singing lessons, learning dances and dance practices, workout time, time with other members, recordings shows they work on, writing, interviews, eating, sleeping, and I didn’t mention everything. So … I am sure there aren’t enough hours in a day to concentrate on just dance. Plus Jimin sings while dancing! I can not express just how irritating this man is. And to think they have to learn so much choreography and different genre’s of dance. Wow. I do not think I will be watching this channel again. It is easy being this judge-mental when you are narrow minded. I do understand he is only a dancer.

[@maryannsavage3724]

All Diva I totally agree with you. This man has NO IDEA who he's critiquing. 😂 Jimin is the last person that someone should critique. He's the #1 male Kpop dancer in the world for a reason. He even beat out Taemin and Kai who are two of the BEST dancers in the industry! He's also been praised by MANY dancing professionals. I would like to see this guy do the choreo to IDOL and FIRE. Jimins dance break during FIRE is EPIC (especially live). I've NEVER seen anyone dance like him.

[@michealogboru9578]

You should have told them they where dancing in water cuz I 100% sure If they danced in water they would have fallen if careless I can 100% tell u that jimin is way more flexible than he is no hate or anything again they were dancing on water I don't know if he knew that or not cuz BTS had to also think about not falling while dancing on water.

[@misscrepesuzette]

I appreciate Merv’s critique. He’s not willing to say a dance move was executed perfectly just to please the viewers/Army. Isn’t the reason we watch a reaction for people’s opinions? Merv still explains that the performance as a whole is wonderful and it’s difficult to use perfect technique with pop/trap music. Also just like anything in life if you don’t constantly practice you lose it. I’m Army/ a dancer and I can tell when moves aren’t executed perfectly, but that doesn’t mean I don’t love the performance and content BTS offers. They bring contemporary dance to the masses and make it popular. That’s something to celebrate!

[@lelali387]

@@shanjida609 same

[@lelali387]

Who is this dude tho? What kinda dancing style this one even excelled.

[@lelali387]

@@jesin0005 isn't it an obvious question lol🥴 unknown dude talking about dancing, then they need to clarify what dancing techniques they excelled & what professional experiences they have for qualifying to review one of the very praised dancers in kpop idols' sphere. But why are YOU sounds bitter about my question bcuz like i said before it's an obvious question...

[@JadeSeaRivera]

Lololoo no worries. Thanks for the voice over!! I’m surprised he hasn’t been that impressed up to this point but cool to hear his feedback! Merry Christmas!

[@genciebowlin9477]

Jimin is known to be one of the best dancer in the world because he has developed his own style using his different styles of dance. He studied contemporary dance at his Busan High School of Arts and was one of the top students. He was so good that when his parents couldn't pay for his schooling, his school did not want to lose a talent like his so they paid for his training. He also studied modern dance, hip hop, k-pop, contemporary, Japanese, ballet, poping, locking and other dance styles. He also was a black belt in taekwondo and other martial arts as well. He incorporated all these of these into his dancing making him a stand out. Not only is he one of the best dancers he also taught himself how to sing. When he joined BigHits, he did not have any training in singing but his father said he did karaoke and he could hit those high notes as a kid. BigHits did not want to train him in singing because they weren't sure they were going to keep him. He did take some criticism when the group first began because his voice would crack at times. When he sang in the beginning, he had to sing those really high notes and had the most difficult choreography parts to do that contributed to his vocals cracking. This is all base on what I read about him. You can research all this for yourself and discover other things about him.

[@BringSugaTangerineTheDocuments]

ok...........i can appreciate your friend as a dancer but we not gon be on here critiquing Jimin the international mega star im sorry....whether it was perfect or not..apparently BTS is doing something rite...still LOVE you page very much.

[@anaisc8733]

He doesn't criticize, come on, don't be ridiculous, he only says, and we see it later, the parallel between the Jimin who did hours of contemporary dance - daily - to a Jimin who chose another career which does not allow him to keep that kind of level. And yet he's a great dancer - the best in k-pop and in the category of singers who are also dancers, in my opinion - and a performer. Honestly, he had a good reaction.

