Low Food Supply - Camp Conversations / Interactions and Hidden Dialogue / Red Dead Redemption 2

[@DarkShadow775]

Now I see why Arthur says at the end of Chapter 2 “I’ve turned into the goddamn errand boy.”

[@jordandennis6794]

Arthur was the errand boy the entire game

[@AMaidenlessRunt]

Have some faith Arthur by making sure I have a better tent and I'm fed daily.

[@husaammaawia3057]

"YOU HAVE TURNED INTO MAH SON!"

[@Burg3ss]

@@husaammaawia3057 and i have to protect you

[@huskobyte]

I think you meant to say “the goddamn errand *boah*”

[@crunchynoodle_Sam]

Arthur is the muscle of the group... And the milk man And the ammunitions man And the charity man And the medical man And the "I lost this, can you get it back" man And the play dumb man And the "drive the wagon" man Oh, Arthur.

[@manictiger]

Another settlement needs your help. I'll mark it on your map.

[@tommyshelby2250]

He said it himself. "I've turned into the goddamn errand boy.".

[@e3126]

He's basically the man man

[@trollege9618]

Don't you "Oh, Arthur" him

[@commonergrant9766]

Don’t forget he is the vault man as well

[@ikalimah]

"We're starving Mr. Morgan!" "I got some jelly beans."

[@danielpedro8081]

Underrated comment

[@exddertv]

Lmaooo

[@finkyedou4316]

Jelly beans existed in 1899 so technically that could happen

[@hraeth2052]

"you like jelly beans"

[@chekums1561]

@@finkyedou4316 you had to be there to understand

[@Sparky-gp9vh]

I saw the one were jack said he was hungry and immediately left camp and came back with a deer.

[@stekras2643]

Same!

[@milesupshur4179]

4 years old and already a man grown

[@southernfriedmedia3968]

HES JUST A BOAH!

[@miggycaro]

Sparky 2039 yooo is there a vid of this on here? I cant find it anywhere!

[@ashen6579]

Same haha

[@CarlosSanchez-ip1vs]

Jeeeezzzzuuuusss is Arthur the only one that has limbs or is the only one capable of providing anything in camp? No wonder the gang fell apart when he got sick, he was the heart and soul of the gang.

[@dusty203]

lol fr

[@spadeecstasy8709]

Carlos Sanchez He needs to, I mean, Arthur is the only one not guarding the camp, heck even Hosea's guarding it for a while in horseshoe overlook. Arthur is the only one they got going around cause they too tired of guard duty. Dutch too tho but idk

[@metro1279]

Mitochondria Cell micah doesn’t guard either he just does nothing for 70%of the game lol

[@spadeecstasy8709]

Metro Oh yeah micah too

[@Kuzan24]

Metro true I think they let Micah and Arthur do their thing because they’re the main gunslingers lol. And I’ve seen cutscenes with Micah bragging about putting money into the pot at Clemens

[@OrbitOnceAround]

Pearson: “We need food!” In the corner right of the screen $2,000,0000

[@harrizh146]

How did he get that money?

[@eshwar6969]

@@harrizh146 I think he used an old gold bar glitch before it was patched. But there's about $21,000 worth of gold on the map. Look up a guide.

[@flopytheflop4837]

He maybe used the cheat code. It would take about 10 minutes

[@bygonebebygones8503]

But... but... you can't eat money though...

[@Scatmanseth]

@@bygonebebygones8503 money can be used to purchase goods or services

[@Godzilla00X]

Poor Bill, probably thought he'd get a heroes welcome for bringing the camp food. He really just wanted approval and to feel appreciated

[@eigorson]

Yeah, since he gets called dumb alot

[@Asraeks]

also he's the one who organizes the most succesful mission in game. You have more than enough money for the rest of the playthrough

[@Camromulus]

You ever notice how he tries stealing from the box? In like chapter 3-4 there are moments where Bill looks like he's trying to sneak some money outta the box.

[@Jsjeuducjejwjsif]

Pablito123 Which mission? I forget

[@Asraeks]

@@Jsjeuducjejwjsif one with robbing a bank in small town i think

[@e.x.watson9997]

"We're starving, Mr. Morgan!" * 18 chickens just walking around...

[@e.x.watson9997]

@@thepaintingbanjo8894 so you're saying they're not really starving because they have all those eggs just lying around...

[@ToastyTeresa]

@@thepaintingbanjo8894 I wonder if those *E G G S* you talk of could help them not starving in some way

[@tunasandwich8049]

I get your point but eggs arent really sustainable for a large group of people. Les do the math: I think there were about 18 chickens in the camp. 1 chicken lays around 5-6 eggs a week giving us 90 to 108 eggs a week. When the gang is complete there are about 23 people in total to feed, meaning everyone would have to eat 4 eggs every week for an efficient ration.

[@wallacecollins8411]

Those are the attack chickens, very important to the camp's defense.

[@rdr2v1nce7]

@@wallacecollins8411 ey how did the zelda chickens get in here

[@horrorreads5771]

Abigail was one of the only few who told Arthur to get some food without blowing his ears out.

[@Zz0Z79]

I hate her tbh

[@Zz0Z79]

@Some__ Guy she had fun with all the gang 😳😋

[@Zz0Z79]

@Some__ Guy u see it is a normal thing?

[@Zz0Z79]

@Some__ Guy if u are happy by marrying a b**** i think it is ur problem

[@Zz0Z79]

@Some__ Guy sure

[@gemsdirtykitchen3658]

Over half a million 1899 US dollars in camp funds... "We are going to starve!"

[@brian6470]

GemSignor Plays I don't know about u but I don't usually eat any kind of money

[@iVladX17]

@@brian6470 r/whoooosh

[@gemsdirtykitchen3658]

@@brian6470 Chocolate coins FTW! :-D But seriously, we know that Pearson goes to the towns to buy food supplies. The real question is if anybody else has access to that camp funds box.

