Pink Floyd - 1st Echoes Performance! 1971 -High Quality-

[@MilesBellas]

0:03 "you know that one?" "no, never heard it"

[@pinkrudy]

ha! they were in for a treat

[@chillingonthesofa]

they didnt know what they were in for. history happening right in front of them.

[@ssm2942]

@@chillingonthesofa historical 🙏

[@Bulldog__67]

This is pretty much the only reason I like the internet. So much for us Floyd fans to discover and experience.

[@mr.mirchenstein6549]

Right? Should be a slogan. "RARE MUSIC: It's The Only Good Thing About The Internet". LOL. 😎🎶🎶

[@234cheech]

lol try it before the internet

[@dre4011]

Amen!

[@shashankpawar8010]

Totally agreed

[@captainrikcaldwell9375]

Totally agree

[@milfsfilms]

*"The Return of the Son of Nothing"* Planets meeting face to face, Bound to the air of light, how sweet! If painlessly we might embrace, The perfect union deep in space. Ever might this once relent, And give us leave to shine as one, Our two lights here forever, one light blended. And in that longing to be one, The parting summers sound is gone, I see you've got to travel on, And on and on, around the sun. Strangers passing in the street, By chance two separate glances meet, And I am you and what I see is me. And do I take you by the hand, And lead you through the land, And help me understand the best I can. And no one calls us to move on, And no one forces down our eyes, And no one speaks and no one tries, No one flies around the sun. Cloudless everyday you fall, Upon my waking eyes, Inviting and inciting me to rise. And through the window in the wall, Come streaming in on sunlight wings, A million bright ambassadors of morning. And no one sings me lullabies, And no one makes me close my eye’s, And so I throw the windows wide, And call to you, across the sky.

[@MilesBellas]

inspired by.... *Two Planets* by Allama Sir Muhammad Iqbal Two planets meeting face to face, One to the other cried, ‘How sweet If endlessly we might embrace, And here for ever stay! how sweet If Heaven a little might relent, And leave our light in one light blent!’ But through that longing to dissolve In one, the parting summons sounded. Immutably the stars revolve, By changeless orbits each is bounded; Eternal union is a dream, And severance the world’s law supreme.

[@cybershadow58]

@@MilesBellas TY for that reference!

[@MilesBellas]

@@cybershadow58 Also this may have been an influence? ARETHUSA by Percy Bysshe Shelley Under the bowers Where the Ocean Powers Sit on their pearled thrones; Through the coral woods Of the weltering floods, Over heaps of unvalued stones; Through the dim beams Which amid the streams Weave a network of coloured light; And under the caves, Where the shadowy waves Are as green as the forest’s night:-­ Outspeeding the shark, And the sword-fish dark, Under the Ocean’s foam, And up through the rifts Of the mountain clifts They passed to their Dorian home.

[@EdgarAndEdgar]

thank you!! I think this is the most accurate transcription I've found online - I still think it's: *The parting summer sound is strong* though, I may be wrong but I've listened closely and it doesn't sound like *gone*

[@thewordofgord]

Thanks for the original lyrics!

[@ROSTAFA]

Lyrics. Only difference is 1st verse. Planets meeting face to face One to the other cried, how sweet! If endlessly we might embrace The perfect union deep in space Heaven might this once relent And give us leave to shine as one Our two lights here forever, one light blended And in that longing to be one The parting summons' sound is drawn I see you've got to travel on And on and on, around the sun Strangers passing in the street By chance two separate glances meet And I am you and what I see is me And do I take you by the hand And lead you through the land And help me understand the best I can And no one calls us to move on And no one forces down our eyes And no one speaks and no one tries No one flies around the sun Cloudless everyday you fall Upon my waking eyes Inviting and inciting me to rise And through the window in the wall Come streaming in on sunlight wings A million bright ambassadors of morning And no one sings me lullabies And no one makes me close my eyes So I throw the windows wide And call to you, across the sky

[@91541matthias]

Is there a story about the 1st verse, that it was no longer used?

