Pink Floyd - Echoes (Rare Alternative Version, Similar to Pompeii)

[@matiseugene6269]

Best song ever by the way

[@VictorinoxNL2]

No doubt

[@cybershadow58]

Always one of my favorites! In a classical structure of 4 movements-- The Intro, Funky Beat, 'Lost in Space" and Reentry/Musical Dialogue/ & Outro. This has a PF signature sound structure reminiscent of "Interstellar Overdrive, Set the Controls for the Heart of the Sun and some others.... This is such a sweet piece of music, and I am eternally Grateful for it!

[@muhammadfirman4464]

precisely, well, i loved all Pink Floyd compositions, pre and post Dark Sides, but IMO their pre Dark Side adventurous era was probably their best

[@tophr2710]

Yeah this was originally space themed as well! Then changed to nautical.

[@AMRAND0.V2]

This piece of music is focualy written to change the idea that PF is all space music and nothing else, so Roger Waters switched things so it would express the deep ocean which is the contrary of "space" that you still fell for

[@tophr2710]

@@AMRAND0.V2 as you (and I) made clear, it was changed in the middle to end of it. So it's not really a "fell for". Also I'd argue that the ocean isn't so contrary of space. Maybe literally, but metaphorically speaking they're very similar spaces.

[@reigneduardo6732]

sorry to be off topic but does someone know of a tool to get back into an instagram account..? I was stupid forgot the password. I would love any tricks you can give me

[@ieltsfocus]

This is from the John Peel sessions at the BBC in 1971, i have it on my mac mp3 format

[@barrettmalaspina2055]

The most amazing thing about this song is that it takes you through billions of years of evolution in the span of 25 minutes

[@josequispe180]

Cada vez que escucho este tema en vivo es como si lo escuchara por primera vez siempre, tiene tantos estilos y varientes , creo que eso lo hace tan especial para mi

[@kunzumla94]

Thank you. I really enjoyed this performance. Echoes seems to be on loop in my dwelling recently. God bless Richard and Syd

[@JosEPh-zy3yr]

Both are already in their finally "resting place" and cannot be "blessed" or "cursed". We Hope that Both found Jesus before they moved out of this physical plane of existence.

[@heavymeddle28]

It drills in every fucking synapse in the brain and the excessive energy laces the skin with acid and makes the hair stand straight up. Bombastic

[@S3BASTIAN05]

This is very different. The vocals sound nothing like the Pompeii or studio version it’s wetter. This is a gem

[@maxlethe3973]

Awesome, I love hearing them reaching and experimenting. The dynamics are good and Nick is in top form. This is prog psychedelic jam banding at its very best

[@vandmusic]

Esta versión es la misma que la de 1971 en bbc, pero las voces no tienen tanto reverd, magnifica!!

[@charlesdecarvalho2547]

Vintage Song never dies!!!

[@shroomshady27]

Right around the seven minute mark is probably my favorite piece of music ever made. It's even better in the Pompeii version. A big part of what makes the Pompeii version so great is the slightly different baseline Roger's playing. He's playing nearly the same baseline as the Pompeii version in this one. It just adds a little more funk to it and so fucking awesome. -

[@mikeMikeydowns]

Thank you for this awesome upload!

[@liamfreitas]

2:21 i love when they let just the drum and after everybody come back after the drum fill

[@jimiguitar100]

If I ever form a band, it will be called Skip add

[@banehog]

Skip ad would be better though

[@pandora_box01]

chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/adblock-plus-free-ad-bloc/cfhdojbkjhnklbpkdaibdccddilifddb?hl=it just one of many extension that will help you to get rid of all ads on youtube

[@matiasdezotti3212]

Ju

[@jimikguitar]

@@banehog right, I Will change it :) tnx

[@jimikguitar]

@@pandora_box01 thank you !

[@huhuhu557]

This is live from bbc back in 1971

[@areposs]

aka Paris Cinema Sessions

[@non-haereticicoalition8392]

you know how you can tell? They mess up the lyrics on the second verse.

[@shroomshady27]

Thank you, I was trying to figure out which version this was. Well done. -

[@odilm]

Mon dieu que c est beau 🙏 Superbe version 💚

[@victordu1733]

BBC - 1971

[@leandronolascoferreira4542]

A lot is said about this or Pompeii's version (by the way, I like edited version more than director's cut). Guitar, vocal, Rick's keyborads, Nick's smooth drums ... But, here's a comment that I had like to place before (in this version or Pompeii one), organ and bass entries causes chills in this epic song. Do you agree? Floydian cheers, from Brazil...

[@brothermaleuspraetor9505]

16 dead romans down voted this due to having no rest that day.

