Pink Floyd - The Great Gig In The Sky (PULSE Restored & Re-Edited) THE WOLF HUNTERZ Reactions

Want a custom reaction video?
www.THEWOLFHUN...
Song intro THE WOLF HUNTERZ - Lock Shields
• THE WOLF HUNTERZ - Loc...
Song intro THE WOLF HUNTERZ - Lock Shields ( LIVE )
• THE WOLF HUNTERZ - Loc...
merch store
teespring.com/...
spotify
open.spotify.c...
The Wolf HunterZ
albums and singles available on
www.thewolfhun...
AMAZON
www.amazon.com...
ITUNES
/ last-man-standing-ep
and more!
outro song
bang my head
KZbin
/ thewolfhunterz
Facebook
Faceboook: / thewolfhunterz
Instagram
/ thewolfhunterz
Website
Website: www.TheWolfHunterZ.com
*Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use"
for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use
is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or
personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use. No copyright infringement intended.
We are a reaction video show that comments on the positive aspects of artist and their video.
#thewolfhunterz
#znation #femalefronted #girlswhorock #clevelandmetal
#thewolfhunterzmusic #thewolfhunterzmusicvideos #reactionvideos #musicreactions #reactors
#thewolfhunterzreactions #SuziQ #CoupleReacts #suziandtravisreact
Thank you Videezy.com for the special affects videos!
THE WOLF HUNTERZ Reactions
THE WOLF HUNTERZ React To
Pink Floyd - The Great Gig In The Sky (PULSE Restored & Re-Edited)
• Pink Floyd - The Great...
Ask your smart speaker to play Pink Floyd
Pink Floyd’s P.U.L.S.E. - Restored & Re-Edited out now. Restore...
Delicate Sound of Thunder, restored, re-edited, remixed, out now PinkFloyd.lnk....
Filmed live on 20 October 1994 at Earls Court, London, UK. Restored & re-edited in 2019 from the original tape masters.
THE LATER YEARS
Included on ‘The Later Years’, a 18-disc box set (5xCDs, 6xBlu-Rays, 5xDVDs,2x7”) covering the material created by David Gilmour, Nick Mason and Richard Wright from 1987 onwards, with unreleased audio and audiovisual material, including the 1989 Venice and 1990 Knebworth concerts, as well as updated, restored and remixed audio and video, 2 x 7” singles, 60-page hardback Photo Book, 40-page hardback Credits Book, Lyrics Book, 3 x reproduction tour programmes, card envelope containing collectible memorabilia, plus Blu-rays and DVDs in individual wallets.
#PinkFloydFridays #PinkFloyd #Remastered #TheLaterYears #LaterYears #PULSE

[@jamesmorgan4121]

Never has so much been said without a word being spoken (or sung).

[@MrTech226]

Travis & Suzi Back in when Pink Floyd 1st recorded this classic song, they had only one female vocalist named Clare Torry. Clare asked them how she do the vocals. They told her improvised like being born to life to death without words. Here, I think backup vocalists take turns on Clare's way.

[@Boodieman72]

Yes and she got paid the standard studio rate of 50 pounds I think. Then after some "negotiations" she got cowritter credit, etc.

[@skiptindle5976]

I wound not call any of the three women here "backup" singers LOL!

[@kevinkennedy8451]

first singer Anger, Second singer denial, third singer acceptance of your death with no vocals just gut emotions..a masterpiece

[@davidmckenzie420]

It's always such fun to watch Pink Floyd in concert...That said, and if you liked this song, you must listen to the studio version for perhaps the greatest no-verbal vocal performance ever. Legendary.

[@trevorholden7423]

Never fails, I'm still mopping my eyes... just brilliant emotional talent.. extraordinary!

[@Dan-tk5zs]

3 stages of dying: anger, denial and acceptance. Perfection.

[@ShayCGoat]

30 years after the first time I heard them, this still gives me goosebumps. Not the original vocalists, but damn good! Another good one!!!!

[@Raven-fh2yy]

The song is basically about being told you are going to die.. going through the stages of anger, denial, etc all the way through to acceptance... no words... just emotions.

