Persona 3 Reload vs Portable | Which looks better?

[@hellpwnage6665]

It's impressive how much technology improved in a year

[@AdacherTheCabbageEater]

lol

[@NaxaGamingg]

Lollll, someone paid attention to detail

[@IvoryCaffeine_]

​@@fromixty i think that's the joke?

[@fakename5308]

@@fromixty It’s wild af that 3 people were stupid enough to like your comment🤦‍♂️ Yes; you are stating the obvious to the point that you clearly got whooshed

[@Max78000]

@@fromixtyhumongous brain

[@SeiyaTempest]

"2023" is kind of misleading, it's a port of a 2009 game.

[@explainer777]

It's a port of a 2011 portable version of a 2006 game

[@senou1201]

​@explainer777 well the localization for the European audiences was in 2011, p3p came out in 2009.

[@explainer777]

@@senou1201 fair enough

[@explainer777]

@@JCaesar71306 this is about changes in graphics, which started from 2006 as for original edition of Persona 3

[@Especis]

Comparing the graphics of a PSP game and a PS4 game and asking the question in the description "which one looks better?" is really dumb to begin with.

[@chriz_ra]

Bro i miss makoto spinning his gun😭

[@lazersfixall3939]

He still does it when you go to select a move

[@tonynguyen4599]

He flips it when he switches persona

[@jay-no9qq]

@@lazersfixall3939it’s not the same though. It’s not even comparable man

[@zlangtheconqueror8351]

I swear this move was fire

[@Un_Named05]

​@@jay-no9qq his body is just blocked by the UI, but you can see his silhouette also doing the suicide gun twirl

[@Lock2002ful]

It’s a bit different in artistic style but obviously the remake looks better in general.

[@Eduardo-ll7eg]

Art style for atlus games for sure has evolved drastically, I forget the lead artists name who designs the characters but you can tel how he’s improved with the way he draws face shapes and how he draws eyes the most.

[@xornedge8204]

Idk I kinda prefer the old one 😅 Obv the improved graphics are cool but that ending animation and the amount of changes take away the more serious vibe of the OG

[@Doriya678]

​@@xornedge8204blud said animation on portable

[@xornedge8204]

@@Doriya678 what? No one mentioned the PSP game we're talking about the PS2 version you donut

[@ezzythegreat6]

​@xornedge8204 the og ending animation is not serious at all 😂 it kinda makes me laugh

[@nutterbuster305]

I'm usually not someone who says "oH nO nOt PeRsOnA 3 pOrTaBlE, pLaY fEs" but showing off the difference between fes and reload instead would've been way more fitting

[@bulba3342]

Not begin able to control party members in fes is why portable is just better

[@nutterbuster305]

@@bulba3342 portable in general is just the definitive version of 3. Honestly if they didn't make reload I would have wanted them to port FES into Goldens engine then backport all the extra content from portable into it and be the defacto version. But I'm happy with the remake

[@bulba3342]

@@nutterbuster305 They honestly can make a good dlc with the fes extra content or the femc

[@GUMPIER]

@@bulba3342cope and seethe

[@thiago292]

​@@nutterbuster305not really, none of the 3/4 versions P3 are the definitive (and P3 reaload already has all the content from FES, including an upcoming DLC for the Answer apparently)

[@1stioal]

huh, pretty sure P3P is 2009.. they just port it to new console/device..

[@plusefrie4170]

yep the person who posted this video is lazy and just trying to get clicks lol

[@AeisMado]

isn't it actually 2006? since that's when the original original came out

[@GearTech147]

​@@AeisMadoYeah... but the version used in the vid is the Portable version, ergo the release date of the original P3 is irrelevant

[@jeezycreezy4220]

Comparing a PSP game to a current hardware game is like comparing an old Honda to a Lamborgini.

[@megagino7579]

Its just fun to compare the 2.

[@christopherwhitfield4005]

I just downloaded this. Can't wait to play it.

[@TaeSunWoo]

How they walk away after the battle in Reload goes hard af

[@bittersweetpepper2482]

I love both, I wasn't alive/born when P3 P3F and Port were released, Reload is my first introduction to P3, so it's nice breaking out of my Persona 5 hyperfixation to go to another one.