[@Ensam4]

@@iVladX17 Not a woooosh dipshit. Please just stop

[@mfs-3kiryu592]

@@iVladX17 you're the one thats been wooshed

[@brandonwhite1786]

Everyone: I'm hungry Arthur Me: You can feed yourself Jack: Mama, I'm hungry Me: *starts hunting aggressively*

[@minneeagle]

👌🏼👏🏼

[@kingoftfl2149]

Me:*Starves Jack

[@sinandonk6782]

*angry hunting noises*

[@Clarence-gg3ul]

kills every living creatures in the world including men who do not give me sum MUNEHHHH

[@Ayotttttt]

shoots a fucking rabbit with a pump, MM GOOD MEAT

[@elias9852]

Camp: “We’re hungry, Arthur!” Arthur: *goes hunting and returns to camp* Camp: “Eww! You’re covered in blood!”

[@nikolasmtr]

this:

[@ex8800]

fr

[@JC0ALOFT]

“And I thought I was the butcher! You’re covered in blood man.” The amount of times I heard this line while starting a new play-through can make me go mad

[@cristakatsumi8515]

Or the meat is one or two star quality 😂

[@jin_cotl]

@@JC0ALOFTit’s so obnoxious

[@ahmedoburak]

Bill: *donates one flight feather* Pearson:tHe OthErS arE pUllİnG Theİr WeİgHt

[@AMaidenlessRunt]

Micah donates a rat... He sure pulled his weight.

[@blankblank5409]

8:08

[@dire_wolfheart]

@@AMaidenlessRunt by rat do you mean a real rat or himself. I cant tell rn. Did he donate some food for himself or donated himself.

[@MariusBoss11458]

@@dire_wolfheart Himself.

[@thisisafalseaccount105]

CanineTuna 2540 a rat

[@batjoke777]

Arthur: Everyone in the camp that has nothing to do in the spare time: We need food Arthur!

[@deloreandude4636]

Mr Morgan*

[@wisam111]

Ox in the box I mean god forbid they actually go hunting

[@BN-xq7lm]

Right? Its like Arthur has to do everybodys dirty work

[@Topazert]

Guess he wasn't exaggerating when he said he went from prize pony to work horse.

[@rickyl.103]

I know especially at Horseshoe Overlook. I sit down for 1 second at the camp fire after doing all the chores and being gone from camp for like 2 weeks then right as I sit down on the log Grimshaw comes up like "what are you doing Mr. Morgan? You need to get out there and get us some supplies!" Then Dutch comes up after and is like "What are you doing hanging around camp Arthur? You used to be a man of action, what has happened to you?" ...its like fuck you Dutch I just got back and sat down for 20 seconds and you're on my ass? I just filled up Pearsons table with a feast and donated 300 bucks suck me off! You're on my ass yet I see Javier, John, Sean, Bill, Lenny, Micah, and pretty much everyone sitting around doing fuck all and you dont say 1 word to them! Better yet you sing the praises of Sean and Micah and what did they do Dutch? Oh that's right, Sean donated 1 dollar and a squirrel pelt and Micah donated 15 cents oh bravo!

[@roadworkahead4187]

“Well we all need to eat Mr.Morgan” Charles exists you know.

[@icecream4you161]

If anything, Charles is more capable of hunting than Arthur, he has spiritual connections and probably canonically is better at it.

[@Mr_Fancypants]

I thouged you imply we need to eat charles.

[@roadworkahead4187]

@@Mr_Fancypants who said I didn’t?

@@Mr_Fancypants Good one xDD

[@Mr_Fancypants]

@ thank you dubi

[@MrZomBie775]

"Sharks are nothing compared to human beings." Damn Uncle's seen some hard living.

[@tracyrae4854]

True Words

[@Unknown-qb9wm]

Its because of the *LUMBAGO*

[@joseywales6112]

Ethen Millard terrorist attacks, murders, war, assassinations, antagonization, fraud, assault

[@thatoneunemployedmf]

@@joseywales6112 But you ARE a human lol

[@frogglen6350]

Not really It's a fact that sharks are barely a threat to people. In fact, humans kill 100,000,000 sharks each year

[@koosskoo5966]

Arthur: put's 1000$ into box Everybody else: 25c, poor bat wing, rotten opossum Miss Grimshaw: MR MORGAN I'VE NOTICED YOU'VE STOPPED PAYING INTO BOX...

[@Dylan-bm1jn]

I can actually hear your comment in my brain

[@theflyxx]

NOT NOW

[@Skinned_fried_n_cut_up_potato]

No fucking joke on my first Playthru I was donating to the box like crazy and for two in game days I stopped in next fucking minute miss Grimshaw comes up and tells me to donate in the box and I’m being lazy shit

[@Josh0Tv]

DID SOMEONE SAY BAT WING SOUP???

[@KnowYoutheDukeofArgyll1841]

@@Josh0Tv I'm sure it was Bat Man soup.

[@thecheck968]

Pearson: Put me on an ocean and I could catch a whole feast Also Pearson: *on a lake with a newly bought boat surrounded by fish*

[@arrye7790]

To be fair, he does fish pretty often in the evening at Clemens Point. I just don't know if he actually catches anything or if it goes into the pot

[@wobblywack5531]

​@@arrye7790 I saw him catch a fish once and I was like wtf

[@barrymantelli8011]

😂😂 IKR

[@saulgoodman2071]

I try to fish at Clemens point and it takes as long to catch a fish as it does irl

[@Mobster78]

I’m wondering if anyone notices that Pearson is always making stew? It doesn’t matter what you bring in. Fish, deer, raccoon hell even a brown rat or a songbird you accidentally hit while on horseback. It will always be stew.

[@thatoneunemployedmf]

Reminds me on something...

[@nbmaheswara]

I caught a big salmon, thought it would be the camp's menu for that day. Nope. Stew it is.

[@mza111]

Welcome to Naval Cooking School.

