Dr Swamy at SAMSOE on when India will be a 5 Trillion economy

Dr. Swamy explains how his advisor Dr. Simon Kuznets arrived at defining the term Gross Domestic Product (GDP). Watch this fascinating talk where Dr. Swamy explains the GDP computation with examples.
#SubramanianSwamy #Economy

[@hussaintanvir3415]

Let's campaign for Subramanian Swamy to be the finance minister in present government so that our country can benefit from his rational ideas. Compel the present government to make him FM.

[@fact5832]

How much did he pay you for this?

[@hussaintanvir3415]

@@fact5832 How much do you expect from him

[@TheCosmique11]

arun rao he does speak on agriculture, cow Jessie’s, A2 milk and how to get water to farmers. He is well informed.

[@rameshyk]

@@hussaintanvir3415 well said 😂😂

[@knightf8648]

Aren't enough hotheads there in cabinets? Do you want another one?

[@sumandasgupta6179]

this is like a class taken by a professor ... this type of discourse is what really matters ... others in the media are just spraying opinions

[@citisamsjw5513]

You mean spraying fart😆😆😆😂😂😂😂🤣

[@sumandasgupta6179]

this is the kind of motivational speech Indians should hear rather than getting depressed by following on what is happening in Delhi

[@knightf8648]

I haven't followed anti CAA protests since December. It makes me depressed.

[@knightf8648]

@rhonit roy ours is divided,diverse society with numerous faultlines. If not religion then caste reservations would be next subject of protests. What to care about and not to?

[@sansubr19]

@@knightf8648 Your comment above is very naive. We have a diverse society, I agree, but you need to understand the only people protesting are Muslims under the guise of being Anti-CAA. You cannot generalize what one community does and juxtapose that on the entire country's fabric. You need to look at things from a telescopic view. Things are obviously not so beautiful all the time, but this is reality and this is what you must live through. You must understand it, pay attention to it so you can secure your family and your community.

[@varundurvasula7536]

there are 21 people who misread samsoe as samosa and got angry and disliked the video.

[@malladipradyumna7035]

44 now!

[@MadaraUchiha-vd5de]

I hope he live a healthy and active normal life upto 100 years....

[@sg3226]

Madara Uchiha more

[@gouthamsagar3641]

As usual you are keep on insisting some key issues ... hope the results would emerge with days yet to come .. long life to guide us more sir

[@ushanouduri]

Our next generation definitely needs you Sir. May you live the longest.!!!!

[@ashuuvatikaa]

Currently the greatest Indian figure...

[@RaviKumar-ii6cb]

But ignored in his own party.

[@shivmuttoo]

Hope the finance minister was sitting in the audience and taking notes...

[@lolvivo8783]

I was going to comment the same. Shes probably taking them online like us.

[@ronytjoseph]

🤣🤣

[@kirankonher]

Mrs.Sitharaman is as RESPECTABLE as my own mother. & She knows BIOLOGY

[@kirankonher]

Sir, MODI JI is IN & YOU are OUT. Please wake up. Otherwise, you will continue to be in dog house.

[@manjunathgangadhargangadha4364]

Swamy forgetting he is over 80...

[@mdpasha5599]

Every answer he made his perfect to the question directly without any time pass things. This legendary man is still not our finance minister, Indians loose big without his say in Indian Economy. He really concerned about people, such people should lead the economy at any cost.

[@mdpasha5599]

Most iconic speech, especially in question & answers segment the answers were like economic enlightenment. He really concerned about this country and lives of Indians

[@mrinalsarkar5190]

10:15 - God treats you like a tennis ball..if he hits you to the ground (harder) you go up even higher.. well said..

[@RajKGajjela]

He's really high spirited & ambitious for an octogenarian.

[@sumandasgupta6179]

wow what a good explanation on GST ... I have been hearing a lot of anguish from honest small and medium business owners

[@borntorebel3848]

I admire Smamy sir honesty and straight forward attitude who don't shy away from speaking his mind though at times I don't agree with him but when it comes to economic he is an Indian gem.

[@ankur001ca]

Swamy with huge wisdom and knowledge is not indias finance minister ..is the most sad thing

[@saikumar-vz6vl]

Ask P.M Modi

[@roserosarosen5637]

Swaami Sir's immense knowledge is widely acknowledged..! One needs to have done thorough homework before engaging with him!

[@PARMARDEFENCE]

But why he isn't the FM

[@pankajmundhra7421]

Because if he become he won't listen to even modi and will do what he feels is right even if that goes against bjp

[@666lucky5]

he charged huge amount of salary and he is not puppet

[@chetan8872]

My guru Swamy sir🙏my ideal person

[@checkfacts9701]

Swamiji..... please live long at least another 100 yrs. For sake of my country.