[@kimber1y]

@@anaisc8733 lmao why are you going on every comment defending him 😹

[@anaisc8733]

@@kimber1y 'LMAO' I made four comments, that is no different from you looking at thoses same comments, the only difference is that I responded to people who act like kids.

[@BringSugaTangerineTheDocuments]

@@kimber1y Thats how ppl do on the keyboard ⌨️ because they definitely would never say to my face in real life lol ppl stay trolling 🤣

[@laviniasilva3130]

JIMIN IS THE KING 💜👑

[@maryannsavage3724]

Lavinia Silva And a lot of people are just JEALOUS of him. He's the #1 Kpop dancer in the world for a reason. I find it funny when people try to critique him. 😉😂

[@laviniasilva3130]

@@maryannsavage3724 To criticize, you have to do better 😌

[@naghammalla3543]

Pleassssse showt it jimin filter and serendipity and lie live💗❤❤❤❤❤

[@soullmender]

Honestly?? I am going to be very honest, no hate! I think for whatever reason Merv has decided he does not like Jimin's dancing and so he approaches the videos with that mindset to critique! And I say that because he seemed impressed with Tae's dancing and this is not to put Tae down but I honestly find it hard to believe that someone , a dancer nevertheless can honestly say they likeTae's dancing and don't like Jimin's it just doesnt make much sense overall. That being said maybe he is critiquing Jimn harsher because Jimin has a dance background? I don't know but honestly if he does not like Jimin, I don't think you should try to win him over. people usually end up going the opposite way and end up being more critical. Not everyone will like everything the same, and I understand the need to make everyone like BTS and or Jimin but some people just won't and thats ok

[@Koko3op]

I appreciate your honestly. It’s definitely the latter, he’s harsher on Jimin because he sees qualities he LOVES and wants to see more of them because he is so talented basically. He was losing his mind seeing him in the last two more contemporary videos so I’ll definitely show him more of Jimin cos he doesn’t have anything against anyone personally.

[@winter-hs3yf]

agreed

[@uglyneverstartwithibutalwa8754]

*JIMN IS A VERSATILE DANCER*

[@laneykent7168]

Just curious: jimin's dancing has been praised by pros and other dancers mult times. Your friend doesnt like him so plze dont make him watch someone he cant stand and who he thinks is better than. Why torture the guy by making him watch the videos? I'm curious. I've never heard of him. Is he renowned for dancing? What famous things is he known for? Where can I see him dance? Just wanted to see him dance since he apparently is so famous that his opinion is considered valuable to you. Where has he been? What has he done that qualifies him as an expert?

[@Kookiepookie2025]

Jimin is an angel when he dance 💜 Right the hair color , makeup all ofc make difference but normally jimin is just too pretty

[@doingmything1015]

His sbs gayo daejun 2016 opening performance along other dancers is also good. Nice interpretation. Thanks

[@laneykent7168]

Ok so this guy thinks jimin is not a good dancer. Why have him watch the videos?

[@jwk2526]

I usually enjoy video's from this channel, but this reactor is quite harsh, especially not knowing the Korean influences in his (their) movements. I would LOVE to see his perfect leg extension while dancing in a full suit with dress shoes while in water with a partner with zero training in ballet/contemporary/modern dance. I will not even finish black swan or watch Jimin's beautiful I Need You solo. That being said, idk the commentators name, but you tried...As always, I loved your comments and ty for trying to fix this audio issue for us.

[@sariel8406]

Seriously!!!!! Until you have danced on water, real slippery water, you can't criticize Jimin's lines. Or JK for that matter. If you want to show, show on water. Do it.

[@roldyvillabroza6960]

I love Park Jimin and I think he is an exemplary and commendable dancer.

