Persona 2 Innocent Sin Review - Sins of our Past

Go to www.expressvpn.com/namcomp to take back your Internet privacy TODAY and find out how you can get 3 months free.
Audio Edited by Reuben Deeley ([e-mail])
Patreon: / namscomp
Discord: / discord
Twitter: / namscompendium
My Other Persona Videos: • Persona Videos
Welcome to my Persona 2 Innocent Sin Review Sins of our Past! In this Persona 2 Review, I'm going to be analyzing Persona 2 Innocent Sin as well as critiquing Persona 2 Innocent Sin. In this Persona 2 Innocent Sin Analysis I'll be looking at the highs and lows of Persona 2. This means this will also be a Persona 2 Innocent Sin Critique. Persona 2 Innocent Sin Review Sins of our Past is inspired by certain events that take place in the game where the characters reflect on their Past Sins Hopefully, this video does inspire you to check out Persona 2 whether that be Innocent Sin or Persona 2 Eternal Punishment. As Persona 2 is underrated. This is a follow-up to my Persona 1 Review Dreaming of Butterflies so please check that out.
Special thanks to That Boy Aqua for the help with the video: / iamaquanex
0:00 Opening
3:28 Persona 2's Introduction
7:26 Visual Design
9:09 Gameplay Critique
18:46 Childhood Trauma
24:53 Character Analysis
35:59 Story Analysis
42:52 Conclusion
44:35 Outro & Patreon Credits
Alright, it’s been a bit since I last covered the Persona series. So after taking a small break from the series, I’m more motivated than ever to get back into the swing of things. Despite my personal feelings towards the original Persona, the game sold very well, especially when you consider the size of Atlus at the time. Atlus would be crazy to not capitalize on this success and around three years later in 1999 we were introduced to Persona 2 Innocent sin… only in Japan.
Alright let’s just get into this now. Persona 2 is actually a duology. The first part, innocent sin, was originally never released worldwide initially. The reasoning for which has never been officially stated, but it’s most likely because some of the game’s imagery could’ve stirred up a lot of controversy. We did however end up getting the second part of the duology, Eternal Punishment, in the year 2000.

[@NamsCompendium]

Go to www.expressvpn.com/namcomp to take back your Internet privacy TODAY and find out how you can get 3 months free.

[@ImaGuyIdiot]

please tell me you plan on doing a video on eternal punishment

[@caellanmurphy4751]

YEAH PS1 INNOCENT SIN is wayyy more powerful online you can even get PS1 VS PSP STAT COMPARISONS on the wiki and its not even close

[@bnashtay2278]

lol japanophile

[@nickolaswalthers7531]

Dude im loving these reviews. saw your persona 1 review and now this. these stories are really good and i wish i knew about it years ago. but seein as i had to get in the series thru the 5th game. i felt like i couldnt transfer the battle system that p3, 4 and 5 had. thus i never got into the first 2 games. thanks and i cant wait for that next review

[@ArshadZahid_nohandleideas]

Sinnocent In

[@typemoriarty3898]

Massive flex getting your first sponsor on the video with hitler

[@gitgudcasul2861]

Dafuq why is this comment 2 weeks ago and the video is 1 week old

[@SunderMun]

@@gitgudcasul2861 the video came out November 28th. That's more than 11 days ago. (Since it's been 4 days since you said that)

[@gitgudcasul2861]

@@SunderMun oh sorry

[@thegumonyourshoes]

Yeah that’s the fattest flex in terms of sponsorships.

[@plot6520]

Shshdhshys-what the fuck?! :D

[@AnActualRealPotato]

"Jun isn't thinking straight" Is he ever though?

[@thegumonyourshoes]

Well, Tatsuya certainly doesn’t think so either.

[@SAIMONch]

That took me a hot second to get lmfao

[@jovif.spemudaindonesia1841]

Goddamn it 🤣

[@thegumonyourshoes]

@Miragedramon. One Vision. From what I recall, the writers have admitted that in IS, it is canon. For EP, that might not be the case though.

[@LongSinceDead1]

Kind of crazy that Innocent Sin is the only Persona game with a bisexual protagonist who can pursue a same-sex romantic option and it released in 1999. Like, come on Atlus, how hard is it to do that again?

[@finecastleie]

"Its whoop-ass time!" ~Maya, everytime

[@user-xl6eq5ox2q]

Definitely

[@osdesinteligentes7946]

"whoop-ass completed!" ~Maya, sometimes

[@rajin_1136]

Ciao! - Maya amano sometimes

[@gitgudcasul2861]

@@user-xl6eq5ox2q yep

[@jaywhangmakes]

"Let's positive thinking!"

