PINK FLOYD - SHINE ON YOU CRAZY DIAMOND (I-V) | Musical Perfection | FIRST TIME REACTION

#PinkFloyd #ShineOnYouCrazyDiamond #Reaction
Hello guys! We are brothers George & Patrick from Georgia reacting to various content.
Social Media - George:
📸 Instagram: / george_murva
👍Facebook: / giorgi.murvanidze.7
Social Media - Patrick:
📸 Instagram: / patiko_murvanidze
👍Facebook: / patiko.murvanidze
We are also on Patreon, help us grow and we will provide you with amazing content. Thank you!
🎵 Patreon Link: / broaction777
🅿️ PayPal Link: www.paypal.com/paypalme/broac...
🅿️ PayPal Email: [e-mail]
Reacting to:
Artist: Pink Floyd
Song: Shine On You Crazy Diamond
Album: Wish You Were Here
Released: 1975
Genre: Progressive rock, Blues rock, Psychedelic rock.
Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use. No copyright infringement intended. ALL RIGHTS BELONG TO THEIR RESPECTIVE OWNERS

[@broaction5343]

GUYS! If you enjoyed our reaction make sure to SUBSCRIBE, LIKE AND COMMENT!!! LINKS to other PINK FLOYD reactions: kzbin.info/www/bejne/op_ahaqrq9hjg5I - Money kzbin.info/www/bejne/qXXahKOXoduIppo - On The Turning Away kzbin.info/www/bejne/l6Dcqpt7bamdftU - The Great Gig In The Sky kzbin.info/www/bejne/d6jNm5yfisiffZY - Time kzbin.info/www/bejne/qF7UYYFpf7GZfas - Comfortably Numb (Studio Vesrion) kzbin.info/www/bejne/laSzcpeVeLx5o5o - Comfortably Numb (Pulse Live) kzbin.info/www/bejne/b5yXk4GAl7J0d5o - High Hopes (Studio Version) kzbin.info/www/bejne/b2iZeJ59ds6Kf9E - Wish You Were Here (Studio Vesion) kzbin.info/www/bejne/rYXQYWmVeMykb8U - Wish You Were Here (Pulse Live) kzbin.info/www/bejne/fGSyYqKVp9WEocU - Us And Them kzbin.info/www/bejne/iIDZZGiPbLeXfMU - Have A Cigar kzbin.info/www/bejne/oajZkqVogNSZrq8 - Shine On You Crazy Diamond (Part 2) kzbin.info/www/bejne/gXrdgGqBip1rqrM - Welcome To The Machine

[@Elizabeth-yp8re]

Wine glasses.They actually make wine glasses sing...

[@penelopehornswaggle102]

They didn't dedicate this album to Syd, they WROTE it about him and a tribute for him. Different than a dedication.❤❤❤

[@PhotonBread]

The guy on the left is listening to Pink Floyd. The guy on the right is experiencing Pink Floyd

[@jeffpickard8709]

"The universe is in this song" is one of the most accurate statements about pink floyd. Best band of all time imo

[@-Tidgy]

"opinion"? Fact not opinion.

[@matiaslucasroger]

@@-Tidgy Best comment.

[@SugarcatPlays]

The open 4 guitar notes to me feel this way

[@thenote2367]

@@SugarcatPlays same as Beethoven's 5th symphony that developes simply 4 notes from start to epic masterpiece !

[@TheGraphix71]

I can't add anything to that!

[@claudepage6214]

For 45 years, this song always gives me the same effects, goosebumps and chills.

[@keithjones6023]

You and me both, you'd have to be comfortably numb not to! 😏

[@Leon011]

Same

[@keithpasculli7465]

Me too; exactly the same effect

[@Duci66]

Dito for 45 y (54)

[@Keesecito]

Same thing here.

[@karenlong5616]

The only thing better than listening to this song is to listen to it again. And again. And again.

[@alexskywalker664]

Better listening on LP🤩

[@OriginalPuro]

That's straight up truth right there.

[@dyanyork5027]

And I do....daily 💖

[@iknowtheroutetoheaven4456]

And again

[@johnfloyd4166]

Addictive. X

[@ArniePorter]

A song for all of our friends who lost their spark and minds to drugs. They flew too high too fast and never came back down to earth.

