Pony Tales (MLP: FiM Fanfic Readings) 'Love, In All Its Forms' by Obselescence (precanon sadfic)

[@lulualma4139]

Man, if this was canon, this would of been a giant hit to Luna's psyche. I mean by the way Celesta worded it, she might as well of killed Luna's daughter, hell im pretty sure that's why Luna never went looking for her in the story. Imagine having to live with the person who murdered your child for who knows how many years, watching as they have students and subjects and friends who flock to them naturally. While that same person so many people love, was the one who took away one of the only people who actually wasn't scared of you, and saw beauty in your talents. I would of lost it too, to be honest.

[@blueshadow3079]

No wonder Luna didn't fight chrysalis in a canterlot wedding

[@benhuether5474]

And the reason why she hates Celestia most of all.

[@pridewolf8388]

I fully agree

[@lpspanda-moniameom6118]

Right

[@informationyes]

@@benhuether5474 its fan fiction lol

[@georgem9975]

Ok, first of all, Luna would NOT have died if antumbra stayed. Feeding off love only makes ponies weak, not kills them. And second of all, Celestia didn't even think that the lack of sleep of taking care of antumbra would be the reason why Luna was weak and Antumbra didn't even know she had these powers, which means if celestia never said that it would probably never lead to the wedding 'incident'.

[@noah-i4436]

But think about it, if antumbra stayed, Luna might have become to weak to raise the moon, then what could she do? Then she would have to spend more time with antumbra and getting sucked more of her magic trying to rest up, and even if Celestia moved Luna to a different room to rest up, she would still have to recover her magic, so that would be maybe a couple of days without the moon, since Celestia didn't have control over the moon too yet. Then the day and night schedules would get all messed up.

[@destroyerblackdragon]

I think Celestia can handle moving the moon she's been doing it for a thousand years also the laws of real world physics don't apply in the show such as the sun doesn't actually raise the planet just revolves in front of it, thunder comes directly from lightning instead of moments after a strike, and all the seasons and weather or manufactured. Don't try to apply science to a show about magic and unicorns.

[@leahabreu3758]

@@noah-i4436celestia has been raising the moon for a 1000 years she can continue that and luna can have HER baby antumbra was young and all those years without her mother made her cold then when older as to when she started having kids of her own she just wanted her mother back think about the first time of having one of her own kids she didn't know what to do and having so many? she needed her mother and i think she still does after all luna just wanted a baby and some one to love her nights as with with her moon but when tia came into the photo she messed it all up luna would not die she can't just be weaked nobody has control of what they do when little or even just babies we all know tia would want somebody to love her as well if she was in lunas place it is not lunas mess up its celestias if she never did that maybe Antumbra would of never wanted hurt others

[@TheSleepery]

Mybe the reason Chrysalis was able to get through the barrier in a canterlot wedding is beacause Luna let her in

[@neferiusnexus]

Luna: Hello everypony. Have I missed anything? *everypony stares at her with forced cheerfulness after the harrowing madness they have all been through* Celestia(telepathically): _And where have YOU been oh Dear Sister of mine?_ Luna: _Worry not my beloved big sister, our blasphemous existence is soon drawing to a close. I have had an aeon to come to terms with that, now I am merely going through the motions of what is to come. Darkness shall fall, Silence will reign, and The Doctor can do nothing to stop it._ Celestia: _You are testing my patience again I see..._ *everypony bursts into laughter*

[@austiny6512]

That also might explain way we didn't see Luna during the invasion

[@TheDerpyANDMuffinShow]

Good thinking my friend!!

[@darknesstheproxy9716]

No she couldn't only shining armour controlled it it's because she took his love so made him powerless tho if you made s fan made idea you could put that

[@galaxygimbiino8544]

@@darknesstheproxy9716 Not trying to start an argument but most likely Lau said that because Princess Luna is more powerful than Shining Armour when it comes to magic, I mean she is one of the two rulers of Equestria after all, if she wasn't powerful, this sadfic probably exist per say? Again, not trying to pick a fight, I'm just voicing my thoughts, is all :)

[@MischiefHowlVA]

One more step to Luna becoming Nightmare Moon. If this was canon I would've really disliked Celestia. Who knows how many times Luna tried to search for Antumbra. This story is really sad and makes me want to forever hug Antumbra.