[@carlosruiz-ob7le]

Exacto y Como solo Pink Floyd podía hacerlo

[@AliasMark69]

I met David Gilmour back stage at a concert in California 1984. I asked him about the meaning - reason for “Great Gig In The Sky”…. David’s answer was something like…. .I was asked if Pink Floyd would ever do a song about Religion like some others have… so I said, You are referring to the great gig in the sky they call “God“. What words could be used to describe all the pain and suffering caused by religious beliefs. All the crying and wailing from mothers who lost their husbands or sons in a war fought over religious differences. The only vocals should be just the sound of a mothers crying with pain and suffering. That’s the true intentions of the song. We didn’t want to make that public so as to avoid any religious boycott like what happened to the Beatles after Lennon made his comment about Jesus. We could not tell the singer so as to avoid her making any comments that would end up in the media. The speaking heard at the beginning was recorded at Apple records prior to the recording of the song. Roger Waters placed a recorder at the door asking anyone who walked by to answer some questions into the microphone. The doorman stopped and recorded his answer to the question….”Are You Afraid Of Dying”?. weeks before the song was recorded. It was decided to add the recording to the start of “Great Gig In The Sky”. It leads people to believe the song is about dying, but that is actually not the case. The Great Gig In The Sky…is GOD … The incredible vocals from Clare Torry happened when she did not know what they wanted. David Gilmour told her to pretend her voice is a Saxophone like on other songs on the album, no words, just tones. Results are legendary.

[@larryc3860]

yes.....a different singer for each stage of the process

[@AliasMark69]

@@larryc3860 That's not the real story of the song. Has nothing to do with death- grieving. Great Gig in the Sky is all about GOD, religious beliefs and all the death caused by those beliefs. As told to me personally by David Gilmour himself.

[@larryc3860]

@@AliasMark69 he should know...however many share the opinion that I stated (see below)........I think David and Roger would let us each interpret the vocals as we listen to these wonderful vocalists...just an opinion

[@randybond5927]

I love your reactions, I'm a huge Pink Floyd fan and I've also checked out your reactions to someone new, The Warning, I love your sense of respect for the artist, including in this case the solo performances of the vocalist. I check out a lot of reaction videos and there is Alway's something that puts me off about them. so, I have never! subscribed to a reaction broadcaster, until now, I am happy to subscribe to your channel! Keep up the good work. ( indecently, the Warning has just released a new album)

[@mikebunner3498]

Travis and Suzy, It appears that I may owe you two an apology. I went on and on in the comments about this song on one of your other videos. Well hush my mouth, here you two are reviewing it. Thank YOU both... You will love it!!! How about that lap steel???? Get ready!!! I first heard this song 50 years ago and it still moves me like it did the first time!!!! Spiritual!!!!! LOVE IT!!!!!!! Great work, classic. True talent!!!! For sure & for certain!......... One of my favorite portions of the video is when David stops playing and just watches the women sing.... A classic!!! Pure joy.....

[@mindykloster3540]

This piece of music/vocals is otherwordly! It captures so much emotion, intensity and pain. I'm continually amazed everytime I listen to it! This album changed my life!

[@DavidGarcia-kw4sf]

The original studio version can be found on "Dark Side of the Moon" and is well worth checking out as a point of comparison. (The whole album is great by the way)

[@saviourvisanich9585]

The original female vocal on this was Clare Torry and it’s the best there is. She just went into the studio and invented it after just listening to the music. It’s on the album Dark Side of the Moon

[@carolricard1903]

Think about it- in 1968 a young ALAN PARSONS RECREMENDED CLAIR TORI BASICALLY OF STREETS TO DO THESE VOCALS FROM SCRATCH. Did all by herself and nailed it at ABBEY ROAD STUDIOS IN LONDON. The five stages of death explained no words. This piece for fifty years still moves my spirit.

[@Kitch-hu7tm]

The story of the song is amazing and the performance is always a goosebumps ride. Pink Floyd is a blast of sound and emotion.

