Will MUMBAI Fail as Other Cities Develop in INDIA ||😟||

#MumbaiDevelopment #UrbanChallenges #cityplanning
Welcome to our channel! In this thought-provoking video, we delve into the question: "Will Mumbai Fail as Other Cities Develop?" Join us as we explore the dynamics of urban development, the challenges faced by Mumbai, and the potential consequences of neglecting its growth.
As one of India's most vibrant and populous cities, Mumbai has always been a center of economic and cultural importance. However, with the rapid development and modernization of other cities in India, concerns about Mumbai's future have been raised. Will it be able to keep pace with the changing times, or will it falter and lose its standing?
Join us on this eye-opening journey as we analyze the key factors contributing to Mumbai's potential struggle. We discuss urban planning, infrastructure, environmental issues, and socioeconomic aspects that impact the city's growth. Through expert insights and data-driven analysis, we aim to shed light on the challenges Mumbai faces and the possible outcomes.
Sources and Links
memumbai.com/t...
www.mid-day.co...
economictimes....
www.outlookind...
www.newindiane...
indianexpress....
timesofindia.i...
news.abplive.c...
scroll.in/arti...
www.indiatimes...
🔔 Join this channel to get access to perks:
/ @powertrain
OUR OTHER CHANNELS
⚪VLOG CHANNEL - / @aakashbhavsar2342
⚪FOOTAGE DEMOCRACY - / @footagedemocracy3663
⚪SHORTS CHANNEL - / @powershorts1068
FOLLOW US ON
⚪INSTAGRAM 1 - / aakash_rb
⚪INSTAGRAM 2- / powertrain_yt
⚪FACEBOOK - / powertrainofficial
⚪TWITTER - / powertrain_yt
⚪DISCORD - / discord
_____________________________________________________________________
INTRO MUSIC IF PRESENT - LEMMiNO - A THOUSAND YEARS
• LEMMiNO - A Thousand W...
CC BY-SA 4.0

[@TJSaw]

I’m a Mumbaikar and I want other cites to develop, as that will mean less people flocking to Mumbai. Mumbai is now at saturation point. Other cities have to pull their weight now.

[@renny841]

Sir being a Mumbaikar myself you need to know there is lot of reverse migration happening from Mumbai now esp educated youths. We ourselves moved to Bangalore 4 yrs back and as far as we know there is a big population of Ex Mumbaikar here. But I will miss Mumbai forever.

[@akshayballal6683]

That's a bullshit argument. Mumbai and Mumbaikars are living in a daydream of living in a India's financial capital. Mumbai is a city with no intent of future growth but living only on the greed of today's capitalism. Absolutely unreal property rents and rates & pathetic commute options will throw people out of this city. And when the moving out population crosses the number of people coming in, the downfall of Mumbai begins. And with above mentioned reasons I don't see this happening in a far future.

[@TJSaw]

@@akshayballal6683 Good. Stay out of Mumbai then.

[@akshayballal6683]

@@TJSaw Yes I will and I am. You better hold on as things will get out of control soon.

[@TJSaw]

@@akshayballal6683 We will manage it here. Don’t need your nonexistent expertise on how to run our city. Don’t worry about us. Just stay the fuck out of Mumbai.

[@jithh]

other cities develop ho jaye to accha hai... Mumbai me crowd thoda kam ho jayega.. environmental drowning of mumbai is far away..

[@utkarshparate3333]

Never... Mumbai ma development kbhi rukega nhi... In future Mumbai will again surpass Delhi... Mumbai is already going through reforms... After they got hold of that it will only grow a lot

[@VitaminProtein4256]

Jab tak BJPee hai tab tak Maharashtra ka kuch nahi ho sakta....

[@mummy5490]

​@@VitaminProtein4256lol..To MVA me investments kui nhi aa rahi thi maharashtra me infact..it was not even top 3..ab fir top 1 me aa gayi.. Maharashtra is running actually due to BJP....

