Post Malone « I fall apart » Tiny Desk concert

[@georgemathai1014]

02:10 bassist vibing to the strings is what we're all feeling too.

[@I__Love_Lamp]

I absolutely respect any artist that can go raw like this! Mad respect!!!

[@UkMack-m3d]

He doesn’t even have the best voice but there’s so much passion and purity to his songs live 🙏 highly rate this geeza

[@EthanfromEngland-]

He has a great voice, he's sick @@UkMack-m3d

[@Eleven5Sobriety]

Rest Peacefully Tina Marie Stewart, July 3rd 2018 she was my GF and this was our song.. Fly High Baby Girl.. #fuckfetanyl

[@Angoat698]

You are a goat, keep head up

[@craig5222]

😢

[@mattz5275]

My deepest condolences 🙏🏻

[@ElijahPeterson-s8u]

I'm sorry for your loss

[@yellib7651]

I'm sorry man. Love to you 💗

[@taniamarie693]

I loved the original when I first heard it, but this one. Omg absolutely beautiful. When them strings came in, tears down my face. I love the cello.

[@johnwaynecannon7236]

I loved Mac Miller at the 11 minute Mark with the full symphony sound at NPR. Mac is still the man and then the one your anniversary was tear-jerking.. thank you, NPR

[@Murrell84]

When those strings hit!!! 🤌

[@frankmarquis3160]

Great version , I Can feel the rawness !!

[@alejandrogalfredo8832]

Amazing tears always on my eyes every time i hear i fall apart

[@marktube4377]

This is one of the most beautiful things I’ve ever heard.

[@GrahamWillis-of4md]

You right their just discovered this gem and would have given anything to have been one of the lucky one sat in that close intimate session the orchestra adds such a depth and tone to the song.

[@OpticsN3rv3]

this is by far the most beautiful performance of Post doing this song I have ever seen! Raw talent and heart going into everything you do at its finest!

[@jenniferhicks78]

This song reminds me so much of my on/off bf. He’s hurt me so much and I know I’ve caused him pain as well. He has no idea of how much I still love him. Sadly, daily we are drifting further away and it’s killing me.

[@magicalmuffin]

I'm only in my 20's and I know I have a lot of learning to do when it comes to love, but I've felt the drifting apart from someone I loved. She moved on and had kids with someone else, it kills me to see what could've been. Grab a hold and lay it out, you either rekindle something or speed up the inevitable. Best of luck to you

[@bigpapalo432]

Whoever broke his heart to make this song thank you

[@KizWhalifa.]

His ex right before he got famous

[@refcoronado7931]

Bitter sweet type

[@davidwing3386]

your Mumma

[@jasonsmith2380]

I can't help but be amazed by the musicians who make this song amazing. Mr Malone is almost a bystander in the process. The music industry is a very interesting thnng. Big ups Mr Malone.

[@lonnypaalman3805]

This is the best song from Post!

[@weshansen8682]

If only Post played Magic as well as he sings. He keeps avoiding playing me. One day young man....

[@Patches-0-Houlahan]

Beautiful voice!!! I think i just fell in love ❤

[@MrBlef666]

Better than original from his album imho

[@beschorner-creative]

Yes!!!

[@danielmontford3533]

Its more raw & real definitely

[@drizzy9421]

Definitely!!!

[@timdirkes1357]

why haven't I seen this sooner! Amazing 👍

[@thered1991]

Let's be honest he doesn't have technique but his charisma is the key here.

[@Byun_David]

It's called raw talent my G and sometimes that's all that it takes + the courage to be vulnerable with it 💯

[@rinashi73]

Huge Mac 2009 vibes

[@wrxham3695]

How?

[@SJM7777]

​@@wrxham3695the vibe bro, the vibe...

[@michaelcdelasoul]

Perfect vibe comparison

[@XXXINSOMNIAXXX]

Rip Mac

[@caseyobrien1133]

They'd say any song with a damaged white man with damaged lungs and drug habits with a piano above middle c and a small string section is that one song they heard in high school

[@roxy0729]

This man never disappoints! 🥰😍😘

[@alfredoeguino]

I love this guy ❤

[@luizvidal8420]

I love ths song forever on my ll lifes on linestars. Thksbroo ure amzng ❤

[@Samuel.H922]

Post Malones voice is amazing!