[@unstrung65]

My favorite song by Pink Floyd , also like Echoes Pt 1 at Pompeii --------this sounds quite similar , but raw . I'm sure the released Pompeii version was sweetened in the studio ( which is fine ) - their harmonies sound about what it would sound like live and outdoors - whereas on the filmed version they sound perfect !

[@hatemfarouk4455]

Gilmour is rather a magician than a musician

[@Anything4adollar]

@Hugh Jones how about...the 5 of them created something magical over about a 12 yr period...yes, Syd included..

[@juliegunn7944]

No, Richard Wright was the magician... :)

[@theknightsofawesomeness2701]

@@juliegunn7944 they were all magicians

[@GeorgeAlexander3370]

Blessed ...

[@fabiotrizzino7384]

Echoes è per la musica moderna ciò che la V di Beethoven è per la classica. Memorabile ed immortale!!!!

[@kinyamadege__6235]

Floydian Therapy

[@tapiantampubolon]

i think thats Echoes at BBC 30 sept 1971. you can listen on the pink floyd official channel but with bad sound quality .Sorry bad english :)

[@peternilsson7032]

Ja Pink floyd för mej till en värd att förstå världen som vi lever i skulle vara bättre med lite budskap som kommer från pink Floyd🤔🙄🙂

[@faustdownunder]

Correct.

[@234cheech]

yea

[@midnightinaperfectworld]

I like this. As awesome as Echoes is (awesome, as in, awe-inspiring), it sometimes feels sonically and tonally at odds with the rest of Meddle, whereas this has a similar mellow vibe as the rest of the album. It's more psychedelic than prog, feeling more in line with the late 60's-early 70's end of Floyd's career. Still prefer the original, but I'll definitely come back to this one now and again.

[@emanuelapiccolo5773]

Echos brano magico di Roger e di ghilmor scritto e suonato sotto effetto di lsd Trip che negli anni 70 e 71 si chiamava Pink Floyd e che tantissimi non lo sanno.anche io per 1na volta l'ho usato x entrare nelle loro dimensioni ed è stato stupefacente quello che ho vissuto.viaggiava con loro nelle vibrazioni che questo brano magico mi ha fatto vivere.durante l'effetto non esisteva più il tempo si camminava senza una meta x circa 8 ore in giro x Rotterdam.esperienza al di fuori della realtà terrena.viaggiavano nello spazio con la mente che si staccabmva dal corpo a volte ritornava nel corpo e a volte andava x i fatti suoi.esperienza unica.ecco perché i Pink sono parte di me ed io di loro.avevo 22 anni e vivevo a Rotterdam con altri amici anche loro amanti del gruppo.ora che ho 74 anni li ascolto tutti i giorni per rilassarmi.Dainese aldo.super amante dei Pink x tutta la vita.così come amo il grandissimo endyx.

[@JB-rn4hw]

Amazing

[@gabrielsacks5267]

Isso é uma versão da gravação da BBC em 1971. E a semelhança entra essa versão e a do Pompeii se da pelo fato serem somente 4 dias que separam uma da outra.

[@thewoodentops.]

squeaky bit is nasteee! loudest thing in the track, angry squeaks action! The organ plays a completely naff scale in the middle of that section which is really funny, like it shouldn't be there. 'checking it works' kind of thing.an oops! moment perhaps. Sometimes people say 'better than the album' in a way personally i think this is. The album is immaculately produced, has a couple of great parts not on this version but somehow this clinches it for me. Exlnt rub of the Floyd ty 4 posting.

[@leticiahellen5153]

Mds q perfeição ❤❤❤

[@leandronolascoferreira4542]

Muito se fala desta ou da versão de Pompéia, cujo vídeo gosto mais do editado do que da versão do diretor. A guitarra, o vocal, o teclado do Rick, a suavidade da bateria do Nick... tudo está perfeito nesta suíte... Mas um comentário que eu já quis fazer à respeito: tanto nesta versão como a de Pompéia, as entradas do órgão e do baixo causam arrepios neste épico. Concordam? Saudações Floydianas aqui do Brasil...

[@franciscoaragao5398]

Leandro Nolasco Ferreira . Perfeito comentário, Leandro. Perfeito

[@imcampos4952]

Conforme dito pelo usuário Tapiam Tampubolon, esta gravação faz parte de um disco pirata chamado "Meddled" que traz um concerto ao vivo que o Pink Floyd fez na BBC de Londres em 30/09/1971. Não sei se saiu em algum disco oficial da banda. As said by user Tapiam Tampubolon, this recording is part of a unofficial CD called "Meddled" which is a live concert by Pink Floyd at the BBC London aired on 09/30/1971. I have no notice if there is an official recording with this show.

[@DaEleven]

imcampos Valeu colega! Estava a procura da origem dessa versão há anos! Deus te abençoe, haha!