[@JohnDonovanYT]

I think Rockstar got lazy.

[@AMaidenlessRunt]

Fat ass only makes stew because that's the only thing he actually knows how to make

[@lanipanix8519]

I remember after Arthur got kidnapped and was on bed rest for a while, as soon as I got out to walk around camp Dutch started yelling at me to put money in the box 😔

[@Goofiest-Goober0h]

Same, that plus him saying I was hanging around camp too much also right after the coma thing made me just antagonize him every time i saw him.

[@shydreameress264]

What an asshole move xD

[@SD_yessir]

To be fair, it cuts to like 2 weeks later after that mission.

[@danl2136]

@@Goofiest-Goober0h I always got Dutch or Susan telling me I was in camp too much lol. I'm thinking I do fucking live here 😉

[@Goofiest-Goober0h]

@@danl2136 the 1st time he said I was hanging around like a bad smell I was like ok if I'm not here guess I cant put money in the box. That shit was at 3.74 from valentine til the end lol.

[@defense90100]

“We are gonna starve!” Arthur: “Hmph... I’ll see what I can do” as he walks away with 21 million dollars lol

[@nkl7345]

Lmao, he's just trolling the peasants

[@monkeyskitz]

$777,000,000 in todays money if you adjust for inflation 😂😂

[@TheSlinkyDogg]

"Sharks are nothing compare to human beings." I never imagine Uncle could say anything deep like that. I feel like I'm seeing him in a new light.

[@Neo101ai]

lol Uncle is the smartest of all of em idiots. Didn't you pick that? then you have missed some of the uncle conversations. Watch the one where uncle confronts DUTCH :D and you will see him in a newer light.kzbin.info/www/bejne/nmfcmGWkl8asq5o when uncle roasts dutch right off the bat then youll take him a bit serious.

[@frogglen6350]

That's not deep tho. That's a basic fact. Humans kill more than sharks and are responsible for climate change

[@Rex-X-Dark]

@@frogglen6350 stfu no one talked about climate change you stupid bitch

[@prussiangermansoldier2987]

@@Rex-X-Dark Jesus calm down

[@dernurhalbwegsinteressiert5118]

@@Rex-X-Dark You are one of those guys who feel guilty for some reason when people talk about clima change, aren't you?

[@grzk]

When I first played the game and Pearson said that everyday someone needed to bring food I thought that if i didn't, I would get kicked out.

[@femmemachete]

Imagine the storyline if Arthur did get kicked out.

[@bennettjohnson574]

@@femmemachete it seems like things would pretty much fall apart without arthur

[@AMaidenlessRunt]

Shit I'd love to get kicked out the camp I'd just stay in rooms and eat at the saloon instead a warm place over my head and a fine meal. Go hunting sell carcass to butcher everyday bam I can make a daily living. While Dutch and friends gets to eat each other

[@minneeagle]

They can start eating Pearson. He’s the fattest.

[@immrcontagious9096]

I don’t think they would kick him out because without him the gang is practically weak. Especially when Arthur gets (you know what) the gang won’t survive without him. That’s my prediction

[@mavericklucas594]

Other people are hungry: *I sleep* Jack is hungry: *slaughters a herd of deer*

[@idk6651]

Remind me of Gordon Ramsay between kids and adults

[@biscuitsofficialyt2336]

Ah.. i like jack better than john

[@Zz0Z79]

@@biscuitsofficialyt2336 I hate 'em both

[@Zz0Z79]

@Clanker i hate u more than them

[@cm-nk4li]

@@Zz0Z79 why lol

[@cerberusgaming3515]

5:37 grimshaw pulls crate like it's heavy 6:15 karen just lifts it up like it was nothing.

[@chikirin9349]

She a sturdy girl

[@lunadashie4642]

I laughed my ass off😂😂😂

[@AMaidenlessRunt]

She's a big gal

[@muhammadumarizuanbinmohdsa2955]

@@AMaidenlessRunt she's mine be carefull with ur mouth bhoi

[@AMaidenlessRunt]

@@muhammadumarizuanbinmohdsa2955 I beg you pardon, but I must inform you that Karen is sleeping right next to me with Mary Beth and Tilly.

[@garmenlin5990]

Camp literally has chickens Everyone: Find us some food, Mr Morgan!!

[@AltoStratusX1]

Lol. And like 5 rabbits running around the underbrush on the path to camp 24/7. Like I kill 2 everytime I come in hot with the horse.

[@ShaddySoldier]

Chickens are too valuable to eat. Up until the middle of the 1900s they were incredibly expensive.

[@kinka9883]

ShaddyCrunchum I think they meant that they could be eating eggs.

[@profchaos7289]

Also some horses laying around that nobody use

[@syedsyclone6827]

@@profchaos7289 yeah, why can't they just sell one?

[@ryanlugo321]

Arthur: single-handedly improves the entire camp and decides to take a much deserved break. Everyone at camp 5 hours into your rest: you need to help us out more Arthur.

[@volkan202]

I looked at the ledger, arthur is the only one that contributes anything of worth you can't convince me they'd have lasted without him, No way

[@thenightling6919]

They didn’t last, that’s why the gang fell after he got tb

[@yiklongtay6029]

I wish they had a rubber banding system where everyone's donation rates are dragged up when you pull your weight and dropped if you slacked

[@Synthia17]

@Dutch Van Der Linde They had to because if you don't donate for a little while Dutch starts giving you shit even though you donated more than everyone else combined

@@Synthia17 This is why you gap your givings. I give like 5 dollars once in a while lol.

[@Synthia17]

@ Yep, I was giving 5-10 at a time, then got captured by colm because of dutch, he didn't help me out and straight after I recovered he comes to me with his bullshit that I'm not giving enough money. Bro, I was in a coma for 2 weeks, fuck off. Had a good laugh at that tho.

