Pixar Shorts Tier List

[@DHynes5]

Day and Night is easily S Tier for me! Pure creativity and hilarity the whole way through

[@cintronproductions9430]

Piper is easily S tier for its extreme cuteness. 😍🐣🐦

[@jZ0357]

That in IMAX was amazing

[@annabrown3337]

Agreed

[@tantris2876]

Exactly

[@carolrickroll767]

It’s so CUTE!!!🥺🥺

[@Eeveeismypatronas]

When I re-watched it, for some reason it made me cry. Probably the music or the cuteness of it. 😢

[@arenjtumastens]

Never really ranked all these Pixar Shorts myself. But my favorite has always been "Geri's Game." It was the first one I saw.

[@Drace90]

Brian: "Blue Umbrella. Don't like it. Too romancy. Don't like romances. D-Tier!" Literally one second later: "LAVAAAA! Love it! Love the romance song! A-Tier!!!" #JusticeForTheBlueUmbrella XD

[@jillevers1432]

I stand by you statement 💞

[@Cali_Pops]

Lmao

[@kaitlyn8515]

Seriously 😂

[@jeancarlomartinez835]

Brian you’re Lazy

[@jonathanvo7991]

@@brianhullsvoice DO YOU UNDERSTAND ME HUH HUH

[@meggypeggy9142]

Bao is my all-time favorite. It tells such a universal story. I was 15 or 16 when I saw it in theatres but it made me cry so much. I have such a close relationship with my mom and knowing that someday she will go through something like this was eye-opening and touching. I also love these kinds of shorts where we are immersed in a culture. I watch it all the time, its just wonderful.

[@StarFoxette]

Bao is my favorite too! The allegory was brilliant, and for me it's the only short that goes through such an emotional rollercoaster in only 8 minutes and without any dialogue, much like the beginning of Up.

[@Eeveeismypatronas]

The ending of that short film left me speechless & on the verge of fainting. WTF?

[@petros6013]

The Red and Blue Umbrella is my favorite. Though, there are so many that are good, it’s hard to choose.

[@DavidRay_40]

It's just called "The Blue Umbrella". No "red" in the title.

[@Eeveeismypatronas]

​@@DavidRay_40 I see you a lot on Brian's videos.

[@dustyhughes1049]

I love Knack nack and it’s cute also love Bobby McFerrin song in it “Don’t Worry be Happy”

[@myjourneywithjackson2982]

Thank you for putting For The Birds on the S tier as that is the first Pixar short I ever remember seeing. And yes, Lava is soooooo catchy. My husband is so tired of me singing it all the time.

[@fanofyoshi2238]

14:23 True. It warmed the cockles of my tiny black heart, Piper was really heartwarming.

[@Eeveeismypatronas]

It's ADORABLE, isn't it? If Piper was a pet bird, I would adopt *them* (Pixar Wiki says female because of predominantly feminine name, but the description of the video says it's a male) HANDS DOWN!!!

[@StudioLindsay]

Bao is my favorite short. I always cry when the characters cry. But the first time I watched it, that part you referenced was quite shocking.

[@xandred_bass1011]

I'm glad I'm not the only one who is afraid of the baby in tin toy Also I went and watched Mr Incredible and Pals after this. (I also watched the commentary) and I'd just like to say, I have never seen anything so terrible but so amazing!

[@bigheadrat9493]

Hey at least it doesn't make you want a young character in a entertainment thing dead

[@funnifrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrameesss]

@@bigheadrat9493OMG it’s brain

[@funnifrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrameesss]

@@bigheadrat9493what are we going to do tonight

[@bigheadrat9493]

@@funnifrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrameesss the same thing we do every night, try to take over the world!

[@funnifrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrameesss]

@@bigheadrat9493 that was quick

[@berjo516]

I’d switch Lava and Blue Umbrella in a heartbeat

[@antoniomarin9061]

I agree with you about the baby in Tin Toy being creepy because it reminds of the baby spider toy in Toy Story which almost gave me nightmares when I first watched Toy Story😴😧

[@Eeveeismypatronas]

Hell yeah. Only Baby Face (the spider baby) is cuter than that baby.

[@grayduck1904]

My personal favorite Pixar short is Geri's Game. I just loved the concept and I was thoroughly entertained by it.