[@kenyanbee753]

The relentless army spirit. Show them more until you find something they like! Sorry about the mic

[@poobearlolcakes]

Should have shown him Jimin fake love fancam

[@Koko3op]

Now that he’s seen the dance practice (coming soon). We’ll definitely film that next time

[@maryannsavage3724]

@@Koko3op You should show him the fan cam of Jimin during their Dionysus performance at the MMA'19. I'll post the link below. That man can dance his ass off! 🤯 kzbin.info/www/bejne/nXfRiGdjqNShjsU

[@gloriat3446]

Love your dedication to showing him multiple videos and then continuing to voice over the video 😂 we stannnn mr park jimin

[@dennilee2137]

King Jimin 👍🏼😍

[@carolineb.9596]

The voice over was good enough and fun don't worry, and kudos for not giving up!! That being said, i'm sorry but your friend is a snob and a half. Cleanliness and technique are great, but dance and especially performance are about emotion. What makes Jimin's dancing so mesmerizing imo is that he does have a lot of technique and he is very precise, but he also knows when to dirty it a bit and let go of some things for the sake of the performance. Also i'm sorry but pausing every second to analyse every pose and not even trying to appreciate the performance was kinda irking me ngl... Nobody ever said Jimin was an unmatched technical prodigy, but he's been praised by countless professional dancers for his performance, his lines and his versatility so maybe we could tone it down on the nitpicking for the sake of being a contrarian... Again not holding it against you *at all* !!

[@Koko3op]

You have to give him some grace because a lot of his hmmm’s and signs of appreciation are muted. It’s his personal taste and he mentioned Jimins emotion on the I Need U part so he appreciates that and I may have forgotten some parts so please give him grace. Calling someone a snob is a bit harsh when they’re just giving their honest take. It’s not personal at all.

[@Koko3op]

Also glad you enjoyed the voice over! Also I encourage the pauses because I want to learn about technicalities too. Also he did acknowledge that garments idols wear can be restrictive so no credit taken from Jimins dancing.

[@carolineb.9596]

@@Koko3op Sorry i had to mention it about the pauses, I'm all for them usually, it's just that a few times he paused like 2/3 times with only a few seconds in between to criticize several poses in a row and i was like 'will you let the man dance for gs!' A good alternative is rewinding just a bit when you paused a lot not to loose the flow of the performance? just an idea, i know you're not controlling what they do

[@carolineb.9596]

@@Koko3op Also i'm sorry if calling him a snob sounded harsh to you but i don't find it harsher than the criticism he was giving. I'm not trying to be nasty but when watching something for the first time it's nice to try to be open minded and it felt to me like he came in expecting to be disapointed and ready to nitpick it to death. You can't come into a performance for a song about mental health and losing your passion with the same energy as you'd judge an audition for like a comtemporary dance company or a ballet position... Anyways, i'm sorry if you felt i worded it too harshly, snob is not an insult to me, and it's just an opinion as well, no hard feelings (against him either!)

[@anaisc8733]

Yes, the performances are about emotion, especially at the highest level, but I don't see the problem when he highlights that certain gestures are not as they should have been professionally. I don't see why you watch a professional dancer give his opinion if it is to attack him when he speaks as a professional precisely, if you want emotion, a lot of reaction exists on MMA 2020. As a fan, I consider Jimin's performances to be incredible, as I have never seen other singers who are also dancers be so excellent. But for a professional dancer, it's not the same as a fan. Pausing every second to analyze every pose, that's what professional dancers do for a reaction, that's literally the point of this video. Nobody said either that Jimin was an unmatched technical prodigy, but given your reaction, that's the way you view him, as a fan, and it bothers you that he isn't. Maybe you should tone it down, on how you address people who have only made constructive comments - without bashing - on TWO gestures from Jimin on a 19-minute video. Seriously, reflect on yourself right now.

[@alizaabbasi2706]

well i don't want to say but will still say since he have watched V's dancing style he is looking every member from that perspective as we all know every member have their own unique style & the style which jimin has no one can match that. i don"t know but he is too biased with V that he cant see what jimin's own style is. i am an OT7 dont think i am against V i m just saying he is not doing a fair judgement.

[@ranirani7312]

💯

[@tarastrong4798]

He needs to see Lie Thats a beautiful piece

[@dn5450]

Jimin 💞

[@uhgoodsam]

Show him Jimin dancing to Lie, theres a video on bangtanTv

[@vesperslynd2676]

another thing that makes Jimin's performances so mesmerizing are his facial expressions. The one at the end of the MMA dance (I Need U) was hypnotizing.