[@zigodgaming778]

Miss Grimshaw knows Arthur's the only one who gives a lot of money the ledger looks like John: 25c Tilly: silver watch Micah: Rat Sadie: 2x feather Karen: 19c Susan: $1.00 Mary beth: 32c Pearson: $1.52 Dutch: silver engraved buckle Charles: eagle talon Bill: silver wedding ring Sean: $10 Jaiver: Silver emblem ring Abigal: 90c Lenny: silver pocket watch Reverend Swanson: $1.57 Leopold Strauss: Chicks debt money Hosea: $11.51 Jack: candy Cain: rabbit Uncle: bat wing Josiah: empty bottle Kieran: 17c Arthur: gold bar

[@Crafty5890]

Change that to Arthur: 1,000,000$

[@nuv2987]

Yeah, I actually donated that gold bar that you get from the German guy to the camp.

[@lennysummers1865]

Zigod Gaming lol “Cain gives rabbit”

[@zigodgaming778]

@@lennysummers1865 should I add the prices to the items ?

[@MOARELDENRING]

Zigod Gaming Micah:Rat foreshadowing much...

[@mattnlogan101]

“So what’s for dinner? Dysentery again?” LMFAOOO

[@LiterallySpikeSpiegel]

Pearson definitely deserved to be antagonized there. Being the camp cook doesn’t absolve him from going out and doing a little hunting lol.

[@blkplauge]

I’d let them all starve if it wasn’t for Jack. 20 or so grown men and women complaining about being hungry while not doing anything about it. 🤦🏾‍♀️🤦🏾‍♀️

[@mmello68]

Fuck jack too

[@noahguzman5850]

Ok௹ why

[@thaibogaming9333]

@@mmello68 why man he is a kid

[@l-DrFizz-l]

Ok௹ im calling FBI

[@kennyermorido]

@@mmello68 no fuck you

[@kasperoll7723]

Seeing Jack be hungry is the worst feeling ever

[@kanker3465]

Best*

[@yoman3690]

ForceZ Not really

[@kennyermorido]

The only reason why I hunt in the game. Jack.

[@reyfatcat7879]

@Joshua lol

[@shodan2002]

Id kill them all if the game allowed me to do it lol

[@mahendialvines3072]

Say no more Jack, here's a legendary pronghorn.

[@mr.nothing8031]

I read it wrong.....

[@jayleenmato]

When I am not playing Red Dead 2, I am watching video about Red Dead 2

[@lionelzisengwe9607]

Same here. Am on my second walk through and i tell you i am loving every moment. RDR2 keeps surprising. Good gaming!

[@sliverspoon195]

One does not simply not think about red dead

[@mattnlogan101]

Can I haaa yo digies ??

[@MeatObelisk]

@@mattnlogan101 she's ugly as hell dude you don't want that

[@LethalSaliva]

Amen to that.

[@authurmorgan8614]

“I’m trying to”

[@Matthew-pb9ep]

ThEn TrY hArDeR mR mOrGaN

[@sharp6517]

You know you spelled Arthur wrong right Auther

[@Matthew-pb9ep]

Oh yeah lol

[@sliverspoon195]

@@sharp6517 it should be OrThEr as dutch pronounces it

[@qwopert7092]

Want me to go hunting with you amigo

[@benaroundinternet7636]

It broke my heart when Jack was hungry and Abigail helplessly asked him to read something for her. Oh god, Arthur’s death is something, but I never thought even that’d make me so sad.

[@MrLiverpoolfan92]

6:34 about time Arthur told him that feeding the camp is not just his job.

[@ogloc8212]

@Edwin C. I always roast him because he's such a bad poker player he folds every round before he even sees the first 3 cards 😡

[@blankblank5409]

OG Loc lol

[@kidnamedfinger2840]

@@ogloc8212 yo that's actually true lmao

[@vihuynhquang5204]

Arthur: "Others are pulling their weight? What happened to 12 deers, 10 pronghorns, 6 rams, 20 rabbits, 3 coyotes, and about 4000 pounds of meats i gave 'em 5 days ago?" That'a the amount of food i donated to camp in-game.

[@poultry-lover6665]

@Edwin C. he's the cook he does his job

[@dankdoggo5025]

Omg all the guys in the gang but no arthur is the one who needs to bring the food let's be honest the only reason why we give food to camp is because of jack

[@OneofInfinity.]

And Miss Jackson, shes always so friendly.

[@dankdoggo5025]

@@OneofInfinity. yeah tilly is pretty sweet to :D

[@AMaidenlessRunt]

Jack is the only reason I fed the camp tbh. Everyone else are nothing but a bunch of deplorable lazy fucks who sit on their asses in camp 90% of the time during the day.

[@dankdoggo5025]

@@AMaidenlessRunt ahem ahem abigail ahem ahem molly ahem ahem ahem

[@AMaidenlessRunt]

@@dankdoggo5025 especially them and more so Molly

[@thecommunistlad7421]

Bro the camp be always puting the problems on arthur when he's doing the most work outta everyone combined there...

[@arthurmorgan7333]

I'm always the one hunting, donating money, and doing camp chores and yet 20 PEOPLE cannot even donate something better than a GOD-DAMN FEATHER.

[@jeremymead1308]

Arthur is the camp workhorse

[@h373rom5]

@@arthurmorgan7333 Or a bat wing.. like, where the hell they hunt them bats from? Whole gang done some Bats Genocide, always seen at least 3 people donating some bat wing everyday

[@5dancingisraelis535]

When somebody works their ass off and all the lazy people complain about not redistributing wealth it kinda sucks, eh?

[@Staxmontana2223]

Well that’s kinda why I just camp by my self with me and my horse in the wilderness and make my own food and hunt my own stuff

[@fellowtemplar5679]

I literally pick a little ammo and some food and Hosea starts complaining about low supplies a few seconds later. Also, don't you hate that the whole gang is loitering about at the camp and come complaining to you?!

