Planet Dinosaur (2011) Accuracy Review PART 1| Dino Documentaries RANKED #20

The Planet Dinosaur review is finally here! This super popular dino documentary is seeing its day in court. How does it hold up scientifically?
Dinosaur Revolution: • Dinosaur Revolution (2...
Dinosaur Planet: • Dinosaur Planet (2003)...
Sources
Microraptor Color: www.smithsonianmag.com/scienc...
Microraptor Flight: www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/arti...
Onchopristis- woostergeologists.scotblogs.w...
Spino Diet- www.nature.com/articles/43003....
2022 Spino Paper- www.nature.com/articles/s4158...
2021 Spino Paper- palaeo-electronica.org/conten...
Venom- www.smithsonianmag.com/scienc...
Yi Qi- www.sci-news.com/paleontology/...
Facebook: / redraptorwrites
Patreon: www.patreon.com/redraptorwrit...
Instagram: / redraptorwrites

[@redraptorwrites6778]

I should mention, my Blue Snowball mic broke so I'm stuck using a lower quality one for the time being. Hope you enjoy regardless!

[@Spiny_21]

Are there going to be anymore accuracy dinosaur documentary reviews

[@pbh9195]

Can you do an episode on monsters we met?

[@redraptorwrites6778]

@@Spiny_21 Yes, definitely

[@redraptorwrites6778]

@@pbh9195 I'll look into it

[@mb_allo-3023]

FINALLY PLANET DINOSAUR

[@GTSE2005]

I swear, Spino will be the reason a time machine is gonna be invented. Someone would just need to see whatever the heck Spino was like in real life. Shows how mysterious prehistoric creatures were

[@ShinGhidorah17]

If a time machine is used, the people using it should NOT alter the future as bad things could happen.

[@stare4539]

Yea

[@chadgorosaurus4898]

You: pick up a rock from 1 billion years ago Future: *NEW SPECIES*

[@professionalidiot4987]

@@ShinGhidorah17 just existing somewhere you're not supposed to be at could change stuff. But the better output is an alternate timeline. Just the thought of these being a possibility makes science seems more fictional than magic.

[@seanmckelvey6618]

@@ShinGhidorah17 what if they create a BETTER future though?

[@the-radio-robot7731]

Herbivores when a carnivore sees them in a dino doc: "Guess I'll die."

[@alejandroelluxray5298]

Not in this case, the Edmontosaur repelled the troodontids and most of the Centrosaurus fended off the daspletosaurus, literally only 2 died because of the predators, more of them died because of the flood

[@andrewgan557]

In real life: herbivores especially big ones: so you chosen death.

[@maxrichards3881]

Stegosaurus stabbing Allosaurus with its Stagamizers says Hi!

[@parakeetbudgie]

they accept their death but run away a little bit just to make it look like they want to survive

[@catpoke9557]

@@parakeetbudgie I know it's a bit of a cliche to say it at this point but Prehistoric Planet struck the perfect balance in that regard. They made the pachyrhinosauruses terrified, but because they were fighters rather than runners, they actually held their ground for a very long time until a particularly stupid individual decided to run, breaking the formation and inciting panic. They managed to show that the animals were scared while also not making them seem like punching bags. Not only that but the one that died was a slow one, implying it was weaker than the others meaning that the others wouldn't inherently be sentenced to death. They managed to make them not the "Guess I'll die" situation, while also avoiding the 'awesomebro' attitude and invincible stature. They were fearful, and they could be killed, but they knew that they themselves were dangerous animals that could fend off or kill a nanuqsaurus if they were strong enough or smart enough. A perfect and realistic balance. It was beautifully done.

[@TheShuckmeister]

I actually did a report in college on the spectroscopy methods they use to determine pigments from fossils. It's a bit limited at the moment, only being accurate for some shades of blacks, blues, browns and reds, but still really cool nonetheless.

[@chadgaming7466]

Ayo shuck moment?

[@ShinGhidorah17]

You know what I personally think is a very underrated (or at least underappreciated) prehistoric animal? Deinotherium. I love that elephantine animal just as much as the mammoth. I love it’s unique appearance with it’s shorter trunk and it’s downward facing tusks hanging under its jaw.

[@TheSpeculativeDoodl]

I like the amebelodonts because of their funny weird faces

[@gergopiroska5749]

As a kid i always thought that it had buck tooth lmao

[@ShinGhidorah17]

@TheCrackEdFett mine too.

