Top 5 Most Robbed Survivor First Boots

Heroes, villains, titans, rebels - they all come and go.
But legends are forever.
If you'd like to support me, check out these links:
💎 / peridiamclips
💎 / peridiam
💎 / peridiam
💎 / peridiam
💎 / discord
💎 / billygiese
💎 / billywgiese
KZbin PERKS: / @peridiam
SUBSCRIBE & FOLLOW FOR ALL THE SURVIVOR & BIG BROTHER GOODNESS! :D
EXPECT A NEW VIDEO EVERY WEEK!
#Peridiam #Survivor

[@andrewrandolph2547]

I personally think the most robbed first boot is Maddy from 44 for the sole reason that she is the only first boot to be idoled out of the game.

[@MariaJose-os8ll]

Same opinion, the only bad thing she did is not talk with kane to split the votes beteween brandon and Matthew, since its obvious that jamie gonna play the shot in the dark .

[@andrewrandolph2547]

@@MariaJose-os8ll oh yeah i do not think Maddy played well as she was definitely too aggressive way too early in the game. but when comparing her to only first boots, she is the only one to not get the majority of the votes at tribal council.

[@genscina8261]

I don' t think so, she knew Brandon had an idol and she targeted him anyway.

[@FedericoAsturias]

So... she got outplayed and outsmarted so she is robbed 😂 and she also knew about the idol and decided FULL ON to target Brandon...

[@kirstybrown1185]

@@andrewrandolph2547 she’s not robbed if she didn’t play well then. Reading your original comment I’m like “aww that’s not fair” then you said your next comment and I’m like, conceptually, yeah, in practice you agree she played badly, so wasn’t robbed. Now imagine that happened to a great player. That would be funny. Sad but a little funny.

[@123PhoebeC]

When Wanda says “have a good one guys” it makes me wanna cry every time 😭

[@othosos]

Love the jelinsky baits

[@J55_ZR]

David*

[@XanderMatthews-nv9zf]

Yeah Jelinsky was a gorgeous mess

[@Ruddline]

Jelinsky was arguably a bad first boot I know he was deserved... but he ruined his tribe. I feel that Survivor casting keeps getting screwed by either quitters or wackos. So they make the perfect challenge in second episode for him, you can tell "purple" had almost zero chance to win that challenge but did with Jelinsky. I would like these people to not be casted.

[@crazyinsanepenguin]

You know, I've got it on good authority that Jelinsky is a Jelegend

[@HenryHickmanSurvivor]

I'd put Fairplay up as a robbed first boot. Robbed of his pain meds, robbed of having an unbroken jaw, robbed of having an idol at the first tribal. Man had it rough...

[@hewiebecker6165]

Survivor didn't make him leap on Danny Bonaduce though. That's on him

[@HenryHickmanSurvivor]

@@hewiebecker6165 yeah that's a fair point, it is Fairplay's fault his jaw was broken in the first place. But he probably would've done pretty well if he didn't end up with his face smashed into a boat by Yau-Man. Hard to say.

[@milkshakedraws6944]

@@hewiebecker6165I think James had been given nicotine patches while Fairplay was denied his meds, so there was definitely an imbalance in treatment that directly led to his elimination

[@junkerinhistrunker]

@@HenryHickmanSurvivor oh lord here we go again. please go back and watch the episode. Yau man does not touch Fairplay. Fairplay trips and smashes his own jaw into the boat.

[@survivorfreaknr]

I love how fairplay just immediately accepts that rupert stole the shoes and was completely okay with it

[@qu4ry529]

The other first boot Tina from Panama, was robbed. She got unlucky with being on a tribe of 4 and unfortunate enough to be on a 4 person tribe with Cirie

[@mikegoldberg8939]

And also had heartbreaking personal tragedy right before. She may not have been ready to play unfortunately.

[@teamsteed1]

No, she wasn't unfortunately

[@queenzoroark]

​@@teamsteed1She was just unlucky

[@SpanishFly120]

I know I've mentioned this a bit, and I agree that Jonathan/Wanda should've had the chance to get voted out, but it's still hilarious to this day that on the Palau DVD commentaries, Tom and Ian mention how Jonathan's social game was SO BAD that half the cast literally thought his name was "Kevin", lol.

[@Lechgang]

Jonathan from Palau is funny, because if I recall correctly, he was so bad socially that most of the cast thought his name was Kevin.