[@Dattebayo3089]

​​@@mummy5490Abe chuitye maharshtra gdp dropped first time since 1960 excluding covid years. First time 21+ companies rejected maharshtra within 2 yrs

[@tomriddle4110]

@@VitaminProtein4256 nah, it was bjp that started work on metro and rind road, chandni chowk etc in Pune. Fadnavis is only hated for his caste but many important projects started under him like mumbai metro, coastal road, samruddhi, Navi Mumbai airport and uddhav opposed all of these, he is also opposing barsu claiming it hurts environment. Also under uddhav maha was 3rd in FDI and now it is 1st again. Also all uddhav and saheb are doing these days is crying for sympathy votes rather than talking about development. Modi is baised to gujrat but so is saheb to baramati.

[@Roman19926]

Mumbai will NEVER fail, because Mumbaikar's professionalism and attitude cannot be replicated anywhere else in the country. ❤

[@samiuddinomer8154]

Wake up and face the reality, don't live in dreams. Is this why mumbai is called the city of dreams because people live in dreams not in reality 🤔 😕 😐 😳 🙄 😑 🤷‍♂️

[@Qwmnenbvctyzioswo]

Chuitye world history padhle empires are built and eventually fade away

[@livingdead233]

Never say Never!

[@herambpatkar]

One major factor is the slow development of navi-mumbai. Navi Mumbai had the potential to be the IT, electronics and even semi conductor hub however pathetic implementation of infra projects Airport, CIDCO metro, vashi bridge expansion, fast train on harbour, airoli to kalyan line, MTHL, uran line led to its downfall..these projects should have been up and running 15 years ago!

[@antoroy5626]

As navi mumbaikar I can relate to this😢

[@swapnilkokamkar212]

People really desire to accommodate in Navi Mumbai but due slow transportation and bad connectivity with Mumbai main land they skip the desire. Why they don't planned connect one phase of upcoming Trans-Harbour sea link to Belapur or Kharghar.

[@sadenb]

@@swapnilkokamkar212 Why can't mumbai itself be the tech hub. Why has Navi mumbai got to do with it.

[@swapnilkokamkar212]

@@sadenb There is one limit for everything, Mumbai ko aur jyada grow karna not possible it's already over crowded and poor infrastructure planning, uppar se jyada budget to Mumbai me land reclaim karne me jyata hai projects ka. Crowd ko segregate karna chaiye ab. Locals trains and roads ke haal dekho.

[@aniketmahajan8422]

​​@@sadenbhat's the mentality between Delhi metropolitan Region and Mumbai Metropolitan region . As Delhi pushes it's development in Outskirts such as Noida and Gurgaon, but people in Mumbai want development only in Mumbai rather than the outskirts ( metropolitan region) such as Navi Mumbai and Thane . Delhi Metropolitan Region segregated all its industries separately in its nearby satellite towns, Mumbai didn't do it even though Mumbai is Teir 1 city the satellite towns are still struggling to enter Tier 3 category, Traveling is most terrible in Mumbai as majority workforce Mumbai is located in its satellite towns

[@debraj2075]

When British left Kolkata was the financial capital not Bombay. Mumbai became financial capital in 1970s around.

[@thechosenone1533]

Both were financial capitals but Kolkata dropped the ball leaving Mumbai as the sole financial capital.

[@shibamdebnath254]

​@@thechosenone1533 yeah for some fucking politicians. Kolkata gdp dops.. Bt still kolkata is in 3rd position .. Bt now kolkata GDP is raising again😎..

[@LapisPhilosophorum222]

​@@shibamdebnath254 Yes thanks to Mamta didi and Bangladeshis

[@mrinmoyM1998]

​@@shibamdebnath254 actually not only the politicians but also the unfortunate event of the Bengal partition decided the fate of Kolkata.

[@shibamdebnath254]

@@LapisPhilosophorum222 that's true..

[@theawesomedas]

I can say that Mumbai is not dying. Mumbai is expanding northward towards its sub urban area and to its neighboring district like Thane.

