Рет қаралды 78,603
The Lynnwood, Washington School of Rock covering the song Pigs by Pink Floyd at Tony V's Garage in Everett, Washington.
NOTE - tasteful critiques, comments, and opinions are welcome, but here are a few disclaimers to consider before making an overly critical or snide remark:
1) All performers on stage were age 16 or under at the time of performance (I added approximate ages to their names below). THINK ABOUT THAT. What were YOU doing when you were 12-16?
2) As part of their curriculum at the School of Rock, they are typically taught about the bands and songs that they play and a bit about what was going on in the world at the time, why it was written, etc. They often perform generational or honored musician-themed music shows (some examples of past shows: 50th Anniversary of Woodstock, 80's Rock, Tribute to Rush, Women of Rock, Best of Bowie, Classic Metal, Prog Rock, etc) and most of them are fans of (or at least have a respectful appreciation for) the most influential rock music of past and present generations. They actually LIKE a lot of the music they play. Compare that to most common 12-16-year-olds and the music and culture they're talking about at that age (if they even care about either).
3) There are several other performers in the group than what you see on stage and they switch out most of them on EVERY song. Imagine how challenging this is to coordinate on each song: having to quickly get in/out of a drum kit, unplug/plug-in individual guitars/bass/effects/microphones, etc., having to make sure the last person didn't accidentally leave on the tuner pedal (why is there no sound from the amp?) or didn't push in the microphone plug quite enough (why is my microphone not working?) or raise/lower the seat height (why can't I reach the cymbals?). These kids (and their directors) handle all that chaos so incredibly well, really.
4) This was recorded using my cell phone only (no special recording equipment) so the picture and sound quality are not great. But keep in mind that the overall WAY the music is played and whether it should sound EXACTLY the same as the original is subjective. When was the last time you went to see a concert and the band played their songs EXACTLY like the album? Pretty boring if they did that every time, if you ask me. Their music director attempts to arrange each song to do it justice, for sure, but sometimes it's truly a unique variation of the original. No, the keyboard does not sound EXACTLY like the way it sounds on the album (they didn't have a 1970's Hammond organ), the guitar could have been louder (she was having technical difficulties with the amp), the bass player could have stepped up to the front more (she's really talented and did especially great on this one, but it's a pretty small stage), the cymbals were a bit sharp sounding (when do drums ever sound right when recording from a phone?), etc., etc., etc. All accurate. more or less. Bottom line should really be: did they at least do the song justice? With about three months of once-a-week band practices before performance (some of the kids have never even HEARD of the songs before they're assigned), I'd say they kicked some serious booty.
Vox: Olive (13)
Lead: Ava Llew (14)
Rhythm: Madeline (12)
Bass: Marissa (16)
Keys: Lief (14)
Drums: Gretchen (16)