[@crissyhutchins3289]

I don't really mind the others loitering except Dutch 😂 Always saying he needs that man of action back. Gotta grab a wagon and run him over a few times till he angrily goes to the cliff edge at horseshoe and then I back up and knock him off lol

[@DOCimpovised]

1:31 - abigail: we gotta get somethin to eat, arthur -arthur: SHOA

[@Lagmaster33]

Why dont you eat the BOAH?

[@diobrando7774]

My boah i'll get ya sumthin to eat

[@jaredjx]

Shore

[@thewiltedharp6385]

I got some Jelly Beans

[@Eastsidet03]

We also need muneh

[@JuniorJr...]

The dialogue between Mr. Pearson and Uncle is deep and moving. So well written and staged. Sharks are nothing compared to human beings! Gave me goosebumps!

[@BlobbyPlayer93]

If Uncle wasn't suffering so much from lumbago he'd go out and provide the camp with a feast every day

[@Combustion803]

Uncle actually isn't lazy at all, he always says he's thinking about something, he's a philosopher

[@JuniorJr...]

​@@Combustion803exactly. And Uncle's also a real survivor. His story's kinda like the rest of the gang, but unlike the others, he didn't have a Dutch to lean on when he was just 9 and ended up on the streets after his parents passed away. This game's seriously epic - they really went all out making characters with their own stories and quirks.

[@oliver_owl2360]

1:05 soon as I heard this in my game, I went hunting, sold roughly 50 deer pelts and restocked the food supply. It may be a game but I hate seeing kids go hungry.

[@SinisterServal]

You have a good heart ❤

[@oliver_owl2360]

SinisterServal Thank you.

[@smoke1nmirrors]

Well maybe don’t go to Africa then. :/

[@Hhhhhhhhhhhjhjjjjjjjjnnnnn]

Jack: im hungry momma Oliver when he sees a deer: *_TARGET SPOTTED_*

[@tahabashir3779]

@@Hhhhhhhhhhhjhjjjjjjjjnnnnn *open fire*

[@professionalgamer6522]

Some Gang Members Start Flexing when they do something but It's still 99.9% Arthur lol

[@jasondyrkacz8270]

Micah: I donated a rat. I'm the biggest earner this gang has ever had.

[@ShootistFN]

@Morgan Alexander when I saw him say that I brought my spare horse with me.. caught 3 perfect deer.. once with lasso one one main horse and one on spare horse and brought it to camp.. then donated my 78 big game meat then put in 5k into the box..

[@pinkerton5382]

I hate hearing how they're hungry.. breaks my heart. Always hunting for the camp! My grandma would starve herself just so me and my brother could eat as children. Now I make sure she has a freezer full of meat, sweet treats, and all the coffee she can drink. I love her so much

[@Gamemania_C-137]

that's really nice of you

[@drysoup3017]

Good man. What about u?

[@officiallydrae]

You sir, are a gentlemen!

[@mycycleminorities]

You're completely the opposite of your name, I salute you!

[@thesaltbaron3029]

Nice try Pinkerton!

[@echoecho4654]

so Abigail is completely ignoring the full bowl of stew right next to her and jack 4:51 Wow i did not expect to get this many likes

[@CommunistDoggo-cs3pp]

I saw that to

[@WillyWarby]

@@CommunistDoggo-cs3pp yeah...you were there

[@Godzilla00X]

Abigail doesn't feed Jack nasty camp slop, he gets a nice steak or some ribs

[@dutchvanderlinde2488]

she can't read,she probs doesn't now what food is either

[@Norinia]

Godzilla00X speak for yourself. The camp soup in my game is near Gordon’s level (near because it ain’t served with the same flair lol)

[@billshamrock449]

I never thought of starving these annoying fools lol. They noticed that Arthur stops contributing to the Box LMAO every time I looked at that ledger Arthur was the only one contributing anything worth a damn LOL

[@Godzilla00X]

All the talk they give about people being lazy and pulling their weight lmao Arthur should've gotten a feast for himself in town

[@billshamrock449]

@@Godzilla00X i always got Arthur the good stuff to eat lol. But kept the camp stocked also. But that's only because i like hunting and fishing

[@Mobster78]

Bill Shamrock Right, and whenever I donate money I always use the items instead of actual money. No way in hell I’m putting 13 gold bars in the box just to get betrayed in the end.

[@billshamrock449]

@@Mobster78 no keep as much gold and jewlery in Arthur's Satchel as possible until the end

[@gerRule]

Bill Shamrock don’t collect the gold until you’re John

[@2KXMKR]

I upgraded everything shortly after starting chapter three. I thought great! The camp is all set, no way are they going to go hungry now. So i set off exploring the entire map. Eventually Javier came to look for me, so i guessed i'd spent enough time away and headed back with him. Got back to camp and saw the food was empty. Every single one of them complained about me not bringing food... while they were sat right next to a huge lake full of fish and turkeys ran around in the woods not 100 meters outside camp... Screw you guys! I never gave them a single item of food for the rest of the game.

[@davidloisel3833]

I never knew characters would come looking for you after you leave the camp long enough, that's cool.

[@chillycoldchomper9389]

​@@davidloisel3833I guess it happens during chapter 6 when Dutch becomes more paranoid

[@tallic967]

​@@chillycoldchomper9389No, it can happen as early as chapter 2

[@chillycoldchomper9389]

@tallic967 OMGosh, I'm such a clutch. I meant that it probably happens more often in chapter 6 because that's the peak of Dutche's paranoia.

[@juhaeerjayran4246]

@@chillycoldchomper9389 i doubt he cares abt arthur anymore in chapter 6 tho. i mean just by arthur insisting he got all butt hurt

[@2KXMKR]

Arthur donates $10,000 Three days later I've noticed you've stopped paying in to the box!

[@minneeagle]

2:44 Pearson looks like he is going to hurt Arthur the way he is going towards him

[@dusty203]

LMFAO

[@a1kev]

Husky boah is hungruh!