[@JOAOCFONSECA]

Esse som? kzbin.info/www/bejne/iorWh4Guat16ptE

[@sergiocarbullanca6741]

Muy bien estimados todo tiene su tiempo y me disculpo por si he llegado tarde. La Versión de esta obra corresponde a la grabación de Pink Floyd (The Early Years) 1971 Reverber_ation (2017) 05 - Echoes (Live BBC Radio Session, 30 September 1971) esto es definitivo. Sin embargo rebizando mi colección de archivos de Pink Floy luego de vacilarme las diferentes versiones de Echoes encontré que esta versión en crudo, en bruto, tosca debiera corresponder (debiera) a la presentación de Pink Floyd Londonfields 1990, al menos es tremendamente parecida o quizás a esa altura Pink Floyd me tenía elevado a la 3 dimención. Pero definitivo que lo encuentran en (The Early Years) 1971 Reverber_ation (2017) 05 - Echoes (Live BBC Radio Session, 30 September 1971. Gracias Da Eleven, fue interesante esta busqueda, encontré unas versiones que pocriamos llamarle versiones de Pink Floyd bastante callejeras, pero muy experimentales o quizas el termino sería "Evolutiva". La versión de la BBC es mucho másc es tremendamente bien trabajada. Agradeceré a quien pueda entregar mas datos incluso aclaraciones de lo que he entregado,. nuevamente PF me ha dejado en otro nivel espiritual .

[@realreepeshtandukar6470]

Wow.. 😍😍.. I would rather listen to pink floyd alternatives..

[@thehighwaystar1339]

Putting ads in the middle of the song, the hell's wrong with you

[@thehighwaystar1339]

I can't get adblock on a phone if I want to listen to it on my TV

[@stefbughead2868]

@@thehighwaystar1339 Brave mobile browser

[@Anything4adollar]

@@thehighwaystar1339 you do know there are alternatives (just like PF songs) to ad blockers for the phone too...

[@thehighwaystar1339]

@@Anything4adollar too much effort and doesn't make the uploader any less guilty

[@DaEleven]

Have you ever upload a video whose content were under copyright laws before? These ads are automatically activated by the owner of the content (Roger Waters/Harvest Records), it's an agreement that makes me able to use this song in a music video, so this video won't be removed from our channel. I couldn't remove the ads even if i wanted to, and if i could do it, this video would simply get removed from KZbin. All you need to know is, we don't receive a dollar for uploading this video, everything earned from the ads goes to the original owner of the rights. Skipping ads are the only ''price'' you pay for being able to watch this video for absolutely free.

[@djlindao1236]

Acredito que essa versão foi gravada, no mesmo periodo que a "Live at Pompeii", por conta do vocal, e pelo jeito em que a musica toma forma em si. Possivelmente foi algum take estudio de echoes (no periodo da live), ou um dos primeiros takes da versão de estudio que foi pro album.

[@bahmaneloy9385]

2022 ?

[@WhySoitanly]

This just in: NASA is sending Echoes to the moon on the 2024 Artemis expedition, to help the man & woman team acclimate to the harsh environment at the lunar south pole. Echoes will be on a subliminal continuous loop, an amalgam of all Pink Floyd renditions of the epic piece. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Artemis_program

[@philipperosbourg5113]

very well

[@janetkidd5545]

my rabbit just nearly shat himself when it got to the screechy bit! LOL!

[@lucasduarte1368]

Se eu não me engano, essa versão foi tocada na rádio BBC

[@1971Sdiaz]

This version comes from the BBC Sessions. More raw, and even I can called Rock.

[@winny212]

I don't know of any bands, that have several different sounds to 1 song, on many different songs, that all sound amazing

[@uaislan]

Eu tenho um CD com essa versão, também acho a melhor. É um cd ao vivo alternativo,ele é bem raro de achar,se chama Pink Floyd dream s factory

[@rez_vector5622]

I believe this is a cleaner version of the live at the bbc

[@georgelangley8444]

4:35 David and Rick sing the wrong line. Well one of them does.

[@MelchizedekKohen]

pink floyd is like the doors they have a sound like no other

[@francoboggi9542]

Grazie

[@alexandremagnoguedesalcofo8454]

LINDO

[@BloodyxProtest]

I like the keyboard on this one

[@Deadshot1997]

listen to the Gdansk version if you like the keyboard. Roger and Rich echo each other in the outra and it's the most beautiful thing.

[@cultofbunny]

@@Deadshot1997 great advice, just heard that version today! Rick's last performance of this song. Sad. RIP Rick Wright.✌❤

[@TheNuzzman]

Another early title for Echoes is "looking through the knothole in granny's wooden leg"

[@wassupnomesayin]

That wasn't an early title. That was what Roger Waters occasionally announced it as during live performances after the song had been officially released as " Echoes. " At least back then he had a sense of humor.