[@cavaliers60]

The Blue Umbrella is a work of art! It deserves S tier status! 😁

[@angryb0325]

12:54 I have that song stuck in my head right now

[@xArcade_]

My top 2 will always be One Man Band and Presto (interchangable). My mom even made me a Pixar cake once for my birthday and included my favorite shorts and full length film on it. Still my favorite cake to this day.

[@kimbarbeaureads]

Partly cloudly is my fave. I remember buying UP because I found myself standing in Walmart staring at a big screen like an idiot giggling about the cloud's reaction. For the Birds is second

[@masonharris9403]

I love Lava because my friend in 6th grade loved it and would always want to play it in music class. He died that year and it’s my favorite because of him.

[@Eeveeismypatronas]

Sorry for the loss of your friend.

[@weirdproq]

I love Geri's Game, and the fact that he kinda makes a cameo in Toy Story 2 blew my mind when I found that out.

[@EDMYuki]

Kitbull made me cry so much because I myself have a soft spot for pitbulls growing up with them nearly all my life. The message was so strong too.

[@alphanightfury97]

When are we going to get tier list for DreamWorks movies?

[@trainboy48]

I’ve been wondering that too, there are a lot of Dreamworks films to cover up and this a perfect time for him to do so. We got the latest film that came out this year Boss Baby 2.

[@antoniomarin9061]

He should also do a tier list for live action Disney movies

[@maliszam2954]

The Mr Incredible and Pals was my favorite thing on the Incredibles bonus DVD along with all the hero bios!!! 🙂 Good times...

[@justanerdyhobbitgirl]

My list would be pretty similar I think other than the blue umbrella :) I always pictured geri just having fun all by himself; I never thought he could be going crazy yikes I loved the editing on this! It made me laugh. Also the song in your friend the rat always cracks me up. It's just my kind of humor I guess XD

[@jillevers1432]

Blue Umbrella was my favorite. I get into the romance stories so yeah, be in my top favorite shorts

[@chrissyr8387]

5:49 - 6:23 I just watched both. AND IT IS SO GOOD. The commentary was so funny I started to laugh cry. Y'ALL GOTTA WATCH IT!!!

[@ItsSpudNick]

Bounding is the best short, it was my childhood

[@Eeveeismypatronas]

That's one of my friend's favorite shorts, too!

[@marissaromero8417]

I just watched Mr. Incredible and Pals (both the original and the commentary), and I agree, the commentary is way better. It was so funny and had me laughing so hard, specially with Samul L. Jackson's commentary of his character and the rabbit!! 😂😂

[@Eeveeismypatronas]

14:19 I watched Piper for the first time since it came out in theaters with Finding Dory, & believe me when I say IT WAS SO FREAKING CUTE THAT I BAWLED MY EYES OUT!

[@acdragonrider]

Bao is my favorite

[@FormalFilmsProductions]

Mike’s new car is my favorite. It never fails to make me laugh out loud

[@Raquel96]

The connection between La Luna & Luca, oh my gosh !!! AH I didn't notice that, but you're SO right wow

[@Eeveeismypatronas]

It makes sense, since they're both Italian Pixar stories.

[@protog2663]

@@Eeveeismypatronas it also makes sense because they were made by the same director.

[@Eeveeismypatronas]

2:59 Hell yeah. 😬

[@arenjtumastens]

Some of these shorts I never knew existed until now. And some others I only heard of, but haven't watched yet. The other others I've actually watched.

[@bc6399]

Hey Brian! I have to be honest. I haven’t watched many of the Pixar shorts yet, but I love your tier list videos! You got me curious about Mr. Incredible and Pals. I was having a hard evening, but listening to you laughing hysterically over the commentary was contagious, and I started laughing too. I’m curious about it now. I’m gonna have to watch it! I have Disney Plus!

[@JPMario]

I remember my first time watching tin toy when I was a kid and never liked it because of that baby. He was just too scary for me

[@Eeveeismypatronas]

Same.

[@melanieaburto1]

I love Geri’s game it is so funny 😂 and hilarious 🤣🤣 because he was playing against himself and then losing and then winning literally I almost died of laughter. Hehehe 🤭

[@breeneal2843]

Piper, Knick knack, and Jack Jack attack will be my top three for a long time!

[@dragondavidisawesome]

You should rank all the Disney Toon movies

[@iansweeney9953]

I agree with you on Tin Toy.