[@Retrospective.]

I'm 50, and from the UK, i grew up wit this, and watching you discover it, brings a smile to my face, this is what us "oldies" listen to, and it touches you, it's timeless. great reaction.

[@williamschroeder1458]

The UK sent us a lot of great music in the sixties and early seventies. The Beatles, Rolling Stones, the Animals, Van Morrison, Pink Floyd. Wow! Great decades to have been young. I was in high school when the Beatles hit. It caused a near instantaneous change in our music

[@evancain4906]

@@williamschroeder1458 Don’t forget Led Zeppelin

[@deveshsingh1479]

na bro inn 19 and i listen to this its timeless my freind shared it with me and we listen togther

[@dirtycow]

Dark Side of the Moon is one hell of an album. The Wall is one hell of an album. But Wish You Were Here and Animals are something else and over time everyone starts to notice it.

[@Dustyholes]

Dogs is arguably their most underrated song ever and one of my personal favorites. Top 5 probably,

[@gururajchadaga]

@@Dustyholes Dogs is my most favourite Pink Floyd song. Ever.

[@SirHilaryManfat]

Agree with this so much. Wish you Were Here and Animals are their true masterpieces, hiding in the shadows of the more popular DSOTM and The Wall.

[@ameyavikrama1535]

I actually can never pick one between these four and The Division Bell. I love all these five so much!

[@GaudyGabriev]

It's funny, my favourite Floyd songs are Echoes, Comfortably Numb, and Shine On, from 3 different albums, none of them my favourite, which is Animals (although of course, it's right up there with Wish you Were Here, and Time and Dogs are right up there too). The Waters-Gilmour era of Pink Floyd, Meddle to The Wall, they were just the best band to ever walk the Earth. Plain and simple.

[@Jaydon05]

My younger brother died last summer because of Covid. He loved this song. He was a crazy diamond but he shone like the sun! Nice to see 2 brothers having a youtube channel! Stay safe!

[@lazyhazeldaisy9596]

Much love to you my friend stay strong your Brother is always with you.❤️

[@CelticArmory]

Sorry for your loss. May our Lord and Lady watch over your family and guide your brother to the next life.

[@roronoazoro-518]

I am so sorry for ur loss 😭 May ur brother rest in peace and i pray that you and ur family can overcome this loss and be strong in these hard times.

[@Jaydon05]

@@roronoazoro-518 Thank you! Words can be gold!

[@sishirmehta3854]

The guy on right is high as shit

[@trouty42]

08:34 That is the correct response to this particular piece of guitar work. Perfection.

[@pommie5093]

What a stunning comment and so accurate: "The entire universe is in this song"

[@flubblert]

"Remember when you were young, you shone like the sun Shine on you crazy diamond Now there's a look in your eyes, like black holes in the sky Shine on you crazy diamond" Syd Barrett left Pink Floyd, and mentally speaking, reality, around 1968. But in a sense he never really left the band. He would become the muse behind so much of Floyd's music and tone through their most successful era, along with Roger's own dark reflections. This masterpiece isn't just about Syd, it's about the darkness.... Universal and always just around the bend for all of us to steer ourselves away from the best we can. "And if your head explodes with dark forebodings too I'll see you on the dark side of the moon"

[@maxineneild7352]

Pink floyd pure therapy there will never be band like this again spine chilling

[@lynnecox6431]

Not in this life anyway .....

[@PbPomper]

@7:!6 "Bro, can't you see I'm drifting in a parallel universe somewhere?! Leave me alone!" I can relate XD

[@ziggymarlowe5654]

A tribute to Syd Barrett, Pinks original guitarist.

[@flubblert]

... and lyricist.

[@johnbagley99]

And singer

[@mahdi7557]

and band member

[@Theutus2]

and friend.

[@geraldherrmann787]

and founder

[@JohnSmith-oe4ci]

Floyd's music is a cosmic journey - an out-of-body experience

[@sarahvanucci597]

I’ve watched so many young people discover Pink Floyd, band of my youth. You two young men really get it at a deep level. I’m 65, and you and I could sit for hours and talk about my generations rock music and I could tell you so many stories of what I was doing in the 60s and 70s with Pink Floyd as my favorite band playing in the background, what their music meant to me as an 18 yr old coming of age back then. I love seeing you two because you truly appreciate the musicianship, so lacking in much of today’s music.