[@queenzoroark]

He also complained about ruining the clothes his dad gave him

[@coolguyc4sey]

Choosing Willard and winning every single challenge is still insane to me, didn't even need buff and tough Jonathan

[@fruitschnacks]

The Jelinsky-bait on this video was uncalled for 😂

[@koernerkomedy]

Love the Reebok Conspiracy with the Souna vote, and that was a fun behind-the-scenes story I'd actually never heard before, though it should also be noted that there were probably other factors to her boot. I believe I've heard Burnett's book says Rich was probably going to be the first vote until he came out at TC (which never made the episode), and that probably had an effect on things as well.

[@jackbarnes700]

Jonathan and Wanda got even more robbed because they would've been likely candidates for the Guatemala captains if Ulong didn't get decimated

[@burnsabeast]

The trolling of David throughout this is incredible and absolutely deserved.

[@lerdog]

I'd say Francesca was in a pretty good position pre-game-wise, it's just that her "allies" thought it would be funny to vote her out first again.

[@gracereitz1]

And honestly…it was pretty funny

[@ThePmacattack]

Don't blame Survivor for Wanda's song getting cut, blame Leonard Bernstein's estate for making licensing of his songs such a mess!

[@bunnyslope1049]

Okay, but can you imagine Wanda being on season 46 with the tribe that keeps singing camp songs? She would have thrived! But alas, she was several years too early

[@Damianoutlaw]

I've always thought it would be cool to have a Survivor 2nd chance season with returning players that were all first or 2nd boots.

[@lerdog]

Most of them were voted out early for a reason, It'd be really tought to put together a strong enough cast. A season of pre-mergers would a better option imo.

[@Damianoutlaw]

@@lerdog you don’t know that….we never saw how good these players could be since they got voted out so early. Boston Rob was a nobody after Survivor Marquesas. He didn’t become box office until survivor all stars.

[@Michael-vn2jj]

I thought Francescua would be #1 on here right when I saw title. Producers set her up for failure, they knew Phillip would go after her again

[@petermarshall7352]

No, she set herself up by being such an arrogant bleepity bleep bleep bleep.

[@magicmerl7749]

This video is a hilarious diss track.

[@SidequestGameStuff]

Without even saying the dude's name. Masterful writing.

[@StefawnVan]

I'm really hoping your thumbnail is ironic... I knew I could count on you. Really appreciate the troll

[@maxperdu4612]

WHERE IS MADDY POMILLA

[@MUDGameshows]

EXACTLY

[@bencalebrod]

She kind of did it to herself, targeting the strongest guy on her tribe who had an idol. That was WAY too risky of a move to make the first round.

[@theatomicmom]

I wanted to much for Francesca to make it the second time. She would have been fun to watch. Phillip is insane.

[@TheLoserface45]

Francesca was definitely one of the most robbed but Ciera was suuuperrr robbed in Game Changers. That tribe had no idea who to vote and she was the only one trying to make anything happen so they all said her.

[@silentassasin-q8l]

You forgot Marisa from Samoa, Russell's first victim

[@XanderMatthews-nv9zf]

Nah, never admit to distrusting anybody to their face Marisa put way too much stock in her physical game and stood out too much in front of all the wrong people

[@simonstrobl7919]

I just realized that Wanda’s song as she’s leaving is a rendition of “Maria” from West Side Story wtf

[@austinwillson7779]

Frankchessqwa

[@aaliyasaaree1977]

Frankiechestqueena

[@esinger23]

Not once, but twice

[@freckleface8402]

Franceskuwaa

[@SuperSmithersGalaxy]

Just wanna say you rock for uploading every Wednesday Perd man :)

[@tylerhaggerty4805]

They should bring Jonathan, Wanda, and Mikaela McNulty (Fiji non-starter) back as a member of each starting tribe, and not tell anyone who they are! 😄 Sonjia is still the oldest woman to ever play, which is wild

[@kimclaussen9413]

I did not know about the details behind Sonya's stumble!! Oh man, I feel even more sad about her boot now. I always thought she seemed so wholesome and lovely and I always wished we could've seen more from her. (Granted, if Rudy had gone home first, we wouldn't have his iconic lines or his "I don't know" trivia challenge. 😂) Definitely most robbed is Wanda and Jonathan. Based on the very little we saw, there's a good chance they'd be first boots anyways, but still - maybe not!! Give them a chance! Give them a SECOND CHANCE!! And, genuinely, justice for Francesca. I'm sure they put her with Phillip for round 2 for the dRaMA potential, but it was SO sucky and unfair that she got ousted like that. I'd personally also add Tina from Panama Exile Island, because she seemed awesome, and the weird format twist absolutely screwed her over. Thank goodness we got to keep Cirie that episode, but I've always thought it was so crap we had to lose Tina and she never played again. Honestly this just makes me want a First Boots season really bad. 😂 They cast people for a reason, and we obviously don't get to see much of why, so I think it'd be so interesting!!