[@chronicallyunstable]

One of my favourite moments in this game is when you get to revisit Sumaru Prison and check up on Eikichi's friends over the course of the game. When you first witness how people become Shadowmen, you don't think much of it, because, initially, this is how people without dreams and passion for life would act. However, what elevates this idea further (as opposed to, say, the Apathy Syndrome in Persona 3), is that it shows the regression people experience as their desires and will to live dissipate. Over time, instead of repeating the "what's the point anyway" lines, their condition worsens. First, they start to say select phrases. Then, just one or two words. After that, they just remain silent altogether. But what solidified this concept for me was my last time at Sumaru Prison. After reuniting with the gang at the detective agency, I decided to revisit the Prison one more time. What followed was the moment that made me fall in love with this game, and shed genuine manly tears. Eikichi's friends, whose conditions have been progressively becoming worse... disappeared. *Gone.* *Poof.* Most likely never to be seen again. And then you have to witness everyone's reaction to this moment, Eikichi's obviously being the most heartbreaking (but I also have to mention Shadow Maya's reaction - it has so much spite and venom in it, it made the moment all the more tragic). This is where I want to seriously praise Persona 2 IS for making actions matter. The concept of Shadowmen isn't just some thing that's happening in the background where you never get to fully witness its consequences (looking at you, P3). No, the status quo actively changes throughout the story, and you get to see the effects it has on the setting, its inhabitants and, in turn, the main characters. *Actions have consequences* - and Persona 2 will make damn sure you, the player, remember that. But let's look away from Eikichi's friends and look at the world at large as well. When you interact with various NPC's, you'll see some of them express certain dreams or desires, or being members of the Masked Circle, only to become Shadowmen at some point later. What makes this even sadder is the reaction of other NPC's who were in the same location/interacting with them. When asked about it, they'll just say something along the lines of "Huh? Was I talking to someone? Oh well, doesn't matter". The same thing happens when literally *dozens* of high school students during the Kasugayama High school festival are turned into Shadowmen - so many students, gone, and no one realises that. Recall the poem Maya cites near the end of the game when going through Xibalba, specifically its last line. *"Worse than dead / Forgotten"* This right here truly drives home just how painful it must be to only be seen as mere shadows by the people you know and love, as if you never even existed. Sure, the main cast, who are Persona-users, can see them, but to the world at large? A mere speck of dust in the wind. Moments like this is why I think Persona 2 Innocent Sin is one of the most fascinating video games I've ever played. Its core themes and ideas are so well-put together and expressed throughout the game, it genuinely feels like an experience worth pondering and, well, *remembering.* While I still think Persona 4 is the best game in the series, Innocent Sin comes damn close just for the story and themes alone. Granted, I still haven't played Eternal Punishment (waiting for cj_iwakura to finish his fan translation of the PSP rerelease), so my opinion might change after that. If you haven't played this game, I implore you to check it out - gameplay issues aside, this will probably be one of the most fascinating games you've ever played. And if you have, *please* watch SnicketySlice's analyses of these games - they're incredibly detailed and informative. Thank you for making this video! Having recently beat both Persona 1 and 2 IS, it makes me happy to see more people talking about these games! P.S.: can I also say that the soundtrack of IS is criminally underappreciated? The way the tracks tackle recurring leitmotifs makes the experience even more cohesive: the shops sharing similar motifs depending on what function they serve in the game, the main theme of Sumaru City popping up every once in a while, Joker and Jun's themes being connected, you name it. Oh, and Kimi no Tonari slaps. Fantastic end credits theme.

[@skunthundler]

That PSP fan translation isn't going to come out anytime soon (or at all maybe), you're better off just playing the PSX version. The translation there is by no means bad, and imo the PSX versions have the better battle system as well.

[@chronicallyunstable]

@@skunthundler Really, it depends on how soon it comes out. From what I've seen on the August 2020 update, the translation is actually progressing at a better pace. But hey, if it doesn't, I'll play the original PS1 version, no biggie! Definitely don't want to miss out on the second half of the duology. Plus, I'm currently taking a short break from Persona anyway (to avoid burnout).

[@wutduck1763]

Your comment explains exactly why I love the NPCs in Persona 2 so much. I swear they always have something new and relevant to say and it’s great. Also I remember first being confronted with the shadow men at the beginning of the game and feeling genuinely disturbed. I was going in blind at the time so seeing Eikichi’s friends turn into shadow and slowly become forgotten really hurt. Plus Eikichi’s sad theme was perfect for that scene after they first become shadow men,,

[@cumekira70]

shut up lol

[@Desmond-xp4wr]

@@cumekira70 feeling better now?

[@Nobe616]

As goofy as it is I love hearing Maya scream out, " It's woop ass time!" At the start of a battle. It's so corny but adds a whole lot more personality to Maya. In a persona game with no social links

[@yangonzalez2338]

That fucking boat scene with maya driving and failing while the others fully expected it, always gets me lol.