[@ForgottenDaydreamer]

I know right...

[@derpyhooves4287]

MischiefHowlVA You know that's probably queen chrysalis right?

[@ladyren1575]

Derpy Hooves yes she is

[@indigo-streak9912]

Derpy Hooves an ancestor. Antumbra is Chrysalis' ancestor

[@oliverc1790]

That my friend I can agree

[@hoganhogan952]

I cried a little when antumbra said "Mother will find me..." It was just too much T_T

[@him_shift111]

I actually think, right after the Canterlot Wedding, Luna headed off to where she saw Antumbra/Chrysalis being blown off.

[@3323galaxy]

Well she stays up all night if I were Luna I would sleep :T

[@grayeaglej]

This was beautifully read Miss Scribbler. And this story fits so well the Chrysalis/Changeling cannon as well as Luna's character. And even Celestia's actions fit her character as well even though she was completely and absolutely wrong in her decisions. If Antumbra/Chrysalis had been immediately accepted as Luna's daughter and a member of the royal family she would not have suffered the abuse of being confined and also she would have been "fed" by the adoration of hundreds of guards, staff, subjects, friends, etc and so Luna would not have been bearing that entire burden and therefore would have recovered from the beginning and not become depleted. Celestia had her sister's welfare at heart but instead did irreparable harm. :(

[@PlagueBunny]

Celestia needs to stop taking ponies children she has a bad habit of that.

[@derpyhooves4287]

None of Your Business

[@milimnotfound8251]

first Nyx from Twilight now Antumbra from Luna!

[@yuzukirose3998]

4G KILLER who is Nyx?

[@JazzyWaffles]

Yuzuki Rose Nyx is the protagonist of "Past Sins" and its many sequels. It is one of thw most popular fics ever, being written in 2011 and rewritten in 2012 after Season 2 aired. It's about a cult trying to revive Nightmare Moon. They succeed, but the process is interrupted and the ritual creates Nyx instead, a filly version of Nightmare Moon with none of the memories. Twilight has to keep her a secret from Celestia, but once Celestia finds out everything goes downhill fast enough to make Sonic the Hedgehog look slow by comparison. It's an AMAZING fic and I definitely recommend it and its sequels.

[@SammyNeverEver]

Jazzy Waffles it starts ok, and the ending is fine too, but the middle REALLY DRAGS, AND DRAGS.

[@SasamiTM]

that's kind of how I took it. Luna's desire for someone to love her somehow affected the spell that created Antumbra, to create a creature that hungers for love, who's form reflects holes in Luna's heart, and who can hide in plain sight the way Luna must have hid her own sadness. Hmm of course this now makes me wonder what did happen with Luna during the Canterlot Wedding episode. Was she really not there, or just unable to fight her daughter?

[@rainbowcat6905]

Celestia basically put her subjects in more danger WOW GREAT JOB CELESTIA

[@viriyananda]

"The Equestria is gonna destroyed because of your" I reference to encanto

[@sunnydays8488]

the people who wrote this should make a pony movie, because I would so watch it!

[@brooklynnbusch]

Ender Girl i will try to make one, im not the owner though

[@sunnydays8488]

Gingersnapcat thanks :)

[@brooklynnbusch]

i hardly know how to animate so ts probably gonna be a comic, FOR NOW!

[@sunnydays8488]

still I know its gonna be awesome!

[@JustMe-gu8ew]

Ender Girl I can animate (a bit) bbbuuuttt I'll need voice actors a animating thing etc ssssooooooo yeah plus it will take FOREVER!!!!

[@ForgottenDaydreamer]

"Her heart wasn't made of stone..." (Laughs) YEAH FLIPPING RIGHT!!!!!!!!!!!

[@princesschrysalis7121]

👂

[@squidgiemctentacles5265]

'Dear Princess Celestia There are reasons why people hate you. And though you were acting for the best of your kingdom, this is still one of them Have a muffin'

[@RedactedText]

Lol

[@informationyes]

its fanfiction

[@squidgiemctentacles5265]

@@informationyes Nah man I thought this was real life, they just hiding the ponies at the center of the Earth.

