PM Modi की मीटिंग्स में क्या होता है, Amit Shah, Nirmala Sitharaman,RBI की अनसुनी कहानियां|Kitabwala

खबरों को विस्तार से पढ़ने के लिए क्लिक करे यहां- www.thelallantop.com/
Economic policy has a direct impact on how people live, eat, work and spend. It governs every aspect of life, and finance secretaries are central to how economic policy is made and implemented. In this book, Subhash Chandra Garg, former economic affairs secretary and finance secretary, tells the inside story of how economic policy is made, and unmade, at the highest levels in the Government of India.
We Also Make Policy is a fly-on-the-wall account of proceedings within the finance ministry. The book talks candidly about controversial decisions from the first tenure of the NDA government, such as the politics of ‘minimum support price’ to farmers, electoral bonds, recapitalizing of banks, monetizing national assets and the controversial resignation of RBI Governor Urjit Patel, among others. As the author of three Union Budgets, Garg also talks about what it takes to put the Budget together: the pressures, the processes, the calculations and, above all, the politics.
LT Premium जॉइन करने के लिए नीचे दिए लिंक पर क्लिक करें: / @thelallantop
Instagram: / thelallantop
Facebook: / thelallantop
Twitter: / thelallantop
Produced By: The Lallantop
Edited By: Radhe

[@adeshmukhb]

Genuinely I didnt get the purpose of the line of questioning here? What is the agenda? All he asked was about how were there interpersonal problems? Did he asked why the economy was slowing down around 2019? Did he ask why the banks were in bad shape? These questions weren't asked because that would have shown how Modi govt actually did a marvelous job on economic front against all the odds..!!

[@fool7682]

There objective is to show how poor Modi government is.

[@mohitjain7994]

He based his questions on whats in the book. The purpose is to promote the book.

[@adeshmukhb]

@mohitjain7994 I haven't read it myself yet, however I dont believe that the Author after retiring from his illustras career write a book /biography only to describe his squabbles with his bosses or colleagues..!! I am sure th3 book must many more information.

[@anujsethi7845]

​​@@adeshmukhbtrue😂😂yes boss kind of employee he is. Same as Current RBI governor.

[@user-xd9xy5yl9l]

- Our GDP run rate in last 9 years is about HALF what it needs to be. Do we want India to win? But our run rate is about half then we aren't winning. Even Rwanda and Bangladesh are ahead of us, our rank is 120 in GDP per person. - Absurd Inflation: basic Toor Dal which I think was Rs. 50 in 2014, recently I paid Rs. 270. Absurd. - Unemployment is the worst it has ever been in decades. And when many IIT or IIM are not getting placed obviously there are serious fundamental issues in the country. Clearly, something needs to change. To win our run rate needs to be 8-10% not 5% (for the last 9 years it's averaging around 5.1%). Unless we double our run rate from say 5% to 9-10% we will continue to be behind other countries. It's that simple. Now you will ask, is it possible to double the run rate? Yes it is: This same 8% rate has in fact happened in the past IN INDIA ITSELF (for 6 years under another person). And it has been done by other countries much worse than us. And these countries are now ahead of us. Even now, here and today, this 8% has finally been achieved now in the 10th year (although the last 9 years were pretty weak. So the average is pretty ordinary.) So absolutely it is doable, was done for 6 years. and is being done now. *The sad thing is in the last 9 years we were at a mediocre growth rate*. And so we still are at rank 120, unemployment is terrible, and inflation is mind-boggling, and out of our 10-15 major problems only 2-3 are solved after 10 years.

[@rishianant4986]

Very engaging, very engaging.. Lallantop me pehli bar laga ki saurabh bhyia se bhi zada shant, engaging aur provocative host hai Deepak.... Behtareen. Deepak ji aapko wo Manoj Mutashir wale episode se notice kiya tha par aapke shant chit waale persona waale character ke kaaran aapke jaisa banna chate hai. Raat ki shift k baad subah 6 bajne waale hai aur ye itna engaging hai ki band nahi kar paarahe, agar aap tak baat pauche toh like karke batayega, please

[@TheLallantop]

Thank you for your kind words.🌻

[@100960mmm]

In democracy Elected person have upper hand than Selected persons like Raghuram Rajan and others. We are already in high growth Range which proves Sitaraman Handled much better than others. Dedication of PM modi is not quesnable. After hearing long conversation of beaurocrate I have more tilted that Modi govt is doing it's best

[@anujsethi7845]

😂😂wish you could read numbers better

[@authentic_101]

They're not doing a good job as long as gas cylinder, petrol and diesel are breaking the back of the common man!

