Persona 3 Reload VS Persona 5 the Royal Hero's comparison/ペルソナ3リロードvsペルソナ5 ザ・ロイヤル, P3主人公(結城理)モーション比較

[@JackieJKENVtuber]

P5R: Sleepy because Dark Hour P3R: Fuck it we ball

[@Dstryrr]

We he does have a yawn animation if you stand around in Tartar Sauce

[@yu6btemz]

Tbh he still does that little spin move he does with his evoker in P3R. you can see the animation in the HUD when you switch personas

[@Raydnt69]

Not good enough, I want to see it in it's full glory like P5 showed

[@Crowned_Hearts]

The motion is different. P5R actually has impact to it he doesnt simply pull and spin his evoker

[@harizrabbit7221]

He only spin the evoker,he doent make full body move like original animation

[@kunda03248]

顔や体の全体のバランスが整ってたり、召喚機で頭撃ち抜いた時の反動の有無とか召喚時のリボンやペンダントの揺れとか細かいモーションの修正がかなり散りばめられてて凄すぎる

[@hwanniggles187]

You know i prefer Messiah's old animations better. It really gives off that feeling of being so divine that you give small gestures that give great power

[@Otto_pg]

Same

[@lemonlime8949]

Agreed

[@MrCleetio]

This boss fight in p5r was the first time I ever experienced anything to do with persona 3. You can imagine how flabbergasted I was when mid battle he whipped out a gun and shot himself. I was not really for that at all.

[@yspt]

😭😭

[@Coudrender]

Battle OST really hit's hard man I'm vibing

[@chiffoncakeandtea]

The thing in p3r is that the characters (not only the mc) take out the evoker when you're in the persona skill menu, so by the time they actually use x skill their evokers are already pointed at their heads and you only see them shoot. In the original p3, even if you were in the persona skill menu they wouldn't take out their evokers and would simply remain in their idle animations, it's only after you actually confirmed the use of a skill that they would take it out, allowing you to see the animation. They do technically have an animation in p3r, which can be seen in the blue silhouette in the skill menu, and you can actually see the mc spin the evoker although it's much less exaggerated, but it still doesn't hit the same It's such minor detail but it adds so much charm and personality that it's a shame it's gone, definitely one of the thing the og and even p5 are better

[@masterblaster38]

The fact is that withaut that, its the reason why the combats are quicker. In P3, P4 and P4G, each time you used a skill they had to do the full animation and all (pulling the evoker/card) and then the animation of the persona. The reason why in P5, P5R and P3R the combats are faster is because when you are in the menu skill the characters already go into a position of summoning their persona, so when you press the button its just "bum" and the attack inmediadly happens. That simple thing makes the normal battles actually faster.

[@meikisaragi1445]

P3R is definitely cooler with the newer character model and newer cut in. BUT i love how they show how he pulls the evoker from the holster and the particle effect when he pulls the trigger being more subtle is kind of a plus for me. (I know they also show him pulling the evoker in reload but it's just his blue silhouette because stylish menu) Still, I love both. All hail the Messiah of Persona.

[@DragonEdge10]

Well if the answer does turn out to be dlc we should be able to see that evoker twirl animation

[@meikisaragi1445]

@@DragonEdge10 yea. Since we'll be fighting him.

[@MrWiki2]

I wish that in p3r they could take out their evoker and put it back similar to p5 that’s the only part that looks more realistic and somehow better with less effects

[@Step43099]

Not counting the part where his sword disappears and reappears in his hand

[@ShadowOfMassDestruction]

Well if you just open the Persona menu and close it they do, and they probably do on Act Freely too.

[@stu6841]

If u cast the spells quickly u can see them taking out the evoker. And if you cast a support spells they have animations where they put it back (u can always see this in yukari heals).

[@RuggedRing]

I guess the reason they dont do the animation where you put back the evoker is because you can change your costume to ones that don't have a gun holster

[@kuroneko8580]

if you look closely you can see doorkun putting his evoker back it can't be seen easily since the effects cover it

[@thisisntevenmyfinalform2025]

I like how they completely remake the character models instead of reusing them, although i feel like the P5R model is more "faithful" to the PS2 version but the new models look amazing

[@TechBlade9000]

Oh no they reused the models all right, thought they were dancing game only? This is what efficient recycling looks kike

[@noodleexpanding3407]

They switched engine. P5R used atlus' in-house engine, P3 used Unreal. They prob redid the model because they can do a lot more with lighting in Unreal now. P5R used a lot of baked in lighting.

[@フロストジャック-b7z]

やっぱり銃クルクルが無くなったの勿体ねぇな

[@チェンソーマンになりたかったパパァ]

ペルソナチェンジの時にシルエットがクルクルしてますよ

[@遥ぴ]

P3Rでペルソナを切り替えると青と白の影絵で銃を一瞬クルクルさせるから、あの銃クルクルはペルソナの切り替え合図にもなってたのかなって考えたらP5Rのクルクルに未練無くなったよ

[@yuki-fs1cp]

比較してみると明らかだけどP5Rの黒すぎるところが無くなってすごい良いグラフィックだ

[@josetomascamposrobledano4618]

I love how P5 got the original English VA.