[@tyrannotherium7873]

I Heard that deinotherium It’s not a true elephant

[@erikhamann]

Where do you get from that they have a shorter trunk? How do you think are they drinking?

[@yeeters2347]

15:19 Literally said in that segment in the show, “Anywhere else, Rugops would dominate.” Meaning if it lived in any other Ecosystem, it would be the apex predator, but it has no need too with Spinosaurus and Char-Chars around

[@maxrichards3881]

Paul Serano has actually found concrete evidence of Rugops predation, so the “scavenger” level is still a lie.

[@Kor06.]

It doesn't matter rugops was never a scavenger

[@jeffreygao3956]

@@Kor06. Not never! What if it was hungry and found a dead Rugops in its path?

[@Kor06.]

@@jeffreygao3956 rugops scavenge in that case but isn't a scavenger

[@karenboy1005]

What I probably like the most about PD are the black and white segments when they discuss certain discoveries that prove what happens in the show. They could have gone the easy route and have some paleontologist talk about dinosaurs in front of some dusty bone for 5 minutes between each CGI segment like most other documentaries do, but they actually took a more interesting approach that still teaches you stuff without boring the fuck out of you.

[@alejandroelluxray5298]

Well Raptor, in defence of the Daspletosaurus and the troodontids: That tactic worked because they attacked either at night or at the dawn of the storm, using the darkness and the noise of the storm to hide themselves from the herbivores and causing chaos to split the herds and expose the weak. And Besides as the documentary shows that didn't exactly work that well since the edmontosaur managed to defend the calf the troodontids were after and most of the centrosaurus fended off the Daspletosaurus, with only 2 being killed by the tyrannosaurs And as for the "Last Killers" part, they Are refering to the non avian dinosaurs

[@Jadenette11111]

Thank you

[@iron2684]

Ye i feel that this review was pretty harsh

[@maxrichards3881]

That’s not what the producers made John Hurt say. Specify non-avian, or we have to take it as referring to ALL dinosaurs.

[@maxrichards3881]

@@iron2684 You clearly haven’t seen part 2, he gives it pretty fair B.

[@kennethsatria6607]

I assumed it meant more like the last of the large killer dinosaurs, cause lets face it carnivorous birds never reached that size again, the Abeliosaurs and tyrannosaurs were definitely the last and some of the greatest predatory dinosaurs.

[@TheSharkAnt]

Dinosaur documentaries have always seemingly implied that birds are not actually dinosaurs, but merely descendants of them, which is complete and utterly idiotic. It would be a lot like saying that horses are descended from mammals. Birds ARE and always have been dinosaurs!

[@klikssiikubra314]

It's not that strange. By this logic, literally every tetrapod is also a fish, but if I called a mosasaur or ichthyosaur a fish, I bet people would take issue with that.

[@TheSharkAnt]

@@klikssiikubra314 I don't think you understand what I'm saying. Sorry for the "late" response, I was busy with other things.

[@Ozraptor4]

@@klikssiikubra314 Not the same - there is a clade called "Dinosauria" of which modern birds (Aves) are a subclade. There is no such clade called "Fish" - fish being a paraphyletic grade that basically includes all vertebrates that are not tetrapods. Same sort of term as "invertebrate".

[@klikssiikubra314]

@@Ozraptor4 The point still stands in common parlance, which is where fish is used. But if you want a more clade-based example, technically speaking all tetrapods are also sarcopterygians yet it's very rare for anyone to refer to the majority of the group like that.

[@maxrichards3881]

@@klikssiikubra314 That doesn’t work because fish are a polyphyletic group, unlike Amniotes.

[@McChicken03]

I’m so excited for Prehistoric Planet! It actually looks accurate, but we’ll have to see

[@parakeetbudgie]

it is accurate

[@adammarch9604]

How can you or anyone know that?

[@wor575]

Will you review Prehistoric Planet when it comes out? Super hyped for that one

[@starzilla624]

This is a great review! I will defend these things though: The female Majunga was probably desperate for food, as the segment took place in a drought. Also, the male had threatened her baby. The Troodons did charge into the herd, yes, but the real sin would be if they were to attack an adult, which they didn't. I assume they were trying to break it up so they could target a juvenile, which they do.

[@heilmadon]

Have you ever seen a modern animal charge into a herd. Most herding animals wont jusT run away but will gang jump predators that size difference should mean that pack should Have lost a good chunk of its members.