[@MrSirAussie]

One awesome, enriching and inspirational Dr. Subramanian Swamy. JAI HIND. JAI SRI RAM. BHARAT MATA KI JAI.

[@SaiTeja-zi4uc]

Every thing is devalued, people lost confidence in investment and doing business. Banks looking at everything as worthless ,people lost hope in risk taking because things getting devalued, undervalued by Govt attacks. Democracy changed its definition to By the Govt,To the Govt and For the Govt.

[@bhaskar0903]

Swamji is the best. Lots to learn from him.

[@TheVinodhrkumanu]

I thank Pgurus channel for posting this very informative video... Now high quality knowledge are accessible..

[@VikashKumar-hm7rx]

Swamy sir is best and we are proud of him😊👍

[@Aditya-vb8sm]

Atleast modi should give him a cabinet rank just like pv narshima Rao did,or advisor of nirmala sitharaman.

[@mikedanil]

It won't work. Nirmala's ego will not allow that.

[@chengapparanjith141]

Motivating talk by Dr.Swamy!! Hope his ideas get implemented soon.

[@omkaracharya1993]

Thanks a lot for this video,great session by Dr.Swamy

[@manoharkashyap1836]

Pranamas to Dr.swamy and thanks to Pgurus for allowing us to be a part of true economics

[@bmbuvkeair]

Great sir. Thanks for sharing your ideas.

[@Saral_Lekhi]

Hearing this I am now scared that BJP will leave a legacy of blunder financially. The way Dr. Swamy explains it, GST is indeed a blunder. :(. Very depressing

[@yugalsharan]

Dr. Swamy, a brilliant man, destroyed by chamchas around him. Had he invested in grooming bright honest & fearless talent, our country could have been a better place.

[@getprabhs]

You are a great man and inspiration to all of us sir.Eager to meet in person

[@VIKASHKumar-office]

Very good lecture

[@sg3226]

Epitome of knowledge and he explains the concepts in such simple terms, and of course his sense of humor is exceptional too. I support Modi ji for his daring actions and strategies BUT WHY IS ONE OF THE senior most and worthy stalwart ( in politics, academics, strategies) not made the FIN minister???? This is why I believe we should never be dedicated to a political party or be a blind follower of a political leader. Swamy sir has been very clear GST is not meant for Indian economy. For example, many handicrafts - wooden toys and kitchen tools made in Mahua, Gujrat have 18% GST levied on them. They are suffering to the verge of extinction. Another one is the rare lamb-wool and cotton weavers in Gujrat itself who are victims of 18% GST and so on.

[@RaviKumar-ii6cb]

The obvious reason is that if he finds fault in his own party, he will fire them as well. He is supposed to be a loose cannon. In politics everybody within the party are very diplomatic. That is the thumb rule.

[@primeautobots5030]

What a clarity of thoughts. Long live legend

[@coolkal7590]

Listening to this I'm pretty certain the maverick will never be made FM under any govt And thanks heaven for that

[@Utkarsh.S]

Yes he says abolish tax gst increase interestet on FD, decrease interest on loans

[@eshantwasekar435]

Definitely it is one of the most incite full lecture on economy.

[@shivamkesarwani8477]

what a speech...sir..@@@indepth analysis wow sir!!!

[@atmakurmuraliKrishna]

Campaign for Dr. Swamy to reach finance ministry is in progress. All to join and spread to the high command of ruling

[@krishnanaishadham9359]

Hats off swamijj

[@templetours9]

Dr Swami for FM

[@Do_Anything_you_want]

1:07:14 Budget & Gulf war

[@SaiPavanKumar19]

Same person was trolled for saying printing lakshmi on currency note will improve economic growth

[@The6rohit]

Dr. Swami's confidence is amazing. But can someone tell me if bank's offer loans at 9% and accept FDs at 9% also then how do the banks gain? Am I missing something?

[@ajayarora7301]

Separate the banking & lending Anyone can lend Separate the wages & profits, Govt will pay wages & investor will get profits, More wages More Profits Stakeholder Capitalism

[@natalkumar6132]

@@ajayarora7301 for that to work we need a legal system which is a guarantee and a protector of economy . I mean laws as silly as Spitoons are some silly shit which are stalling the things we need .

[@nanusk991]

Dr.Subramanian Swamy

[@sumandasgupta6179]

really happy to know that Swamiji is talking about INR/USD exchange rate ... it seems to be totally absurd now

[@capitalsubdivision708]

he is fittest to be the finance minister. man of word and action.