[@NafthaliHananja]

I’m 22 but I totally agree with you! I love Pink Floyd and it’s great to see I’m not the only one of my generation. I can only image how much more this music means to you than it means to me :)

[@sarahvanucci597]

Nafthali Tollenaar you are so right about that. The 60s and 70s were an intense time to be young with British music rocking us here in the US providing us with a soundtrack that helped us connect with ourselves and the world. Seeing Pink Floyd live performing Dark Side Of The Moon in 72-73 was a big influence on who I became as an adult. The power of music!

[@Inquiringmind0]

This music connects fans in a profound way across time and space.

[@snakelite61]

Roger's lyrics are amazing. I think everyone knows someone they have conflicted feelings about. Syd's deterioration while part of the band at times alienated him from the others. "He wore out his welcome with random precision." is a complex turn of phrase. He drove them crazy, angered them, and they loved him. This song is a tribute to Syd and embodies all of those conflicting feelings. We've all been there.

[@C1APF]

Una cosa es música , otra canciones, pero cuando el alma , el sentimiento, las emociones, los temores, miedos y la adrenalina confluyen en una composición solo puedes decir , esto, esto es Pink Floyd

[@crudburgerwithfries3614]

Tambien puede ser Triana :-)

[@marymargaretmoore9034]

Rick Wright played all the keyboards including synthesizers. David Gilmour’s guitar and vocals are heavenly.

[@grantdumas4076]

On this song and most songs on this album, Roger Waters sang lead vocals.

[@sammmartinn]

@@grantdumas4076 they harmonized for a decent amount

[@sammmartinn]

@@grantdumas4076 but David sings on wish you were here and welcome to the machine with Roy Harper singing on have a cigar

[@grantdumas4076]

@@sammmartinn I know. I am just trying to give Roger's singing some love.

[@saajingrey]

Watching people of your generation discover the timeless magic that is Pink Floyd is one of the best things the Internet has ever done for me. I just sit here with my beer and my pipe and watch your minds get blown the same way mine did decades ago, long before you were even a glint in your daddy's eyes. This is the greatest band that has ever existed, not only because of the art they have created themselves but also because of the countless people they've inspired and the undeniable way they have shaped music for thinking people. Welcome aboard, fellas. Edit: Not gonna go on a total rant about it, but you should look into Porcupine Tree if you haven't already. It's like Pink Floyd and TOOL had a baby.

[@thewinnertakesitall4384]

Could not agree more , its beautiful to see the youth of today engage with this masterpiece.

[@willasacco9898]

This song is the entire universe- Once again you guys totally nailed it. YOU GET PINK FLOYD

[@hopekondrk8945]

"Wish You Were Here" is one of their albums I always listen to start to finish. Seeing them live was even better. Forever Floyd!

[@BrooklynBear63]

"The whole universe is in this song..." AMEN!

[@cherylwoodward]

I liken their music to a spiritual experience. You just let it wash over you and fill you up. You sit back and give into the moments, sacrificing your time while it takes over mind and soul. Still makes me feel today, what I felt the first time.

[@billhiggins1882]

No need to

[@billhiggins1882]

Do anything else

[@nickdanger3837]

Both of you have superior music evaluation skills. Pink Floyd and John Lennon will be remembered like Mozart and Beethoven.

[@joaocardoso8453]

Please don't t forget ... McCartney! 🎵🎶🎼

[@elijahyoung11]

Pink Floyd, The Beatles, Led Zeppelin. Just the best.

[@Now-ai]

@@elijahyoung11 Supertramp too

[@w.geoffreyspaulding6588]

Next by Floyd: Either Echos or Sorrow......Echos is SUCH a trip....and Sorrow is so unbelievably gorgeous.

[@andreabindolini7452]

Sorrow is awesome. The best lyrics from David Gilmour (after the departure of Roger Waters)

[@PanarchyInTheUK]

Meddle truly is an amazing album. Echos has the power to take you somewhere ... outside of yourself. Or it it deep inside?