[@philipshort7491]

It's time once again for another crazy STEVE VAI MASTERCLASS!, STEVE VAI INCREDIBLE GUITAR PERFORMANCE HD. best wishes from the north east coast of England.

[@Tattitude241]

"The Great Gig in the Sky" is a song without any words about the journey of life from birth to death. The music brings you along that journey until the end when we all attend that Great Gig in the Sky called Judgement Day.

[@kevinohara2618]

this song, initially called the mortality sequence is actually about the stages of dying as from the composer richard wrights has said, from disbelief , anger, confusion, grief, mourning, acceptance and calming, it is also why they put in the words about dying in it.

[@AliasMark69]

Nope.....I met David Gilmour back stage at a concert in California 1984. I asked him about the meaning - reason for “Great Gig In The Sky”…. David’s answer was something like…. .I was asked if Pink Floyd would ever do a song about Religion like some others have… so I said, You are referring to the great gig in the sky they call “God“. What words could be used to describe all the pain and suffering caused by religious beliefs. All the crying and wailing from mothers who lost their husbands or sons in a war fought over religious differences. The only vocals should be just the sound of a mothers crying with pain and suffering. That’s the true intentions of the song. We didn’t want to make that public so as to avoid any religious boycott like what happened to the Beatles after Lennon made his comment about Jesus. We could not tell the singer so as to avoid her making any comments that would end up in the media. The speaking heard at the beginning was recorded at Apple records prior to the recording of the song. Roger Waters placed a recorder at the door asking anyone who walked by to answer some questions into the microphone. The doorman stopped and recorded his answer to the question….”Are You Afraid Of Dying”?. weeks before the song was recorded. It was decided to add the recording to the start of “Great Gig In The Sky”. It leads people to believe the song is about dying, but that is actually not the case. The Great Gig In The Sky…is GOD … The incredible vocals from Clare Torry happened when she did not know what they wanted. David Gilmour told her to pretend her voice is a Saxophone like on other songs on the album, no words, just tones. Results are legendary.

[@kevinohara2618]

@@AliasMark69 richard wright wrote this, he said its about dying, im going to believe the guy who wrote this, either you are talking bs,or this is further proof that gilmour changes facts to suit his narrative, which is it ?, by the way, gilmour has always said he is an athiest, so it does make sense he might have said it, but again, i say that the writer has probably the facts about the song

[@AliasMark69]

@@kevinohara2618 Richard only wrote the piano music long before the song, but not the concept of the song. I believe Gilmour. It makes much more sense as well.

[@timkohler3923]

@@AliasMark69 "It makes much more sense as well." As someone who knows both interpretations now: no. Doesn't. Neither in the context of the album nor in the structure of the song. Both do fit in the "death"-narrative much better. So, I don't know, which story is the right one, but when it comes to making sense...

[@brianlipskey8440]

greatest song ever sung without words.....

[@davidstathers9534]

Great reaction guys Pink Floyd are masters of sound they just use any form of sound to draw your mind in and hold you there pure genius

[@malcolmrayner6674]

Clare Torry only got paid a thirty pound studio fee for the track that she co wrote with Richard Wright she sued in 2005 and they settled out of court and all products released from that date have her name on them as co writer You need to listen to the original to hear Clare do it all solo.

[@jasonowen2252]

I'm from the uk. you are doing good work... keep giving us the truth... all of you keep safe...

[@rickpearson3018]

The song before it on the album, "Time", is about how time flies by and suddenly one realizes that so much of life has passesd without us knowing it. This song is about accepting one's own death. At 65 years old, this moves me to tears as it did when I was in high school, but now I know why. Here are the words from the beginning: "I am not frightened of dying, any time will do, I don't mind. Why should I be frightened of dying? There's no reason for it, you've gotta go sometime." If you can hear this whispering you are dying."

[@philshorten3221]

If you want to see the main line-up at the time they found themselves musically then check out Pink Floyd "Echoes" (Part 1) Live at Pompeii 1972 (I suggest the split version as it's probably better in terms of length as a reaction piece only) No Lights, No Pyrotechnics, No Backing Vocals, No Audience! But plenty of talent😉

[@bjhellstream]

Claire Torry made the original on the album in one take and was paid a few pounds as a session musician. She later got writing credit for the melodies she created.