[@burgessbrooks4435]

Dope!! Songs lyrics are top shelf!!!

[@traviswalden7765]

Dude sounds like a fkn angel 😇 😢❤

[@Ample17]

He didn't hit a f*cking note without his auto tune. Like the guy, but this was terrible.

[@jeffeyjeffey8]

@@Ample17 you're genuinely tone deaf if he didn't hit a note haha

[@Notnac]

@@Ample17at the beginning of this set he said he lost his voice because he was in the middle of tour and came by for the tiny desk set

[@dannypankhurst7359]

For anyone thats says posty cant sing need to watch this!❤

[@gambuch]

He cant i was disappointed rather hear the song with all the autotune

[@I__Love_Lamp]

@@gambuch then I guess you'll always be a sheep because you will almost never hear an artist going raw like this!

[@gambuch]

@@I__Love_Lamp it just sounds bad is all im saying hes work is not the same , t-pain can sing even doe his music is all autotune but the dude can really sing post just dont got the a good voice

[@MGMcnutt]

@@gambuch he has a nice voice. not a super powerful one but its good. youre aloud to have your opion tho

[@gambuch]

@@MGMcnutt thank you sir

[@ashash7490]

Love love love this song. Trying not to ugly cry. 😊

[@bigpapalo432]

2024 he still should make a official music video for I fell apart song 🎧

[@ed8054]

I feel like he shouldve sang it in a lower key. He seems to be straining a bit for those high notes sometimes.

[@Ample17]

He can't sing without his pitch correct effect on his voice (aka auto tune) thats the reason. Basically he's just not a good singer.

[@ed8054]

@@Ample17 I definitely dont think hes a great singer, but I would say its quite clear hes struggling more here due to trying to sing the higher key at a softer volume.

[@Ample17]

@@ed8054 As most people. Higher notes are harder to control and sustain. The rest is really hardly singing, if you define singing by hitting and holding certain notes for a certain amount of time. I have nothing against the guy but I know know why he relies so heavily on auto tune and it's kinda sad, that you don't have to be able to sing anymore these days to be a singer, lol.

[@ed8054]

@@Ample17 I mean sure. Your basically just agreeing with my assessment and adding unrelated comments to insult the dude too.

[@Ample17]

@@ed8054Incorrect. There's a difference between someone having to strain to hit some notes and someone being an outright bad singer, not in control of the most basic techniques. We share some common ground in our statements, but if you really think I just latched on to what you said and added "insults" you either have a problem with reading comprehension or inflated ego. Or both. Good day.

[@justincornejo6211]

Real ones know this one hit different during his 2023 tour

[@davidwing3386]

i thought Post Malone was so so, im seeing this for the fist time. when this guy is raw he's amazing

[@JacobMcDaniel-ui2qe]

Love you post

[@veronicamozee]

This is amazing! 😍

[@yellib7651]

Baby youre so sweet! Hugs xoxo

[@anthonykilburn9302]

Now that's how you sing a break up song!!! 😎❤️🎤🎶🎶🎶👍

[@francielledallagnese2025]

Alguém faz esse vídeo com tradução please

[@JMind85]

He didn’t use not ONE back up singer. You see them at the end just vibin…

[@jilltaylor6093]

He's Amazing ❤

[@graylotusflower]

Beautiful

[@RealScytheyy]

OUUUUUU I FALL APAAART

[@jrsterdis]

Love. Love. Love ❤️

[@GlesgaCeltic1888]

Fuckin luv this song

[@samuelrobles3473]

This really made me cry

[@benjaminallen5608]

Post has some deep songs makes u think about life

[@kingkay3139]

"Tell me you don't love me no more, but I can't let go"💔💔💔

[@TRIPLESTACK-R9]

Theres a reason this song goes hard every guy has been though this I know I have worst pain cut my arm off and its not like when you love someone

[@thomasmorris61633]

I feel you bruh.

[@caevv6026]

why does he have his whole mouth shining like a jewelry shop? did he get punched all teeth out or is this a common thing in america?

[@Korrie26]

Love this MAN

[@johnwaynecannon7236]

Man, post. why you do me so emotional like that?

