Pinkie's Brew (Extended Version)

[@CaptainKronkers]

Looking back on this song, I realize that it's actually ridiculously well written. I miss FiW music.

[@ctoacu6188]

Hey, just thought I'd remind you of this comment 3 years later. Yea you have 430 likes.

[@sempiternal.98]

@@ctoacu6188 596*

[@manworms]

@@sempiternal.98 721*

[@Handledgovernment]

757*

[@Acceptable890]

772*

[@Punkini]

Friendship is witchcraft had absolutely no business being so GOOD. The songs are legitimately SUPER well-written and the fan backstories are legitimately entertaining. I miss this era of the internet so much

[@michaeldebellis4202]

I’ve heard Jenny say she doesn’t think it’s very good. I disagree. I love all her stuff but there was something really special about how they took a kids show and made it sarcastic and hilarious and still kind of stayed true to the original characters. I never get tired of watching these.

[@TheFoxers101]

@@michaeldebellis4202 I thought it was amazing when I first watched it. Now rewatching, it's even better than before. A lot of the jokes still hit and the humor is so subtle that it makes the more bold parts (twilight's non biologically related brother-lover) amazingly absurd. I love it. And you've hit the nail, it literally doesn't feel out of character at all. I think Jenny or anyone looking back on their old art would have a lot of negative reflections about it, it's just kind of how it is with artists. FiW is still my favourite thing to come out of the MLP, like they didn't have to go this hard but they did, and you feel every drop of effort.

[@michaeldebellis4202]

@@TheFoxers101 Totally agree! Especially how you catch so many subtle jokes and puns on repeat viewings.

[@pokevenom314]

@@TheFoxers101 Absolutely adore seeing appreciation for FIW 12 years later (holy shit... cannot believe it was that long ago). Thanks for sharing your thoughts. This fanwork went way beyond what's expected from a "silly parody dub". It was really, really special. It had a unique form of subtle, dry humor you can't get from just anywhere. Big reason why I love what Jenny does

[@ath0lbr0se]

@@pokevenom314 12 years ago? This again reframes to me how young I was when I entered this extremely adult fandom back in its glory days lol. 9/10 year old me really had no business being this heavily invested in the fandom but I wouldn't go back and change it. MLP seems to be having a fandom revival and that makes me really happy. I'm glad the love for FiW is still strong today.

[@retpolanne]

Friendship is Witchcraft is pretty weird. I mean, it's not something big, just a regular parody. But THE SONGS, OH MY GOSH. How can you do something so great?

[@nox_chan]

The amount of effort that went into this series is amazing

[@retpolanne]

6 years later and I still love Jenny Nicholson

[@lane7780]

@@retpolanne i ddont Know what ur pfp but i LOVE IT!! he looks like a funny bloke and such. Brings a smile 2 my face 😃😃😃👍

[@kittycatrittycatalt9523]

True lmao but your comment is from 6 years ago

[@AA-lp6bo]

@jonathon brent opnpooon

[@HappiPine]

This is actually so well written. "They say a kitchen times saves nine but I'm just saving two" Like what that's so clever!?

[@Anstherz]

i dont understand that line 😭😭

[@HappiPine]

@@Anstherz It's sort of like "cooking can feed many people, but I'm only doing it for two"

[@Anstherz]

@@HappiPine Ohh okay! Tyy ^^

[@HappiPine]

@@Anstherz No problem!

[@Blue-fj6js]

@@Anstherz also the way it’s written sounds like a “kitch in time” mean stopping the time at that specific point

[@thewanderer5506]

"Bake the fourth wall" Oh Pinkie, never change

[@heyimhere7048]

yep

[@StillaMarls]

@@heyimhere7048yep

[@FishTroll-q4u]

​@@StillaMarls yep.

[@milkbreadcuzyes]

​@@FishTroll-q4u yep

[@Ilovelittlecorgiz122]

@@milkbreadcuzyes yep

[@belobimkauagabriel5380]

WE'RE BAKING A PORTAL TO SAVE PINKIE'S PARENTS WITH THIS ONE‼️‼️‼️‼️🗣️🗣️🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🥶🥶🥶💥💥💥💥💥💥💥💥💥💥💥💥💥💥😎😎😎💯💯💯💯💯

[@mandynanda]

YASSS!!!

[@Jay35513]

We're baking the fourth wall with this one‼️‼️‼️🗣🗣🗣🗣🗣🗣💥💥💥💥💥💥💥💥💥💥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥😎😎😎😎🥶🥶😹😹😹😹😹🙀🙀🙀🙀🙀🤥🤥🤥🤥🤥🤥

[@Kiruminzuu]

WE’RE COOKING A SOLUTION WITH THIS ONE 🗣️🗣️🗣️🗣️🗣️🗣️🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥

[@Lilbedsheet-te9vz]

WE'RE SAVING A KITCHEN TIME SAVING NINE WITH THIS ONE🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥@@Kiruminzuu

[@quimicalkirby]

WE ARE GETTING GYPSY WITH THIS ONE 🗣🗣🗣💯🔥🔥‼️‼️💯🔥🔥

[@coralia3238]

Please tell me I'm not the only one listening to this after 9 years

[@pinkiepie1469]

Hey, I'm here too, so you're not alone!