[@acswain6720]

​@@authentic_101What are you talking about? Price of petrol has stayed the same for more than 1 year defying inflation. A post office KVP deposit doubles in value in almost ten years. For a country to grow and function properly, all consumable items should double in value in a decade to account for the compounding effect of normal annual inflation. For your kind information, PRICE OF PETROL IN MAY 2014 WAS RS 71.40 PER LITER. So, the Modi govt has done excellent job of keeping its value much below the inflation and GDP growth rate justified Rs140 per liter in January 2024, almost 10 years later.

[@mukulsehgal]

True.... these are all chamchas who have lost common sense

[@yourstrulytk12]

​@@authentic_101 We are buying Russian oil to reduce prices. Efforts are visible.

[@abhinavverma-2030]

Very calculated answer by Subhash Garg

[@OmParkash-wi3xz]

He is true IAS, basic quality to please boss and act accordingly. To finalize budget in few minutes itself shows seriousness towards important documents. Conversation clearly shows he was yes man.

[@jzxynow2a8gs21]

If that is your take, you are just an idiot, the man resigned at the top of his career over his own principles, "clearly" dekhne ki aukaad nahi hai aapki, ek aur janam lagega

[@pramodharit834]

शुरुआत करते बैठते ही आनंद आ गया...

[@baldevsinghbisht1959]

Very good conversation and informative knowledge that how government, politician and big beaurocrates works together for genral public besides their individual egoes.

[@AkashBanwani]

I d😢🎉

[@arvindsharma3995]

Is it fair to discuss internal meetings details in book

[@amitwankhede1236]

Absolutely good discussion by host and Guest, I would request more and more guest such a guest should be call on. Lastly HOST done wonderful job 🙏🏻🙏🏻

[@nathanrv]

ye rinku singh ka bhai lallantop kab join kiya ?

[@atulmahato1944]

One Life is not enough is the book we appreciate in Lallan top podcast to discuss.

[@user-nj8dr8ul6r]

Commendable interview.Thnx to lallantop for such secretive in conversation

[@ishandindorkar2846]

The guy who is taking interview seems to be from TV background. Intermittently, he is trying to make breaking news from the interview by repeating what Mr. Garg is saying. At one point, he also insulted the guy - yeh maine likha he kitab me(padhi nahi kya tumne interview is pehle?). Saurabh bhai, you should come back and do such critical shows.

[@Keshav1992]

Deepak is someone whom I admire most at Lallantop after Saurabh Dwivedi for command on Hindi (P.S. I am Marathi)

[@ayushbagouli4703]

Very good interview, kudos to the host an guest 🎉

[@milupatadiya.7205]

Thank you 🙏🙏🙏

[@rajeshsinha937]

This is marvelous presentation ❤❤❤

[@surjitkaur5951]

Good discussion thank you so much

[@arunasinha-yc3st]

कितना बच बचकर बोल रहे हैं 😊

[@shashiprakash9481]

Very informative keep it up lallantop 😊

[@sidharthsahoo7842]

Iske jane k baad gdp sharp growth hui hai 😅

[@GamePlay-it9yw]

Thanks for excellent information

[@madhubhaipatel5100]

Very nice conversation & informative as well about the Administrative aspects & policy matters etc being dealt with for good Governence in Govt.🌹👍🏼🙏🏼

[@smitjeswani4286]

Why the host is asking only about controversial things ? why no questions and topics in detail on how decisions were made by RBI in those years and his professional experience This is worst and Poor host , needs to learn line of questioning

[@SkSingh-tu8un]

Interesting episode

[@appajirao]

Excellent show !

[@abhijeetprakash4866]

Bhut hi behtar interview

[@colsahasi]

Garg trying to diplomatic rather than effective and dynamic Secretary

[@omtiwari6862]

Thank You sir ❤

[@nitinyadavyadav6870]

Shandar discussion ❤❤❤❤

[@sureshbharadwaj7403]

If the FM wants a formal relationship with her FS so be it. It is her prerogative. Why should the FS seek for the sort of pally , informal terms he wants. Very egotistical of him. And inconsiderate especially considering also the FM is a woman who may not want a over friendly, informal interaction with her officers unless they pass her comfort levels.

[@msdadsfsx]

u work in patna?

[@aloknarayan2914]

​@@msdadsfsxit's a general observation and quite apt to say so. Babus in India have an inflated sense of self and tend to have an opinion on all and sundry despite having no particular domain expertise in financial, industrial or defence policy.