[@drtydawg73]

yeah ecoes with the pompey video. :-)

[@slayerrocks2]

When I drive to this, I rock. When I sit at home and listen, I tear up. Pink Floyd made music that can elicit both, dependent on the listener.

[@rafalkrawczyk940]

These emotions have accompanied me for 30 years. I still get chills when I listen to the first sounds.

[@davidking3118]

I’ve heard it so many times, and it might get better every single time

[@musiclover9361]

Spectacular guitar playing by David Gilmour. As Keith Richards would say, "He just bent that string three yards, man!"

[@VSMartins398]

S hine on Y ou crazy D iamond (Sorry i did it!)

[@feliperodriguezborquez]

Omg is this real?

[@lynnhoffman247]

@@feliperodriguezborquez 👍🏼

[@broaction5343]

Perfect!

[@lynnhoffman247]

You beat me to it, vinicius 🤗🤘🏼

[@alisonanthony1228]

Someone had to do it - why not you 😋

[@frozencanuck6764]

Pink Floyd were the masters of sonic soul travel. Truly one of a kind.

[@johnallen869]

Shine On, Time, Echoes live at Pompeii, Dogs, and Comfortably Numb Pulse live are my favorite PF songs. I've been listening to them since 1973, it's just as good today! The intro to Shine On is just as good as any of the great composers!

[@James_Loveless]

Wrong... Listen to the entire albums like originally intended. Pink Floyd is a cerebral musical journey, was never meant to be broken into individual songs. As you should know DSotM, WYWH an Animals albums are continuous where songs just flow into one another

[@zablorbonkloken1420]

@@James_Loveless lmao what? their songs and especially the ones this dude chose can be enjoyed without listening to the albums. you know why? bc its good music.

[@andreabindolini7452]

Echoes studio first. Always the studio versions first

[@joeduren4836]

i HIGHLY recommend listening to the Echoes live from the BBC. its so full sounding. not taking away from the live at pompeii!

[@MrUnderdog-vn3zf]

@@andreabindolini7452 I completely agree 👍

[@liefde1911]

Don’t talk......just drift away.......in perfection.....

[@comm2190]

This song is dedicated to Syd Barrett who's eyes became like 'black holes in the sky' after taking too much LSD. Although the lead creative force behind pink Floyd in the early days he was finally replaced by David Gilmour who used to fill in for him on stage when Syd could no longer hack it. After many years of Syd's absence he mysteriously showed up at the studio during the recording of this song. The only thing I can suggest is to try to watch the Pulse video and the visuals that go with it. This song is the opening track.

[@6sixblue]

Fue el primer álbum que compré a los 12 años. Me cambió la vida. Ya la música no fue solo ruido era otra cosa más importante. Luego conocí otros grupos como LED Zeppelin, Genesis ( con Peter Gabriel), Deep Purple, etc, pero nada se iguala a Pink Floyd.

[@kellydelay18]

Been given me chills since 76

[@jamesavalos9612]

Listen Shine on You Crazy Diamond Part 2 VI - IX.

[@TheGraphix71]

I heard the song in my youth on LSD and when I remember it I can still cry like a little child!

[@davidwalker5054]

This masterpiece is more classical music than rock its a perfect example of building up tension and keeping you on the edge of your seat in anticipation

[@lisamorrison2149]

How can anyone not have a great reaction to this Masterpiece?♦️🌟

[@jswimeaden2365]

They hadn't seen him in six years, but Syd turned up in the studio whilst they were recording this song. It was the last time they saw him ever again.

[@unknowntosociety01]

Universe works in some really weird ways

[@CelticArmory]

The really weird thing is when he was wandering around the studio, they didn't recognize him at first. Also, he got an equal cut of all profits Floyd ever made, even on all the albums long after he was no longer a part of the band.

[@charlestherrien9934]

This song keeps getting better with every listening...

[@caligkontra]

This may be their best song

[@Pjaypt]

I've been listening to this since 1975, and I intend to continue to do so!

[@CaptainNemo1701]

Enjoyed your reaction guys, George looks like he should lie down somewhere to recover...LOL!. You should put 'Dude, those transitions!' on a T shirt.

[@naturalrestingface4909]

Nick Mason's drumming is key to both DSOM and WYWH. He leaves so much space for the melody.