[@starzilla624]

@@heilmadon It was at night, and moments before the narrator (bless John Hurt) had mentioned that Toodon had large eyes for nighttime hunting. Edmontos would've panicked if they couldn't see their assailants.

[@heilmadon]

@@starzilla624 Again Even if they were surprised a 4 metric ton dino is not going to be scared of a 50kg pack of light weights even the wolf versus moose have A closer body size comparison more around 10% body mass versus the 1% size difference. Not to mention there is no evidence for social behavior in troodons and much more likely they hunted alone for small dinos and mammals. This is part of the smart raptor bull since raptors were smart enough for packs then obviously troodons the big brain dino could which would probably have the brains of a chicken.

[@GTSE2005]

@@heilmadon Still though, despite how large edmontosaurus was compared to the troodonts, it would be terrifying to be fighting against enemies they can barely see

[@trolgeeeeee]

@@GTSE2005 specialy how little thay are

[@evantreffinger2009]

When Red Raptor said that the troodon made possibly the dumbest decision to run through the herd all I could think of was “The Nanotyranus decides to put its speed, against the might of an angry mother Tyrannosaurus” from JFC🤣

[@joshuacanales6419]

Finally I've waited for this for so long also I have a request I know it's not technically a dinosaur documentary they can't do an accuracy review on the future is wild and tell us how accurate it really is to predict the future animals compared to modern ones and has a formula similar to other documentaries and well it'd be nice to see you review on it in the future

[@LMS5935]

Planet dinosaurs was my second favorite dinosaur documentary when I was a kid so I’m glad you’re reviewing it

[@lucasgotardo4919]

What was the first?

[@LMS5935]

@@lucasgotardo4919 walking with dinosaurs

[@noahd.4551]

@@LMS5935 I'm not trying to put you down personally or anything, but I really don't get why people love this documentary so much. I looooved dino docs when I was a kid, and I did just about everything in my power to get my hands on as many dino docs as possible, but somehow I missed this one when I was younger. I recently watched it for the first time, and I have to say I was really disapointed. I really disliked the cg background, which made it feel much more like a low budget animated special than a proper recreation of prehistory. They reused the same sound effects for basically every dinosaur, and it's not subtile at all, litterally every large carnivore has the exact same sound. The same is true with every midsieze to large herbivore (excluding sauropods), every pterosaur, and every small dino. The dinosaurs moved very robotically (much more so than the very realistic and believable movements we got in the Walking With series, which was made by the same people, and is almost 11 years older), so as a result I never got that "wow these were actually what these animals were like" feeling that I got from some of the better dino docs from the early 2000s, and all the show ever focuses on is how preditors would've killed prey, which gets boring quickly, and makes all the episodes feel very repetitive. But worst of all by far is the camera movements. Whoever it was who sugested that the camera should always be chaotic, shaky, zooming in and out all the time, and moving around like crazy, should've been fired on the spot. The way the camera moved made the show borderline imposible to watch. The scene where the carcharodontosaurus fight is the worst offender. The camera is shaking like crazy, zooming in and out all the time, and is flying all over the place. The audience isn't given a single moment where the camera just sits still and we're permitted to see what the heck is actually happening in this fight. For me, Planet Dinosaur doen't even break into my top 10, let alone my top two.

[@funwithfish1507]

@@noahd.4551 I didn’t know you could still find it at all

[@noahd.4551]

@@funwithfish1507 it’s hard to get online without buying it, but I have a library card so I just rented the dvd from there.

[@rl9217]

18:44 Haast Eagle: “I’m the most powerful predatory bird that has ever existed!” Terror Birds: “No, we are!” Argentavis: (feathered screeching) Dodos: (has quietly committed multiple crimes) Mysterious voice in the background: “Pathetic…” All of them: “What was that, punk?” Rico, the only predatory bird that made his dinosaur ancestors proud: “PATHETIC!”

[@thisisnami6054]

The Bird flying was actually Pelagornis

[@joshuaW5621]

Remember me of a meme I saw regarding how the Oscars brushed off animation as for kids, The Simpsons and Futurama: “Did you forget we exist?!” Family Guy: “I’m the most adult cartoon out there.” South Park: “No I am!” Big Mouth: “Hold my beer!” Bob’s Burgers, American Dad, King of the Hill, Rick and Morty: “You still think otherwise?!” 9: “You calling us kid-friendly?” Sausage Party: “Surprise mothetf**kr!”