[@ddkle1]

you indeed need an informal Rappo with your boss/stakeholders for max productivity, if you work somewhere you will know.

[@msdadsfsx]

@@aloknarayan2914 u seem to be working in grocery shop, leave it u won't understand how workplace environment is

[@dilippandya7903]

Some times presentations by bureaucrats are also influenced by certain unseen strings and no minister can and should trust fully on them. Informal meetings with concerned private citizens whom politicians trust gives insides of the correct nature of bureaucracy, capacity to understand each other and try to reach a balance decision in the broader interest of nation is important. EGO on both the sides hurt the common citizens.

[@gauravnirgure2857]

कृपा कर मोदी जी एक कानून ये भी बनाये की मंत्री पद के लिये आईएएस की तरह परीक्षा पास करनी होगी और डॉक्टरों द्वारा पूरी तरह मानसिक जांच के बाद ही कोई मंत्री बन सकता है वरना तो कोई भी अनपढ़-विक्षिप्त इस महान देश का मंत्री बन जाता है और भुगतना देशवासियों को पड़ता है

[@user-bw2oq8wr8x]

जब तु इतना ही अक्लमंद है तो खुद को बेरोजगार क्यो बताता है?

[@nacpatil]

You simply want intelligent people over democratically elected. Intelligence can help solving puzzle but politics is about rallying people to support govt. It’s different thing altogether

[@gauravnirgure2857]

@@nacpatil यदि कमेंट पढ़ा और समझ आया तो आप हिन्दी भाषा जानते होंगे ही तो ये आंग्ल भाषा किसलिए प्रबुद्ध छद्मआवरण हेतु ? if we support dictatorship we need to kill democracy ,

[@nacpatil]

@@gauravnirgure2857 Google translate use karlo. Not good at hindi. Dictatorship to librals karte hai by protesting over democratically signed bills by doing street violence. You dont like modi but he has majority to make decisions he make. And people like me want a strict govt who straiten out indiscipline.

[@gauravnirgure2857]

@@nacpatil Dear fellow human this comment of your clearly shows some major symptoms of malfunctioning brain fogged by andhbhakti I hope you'll heal up soon someday and get through disatourous calamity Nation is facing , get well soon

[@deepakbhatia96]

बहुत बढ़िया प्रस्तुति

[@colsahasi]

How NPA written of by Modiji to help big industrialist

[@dilippandya7903]

He Lacs confidence or he is trying to be modest but lacs clear indication if there is positive improvements in the Economy after 2014 and what created mess prior to 2014 .

[@giteshbharati1811]

मोदी जी का अनुभव एक मुख्यमंत्री के रूप में 3 बार का अनुभव, बहुत बड़ी चीज हैं जो उनको प्रधानमंत्री के तौर पर काम करने के बहुत काम आया होगा

[@rajeevbhatnagar6495]

Finance Secretary should have knowledge of theoretical economics. Training function for IAS is weak. All his problems are basically IPR (Inter personal relations). Should have navigated and not resigned. Here so training is helpful.

[@anujsethi7845]

Same things applicable to current RBI governor

[@rajeevbhatnagar6495]

@@anujsethi7845 Yes

[@megh2307]

Use of a proverb, doesn’t mean you’re calling names to the person literally.. Sensationalism at its worst…

[@ChimtuChhatraneta]

Bhai masala bhi to chahiye... Kitaab kon padhne vala h vese bhi

[@lalitjobanputra9193]

Garg ji is too ambiguous

[@ankitpathak8929]

Very nice interview

[@Learner_being]

Like politics is going in development direction. Same for bureaucracy on performance basis. Nationalist officer (not enough but more than previous) 2014-2019 was hardest tenure for modi because bureaucracy was set according to congress, their ideology people. Now 2019-2024, bjp type bureaucracy, ideological people coming. So 2024 will be more good. Andhnamazi cant accept this ongoing changes in india. Now want yogi as pm in 2029

[@milupatadiya.7205]

આભાર 🙏

[@shashiprakash9481]

Great sir

[@vivekpai142]

Can you highlight the book? I don’t think the title of the book and author’s full name has been mentioned in the show so far…

[@rkmlkpk]

Very polite man❤❤❤

[@DHAVALPATEL-bp6hv]

lallantop interview, bahooooote badhiyaaaa!!!!!!!!

[@samadhanFatafat]

Nice😊

[@shashiprakash9481]

Great vert informative ye kitab kha milega

[@OhhTeri1234]

Bhai sahab mazaa aa gya.. from Boston..

[@shrikantkulkarni6129]

his flow of words is not continuous ,, cautious replies ..