[@mofine23]

he needs lemon water and honey to clear that throat

[@bodezzy212]

One of the dopest Marine Corps songs ever! I was in Iraq the same time Major Corrado was ⚒️

[@RD-pn2nv]

Why is this only in 480p? This should be a crime

[@TimiElvis]

I wish I could make music with you ❤

[@Rumbleinazoo]

Fire

[@XsalvadorianX]

🔥🔥

[@shaneenantar1861]

❤❤❤

[@rumersonlaeno6930]

Damn....

[@colerobinson2628]

That alchemist om the keys!?

[@thomashall3485]

He can actually sing so why use auto tune postie ayyy 🤙🏼

[@rekososa3175]

My ex fooled me twice and left me scarred literally 😢

[@DoloresRichardson-n8q]

Martin Eric Jones Jose Johnson Jose

[@maxdegrom6907]

Alejandro aranda's version is better. facts

[@toddupchurch1028]

Anyone and everyone has a platform now. Garbage on a pedestal and it gets called a trophy.

[@kwhitfield6684]

🎊 *promosm*

[@btizzle3657]

I don’t like his voice

[@rnnskal7480]

@@btizzle3657 your sensibility … but let positive comments here .. if you don’t like please go

[@btizzle3657]

@@rnnskal7480 no I can comment what I want to. You go.

[@brandistump2137]

I love his voice!! .. but to your comment, I feel like if you are going to take time to leave a comment on an artists’ work, it should be more of a positive vibe .. but then again my father told me that if I didn’t have anything nice to say about another person then I really shouldn’t say anything.. and that my attention would probably be more valued elsewhere. …However my mother told me that opinions are like assholes …I think everyone has 1 of those!! ..so there’s that too.. I think there is probably somewhere more fitting to discuss what you don’t like about Posty in any case ❤ I think he’s refreshing!! The fact that he can jump miles from one genre to another while being accepted by so many artists says a lot more though! 😊

[@btizzle3657]

@@brandistump2137 if I want to leave my opinion i will! You can leave yours too as you have done. Have a great day I know I am while listening to something else.

[@PopCultureAntics]

This is him at like 20 percent power his voice was damaged from touring when this dropped

[@groverstreet7128]

Disappointed in his voice thought he was a better singer than that and looks like a child drew on his face. But he’s ball’n in dough and im not so 😂

[@FrancoisGagne-bh3kl]

he,s so bad hahahahaha its incredible that he has sucess its just incredible

[@GrahamWillis-of4md]

I enjoy that his voice is straining gives the song a raw emotional feel which as its about heartache is quite fitting. Stop hating, their is a thing called constructive criticism but suppose its true it l is easier to break something than create it.

[@SteFinch81]

Damn. Lotta difference between this and the auto tuned version. Disappointing, actually.

[@Youarelovewalk]

You sound like a hater

[@Brew-Tality]

Nah i love posty, but he is right... posty is able to write hits like its nothing and he gives everything but if you rate his technical skills as a singer he cant Keep up.

[@pedromendonca5964]

He was on the middle of his tour then. Nearly out of voice

[@salex354]

@@Brew-Talityi feel with this, its less the technical skill and the raw emotion. Its clear this song hits a chord with him with every performance he does live, he always pours himself out and shows himself as vulnerable

[@vzeller]

​​​@@Brew-TalityYou clearly don't understand how the voice as an instrument works and what it takes to be great all the the time. It's a physical impossibility. He was on tour. I'm not sticking up for him. I'm stating a fact when it comes to the physical demands of touring and not getting sleep. Unless your name is Chris Stapleton, you don't have an unlimited supply of vocal power. He misses zero notes in this version. His technical skills are more than fine. He's just singing tired. This is something that every singer has to do. He's also not getting any help from the mix. He's basically singing into the room with zero delay or reverb. The mix is just there to pick up the sound. This is a great performance relative to his exhaustion. He makes it an emotional delivery. It's so easy to troll touring artists and find clips that aren't optimal when almost everything they do is filmed. Get some perspective on how live performance works. If he had a mix with all the effects they use in the studio, you wouldn't even notice a difference.

[@rudemooddudehamburg]

His Voice isnt good