[@averyaustin1]

I love the idea of 3, 4, and 5 being in an alternate reality where the world wasn't destroyed. I am curious to see what SEES, The Investigation Team, and The Phantom Thieves are like in that other reality....

[@wutduck1763]

They could be dead or simply not exist since everyone except the people in Sumaru City straight up dies. Though it’d be interesting to see what life is like in the original timeline ten or so years later.

[@Dalrane]

Most of the P5 cast wouldn’t be born yet, as P2 takes place in 1999, and most of the cast was born in 2000-2001.

[@averyaustin1]

@@Dalrane Of course. But, i'm meaning in the timeframe of their game's time setting, for example, what would that reality's version of 2016 be like, i wonder?

[@boohoo723]

@@averyaustin1 I mean, do you care about spoilers for Eternal Punishment?

[@averyaustin1]

@@boohoo723 Not one bit. I mean, i obviously don't care about Innocent Sin's spoilers since i'm on this video.

[@AraiiarA]

One thing that surprised me about this game was how it portrayed Jun and Tatsuya as a potential couple. Throughout the whole game we are shown how deeply they care about each other with the gift exchange, all the flashbacks that involve just the two of them, Maya's comments, their Persona designs mimicking each other's gifts, etc. When I got to Taurus dungeon and had the "romance" choice I picked Jun cause I liked him the most and was fully expecting to get a "haha funny" answer from the game, but no, Lisa even aknowledges it in an accepting way and the game never mocks you for it (except when it does if you do the lovers interaction with certain demons). It's especially impressive considering this was made in the 90s and it's a japanese game. Maya fits the overall story of the duology better tho.

[@xtato01]

Plus the writers confirmed that jun is the canonical romance option for tatsuya, its really cool how accepting the writers are even in 1999 japan

[@helloill672]

I find it kinda odd that you can be gay in a persona game from 1999, but not the one from 2016.

[@bluejay7058]

@@helloill672 this made me so mad, but I get it. After the aids epidemic, gay people were demonized so horribly, so no company dared even hint it. May be a component of why this wasn't advertised in America either

[@Kammereer]

> and it's a japanese game It's a big and common misconception that Japan is some cruel and outdated backwater. If you go outside the mainstream AAA - into niche genres, mid-budget and indie RPGs, and even eroges, you'll see creators willing to explore non-mainstream concepts.

[@AraiiarA]

@@Kammereer I am well aware of that. I'm japanese myself and grew up with a bunch of japanese games lol It pretty much goes for every country now that I think about it. Indie games don't suffer the same restraints when it comes to subject matter like AAA games. Perhaps I should've said mainstream japanese game instead. LGBT representation has gotten better now, but back then especially for mainstream games, it was hard to find a nice actual gay option and not something that felt exploitative.

[@ThatBoyAqua]

The return of the king

[@finecastleie]

Ahh, demonetisation. The boss who's stronger than Nyx

[@thaddeuscheeleyjr.369]

Don't you just hate it when you're battling demonstration and it uses defunraja to remove all your income?

[@leadmaxwellarco2574]

THE DEMONITASATION IS THE MEANS WHERE YOUR REVENUE IS REVEALED

[@raymond2125]

I’m just gonna say this right now, “Close you’re eyes.” *Tatsuya did an impression of a motorcycle engine*

[@asdray529]

I'm offended! *ke-plunk*

[@ilucasz]

Love your Walter

[@Blarglesnarfe]

*your

[@themadhatter7648]

“I’ve been waiting for this”

[@jasonblundelldobebussing]

"Did you see that, Maya?"

[@angelinaarecco4]

P3 REMAKE after strikers what say we celebrate on the release date?

[@rolfthebolf]

@@angelinaarecco4 persona 3 fes is on ps3, we dont need a remake

[@RealScrymeaRiver]

"Maya's avatar is blinking 'online' for Innocent sin online. Will you spend the day playing the MMORPG?"

[@angelinaarecco4]

@@rolfthebolf what do you think the reason for the Sega Microsoft's deal was? Exactly that.

[@burnt_ramen9757]

Persona 2 duology is a masterpiece

[@Evilriku13]