[@unimochi3523]

Omg you so great ..Good job yeahh we won 😂...when he say that way and I was like whatttttt....event profesional ballet from Japan said that jimin really great and he never see thing like this...thank god he finally I love it at the end....maybe he say that cause u know jimin dancing like hiphop or like modern dance so he rarely use his flexibility so maybe that's why his flexibility not that much ...but yeah ...only this mv can show his contemporary dance maybe also fake love when he split..but overall thanks for your job to make sure he like it..😂

[@Koko3op]

Of course! Yeah other dancers will just experience things differently and I’m Sure they debate too because they see things differently! But thank you!

[@leahbowen6323]

Clearly your friend knows his stuff but it seems like he's watching merely to find fault and disregard the good aspects of what Jimin is doing. It's a shame really because he surely knows how hard it is to execute these routines..

[@leahbowen6323]

@@jesin0005 I acknowledge that he praised Jimin and absolutely do not expect solely positive comments but there is still a lack of credit where it's due compared to the nitpicking. Also bitterness where? I'm fine sweetie, it's merely my observation.

[@pralee3715]

@@leahbowen6323 @Aster Jx is a Jimin anti ignore her. She’s in almost every thread just to put him down and praised the reactor for his criticism of Jimin.

[@singularity7420]

All toxic and insecure pjms be like:-

[@icantjimout4298]

@@singularity7420 that’s why u came in jimin’s video cause of the insecurity u have.

[@Spoopy3562]

The Bangtan Bomb of Jimin performing Lie for the Short Film : kzbin.info/www/bejne/f4bLnntthtaeqdE 3J house party (please remember that during the performance jimin realized his shoes were too slippery and couldn't do some moves fully) : kzbin.info/www/bejne/jWatc2eOqM-Gjrs

[@1starrynight1]

I would actually love to see your friend do a cover of the black swan or i need you dance and show us the proper execution from purely contemporary dance side..

[@ayvirak3986]

Jimin is actually really flexible but now as he has been performing almost like every day he had lots of muscle pain he has knee problem like really bad and neck problem as you can see on ON CHOREOS THAT HE IS THE only one to not turn his head and He also has pain in his shoulder not exactly there but on back side because of this he can't really perform like he wants to as before pandemic they had lots of ongoing concert tour and he is the only one person along with jk to perform like really hard to the point where the whole body was drained at the back stage and not showing their pain to us and in fact Jimin is one of member who is not satisfied by his own performance and keeps on practicing again and again to make it look perfect so yeah

[@boo3819]

I think sometimes what we forget as dancers is that perfect technique and form is not the be all and end all of performance. I am a completely different dancer now to when I was being technically trained and as you grow you interpret music and develop movements in new ways because there is more room for exploration rather than the harsh rigidity that you often find in modern dance training. Jimin certainly hasn’t forgotten his technique, you have to appreciate that he is dancing to music that often does not allow the room for growth in movement because of the fast pace of it, his technique flourishes in the transitions and his insane musicality and the quality of his movements, he has such an amazing contrast between his heavy and light moments in dance that is so difficult to replicate and transition between. What we see in the video from the past is his strict training in one dance style, what we see now is him drawing in elements from all sorts of styles to create his own sense of fluidity in movement

[@fernandacervantes1389]

I love the voiceover and the fact that you didn’t give up until he saw how amazing Jimin dance

[@Koko3op]

Hahaha yup!!

[@alis6259]

I'm glad you did the voice over. Thank you for the extra effort. And thanks for pushing until he saw the beauty in Jimin that we see!!

[@Koko3op]

Of course!! Thank you!

[@akk9999]

I did not like the voiceover reaction. Plz next time do a live commentary reaction.

[@Koko3op]

Merry Xmas to you too :)

[@kristin123a]

I think Jimin(and probably other talented idol dancers) is let down by their choreographers and performances. They direct most performances to show as much as possible in the little time they have. If they gave Jimin(or Hobi) ten minutes on stage and gave him an actual modern or contemporary choreographer to work with, the outcome might have been very different. They get maybe 30-50 seconds to show as much as possible in a solo part. The same goes for their group dances. They need to be "easy" enough for the weaker dancers to take part and look good. They can't go all out. His Black Swan solo in ON:E is IMO better than the MV one, though. And to think Jimin only learned contemporary for like 2 years? It's not all hard work with him, he's got a natural ability few have. It's okay for Merv to be hard on him because we all know Jimin came very far with the limited training he's got and he's been hugely influential in Kpop. There are other dancers who's got ballet or contemporary backgrounds, but none of them utilised it like he did. But now everyone tried to do what he does. It might not be as obvious, but he's up there with Taemin when it comes to being an influential Kpop dancer.