[@XDevonBueno]

@@bittersweetpepper2482 only thing is p3r is basically blue p5 gameplay wise😭

[@bittersweetpepper2482]

@@XDevonBueno metaphor refantazio is just painting-p5 by your logic.

[@raycraft001]

So by the video’s logic you’re one year old

[@FreyrtheFryer]

The gloves are such a nice touch

[@jokeregg2045]

The new dungeons are so much more unique and it makes tartarus super fun.

[@thedragon12]

Yeah I was always so bored from going up Tartarus because it was always the same thing but different colors... Persona 4 Golden is my favorite even tho the dungeons in 5 is pretty sick too

[@Kam-King213]

What you find better bro, 5 Vs 3 reload. Should I ditch persona 5 on switch and get reload on ps5. I am past 1st dungeon on royal. ​@@thedragon12

[@rellertr]

​​@@thedragon12you have to be kidding me with that P4G comparison. I like P4 but the dungeons in that game are not only as boring as the ones in P3, I'd say they're MUCH worse since they don't even have the staircase rooms like in P3 that added at least SOME flair. Literally all P4 dungeons are just reskinned hallways. Also, unlike Tartarus which has one but ever changing and simple bgm, P4's dungeon themes are all somehow the most headache inducing Persona music which is mind boggling considering how good all persona music is. Heaven is an obvious exception, of course, but The Sauna and The Striptease themes actually made me want to rip my ears off while grinding dawg

[@thedragon12]

@@rellertr that is your opinion, I dont really care as it doesnt change mines anyway

[@chukyuniqul]

Yeah, seconded. Visually the new tartarus is a clear improvement. But... I still think the dungeon crawling was better in the OG because it was actually MEANINGFUL and had stakes. In the original it was part of my routine to ready up so I'm feeling great and can go exploring, and this went on until I hit the current cap. In this one I just leave exploring to the 2nd to last day so I can get every lost git in one swoop. And does it feel like that fits the story and dialogue? Edit: also the difficulty made the rewards worthwhile and every inch of progress was earned, which makes up for the boring design because you spend a lot of time strategizing or fighting and when you do get to the point where you sweep in an area you're near the end which makes it a pay-off before you enter a new area with new loot and enemies which is exciting.

[@microcosmic]

it's a crime they didn't create a FeMC version this os beautiful 😢

[@TheAtticus82]

Tbh I miss the look of Portable when playing Reload. It has a certain je ne sais quoi that Reload just doesn’t.

[@azk9218]

They changed the vibe a bit. P3 was the first Persona with major gameplay systems implemented and world wide success. It was still standing between what SMT was and what modern Persona is and they remade it with that in mind

[@nickphaux]

I never played the original but im playing reload and im having an absolute blast. This game is very fun, i like it just as much as i did 5

[@nickphaux]

Just finished it.. rarely does a game enter my top 5 after my first play through, this one definitely did…

[@wildforce1433]

@@nickphauxending of the game really was peak, I feel like the ending was just perfect

[@100_yen_man]

Why compare portable to reload? Portable is basically a downgraded version of persona 3. Why not use Fes?

[@marcoswors]

Because you can't buy fes anymore

[@BeWaReJay]

@@marcosworsJust pirate it??

[@marcoswors]

@@BeWaReJay the video is comparing the two current versions of p3 avaliable on the market, p3fes ain't one of them... You can pirate fes, but promoting piracy isn't what the creator of the video was aiming for(obviously)

[@Mondo_Monkey]

​@@BeWaReJay thats illegal, my Dad works for Atlus and I'm telling him! I hope you like prison food!

[@chukyuniqul]

​@@marcosworsit's not piracy if it's abandonware.

[@danarthur771]

the real comparison is P3 FES: it's so hard it makes you throw the controller P3 R: it's too ez, even merciless feels like a kids game

[@ThatPancakeCat]

Are you using DLC personas?

[@danarthur771]

@@ThatPancakeCat no. i played p3fes, dlc will only ruin the game. also i dont control the other sees member to bring the og hardcore feels

[@dmitriydubovetsky5778]

game being too hard isnt something always good u know...