[@alexcampos4370]

Please listen to the album version. It’s amazing!

[@Magic-hb5xt]

Sam Brown is the blonde female vocalist. Claudia Fontaine is the other vocalist. Claudia passed away in 2018

[@phillipdunn6009]

Unpopular comment, I think this is better than the studio version and I played the studio version at my dad's funeral.

[@bkniker]

This is my favorite Pink Floyd song, period, you just get lost in it.

[@martincummings7886]

Great your reacting to Pink Floyd playing "Great Gig in The Sky " it's off the album Dark Side of the Moon, as with all Pink Floyd album's they are concept album's (A theme from start to finish) this song is about 'Death' meaning that The Great Gig in The Sky is where you go when you die basically up to Heaven..!! I was lucky enough to be at this concert at Earls Court in London in October 1994, from the Pulse Tour, they finished the 2 year Tour off at Earls Court London playing 14 consecutive nights give or take the odd day off in between..!! The whole concert is INCREDIBLE as its well known when you see Pink Floyd play live it's not just the music it's a light and lazer show with amazing special affects..You should watch the whole concert and it will blow you away like nothing you've ever seen before, watch "Comfortably Numb" and the effects and the guitar solo by David Gilmour its known as the greatest guitar solo of all time + a giant mirror ball comes down from the ceiling in mid song and I was sitting in the top balcony directly opposite the giant mirror ball on the side of the stage I was to the left of the stage facing me PS I'd taken a 100 Magic Mushrooms 🍄 and was tripping my tits off watching them and all the mind-blowing special effects of lights and lasers and other stuff they engineered in the show at one stage a Giant Spitfire plane flew across the Stadium from the back of the Arena and crashed exploded on the stage in a massive explosion and fireball.. The original version of Dark Side of The Moon is just no lyrics and female singer her name is Clare Torry, when she went to Abbey Road studio's to sing Pink Floyd had already written the music but had no lyrics so told Clare Torry just harmonise to the song and that's how it was made incredible hey..👍🏻

[@fd1930]

Nice, respectful review guys. Such an emotional piece of music. Great to see you reacting to Floyd again, can I suggest as your next one - Keep Talking, from the same concert (Pulse). You'll love it.... and so will we!

[@achebwahs1111]

We got in trouble for playing this in an outback caravan park back in 1989. The owner told us to turn it off because it sounded like she was enjoying herself too much. My reply was "is there such a thing?" Thanks hunters

[@Omegaphats]

🤣🤣🤣

[@chrislc35]

yea i love the way he looks at her at the end. they all did amazing, tough song to do.

[@mikebunner3498]

I suggested this tune to you two earlier then I tabbed down and found this. The ladies in this classic are wonderful. David's lap steel makes the song. I love how near the end he stops and gazes at the singers. As if he is spell-bound also... Was this spiritual or what? /For me it is!!! I love it..... And I love your channel.....

[@johnsrensen3366]

Listen to studio version gives you a goosebump

[@blatantfoul8836]

Angels singing

[@kevinlese633]

Got to listen to the studio version

[@Facewest]

You have to hear the original recording with Clare Torry singing. She is so good that even with 4 singers trying to copy what she did in 1973 they can’t even come close !!! Listen to the original and you will see a incredible Clare Torry is

[@bobbergirl111]

I love the attention on the back up vocalists

[@charlestath4758]

Love telle another song that you now without words

[@kima.4268]

the studio version is amazing. So much better!

[@Pulsar77]

It's a shame that they cut out a minute of the third singer's (Claudia Fontaine) part on the DVD and Blu-ray. The full uncut version is on the old VHS tape and on the Pulse CD.

[@thomassanchez8956]

Gatos do 💰 from same concert was next song after Great Gig✌🏼❤️

[@BrianR.]

The original singer was Clare Torry, the one singing the first part here is the great Sam Brown.