[@MOARELDENRING]

Jonson1o LMAO Arthur would fuck Pearson up

[@minneeagle]

I agree

[@audreygold7533]

IM LAUGHING

[@moret25]

7:25 I love how the camp has half a *MILLION* dollars in their coffers but won't use a single quarter

[@evolutionmax9791]

Damn these fools start turning insane, if you don't give them food like they don't got charles, John, Bill, even Micah, and he doesn't even do anything!

[@subaru9639]

They could just ask charles, he's an expert hunter

[@flaco316]

They could also ask Javier, who is a master fisher

[@subaru9639]

@@flaco316 yep

[@drobviouslol]

They could ask Hosea, he's also a good fisher (according to Arthur)

[@botconboy460]

All this tells me is that Arthur is the only one who gets food.

[@trashmann1971]

Other then jack

[@botconboy460]

some guy - when does he bring food in?

[@svengonsalves8538]

some guy jack can barely read how can he hunt?

[@guy4142]

@@trashmann1971 what does Jack do lol

[@flyingrancidm00nfish7]

Maybe Charles and John too, but Arthur probably brings in thrice as much as them put together

[@xCARNAGE_ASADAx]

“You better find food and money for us all, Arthur. In the meantime, we’re gonna sit in our asses the entire day until you get it done. Oh, and you better upgrade Dutch’s tent to keep us motivated.”

[@nbmaheswara]

Ms. Grimshaw: "I've noticed you stopped paying into the box!" Me, literally just gave $300 to buy that boat: 🙄

[@AMaidenlessRunt]

I had a meltdown when she said that. My reaction to that was really? I purchased all these upgrades updated Dutch's tent and the everyone else's tent bought a useless boat despite all this I keep donating 20 dollars everytime I show up at the camp and yet you have the balls to tell me that I've stopped putting money into the chest... Dutch didn't even used that money for the camp he kept it for himself and I don't see you miss Grimshaw doing anything other than nagging the other women. Fuck you miss Grimshaw

[@bigjohn6310]

I bought everything in the ledger and donated loads of money plus food and no one thanks me

[@jcgggg]

I got that comment (along with Dutch accusing Arthur of betraying him in the future) immediately after the mission where Arthur gets taken by the O'Driscolls. Firstly, I'd donated like $3000 buck and upgraded everything in the camp by that stage and secondly, I'd just been kidnapped, beaten and shot. Fuck off Grimshaw, you ungrateful bitch.

[@diobrando7774]

@@bigjohn6310 no you are a terrible leader

[@bigjohn6310]

@@diobrando7774 Arthur could be better but I have a plan

[@haripk1]

This game still has many hidden dialogues even after 1.5 years from its release.. Wow

[@k.nrwd1]

I’m honestly not surprised the gang fell apart after Arthur got sick. He was responsible for everything and everyone relied on him for every little thing. He fought for everyone. Still angers me to this day after years of playing when Arthur gets kidnapped by the O’Driscolls they left him. He had to rescue himself, only one there to help him was his horse. Even when he came back he got looked after by Miss Grimshaw but still got relied on even after it. If it was anyone else in camp, Arthur would’ve been there faster than a bullet to rescue them

[@chillycoldchomper9389]

My personal theory is that Micha spat out some kind of lie that Arthur was okay because NO ONE was doing anything when Arther came back ny himself nearly dead. The gang were way too calm.

[@chillycoldchomper9389]

Though, I don't think that's what happened, but it's the only thing that makes sense to me.

[@dwaynejpeterkin]

If I was Arthur I would of left them after I got better as they don’t deserve Arthur they can’t pull their own weight

[@danestambaugh255]

​@@dwaynejpeterkin easy to say when you haven't spent 20 years of your life working for said gang and you consider them family. And your entire life's philosophy revolves around the gangs mere existence. There's a reason it took so long for Arthur to finally lose faith.

[@dwaynejpeterkin]

@@danestambaugh255 arthur had too much faith in dutch which lead to his downfall however he should of been questioning them the moment they didnt come for him after colm captured him if arthur was a leader he would of left months ago before everything went left

[@portal8920]

6:27 meanwhile John walks up with a full bowl of stew at the campfire

[@OhdeerOhfrancis]

Jack: I’m hungry! Me: * immediately goes to kill animals*

[@smoke1nmirrors]

Sparsity ! *It’s about time I rode to Valentine!*

[@kingoftfl2149]

Me: *Starves him to death

[@nickoteen5462]

Jack can go back to Saint Denis and eat fucking spaghetti with papa bronte while wearing his stupid slippers and reading his books 😝

[@blankblank5409]

Nick O’Teen As much as i hate to say it. Bronte treated him better

[@Literallyryangosling777]

*brings death dog*

[@LordTr0PiK97]

Camp: has thousands of dollars Dutch: WE NEED FOOD OR MONEY NOW ARTHUR

[@tradingturtle2313]

at least bill did something while everyone in camp was bishing

[@12227UserName]

You know, I actually liked Bill. In RD Redemption 2, he never outright does anything wrong. He does allude to future events, forshadowing that eventually he'd become his own leader of the Bill Williamson gang - but that was really the only questionable thing he did in RDR2. Even in the first Red Dead Redemption, despite being a pretty bad guy at that point (for example, having his gang slaughter the folks of a ranch, not to mention other heinous acts), he did give John Marston a chance to back away. It was Marston who tried to draw his gun first but failed. I don't know. I think Bill was just an unfortunate character who obviously had bad tendencies.

[@imperor0]

@@12227UserName I think bill actually starts the early parts of Red Dead 2 wanting to be a provider for the gang and tries to help however he can. In the train heist he tackles the most dangerous job of setting up the explosives, with arthur's help. However the explosives don't work and Bill is blamed. This is the start of a pattern which Bill Williamson himself notices. Bill tries hard and does his best but whenever something goes wrong that he had his hand in the gang never lets him hear the end of it. However when Arthur messes up it's just seen as one of those things. I think the driving factor for Williamson opposing you at the end is not blind loyalty for Dutch but a chance of revenge at Arthur and John for getting all the praise he desperately wanted and it was a final chance to show he could be better than Arthur by sticking with the gang.