[@ROSTAFA]

@@91541matthias ask Roger. Have no idea.

[@confusedsausagetm871]

The second section of the last verse seems to be the same as the second section of the second verse (And do I take you by the hand And lead you through the land And help me understand the best I can)

[@destbar]

@@91541matthias in fear they might be regarded as a "space rock" band, they decided to change the planet-themed lyrics to a underwater theme

[@madcap_9539]

It definitely was to get away from being known as "space rock". The Atom Heart album cover was a cow in an attempt to shed that image of just being space rock.

[@ummagumma7826]

This shows how collaborative they were. What other bands were more collaborative? Not the Beatles. Pink Floyd over and over would take new songs on the road months or even a year before they'd come out on record. Half of Dark Side was first played in January 1972. More than half of each Meddle, Dark Side, WYWH, and Animals all were played on the road well before being recorded.

[@wretchedhuman84]

love Pink Floyd sooo much, hard to believe this almost half a century old

[@johnfisher5465]

I stood in the park on it's 50 year anniversary....and it was raining!

[@Balrog-tf3bg]

Even if it’s not “the future” it still feels beyond our time

[@JJSattolo]

Best Pink Floyd song ever

[@duckface524]

best song ever

[@asloii_1749]

@@duckface524 Yes

[@MuscaTheGreat]

"Echoes" was first performed live on March 13, 1971, at the Concert for the People of Kampuchea, a charity concert held at the Rainbow Theatre in London, England.

[@dryadmusic]

Nope. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Echoes_(Pink_Floyd_song)#Live_performances

[@aquasloth6832]

WOW! Never heard this version before! And Roger on vocals, what a difference. There's so many great little things to pick up on in these early versions. Thanks for the upload!

[@huhuhu557]

aquasloth that isn't Roger singing, it's David and Richard wright

[@user2j3ycg4df]

@@huhuhu557 oh from the start it was only those two on vocals? Thanks for the info.

[@pomatix]

The first performance of Echoes was really at Norwich Lads Club on 22 April 1971.

[@pinkfloyd.appreciation]

That's correct 👍

[@merganser32]

@@pinkfloyd.appreciation I was there.

[@tangibleandroid285]

@@merganser32 says you.

[@geraldinejasnin7378]

do you know if a record of that performance exist??

[@wassupnomesayin]

@@geraldinejasnin7378 Pink Floyd themselves recorded it. Does it STILL exist ? Probably somewhere in their vaults.

[@paniranii]

First time listen to PF was TDSOM love the music it was my only music style made me to play guitar . since then 46 years pass and got 60 years old still have the same feeling about music. Echoes is one the most favorite song take me somewhere no explainable

[@ThePinkfloyd51]

Pre-Meddle early version? Yes. 1st performance? No.

[@HW944]

There was a performance of return of the sons of nothing on april 22th 1971 dont know of this was the first performance

[@aditshrestha5053]

Stfu and let people enjoy!

[@patriothammer1460]

@@aditshrestha5053 move along ignorant that To enjoy is best achieved with eyes closed

[@wassupnomesayin]

@@HW944 Yes, it was.

[@sujaulkhan9633]

FLOYD MAKES LIFE BEARABLE. GOD BLESS YOU FOR POSTING THIS! KILLED ME FOR SURE.

[@damon744]

Fascinating. This version is completely different from what Echoes evolved into, not only lyrics wise but guitar/synthesizer dynamics, and the choir-esque singing at the end. Also the heavy echoes on the voices.

[@Syfoll]

No synth, organs and leslie affected piano

[@williamriley9922]

I love my Pink Floyd Damn it!!!

[@999dgf]

@@Syfoll And Echorec, lots of Echorec! :)

[@Syfoll]

@@999dgf ah yes, the lovely echorec

[@willis-zane12]

Although this is an amazing early performance of Return of the Son of Nothing (as was the entire Crystal Palace show), the band’s first live performance of this song was nearly a month earlier on April 22, 1971 at Norwich Lads Club, Norwich, England.