[@brianpugh6707]

Well said Natural Resting Place! Most drummers beat or bang on drums; Nick, Bonham, and a few others Ctually PLAY them like an instrument!

[@jamesclarke3113]

I had chills too, they're multiplying and I'm loosing control.

[@sarahzentexas]

I see what you did there. #Grease

[@kitsullivan1583]

@@sarahzentexas so did I Sarah, he can't spell 'losing.'

[@j.k.1963]

Patrick, you just brought me to tears. Thank you. And then there is yet another one...

[@helenwilliams7065]

So many of their songs are emotionally emotive masterpieces. After all these years they still blow me away.

[@mikefetterman6782]

I have played guitar for twenty five years. There have been moments in my practice where I can just glimpse the genious of DG for just a few seconds. It feels the same way. When playing with band mates and this happens and everyone looks at me, we are all shocked as I look at my fingers. I wish I had this everyday all the time like Gilmour. I have only touched that all might groove here and there and it is a drug, you literally take spiritual flight.

[@hangman2159]

must be an amazing feeling

[@0gkmedia0]

Great reaction to that masterpiece. Some backgrounds: Pink Floyd had no ideas what they should go for after Dark Side. They experimented with household objects what survived as intro to Shine On. And as they had no ideas the thought about absence of ideas and absence of the creative force of Barrett. And - and that a miracle by itself. When they did the final mix for Shino On suddenly Barrett appeared at Abbey Road. But noone recognized him. After he was finally recognized they had some wired moments with him. Still thinking the Pink Floyd story deserves a high budget film one day.

[@AD270479]

'There are a few other songs I'd put on the same level.' Yes me too... They are also by Pink Floyd but.

[@2869may]

Solo David Gilmour ~ "No way out of here" "Raise my rent" "No Way" are really good as well.

[@gbsailing9436]

Nice reaction guys...when you world turns to shit and you've had a crappy day, you come home, pour a scotch (or similar), or glass of red, drink that, pour another, drink that, then pour another one and go turn off all the lights. Put this record on. Go find a bean bag or deep leather couch, put your headphones on and sink down into it and sip away the final drink, and let the music sooth your soul !!!

[@gbsailing9436]

@Anthony F. Tuffiano buss???

[@ginaluvsrush6093]

The whole Animals album is another masterpiece..

[@GBeret83]

@rushgal4ever, fucking A!! Used to love to drop some microdot and get lost in the Animals album!

[@frankpuncekar5051]

Pink Floyd is timeless. This music sounds as good as it did when I first heard them in the early 1970’s.🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘

[@user-qj6fs7zr5c]

伟大的音乐，非常感性的反应

[@patrickvecchio8138]

Hey guys.First time I heard this song, 45 friggin yrs.ago....I almost cried.It was that intense and emotional for me.....and I wasnt stoned !

[@adinafarkas769]

Yesss! I’m one of those who have waited for that 😉🎧

[@bendelianibeka4628]

This music takes place in Top 5 for me , good job men

[@musiclover9361]

The inimitable Dick Parry delivering a Saxophone masterclass.

[@Theutus2]

Pink Floyd needs to be full album listens to get the real feel.

[@chemicalBR0]

I was 4 when this came out, my dad bought the Album and played this song to me to put me to sleep at night. it's better than any lullaby and still gives me chills to this day "remember when you were young" yes , yes I do

[@sportsfaninternational1614]

Actually, one of their BEST songs, musically speaking (my own personal opinion, of course) is On The Turning Away. Just cold chills down your spine from start to finish.

[@RuudJH]

For more than 20 years, or so, this album has been charted one of the highest in most major countries around the world, every single year. Not only in their own time, but also in 2 or 3 new generations. This will be classic in a century to come.

[@EXBG]

Indeed the BEST composition ever made in history of music. Thanks.

[@w.geoffreyspaulding6588]

Uh....no. BUT one of the very best in last 60 years.....perhaps the best.

[@PaulHoffman-mo6qu]

This is my go-to song when I am feeling in the mood to relax. It gets better with every listen...and I've been listening to it since it was released.

[@rickb.4168]

He’s right Pink Floyd is a drug. Literally. Acid, if I Remember correctly.

[@harrystottal]

Yes it was indeed.. I remember the times back in the late 70’s early 80’s well.. Head phones on music full blast.. A very personal concert..