[@ShavayD]

This will always be my favorite documentary, despite the inaccuracies nowadays, this is an absolute masterpiece

[@jurassicarkjordanisgreat1778]

Finally! The long awaited time for spino to have a proper documentation about it! Love how this documentary has made it engraved in pelaeo culture that spino ate sawfish!

[@hectorgperez]

Omg even in paleo media The Slap makes an appereance (14:44), bless this review.

[@sppplycakes527]

I have a minor nitpick. When in the Troodon scene, The Edmontosaurus juveniles look a bit to much like the adults to me. I really liked the difference between the adult Edmontosaurus and the juveniles in March of the Dinosaurs. I really like that design. But the juveniles in Planet Dinosaurs look to much like the adults.

[@kevinnorwood8782]

Very interesting hearing about what Microraptor's color actually was, because I heard that a similar study was done for Archaeopteryx in around 2015. Growing up, when I saw images of Archaeopteryx, it was always portrayed as being very brightly colored and having a wide variety of colors as well, almost like a parrot. Well, this study blew that theory completely out of the water. It showed that Archaeopteryx was primarily black with some patches of grey or silver.

[@Joose_box475]

The planet dinosaur documentary series made up my childhood and even though some information is outdated its nice to look back on it. Keep up the good work on your videos.

[@Deform-2024]

I really want a modern documentary about the kem kem beds, it's criminal how poorly represented it is. There are so many huge carnivores that alone could make an entire series.

[@hekt0rh]

Great video series! Hope to have a video about Prehistoric Planet when it come out

[@gaminggator37]

I was once again about to turn myself in for not paying my taxes. But you posted again. Perfect timing.

[@LetsFullStack]

Your videos are so interesting. As a 25 year old dino fan since childhood. These videos are so refreshing and entertaining. Thank you

[@redraptorwrites6778]

Awesome! I'm glad you're enjoying them!

[@chubibi06]

Good job, yet again ! Unlike most, i supposed, i had mixed feelings about Planet Dinosaur ; and you managed to put words on those issues i had with it. Thank you for that. Also, will you review the dinosaur documentaries from Curiosity stream ? As well as older documentaries (such as Paleoworld) ?

[@thespinofamily7565]

This is by far my favorite dinosaur docco, ever since I was little. But I have a feeling it won’t stand a chance compared to David Attenborough’s Prehistoric Planet. It will stream on May 23 this year! You GOTTA do a review for it. Literally type up “ Prehistoric Planet- Official Teaser”.

[@noahd.4551]

Out of all the great dinosaur documentaries out there today, how on earth is Planet Dinosaur your favourite? Walking With Dinosaurs, When Dinosaurs Roamed America, Chased by Dinosaurs, Chased by Sea Montsers, Sea monsters: a Prehistoric Adventure, and Dinosaur Planet are just a few of the really good ones. I'm not trying to put you down personally or anything, but I really don't get why people love this documentary so much. I looooved dino docs when I was a kid, and I did just about everything in my power to get my hands on as many dino docs as possible, but somehow I missed this one when I was younger. I recently watched it for the first time, and I have to say I was really disapointed. I really disliked that they chose to use cg backgrounds instead of real ones, which made it feel much more like a low budget animated special than a proper recreation of prehistory. They reused the same sound effects for basically every dinosaur, and it's not subtile at all, litterally every large carnivore has the exact same sound. The same is true with every midsieze to large herbivore (excluding sauropods), every pterosaur, and every small dino. Which again makes it feel low budget or "cheap". The dinosaurs moved very robotically (much more so than the very realistic and believable movements we got in the Walking With series, which was made by the same people, and is more than 11 years older), so as a result I never got that "wow these were actually what these animals were like" feeling that I got from some of the better dino docs from the early 2000s, and all the show ever focuses on is how preditors would've killed prey, which gets boring quickly, and makes all the episodes feel very repetitive. But worst of all by far is the camera movements. Whoever it was at the studio who sugested that the camera should always be chaotic, shaky, zooming in and out all the time, and moving around like crazy, should've been fired on the spot. The way the camera moved made the show borderline imposible to watch. The scene where the carcharodontosaurus fight is the worst offender. The camera is shaking like crazy, zooming in and out all the time, and is flying all over the place. The audience isn't given a single moment where the camera just sits still and we're permitted to see what the heck is actually happening in this fight. For me, Planet Dinosaur doen't even break into my top 10, let alone be my favourite.