Sadly u didn't understand the Yukino part, but that is because of what it overall it is about the choices that u haven't gotten, and what the persona games were back then about: Independence, self-reflect, acceptance. In this case, Yukino was asking to be with her dying/died friend Fujii Shunsuke (Fujii named after the rl camera company btw), saying "I can't fight anymore" and "leave me to be with him" which sounds like she was saying "let me die with him" and thus giving herself up, which isn't helping her or anyone in this case, as he wanted to live on for his sake too. Her dream of becoming a professional photographer and her promise from earlier in the game to save Anna would have died too. She wouldn't have overcome, by what she implied, the grief of her friend's death alone and needed to share this moment with others to get back on herself again. Also about Maya and her progression: Maya is the only character in the franchise to not accept her shadow, and since this series is about progression, it would mean that Maya wouldn't have accepted her inner (and as a matter of persective: dark) desires that she kept away from others around her, for Maya cares about spreading positiveness and making others happy, to gain happyness in return. The reason why this is such a bittersweet act has to do with the ideals of jungian psychology (one of the fathers of modern psychology & philosophy along with Friedrich Nietzsche) that not overcoming such bottom moments in life is weakness to your own growth as a human/living being, as to some extend it is apathy, a fate worse then death, which btw was a quote Maya mentioned about a poem at the start of the game, which is also linked about being forgotten and overally tied to persona 2 (both games) thematic.

[@Crok425]

I never got that and just thought that Maya was in denial. Thanks for the insight, it makes me appreciate the classic Persona games more, especially how it treats Shadows and a human's personality.

[@yamihatarou7850]

Damn this game sounds amazing. I thought I wanted to play P3 but this actually sounds like an incredible experience to undertake if my computer can handle an emulater. I kind of feel guilty for all those times I made those "Persona 1 and 2 don't exist" jokes

[@chironthecuddley6144]

P2 IS was my second game in the series after P4 original and I got sucked into this game just as easily as P4. The soundtrack is phenomenal and the characters are great. Luckily the PSP is fairly easy to emulate from with I've heard(I don't have a PC and I only emulated GBA games on my mom's computer back in the day), so as long as you grab PPSSPP and the game, you should be good to go.

[@Next-xm2dh]

You have to regret making these overused jokes that always end any conversation about p1 and p2

[@loruapollo6634]

The ps1 emulator is very easy to run so you should be able to play the fan translation of P2 IS and play Persona 2 eternal punishment after. Like the comments before said, the psp emulator is also a good option if you want to go for that route but i recommend the ps1 emulator more

[@purplespectre]

@JC Exactly, well said.

[@nokl9861]

If your computer can't handle it you can download ppspp to your phone (if you don't use an iphone). The game works very well!

[@AgentNine]

Considering this was the first Persona game I actually played, I'm really glad that this story's being talked about more.

[@BlueMageDaisen]

I feel the logic behind the Yukino choice is that by leaving her behind to mourn, you're not having faith in the strength she has, instead letting her dwell and collapse under the weight You're not trusting her to be able to handle her now and present responsibilities

[@Hawkatana]

2:13 Actually, the reason has been stated. They just didn't have the money to export it. Atlus West only had enough money to localise one of the Persona 2 games, and chose Eternal Punishment because it had a more complete ending.

[@justayoutuber502]

I remembered that someone once summarised the whole story of Tatsuya in IS and EP in a sentence. Cant remember the exact words but it goes like this: "What he did was an Innocent Sin, what he got was an Eternal PUnishment..."

[@mandochan69]

Nyarlathotep is the best boss in the entire persona series since he actually won and for my experience in the series (I have played 1,2,3,5) he was the only final boss that was a challenge for me.

[@ilucasz]

Yeah, but if you consider that Nyx is unbeatable and that everything will die eventually...

[@daviemerim3002]

Nyarlathotep is unforgettable, but Dr. Maruki is my favorite for being a human with honest desires.

[@basilofgoodwishes4138]

@@daviemerim3002 Nyarlathotep was the main villain of 3 Persona games, he is anything but forgettable. Also Maruki is not the only one with honest desires, we have Adachi and we have Strega and in Persona 2 we have Joker, who also wanted to only help humanity.

[@daviemerim3002]

@@basilofgoodwishes4138 Among antagonists, yes. But I meant final bosses; Maruki is the only final boss that isn't some kind of god or entity.

[@basilofgoodwishes4138]

@@daviemerim3002 Well most of the villians are not really gods but shadows of the human psyche so it depends on what you view as a human. Maruki might be the most human, but the others are in my view also very human, especially Nyarlathotep.

[@honeyOTU_]

I feel like in the ending when we see eikichi and miyabi together, I was honestly hoping she'd be shown as chubby in the end to really hammer in that it doesn't matter what weight you are, what you look like etc etc, the love will always be there. but I'm happy they're together regardless, their arc is too cute (づ￣ ³￣)づ

[@KatsuyaTheFuuk]

Yeah about the gameplay, I have only played the PS1 translation, so seeing your PSP gameplay left me speechless. The tiny amount of damage you were taking is not something I'm used to seeing. I understand the idea of sticking with official versions and ways to play, and I respect that. But I think you should still check the PS1 version out if you ever get the chance. It's very affordable to get an actual copy of it to apply the patch, and it is actually compatible with real hardware too

[@NamsCompendium]

If I go back to Innocent Sin, it'll be the PS1 version just to see if it is much better. People also suggested to me to go through Persona 1 again but make sure to get Reiji because he adds a lot to Kandori in that game. So I'll probably do a stream if people are interested. I'll see if I can snag a copy of the PS1 version of Innocent Sin at some point.