[@leonardbellinger5223]

Great Gig In The Sky Clair Torry Vocalist The album was released in March of 1973 but was started in 1971 and was worked on till the release date This album is considered one of Pink Floyd’s best works Roger Waters states it’s an expression of political, philosophical, humanitarian, and documentary that was desperate to get out. Pink Floyd went to Allen Parson for a female vocalist to perform the Great Gig in the Sky and he suggested Claire Torry (one of the best vocalist ever). Clair was guided by David Gilmore who told her the cut was a song written about life and the inevitable descent into death without using any words Clair was to convey this, This was when Clair decided to use her voice as an instrument and did a one take doing this and left the studio not knowing if Pink Floyd liked it or not thinking she had failed it wasn’t until the release of the album that she new her cut was used the problem was that Clair Torry was not credited as a co-writer and was not credited for any royalties which she sued for in 2004 and won. She received an undisclosed amount in the settlement. The album went to #1 on Bill Board and sold over 45 million copies it stayed on Bill Board's top 200 for 33 years

[@Tijuanabill]

I love the smirk before the first girl goes IN on the vocal fray. Like...haha I'm so pretty....ROAR!

[@YDdraigGoch43]

The first lady was Sam Brown. She had a no.1 in the late 80s earpy 90s with Stop.

[@riff8114]

David Gillmore, kills w/the bends lol

[@MrJoeinz]

This is a good imitation of Claire Torry . . . the original vocalist on the Dark Side of the Moon album.

[@begogaro8192]

The song Great Gig in the Sky is about dying. The first part is the final fight for life until the lull, then acceptance of the inevitable.

[@catman2629]

Back in the 70s Clare Torry did this solo. 2022 it was such a great track they can re imagine it .

[@keyrat1753]

The original studio version of this song was also only female vocals.

[@notanotherenigma7759]

For a better live version, check out the Delicate Sound Of Thunder concert.

[@donrobbie1461]

This song is off the iconic dark side of the moon album and is about dying. On live gigs the singing was done by the 3 backing singers as i dont think Claire Torrey ever sang live after doing the studio recording - and in one take!

[@martycech5844]

Pink Floyd is Absolute Perfection… Amazing

[@trevorholden7423]

PS luv ya hair Suzie, very creative and cool!!

[@mikebunner3498]

It is off of the Dark side of the Moon. One of the best albums ever! The ladies singing solos will melt you two brains right out of your heads.. David finishes his paty and becomes part of the audience.

[@mikebunner3498]

Pink is a collection of master craftsmen!!!! This song is off of one of their best ---Dark Side of the Moon.!!! I say that without pause! A lady has always sang this part of the song..... ALL of these ladies are special! "Holly smokes" bet your last dollar!!! I enjoy the part where all of the ladies sing together... Another favorite part is when Davis stops playing the lap steel and calmlt watches them sing.

[@zurnie]

Leave it to the masters, Pink Floyd, to take a country\western instrument and give it soul.

[@fifidurand7421]

the emotion of claudia fontaine (3rd) always give me tears ..RIP......

[@MrFreakyFatBoy]

G’day Mates, I’m old so I got to see Pink Floyd live at Sydney Entertainment centre way back in 1988 on their Delicate Sound of Thunder tour. It was f’ing Awesome.

[@stephen5465]

I got to see the same concert but in Melbourne. Still one of the best concerts I've ever been to

[@Fairygrl_TW]

There were different women in first virsion, these women have been with Floyd in later yrs. Such a brilliant song to convey stages of dealing with death without words, anger fear, sadness, and acceptance. Pulse is def the best concert ever. Thanx so much, Peace

[@SoBackSo]

They legend band is pink floyd broo

[@mikebunner3498]

For your information Pink had sold 45 million copies of this classic...

[@glyngasson8450]

The studio version is one person doing it and it's the second take

[@gibsongirl2100]

These woman did an incredible job and deserve all the applause and praise. Having said that, you really should also check out the studio version of this song ("Dark Side of the Moon") - Clare Torry will break your heart - it truly does sound like a soul leaving this life and being born into the next. And don't forget to listen to "Sorrow" from this same concert - mind blowing!!