[@dmr-Prh-32n-QNQ]

!GREATEST PM ! INDIA IS LUCKY TO HV HIM...HE REPRESENTS 1.6 BN INDIANS.... YOU PPL ARE BUREAUCRATS... DONT BE OVERSMART... OBEY HIM...MODI FOR 2024!!! ❤❤❤

[@sibaprasadmishra2994]

The Lalan top is the 👍 ❤❤

[@ajaybrahmnalkar3684]

ॲंकरजी चार्ल्स व्हिलान लिखित नेकेड इकॅानॅामिक्स पढिये.

[@bapanbiswas9940]

Right

[@sidharthsahoo7842]

Modi jee is unbelievable 😊

[@kamaljain8919]

फिल्म शुरू करने से पहले फिल्म का ट्रेलर क्यों दिखाया जाता है। मतलब video शुरू होने के पहले जो स्टार्टर उससे दर्शकों का लगभग 2 मिनट का टाइम और डाटा व्यर्थ ही खर्च क्यों करवाया जाता है? ऐसा यहीं पर नहीं अब तो अधिकांश youtube videos में यह होने लगा है।

[@saurabhrathkanthiwar3423]

In this one and some more of interviews Sound gets echoed In-between the video. Kindly work on this to improve.

[@rudrapratapsingh7232]

गीता का ज्ञान : डा. विजय अग्रवाल

[@krishnakanthgriddaluru8818]

Breaking the mould by Raguram rajan

[@prateikiscool]

He is very scared

[@lgic111]

PLEASE PASS ACTIVE EUTHANASIA LAW. Right to choose death on wish and self declaration should be allowed by Parliament. Citizens above 50 years of age must have this fundamental right.

[@HimanshuKishanShukla]

LALLNTOP हिंदी भाषा में कार्य करता है, सारा इंटरव्यू हिंदी में किया गया लेकिन डिस्क्रिप्शन को कड़क अंग्रेजी में लिखा। ऐसा क्यों?? लंबी हिंदी लिखने में दिक्कत हो रही थी या अपनी अंग्रेजी जानने का रौब दिखाना था??

[@sibaprasadmishra2994]

Namaskar Sir ji❤❤🙏🙏🙏

[@SaurabhGupta-hc9wu]

❤

[@neeteducatormmbaldodia]

Great Conversation Deepak..👍

[@kvishwanathan5589]

इंटरव्यू देख के ये लगा की मूर्ख लोग सरकार में है

[@anoopshankhdhar2369]

Pls provide book name. Thanks

[@Ndia583]

Gargg shahab is typical Babu type.

[@user-fb4jc8rl9q]

Lallantop Wale Yaad Rakhna ki yese he question Aap other party' s Leader se bhi Puchho, Ager nahi puchha tuo Aap bhi Rajdeep Sardeshai ki he Line Wale Gine jayengen. Soniya Ghandhi waala Interview Yaad hn na Kese Shash-bhahu Wale Question puchha rahe the.Ek National Leader se. Darbaari journalist Raj Deep Sardeshai.

[@ideefixxe]

He was too used to Gandhi family way of working. Nothing else. It is very difficult to adjust to change. And when you cannot, you get booted out and then you go out and shred donkey's tears

[@abhijeetbirajdar2755]

Faltu interview, ye kya bol Raha tha kuch samaj nai aaya Or to or ise kuch book recommend kerne kaha tho wo bhi ese nahi aaya

[@trueindian510]

Nirmalaji ko gussaa atta hai....unbelievable

[@Mantri_jee1]

किताबवाला में अजय बिसारिया कि किताब -- एंगर मैनेजमेंट : द ट्रबल डिप्लोमेटिक रिलेशन बिटविन इंडिया एंड पाकिस्तान पर चर्चा हो ।।

[@keyurpatel5026]

The intelligent rishi

[@pateljayantij2689]

Dr, Hasmukh Adhia was lifted from Gujarat, Directly to Delhi as Finance Revenue Secretary and Vanished Economy by Implementing GST 12:54

[@kishanmundra9167]

How had economy vanished, can u elaborate or just wish to raise slogan ! Into the long run, GST is the best thing to happen into tax system in India. We will realise this in year 2035 or so when we analyse with results and not assumptions

[@anujsethi7845]

​@@kishanmundra9167BJP was the first one who opposed GST in 2013. Originally GST proposed by council yet to implement. Lots of GST rules need to be done. Why doesn't the BJP government bring energy, oil, and liquor brought to the GST regime? Why looting the people on petrol.