[@coralia3238]

@@pinkiepie1469 Yayy

[@Drifter1558]

The first 30 seconds of the song randomly resurfaced in my mind so that brought me here

[@foozzy8288]

Your not alone my friend

[@0MN1AC3JESS]

Im here 2! Omg i loved this when i was little

[@Lottistari]

how do people think this is from the show? it’s literally about Pinkie trying to bring back her dead parents. 💀

[@hopeshineseternal]

the incredible quality

[@yourfriendlyneighborhoodbl1520]

It doesn’t even sound like her 💀

[@JordenJords]

Me: No it’s no- “bread and butter, chant and mutter” oh and I hear it now- Edit: just got to 1:34 💀

[@exotic_existenceiquit4130]

@@JordenJords that’s dark..

[@depressed.horse420]

It's about her bringing the cakes back from a different dimension that they're stuck in 🙄🙄

[@SummerStars323]

I really miss the prime of this fandom. Season 1-2 was great, lots of talented and creative people back then. The constant Copyright strikes from Hasbro really killed a lot of cool content that came from the fans of that show. Its sad really.

[@lunabruce1804]

Agreed.

[@pikapals41]

Amazing Porpoise RIP Fighting Is Magic 😓

[@lunabruce1804]

pikapals41 Indeed.

[@SummerStars323]

Wouldn't trade those memories for anything. It may have been only a fairly short amount of time but during those two season I met plenty of friends who I still talk to on a regular basis. Its just sad to see what it became. MLP was always meant as a show to sell kids toys, but it never seemed to sacrifice the quality of its writing or characters to do it. I don't think I can confidently claim that anymore.

[@dholezs9362]

However i do agree on somethings you said however you must remember that this is their property What would you do if you own a popular cartoon and people doing stuff to it and misleading the brand.

[@jotaro4874]

This shit has no business being this good

[@user-lz9zo5ly5o]

great opinion, jotaro from jjba!

[@foofighter5672]

You're right, Mister Kujo.

[@woomygod5154]

Jotaro didn’t expect you to be here

[@jotaro4874]

@@woomygod5154 nobody expects the jojo inquisition

[@dioderent2653]

@@jotaro4874 😳

[@novalisk]

It's fun, smiling all the way, then that last "someday I'm gonna go home" hits, and eye gets teary right away. Don't even know why.

[@moronribbons5774]

and then that little whimper oh my god

[@aspdangel]

theres hardly room for seconds when scond melt away??? bruh this legit so good lyricism

[@therealslimshawty1854]

"...But I'm just saving two.'' ''There's hardly room for seconds when the seconds melt away!" ''Sometimes life is not a cake walk served up on a silver spoon'' ''Let's beat these yolks and save my folks'' ''God help the outcast with her withcraft'' *''Someday I'm gonna go home''* I love the dark implications of this song.

[@shi-chan2]

One month ya still there do you remember huh?!

[@your.only.rui.xoxo0921]

I’ll cook up a solution with knowledge l’ve accrued they say a kitch-en time saves nine but im just saving two,I’ve gathered the ingredients to make some time sorbet there’s hardly room for seconds when the seconds melt away!,watch as I work my gypsy magic eye of a newt and cinnamon watch as this matter turns to batter open the portal,jump in! Crude stew; do you fear it, apple bloom? Sometimes life is not a cake walk served up on a sliver spoon,toss a fig and save the date and,bread and butter,chant and mutter,marination,incarnation,chocolate icing,timeline splicing,yeast is rising, rectifying Pinke if you’re hearing this it means we’re dead and gone.please dont bake a portal;just accept it and move on. Watch as I work my gypsy magic seapony tears and provolone god help the outcast with her witchcraft someday I’m gonna go home,someday, im gonna go home.

[@idv181]

“Pinkie if your hearing this this means we’re dead and gone, please don’t bake a portal and accept and move on”

[@idv181]

“Open the portal, jump in!”

[@idv181]

“Do you fear it apple bloom?”

[@sennas5235]

Why are all pinkies songs so dark jezus I didn’t realize this as a kid

[@littleredpanda3620]

I think it’s meant to balance out her crazy personality 😂

[@snickermints9040]

Emma Spork and also this isn’t from the show so it’s a little weirder

[@karxxx5056]

SAME LMAO-

[@choiyerimily]

@@littleredpanda3620 there all about her parents

[@gecchan9741]

Emma Spork that’s why it’s called pinkamena uwu I realized all these dark things when I first watched those when I was younger

[@Griffinilla]

the memories ;_;

[@TheQueenofMaggots]

+Griffinilla We will be saying that in ten years lol

[@tazzok9037]

your doing a livestream

[@Rage_WinterchiIl]

+Griffinilla Same. =/ These came out during an awesome time in my life.

[@juliabeewastaken]

+Young Savage haha love your profile pic.

[@Rage_WinterchiIl]

Julia Belonguel thank you

[@Stonmann]

Now that comments are on, I gotta say, I've never watched mlp but holy hell does this song go hard.