[@Blazing_Emblem_Natsumi]

I wonder who wrote that… 🤔🧁

[@fabianbonilla1421]

- Derpy Hooves

[@ladyren1575]

The ending when Luna shouted was Speeschless. Celestia's got what she deserved!

[@ashleyvanhammer3448]

Most of the "sadfic" stories just depress the fire out of me but this was a very interesting idea that pulls more at empathy and compassion, conflicting ideals of right and wrong. A very well-written piece which takes the backstory of the series into darker territory in a mature and unusual fashion. Kudos to the original author and to Scribbler as well for a powerful reading.

[@Nada_Thinks]

you know, this is somehow even sadder now with current cannon. The fact that Antumbra could have been spared this fate had they only known what we know now about changelings.

[@ammitthedevourer7316]

This is the first non-"creepypasta" MLP fanfic I've ever heard of, and the first I've listened to. It was wonderful, don't get me wrong, and the narration was great, but I'm not gonna lie, the end was jumpscare city, lol. I know that it was intended to be like that, but wow. It was kind of like watching a toaster: you keep expecting the loud, sudden thing to happen, but it still makes you jump whenever it happens. Like I said, though, I know the loudness was intentional, and it did add to the story. Wonderful job! :D

[@remcat03]

What?! How could the author end it like that?! We still don't know how Antumbra's name became Chrysalis, and how she got her hive! It's a good reading, but... I demand the answers to these questions.

[@remcat03]

***** Yeah I guess...

[@JonathonWilder]

I believe Antumbra is supposed to be the ancestor of Queen Chrysalis.

[@jasontodd3035]

remcat03 I LOVE YOUR PROFILE PICTURE

[@remcat03]

Jason Todd Thank you.

[@jasontodd3035]

remcat03 jeff the killer and a poney. its like BADASS+SWEETNESS=AMAZING

[@diamondinthesky4771]

All Antumbra needed was someone to show her how to share love instead of take it. Too bad Aunt Celestia was too much in a "I'm Frollo but a Horse" mode to think of that.

[@austiny6512]

Man.....so many emotions in this story and Luna oh man To see Luna in so much pain and sorrow like that broke my heart and what Celestia did was EXTREMELY way to far even for her oh poor Luna I don't blame you for never wanting to see your sister again after that

[@14nsmusic44]

My theory was this was not black magic but alchemy like the homunculus

[@KimmiGeraciHarmonyAngel]

It made me cry at the thought of your child being taken from u... I can't imagine the pain Luna felt nore do I want to find out

[@Xx-jh7iv]

I like how the writer left the end up to interpretation, really shows the signs of a good writer

[@predawarriorstudios5787]

I can totally see this scenario: *Chrysalis (as an adult) in her hive, sitting on her throne has a flash back to when she was banished and saying to herself; "Mother will find me" unaware that she was saying it also* Changeling drone: "My queen?" *Chrysalis would look down from her throne to see the drone* Chrysalis: "What is it!?" *The changeling drone ducks his head not wanting to feel his queen's wraith* "I heard you talking to yourse-" *Chrysalis would quickly changes the subject* Chrysalis: How are the prisoner's pods?" "The Princesses and the mane 6's pods are secured, your majesty." Chrysalis: "Good." "All though when we captured Luna, she called you "Antumbra" so-" Chrysalis: *quickly turns her head and narrows her eyes at the drone* "That name, means nothing to me now, and you will never mention that name too me again!" *The drone would nod in agreement and give Chrysalis a confused look* Chrysalis: *waves her hoof dismissively at the drone* "Leave me." "Your high-" *Chrysalis would give a threatening growl at the drone,* Chrysalis: "I said 'Leave me!'" *The drone would fly off leaving Chrysalis alone* Chrysalis: *silently to herself as a tears qould go down her face* "Mother will find me, mother will find me, mother will find me, mother................................................... Didn't find me."

[@benhuether5474]

I just hope they will be reunited in a later fanfic.