[@lovefromshirley]

Savage was just grumpy that everyone actually likes Rupert. Not Rupert's fault they left a bunch of soggy shoes unprotected 😂

[@theprettyoftheodd7997]

Wanda went out of the game the same way she came into it; singing loud for all to hear

[@willipig2270]

Darnell.

[@ajl9772]

Gotta mention Fairplay. His elimination had nothing to do with pregame alliances. I know people are gonna say he basically quit, but when you look at it, it was sort of dumb. He got his head slammed into a boat after oral surgery and had to go into the game without his pain killers. If he didn't get into that accident before the game or if Yau Man doesn't slam his head into the boat to try and get the idol, he likely makes the merge. Also, sort of dumb they wouldn't let him receive pain killers, but were okay with James using nicotine patches.

[@Meodread]

I think the issue with Fairplay is somewhat simple though: he just shouldn't have been there. There was no game element or other player element that "robbed" him. Just the man was coming off a medical issue that should have had someone else there. No pain killers after getting you face smashed? This is insane. And depending on the PKs in question also insane to allow the use of.

[@Nzcade]

Zane Knight from Survivor Phillipines

[@fatalcalamityz1365]

There's a Survivor rumor that in Palau, Caryn chose Willard over Jonathan because Caryn figured Koror would be more likely to vote out Willard first than herself first if they lost an immunity challenge. Basically, she thought that adding Jonathan to the tribe would have made her own target bigger. Regardless if this is true or not, it's still unfortunate for Jonathan. :(

[@queenzoroark]

Jonathan also had a bad social game

[@alexandrarose982]

i’m watching this video not even a day after finding out abt sonjas passing😭

[@janejones7638]

I always felt like Rupert would fit in on that Bar Rescue episode where there was a permanently pirate bar. I felt like everyone involved staff and patrons were lunatics.

[@ericgrimes341]

Those people were delusional lol

[@Yeaster]

The producers should’ve saved Fran for a season of returning early boots

[@splendisdude]

Jelinsky was probably never said no to as a child. Me and my family wish he’d stayed longer because it was so fun just ragging on him.

[@rileyweida]

I will always feel so bad for Wanda

[@chrisjacobsen5558]

The only saving grace of Wanda getting out first is her singing and then the fabulous “wand-off” we got for many years on Rhap. Horrible that they cut her song on paramount !

[@abbyrose6660]

the fact that rupert basically broke panamaian law by stealing the morgan tribes personal belongings is new information to me. reminds me of colby breaking australian law by taking some coral from the great barrier reef. makes me wonder if theres any more instances where players technically broke the law in the country they were in.

[@josiahclagett7369]

Number ONE victim robbed was ME for the 14 minutes of Jelinsky baiting with no payoff.

[@teamsteed1]

Thank you for posting the video.

[@dontmakedestroyyou6256]

Justice for Jelinsky

[@WorldRaceMVG]

I’m sorry but Jelinsky was not robbed. That guy was a disaster from the start. Him and Banu did not deserve to be there

[@timpearson4202]

He wasn't in the video

[@WorldRaceMVG]

@@timpearson4202 I got Jebaited by the thumbnail

[@miajean1514]

It took me such a long amount of time to realize that Wanda was singing to 'Maria' from West Side Story

[@ElliottJames-e5s]

Honestly I think the audience was robbed of chicken in survivor China

[@alkholos]

Jelinsky was the most appropriate first boot in the history of the game. With that fill-the-vat challenge, he just gave up! Maybe he was just shell-shocked at the intense scrutiny, but I loved that his soon to be miserable loser tribe got rid of him so quickly.

[@JD-hz4lk]

Total off topic but the thing that always bothers me about Survivor is everyone's perfect teeth. I want to know if they pick people based on teeth or if they bleach the crap out of everyone before they hit the beach? Combo of both? They can't be straightening them too...

[@WalkerFilmsOfficial]

Happy Wednesday and thanks for another great video :)

[@sj69694]

I would add Stephanie Gonzalez from Ghost Island to this list. She wouldn’t have been a first boot if Jacob Derwin wasn’t sent to Ghost Island.