[@delabellum]

You should. Just give it a try watch episode 1, if you think it's gay you can always turn it off

[@broskify]

This isn't mlp, it's just a youtube AU thing called friendship is witchcraft, it's a lot more adult than the real show lol

[@Otis.has.blueberrys]

@@broskify yes its not mlp but it's still based off of it so your still gonna find pinky pie and applebloom in the show

[@WindyWïsps]

@Stonmann watch at least 5 episodes if you don't enjoy it after that it's not for you. That's my rule for all the shows I watch, cause those first episodes can be kinda weird introducing the plot and characters

[@Agoraphobia2763]

Its a parody called Friendship is Witchcraft

[@gortmo]

i dont give a shit if it's a mlp song this shit goes so fucking hard holy shit

[@Catalinazephead]

It’s not from mop it’s from a parody called friendship is witchcraft

[@PlutozDreamz]

Dude it's the internet

[@williamcaputo7931]

Look at this again, look at the lyrics, then tell me this is a mlp song It doesn't take 263, Einstein-type level of IQ to understand this is a parody

[@ToxicYaoii]

I agree

[@nazecy8423]

Same here

[@takeshikoibuchi7005]

Its interesting to interpret "Toss a fig and save the date" may have double significations: "put in a (dried) fig as a sweetener so you dont need to use the dried date" "throw away something menial(as in : it's not worth a fig) and first thing save(record) the date(referring to something of importance in contrast)

[@penntopaper9305]

i thought of it like how the other lines are, where the first part of the sentence is a baking instruction, "toss a fig", and the second half has something to do with the time travel portal shit, saving the date as in recording the date to travel to

[@jofrostsupernannystan4784]

@@penntopaper9305 that's the thing, this song is actually so well written that everything has so many meanings to it it's creative asf

[@thalimag1778]

This made me even more confused

[@dinasaur8626]

@@thalimag1778 the first one is you throw in a fig cause it’s not worth a date, second one is you throw in a fig and save the date as in saving the date for going back in time

[@eccentric_creampuff4983]

I also always thought save the date partially tied to the phrase “save the day”, as in save her parents from the day they died

[@taycat34]

I know a lot of comments saying "2019?" have a bad rep but does anyone listen to this anymore? Genuinely wondering.

[@callmealx]

I'll come back to these songs quite a lot. One of the best things to come from the MLP fandom.

[@Strein86]

This song gets stuck in my head every few months it seems, so like a loyal puppy I come waltzing back.

[@Lae-zel_enthusiast]

I literally came back just a few days ago

[@finn-8560]

yep i still do even before tiktok stole it

[@Nesaitara]

Y es

[@theamazingmaymay123]

11 years, and I STILL remember this song word by word. God I miss you guys…

[@royalraptor6245]

We miss you too /)

[@circuschaoss]

12 now :)

[@jellystualy]

now memories are blurred and their faces are obscured but i still know the words to this song :0

[@jaimee6672]

​@@jellystualythem lyrics have literally been engraved in my head for years. I think about it all the time

[@FuoxdenTech]

I found this like a few days ago and i am so happy i did, Man i miss the mlp fandom

[@Tijopi11]

1:50 "God help the outcast with her witchcraft" I just realized this might be referencing The Hunchback of Notre Dame, where Esmeralda (a Gypsy) sings "God Help the Outcasts."

[@Rage_WinterchiIl]

im very very sure that you're 100% right

[@garethalford682]

Obviously

[@xanderguyer7512]

This is from 7 years ago, but Jenny Nicholson, who was heavily involved in the series, said that the creators were... REALLY into Hunchback of Notre Dame. Like, entire plotlines and character arcs were lifted from it, aside from a ton of references, haha

[@Tijopi11]

@@xanderguyer7512 interesting. I don't know where else they make references, but this one is pretty clear.

[@_Experience_.]

I remember that song lol I thought the line gave me a strange feeling haha

[@ASONG4MATILDA]

Thinking about the fact that SIX YEAR OLD me, wrote out every single lyric of this on construction paper and showed it to my school,,,,, 😭😭

[@heyimhere7048]

omg what did they say 🥴

[@anime_simp8279]

I was singing this back then when I was like 5 and my sister's just like: WTF 👁👄👁

[@heyimhere7048]

@@anime_simp8279 *oop*

[@isabellek-q3183]

NO-

[@yvmmiii]

WHAT-

[@swfreak258]

This being Jenny Nicholson still feels like a fact that shouldn't be canon

[@twinkiesmaster69]

It feels cursed but i hear it

[@charlottehahn2226]

@@twinkiesmaster69 no it’s literally her

[@tygical]

@@twinkiesmaster69 she's actually the va here

[@theslendynet404]

​@@tygicalGriffinilla/Fandroid music wrote all the songs NOT Jenny

[@tygical]

​@@theslendynet404 griffinilla/fandroid may have wrote them but that doesn't mean they sang them

[@thingsareabouttogetgrusome5092]

I never thought I’d see the day where the words “chocolate icing” and “timeline splicing” would be rhymed so well

[@rebusn1505]

"Pinkie, didn't you already have a childhood?" "No. . ."

[@whyamilikethis3547]

This song is from the fan made tho About the song:Pinkie is trying to save HER parents so she make a portal to travel back.in.time so she can save her.parents!

[@TheRealJackOfTrades]

@@whyamilikethis3547 no literally that's a quote, right before the song plays applebloom ask this question

[@franknfurter5336]

holy shit

[@thepinkone6932]

such memories, best year of high school

[@thisiswhyiamnotameme5015]

The Pink One I sang this back in middle school.

[@thepinkone6932]

Lol mlp fim wasn't even a thing when I was in middle school

[@thisiswhyiamnotameme5015]

The Pink One I don't remember when I sang it or which grade I was. The odd thing is all of them seem to love it. My friends still talked about it. The best memories.

[@thepinkone6932]

Just imagine us telling our grand children about this Me: "so Bobby, when I was your age I watch a little show called 'my little pony'" Bobby: "grandpa! I'm 17!" Me: *triggered*

[@thisiswhyiamnotameme5015]

The Pink One Well I'd be *triggered*

[@PinkieRose]

took me three hours, but I did an impression cover of this song :)

[@murkyhydra6351]

Cool!

[@BLVZE]

PINKIE ROSE?