[@benhuether5474]

I also hope Chrysalis and Celestia will make amines.

[@Goldfiend]

Wow! That was like totally wicked epic! It got so emotional and intense at the end! The kind of thing I would expect about a changeling story. Your soft accent does so much justice to your reading. I look forward to hearing more stories read by you...

[@mouseonthestreets8675]

Dammit celestia what is it with you a banishing people

[@MillietheShaymin]

Yeah Tia poor Luna and antumbra

[@jellymintoro756]

if this actually happened in the show then it would have been much sadder...poor chrysalis (even doe her name is antumbra in this sadfic)

[@lunasnightshade]

Chrysalis is the daughter of antumbra ( that is what I think it would make sense since this is before nightmaremoon and the changlings are not immortal so it would make sense that chrysalis is in antumbras daughter) ( sorry for my spelling)

[@jellymintoro756]

Kaitlyn Foley ooohh

[@jordanechols4412]

Kaitlyn Foley

[@jordanechols4412]

Kaitlyn Foley

[@yourmom-tr7gq]

Dylan Cabrera JUST LOOK AT CHRYSALIS IN THE THUMBNAIL! POOR HER

[@ps1hagrid823]

It would be funny if Celestia opened the doors and there was Luna trying to beat dark souls 1,2 and 3 for the past 1000 years

[@flibbleflabble4868]

I never would have thought Celestia would ever do something that cruel.

[@cheeryrozetea]

Same

[@devonrussell7344]

That was amazing! With your voice and all, screaming(Luna, Celestia) and just acting you were them and how they would felt... just amazing.

[@adomaniacs]

Eh.. I cried for a minute or two.. Celestia should be the one sent to the moon - in fact, THE SUN.

[@nightshade-warroir6915]

she actually does get banished to the sun at one point in the MLP: FIM series XDDD in the finbal episode of season one, when luna is turned normal, celestia APPEARS from the sun as it rises XD like luna APPEARED from the moon XD

[@adomaniacs]

Nightshade-Warrior Enviromentalist YAAAY. SHE DESERVED IT! :3

[@nightshade-warroir6915]

pftt I guess she does in a way XD

[@benhuether5474]

But she thought it was slowly killing her only sister!!!

[@uhhhhhhhhhi9223]

Ben Huether Still, a thought is not a reality until you make it one. Celestia CHOSE to make that a reality, just like Luna chose to take care of Atumbra. Also Celestia may be her sister but Luna should have made those choices, NOT celestia. Anyways, good day.

[@libergarcia4886]

Welp..sunbuts an asshole,Luna might be so sad to never leave her room and in a few years she will come back to be known as a changling queen. So honestly...this is sunbute,I mean celestias fault.

[@puppyraptor5765]

The ending with Luna screaming scared the SHIT outta me

[@v.j.bartlett]

I have to admit it did strike me that even in cannon the moment Luna starts making friends Celesta moves to block her. Example Luna learns how to dream walk and starts making friends because she finally gets to be with the ponies for part of the day and Celesta announces that they are retiring in favour of Twilight. Um, really Celesta? Did you ask your sister about this? You know did you ask whether she wants to retire the moment she starts getting friends? Sometimes I think Celesta is jealous of Luna getting any of the attention and she'd rather go without the attention herself than share it with her sister. Talk about cutting off your own nose to spite your face.

[@Artist-yu5qe]

This story unbelievably still holds up even with all the current seasons I really wish the story was Cannon I really wish the story would be addressed within the show because then we would really be able to see chrysalis giving into friendship

[@jeanwing5752]

This explains why Luna did not interfere with chrissy when she came to canterlot

[@LadyAndromeda1234]

In a way, Celestia caused the problem herself. By locking Antumbra in Luna's chambers and forbidding her from leaving, she ensured the only person Antumbra could passively feed off of was Luna herself. With a wider array of ponies, the draining could have probably gone unnoticed. She also ensured her hatred of Celestia and co-dependence with Luna. So much could have been avoided if not for Celestia's own fear.