[@stevenelbert8989]

Two other positives that you missed the Thropods all have the correct arm positions and that sinorithosaurus true color is correct being a reddish-brown which would help it blend into when hunting

[@kailanerman5090]

OMGOODNESS dude have you seen the trailer for Prehistoric Planet?!?! It's looks incredible, and you should definitely cover the trailer and scene! I think the show airs in May

[@jonathansefcik473]

Oh RedRaptor, your memes are always on point.

[@CS-my2wp]

Yeeeeesssss finally I been waiting for this moment for a long time

[@Ozraptor4]

Scavenging Rugops is in no way the fault of the filmmakers = this hypothesis comes from Paul Sereno who described the animal (and is presented on his own Uni.Chicago website). He claimed that the skull is unusually lightly built for such a large predator. From a 2004 interview = "It's not the kind of head designed for fighting or bone-crushing," Sereno said. Instead, he believes Rugops was a scavenger, using its head to pick at carrion rather than fighting other animals for food.

[@pbh9195]

4:47 OMG that was a "blast from the past"

[@projectdarktrooper2721]

I love this show my favorite part is the carcharodontosaurus fight and how they don't fight to the death but just try and intimate each other before having a minor fight. My only complaint was they didn't show t rex in this show.

[@guerillabeachholland4504]

Love these accuracy videos Red Raptor.!!!For me Planet Dinosaur still is the fav.doc series, even though some things are epic fails or misconceptions. Feathered Dragons is my fav.episode with all these weird new species, I had a jump scare the first time watching when that Gigantoraptor snatched the small Troodon like dino. Keep on making these superb videos yes please

[@Actually_Alice_Orchid]

I have been so hyped for this

[@MassimoMSSR]

I always found the lower jaw of Carcharodontosaurus too thin and fragile watching this when I was younger.

[@jdmangrich]

I hope some day we finally discover a dinosaur that is in fact venomous. Even a few modern birds have toxins in their feathers absorved from bugs that they eat, so why prehistoric dinosaurs couldn't have something like this?

[@paradoxx639]

I can t wait until you review the new documentary that ll come out on apple tv. The teaser for it looked sooooooo good.

[@velociraptormongoliensis7509]

Rugops is also oversized at 8 meters long when they were actually 4.2 meters long.

[@ProxxRoxx]

Thanks for another great Episode! I'm a bit confused as there are several Scenes shown here which I don't know from my german Version of Dinosaur Planet.

[@iamsimplydynamic]

Let's gooo, been waiting for this one!

[@mosasaurenjoyer4883]

1:43 Wait till' Prehistoric Planet comes out...

[@dynamosaurusimperious2718]

This was the perfect and guilty pleasure of a review and I adore it alot

[@ahmadfaizan3035]

at last i have waited so long for this

[@bruh949]

Deltadromeus and Bahariasaurus are possibly related, but by no means synonymous. Bahariasaurus is far larger and much different and certain structures to be the same, unless Deltadromeus is a younger under developed one.

[@flightlesslord2688]

always liked this series. It has flaws, but its got a lot of great stuff. I actually like the intercut science stuff, its not as intrusive as like dinosaur planet and its well presented

[@dondigao1057]

The Spinosaurus model is so good and i love it when the time the spino went fishing

[@GEK0dev]

Rico at the end killed me XD, anyways nice vid

[@redraptorwrites6778]

Thanks! He's an inspiration to us all

[@maxrichards3881]

@@redraptorwrites6778 “Penguins are killer dinosaurs!” That’s what I screamed at my TV when watching Last Killers. And you thought PD was going to be an easy A…

[@sannicfann3338]

oh I've been waiting for this

[@canonbehenna612]

18:52 yeah out of all the carnivore’s birds Rico is like a devil inside a sweet rabbit speaking of dinosaurs Have you seen the trailer for prehistoric planet trailer and I’m very excited to see it

[@youlaughyouphill842]

Looking forward to the prehistoric planet review when it releases

[@allofilms2923]

Are you going to do a review of the trailer for prehistoric planet I’d love to hear what you would think about it Honestly I’m just glad that there is a dinosaur documentary that has dinosaurs fully feathered

[@bennopelka5082]

Will you cover prehistoric planet on Apple + when it comes out?