[@katie15732]

Hiya

[@kittycatrittycatalt9523]

Ahhh you were my childhood :,) Ty for the memories

[@crownedprincesses8365]

Omg hiiiii

[@sgtsurgeon.]

"Toss a fig and save the date" is such an underrated line Also "baking the fourth wall" that's so silly and clever I love it

[@rolandwilliam3257]

This song is unironically so good...the music is great, and the lyrics are so clever...what the hell...

[@user-yq9ul9rw1x]

I think that this song is about Pinkie wanting to go back in time to save her parents from whatever happened from them in the past. Her parents know that Pinkie can't bear the sadness if they died, so they saved a recording about how they want her to move on and accept their deaths. But Pinkie still wanted to make a portal so she can save them. It's like Gypsy Bard. In Gypsy Bard is about how her parents have died and she was shipped off to the orphanage. The orphanage told Pinkie to forget about her parents to fit in, so she dug graves and danced with orphan foals in the grave. Pinkie mentioned that when you're feeling sad, listen to the song and it'll make you happy because her gypsy magic hypnotizes you to being happy. Well... That's pretty dark...

[@PopopamAJ]

im pretty sure friendship is witchcraft explains it but since I haven't seen it... (I try to keep my search history clean) from what I've seen i think its mostly the same as you said but I think they are talking to her from heaven or as ghosts or something

[@dlt78081]

;-; Why did I have to see this comment

[@MafuMorales]

In friendship is magic it literally explains that

[@SirLuckySlime]

In gypsy bard it says "when I was a little filly, a galloping blaze overtook my city" Very next line - "so they shipped me off to the orphanage said 'ditch those roots if you wanna fit in' " So right after the fire, she became an orphan. Clearly pointing out her parents were killed in a fire

[@livvylubug]

Im pretty sure it was a fire that killed her parents, cause in gypsy bard she said “a galloping blaze over took my city”

[@solistaVT]

6 years later, I'm back here again. :')

[@z0-mg]

Jaxx same

[@fluffiu]

:) welcome to 2019 where we still listen to this song

[@turtle_golem4570]

@@fluffiu I'm with you, fellas

[@emma3547]

Jaxx, we feel you

[@skykeenan9757]

make that 7

[@Saritah12]

Damn, the "Someday I'm gonna go home" part at the end made me cry and I don't know why-

[@ChocoThe_Cat]

Same, Poor Pinkie :(

[@ahaahbahoo1821]

made the lil crying gland trigger, didn't happen though, I'm a big strong boy😌

[@brittany4849]

AM I THE ONLY ONE WHO DIDN’T KNOW JENNY NICHOLSON VOICED/WROTE FRIENDSHIP IS WITCHCRAFT!!??

[@jimmyelkordy3752]

Brittany Hansen who?

[@creaturehands]

@@jimmyelkordy3752 Jenny Nicholson! She makes Disney/Pop culture related videos here on KZbin! She's great!

[@videosofmesinginggreendayt4016]

I only found out from her video on the last bronycon haha, I think it's pretty cool that she acknowledged that the g word for travellers is actually a slur and that she regrets using it. The song still slaps tho

[@notdeadyet3680]

@@jimmyelkordy3752 she's amazing

[@theslendynet404]

Griffinilla/Fandroid music wrote all the songs

[@szalhi]

Probably already commented this but whatever. This is literally about Pinkie bring back her parents, but making enough to save seven more, which is literally reflected in the series by the x/9.

[@paulelkin3531]

I wasn't around when FiW was actually being put out. As it's also a pun for "a stitch in time saves nine," was this actually a thing in FiW that she'd save nine ponies total?

[@TheTinyDiamond]

@@paulelkin3531 yeah, that’s what the original comment was talking about: the counter that pops up pretty much whenever time travel is involved is the “nine” she saved

[@paulelkin3531]

@@TheTinyDiamond That's actually really clever. Thanks for clarifying.

[@Afirebison]

@@TheTinyDiamond the better part is that everything that pops up could be considered a parent

[@katelyn4real214]

I’m not even a fan of M.L.P but this has been stuck in my head this whole week.

[@discoshark7767]

Trust me This is NOT a part of the show

[@gracie9551]

@@discoshark7767 no but it should be

[@Farah-sr8sq]

@@gracie9551 that would be dark

[@roun6479]

right, shits catchy

[@vinzettas3021]

@@Farah-sr8sq most of pinkies songs are already dark

[@jamesfromteamrocketmcduck7288]

OMFG as a kid, I was babysat by my aunt who was a pastors wife. They were so mad and disappointed in my parents for giving me an MLP themed birthday party, and talking about how it’s witchcraft and magic. And right now I’m remembering exactly what they said,”there’s a secret hidden version, with its real name ‘friendship is witchcraft’” when my mom and I were like, ‘ohhh haha no that’s probably something else’ he said “don’t believe me? Look it up in KZbin” my mom did, I wasn’t allowed to watch MLP after that 😔

[@luzmar1e]

my mom didnt let me watch it again bc she saw a “fan made” video of twilight n spike doing the yk.. so she thought the actual show was like that 😭

[@sundaystorms5171]

What the hell that’s actually messed up 😭

[@ahaahbahoo1821]

dude that's so sad

[@daelen.cclark]

That’s the problem with lots of the MLP fan-work, really.

[@BrozdoVSN]

Man, 11 years ago. Things sure have changed...

[@ElKabong3345]

Yeah, things were more simple and humble, it invited people to be creative like this. Now it's all Princesses and Castles.