[@Limbocats]

I AM CRYING I WANT TO HERE MORE OF THE STORY POOR PONYS ( antombra to )

[@arkinstone7165]

How Luna became nightmare moon When Celestia returned lina approached her and demanded to know where Antumbra was. So Celestia told her........ After a few days/weeks Luna became more and more angry at Celestia until eventuallu she turned into nightmare moon in pure rage and hatred for Celestia. Celestia was forced to banish her sister to the moon for a thousand years, Celestia wept and regretted sending Antumbra away because it had caused lunas insanity. When Celestia went to find Antumbra so she could try and help luna, she looked everywhere. but she couldnt find Antumbra. lunas insanity was also pushed over by the tantabus thats my theory of how it went down afterwards!

[@JonathonWilder]

I personally love this fanfiction, the emotion and heartache of the choices made can be clearly seen. Yet I will stand by that readers/listeners are not truly seeing the fanfiction for what it is, a tragic tale of unhealthy love that is parasitic in nature. The origin changlings, the dark magic used to create them, and the part they played in Luna's fall and corruption into Nightmare Moon. A creature created out of loneliness and sorrow from one seeking love that Luna felt she was did not otherwise have. Celestia made many mistakes, all of which would likely lead to farther division between her sister, the first being allowing Luna to keep her creation as a daughter. Antumbra may have not intended or meant to hurt the mother she loved, yet this does not change the fact that she was harming Luna. She was draining her and if Celestia had not taken Antumbra... Luna WOULD have been killed. Not only that, but the relationship between mother and daughter was extremely unhealthy. Antumbra may have been one that Luna could have give and received loved from, yet it was farther reinforcing the Luna's separation from her subjects and her older sister.

[@naye3488]

When you have read sick I thought that Luna has been 'mated' and had a child of her own but actually made life out of magic. -_- *sweat-dropped*

[@777Rowen]

I understand both princesses perspectives. Luna loves her daughter, and wanted to do anything she could to protect her. But she created her from dark magic, and created a changling. Anton bra was slowly draining her mother’s strength by consuming her love. Celestia loves Luna, and would do anything to protect her sister even if it meant breaking her heart and taking her daughter away. Such a tragic yet intriguing tale.

[@skittleswolf2498]

I can relate to luna in so many ways loneliness can lead to depression and feeling unappreciated by friends or family if this was actually how luna turned into nightmare moon i would probably hate celestia but anyway great fan fic reading as always

[@BlitztheMutt]

From this story, I think it is safe to say that should Celestia had not been so cruel to Antumbra (please correct me if the spelling is wrong), the Changling attack might have not occurred. This being that only Celestia was captured and tied up and Luna (as far as we know) was not. If Celestia had even shown her niece any form of real love and affection, she might have grown up as a real princess in Equestria

[@kimberliemessinger8986]

Poor Antumbra :( and poor Luna

[@faith5485]

Awww . . . this is amazing; all of your readings are! It's wonderful and captivating!

[@chicka906543]

What? That's it? You can't end a story just like that!

[@Woodsstories]

If something like this were to happen, it would be the perfect excuse for the writers to give Luna a larger part. After all, she knows the symbiote's power better than anypony (except perhaps Sombra). Now that would be a terrific opener for season 5 or 6. Something would have happened at the end of the previous season, that made Twi very angry and perhaps untrusting of Celestia. In the opener, she would start behaving harshly towards her mentor, until she became a new version of NNM.

[@spookychan7189]

Bro, I remember when I was little I listened to this fanfic and was moved. This was honestly one of the best fanfics I've listened to in a long time.

[@snowdust5382]

one of my favorite fan;fics of all time! this fic is on a vary small list composed of grand fan;fics!

[@destruction42k]

+Isaac Elrod You have good taste!

[@imoon1193]

I want to see part 2 of this and I'm really curious what will happen next 😮 !?!

[@Bewildering3630]

Sadly, There's no part 2

[@lovezoojoy4189]

I agree with super gamer, maybe when they met again or maybe when chrysalis have child's of her own? I mean think about Luna see her daughter again 💖❤️💖

[@lunasnightshade]

+Velociraptor516 AKA Heather watch pest control and u will see y she was not there

[@fablegardens2052]

it nice to finally find someone that i can just play through the list without having to listen to a clop fic. thank you.