[@actuallyalec]

i was so sure Maddy would be #1

[@KevinRothert]

Fransequa better be in this video 😂

[@SirChristopher365]

So, if Jonathan & Wanda are co-1st boots.... does that make Jolanda the 3rd person voted off of Palau? Never thought about it that way, but..... hmm.... yeah, I guess so!

[@larstem2080]

Pat Cusack stares... *MENACINGLY*

[@de-niall]

doing a minute 1 vote off on a season where you know for a FACT there will be pregaming will never make sense to me.

[@lawrencebutrandom9864]

12:02 The winner of the first survivor competition… Sonja (AND KELLY GET’S ROBBED AGAIN-)

[@jjredeyedeagle5640]

I'm honestly surprised that Francesca was only an honorable mention but I am glad she got mentioned at all. I mean we were robbed of a potential great strageist twice because of Phillip. I think I spelled her name right let me know if I'm wrong and I'll fix it.

[@jjredeyedeagle5640]

I think I spelled her name right let me know if I'm wrong

[@VivanLaMNWA]

Justice. For. WANDA. WE ARE SURVIVORS.

[@bushidobot8251]

Billy would have never let that happen to Candice

[@uglyaniimals]

idk if she's quite as robbed as some of the people up here but imo morriah from 43 at least deserves an honorable mention. gabler, elie and jeanine's main target was safe, and they felt like they couldn't gun for owen or sami because they were blatantly the two strongest people on the tribe, so the vote kind of landed on morriah by default. even the excuse they used, that she was weak, didn't really hold up since she did very solidly in the first challenge

[@handsoaphandsoap]

Elie and Janine were not targeting Gabler, they could’ve easily voted him out if they wanted to since he didn’t use the idol. Elie was working with Gabler and thought she could manipulate him, which worked until Sami ratted her out.

[@bluepower1177]

What season did they do the school yard pick and then the 2 that didn’t get picked went home immediately? I felt so bad for those people that’s fucking bullshit

[@bluepower1177]

Nice I was hoping you would include that 😂🤙🏼

[@DylanDickson2]

@@bluepower1177 I remember watching that episode as a kid and hating it, seems cruel to not tell the players in advance there was going to be a vote out impending. Then seasons later I thought they were going to do it again, but instead of the players going home, they got a free helicopter ride to camp.

[@bluepower1177]

@@DylanDickson2I’m almost surprised they didn’t get sued somehow. Chance of a life time and they just nope you right out of the damn thing 😂

[@thebigshark42]

idk how survivor legend and monster jalenski wasnt mentioned although teased the entire video

[@Guts-blood]

Francesca 😫😫😫😫😫😫😫😫. they literally put her with a crazy person

[@nebulous798]

Legends in my eyes

[@RandomIndyWrestling]

Justice for Chicken

[@airagog1016]

Jelinsky the G.O.A.T. 🐐🏆He would have won the season and gone down potentially as the greatest player of all time if several of his allies didn’t BLINDSIDE him at the first tribal 😤

[@duffnolan08]

I was looking for this comment. He got robbed in a big way. Jelinsky might be one of the fiercest competitors that has every played the game. No quit in him and amazing social skills. I'm sad we we're robbed of his charming personality.

[@zacmitchell3468]

He didn’t have seven allies, he had 3. Several means seven!!!!!

[@marina_diamandis]

Wanda was voted out because people realized how big of a threat she was.. She was a challenge beast, a strategic mastermind, and had the best social game out of any survivor. If they kept her in, they'd just lay their torches down and quit, because they know she'd win the jury vote 7-0

[@MenverMan]

Did franquesa franisla ever eat that rock in a secret scene?

[@miosnikzycia2913]

Morriah was also robbed on 43, since people wanted to vote Gabler out, but had doubts after he announced his idol

[@BoardInTheHouseBGAplayer]

Who was Franchesca's pre-game aliance?

[@Quetzal00358]

The most robbed contestant is Amber. We know she's been "Rob-bed" at least four times

[@petermarshall7352]

What about the season where two were booted immediately

[@RavenLuna-ii6lx]

King Jelensky!

[@daniellegershman9165]

Marisa from samoa at least deserves an honorable mention. She was the first person to sniff out Russell on a tribe of players who overall weren’t great at the game and just didn’t believe her. Russell was terrified of Marisa and intentionally made her a first boot because he thought that if she stayed she would win the whole game

[@queenzoroark]

I don't think she would win, but she would get farther than she did

[@prestonk6271]

Tina from season 12 should be the clear number 1. She was in a tribe of four (smallest starting tribe ever) and was in a good position but then Cirie flipped the vote. No shame losing to one of the greatest Survivor players ever! Worst part was that the tribes swapped next episode too.