[@atmakurmuraliKrishna]

What about huge film sets, informal labour employed in housing sector, construction sector?

[@premlatamahale3256]

Grand salute to you sir, Mr Swamy!! Jai Hind!

[@vivekjagota7373]

Dr Swamy 🙌🙌🙌

[@seenamoolya2059]

Excellent

[@pallabsamanta3884]

Wait and watch

[@bendrekunal]

Wow ....

[@alokkc1356]

Best thing will a debate b/w Dr Swamy and Nirmala on current Economy

[@Abhaysingh-zw4mi]

Supperrrrrr ...... 💐💐💐💐💐🌷🌷✍✍✍✍🙏🙏🙏 . .

[@sumandasgupta6179]

growth rate = rate of investment / capital output ratio ... corruption (aka transaction costs) erodes rate of investment and increase capital output ratio

[@vitsboy46]

1:00:00

[@VeeraragavanN]

Why is the audio mono (right side only)?

[@vikasdwarkinath5309]

I was wondering the same

[@Primus_suspectus]

Gold

[@niraj2020]

India's economic policies are very much wrong. US and western nations living with our money in manipulated stock market, higher interest rate, currency manipulation, etc. This area needed to be exposed. US and western nations interest 2%. FDI in banking foreigners or indian politician and manipulators investing and taking away profit without adding any wealth or productivity, citizen of India get enslaved to other nations at 6 to 8% basis without their sin. Without collecting any income tax many countries flourishing including less VAT or GST and property taxes, and so many licence fees and taxes again our faulty system of tax collection making enslaved to the system called govt. and multinational companies and govt. Despite collection more taxes nations debt rising rapidly. Dr. Swami making wonderful expose on various front which we should not ignore esp the govt of the day. I want Dr Swamy make above point to expose the govt. Anyway middle class and general caste in the country is quite worried and unhappy with the govt. Dr. Swami and like minded people like Sree Iyer and we'll committed come forward in making a political platform voicing our opinion and electoral prospects where we are the deciding factor electorally as well as a tax payer who is main contributor to the natin.

[@3idiotfilms723]

Totally!

[@sankarshbb9503]

Instead of typing on computer please find a way to contribute, 🙏🙏, we need people like you and swamy.

[@aparnaakilla4462]

There are very few people who put their position and ego aside and listen to and value other’s opinion, be it a layman or be it a person like Dr. Swamy. If he’s going to produce his life in an unabridged version with thousands of pages, I’d still be delighted to read it.

[@maddy1429]

Mr. Swamy must be our finance minister,,,,,,

[@atmakurmuraliKrishna]

Holding government and the bureaucracy accountable for corruption will automatically check corporate corruption too, because it is the former that must be bribed for corporations to circumvent the law.

[@neelbhai1234]

I support Swami for FM

[@pranjalgahlaut1433]

Does this mean if i go and work in US and earn in dollars and come back to India and converting to rupees, this is going to be increasing inflation because more money is being put in the market than there should be ( given the dollar to rupee exchange rate is higher than it should be )

[@kirtanpatel967]

22:00 :)

[@digavalliramachandra4504]

He is genius with a brilliant academic record. He is outspokenly critical of his party's economic policies which very few politicians have such guts to do so . So far so good. It seems he seriously believes that he is capable of bringing a turn around in the economic scenario of the country if he is made FM. Probably most of his party men cannot even comprehend what he is speaking. Dr. Swamy should have continued his academic career in Harvard .

[@bharathajay8397]

Make sense on GST

[@manichand1996]

40:00

[@venkateshsubramaniam7631]

FASCINATING GENIUS INDIA MISSES A LOT

[@manvendrasingh3119]

Great swamy

[@kgmuralidharan07]

All These sounds good of improving our economy but it should be implemented or allowed to be implemented.

[@atmakurmuraliKrishna]

Bureaucracy should take lead. If a bureaucrat is found corrupt, he should be shown the jail in months. Politicians stay for five years only. Bureaucrat should not fear a politician. IAS officer is an appointee of President. So as governor. Both must become watchdogs and bark and bite against corrupt politicians. It is easy. Citizens must be ethical minimum for 5 years

[@SaiTeja-zi4uc]

Every hypocritical economist should learn from this legendary Indian economist. Such rational financial minister like Swamy will definitely improve the incomes of people. Increasing the peoples income is the only solution for poverty.

[@cb9461]

I always like and respect Swamiji but somehow could not swollow fixed exchange rate suggestion. Maybe in new world order when dollar looses it's predominance it may become possible .