[@ranigoldenberg6962]

I love this story I wish there was a sequel where Luna and her child are reunited

[@CV2069ful]

Wow.... I don't really know what to say, Why would princess Celestia do that? Wait what if that's why luna wanted to take over? What if that's what happened? Maybe she didn't want to just become the only princess... But revenge is what she wanted most, Poor luna.....

[@Jordan-wc6nh]

What was Celestial supposed to do? Let Luna wither so much she died?!

[@pupperpalace9889]

@@Jordan-wc6nh Yeah, but she essentially abandoned a child in a harsh environment who had no ill intentions and couldn't control the powers they had (nor did they even know about them in the first place).

[@ashedd3441]

POOR ANTUMBRA! I I were her I would reveal myself to celestia after I take canterlot and Get my REVENGE!

[@DizzyBlackUA]

Brilliant arrangement and acting! Seriously, this was better than most of profesional audiobooks I've listened to. Great job!

[@DragorKing]

Makes sense why Luna was nowhere to be seen when Changelings attacked Canterlot. She couldn't fight her own daughter.

[@michaelm9975]

According to the comic book series Chrysalis and the Changelings were created when Star Swirl contaminated an underwater cave reservoir. With some liquid based potions, but that was probably before this fic was written

[@Jeffthecreepyastafan]

The comics are B canon that means there not canon unless addressed or show in the show itself or the creators say so otherwise.

[@medina6881]

wow that cliffhanger. I really wanna know what happened to to little philly

[@strawberryguy9654]

She raised army then mlp provided us a canterlot wedding

[@lunasnightshade]

+Strawberryguy antumbra is chrysalis mother ( that is what I think )

[@JustMe-gu8ew]

Kaitlyn Foley I believe that and I believe that crystals

[@JustMe-gu8ew]

is her as well

[@ladyren1575]

Filly*

[@ladyren1575]

This is a better story to make up why Luna became Nightmare Moon.

[@TheDragonNinjaLord]

This is a VERY logical explanation for many holes still left in the timeline.

[@josegar30]

Damn. 1, this is a great narration, it gave me mix feelings. My heart know the ending was right but my head is mad of what happen. 2. What beat did you use near the end? Sounded like violins

[@jeanwing5752]

OH my god I Need a part 2 😥😥😥😥

[@bloodstonedrawer2445]

Ikr

[@IIINorrinRadd]

YEAH!!

[@timberstroke4128]

This needs a part 2

[@pokemonu.s.a8016]

omg me to

[@BeeGaY_boi]

hej

[@MrAnthonyIII]

I understand Celestia's reasoning; she did what made sense, or at least what she thought was for the best. Clearly Luna was unwell

[@avalon6060]

I actualy like Chrysalis more than any Alicorn. I didn't like Luna and Celestia. But after this story I like luna slight more. And Idk if it is on this channel alredy or maybe it will never be. But Part 2..... would realy sound nice. I hope thats not to much trouble.

[@wwolfneo]

this was outstanding! i love that last 2 scenes the most! you did a wonderful job scribbler

[@kartervibesandstuff]

I feel so bad for Luna and I will never forgive Celestia!

[@SuperPet221]

thank you for reading these fanfic's it helps me calm down and draw!

[@kitty_slayz_it6833]

At the end it was a little heart breaking for me because Celestia took Luna's daughter away from her.

[@thedemoninside8338]

I know this is out of context, but is that Bleach music I hear at 39:40??????

[@wolfgirl4678]

If I was Luna this would be me"SISTER I WILL FIND MY ANTUMBRA AND U SHALL BE PUNISHED"Luna turns into nightmare moon and sends celestia to the sun

[@wolfgirl4678]

And I now hate her on this not in the show

[@MegaTrio]

I love Cookiez Antumbra was literally killing Luna. celestia was trying to help her.

[@Erosophany]

That last part always makes me cry... ;~;

[@JonathonWilder]

This is a fanfiction that shows Princess Celestia not only in the role of an older sister but that of a ruler, though also very flawed in her own way. She could see what was happening to Luna, even though her little sister could not. I do not believe Antumbra meant to hurt the one she called mother, but she was made with dark and evil magic... formed in desperation, and by one longing for love.