[@chroe4729]

@@NamsCompendium if you do a stream will they be archived?

[@NamsCompendium]

@@chroe4729 Yes. I’ve streamed a few times in the past and they’re currently in a playlist on my channel. They’re unlisted videos so you have to watch them through the playlist.

[@Evilriku13]

@@NamsCompendium oh you don't know? The hard mode of the PSP version is the PS1 difficulty of it.

[@viniciusborges3339]

the original PS battle system is better than the PSP remaster one, period.

[@rue6368]

Maya is actually an incredibly important character and holds one of the greatest forms of symbolism throughout both games. The amount of depth this game has into the collective unconscious and Hinduism is absolutely insane. Loved IS and EP.

[@danielj366]

I’ve been looking forward to this since your P3 analysis! P2IS is my favorite Persona game by far, can’t wait to hear your thoughts on it :)

[@ElectricBarrier]

In Philemon's defense, I think he didn't really have any choice in the matter of putting together this scenario. Really, honestly, neither does Nyarlathotep. They're both beings who were created from humanity's collective unconscious, and they both represent different facets of humanity. Philemon is our hope and optimism, Nyarlahotep is cynicism and nihilism. The latter will always try to destroy the world or cause pure chaos because it's the part of us that want it, and the former will always choose heroes to fight against that because it's the part of us that don't. That's how I see it, at least.

[@hoorenglish5732]

Tatsuya will forever be my favorite protagonist of the series. Also shout out to him for being the only canon bisexual who can have a boyfriend. Good for you, Tacchi.

[@wutduck1763]

At this point, he’s just my favorite male character from the franchise period. He’s just so fascinating and different from any other Persona protagonist and it’s great. Wish he was as popular as, say, Joker, but I just want Persona 2 to be more noticed in general.

[@greggaygayakutami1402]

@@wutduck1763 He needs to be more popular than Joker because Tatsuya is peak fiction level protagonist unlike Joker who's just a self insert Empowerment bitch.

[@dx5gaming715]

@@greggaygayakutami1402 I mean 1 & 2 did focus more on the mc’s the most and p3 protag was slightly at best, p4 was a genuine self insert but joker was something similar with 2 and 3 and a mix with 4 I can’t English cuz I’m hella high rn

[@greggaygayakutami1402]

@@dx5gaming715 there was nothing about his history, there was no older brother like Katsuya who prevents the self inserts from doing shit, he was just sent to a new place just like Yu Nakamura and he's a bland self insert, also the Persona 1 Protagonist was also a bland self insert so he is not an indicator that the original is the best, it was only when Tadashi handled the story when Persona became close to Peak fiction, there wasn't any bland character archetypes, there wasn't any random cosmic villain that came out of nowhere, there wasn't any self inserts, there wasn't any chunnis who think they got stands, Nope they made the situation worse because of how immature they are and the conflict just continuous to get better and better. This is why Persona 2 is INFINITELY better than all Persona Games and is one of the best games in video game history and is also one of the most well written fantasy operas ever made.

[@jorjorbanks8876]

@@greggaygayakutami1402 *cringe*

[@brenzo2224]

This is a great video and review! I'm so happy to see more people talk about Persona 1 and 2, I really love those games and I hope that more people can appreciate it by watching your content. Persona 2 IS and EP really changed me and I fully think that they are some of the most underappreciated games ever made. The story telling, characters, atmosphere, music, settings and so much more is really memorable and made for some great experiences.

[@narutk9]

Yes! I've been excited for this one since the Persona 1 video!

[@demiv7110]

I'll be back after I finished the game myself

[@iZapo]

Lol same

[@maskedgamerjoker6148]

Your going to cry

[@murphyaravena774]

Same

[@streamerwibu7009]

@@maskedgamerjoker6148 u never got cry when u got spoiler

[@maskedgamerjoker6148]

@@streamerwibu7009 nope I cried

[@sarafontanini7051]

I'd argue the thng with Yukino's choice is worded different from the past choices, and doesn't imply "trusting her to handle something herself" and more "leaving her alone to focus on the quest", while the good chocie is "helping her push aside her grief for the sake of others", and the overal situation is very different in context from what I can tell. PLus somestimes you kinda HAVE to help someone through a problem, such as their grief at the loss of a loved one, and not just leave them alone to it. Sure, they could've given you more choices like that so you avoid tackling everything in the same way, but I don't think it's as bad as you're making it out to be.