[@Eeveeismypatronas]

Same! 😬😩😫😣😖 That baby's face is TERRIFYING!

[@JoseCastro-rd3tb]

My favorite shorts are for the birds and Mike's new car

[@spykidtalksaboutanything4395]

I am really salty lots of people miss the short "Feast" I loved it from beginning to end

[@thebombminecart7541]

Feast isn't actually pixar. I looked it up, and it was created by Walt Disney animation.

[@TheOldandslow]

Yay Pixar Shorts! Luxo Junior and beyond!

[@Eeveeismypatronas]

17:29 XD The one with "What? No!" was HYSTERICAL!

[@thebookbunnypodcast818]

Do you think you could do a Tier List of all the Marvel and/or the Direct to DVD Disney sequels?

[@Greykmusic]

I was wondering if you would ever do a Dreamworks Tier List?

[@coltonstube4u898]

Hey Brian! U are my favorite KZbinr ever! When I’m down I always come to u and u never fail to put a smile of my face , my my dog and great grandmother passed away I watched u and I felt happy so thank u so much! Plus next tier list should be The live action disney movies maybe, u will always be my fav! From colton

[@benitahiestermann1186]

My favourite Pixar shorts are 1.La Luna (My favourite!!) 2.Day and Night 3.Knick Knack 4.Partly Cloudy 5.Lava 6Piper

[@Eeveeismypatronas]

It's satisfying to see that tiers A, B, & C have the same amount of shorts to the point where they all meet up at the same place.

[@TheOldandslow]

Oh La Luna is amazing.

[@mmanimates1550]

personally, your friend the rat is my favorite pixar short, but then again i also love ratatouille so..... yeah, but yeah i pretty much agree with the rest of this except for the maters tall tales

[@thebombminecart7541]

I personally think that Kitbull should have been separated from sparkshorts. The message and the story of it made it one of my favorite pixar shorts along with Bao. Yes, it was sad, but it was such a heartwarming story to the point that it could have been an entire movie if they tried.

[@ellebastonart]

Brian: OKAY HERE'S A SHORT I'M SURE MOST PEOPLE HAVE NO IDEA EXISTS! Me: Oooh okay, there's something new for me to check out~ Brian: This is Mr. Incredible and Pals! Me: OH MY GOD YES I LOVE THAT SHORT (seriously I watched that short and all the bonus features from The Incredibles 1 over and over again as a kid and to this day I still have quotes from the commentary randomly stuck in my head on a very frequent basis)

[@bromodragone8405]

Hell Yes!

[@helston27]

I got Monsters Inc on VHS for my 7th birthday (my sister turned one on it’s release) and I have VIVID memories of watching For the Birds with my dad and uncle cracking up. So many memories with both the movie and the short!

[@Lexi69]

I love the forky asks questions those ones r my favorites

[@snippyhera]

This is such a fun idea! My childhood favorite short has always been, Piper. 💖✌

[@TheOldandslow]

It makes me cry every time! The short Birds makes me laugh!

[@QueenSiren4Life]

Hey Brian, I know that you used to play in Fiddler on the Roof. VoicePlay just posted an accepella cover of If I Were A Rich Man. I remember you had a hard time passing on it from your try not to sing challenge 2. I think you will love it!!!!!

[@Eeveeismypatronas]

I was in a Fiddler On The Roof play. I was one of the villagers.

[@shoomps2527]

The lava song has been stuck in my head for decades

[@Scp-001-Scarlet-King]

Hey Brian when will you do Dreamworks teir list please?

[@dragondavidisawesome]

Knick and Knack and Gerri’s Game will always be my favs

[@firelight3653]

Boundin is like one of my favorite shorts because it has a very catchy song and a good relationship with a jack rabbit and a sheep

[@Safariahmari1119]

Another tier you should make is ranking every veggietales episode.

[@franniewaffles6093]

Is tmr the drop of hotel Transylvania 4?

[@Safariahmari1119]

Hey Brian, you should rank DreamWorks animation films.

[@sarahalanastokes]

Your wish has come true

[@joeyglusky4774]

How about doing a tier list for Walt Disney Animation short films next?

[@goldenlightpictures6223]

Yeah I knew that Incredibles short existed I remember watching it on my Incredibles DVD “Did you okay the rabbit?” “I had nothing to do with the rabbit!” 😆

[@Robert-se9jf]

You were my childhood wow

[@jackscull]

I love pixar shorts

[@Missy_394]

Yay! Another tier list!