[@TheChefShipwreckinAlaska]

Grimshaw: Mr. Morgan... I’ve notice you’ve stopped- (gets money box thrown in face) Arthur: WHY DONT YOU DONATE SOMETHIN INSTEAD OF FEATHERS?!

[@minneeagle]

I wish that would happen!!!! 🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@THEDARKMISTT]

Favorite comment

[@danl2136]

Best response is not now button. Arthur dismisses her

[@demijones7537]

😂😂😂😂

[@RobGordonJC]

Read that in Arthur’s voice hahaha 🤣

[@Deyone_Jackson]

1:00 Bruh.. such a depressing emotional moment, she tells him that they need food and his answer is a dry-ass "sure"😂😂😂

[@radiyangulam2480]

I actually like how Arthur doesn’t take bullshit from the men in the camp when they try to call HIM, the heart and soul of the camp, lazy and unwilling to do his part

[@wardenunknown]

But as soon as Abigail or Jack start talking about how hungry they are you hear him begin to be a bit ashamed that he couldn't bring some food in

[@AqwDragulum]

This is why I wished there were camp brawls, especially at Beaver Hollow. Would’ve loved to beat Bill’s ass for doubting Arthur

[@SnoozeLoose88]

I got the Nevada hat and when I came back to camp, they said “new hat”

[@lavdijeabazi7849]

Or nice hat

[@eds1942]

Try the tri-corn pirate hat for a day.

[@cerberusgaming3515]

You should try the legendary bear hat. They will criticize you for wearing it

[@gageware1254]

They said I was dressing as a lawman lol

[@SnoozeLoose88]

Gage Ware yeah they even said that to me too 😂

[@danielchristie2519]

That uncle and person one is so well done and a perfect depiction of tough life during that time

[@justusbenson8622]

Arthur was a real one, but to the wrong man.

[@Tronter6000]

Yeah exactly man bro 😔

[@dmac2899]

4:42 Abigail: You gotta find us some food Arthur. Abigail at about that same time: Has a gigantic bowl of stew just sitting on the ground.

[@Whocares158]

😂

[@demod2080]

Arthur: You got food right there Abigail: That's shoe polish and fingernail clippings Arthur:... I'll be back in an hour...

[@joshuatremper5026]

Fatty

[@GhostShiroyama]

Arthur Morgan, The source of income for the gang The food supplier for the gang The ear for everyone's nagging The fake Sherrif The bounty hunter The babysitter for Jack The wagon driver The man to rescue gang members from jail The man to rescue gang members from being held hostage The man to save gang members from wolves The man to take gang members out for a drink at the saloon The bank robber The stagecoach robber The collection agent The interrogator The kidnapper The fisherman The boat paddler The voice of reason The bar fighter The policeman The cocktail party enthusiast The balloon flyer The poker player AND cheater The rooftop scout The safe cracker The sniper Arthur IS THE GANG

[@joshuatremper5026]

You are not a memeber, you are the entire gang

[@lightningparadox]

7:20 has camp funds thats even hard to count. Pearson: We're going to starve

[@patricioperez7323]

That’s a hack or a cheat code lol It’s not possible To get that much money

[@lightningparadox]

@@patricioperez7323 ik man. That was just a joke

[@MassimoNioli]

7:30 Arthur is a f@cking millionaire Dutch: WE JUST NEED MONEY!

[@kdufjdmdifjdjdkckxl8389]

But he needs the money for Tahiti

[@nuv2987]

The camp even has almost 600k.

[@MassimoNioli]

@@nuv2987 i didn't believe you would take your lazy ass and check the ledger by yourself Uncle!

[@bbpd5315]

Almost 18 million in today’s times

[@nuv2987]

MassimoNioli that’s funny, I’m not being sarcastic. I don’t really have a way to portray laughter with *AhaahAhaHahHahHaH* or lMaO/lol* or the 😂. I find all those ways overused, or not a good portrayal. I dunno, maybe I’m being boomer-like right now.

[@howdydoodilly6812]

Mr Pearson after I give him the entire local population of Whitetail deer: “We’re starving here mister Morgan”

[@MiloMcCarthyMusic]

Arthur: pays 1 million dollars into the box _2 weeks later_ Dutch: “yOuR noT pUllIng YouR wEiGht aRthUr”

[@ace5762]

We need food or money, Arthur. *575k in the camp pot, everyone's just too lazy to go into town for supplies*

[@nandthegreat7066]

While I was busy getting gold bars I went back with these interactions. Then I upgraded the camp fully. I wish Arthur has some dialogues after upgrading the camp.

[@koshisaur7850]

Grimshaw to Dutch: “Mr. Morgan hasn't been contributing to the camp! He's lazy and inconsiderate.” Arthur, currently donating over a thousand dollars into the box: *surprised Pikachu face*

[@Eviloops]

Everything I did wasn’t for Dutch. It was for the camp.

[@osirisgaming9451]

7:20 that’s definitely more than enough money to go to Tahiti!

[@yeetmaster6643]

NAH

[@wolfy9549]

4:43 she says as a nice bowl of stew is resting a few feet away.

[@hugepickachupenis5961]

2:54 Pearson looks ready to eat Arthur

[@theshadowgeneral1759]

This comment almost killed me XD

[@TBrizzle01]

I didn't even notice. They're freaking millionaires in 1899 lmao.