[@jamesmarkell3343]

I feel like everyone who says this is exaggerating. Anyone who finds it easy usually has already played the original or other persona games. That really does make it easier for you than someone else playing P3R as their first atlus game.

[@pre-violetmelain2984]

​@@dmitriydubovetsky5778P3fes wasn't hard, i played it last year and at max was tricky

[@blacklight683]

Am currently watching p3 fes oneday if i came back to p3 i might watch reload

[@IvanShi-k1s]

DISTURBING THE PEACE🔥🔥🔥

[@Afuro-Ougi2]

Why would you choose portable instead of FES for the comparison lol?

[@AmphotericcMike]

Because portable was the one which was ported and they probably already brought it before reload came out

[@nexus8824]

fem mc

[@evanhuggins450]

I tried fes so many times and I couldn't do it just cause it felt like the party was doing the stupidest stuff but Reloaded letting you control the party and the other quality of life changes. I love it

[@J0KERR3577]

I would buy reload once its on sale because its 70 bucks on steam

[@Promtheus211]

2023 was when p3 portable was published!!! Dang i feel old already

[@fefebebecuddle4347]

first impressions of persona are people killing themselves

[@BooneErica]

Persona 3 Portable was a PSP game before it was re-released on other consoles.

[@Webwalkerz]

Its like comparing Super mario brothers to Super mario world Also it tries to replicate p3 (and maybe f.e.s)

[@blackpanther8813]

I've been playing persona 3 reloaded for a while now.And I gotta say I am very impressed with the visual upgrade as far as graphics go. Job well done atlus

[@twindragon5668]

The first review I saw for Persona 3 Reload was legit “I sold my first kid for this game and it was worth it.” They are 100% right, this game was a fantastic remake to play and it should win an award at the GOTY. Even though I played the original Persona 3, I was completely left off guard by how fantastic this game was and I wish I could play it again for the first time

[@Burnie_96]

Too easy

[@pre-violetmelain2984]

​@@Burnie_96harder than p4g and p5 and p5r tho

[@nova_da_silli]

Now compare the cutscenes between Reload and FES

[@user-px2ku1rb9j]

Crazy how time flies..

[@Izoflya]

Also keep in mind that they improved graphics in steam version of p3 protable

[@dinahpearlcampos2104]

People:Its just a game Me and others:Disterbing the peace🗣️🗣️🗣️🔥🔥🔥🔥look in to my eyess.🔥🗣️🗣️🗣️🔥🔥🔥

[@andrebaxter4023]

Awesome how far we’ve come.

[@Jay_Is_Here_1125]

"comparing graphics of a game made in unreal engine vs P3P" hmm I wonder what has the better graphics the world may never know but regardless what version people play the story is still great

[@andrewgibson7855]

Should be titled “ray tracing, before and after”

[@Tarboy]

Kinda miss how dark the original used to look like

[@Miles_Moralez_-o-]

Can’t wait for the answer to come out on September 🤑🤑🤑

[@sonofthefakegod]

Ngl I love the old look, I just got reloaded and I don’t really like the look of it, I guess it’s because it’s based off of p5 and I hate p5 with a passion, I will finish it just to because but I definitely give the OG the win on this one for looks, sound and voice acting is better in the new one so for me a perfect one would be the look of the old with the sound of the new

[@savajesus8614]

I hate that game not being on switch, i really like persona games as i can chill play them while laying on my bed, now have no choice but to play the portable version

[@calebmcnamara6602]

I got portable since it was only 12 bucks and it’s great so far

[@tombotamist1174]

The best bit about reload is that it made tartarus actually fun

[@SmartJapanHacksCulture]

P3P doesn't look that bad at all. I played it first on the PSP, even after buying P3 and FES for PS2, because I love giving Atlus money.

[@jeremyfrancisco9387]

I'm so glad I bought a PS5. What an upgrade Reload was from Portable

[@Dwayne_19K]

Idk why they didn’t keep the ability to actually walk around in school and other places in the portable version like they had in FES

[@theprobotboisyt2801]

Idk maybe because the psp is worse than the ps2? Dude, they wouldn’t make the change if it wasn’t necessary.