[@mr.mirchenstein6549]

Great find! I think the version from Live At Pompeii is still my all time favorite Echoes tho! I Love hearing different performances!

[@tinydancergirl4598]

Definitely my favorite also - esp. the video to go along with it!!

[@johnny4eel]

This must be the short version. I remember this song seemed to last 2...no 3 yeah 3 full days & nights. Gawdam those were some fun times.

[@deltadesign5697]

What a brilliant find! Thank you bootlegger! ..& of course uploader!

[@kenny9048]

What a great listen. I never heard this before. Thank you so much for sharing!!!!

[@Chico50445]

I almost thought we had the footage too. But its still incredible that you found this.

[@MsSteveeverett]

I remember going to this brilliant day first time I had heard surround sound, I think the support band was mountain, god how old am I,!

[@stevemorgan5511]

Sure it wasn't blue cheer. Remember Its all too much being played about the time of the storm. Those days cannot be replicated even with all this new technology

[@allanbancroft4994]

5 off us crammed into a Mini Van and drove down from Rochdale, first time I seen Floyd and the faces live

[@PaulSutherland]

I was there!

[@allanclark3283]

Paul Sutherland . Awesome!

[@milkywayexplorer942]

lucky man

[@AndyMangele]

You are one lucky fella! ;)

[@cjpwallace]

I wasn't there!

[@patrykwalentowicz4691]

Tell something more about this show

[@rocioortiz5889]

Thank you so much for sharing it! It’s a jewel Shine on 💎

[@kevinhause1505]

This isn’t the 1st performance. This was a few weeks later. The 1st performance of Echoes (Return of the Sons) was on April 22, 1971.

[@fifidurand7421]

what a different version! thanks for the post!!!!

[@antonellaandreotti3052]

Avevo letto di questa prima versione ma non l'avevo mai sentita.BELLA

[@liomeltoulon]

I'm 47 years old, i really discover pink floyd at 35... ( before i was a Cure, DM, U2 génération...) this song and comfortably Numbers , Alone of a island... And Nothing other... Thank you !

[@paniranii]

you discover too late man, I am 52 years and listen to Pink Floyd since I was 14 years old :)

[@adamszyrmer4084]

@@paniranii It's never too late :-)

[@agfatheo690]

I have 5 or 6 diverend echoes I like them all

[@milkywayexplorer942]

same as I

[@Tyrannosaurine]

November 15, 1972. Boblingen show. My favorite. Though the 6/5/71 Berlin show is great, the BBC In Concert version, and the Montreux Casino shows are great too.

[@ocultoreal6815]

Echoes Close To The Edge Supper Ready Masterpieces Prog

[@asloii_1749]

The Raven That Refused To Sing

[@kevin34ct]

I love David Gilmour's guitar sound on these early recordings.

[@gbsailing9436]

WAYTA...?!?!?! You can barely hear it!

[@jasonsaylor6509]

Such an original 4-piece fantastic band. When it appeared to be a forgone conclusion they were done amid Barrett's ordeal Gilmour steps in and equals Waters as a vocalist, songwriter, and truly a virtuoso very underated when those are mentioned and ranked. Such melodic, beautiful, searing and moving solos throughout the entirety. Wright equally great musician and Waters too. I draw comparison, for fun, as Waters is the anti-establishment sneering angst of John Lennon-Gilmour is McCartney, Wright the soft spoken one like Harrison!

[@jasonsaylor6509]

I listened to Ummagumma in its entirety tonight followed by the Wall also

[@Y21U4]

Roger's delicate vocals are also harmonious.

[@felipealarcon201]

beautiful thank you very much. the best in the world.

[@heavymeddle28]

I was born that year. 2 month and 9 days later. I would like to believe so because planets met face to face...😵

[@giuseppepiccirillo8502]

Dave the best of Guitar!!.