[@fiafiaaaa]

Shining Armour LET'S FLY TO THE CASTLE!

[@anelson8498]

mlpLinky NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!!!!!! THE MEME IS BACK!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! *Morphs into dragon, flies away* SAVE YOURSELVES!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[@anelson8498]

Weedbrony okay then...

[@BetaJackMaxis]

Oh yeah now it's incest and crap.

[@darkandsweetfairy091]

I totally don't sing this when I cook....nope, totally don't

[@jessicamcmahon5307]

Who does. Not me. 0-0.....

[@tsuboshihatsune614]

Trust me... * i go under the counter grabbing a bowl and dough and i start to sing, i come back up , covered in flour,* * i then stand up holding up a dog* IT WAS THE DOG..

[@Voltorb1993]

I'd like to do that, but they don't sell any eyes of a newt in the local grocery store.

[@tsuboshihatsune614]

XD Or do they? DUN DUN DUN....

[@Playmobilfanatic123]

So.. You're making a portal?.. ... Okay.

[@souyo941]

I’m glad this is the legacy Jenny Nicholson left behind.

[@MsRabbitGi]

Now she makes some amazing video essays! ❤

[@KalijahAnderson]

I'm still curious how this would have turned out if this series continued. I would have loved to see Pinkie's song about actually getting back home.

[@S0m3B0z0OnTheInternet]

This isn’t from the show if that’s what you’re implying lol.

[@KalijahAnderson]

@@S0m3B0z0OnTheInternet I know that, it's Friendship is Witchcraft. But they got a C&D from Hasbro.

[@pokevenom314]

Well, Pinkie did end up being reunited with her parents, but she was stuck with taking care of them as babies in the present day. So there didn't end up being a home for her to return to

[@ouryuu69]

HOW DID I EVEN GET TO THIS SIDE OF KZbin. I'M NOT EVEN PART OF THIS FANDOM AND I LOVE THIS.

[@polytimeInduction]

Mr. Mayor!

[@ouryuu69]

*looks up from eating a cookie* yes?

[@ouryuu69]

I guess so...

[@grahamehearnshaw2525]

Democracy Cookie you know so :)

[@ouryuu69]

I guess as my friend says, Pinkie is love, Pinkie is life? Idk. I'm not part of this fandom.

[@sairusexplains8186]

When you think about it, pinkie has no choice then to hide behind a mask of happiness. Her parents gave up on her and when she looked for them, they died. Her sister never cared about her. She was abandoned and misstreated. She is closing of her self from everypony because with out her mask, she fells vulnerable. Idk just thought I'd share

[@benwetzel8449]

I’ve never even seen this show, or any of what it’s fandom has created, but the melody of this song now lives rent free in my brain and I can’t stop whistling it. Someone help. I think I’m going insane.

[@isisseger7320]

Watch the show now. *starts crying*

[@VocaloidPog]

This isn't from MLP it's from fiw (friendship is witchcraft)

[@The-being.0]

Bro I love this song so much for absolutely no reason 😭

[@MiaTheS1llyGooser]

SAMEE🙃

[@princessaur]

Dude this shit is 6 years old today oh my god my life has passed by so fast.

[@Lasagna_420]

dude it’s been 9 years now :((

[@Maczcheese]

@@Lasagna_420 yeah :( almost a decade

[@tsuki9423]

still here.

[@Maczcheese]

@@tsuki9423 yeah

[@lolineedhelp5818]

aaaa

[@cloudypine3683]

"Eye of newt and cinnamon" This lady is legit putting cinnamon and mustard together- *Cursed ingredients*

[@coastalcapybara]

That's Pinkie For ya!

[@tacobaco1404]

its 8 something am and im baked af and this is putting me in my feels

[@tacobaco1404]

thanks pinkie ig

[@barrysteakfriessimp_real]

hehe, _baked..._

[@kenny_ki]

the fact this says 10 years ago genuinely makes me emotional

[@tazoolnynx3947]

This song is a classic from the early days of the Brony fandom.

[@Stormrider019]

You know something, I like this song, it makes me feel sympathy for pinkie pie.

[@chaosdragon0125]

+MidnightStorm022 dude i been waiting for you all day

[@elizabethmiller8808]

would you believe me if I told you I only found this in 2019 on a midnight nostalgia trip and started crying in the middle of the night over it?

[@Jerebee-DS]

The only real way.

[@Maczcheese]

Yeah, its now 2021 and happened to me :(

[@pumpkinbrideinfraya984]

me too

[@Auragaming1642]

Yep.

[@stinkyfriesz]

Just...nostalgic... I was thinking this was just a *burning memory*

[@ramenisyummy6498]

I can’t tell if you’re mentioning the song, or if you’re messing with me directly as I just listened to the whole collection and I’m tripping and freaked out

[@stinkyfriesz]

@@ramenisyummy6498 I just wanted to mention the nostalgia of the song, I know what it's about.