[@risekujikawa7743]

normal P3 Reload, P4 Golden, P5 Royal, like added dlc, events also char maybe?

[@mark_1136]

I personally like the look of the original (I’m not just saying that because I bought it thinking it was reload)

[@wildforce1433]

🤣😭😭 how bro the price difference would have given it away surely

[@mark_1136]

@@wildforce1433 bro I wasn’t paying attention I just saw low number and persona3

[@FireyTheAlienDragon]

P3 portable was not released in 2023. You're talking about the port of the game that's on Steam that was released in 2023. The original psp release was released 2009

[@Alpheus_09C]

The battle reward scene goes way too hard

[@Inquisitor-Doi]

That is how remaking, reworking, and reskinning games works, they normally look different, if they didn't it would be a rerelease

[@jreen58]

P3Fes would have been a more 1 to 1 comparison but interesting nonetheless

[@zeronime284]

Feels like a different games, nice Atlus

[@luigi7781]

Ogs artstyle is better but the remake obviously has better graphics.

[@lovelysophxox]

damn only one year apart 😂👏🏼

[@Sunflamer]

Kinda silly to compare P3P and P3R, tho. Wouldn't comparing P3FES to P3R make more sense?

[@andryanX]

Bruh p3 released like 15 years ago of course reload 10x times looks better 😂 but tbh, p3 back then was such a breakthrough in jrpg

[@danylol772]

Shii, i wonder if a 2024 game made for current gen platforms looks better than a 2009 psp game.

[@Crescent_Crystal2009]

Damn you're right, so hard to see which is game is more enjoyable

[@jeremykeller3041]

P3r truly is the biggest improvement of any game of all time tbh. They took every single part of the game (and yes I mean every. Single. Part.) And improved upon it 10 fold.

[@andryanX]

Not every single part, a 1/3 part of the game (femc) not implemented 😂 with that fans can actually save shinjiro and have a social links with all SEES member.

[@pre-violetmelain2984]

​@@andryanXFEMC isn't that differen tho, and the episodes are better than the FEmc s links

[@bradyoconnell4963]

I mean it’s really just reskin of P5 the engine to look like P3 and P5 came out like 8 years ago

[@Alameguy]

It’s mighty quiet here

[@yellowmonster1563]

PERSONA...DISTURBING THE PEACE!!!! LOOK INTO MY EYES NOW TELL ME THE THINGS YOUR LUAGTHING ABOUT ME BEHIND MY WAY!!!!!!THE TENCITY I KNOW IS ABOUT TO BREAK DOWN NOW IS TO LATE FOR APOLIEGS NOW!!!!!!!!! *MUSIC*

[@aydonisgaming]

They really need to take Denvuo away 😭

[@boisvert45]

Did you really ask "which version looks better"

[@Jake-he3oh]

It’s mighty quiet here…

[@pascaldietrich4661]

Comparising P3 from PS2 with P3R would be better, 'cause P3P was downgraded for an handheld in the graphic aspect

[@wilcoxway]

It's too bad Reload is missing like 30% of Persona 3's total content.

[@AjDrag_8]

It also has tons of new content that the others don’t have to make up for it and the answer is coming as dlc so I’d say it’s okay

[@wilcoxway]

@@AjDrag_8 Oh? Having The Answer as DLC might actually make me buy it.

[@logan-pe4rm]

@@wilcoxwayThe Answer is 100% confirmed to be added later on as DLC

[@logan-pe4rm]

@@wilcoxwayI recommend Game Pass. It’ll be on gamepass for atleast the next full year. Especially PC Game Pass if you have a PC. Or use the Xbox Gold to Game Pass Ultimate conversion trick. It converts Gold to Game Pass Ultimate at a 1:1 rate, you can lock in 3 years of GPU for like $160

[@wilcoxway]

@@logan-pe4rm Nice! Now all we need is a DLC for Portable's alternative campaign and we'll have the best possible version of Persona 3.