[@1punchbrownyt338]

I have been looking forward to this

[@mechakingghidorha9776]

Can’t wait for part 2

[@suchomimustenerensis]

Once Prehistoric Planet comes out will you review it,also what are your thoughts on the trailer?

[@rogerrobertgamer8312]

The only mistake I found of planet dinosaur are the sounds of the dinosaurs every carnivore have the same sounds and so as herbivores

[@nickmitsialis]

well, when you're done with doccos, maybe you can delve into Dino written fiction; I am currently grinding thru a novel called Dinosaur Summer. The premise is that Dr. Challenger actually DID find dinosaurs on that Plateau in Venezuela. Now decades later, the public is bored with dinos so the last surviving Dino circus is taking their animals back 'home' with a father/son journalist team and a group of film makers (Merian Cooper, WIllis Obrien and Ray Harryhausen, among others) to record the adventure.

[@hsdinoman2267]

i think that Planet Dinosaur is Jurassic Fight Club done right

[@maxrichards3881]

No, that’s The Truth About Killer Dinosaurs.

[@BritishTea12]

I absolutely love this documentary it’s the one I’ve grown up with since I can remember and since my 12 years of life it’s my favroute documentary hands down!

[@blacknoir8504]

Love the scientific accuracy documentary series. Can you make another accuracy but with video games?

[@LilRick96]

What's your take on the new Prehistoric planet trailers?

[@timsdoingstuff]

That parental block clip opened a core memory I didn't know I had

[@artkitten8971]

Awesome series! Once you're done with all the docs, could you look at Disneys Dinosaur review?

[@thesenate5956]

Ok, that Rico meme earned you a like

[@scyobiempire4450]

I remember watching Planet Dinosaur when I was a kid, it may be outdated but I still watch it time to time

[@LoudmouthReviews]

Good video as always. This is one I enjoy even if it made some mistakes. The biggest mistake it makes from an entertainment point of view is that the program is simply one chase or fighting scene after another. Walking with Dinosaurs and March of the Dinosaurs did a great job balancing out chase/fight sequences with more scenes of the animals mating, sleeping, or migrating. This presents a more balanced view of these creatures lives. The trailer for the upcoming Prehistoric Planet also seems to understand this with a father rex just chilling on the beach with his hatchlings instead of hunting or fighting. It also was made on a third the budget of Walking with Dinosaurs and you can tell. Despite coming out 12 years later the animation isn't that much better. Both it and March of the Dinosaurs I think were wrong to be fully Computer animated when live action backgrounds just work much better most of the time and give the scene more authenticity. By 2011 standards the creatures not only look shrink-wrapped as hell sometimes but also move in a jerky unnatural way. Probably the best that could be done with the limited budget but its a shame the BBC didn't put more money into this one.

[@starzilla624]

The animation team were on a time crunch I'm pretty sure, which sucks a bit.

[@LoudmouthReviews]

@@starzilla624 Yeah that is evident. Its another reason I am really looking forward to Prehistoric Planet. Its said to have the largest budget of any paleo documentary ever made and has been in production for nearly 3 years. It also returns to the much more sensible habit of placing its CGI creatures against live action backgrounds. So I am very hopeful it is the true spiritual successor to Walking with Dinosaurs that I have wanted for the past decade

[@starzilla624]

@@LoudmouthReviews I am personally more of a fan of the CGI environments, but you're entitled to your opinion

[@100iqgaming]

watched this over and over on youtube when i was 5, this show singlehandedly doubled my vocabulary as a kid

[@cadbanesfavoritehat5655]

Yeah! A mention of the common grackle! I love those birds!

[@everythingshow2142]

I had the same dream that a spinosaurus was chasing me around my house

[@NanuqEditzS]

Will you do an accuracy review on the upcoming documentary "Prehistoric Planet"? It looks AMAZAING!

[@The_Story_Of_Us]

That may end up being the most scientifically accurate Dinosaur documentary ever made.