[@thedapperdummy]

4:50 Abigails complaining about no food, look to the left and then right of the white box. Whats that looks like SOME FUCKING STEW IN A BOWL

[@milesupshur4179]

Feel like you’d have to let this happen intentionally, I always had money and brought back food without even trying, it’s gotta be the easiest thing to do in the game

[@GBLyrics]

Yeah every time I’m going back to camp I just hunt a deer and a rabbit on the way

[@colbalt95]

@DraculaCronqvist other than the raise your honor pitching in $20 every now and then

[@micahbell3075]

Unless you forget like me and every two seconds grimshaw hovers over to me with glowing eyes and screams at me. I let that happen too many times because I spend half the game exploring and forgetting that there is a camp with people that need feeding. I'm very forgetful

[@shihtzulady1978]

I got jumped on by Dragonlady (Grimshaw) 3X in 5 minutes on one visit to camp. Once because I'd been too long without a bath (she stood over me while I bathed and put on fresh clothes, embarrassing), then again because I hadn't contributed to the box recently, then AGAIN because I'd been slacking on food because I'd been exploring and doing missions. I never return to camp now without a some food to donate to Pearson (and a visit to the bath or a swim in a creek).

[@G1NZOU]

Sometimes I've gone off on a long trip hunting, mostly for pelts to sell to the trapper to get new clothes, then I come back and it doesn't feel that long, but someone accosts me for not pulling my weight.

[@Killer_gogu]

Arthur donated 500.000$ Dutch:we need money or food

[@MrDelgrigorov]

"We gotta get something to eat Arthur" shows to her hungry dying son, then sits on a box and that's it. What a mother of the year award!

[@ethansomer7362]

Arthur: puts $5000 into the box Dutch: All we need is a couple hundred more dollars Wow I’ve would have liked to hit a thousand likes on a hate comment tho

[@DEBBAH1907]

I have A PLAN, ONE LAST TIME WE HIT THIS AND WE GO

[@tychogoedhart286]

I wish they'd put in an alternate story where if you donate more than 5000 bucks before the Strauss mission where you get the TB the story goes different, the gang goes free, micah is hanged in Strawberry, the money in blackwater is retrieved and John amd Arthur leave the gang together so you can switch between the two gta v style

[@ethansomer7362]

tycho goedhart that would be cool but they would have to connect to red dead redemption the first installment of the series

[@victorpleitez768]

tycho goedhart on a second playthrough a lot of the games features look more pointless than before. I’ve amassed half of all the gold bars in the map, which is more than what you get from doing any of the missions, and it doesn’t make a damn difference if i put it all in the camp funds.

[@prestige3730]

@@victorpleitez768 I used save editor to get $100,000 (which converted to 2020 USD is $3,086,000) which is more than enough for everyone in the camp to relocate elsewhere in the world not just Tahiti or Australia, and Dutch will be like "wE neED MoRe m0neH OrTHur!"

[@dusundavarfreohr3491]

Bruh... All of them acting like they can't even set a foot out of camp to go fishing 🙄😂😂

[@joshwolf6932]

Pearson: you set me out to see, I'll catch ya a feast The River that is literally twenty feet away from Pearson:

[@SavageMexicanBoi]

“Sharks are nothing compared to human beings” damn it really speaks about today’s society.

[@livewire2759]

It really speaks about how society has always been.

[@badreedinedjellali1328]

yeah it's true

[@somedudefromapharmacy]

Sharks kills for a reason, they gotta eat. Humans kills for various reasons, most bad.

[@lukemorgan6166]

We live in a society

[@BayouBoy2443]

Humanity in general since the beginning

[@Evision5]

Damn....Bill putting in more work than Charles!?!

[@AMaidenlessRunt]

Charles is different. His native American roots won't let him hunt animals everyday so those damned lazy idiots can eat. To Charles that would be equally to killing for fun.

[@minneeagle]

He only hunts on some occasions.

[@furymern8162]

@@AMaidenlessRunt tf no

[@jaydenshepard7928]

@@AMaidenlessRunt What the fuck, Native Americans would hunt if it was needed to eat...the only thing they were against was hunting for sport and not using every bit of the animal for something after killing it. Wastefulness. Weirdo.

[@AthensStudios]

Most I saw Charles donate was some perfect pelt. Too bad it doesnt contribute to Pearsons upgrades ...

[@mattosso7676]

I love how nobody in the camp is doing ANYTHING to get food or provide supplies except for Arthur. lol

[@Gary-And-His-Demons]

Scenes like these make you really appreciate the talents of skilled voiceover actors! Absolutely captivating.

[@124Nightwing]

Food was the only thing we always had plenty of in my game since hunting was my favorite past time and I always had a shitton of raw meat in my inventory.

[@k.cooper8816]

7:38 "You are getting lazy" while the camp is having $574,930.26 and Arthur having $2^32-1...

[@caesar419]

When you realize you’ve heard all of this hidden conversations playing as Arthur during the game lmao🤣

[@RevolverlaRata]

The developers' work in making such a complete and dynamic game is incredible.

[@ayo44]

THIS PAINS ME TO WATCH SO BAD. i’ve had 4 playthroughs and each one besides my first bc I didn’t know what I was doing. my camps were OVERLY STOCKED. always yellow. contributing food and money every time I went to camp. omg I can’t imagine playing like this and getting this dialogue. would drive me nuts

[@diannathexenomorph1878]

First time seeing these interactions, I'm always bringing back a 3 star deer and two turkey's on my horse and always buying a full food supply for the camp. I worry for Jack the most, plus I love the interactions when I bring a perfect deer carcass into camp.

[@weirrockisawesome802]

This just says that Arthur is literally the only one who hunts, or opens the ledger.

[@Synthia17]

@@weirrockisawesome802 Yep and I'm pretty sure I saw Bill and Micah stealing from the box too.

[@8T6yt]

Arthur: puts 90% of his money in the box Everyone: WE NEED FOOD ARTHUR

[@BillyOnYouTube]

4:40 This was the interaction that made me determined to hunt enough game to give the camp a gold food icon. Abigail and the BOAH deserve to have their bellies full.

[@joeparrigen4982]

😂😂😂😂

[@sevez9951]

Everyone in the Camp: We need some food or monney Arthur go hunting Mr.Pearsons Stew: I'm a Joke to you