[@pjmtruth8097]

I think Jimin would appreciate the criticism too because he's always wanting to improve his skills. Also I really think the comp should stop holding the main dancers back and give them solo stages because they already sacrifice alot since the others would have a harder time keeping up

[@k8eee919]

I’m so sorry that your mic died! We all appreciate the effort you put into your videos! Sending love💗

[@prevodiEtranslations]

I suggest everyone to read #HJ Ban's explanation of JM's dance technique ... here in the comments 8 months ago

[@babecrash465]

Love how you always love Jimin!!! Thank you!!!

[@maddy6316]

i'm so sorry you lost audio for this many reaction videos.. i bet that was an awful moment of realization.. but genuinely thank you so much for putting in even more effort for the voiceovers! i'm glad we still got to see all of these reactions still! (this video and the others you've been uploading)

[@Koko3op]

Thank you so much!!

[@mono-mq2ph]

i would love if you would do some j-hope dance moments too. their styles are so diffrent

[@biarru81]

I think this was actually a live performance of the melon music awards, the change of clothes is done in the moment at backstage by the members of the group that were not dancing in that moment and they joined the back dancers discreetly, they are 7 in the group, as you know, and at the end there are only 5 of them, as the other 2 just finished their bit with the white clothes and left the scenery.

[@kekiwa2683]

For me personally the Intro of Black Swan and all its differently executed variations is art. This is really more than mere Pop Music. The MMA version was spectacular especially the Pas de deux of Jimin and Jungkook. The boundaries between pop and classic are blurring. Marvellous!

[@simphiwinkosindaba1036]

Not the Mic failing us like this😭 I’m so sorry Micah! The voice over was very endearing tho Also that persistence…show them everything until they find something they like😂

[@Koko3op]

It was … an experience I tell you! I’m glad! I hope everyone else feels the same!

[@cche16]

well i appreciate you doing a voice over instead of filming again with a fake reaction.

[@iamastrangertothisworld8604]

Thank you so much this video so beautiful l love jimina he is amazing good dance and sweet voice ✨💛💙❤❤

[@sarang8258]

Not sure if you'll see this but Jimin actually did a contemporary piece together with other kpop idols at SBS Gayo quite a few years back for the opening ceremony. kzbin.info/www/bejne/aoTRlI1pmrmrfLc One of my fav performances from him cos I could see he has this extra oomf in his actions especially the way his head and neck moves with the song and the way he milks the music with fast and slow movements make his performance more magnetic and dynamic. There are other angles of this performance that shows the other idols as well.

[@mayagarcia2700]

someone: *criticizing (which isn’t bad) Jimin* y’all: omg hater >:(

[@florencedurand9003]

Can you react to jhope

[@mathyasacosta8693]

Es una lástima que en sus críticas no está el hecho de que están bailando en agua y estaba resbaloso

[@calming2830]

I will never watch any of this guy reacting He doesn’t understand dance

[@Bts-lu4kl]

Training? Don't think it matters here. They are number one artists in the world for a reason. Don't judge them.

[@AngeliciousPie09]

We DEFINITELY NEED MORE JIMIN REACTIONS 😂

[@michealogboru9578]

Pls show him Jimin solo in blackswan map of the soul one concert.

[@argeliaayalalira130]

I think it's a good reaction, dancers when observing each others pay attention to technical and artistic details, even un the case of all of those russian ballet dancers, they are always trying to perfect their moves, so it's like that, Jimin is super talented and beautiful,I'm pretty dure that if he goes back to have his contemporary and classical training, he'll show in the most perfect way his beautiful and artistic dance, but obviously it depends on what he wants, love him

[@taylorfrentress1314]

prefacing this saying bts are my Ults. Love reactions where it’s not just pandering to a fanbase and giving legitimate reactions. I think his criticisms make his appreciations stand out that much more. And the criticisms are understandable! If jimin had continued his contemp training, he would have probably been a master dancer. The fact that he’s so incredible despite moving into more hip hop base and other styles through bts choreo says a whole lot. Really enjoyed this - missed the live vocals but you did great with the VO!