[@obliviontheabysslord9251]

I don't take lightly to this abuse tords a defenceless baby changeling!!!

[@kulehulfer4385]

The name of the fic, the image, the beginning dialouge, I'm getting scared of the form of "love" she's gonna receive.

[@89BlackGatomon]

So Mindblowing... I hear your video yesterday... Totaly was thinking all day today on work about it... Thanks for this amazing work =D

[@breadcrumbs3530]

I gotta say, I really liked the moral dilemma in this fic. Taking a child away from a parent is certainly one of the most egregious acts anyone can commit. At the same time, however, when that child is essential a parasite that is slowly killing the parent because it would die if it’s host left them for an extended period of time, the lines become very blurred.

[@SasamiTM]

Very good as always, I especially like the character in Luna and Antumbra's voices, you can hear the emotion in them both, be it the affection between them or the fear or anger at Celestia. The one big question I have is does this mean Chrysalis is Antumbra or one of her decedents?

[@fashioncats5music963]

poor Luna...

[@eqservs]

Fashioncats5music Poor Antumbra too

[@RossPitSharkHunter]

Eh. It needed a better Celestia. Because Celestia wasn't this cruel.

[@destroyerblackdragon]

Banishing her is such a huge extreme. I'm assuming this was written before season 6 because en-light of some recent events we learn chagelings can in fact live among ponies with no harm. But it's a fan fic so I'll let it slide. Still feels out of character for Celestia though.

[@EFMRP2011]

What happens to Auntumbra????? Is there another part??? This is so sad!!!

[@annakatherinemccrary2945]

Poor Antumbra

[@anoralurlene851]

Celestia, if you love your sister you'll let her keep Antumbra!!

[@hahahahahahahahaa6580]

I'm so happy I found this story again. It's got to be one of my favorites.

[@bowserjrrules1]

this changes my thoughts of this fandom. i love it

[@noblesix4322]

I am only at the beginning song and I can tell I will cry my eyes out

[@dawnforest1506]

Oh dear lord. So Celestia separates a mother and child, causing the mother to give into darkness, THEN SHE PUNISHES HER?! Celestia is the one at fault! Not Luna! God damn it this is such a good fic. And did I hear some of a Bleach OST in the background? That soundtrack holds a lot of memories for me, and it suited the story so well!

[@ceciliayanger7070]

It is celestia's fault how dare she do that to a child I thought she cares for ponies no matter what look or form

[@nenailicbutko797]

😩😩😩😩😩😩😩😩

[@nenailicbutko797]

😒

[@sophieowen235]

why Celestia u a monster u spree her and then punish her

[@killergear505]

damn the last scene made me cry

[@katthoreson8406]

Give us a part two, if you don't have one, you should make one, that was amazing! And sad

[@willroarty1512]

So does luna search for Antumbra or not I must have an answer.

[@izzyb1525]

hey how about this. I do a art about this story and when i'm finish it will answer your question XP

[@willroarty1512]

thank you

[@izzyb1525]

your welcome

[@inoginoino]

Will Roarty me too I need ANSWERS

[@augamer3264]

This is why luna is best princess.

[@poprocks1782]

I'm watching this at 3am, and Luna's yelling at the end !are me jump. XD

[@kbjones3535]

SAME XD

[@musicalknight4900]

so... Luna wanted a parasite as a daughter. huh. coolstorybro.

[@aquaticnight4261]

First off Chrisalis is not a SILLY “Parasite” she just wants to FEEL love ❤️

[@sunnyskies3969]

I barely remember this one. I'm surprised I do. Another lovely one.

[@TheCrystallizedVoid]

isn't the song at the beginning called mother? or at least something like that? all i know is that the chipettes sang it in the cartoon

[@idrawzeponies9392]

You read so amazingly!! This was a great story!

[@novaskies4282]

Another great reading! Thanks for doing these they're quite awesome!

[@cooler1679]

This was beautiful. And Antumbra is so cuuuuuuuuuuuute.