[@gilblax8764]

The most iconic B on the music

[@milkywayexplorer942]

Nothing as good as the Meddle version. 3 LP's 3 CD's with different covers. Just for collection. Rick is just wondeful.

[@asloii_1749]

Ok but Pompeii

[@milkywayexplorer942]

@@asloii_1749 Yesterday, 22/06, evening in Paris France, Nick Mason Saucerful of secrets played Echoes... Just wonderful.

[@mrterry1756]

Sounds like a Beatles bootleg version of Echoes. But it's an amazing piece of work itself. I'm glad I discover the forerunner of my favorite song of all times. I still think it's better than most of the "greatest" songs of 00-19

[@CatheterBand]

Interesting how the opening verse is different from the recorded version. I will have to listen to this a few times to see what they had changed the words to.

[@Szwagier90]

A lot of their first played versions have different lyrics. Check Raving And Drooling or You've Got To Be Crazy.

[@matteoart4721]

It’s a very shame not afford of listening the very first performance of this one, on april 22th 1971. Actually Cristal Palace record is just the third representation ever, after the may 7th gig

[@gregrobertson7932]

Contrast this with more recent recordings. Here the audience is somewhat unresponsive; they really don't know what it is. Now thet go nuts with that first piano note and with the changes in the various parts of the song.

[@stevemorgan5511]

most people there were stoned, there was a lot going on with the lake and a thunderstorm, a distant memorable experience

[@stevemorgan5511]

The audience was mostly stoned as I was there

[@denxero]

I think the full echoes set has been played live many times before 71. And I'm not referring to parts of it under other titles.

[@robertocrauleszapata3115]

Agree. Some experimental at the time in live performance of the song

[@Rasputin443556]

Nope. The closest is the whale song-like bit in the middle was used in 1970 versions of "The Embryo," but otherwise the song is wholly new in 1971.

[@MilesBellas]

Two Planets - Muhammad Iqbal Two planets meeting face to face, One to the other cried 'How sweet If endlessly we might embrace, And here for ever stay! how sweet If Heaven a little might relent, And leave our light in one light blent! But through that longing to dissolve In one, the parting summons sounded. Immutably the stars revolve, By changeless orbits each is bounded; Eternal union is a dream, And severance the world's law supreme.

[@yehyakhorchid3420]

MilesBellas All wrong

[@denizcansevercevirileri]

What's that bro?!

[@MilesBellas]

@@yehyakhorchid3420 Allama Sir Muhammad Iqbal's poem is the inspirational poem behind the original lyrics.

[@MilesBellas]

@@denizcansevercevirileri Allama Sir Muhammad Iqbal's poem that inspired the lyrics.

[@denizcansevercevirileri]

Is it the early version of echoes lyrics?

[@MuscaTheGreat]

Echoes with echoes, yes!

[@234cheech]

iv got a few gigs with the son of nothing

[@robertguildford]

This sound like it was recorded outside. The pics on display would suggest that is the concert at Crystal Palace.

[@pip3124]

Well I never. So lucky to find this. I was there... On before the Floyd were Mountain. Their drummer kept throwing his sticks into the water for the fans to grab. Crystal Palace Bowl has a lake in front of the stage. And the Floyd roadies were going mad trying to stop people getting into the water. We saw why later, at the climax of the Floyd set a big octopus that was hidden under the water was inflated and it rose up out of the lake. Funny what you remember after so many years.

[@TheMaggylu]

INDEED... a GREAT Version! Thank YOU for this... but: "High Quality"?? Anyway: Really THX!

[@pinkrudy]

i didnt want to say great "sound quality" just that i found the highest quality source.

[@dre4011]

Crystal Palace Bowl,London ..................5-15-1971..............