[@mukundshamlalshamlal5959]

Please Mr. Mr. PM MODI we humble request you to appoint Dr Swami to the portfolio of Finance minister. he is not only a brilliant economist but a great patriot of BHARAT. No one maybe as dedicated as you are but he definitely has a great love for you and our nation.

[@pankajmundhra7421]

@1:03:15 Why GST failing?

[@ramkumarkantha9143]

Thanks Pankaj

[@Akshaykumardexit]

There is some problem with the audio. Not able to hear the speaker

[@elamvaluthis7268]

Good you should include temple poojaris mutt Lords income church properties wealth income and other religious income also put income tax India shall develop

[@chid3835]

Make him the FM already!

[@bhaveshbhatt5870]

I am here for samose

[@madnr9150]

Rishi Sunak is the Chancellor of Exchequer (Fin Minister) of UK is the son in law of Mr. Narayan Murthy. Wikipedia Sunak was born on 12 May 1980 in Southampton, Hampshire[1] to Yashvir and Usha Sunak.[2][3] His grandparents were born in Punjab, India and emigrated from East Africa to the UK in the 1960s.[4] His father Yashvir was a general practitioner (GP) and his mother Usha was a pharmacist who ran a local pharmacy.[

[@kirankonher]

Sir, I respect your nationalism

[@kirankonher]

Sir, What have you delivered to INDIA?

[@kirankonher]

Sir, you rightly said that you don't know BIOLOGY

[@kgmuralidharan07]

In the rupee dollar exchange rate explanation Dr Swamy has closed all the doors for our prime minister or opened. Year 2024 will be interesting.

[@subhankardeysarkar1043]

🙏🏽🙏🏽🙏🏽🙏🏽🙏🏽🙏🏽🙏🏽

[@atmakurmuraliKrishna]

Caterers for marriages, flower decorators for marriages, decorators for marriage and many such services cost more than lakhs. Is it getting included in GDP. Many roadside vendors earn thousands per day. There are many restaurants in India won't figure in GDP. What about charities in temples, where millions are fed across India. Are they in GDP?

[@curiousmind2726]

There is a sound problem. I can see the video, but nor audio ????

[@anirbanbhattacharya2874]

Your right earphone may be bad

[@curiousmind2726]

@@anirbanbhattacharya2874 I don't use ear phone. I watch it on a desk top, and my speakers are working well.

[@kgmuralidharan07]

It seems the economy was handled very badly or without much knowledge.

[@crazyrebel7406]

I have small doubt. Government is speaking goal of 5 trillion dollars. If governments target is in INR then inflation comes to picture. How will inflation rate of Indian economy affects dollars.

[@Awesomeness7ish]

Seriously, the man can be difficult to work with but he understands the Economic fundamentals which the sitting FM has no clue about. He must be drafted into the Finance Ministry immediately.

[@rishvinwin]

If USD is devalued suddenly in India to Rs.35/- a dollar from the current Rs.70/-, what will happen to the exporters who have concluded contracts at the current conversion rate?

[@RK-bj8ho]

They would take the dollar (global trade usually fixed in USD) and keep it in swiss bank instead of converting it back to INR ..... but more imp to understand that arbitrary devaluation not possible (USD is free float currency), RBI cannot simply set rate any rates it likes without taking corresponding market action ..... to get to 35, RBI will need to buy up very very large quantity of INR using its dollar reserves.

[@rishvinwin]

@@RK-bj8ho Firstly, If exporters keep their money with swiss banks, how will they pay their bills? Secondly, If RBI has to use its dollar reserves to buy back rupees, does RBI hold that much dollars to buy as much Rupees required to bring it to 35 rupees a dollar?

[@rohanpatil1343]

How many of you mistook samsoe for samosa ?

[@adrrpa168]

True, if smart people dont take risks then poverty of nation is gauranteed

[@sisirjs3333]

Y isn't swami the FM of India??? He could be a great one... He just has to understands the difference btw friends and foes...

[@HRHKamal]

Swamy has taken over the role of the opposition, & is offering oversimplistic, impractical, & unworkable solutions. His greatest quality is that he is a proud & devoted Hindu.

[@kirankonher]

Catch Big People, I agree with you. & I respect you for thruth. Go, catch Trump

[@Baargu]

Why u hate my left ear?!

[@hussaintanvir3415]

Because Swamjee is Right idealistic.

[@Baargu]

@Aarjun Adhikari I was talking about the audio.. through ear phones.. Good example of people finding what ever meaning they are looking for... And then agitating against it..