[@garanceadrosehn9691]

So, a personal story: I graduated high school back in the mid-1970's. After high school many of us left for different colleges in different parts of the USA. Five or ten years after that (and probably after the release of "The Wall"), I went to a party which was a reunion of maybe 30 high school friends. Many of us hadn't seen each other in years, so we're all chatting away to find out what everyone else had been up to. There was a radio station playing in the background, and it started playing the full 9-piece suite for "Shine On You Crazy Diamond". Slowly but surely, *everyone* in that crowd stopped talking. Everyone just sat or stood where they were, listening to the song. The song ended, and after a few seconds I said something like, "That song is much better than we realized at the time". Several people added short comments, like "Indeed" or "Amazing" - and then the entire crowd when back to talking the way we had been before the song started.

[@hazchemel]

spot on. I'm same age as you, in Australia. We didn't realise that it wouldn't go on. Interesting that youngsters are shocked by their Musical Ability, so used to basically posturing, posing and fisting the camera, with a bit of something music like.

[@staciojeda4146]

I'll have what the brother on the right is having... he knows how to enjoy Pink Floyd.. don't talk, don't pause... just let the music take you on a journey you know not of....

[@pickledskater4039]

Welcome to greatness. Pink Floyd will be listen in the year 4000 and beyond

[@geraldherrmann787]

almost 9 minutes biggest balls-intro ever.

[@movietimeateds69]

The intro to the intro has an intro.

[@zohrabbasmajian2040]

And Pink Floyd doesn't needs the drugs, the drugs needs Pink Floyd

[@matteomichielin7817]

yes ! put on the greatest hits, close your eyes and let yourself sink inside.. there is not a single note to change, the sound is so pure and hipnotic... but one time you must see the video, and the video of another brick in the wall, are someting crazy... The crazy thing is that my mother as a girl saw the concert here in venice, that's why I thought of pink floyd as old stuff, then one day I heard them and my musical world changed

[@craigbonsor8328]

In the background at the beginning are wine glasses from the house hold objects album project

[@danknighton3286]

I thought that was a joke, but it’s a real thing! Pink Floyd is a journey, always learning something new 😄

[@Pulsar77]

They also played the intro on wine glasses on Gilmour's Gdansk concert. Spine chilling.

[@davepiper7823]

@@Pulsar77 I did see Gilmore on KZbin talking to that busker who was playing wine glasses and he invited him to play at the opening of his concert.Dave is such a humble and down to earth fella.He made that busker one happy chappy.Could you imagine playing with Floyd.😀😀😀.

[@Pulsar77]

@@davepiper7823 Yes, that was incredibly generous of him. That was the Venice concert. On the Gdansk concert, the band members did it themselves. Here's a video link: kzbin.info/www/bejne/qmSkoKZ3ocaCetk

[@fastat5065]

DOGS DOGS DOGS,your ready😍

[@jswimeaden2365]

Has to be done...

[@unoeinars746]

I think they are ready now. It is a must

[@DruncanUK]

Haha. Your reactions were priceless! 50 years on and I’m still experiencing those same emotions. Welecome the the journey that is Pink Floyd my friend, you are on a journey that will continue the rest of your life. 👍

[@eualemorales]

I was wating for this reaction guys! This is really perfect!

[@oxvaldus]

Rick Wright and Guilmour when they play ask and response really carry the Floyd.

[@teresagorden5984]

David Gilmour and Pink Floyd have discovered the exact region of the brain that reacts to their music, that floods over you. It does make one feel high or smile for a long time. David, Richard, Nick ..Brilliant!

[@garanceadrosehn9691]

When this album was released, a lot of people considered it a letdown from the amazing masterpiece of "Dark Side of the Moon". We all rushed to buy it, of course, but for many it just wasn't up to the same level as DSotM. What we all wanted, of course, was another album which would be the same as DSotM. I remember when "Animals" came out, and a lot of my friends felt that album was *significantly* better than WYWH. Not that anyone hated WYWH, but it seemed too slow and didn't have as much "bite" as DSotM or "Animals". But as the years went by, WYWH seemed better-and-better, and has a timeless feel to it. "Animals" seemed a bit too angry, and was a tied a little too much to the specific years that it was released (especially for the song "Pigs, Three Different Ones"). While DSotM still seems like the masterpiece we all felt that it was when it was released, for many people (including me) WYWH now seems like the better album. Fast-forward to the 1990's, and all four members of the band were saying it was best album they had created.