[@Koko3op]

Thank youuuu!

[@rg1654]

He is interesting I really like him , i would really love it if he reacts to serendipity and lie .

[@ser2952]

I think your voice over is great. Thank you!

[@Koko3op]

Awww thank you

[@divineotobor5730]

Show him the bts marionette dance for fake love

[@riverrun3995]

You need show him Jimin SERENDIPITY on stage performance. It was choreograph my Steezy.

[@Koko3op]

Ohhh who’s Steezy? Never heard of them Before!

[@riverrun3995]

@@Koko3op google serendipity song, Wikipedia give choreograph name and info. also he choreographed butterfly. interview with steezy on-line, great guy. Jimin got eye contact with audience from him

[@schafferable]

Jimin does train everyday even now

[@nikimylonaki3688]

#jimin #JIMIN #parkjimin #jiminie#bts

[@nikimylonaki3688]

#jimin #JIMIN #parkjimin #jiminie#bts

[@nikimylonaki3688]

#jimin #JIMIN #parkjimin #jiminie#bts

[@andreamorlote]

Your voiceover is so funny hahahahaha. "Oh yeah and he was like, is he Jimin? And I sad, no it's Jungkook"

[@Koko3op]

Hahahha

[@azriellen8865]

I'll bet my bottom dollar Koko3op reacted to Minho's (SHINee) new song and it's on patreon.

[@Koko3op]

Not yetttt! I’ll find it tomorrow hopefully

[@missesdimplez]

I love criticism ❤

[@tftyfgj]

King of solving problems!!!!!

[@Koko3op]

Honestly I tried !

[@singularity7420]

@Koko3op, please make him react to some j hope's dance performances. I believe, even he has some constructive criticism to take, but it would be good if real professionals judge them. Please make him react to J hope’s boy meets evil mv, his black swan fancam, fake love mma dance break, and a couple of his hope on the street videos...

[@Rayanna_taylor]

WILL MERV EVER LOVE JIMIN BECAUSE AS S DANCER I GET WHAT HE MEANS BUT AS A FAN MERV YOUR HURTING MY HEART 😫😫😫😫😫💔

[@marinal.]

Hi, i am back, Micah. Good reaction, ty. I like Merv. I look forward to watching more reactions from him. Love Jimin's voice and choreo. He is a pleasure to watch. But sometimes he does not go hard in the practice agree. My eyes are always on him. I feel the emotion of the song more from him. I am so glad he liked some of this. Ty for fighting Micah for our Jimin. Jimin has pretty severe back pain and i wonder if that stops him from certain movements. U know completing certain shapes. Hugs. -NY USA 2019 Army 💜

[@emilydublar1891]

Hello,,, thank you my fellow Army for sharing this,, I really like your reaction for Jimin💜💜💜borahe,, for me I like Jimin dancing style... HE Is graceful when he dances...thank you for this,video,,, 💜💜💜🇦🇪🇵🇭

[@alicesworld1]

Did you mention to him that Jimin's only contemporary training was from the arts high school?

[@barleigh234]

Love that you kept at him lol it would be awesome to see him react to Jimin’s Black Swan solo dance from their online concert Map of the Soul: ON:E next, also Jimin performing Lie, Serendipity and Filter💜

[@christineeaton3593]

Ok show him filter, or some of his concert performances. In concert in front of people is where Jimin thrives and feels himself the most. There are also a few videos with Steezy Studios where Brian Puspos and his friend react to Jimin dancing and the clips they have selected to view are really great, and showcase Jimin's charisma, charm, stage presence and talent.

[@angelicasolmirano4210]

I hope you can also do reax video on Jimin's "Filter" live performance or the 1 minute 3J dance to the "Butter" Megan Thee Stallion mix. 😃😊