[@lolipomfp]

portable was the most misery a persona game put me through, that said, cant wait to buy reload when answer's released

[@ValeriaVarvaria]

Nice

[@jijithirdeye]

p3reload is so disgustingly green it hurtss

[@Peter-gd3qy]

It’s like night and better looking night

[@shevv5263]

Disturbing the peace look into my eyes 🗣🗣🗣🗣🔥

[@bobmcwang3700]

I really tried with Reload but I don't like the new VAs.

[@SilentSkyeGaming]

The fact that persona 3 reload uses the same tech as persona 5

[@Rukia1990]

Now we just need FEMC/Minako.. pls atlus 😔

[@NirúMidori]

Missing FemC

[@Stop1601]

My guy didn’t even use the same kill bruh.

[@AlexDixon-x3d]

Its mighty quiet in here................ PERSONA!

[@joaocajada261]

We need reload on Nintendo switch. If we got persona 5 royal than it’s possible

[@FernandoGarciaJr-n2v]

DISTURBING THE PEACE

[@ManMab-qq4up]

Persona 3 reload is a remake so of course it gonna look better

[@user-x56ji4i2o1]

wait so is it OK for me to play persona 3 reload (at least for my first time)

[@DelanoSeven7]

Of course it is, why wouldn't it be ?

[@user-x56ji4i2o1]

Im a big iverthinker and i kinda just dont know if im missing out on something major if i dont behin with the original (like,, do i need to play it in the future?) @DelanoSeven7

[@DelanoSeven7]

@@user-x56ji4i2o1 Persona 3 reload has everything and more, there's really no reason to play the original outside of curiosity.

[@user-x56ji4i2o1]

@@DelanoSeven7 tysm i was so lost i had no idea which to play 😭

[@Random-Guy328]

Yes, the game is AMAZING, it was my introduction to the persona franchise. I loved every second of it, it has been one of the only games that has made me cry in years.

[@Astrum05]

What's the name of the song that plays during the battle comparison?

[@pink_grape]

Guys its only my opinion but i think persona 3 reload from year 2024 looks kinda better than a game from 2009...

[@RoxasHeartplay]

This question is invalid for using P3P's visual novel style world traversal and not P3 nor FES which are similar to Reloaded. So here's a better question.... Mass Destruction, whose is better: P3's, FES' answer, the remix from the movie, or Reload's? The reincarnation on ain't that bad either (just saying).

[@Isaac_Aaronshorts]

Bro the new dorm song is @ss in my opinion. The old one was way better.

[@bagasadifirdaus9278]

"which look better?" well what do you think? which one huh?

[@JoelSFM]

Instead of [persona 3 portable vs persona 3 reload] do [persona 3 fes vs persona 3 reload] since reload is a remake of persona 3 fes

[@arm514ve5]

I Miss the evoker spin.

[@SoraBSoarin]

P3P did not come out 2023 it came out years ago just got ported to modern day consoles and pc

[@Now_Roxas]

Portable was not 2023, it released on the psp

[@NotVeryAverage3]

Its mighty quiet here…

[@silverfay2902]

If only they make an alternate ending

[@Joueur_3030]

"Persona 3 Portable (2023)" what th are you smoking? It was released in 2009... And on PSP...

[@mylittleworld3774]

I like them both

[@Dante2831]

I miss the gun twirl

[@vergil_vt]

why not show off Persona 3 FES the best version on comparison for persona 3 Reload?

[@EstrelaZero]

Playstation 5 Vs. Atari: WHICH LOOKS BETTER????

[@Agathaz_Soul]

I like both.

[@PhoenixDavis-xx1wl]

Reload is better but the actual fighting in tartrus is still a slog and makes me put down my controller just because i hate taking an hour or more eveytime i gotta go to it

[@jaylenanderson5864]

Really got people saying p3p came out in 2009 like their trying to defend the graphics😭 it’s ok to admit a remake looks better than the original people lol

[@pre-violetmelain2984]

Yeah but it doesn't make sense comparing p3p instead of p3fes

[@theprobotboisyt2801]

@@pre-violetmelain2984like it will make a difference. It is almost impossible to obtain a legal video for p3 fes

[@_Carmela_]

Sorry Darling! I'm gonna stay with Persona 3 Portable because of the female main character!😄 She is best girl!😌💅