[@ThinWhiteAxe]

According to www.pink-floyd.org/faq/faq5.html the first verse is: 'Planets singing face to face Bound to the air of life, how sweet! If purposely we might embrace The perfect union deep in space Ever might this once relent And give us leave to shine as one Our two lights {singing better}

[@philiphadworth2796]

The first verse is based on the poem "Two Planets" by Muhammed Iqbal (much as Roger had appropriated "Set The Controls" from a book of Tang dynasty poetry). Sadly that FAQ transcription is pretty poor. Reading the original poem and listening to multiple early live versions (especially from Berlin on 5 June 1971) will point one in the right direction of the correct lyrics.

[@philiphadworth2796]

For what it's worth: Planets meeting face to face One to the other cry “how sweet If endlessly we might embrace A perfect union deep in space If heaven might this once relent And give us leave to shine as one Our two lights here forever one light blended” And in that longing to be one The parting summons sound is drawn “I see you’ve got to travel on And on and on around the sun”

[@mercurialmagictrees]

Philip Hadworth awesome verse

[@dixondiaz8958]

That was the last time a Muslim wrote anything that wasn't violent.

[@gastonsalvatierra5252]

De primer nivel... por accidente dos miradas separa se encuentran... 🎶🎵🎼

[@bighupp3081]

thank you

[@Mar-tea-Spectral]

echoes with fireworks :p love this one

[@keithboakes3529]

I was there age 16 ;-)

[@oraesempre183nembo]

Great ! 👍😉

[@gbsailing9436]

Shame the mix was so poor that we can't hear David's roaring guitar! Damn it!

[@feliperocha2105]

IT'S ROGER SINGING ECHOES! I never knew he sang it at some point. The lead vocal is him, most likely with Rick on backing vocals

[@ILGAROD]

Felipe Rocha I think it is Dave.

[@feliperocha2105]

Comrade Kalashnikov Don't you notice the weak voice or the kind of lisp Roger has?

[@GTHelkaan]

Felipe Rocha It doesn't sound like Roger's voice at all. Had Roger tried to imitate David's sweet voice, he wouldn't get something that mellow :D. If only the footage could surface, we'd see who is singing for sure! But I bet on David.

[@mochasdog]

GTHelkaan Was there and don't remember a dam thing..

[@ZrxGR3Gx]

Felipe Rocha Isn't it just Dave and Rick at the same time like on the album?

[@Dreadtower]

High quality!

[@richardshumway5972]

I'm not going to say I like this version just because I love Pink Floyd!Definitely not high quality brother.

[@pinkrudy]

at least its listenable

[@jtlampsu2]

It's from 1971, what do you expect? Be grateful for peoples work, instead of slagging them off!

[@Iris-bz8jh]

Are you for real, be happy that this is even on KZbin let alone such a great version. Damn.

[@robertocrauleszapata3115]

One of the best performances of Echoes....

[@rodneybrown7482]

PF was just other-worldly.

[@johnfisher5465]

I have been collecting photos of this gig for years but have not seen these ones! Where did you get them?

[@pinkrudy]

i just did a google search. it says getty images website

[@onurerkan5521]

Dinlediğim en iyi versiyon bu olabilir...

[@miguelmeseguer9581]

Eran mui buenos y siguen siéndolo el tiempo no a pasado para eyos

[@Poniko_Strawberry]

Beautiful(hermoso)

[@pierluigiorsatti4816]

The first live performance was made in the 22 april 1972 in norwich, than it was called "the return of the son of nothing" and it had a different lyrics.

[@returnofthesonofnothing5358]

* 22nd April 1971 (at the Norwich Lads Club)

[@egyptianminor]

Is this from the now notorious 'Garden Party' at Crystal Palace?

[@pinkrudy]

+EgyptianMinor yes this was garden party... it was on a saturday...15,000 people showed up there. the biggest of its kind there. it rained most of the time. floyd opened with atom heart mother...the skies cleared up and opened. the audience huddled under miles of polythene. revellers swam in muddy ponds. the band played on... the music was enhanced by the quadrophonic sound system. the visual aids were effective too. orange smoke bombs misting up the pond, rockets and a giant octopus inflated in the water.