[@oguerfernandez2172]

Esa versión se grabó en la BBC 1970.

[@adamm3580]

CUDO

[@keepft21]

bom demais

[@asloii_1749]

the clipping... ouch

[@Lizard-of-Oz]

Pompeii version for me. Pompeii version it's a very close ending line horse race with Meddle version. Very unique each one. Although what David Gilmour does in here it's remarkable

[@tomjefferson2024]

VERY Good!

[@francosarvi3105]

Hola, te borraron el video la playlist de rock progresivo. Yo la escuchaba mucho y no recuerdo los temas. Podrías volverlo a subir o pasarme la lista? gracias

[@DaEleven]

Franco Sarvi no recuerdo el orden de la lista, y es posible que me olvide de alguna canción, pero le voy a decir todas las que recuerdo (sorry for my spanish, still learning). - Yes - Starship Trooper Gentle Giant - Proclamation Rush - Xanadu Pink Floyd - Cirrus Minor Jethro Tull - My God Eloy - Through a Somber Galaxy King Crimson - Starless Supertramp - Crime of the Century Genesis - Supper's Ready

[@francosarvi3105]

da eleven Thank you very much, this is more than enough! Greetings from Argentina, thanks for sharing this material. (of pink floyd was the alternative version of dogs)

[@charlesdecarvalho2547]

Vintage Song never does !!!!

[@garypierce7380]

It sounds like a practice version.

[@georgytananaev1693]

And it's really great. Pure live performance. Enjoy it

[@milkywayexplorer942]

I don't have enough blue thumbs.

[@leasantosmota9479]

ECHOES É LINDA! MAS GUITARRA DO GUILMOUR NA VERSÃO POMPEII E A MELHOR!!

[@СевоАвагян-я1и]

Это боевой музыка одуши молодец

[@JuneEmpireOfficial]

Долой Штолле!

[@234cheech]

sounds like the bbc sessions

[@non-haereticicoalition8392]

Dude the crackling is gonna drive me insane

[@cityslacker6221]

what crackling? do you mean the seagull calls?

[@arfansthename]

This is very obviously live.

[@joannabell9294]

Thank you. Its time to go to bed my children

[@peelsmyth.7909]

i think its a test take of pompeii? plus there's no audience which makes me think their related? very similar to pompeii in sound playing etc but with slight variations!! Plus you have to remember as well certain members of the floyd sound crew were starting to take heroin and heroin addicts become thieving shits for the most part anyway! so who knows they might of met dodgy blokes in a seedy London pub for some backhanders for getting the bootleggers some new material of the floyd! and the crew could easily of had access to a reel to reels or a a test pressing they had laying about to give to these bootleggers for cash to feed their hobbit or habbit lol!! i could be totally wrong though?

[@nickhirst999]

conkers

[@cultofbunny]

🤔😄

[@BrunoTicianelli]

4:35 Gilmore sang wrongly hahahah

[@sarabamjoei5652]

*Gilmour*

[@heavymeddle28]

@@sarabamjoei5652 nobody likes a knowitall

[@jestermindcrime1773]

so tell him

[@thehighwaystar1339]

@@heavymeddle28 nobody likes people that half-ass people's names either, shut up

[@milkywayexplorer942]

Good to listen to a very different version. Nothing common with Pompei.

[@Brooklyn3955]

Great upload and thank you. "Echoles" is eternal, but I'm not a fan of this version. It lacks edge and electricity. It's raw, but it comes off as fumbling, uncertain of itself and exhausted at times. Glad I did give it a listen though.

[@thehighwaystar1339]

Echoes*

[@Sandwich13455]

Nick Mason is not a great drummer, IMO

[@donleblanc2669]

@@Sandwich13455 what the hell is wrong with Nicks drumming ??? Sounds great too me !!!

[@Sandwich13455]

@@donleblanc2669 he said it himself.

[@FossilisedFishooks]

I think this is the BBC version. You need to listen to the album "Rhapsody In Pink" - I've had this for 30 years and I'm telling you now it's the best early live Floyd album. Fortunately it's on youtube kzbin.info/www/bejne/Z4POY4xmma56prs

[@webz3589]

Quit a good recording the drums do sound a bit lame thought

[@manoelparreirazanelli4365]

Muito boa mas não supera Pompéia

[@edmundosalazar809]

Es un engaño, sólo es una imagen congelada del vídeo Pompeya

[@miguel2740]

que pensaste idiota, que era un video?

[@LordYisusCraist]

hay una sola versión que no me gusta de este tema, la de waters solista. si tiene a gilmour y wright es seguro que va a ser épica.

[@wandafischetti1186]

SOMETHING SPECIAL FOREVER!!!