[@ramenisyummy6498]

@@stinkyfriesz ah okay

[@Moonimii]

Fell out of the fandom a few years ago. Still come back to this song every once and awhile, because its a bop

[@theawesomekitten6057]

If this were a canon: I'll cook up a solution with the knowledge I've accrued. They say a kitchen time saves nine, but I'm just saving two. I've gathered the ingrediants to make some tasty cake (yes all I could come up with) There's hardly room for seconds when I'm baking them away! (that sounds terrifying) Watch as I work my baking magic! Eggs and flower, cinnamon! Watch as the batter turns to matter! Making a cake, dig in! We'll cook food! Do you like it, Apple Bloom? Sometimes life is not a cake walk served up on a silver spoon Toss the dough and save the cake and Chocolate sprinkles, stir the wrinkles, marination, great creation! Vanilla icing, cake piece slicing, yeast is rising, (Apple Bloom gets shocked by oven X3) E-E-ELECTRYIIIING! Apple bloom from a radio: Pinkie, if your hearing this, it means I have ran off. Please don't bake a birthday cake, accept it and move on. My oven is preheated, and I've baked it for the foal. I'll make this click, *sneak in a lick* and make this all work full! *To be continued in a reply that I make*

[@theawesomekitten6057]

Watch as I work my baking magic! Extra sugar, milk of cow! Celestia, bless this birthday today! Today, we're gonna be full! Today we're gonna be full!

[@POPZ1KLE]

I’m shook

[@laylas]

wait omg- your saying that you dont work for mlp-

[@astridspacecadet7973]

This is perfect-

[@Skye1421]

I think instead of "do you like it apple bloom?" I think it would be "do you feel it, Apple bloom?"

[@easygoing9328]

This was 5 years ago!!

[@thepinkone6932]

ikr, such memories

[@Rage_WinterchiIl]

gaaaah don't remind me!

[@Wadacup]

Oh my god that makes me feel ancient...

[@thepinkone6932]

***** Just wait until we are like 70 and rewatching these videos

[@Wadacup]

The Pink One Baaack in my day you were weird for liking crayon colored ponies. Now people are genetically engineering ponies to look like them and naming their children Rainbow Dash.

[@gregonmyheffley]

this is unironically on my main playlist dude it’s so good😭😭😭😭

[@bodokodo7589]

Under pressure

[@Darkest_Hour]

Anyone else notice that little sigh at the last second of the video (a few seconds or so after she repeats the line "Some day I'm gonna go home") It's kinda quiet though...

[@noamsilas7408]

Darkest_Hour OH THATS SAD

[@Miskamouskamikumouse]

Same

[@jamesmcqueary6233]

This hurts on several different levels. But I would never say it's cringey. I miss you all guys, so much.

[@jikoriri3656]

We are still here, old friend

[@jamesmcqueary6233]

@@jikoriri3656 I suppose I'm still here with you! Bro-hoof //////////0

[@carrott.]

yep.

[@ponsedapony4923]

me too anon

[@donutsandgravy3150]

@@jamesmcqueary6233 bro hoof!

[@hisokamorow7053]

Still trying to find out if this is a dark song or wholesome....

[@alittlemisfortunate]

Both lol

[@BleachTea3]

well its about pinkie using witchcraft to go back in time and prevent her parents death, so take that as you will

[@NOno-vs8ol]

Hisoka is also a brony

[@therealslimshawty1854]

A dark song trying it's best to SOUND wholesome

[@totodile987]

100% dark

[@RedButterfly1022]

Damn I was so ungrateful when I first heard this masterpiece on the internet. This is still pure GOLD, and I wish I listened to this more when I first heard it.

[@nerdymemer5792]

That moment when its almost 2017 and you still listen to the song

[@aaronrice782]

Mex Curry same

[@uniflysve6520]

Derpy Vampire that moment when it's 2017 and you're still listening to this song. happy new year!

[@nerdymemer5792]

Unifly Sve Same lol

[@TylerStPeter-su5zn]

When its 2017 and you finally learn about friendship is witchcraft

[@aboyce6293]

Tyler St. Peter Same!

[@diamondwarrior2003]

so this is the funky song made while counting down the days from season 1 to season 2

[@inkySaccharine]

I see what ya' did there........ (JanAnimations refrence)

[@diamondwarrior2003]

Joseph Nathan yeah, it's a shame hasbro pulled the plug on him

[@inkySaccharine]

blusgaming picks No they haven't, Jan has made 2 new PMVs in the last 4 months so I'm pretty sure they have not!

[@diamondwarrior2003]

Joseph Nathan then probably haven't heard about the very recent C&D that he got

[@bekw4366]

yes and i think i know what vid you are talkin about. is it lets go meet the bronies? I LOVE THAT VIDEO!

[@tsumugishirogane6398]

I love this song so so so much-

[@toxic-if6ey]

OKAY BUT SAME 😩

[@miilk.]

SAME LOL

[@lovelyLuke0824]

1:32 my fav part

[@fluffywinter1121]

Whoever writes some of the music for Friendship is Witchcraft, they've got some genius going on...

[@SerreNameless]

It’s amazing how this song sticks with you. I suddenly hummed this today at work and man the memories came back.

[@alyssastanley5992]

I’m obsessed with this song. I don’t care that I am 21 I will always have a special place in my heart for Pinkie Pie!!

[@vanui]

did u watch cupcakes and smile hd

[@curiousconflict]

Fun fact with the line 'Sometimes life is not a cake walk served up on a silver spoon' Silver spoon was voiced by Shannon Chan-Kent, who is also the singing voice for Pinkie in the actual show. Probably not even intended, but fun little added meaning nonetheless.

[@jogiacbaldiandstuff9056]

If you think about it, Pinkie Pie made a whole beat in a song by her parents voice crack mid-recording

[@catalinaargyriou8603]

and also would she have known that a portal could be baked if her parents didnt say "please dont bake a portal"?

[@Anticsofaclown]

GET OUT OF MY HEAD YOU AWESOME SONG.