[@RickMaczka]

pinkrudy my brother r recorded this, you hear him talking to my dad at beginning of recording it was recorded on a Philips portable tape recorder, I recorded tape capies for school friends and somehow it's now all over the place. Good to hear it again as lost the tape after moving county. Had the whole concert on tape crept for bit where tape got chewed up. My Dad accompanied me and brothers to several floyd gigs so eventually he'd seen them more time than any one of us by time he was 50.

[@pinkrudy]

thank you for commenting and thank your family for perserving this wonderful piece of history. if you want to go one step further. go to www.yeeshkul.com and look for user neonknight. he can transfer your master tape professionally and preserve it forever. god bless you man!

[@neonknight1451]

Rick maczka - I specialise in restoring old Pink Floyd audience recordings and wondered whether you could get hold of any 1st generation versions of your chewed up master? I also wondered whether your family taped any other Floyd concerts? Would be great to hear from you. I'm in Kent.

[@egyptianminor]

Thanks for the info. It must have been a magnificent event. Peace.

[@billd2635]

Where do y'all keep the Oxygen around here?

[@sheilathomas6293]

I was there.

[@Therealderry433]

Sure you were, not.

[@PaulSutherland]

Me too!

[@PaulSutherland]

@@Therealderry433 Why are you so cynical?

[@Therealderry433]

@@PaulSutherland no time for ppls bullshit

[@phillippershing6315]

@@Therealderry433 you can't accuse people of lying if you don't have any evidence.

[@sharonrichards1627]

Time sucks. Wish it had stopped in the 70's.

[@МихаилЛизин-ф4д]

Intresting With the pink floyd ,can to have conection?

[@Leo_ofRedKeep]

This sounds clearer than the Sigma 93 CD but is 5.6% too fast. A speed correction of 0.947 brings it to pitch.

[@pinkrudy]

yea the person i got it from said it was speed corrected but after i uploaded i noticed it was wrong.

[@gradyfilms2458]

Andrew Lloyd Weber ripped off that base line

[@michaelsuder3956]

You’re right but it’s the guitar not bass

[@astraltraveller892]

@@michaelsuder3956 its both lol

[@michaelsuder3956]

@@astraltraveller892 technically it’s not. I know it’s just a pentatonic scale but they are the same notes and Phantom came out after Echoes

[@astraltraveller892]

@@michaelsuder3956 I mean its both guitar and bass. And its not the pentatonic scale, its the chromatic scale

[@michaelsuder3956]

@@astraltraveller892 yea that’s what I meant. I get them confused. And what do you mean both bass and guitar? Does Roger play that bass line as well?

[@ThallesPetrus]

o paí vei...

[@astraltraveller892]

This is Dave singing, right?

[@pinkrudy]

yea i think the speed is not 100 percent correct. i didnt correct it myself. it was done by somebody else but i didnt double check it before i uploaded it. its rick and dave together

[@denzan27]

If you refer to the name echoes is one date if you refer to that dong with name sons of nothing and then return of the sun of nothing is a difetent date ....just for the rec.echoes is made from 24 difetent reels put all toghether in one song

[@lordmonkey3285]

Is this the Norwich gig? At the lads club?

[@pinkrudy]

crystal palace UK this is the earliest recording of echoes but its not the real 1st time they tried it.

[@wassupnomesayin]

@@pinkrudy Pink Floyd themselves recorded the fist performance so they could work out the kinks for future shows and also the final studio recording of the song. Somewhere in the vaults.

[@aarongonzales1350]

Where can I find a physical copy of this performance

[@pinkrudy]

here is a vinyl version www.discogs.com/release/9145485-Pink-Floyd-Garden-Party-At-The-Crystal-Palace-Bowl-Sat-15-May-71 and here is a CD www.discogs.com/release/7949941-Pink-Floyd-Crystal-Palace-1971 ebay or any other place that sells bootlegs or music.