[@brezzendorf]

I wished we could keep the revolver ocelot move in P3R

[@olchum7605]

Whoever cooked the crit animations in Reload probs has a 3* Michelin restaurant

[@JoaHosoi]

massive props for making the persona summon on beat

[@angwelio]

The yawn is an idle animation when exploring tartarus I saw it waiting for the reaper to spawn

[@kaisercaesar1348]

立ち姿からしてp3rキタローの方がかっこいいわ

[@vietnguyen2293]

Personally I like the way P5R looks over P3R. I feel like the character model for Makoto looks more closely to the art style of OG P3. P3R is polished and very clean but maybe too clean

[@gohan-yummy]

モーションもCGの進化もエグいて

[@randomcdxx-lxix4552]

I love the gun spinning and original OST in P5R. Obviously the P3R version have better graphics and models, but yeah i prefer the P5R more than P3R. Oh yeah i also realized that Makoto in P5R take out his Evoker from his holster and put it back after using it, which is pretty cool. FYI, Yes i know in P3R they also show it in blue silhouette.

[@TailsMiles249]

I actually like how the gun spin when changing his persona is akin to him changing ammo types in Reload rather then just being fancy with summoning them

[@tanatornkao]

Ahhhh finally I know something missing for both of them. The G U N S P I N in original.

[@squilliamfancyson5313]

Makoto was only using 3.2% of his real power in Royale 💀

[@くまごん-n5g]

銃くるくるといちいち頭動かない点で個人的にはP5のが好き アティスはリロードのがかっこい

[@inplane9970]

Really wish they kept the unique gun flairs for each member. They're barely noticeable aside from their static poses. I know it would make the gameplay a bit slower, but anything to make it more stylish.

[@MonsterZeroLITE]

it already is stylish, this is just personal preference more than anything

[@lemonlime8949]

Anything ? Let’s have a 2 minute long awesome animation each time you want a move to be used.

[@JadenRockz99]

Yu better get ready in three years time

[@pionmiku5514]

どっちもカッコイイけど、P3Rのモーションはゆったりしすぎていると感じる。

[@user-kurozato]

どっちの服好きだなぁ

[@sirmelt1197]

damn why did makoto just yawning make me sad like what the hell atlus

[@DuskyDark4175]

persona 5 looks darker

[@jenarickman9215]

It would have been nice if they did have the animation of taking out the evoker but I imagine they only showed it when selecting a skill in order for the battles to maintain more speed and momentum

[@El_vtuber_fallido]

I like more the royal

[@GReyn]

I like P3 art style more, P5 feels too artistic like waterpaint, nice but idk.. Feels off for me..

[@NanDS_i]

You thought i wouldnt notice the sync with music at 0:53? so dope...

[@botw2260]

正直原作の銃の反動ない主人公とか桐条先輩の召喚の方が大好きだけど、リロードの召喚もかっけぇよなあ。

[@CrimRui]

The gun twirl is better in the old one. Don't know why they changed that.

[@JONtheULTIMATE]

Damn the bebeh huts different fr.

[@Crowned_Hearts]

Bro like everyone says that evoker pulling animation is cool as fuck

[@Ncsd114]

Some how I prefer p5r more……… I mean look at that gun spinning animation and simple yet effective special effects

[@shiroutheherotraceon3313]

Nice.

[@サニースカイ-m1y]

ボーカルがな・・・悪くはないんだけどyeahの部分で上がらないの違和感すぎる

[@bct2308]

0:52 is sick af

[@somebody2344]

🐸🐸🐸

[@ClearmindArtist]

You used the inferior version of Mass destruction. 😅

[@lemonlime8949]

Honestly

[@kamirikuo8945]

1.4k liker

[@anonimonovids]

Can't believe Minato P5 Sprite was better than P3R Minato lol

[@FRNNDSTVZ]

The new versions of the OST are awful...

[@MetalGearRob7]

Facts

[@xaxaxaksaksaksa1493]

so basically this game is 99% reused assets. good to know.

[@KatelynTea]

??? They remade all the environments, enemies, all the character models (reload was likely in development before Royal), they had new voice lines and remade the music Wtf you mean 99% reused assets, all I can think of are the persona models which some have been in use since the ps2 and a couple animations

[@xaxaxaksaksaksa1493]

@@KatelynTea persona 4 remake will be basically a persona 3 reload but with a couple of different models and different UI color, and it will cost 90$

[@KatelynTea]

@@xaxaxaksaksaksa1493 okay but we're not talking about a hypothetical p4re we're talking about reload, you didn't mention p4 at all in your comment and reused assets aren't even bad

[@Lumaciu]

??? Everything is new???? Do your research before commenting something and looking dumb..

[@MasiPT]

@@xaxaxaksaksaksa1493 They did use entirely new models and engine stfu