[@the.sleepy.rat_]

I remember watching this as a kid ahhh what being introduced to the internet at a early age does to you

[@comradeboi3197]

man everytime i think about FiW i feel bad cause it ended, omg there would be so many amazing episodes from the later seasons. Pinkie meeting her family, starlight being a cult leader/dictator time traveler, the school of friendship, twili ACTUALLY becoming a princess, the smooze, omg so many hilarious stuff we'll never get to see

[@elsamariatheshadowwitch5217]

NOSTALGIAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA

[@victoriageorge3459]

+Elsa Maria the Shadow Witch ATACAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA

[@elsamariatheshadowwitch5217]

X'D

[@hewyzer9704]

Elsa Maria the Shadow Witch de que?

[@fluffiu]

N O S T O L G I O AAAAAAAA

[@moaPro]

MORE NOSTALGIAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA

[@christophermackay9192]

How To Create A Portal In Time: Pre-Heat Cauldron Gather Ingredients To Make Time Sorbet (Vanilla Sorbet, And A Watch) Add 1 Eye, Newt Add 2 Tsp Cinnamon Add Frearful Crude Stew (Boil Bone In Water, 5 Mins. Add Scary Yells) Add 1 Cup Sliced Apple Add 1 Blooming Flower Petal Add Road Cake (1 Egg, 3 Cups Flour, 5 Cups Rocky Road Ice Cream, Bake For 25 Mins.) Add 1 Fig Add 1 Date Add 3 Slice Bread Add 2 Tbsp. Butter Add Marination Sauce, 1 Tsp. Add 1 Cup Chocolate Icing Add Rising Yeast Add 4 Eggs Add Time Sorbet Beat Thoroughly Bake 4th Wall (1 Cup Water,1 Tsp. Sugar, 3 Cups Flour, 1 Egg, Bake 30 Mins.) Blend 4th Wall Add 1 Tbsp. Horse Tears Mixed With 1 Tsp. Water Add 2 Slices Provolone Add 4th Wall Mixture Mix Quickly For 5 Mins. Boil In Cauldron 14 Mins. Put In Baking Dish Bake For 1 Hour Take Out Cool For 10 Mins. Open Portal Jump In

[@ghostein.stereo]

+Hannah Smith Lol saaame tbh X'D

[@gardenspiritxell6941]

+Christopher MacKay Ish.... I burn my portal Q-Q

[@royalpariah6428]

thank you, my portal turned out perfectly. although i may have caused a paradox because there are two of me now?

[@amourexpenguin8227]

+Christopher MacKay I wonder who actually tried this XD

[@secondstar4987]

+Helen T (VocallegraHelen) OMG paradox there are two!!!

[@kronehaze]

Comments got turned on just as I look this up again!??????

[@bgbrnbd]

I never really watched this when it came out but I’ve been going through some of the more common FiW stuff recently just to experience it. Jenny Nicholson said she packed this series with references to Disney’s adaptation of Hunchback of Notre Dame. The references are in the littlest places! It’s a completely random subject to incorporate into the plot but every Hunchback reference does make me crack up.

[@composerdavidgiannivaldez367]

I remember being a kid and trying to find this song in MLP, I never realized it was a parody and was sad when the show never did this song lmao, now it's been eleven years and I've just found out that the person I subscribed to back in 2020 making videos about fandoms, sung this song and all those still give me so much nostalgia. It's crazy because I knew her voice from somewhere. Just to find out I fell in love with her singing 11 years ago I got so teary eyed from weird happiness damn these songs are nostalgic 😭

[@silverspawn8017]

god the nostalgia is almost making me cry right now

[@phoenixnoob7928]

U alive?

[@camrynbrewer2370]

Unpopular opinion: I still love this fandom. Sure, it’s not the same as it was back in 2011-13, and a lot of people have left, but a lot of great people have stayed, too. There are still many of us who have stuck with it since the beginning (or since we started watching) and are still dedicated. The ones who are still here are very tight-knit, and there are still people making awesome fan projects. I agree that the show was a little iffy in seasons 6 and 7, but I believe 8 was a bit better, and now that we’re in I last season, I feel that it’s gonna go out with a bang. Even long after the show has ended, the fandom will still be here. And who knows, maybe G5 will be even better (though I kinda doubt it, lol).

[@Loganberrybunny]

I don't think it's that unpopular an opinion. I've been here since 2012 (in the fandom, not literally in these comments :D ) and like you say, the people who are still around are often those who really, really like MLP. Many of those who were in it for the lulz'n'memes drifted away years ago. I actually liked S7 quite a bit, but that's personal opinion of course. S9 is seeming solid so far, I think. :)

[@camrynbrewer2370]

Now that I’ve gone back and watched it again, I think S7 is actually better than 8 (6 is still a mixed bag, though).

[@Loganberrybunny]

@@camrynbrewer2370 For me, the last four seasons are pretty easy to rank: 5 > 7 > 8 > 6. They all had episodes I liked and others I disliked, of course.

[@sanchoys_914]

Hearing this song after 11 years again... I dont know how to describe my feelings... After hundreds hours i spend on Forums, Watching mlp and listening to mlp songs... After all of that... Im crying outta nostalgia. What a good times

[@chrisvisser-fee2631]

"Save the date and..." THREE WAY PUN!!!! Holy SHIT!

[@kylerhoag3550]

1. Save the day 2. Save the date (time) 3. Save the date (fruit)

[@makaron369]

pun implies that one phrase has has multiple meanings, so at most this is a two way pun. But yes it very clever and good on you for noticing that.