[@royalloser4225]

I just found you today since I started my new game + of persona 4 and I am binging your videos while playing. Thank you for for awesome content. I subscribed 👍

[@iwakmangot214]

your essays about persona are really good :)

[@enmanuelsan]

Two entities betting on mankind's fate, a super sentai knock off called feather man, a character named Joker there's a lot of Persona 2 references in 5

[@Mart_Mars]

This video was on my recommend and I clicked so fast and subscribed,, it does an amazing job analyzing persona 2 IS. Personally the duology became my favorite persona game because of the story and how it made me care so much for the characters. Can’t wait for Eternal Punishment video and all the feels it’s plot has,,

[@BAIGAMING]

The PS1 version is a lot harder, the developers probably thought what you did about whether a game should be hard or not and decided to make it on the easier side, they probably got scared of re-releasing a game that was too hard, and made the PSP version a lot easier.

[@AdNoctemMedia]

Subbed in anticipation for the follow up. I have heard much about the story of Persona 2 but never got to play it myself.

[@hearty-dose-of-ranch6]

6:49 Not if you choose Reiji Kido for the 5th party member, giving him slight character development for his hate towards Takahisa Kandori. It’s not much, but it’s enough.

[@owen7592]

hyped for the EP review

[@benermanfuge8050]

I've been waiting for this

[@TrashorTreasure]

Very well put together video, man! I had played this for the first time recently and was surprised at how much I enjoyed it. I thought this was the best of the classic Persona games, still a little rough around the edges, but I really enjoyed the characterization here.

[@lssjgaming1599]

Innocent Sin is my favorite game of all time and I just love the well fleshed our characters, the mature storyline, and the superb voice acting in the Japanese version. Takehito Koyasu is one of my favorite Japanese voice actors and he really nails Tatsuya in both Persona 2 games. I just hope that since 2021 is the 25th anniversary of the Persona sh series that we can get a port of Persona 1, Innocent Sin, Eternal Punsihment, to modern systems and PCs for easier accessibility for newcomers. I also really like how Innocent Sin has great LGBT representation with Jun and Tatsuya. They are the best pairing in the game in my opinion. I also really love the soundtrack and artwork for the game, especially on PS1 with that signature sound the PS1 has and Kazuma Kaneko’s amazing artwork in the manual and the box art. Also originally Jun was going to be the protagonist of Eternal Punishment instead of Maya

[@quack-tastictictac1630]

Where did you hear about Jun being the main protagonist in EP? Sounds interesting.

[@wolvenwolfdogservices]

Then thier canon couple could work, sadly its Maya who is the EP protag if it was Jun then it could change things.

[@ryanadams0922]

second this. I have Persona 1,2IS, 2EP,3 on PSP but if Im going to get 4G on Steam I want the rest of them if not jus to add to my colleciton

[@musicaljoker4812]

Super awesome content! Keep up the great work!

[@yonsumarianov9068]

thank you very much, after watching your review on Persona 1 I really wanted to so a review on Persona 2 Innocent Sin

[@raidoukuzonoha883]

Another Great video from nam

[@Ren_Ca]

Dude, i LOVE your channel

[@Joe_Landry]

I wasn't sure if this video was about persona 2 so the description was very usefull

[@ultima1033]

Ha! Demonitization. Truly, the mastermind of the game.

[@djjamz2887]

Glad to see people like you and Marsh are talking about these SMT or Persona games. Getting people like me more into this series and just making these games more talked about. Great video.

[@bossman3450]

i love your vids man pls make more if you can.

[@andrewmanchiraju8005]

This is my Favorite Persona game and I look forward to seeing your perspective on it it and how much you do/don’t enjoy it. I’ve really been looking forward to this review

[@marcusmoss301]

Great video!!!!

[@dimensionalnemesis8636]

Holy shit! I just finished my 4th Innocent Sin playthrough last weekend and i have never gotten Yukino killed XD, straight up didn't know that was a thing, like maybe i ever so faintly remember reading a random thread years ago saying she can die but i thought the guy was high since it just never happened, i have no trouble choosing the wrong dialogue choices intentionally, but its a heavy scene for me and her loved one just died so i just never even consider leaving her behind, its an empty option in my opinion and doesn't really do anything for her and she's already gone through hell in P1 and now this, so i decide to be cruel and reasonable with "You'd deny his last request?", because i know Yukino would want to follow the request and it would give her the reason to keep living, kinda how Nanjo decides to become the number 1 man in Japan in P1 after hearing Yamaoka's last words. *cough* but yeah you took away the only reason keeping her going in her worst moment so she ends up dying it makes perfect sense, not looking forward to trying that out... Really shows the beauty of how different players can see the narrative through experiences though, if you still remember me im still on Nocturne playing it again but im nearing close to the end, and i'll be joining you playing Eternal Punishment blind because for some retarded reason for 6-7 years as a Persona fan i only now found the time to play it past the intro despite finishing all the other mainline games in months originally, also i still absolutely love P1 combat yet Innocent Sin is so slow for me, so im not a big fan of it either even though i clearly love old school games, plus the easy difficulty (did struggle a lot more this playthrough), but anywho in Eternal Punisment im at the Sanitarium currently, beat its boss and i can see we're both enjoying the increased difficulty. Before i forget this is easy to miss probably but Nyarly can somehow switch his damage to doing SP damage instead of HP damage, so if you look at your footage you can see your SP actually going down instead, though your point about damage might still stand not sure, hard to gauge different levels of easy. Also i know not everyone has all the time in the world like me but besides Persona and SMT there's also the Etrian Odyssey series made by Atlus, its hardcore old school JRPGs playing them myself, might not be your cup of tea but im sure the newer games in the series target wider audiences and you might like those, give them a look as well if you ever find the time.