[@mwatson5702]

Not how I remember it but that’s music

[@garanceadrosehn9691]

@@mwatson5702 - Heh. Well, for "a lot of people in my college", at least. 🙂 I don't remember anyone saying they were disappointed with WYWH right when it was released. But when Animals was released, at *that* point I had many friends say they were excited by the edgier Animals because WYWH had been too laid-back and a letdown compared to DSotM.

[@wallacecallow2255]

My favorite is Meddle. They really turned the corner on that one.

[@koncaswatch8726]

Nice first reaction guys. Excellent selection at this point in your Pink Floyd journey.

[@samwright199]

pink floyd its combination of heart . mind and talent

[@nelo62pt]

It would be so good that 45/46 years ago I had the internet to try and see my reactions to hearing Pink Floyd for the first time ....

[@maryannprzybycien2013]

Pink Floyd is a spiritual experience.

[@hichambarrak2902]

Pink Floyd were an "experimental music group", in the sense that they experimented different sounds. They were different from all other rock groups of the time. They didn't have a belting voiced vocalist like the other groups (Led Zeppelin, the who, Black Sabbath, AC/DC, Deep Purple, CCR) and that's why they lasted for a much longer time than all the other groups. David Gimour changed the path of PF from what it was when Syd Barrett was part of the band. David made Pink Floyd focus on the music & sound more than on the lyrics. he made every instrument that is played shine in its own way: the drums (echoes), the organ/synthesizer (comfortably numb), the bass (Shine On You, Another brick in the wall), the saxophone (Wish you were here), the back-up vocals (Great gig in the sky, Time, wish you were here). All that makes Pink Floyd stand out like the best group of that era. One last remark: None of the mentioned group could have made it if the Beatles didn't split up in 1970.

[@garavonhoiwkenzoiber]

I used to listen to this when exploring the galaxy in Elite Dangerous. Jumping from star to star, nothing but me, the deep, and the music

[@porflepopnecker4376]

I remember buying this on 8-track one day after college and listening to it in my car on the way home.

[@rbruceBruce]

You didn't have to say a word the looks on your faces showed us how much in enjoyed it. Now what you need to do is the whole wish you were here album. It all goes together and brings it all together.

[@Tijuanabill]

They have discovered the answer to that age old question: Which is the best Pink Floyd song, Comfortably Numb, or Wish You Were Here? The answer of course is Shine On You Crazy Diamond.

[@chantho2525]

If I had 25 min to live, I would listen to this piece.

[@franckb8279]

Still gives shivers down my spine, 45 five years after!!! Timeless perfect music!! David is GOD, Rick is GOD, Nick is GOD and Roger is GOD!!! And Dick Parry (Saxo) is GOD too!!! Pink Floyd is the BEST thing that ever happen in rock music!! I SAID!

[@soultraveller5027]

Pink Floyd I know guys How Did they manage to create and produced such music the concept and originality is unreal I know no other group compares

[@masitaatisam3679]

You 2 are one of a kind, Truly think you both have one the most ( if not THE most ) respectfull and honest 1st reaction videos on the net.. For me personally , pink floyd was my only baken in my darkest of times... Even today , 25 years later on in life i must listen their music once in a while altough i have listened it a 1000 of times... I feel i owe them that , seriously. Take care “ dudes “ God bless you

[@rockon4853]

Pink Floyd has given us music beyond the stars ✨✨✨💖

[@09amitava]

Pink Floyd is an ocean kids! I started sailing into it at the age of 12 and now I'm 59 and still sailing and I don't wanna stop till death❤🎸💐👌

[@eugenestandingbear6516]

Background music of our lives . Beautiful !

[@ljude01]

I'm not am envious person. The one thing I envy is hearing Floyd for the first time, again.

[@Uller1967]

What a wonderful turn of phrase, 'Shine on you crazy diamond'. These guys are truly masters of their craft. Musically, lyrically, emotively.....Just LEGENDS!