[@kishanmundra9167]

@@anujsethi7845 UPA lacked political wherewithal to implement GST. Opposing GST politically never meant that GST was wrong. Ya, there may be many things in GST which are yet to be implemented, but how does it matter that things are implemented over a period of few decades into the life of a nation... Everything will evolve and unravel. Pace should not be an issue, Actual intent can be. Here actual intent is positive.

[@anujsethi7845]

@@kishanmundra9167 It's puzzling how the BJP claims credit for GST. The dismissal of the UPA's efforts with a mere excuse of lacking political will doesn't justify the persistent challenges in our system. Although the intent was evident back in 2011, our progress has been far from satisfactory. The nation cannot afford to linger at this pace; we should be aiming for double-digit growth. Yet, here we are, grappling with a single-digit growth rate.

[@abhinavverma-2030]

He is bureaucrat who has spine

[@laxmansingh-zo8rc]

अनुदान के हाल आपने देख लिया होगा , गैस की सफसीडी 20₹ कभी कभी हमारे खाते में आ जाती है , आपने जो योजना बनाई , वह धरातल पर कितनी कारगर रही ? इसपर भी किताब जरुर लिखें

[@PrinceKumar-cf7ek]

🙏🏻🙏🏻💐💐💐💐🙏🏻

[@rishianant4986]

Feb 2017 Deepak ji

[@balakrishnasharma9683]

they execute the vision of the boss by drafting the policy frame work and administrative procedures...

[@Cars360-vs7bk]

What’s the book name?

[@eternalrebel9555]

Timestamp lagane ka thoda mehnat kar lena chahiye lallantop ko

[@nileshpatani3413]

You are interested only asking questions which can create controversy, you haven't ask how the Banking system become strong from 2017 onwards

[@desrajsharma7279]

In case Mr Subhash is recommending book by RR Rajan, who was architect of gold bonds and later on amendment to it within a few days under Chitanbram in MMN Singh Govt, it clearly shows hitilt of scales. With FM Sitaraman his relations have the strains of rigidity to accept a lady as his boss.

[@gamergirlaradhya7650]

Yai sab election kaintimr ki kyu nikaltai hai sapolai😂

[@sanjeevthakkar3155]

Why present government is anti-salaried class. In 9 budgets not once the salaried class was heard. I fact it has remained an easy target

[@rajinderbhat6756]

Nirmala isn't a good minster. No benefit providing to middle class.

[@omkale2223]

First viewer first comment 😅

[@tradewithkashyap]

okay 😅

[@Mahakal_Bhakt_Aghori]

Nirmala is a waste as FM

[@omduttdixit3433]

Ohh, Mr gereg after his 2019 baget stock fell drastically and whole policy needed to be taken back . After that he was fired

[@agrippa-theskeptic9346]

Gereg, baget? अबे लिखना क्या चाहता है?

[@colsahasi]

He is playable

[@user-xv4sb1rh6o]

How much duplicate cruncy print

[@pateljayantij2689]

Yoga Guru and Still Working?? I have met him and knows his Style.

[@abhinavverma-2030]

Inshort Subhash Garg telling Arun Jaitley more broad minded than Narendra Modi nirmala sithraman easily which are narrow minded arun jatiley able to accept criticism difference of opinion 😅😅😅

[@pateljayantij2689]

ENGLISH means - Elisabeth - Nehru - Gutjarilal Nanda- Lal Bahadur Shastriji - Indira Gandhi - Sanjay Gandhi ( Semi Conductor) then 😂😂😂😂😂😂. !

[@SachfanCric]

Saurabh ji keval leftist writer ke interview lete hai kitabwala me

[@kaiwalyaghotkar832]

kitne ghabraate ho Leftist logon se hahahaha

[@SachfanCric]

@@kaiwalyaghotkar832 Lagta hai ghutne me dimag hone ke karan ye shabd nikal gaye maine yaha ye kaha ki vo interview me khud keval leftist writer ke samne rehte hai or baki me team ko bhej dete hai

[@anujsethi7845]

Kyunki rightist books kahan padhte hai.

[@pateljayantij2689]

D.T lakdawa Books Please.

[@pateljayantij2689]

Budget is French World BUDGET ask this Question to PM. Please ! Every Voter of India is Big Political man. Surely 😜

[@AKMISHR9994]

Saurabh ko seekhna chahiye Deepak se...

[@AnilSharma-gb3kj]

This guy knows hardly any banking, and even less central banking...as evident from his comments on PCA and on ECF of RBI...The interviewer knows even less...!!!