[@monkeybrain0212]

What about Paperman? That's my favourite short but is it not regarded as Pixar?

[@monkeybrain0212]

@@brianhullsvoice oh wow thanks for replying! Great to talk to you! :D I seeeeee I understand!

[@DavidRay_40]

Piper is my favorite Pixar short. I am ASTOUNDED you didn't put it in the S tier. It's just so cute!

[@elijahbertuola1564]

Omg Brian forky ask a question is the best one here

[@twentytwoaviators]

You’re awesome Brian!!! I watched ur vids since let it go! You’re awesome!

[@kevingreen5793]

Knick Knack is my favorite defiantly deserves to be in S tier!

[@Projectbadadaee]

My childhood

[@stevenderftuscano2484]

Do next Disney Direct-to-Video Tier list!!!!

[@Eeveeismypatronas]

16:38 Yep. I legit covered my eyes when I got to that part re-watching it on Disney +.

[@evoxrr11]

F in the chat for ms fritter

[@matthewjestus7009]

Boundin' is one of the most pixar style shorts that they have in my opinion I can forgive you this time all jokes aside nice video

[@autobot793]

I've actually seen Mr. Incredible and Pals! That one was funny!

[@DHynes5]

The commentary with Mr Incredible and Frozone made it funnier

[@Eeveeismypatronas]

16:50 you're not alone. I nearly fainted when I saw it in the theater.

[@meredithkeen6094]

what about "Us Again" and the one where the guy lives life and he wants to do one thing but his brain what's to do a different thing?

[@benjamingk567]

I really like it when you're doing tier videos!

[@Eeveeismypatronas]

I just noticed that 3/4ths of the shorts in D-tier have dark backgrounds. The Cars shorts are the only one that stands out.

[@ReidTheNintendoPainter]

16:35 YES! I know EXACTLY what you're talking about! I was very shocked and also kinda teared up a little when that happened in the short!

[@Eeveeismypatronas]

Yep, same...

[@JimmyHodge698]

Can you do Phineas and Ferb impressions of therefore I am by Billie elish

[@Eeveeismypatronas]

2:49 I'm gonna be honest, Brian. I've watched Red's Dream a lot & it's gotten to the point where I've become desensitized by the clown. Also, by your description when I first heard it, I thought you were referencing something related to the IT franchise. Specifically a kid riding a unicycle near the sewers on a rainy day & getting pulled down by Pennywise... I HIGHLY DOUBT that you've watched that movie, though.

[@jacobcoburn3269]

FINALLY somebody else knows about Mr. Incredible & Friends!! It is a true hidden gem and the commentary is priceless! PS Boundin is one of my favorites, along with Presto and Knick Knack. I would've put it in A.

[@goldennugget75]

The incredibles shorts are my favorites and I also love Presto.

[@willgary2]

You are one of my favorite KZbinrs and I love your content and have been watching you for so long

[@kaitlyn8515]

Great video but The Blue Umbrella was robbed. 💔🧐

[@ultimateneek530]

Will we see a DreamWorks Teir List in the future?

[@bigborris1661]

I honestly think they should do another short on Andrè and Wally B, But this time Theres a Plot

[@Eeveeismypatronas]

Or a full-length feature?

[@Eeveeismypatronas]

Am I the only one who was EXTREMELY disappointed to find out that Pixar stopped making short films? I was expecting one for Inside Out 2, but we didn't get one & I was CRUSHED.

[@yakotorres5098]

My favorite pixar short is tokyo mater or auntie edna. My least favorite short are the forky questions and your friend the rat

[@kyleswenson8815]

My Ap Lit class watched a couple Pixar Shorts for full blown essays, I think that says something about the story telling that we could pull full blown essays our very short segments Edit: La Luna and Luca are the same director which explains the visual similarity

[@Eeveeismypatronas]

Plus, they're both Italian Pixar.

[@Eeveeismypatronas]

2:59 💀: Amen to that, Brian. Even for ME (aka The Pumpkin King), that baby is just TOO TERRIFYING!

[@KaylaRCreates]

I was so STINKIN happy when you put Day and Night in the S tier because that’s my favorite Pixar Short!

[@gavinrice2246]

Maybe you should do a tier list of DreamWorks Animation films. If you are interested. 😁