[@marta2631]

If anyone never played this game, PLEASE, give it a chance! It's so painful to see that many people just ignore it ;_; ...

[@gv2212]

the gameplay just sucks so I only watched the srory.

[@mizzix]

@@gv2212 That's fair,the gameplay of the older games is really outdated

[@Drakkyr]

I just started watching the video, but I do like the name change! It’s a lot easier to remember and has a really nice ring to it.

[@elfiebranford9330]

Finally, this game (and Eternal Punishment) deserves such respect and attention. Maya is best girl~!!

[@crim1662]

part 1 of the best one

[@Rilobster]

Can't watch the vid because I don't want to spoil the game for myself, but I'll still drop a like and a comment, and even click the nordVPN link

[@Evilriku13]

Speaking of Persona 2 IS and forshadowing (this covers some spoilers, so be warned): If you start the original PS1 intro (featured in the PSP version mind you) you will also be heavily forshadowed for multiple reasons: For one the dialogue of "der Doppelgaenger" is present there, a german poem (and also a song by the same name by Schubert) which the game also refers to and is also partway key to the story and even one of the conclusion you will draw at the end of the game, even if you have to think symbolic or directly about what has been mentioned there. And the imo way more maliciously forshadowing is the music itself (that also goes heavily for the game with its leitmotifs and parallels in itself, such a high video game standard) which reappears quite some during the story later on, and even after the finale (you know which part of it!), which to my interpretation leads to that everything that happened was a rigged game, that the moment u start playing/watching this.. drama/tragedy unfold that you have already lost the game. The game is so ahead of its time writingwise that it spoilers you basically through music and that the stakes are so rigged that in this game there is no chance you can ultimately win. It is truely a vae victis!

[@maltsutty]

I really wanna play this , great video

[@EduSolsa]

So that is what this game is all about. Thanks for the video. I would play this game to better experienced it, but since I don't have free time for it, this video helps a lot. Looking forward for Eternal Punishment vídeo. =)

[@littiescorp4197]

This is a really good review. I've always been a little interested in the P2 characters cause their designs are cool, but I was never sure if I'd play the older games cause of their age, but the game doesn't actually look that bad, so I'll have to try it out. Thanks for the awesome review and making me want to play

[@Ramble1234]

How was it

[@waterbottle2047]

Kinda sad this didn't get picked up by the algorithm, it's such a good video, unlucky man.

[@NamsCompendium]

I appreciate the kind words!

[@spencer1531]

One of my favorite elements of this game is the way the town dialogue changes every time the story progresses. It's pretty incredible attention to detail.

[@marta2631]

I'm so happy people are still talking about P2 ;_;

[@JustDaZack]

Hugely enjoyed this video :) And yeah, the first hour is borderline cruel with the amount of info it throws at you. The first time playing this and trying to pay attention still went with "Whut?!". 😅😂

[@user-xl6eq5ox2q]

Yet another great analysis. Next is Eternal Punishment

[@pqulxv3810]

I think Tatsuya has a lot of personality in the game aside from the stuff that you stares in your video I'd also add that he has a temper and is sort of aggressive, I mean when you run away from battle one of his lines is " You better watch your back!"

[@charxeleon6313]

Omg I’m so glad you made a vid on this. My (2nd) favourite persona game, it’s so good. The atmosphere, the story, the subtle progression like eikichi’s friends, the unlikable characters who are developed to be the best in the series (for me anyway). I genuinely think this is the best megaten game.... other than p4g...

[@diegoval2010]

i fininshed the game like a month ago and its my second favorite game, excited to see what you think about it

[@duneslayer]

I've never played 1 or 2 but I really like the style of these older persona games and the darker tone. Yeah I love the stylish and bright style of persona 5 but I would love to see a real modern remaster of these games .

[@leschnozzberry]

holy fuucking POG (i hope that stays a twitter thing and doesn't actually become racist) thisis the most excited i've been for anything since mark rober's devil's toothpaste video. amazing how such small creators can have so much quality. keep at it.