[@grimats4431]

@@The_Story_Of_Us Well thats pretty obvious since its the most recent. For it to not be would just be its fault entirely

[@The_Story_Of_Us]

@@grimats4431 No, I'm not talking about that, I'm talking about making the fewest errors even when taking into account the contemporary theory. I mean look, Walking with Dinosaurs was great, right? But even at the time, it got stuff that was blatantly wrong even in the face of what was known with fair certainty. If you look into these reviews done by this channel and others, Dinosaur documentaries frequently get things wrong that even at the time they had no reason to get wrong. I have more faith in this production, not only because of its obviously incredible production value, but because of how they've already treated the animals. Young T-Rex's have feathers, adults don't. Accuracy. T-Rex doesn't roar, it makes low grumbling sounds and hisses, accurate. Shrink-wrapping? Nowhere to be found. And I have faith in this production because the team of Planet Earth, Attenborough included, they care about getting things right, they care about showing the natural world for what it is, like I have yet to see a person more passionate about nature than David Attenborough. That's why I think this will be for all times the most accurate we've seen.

[@wesleydjodo8823]

@@The_Story_Of_Us It'll (hopefully) become pretty outdated in a few years tho, like all other dino docs.

[@The_Story_Of_Us]

@@wesleydjodo8823 But no one would ever be able to say that they actually screwed up their research.

[@elijahmontemayor9423]

Hey red Raptor writes have you seen the new prehistoric planet teaser because it looks absolutely good

[@hyena_fan]

cannot wait for part 2

[@JaySmokes97]

YAY!!!!!!! Cant wait for p2

[@tamayako2000]

I'll defend the Majungasaurus being bloodthirsty here because she only attacked after the male scared one of her babies, and thus her maternal instincts labelled him as a threat, and we all know how vicious mothers can be. Can't defend the Troodons or Daspletosaurus gang though, that was just silly

[@CreatureDomain]

This is nothing but perfection. Entertainment + Education

[@gerardhearst8962]

That Rico one had me crying 😂😂

[@toro8670]

Finally after all these months.

[@nanuqo2006]

Will the last video in this series be on Prehistoric Planet

[@trog.9879]

Have you seen the new prehistoric planet trailer?

[@danktorvosaurus]

Could you review the NHK documentary Amazing Dinoworld?

[@AquaticFlapper125]

Nice Review

[@justjoshua5759]

What do you guys think the final ratings gonna be

[@jessicasavalla4490]

You should review a dinosaur documentary teaser it's called Prehistoric Planet and it looks amazing!

[@manlyhanley6178]

Woooooo it's finally here!!!!

[@nivarity2363]

I don’t know if this is already in your list of documentaries to get through, but amazing Dino world is a relatively modern (2019) and relatively accurate (trodon is in it) that I think needs more appreciation and would be a fun review.

[@maxrichards3881]

How hard is it to pronounce Stenonycosaurus?

[@bringmebedard]

did you see the Prehistoric Planet trailer drops?

[@tyrannosuperior5248]

Can I just go on the record as saying how cool it is that this was narrated by John Hurt!

[@suchomimustenerensis]

Surprised you didn’t mention the smaller edmontosaurus,it’s stated to be 4ish tons vs the 9+ Tons it was irl

[@joshuaW5621]

This is one of my favourite dinosaur documentaries.

[@nacktheslayer9882]

What do you think of the prehistoric planet series trailer that just dropped?

[@cfowler7936]

4:04 that actually jump scared me XD

[@SendPeaches]

The black with blue iridescence of Microraptor often reminds me of the Tui from New Zealand

[@bennettfender9927]

The Majungasaurus mother wasn’t hunting the male she was defending her young and happened to take advantage of the males death to feed on a kill.

[@jislh9453]

You would probably love this and it’s probably the best dinosaur documentary out there

[@deanhennessey9848]

Do you think you will do an accuracy review on PrehistoricPlanet when it comes out? because right now it looks very promising and the dinosaurs in it are refered to as just animals one of the lines says "Tyrannosaurus, one of the most powerful predators on earth but right now, hes just being father" that line is everything I ever wanted to hear in a dino doc.

[@redraptorwrites6778]

I definitely want to do something with it. Not sure how to format a good video for it yet.

[@maxrichards3881]

@@redraptorwrites6778 Yeah, there would be no outdated section, and the problem section would only take 1 minute if you stretched it out. I’d say the best way to do it is covering each episode in different segments, giving them all an individual % grade, and then average them together for the letter grade. I already know it’s going to be an A- at the very least, maybe it could be the first A+.

[@dr.shing3504]

Are you going to do the 2022 Prehistoric Planet?

[@szymonpolski6051]

You should do a reaction and analisis of the prehistotic planet documentary trailer because it seems to be the most accurate to date dino documantary