[@pones2419]

_I'll cook up a bad OC with they knowledge I've accrued_ _The say a rain-bow remake saves 9, but I'm just killing two! (eyes)_ _I've gathered the ingredients to make some OP-ness,_ _There's hardly room for goods ones with so many hybrids!_ _Watch as I work my Gypsy magic_ _A bottle of eyeburn, alicorn wi-ings_ _Watch as the batter turns to matter_ _Oh gawd, my eyes really sting_ _The OC's abloom,_ _Do you fear them Scootaloo?_ _Sometimes life is not Earth Ponies_ _Served up on a Canon spoon!_ _Toss the eye cream and_ _Save my death date and_ _Sparkles & rainbows, Changling leggings,_ _Mind reading, Snowdrop blindness,_ _Stolen CMs, recolorings,_ _Canon relationships, evil alicorns,_ *_Children, if your hearing this,_* *_It means the Earth Ponies are gone,_* *_Please don't try again_* *_The good OCs are gone!_* _The caldron is ready and I have all the neons,_ _Lets abuse the bases and make art worse than 4 year olds using crayons!_ _Watch as I work my Gypsy magic_ _A bottle of eyeburn, alicorn wi-ings_ _Gawd help the recolors with their neon_ _Someday, I'll murder them all._ _Someday, I'll murder them, alllll._

[@mariabeilschmidt6505]

*loud clapping* Pure genius

[@pones2419]

xD Thank you.

[@pones2419]

Hurhurhurhurhur. Hur.

[@murky8268]

I r8 8/8 m8 no h8. I cri everytime

[@pones2419]

I made one for "How AJ Won The War." e3e

[@aidanokeeffe7928]

I still come back to this and the Gypsy Bard. When I listen to this, I feel a mix of melancholy, nostalgia, and blunted cringe all that's left of which is a warm chuckle

[@Dash_o05e]

“It’s from the show” ahh yes Pinkie singing abt bringing her dead parents to life by black magic was my fav episode 🔥✨

[@jesskennedy5966]

my fav part is Pinkies mum and dad saying "pinkie if your hearing this it means were dead and gone please dont bake a portal just accept it and move on!.." i just.. i just love it XD

[@gageemion2549]

I like when she says "do you fear it applebloom" Good reference

[@gageemion2549]

Well do you you need to answer

[@gageemion2549]

Hahahahahahahhahahahah xD i love vinyl scratch

[@gageemion2549]

Wub Wub Wub

[@gageemion2549]

A Duba Dub Dub

[@Montesama314]

I love that one line in the lyrics isn't just a pun, its season-wide foreshadowing.

[@avacadotoast5571]

1:06 is my favorite part

[@Delulu_Lulu-k3e]

Omg yes

[@RoseChloeEmberlynn]

God I miss the golden days of the fandom and just listening to brony music and watching new episodes. I wish I could go back and experience all this again.

[@offbrandfiji6487]

then just bake a portal

[@RoseChloeEmberlynn]

@@offbrandfiji6487 lol

[@EEEEEEE36364]

@@offbrandfiji6487 If only it were that easy, wouldn’t that be cool?

[@offbrandfiji6487]

@@EEEEEEE36364 tell me when someone does it

[@ridgeracer7136]

Oh did the comments section get unlocked?

[@MyStarCat468]

First one to say

[@bionicdragon5]

Has it been 7 years already? Feels like only yesterday, I was watching this in high school. Time's weird, isn't it?

[@IheartVanny]

Looking back at this after like 11 years I miss this I used to sing it so many times back then

[@PaintedCryptid]

Still... still coming back to this. I've have this song stuck in my head after years of not hearing it. And suddenly I thought about it and it hasn't been more than a day or two I go without listening to it in my playlist... that and Bard.

[@liamjochum5930]

you love the song, then you here the ending, and go, wait, WHAT! Some day i'm gonna go home.

[@liamjochum5930]

it's all upbeat, and then, the ending is all sad.

[@once4lyfe492]

Spazz Dino Omg I know. I meant I don't get why they made it sad at the end...

[@crestofreliability5958]

Sad for the ponies, not sad for us, Pinkie would be in our world then. Wouldn't that be great?

[@mayoayase]

crestofreliability then nobody would be sad xD

[@ThePhantombrian]

crestofreliability What? You can feel sad for something that isn't real...

[@kirb2697]

listen im not a mlp fan but mlp fanmade songs always hit hard

[@MrRoblox1377]

This was during a bad part of my life. This fandom got me through it. This fandom was really something. I left after season 4 but my good God were you guys the best.

[@d1n0gorawr]

9 years ago I found this and it got stuck in my head now I’m going into professional voice acting lmao

[@Lamamsl]

Goodluck with your VAing! You'll do great I bet

[@Mypimi707]

10 months late... oh well, I bet you'll be a great VA!

[@owen1228]

I know nothing about friendship is witchcraft and very little about my little pony itself, yet I've fallen in love with this song and have listened to it on repeat for these past few weeks!

[@Theholidaygirl1225]

GRIFFINILA WORKED ON GTHIS!?!? I LOVE IT EVEN MORE NOW

[@raulgonzalez3314]

Crude stew do you fear it Apple bloom? sometimes life is not a cake walk served up on a silver spoon,Toss a fig and save the date and make,bread and butter, chant and mutter,marination incantation chocolate I ring,timeline splicing,yeast is rising,rectifying

[@RaulGonzalez-zo4ou]

0:54 to 1:13 :)

[@thezaineframe1857]

To this day I can't cook anything without first opening the portal and jumping in. Really adds spice to any recipe!