[@brianJohnxx]

Ciera from Game Changers says hi

[@diandragentilin9412]

Tina white from panama?

[@annastasiamoo]

Mari Takahashi technically wasn’t a “first boot” however, very much robbed. From Millenials v Gen X

[@Admiralkirk95]

Man she was so against winners that she refused to even entertain the question of a winner getting to the end and getting votes. I do understand that winners have already won, or that they have more experience so they have an inherent advantage. But just 'no.... no.... no' shows how bull headed she was.

[@JuliaTheTransPeacock]

For me, a first boot I thought was massively robbed was Morriah. She did nothing that would’ve made her worthy of being booted, and the only reason she got axed was Elie getting an early case of big-move-itis and taking out a loyal ally for no good reason. They said it was because Morriah was the weakest in challenges, but that was bs given that Morriah did great during the immunity challenge. Why did Jeanine not get any flak for slowing the tribe down at the challenge? Why did Sami get a free pass when he did just as bad during the final stage as Gabler? What could Elie have possibly gained out of letting Gabler slide by and taking out a close ally on Day 3? This one move pretty much ended any chance Elie had of winning, frankly.

[@XanderMatthews-nv9zf]

Sami was seen as too big of a physical asset to lose first, and Jeanine was clearly a bad choice for the log dig since it clearly favored younger fit men instead of thin women Clearly her social connections with Elie were not good enough if she wanted to keep Gabler over her

[@joerazor09]

I counted and there were several appearances of Jelinsky

[@RL-br6el]

Up until now, it annoys me what they did to Jonathan and Wanda. And how the producers doubled down when they were supposed to bring Jonathan and Wanda back for Guatemala but replaced them with Stephenie and Bobby Jon after the iconic tragedy that is Ulong tribe happened. Can't blame them, but it just felt like salt to the wound for Jonathan and Wanda. They should have been brought back after Guatemala.

[@earvincomora7917]

Candace was voted out because of her unloyal game to the Heroes during Season 20.

[@orrbildn]

You spoiled the Jalenski boot for me :(

[@btreese7]

That first vote on Blood vs Water was BS

[@SirChristopher365]

What about Brooke? What mistake(s) did he make?

[@XanderMatthews-nv9zf]

Making a 4 person alliance in a tribe of 9 Failed to pick up Sarge and ended up on the outs, don’t know why JP, John, or Brady weren’t targeted over him but I’d attribute that to poor social standing

[@booshbear]

Candice ❤

[@the1-upclub98]

I love how you constantly bait-and-switched us and proved that just because it's on the thumbnail, doesn't mean it's on the list. tbh You should've saved it for April Fools.

[@ThePmacattack]

Is the only reason Maddy isn't here that Bruce was medevaced first so Maddy isn't technically a first boot? Robbed g.oddess

[@SirChristopher365]

Jessica in Fiji? Tina Scheer? Francesca 1.0?

[@HKMcRooney]

Off topic, but you referenced it first, so I'm gonna just throw it out there. I agree with what's-his-name about the "several is seven" thing and literally for the same reason as he gave. I've always said a couple is (obviously) two, a few is three/four, a handful is five/six, and several is seven (maaaaaybe eight/nine can slither in there, but ten is then a couple handfuls).

[@Julian-lz5pd]

Morriah from 43 should definitely be in contention

[@dayveo]

The Francesca situation makes me so mad. That that awful man has ever had any control in this game is disgusting. And then for others to join in because they think it's funny. Just hearing about it again here, I honestly have to skip forward in the video

[@whimsiclethefirefly]

Wanda got wronged

[@tdt8854]

yet another production influence situation that saved Rudy in Borneo. Such a shame they had to manipulate the game so much in the first season. This is satire don’t attack me

[@queenzoroark]

Ironic how Richard would be the first boot if he hadn't opened up to the tribe at the Tribal Council 😂

[@hewiebecker6165]

I'm going to admit. I'm not crazy about how a contestant from a week old episode gets top spot on a top 5 list just because of recency bias.

[@uglyaniimals]

did you watch the video ?

[@Ruddline]

Jelinsky was arguably a bad first boot I know he was deserved... but he ruined his tribe. I feel that Survivor casting keeps getting screwed by either quitters or wackos. So they make the perfect challenge in second episode for him, you can tell "purple" had almost zero chance to win that challenge but did with Jelinsky. I would like these people to not be casted.