[@trainszelda3076]

I finally just got innocent sin for the psp I look forward to watching another great video Asap when I Finnish one of the best ps1 games

[@bubbletea_]

The PS1 version isn't much harder. It's still very easy. Very detailed video. There were some things about the plot that didn't hit me until I watched this.

[@eclecticspaghetti]

Honestly this game’s story looks *insane* and really cool, but I don’t think I could bring myself to actually play it just because of the random encounters.

[@purplespectre]

Would you play it if it had a remake?

[@dx5gaming715]

@@purplespectre well that’s pretty impossible to happen

[@purplespectre]

@@dx5gaming715 I know, it was just a hypothetical.

[@scrappy2082]

it aint too bad, trust me

[@lucialudens2614]

Use a fast foward button on emulator or get estoma. The random encounter is maybe the only thing that can get to your nerves, really, but I think is totally worth it.

[@sociallyawkard5675]

Know that there is no point in living; cry that there is no answer. Where there is darkness there are shadows. I myself, am all of you humans.

[@YesLegend936]

Idk why I thought the notif was a port announcement...

[@Crok425]

The choice you made with Yukino was wrong and it does make sense. The choices in having faith in the other characters is about showing their individual strength, leaving her alone lets her get crushed by her emotional weight while "Are you going to ignore his last request...?" is about showing her that she has to get up and keep fighting because it is the right thing to do, the world is in danger and Yukino is strong enough to stand up and keep moving forward because due to the situation it's the right thing to do. It's basically about having faith in that she isn't weak instead of leaving her in her misery... not to mention that the scene is built up to show that she isn't in her right mind due to the emotional shock... so yeah... I do get your logic, though.

[@LowTier4Life]

I LOVE this game. Played the hell out of it when it came out. Funnily enough because of the SP usage correlating to the Affinity of the Persona and the scarcity of SP items, I played the entire game almost exclusively using the partie's starting, prime and ultimate personas lol.

[@iwakmangot214]

your outro song is devil trigger jazz version right? nice choice dude

[@AllBeganwithBBS]

Story's so damn good I start to tear up thinking back on some parts of it.

[@celas1]

cool just in time, I finished eternal punishment yesterday

[@Skona99]

Looking cool Joker!

[@t.t6294]

the game came out 20 years ago. I finished innocent sin yesterday and I can't believe this video is so new

[@ali-yunsworld2538]

The day persona 1 and 2 get remakes and persona 3 fes and 4 golden are ported/get remakes for the ps4, ps5 and switch. I'll be finally be able to die happy....😭🙌🏿

[@ssgss3kalijah846]

I think I have a theory on why forcing Yukino to come with you is the right answer it's because if she with you the shadow can't pull a switch with her or ambush her

[@radiantamaterasu2213]

I knew nothing about P2 and I have to say from hearing it through this video I love this story the most probably.

[@MrT--]

I hope that Persona 6 is about the P2IS cast when they've grown up and stuff and have to reawaken to their personas by confronting their shadows but in this version their shadows aren't like P4's shadows where it's a manifestation of your darkest thoughts and stuff but instead is a manifestation of how people look at you and then they awaken by telling their shadow who they really are etc. and then they fight Nyarlathotep again but it's his actual form and he's huge. yk the Persona thing. Ofc i think they'd have to fix the nazi thing. I think the rumors would be a lot more normal in the start and then get darker as the game goes on.

[@euyemura123]

Awesome review. Innocent Sin is a great game

[@Funnygay132]

*battle theme commence* Do you want my autograph?

[@masterofdisaster27]

*Persona starts to awaken “Bruh it was juSt a praNk, iT wAs juSt a PrAnK!”

[@nr2676]

Most SMT Persona in series.

[@jorjorbanks8876]

P1 takes that

[@anibala.moralessanchez8018]

I used a level 1 (no stats except for Persona stats) code I made and the game (PSP ver.) was still easy with the exception of the final bosses.

[@billyvitajedi]

Yes!!!!

[@yourlocalfemboy8198]

I always find comparing games unfair everyone’s different so everyone likes different things and I believe things should be enjoyed by themselves lol besides that I think all the personas look awesome it would be cool to see a remake of 1 and 2 with the new style of persona we know

[@judtsomeguy12190]

Would’ve been hilarious if at the last dungeon with its high encounter rate the theme is replaced with lone prayer

[@feed8271]

Well that was a surprise.

[@justin51034]

Holy shit it’s been exactly one year since this video came out and I still find enjoyment rewatching it

[@saturdaymorningcartoons9963]

I really want this game to be remade in the style og 3,4 and 5

[@tehandroidmaster]

I'm disappointed that there's no "let's positive thinking" mention in this review. Otherwise, great video my man!