John is like "Arthur do you mind?!" Arthur be like "Not at all Marston!" **grabs 🍿 Popcorn and 😎 watches the Chaos**

2:20

Kieran’s gonna be mad that Dutch’s stealing his girl

Hot take but i feel like Durch would have done this same thing with Annabelle. People treat her like the special case because she was killed and Dutch even tells Colm he really liked her, but I feel like he iust didn’t get a chance to screw her over and leave her for a younger woman. I feel like he definitely would have left Annabelle for Molly, same way he left Susan for Annabelle once he deemed Susan was getting too old for him

0:10

Arthur does have one point of being a gunslinger. Boy needs to protect himself in that day of age. And as we saw in RDR1 and 2, that’s prove enough that he needs to be ready in the face of danger.

Damn, seems like Abigail used to just walk all over him

It really shows how much Dutch as changed. At the first chapter Dutch asked someone to go bury Sadies dead husband out of kindness and (spoiler!!) in the end before the betrayal he intentionally left John behind to die or be captured (can’t remember much im replay it for the 4th time)

I just saw this in game for the first time, and had to look it up cause Swanson wouldn’t shut up

PIG

14:32 its john marston micah

Funniest mission I've ever done in a story game and definitely my favorite GAME of all time, not just story game, my favorite game of all fucking time

Most badass mission ever, I don't even have to explain why this is my favorite game of all time

How can i Trigger Arthur and Mary Beth's Conversation in Chapter 6

Arthur acts different between chapters I don’t care about the nonsense

man I did all the endings. Don't fear the Reaper ending was the best one.

6:34 that i know you from dutch is such a nice nod to the stranger

The bgm is literally 🔥

Unironically, Swanson also has a redemption in this game with him becoming sober and going to New York.

Abigail is really a great character, and his interactions with John are so natural. Since RDR1 came out, I think her character was written perfectly. I don't know why people hate her

I love how Hosea truly appreciates Arthur and knows he’s way smarter than what Arthur perceives himself to be. Unlike Dutch who constantly tries to make fun of Arthur’s intelligence. Hosea was the heart and soul of the gang.

Hosea was literally the "angel on his shoulder"...

Sometimes I wonder if Micah was fighting Dutch as much as he was everyone else. What Dutch wants and what Micah wants are different in terms of the process. Micah just wants the money. Dutch wants money and he wants more, wanting to have his cake and eat it too with whatever personal take on Dutch’s character having some kind of explanation to why he didn’t plan a way to get the money back sooner, which must’ve pissed off Micah to no end

Goes to show that while Micah may be deadly with guns, he's a slouch in a fight. Arthur would have destroyed him if he wasn't stricken with the disease.

7:25 did john just snort

Karen "uhh shit what do i say? Better say it'll be okay again"

11:51 what name ost bro

Riding in first person makes it even more epic!

He wasn't joking there

Is it me, or does it feel weird that each new Red Dead Redemption story keeps going back in time?

i love when they were all about to fight then it just cuts to them dancing together xD What a fucken game!!!

I thought Sadie becomes hard after the events of rdr2. Kind of breaks continuity

Am i being an idiot yes (no water for 4774 days)

What happens if u interact with drunk john while being drunk??? 🤨🤨

No wonder they we suspicious of him being gay. Remember Kieran?

I am with Micah on this one.

This is probably my favorite mission in the entire game. It’s so fun. One of my favorite parts of the missions is the music. It’s so good this one of my favorite missions or the one in chapter 5 but still this is probably my favorite one.

How come micah can hold his guns in camp 😡😡😡

I hate Dutch but I love how he is exactly the person his favorite author would hate. I also love how both Arthur and John get to meet Evelyn Miller but Dutch never gets to.

0:39 bro jumped like 4 feet

0:42 taima going to whoop bill's ass herself

How do you manage as a 25 year old to get bullied by a 4 year old

The Braithwaite family's biggest mistake is taking Jack from them. That led to the destruction of their Manor and their business. Everything that they have is gone, and they got what coming. This moment is the end of a family feud.

thank u for this i couldnt get the tilly one because dutch decided to talk to me at the same time 😭

This rat always drunk

3:01 Arthur jumping up and down like a toddler that wants some shit killed me 😂

John and abigails marriage is exactly the same as Michael and Amanda's in gta, at the start of both games they are both seen as toxic but as the games progress, they both make it work.

who tf beat this guy at begining every guy that respect himself use charm

I used to go in on Abigail but then i accepted that John left them, for a year. Left her alone with a three year old without any idea of what happened to him. If being out there eaten by wolves made her that worried, imagine what that year mustve been like. She couldve been mourning him, an outlaw on his own. He couldve very well been hunted down by Pinkertons or worse. Then this man comes in like nothing's happened, questions the legitimacy of their son, and nearly gets himself killed all over again, just when you got him back. Its an emotional roller coaster for sure. I feel bad for Abigail. I'm glad John gets himself more together. He actually grows up, they're both well written characters, each flawed in their own ways. Doing their best with what they're given.

They're both children