[@aarongonzales1350]

@@pinkrudy you are a fucking stud sir

[@Hazzard972]

Live in Rome 20 june 1971 (Palaeur )

[@tangibleandroid285]

High Quality?!

[@pinkrudy]

you should listen to how bad others versions of this show sound.

[@tangibleandroid285]

@@pinkrudy respect. Because I will take your word for it cuz that would be very believable

[@Vitoputraa]

Mantabbb

[@kenquinn7755]

High Quality?

[@pinkrudy]

other bootlegs of this concert is even worse.

[@giannidebenedictis8700]

Non riesco a trovare aggettivi. Capolavoro mi sembra riduttivo

[@camidoastra]

OMG

[@MatthewReiser123]

orange smoke bomb/rocket thrown at 5:21?

[@pinkrudy]

+Matthew Reiser hey!...yea i hear it. hehe

[@RonnieIsGrumpy]

+Matthew Reiser I might be wrong, but that could be one of Roger's screeches à la "Careful with That Axe, Eugene". Sounds like it.

[@hairyarmpitful]

... also 5:21 is the beginning of one of the best lead guitar chords all strung together E V E R!!!... agree!

[@Therealderry433]

That was Roger's whistle thing

[@BennettAustin7]

7:18

[@allenwagley6956]

anyone has the lyrics of this version?

[@acekiss28]

+WAG www.kaos-sound.co.uk/KSR/Lyrics/Return_of_the_Son_of_Nothing-A0.html

[@Rasputin443556]

From the song and the Iqbal poem illuminating us: Two planets meeting face to face, Bound to the air of light, how sweet! Endlessly we might embrace, A perfect union deep in space. Heaven might this once relent, And give us leave to shine as one, Our two lights here forever One light blended And in that longing to be one, The parting summons sound is drawn (?), I see you've got to travel on, And on and on, around the sun.

[@MisterEkoLogija]

def NOT high quality, the only reason I have to thumbs down... don't clickbait Pinkrudy, just type - low quality and that's it, we'll accept it as it is. no need for lying and false advertising

[@pinkrudy]

i think there is a difference between high quality and sound quality. thats why i didnt write sound quality.

[@2711pedro]

Can anybody tell me where was this, please?

[@pinkrudy]

crystal palace park london england

[@2711pedro]

@@pinkrudy Thank you, I was there, It's just that a friend I was with tells me this was Alexander Palace.

[@pinkrudy]

@@2711pedro every pink floyd book i have says crystal palace. it says they did play the alexandra palace but it was in 67 with syd barrett.

[@2711pedro]

@@pinkrudy Yeah, I was telling my friend he was wrong about that. I don't blame him though, it's been a long time!

[@FuzzyDancingBear]

nah ive never heard offit

[@matypinkfloyd]

Es otra Letra

[@denzan27]

Did u now that band inflated octopus in the lake kill all the fish ...

[@lucasmichaels8558]

The Band's volume killed the fish. Not the the inflatable prop.

[@MichaelHansenFUN]

look it up the pictures are amazing

[@davidslowhand5172]

It was the volume....the octopus scared the shit out of the audience.

[@Jakodrums]

chicken skin. wow.

[@denizcansevercevirileri]

Why the lyrics are different?

[@davidslowhand5172]

Return Of The Sons Of Nothing, early incarnation of Echoes

[@charliebadger]

Utterly pathetic applause at the end. I'm surprised Roger didn't come to the mic and say "Well FxxK .You lot". :)

[@wassupnomesayin]

You have to understand the context this performance. The applause comes out of audience respect for the band and their music. Roger, especially, didn't like screaming fans. He wanted the music to be heard and revered. Years later, his dissatisfaction with their ever - growing audiences reached a head in Montreal, July 1977 when he actually spit in a fan's face who was being unruly. This incident directly led to the writing of his classic " The Wall "

[@Tarsus-y4d]

The audience were loud and intrusive bad recording but still significant

[@paulgalligan1916]

High quality?