[@stephen5465]

You really need to listen to the whole Dark Side of the Moon album

[@brianfranklinlee8490]

Clare Torry was the original back when Dark Side of the Moon was released. Then Rachel Fury , Durga McBroom, and Margaret Taylor were a Trio that sang it. All 3 sang different parts. And you just heard Gloria Fontaine. Also Lorelei McBroom and Sam Brown have been on some live performances. I bought Dark Side of the Moon in 1974.

[@adamsweetz5156]

I think I'm going insane but I see you here with MEEEEEE ❤ that part

[@craigkile9403]

This song is about a person that has died, and their spirit is going through the transition from denial, to fighting it, to slowly and peacefully accepting it. The original studio version was also done by a woman, Clare Torry. You need to listen to "Dark Side of the Moon" in it's entirety to really get the full effect.

[@jimohare7234]

I'm old so bare with me this song is about what it feels like to die .the trip to the Peary gates unfortunately I'll be there before I want but that's that's ok I can hope my trip there is like this song

[@michaelwhitworth2581]

Sam was the first singer, Joe browns daughter, he is a very good musician, still going,

[@byronmitchell3784]

PINK FLOYD, "GREAT GIG IN THE SKY", Singer Claire Tory improvised her voice too the final track on side one, "DARK SIDE OF THE MOON". About the transition of the final moments of life leading into the souls separation from the body, and the deafening echoes of silence.

[@paulpenix8198]

On the album one woman sings. Claire Torrie. AMAZING. Should also here original by her on Dark Side of the moon.

[@jorhanson8583]

Female vocalists are an underrated aspect of the Pink Floyd sound. If you focus on them on certain songs, you realize what they add. Check out "On the Turning Away" from the Delicate Sound Of Thunder concert. 3 different vocalists, another high caliber of talent.

[@AliasMark69]

I met David Gilmour back stage at a concert in California 1984. I asked him about the meaning - reason for “Great Gig In The Sky”…. David’s answer was something like…. .I was asked if Pink Floyd would ever do a song about Religion like some others have… so I said, You are referring to the great gig in the sky they call “God“. What words could be used to describe all the pain and suffering caused by religious beliefs. All the crying and wailing from mothers who lost their husbands or sons in a war fought over religious differences. The only vocals should be just the sound of a mothers crying with pain and suffering. That’s the true intentions of the song. We didn’t want to make that public so as to avoid any religious boycott like what happened to the Beatles after Lennon made his comment about Jesus. We could not tell the singer so as to avoid her making any comments that would end up in the media. The speaking heard at the beginning was recorded at Apple records prior to the recording of the song. Roger Waters placed a recorder at the door asking anyone who walked by to answer some questions into the microphone. The doorman stopped and recorded his answer to the question….”Are You Afraid Of Dying”?. weeks before the song was recorded. It was decided to add the recording to the start of “Great Gig In The Sky”. It leads people to believe the song is about dying, but that is actually not the case. The Great Gig In The Sky…is GOD … The incredible vocals from Clare Torry happened when she did not know what they wanted. David Gilmour told her to pretend her voice is a Saxophone like on other songs on the album, no words, just tones. Results are legendary.

[@pablerry]

I went to that tour in 1994, I was 14.5 years old, that almos ruined my life because it set the bar so high that is very difficult for me to get mind blown, Tool and The mars volta and meshuggah are the only bands that can blow me away these days.

[@xlerb_again_to_music7908]

Hm. Go with the Clare Torry version (on the original LP). There is too much joy here... Clare sings this as an individuals struggle against death arriving; it's a fight then eventual acceptance of death's inevitability. Fun its not; beautiful yes, meaningful for all yes, kick-in-the-gut yes, fun - no.

[@jeffreykennedy1266]

Great music…👍

[@williammuntzer7374]

This is about death. Specifically, your own death and the emotions you might feel as you are dying. Verse 1 reminds me of rage and anger that my life is over. Verse 2 reminds me of the sadness that this life is over. Verse 3 feels like acceptance of our fate and disappearing into silence. I encourage you to listen to the original which was done by one singer in one take. She did it twice, but they lost track of whether it was her first or second try. Also. listen carefully to the commentary at the beginning of the song. Buried in the music (I believe it's between the second and third verse) you will hear a voice that whispers something like, "If you hear this, you are already dying." A very emotional song and a masterpiece.

[@PeterDay81]

just a class band.

[@markkettlewell7441]

The lady is a session musician and very talented. On the original Dark side of the Moon album this part was sung by Claire Torrey another session musician. Claire is still the best exponent of the song because she is a genius. This is not to decry the lady in the concert who is really good. But I have never heard anyone sing this piece better than Claire on the original album Dark side of the Moon. 😃

[@toddlalonde1199]

Denial Anger Bargaining Acceptance Death Yeah Pink Floyd gets in deep. Can't listen to this without tears running down my face.

[@redzone77p]

The instrument is called the pedal steel, used in country music quite a bit. Gilmore did a nice job creating the sound.

[@duhbearz]

Not a pedal steel, it's a lap steel. No pedals

[@redzone77p]

@@duhbearz Not much difference, you still get basically the same sound.

[@duhbearz]

@@redzone77p not really. One gets its intermediate notes via slide, the other by stretching and relaxing strings. The quality of sound of a slide contacting the strings as it moves over them is very different than bending.

[@redzone77p]

@@duhbearz IT'S PRETTY CLOSE IN SOUND, BUT I'LL GIVE IT TOO YOU.

[@markroberts8864]

Pink Floyd, nothing like them... something for everyone.

[@johnsutton1172]

you should check out the original, Clare Torry came in the studio and listened to the track and then did the vocal in one take. Amazing vocalist

[@mattjarrell8945]

Hi you guys. You do a really nice job with this stuff. I know you can’t do just Pink Floyd but when you come back around to PF I’d ask you to consider One of These Days from Pulse (note: pigs are a kind of inside joke to Pink Floyd) and also Fat Old Sun from David Gilmour’s live at Gdańsk concert (a light stoner’s pastoral from the early 70s turned into something much more interesting in the last three minutes). I hope you’ll consider. Best.

[@coot1925]

I agree that the original is never going to be beaten, but you have to remember that these ladies have to do this every night which, as someone who has been a backing vocalists as well as playing 7 different instruments I can tell you that your voice takes a real hammering.

[@richardsmallwood7940]

Hey babes, try "Money" from the same Gig? Same trio of girls/Ladies Same beautiful sounds!

[@vincentpetro7310]

If you enjoyed this version for your own personal pleasure check out this song from the Delicate sound of thunder 1988.

[@wayne7048]

Miss Sam Brown,Amazing!

[@Mal-r5q]

She's as good as Clare Torrey if not better! I actually like this live version better than the studio version. Both exceptional

[@billn7183]

Please don't consider yourselves as having "heard this song" until you listen to the original

[@andrew5550]

Shes the best version her name is sam brown...claire torrey was the original she was good also...the song in short is about dying.

[@bethkelley575]

AND NO AUTOTUNE!

[@BackLooking]

Without any language barrier this song speaks to anybody. Words are very........unnecessary 🙂

[@voxac30withstrat]

Here we are 50 years later STILL in awe. You NEED the original album version. This is a great job but......... I seriously doubt we would ever hear of PF in this day and age with all the garbage, manufactured, auto tune trash totally dominating the radio. I mean seriously Cardi B and her WAP? Justin Bieber? Your honour, I rest my case.

[@sulatlalaki]

As far as live goes, Rachel Fury's performance, I feel, back around 1987 is the best. When David Gilmore was on his Momentary Lapse of Reason Tour, he had 3 backup singers that would rotate singing this because, as I'm sure as we can all imagine, this song would be VERY taxing to sing every night! This gal's performance, IMO, is just decent, but does not move me.

[@fresquinhoprodutoslacteosl6680]

I think thats a tamarin, made a highschool work about that

[@76006linda]

Studio version is much better than the live version. Being told you're dying and being angry then finally accepting. Very horrific and sad

[@markgulbranson7518]

Too many people get hung up on lyrics and forget about MUSIC.