[@aniruddhamkulkarni7]

I am also Dahisar wasi

[@soham6649]

Even if Mumbai loses its service sector to other cities, the city's geopolitical location still provides it with an unique advantage. It is the closest to the Arabian shipping lanes as well as Europe via the suez canal. The city has a good naval establishment which specialises in building submarines. Mumbai can and should shift it's focus from service industries to specialised high tech manufacturing like semiconductors

[@VitaminProtein4256]

But mudi ne vo bhi chin liya 😢

[@VitaminProtein4256]

@@yumi-e2o people knows who is behind this.

[@swayamsantosh8869]

Mumbai is the Paradise for the unskilled and semiskilled labour crowd. Educated and white collar crowds preferred cities are Bangalore, Hyderabad, Noida, Gurugram etc.

[@swayamsantosh8869]

​@@VitaminProtein4256Mumbai's finance and business activities runs by Gujarati businessmen. Now they are moving to gujrat due to the high operation cost of production. Marathi community is not a business community. They are the consumers and employees community. North Indian crowd gradually moving to Noida and Gurugram cities. And moreover anything, high land cost, slum and chawls are the curse for mumbai.. So the future of mumbai seems to be dark. Mumbai has already reached its peak point and now starts declining..

[@swayamsantosh8869]

​@@VitaminProtein4256Mumbai basically attracts the labour crowds. Educated and skilled workforce are preferring the cities like Bangalore, Hyderabad, Noida, Gurugram etc. No one wants to live a compromised life in mumbai. Slum and chawls are a curse for Mumbai. So dear, don't be emotional, accept the truth.

[@ohgauch]

Its beneficial that other Indian cities are developing. Mumbai alone cant handle such large influx of ppl all over India. This balance tilt is needed. Fail is too harsh a word to use. Mumbai is far from it. For Mumbai key words as you mentioned are Political will and Infrastructure. On both these fronts its has found itself lacking severely.

[@VitaminProtein4256]

Everybody knows which party created political instability in Maharashtra, bjpee

[@VitaminProtein4256]

Jabtak bjpee hai tab tak Maharashtra ko central government loot ti rahegi.

[@The1Ab0veAll]

​@@rohand04good.

[@Indra_Srivastava_]

​@@rohand04 yes right

[@chittodnaresh9568]

Then you have kept your eyes closed. Mumbai has the highest amount of infrastructure projects ongoing which worth are more than all other Indian cities combined. And this is happening because of strong political will only.

[@ruturajsarakte6541]

Development of up and bihar is more important than development of mumbai . If it happens the development of mumbai will automatically happen . As the main reason behind overpopulation is population of up bihar is migrating tu mumbai

[@dreamypiscean6849]

So true. I totally agree 👍👍

[@internetzone165]

As far as ik up crowd now moves more to Delhi ncr and other up cities and the rest prefers south idk about Bihar tho

[@AT-vq6nu]

UP and Bihar people are disgusting they just want to reproduce like animals these two states must be removed from india

[@4chry.mohitshindeshinde179]

Why Maharashtra government should only concentrate on mumbai. Not any fu*king bihar.WHY MAHARASHTRA GOVERNMENT SHOULD LOOK AT BIHAR.

[@JoGoat20]

Mumbai is not dying Other cities are growing. Ours is a nation of 1.42 billion population and urbanisation rate is only going to rise Ofcourse other major cities will grow too. Not everything will be dependent on Mumbai and Delhi alone.

[@VitaminProtein4256]

Looking at the migration from villages to cities, this development is negligible....I mean the number of people migrating from villages to cities is too huge.

[@JoGoat20]

@@VitaminProtein4256 that's how development works. All developed nations have over 70 percent urban population. People will migrate to cities from villages in search of higher income jobs. India currently only have 36 percent urban population and this alone is overloading our cities. We need more Greenfield urban cities as well as planned extensions to existing cities

[@VitaminProtein4256]

@@JoGoat20 but no infrastructure for these migrating people developed by Indian government until now.

[@rohitlambole8581]

​@@VitaminProtein4256already migration has led saturation in major cities, creating slums

[@JoGoat20]

@@VitaminProtein4256 well our urban planning sucks that's why. People can claim overpopulation all they want but we have globally cities like Tokyo which is more populated than Delhi still functions well

[@swapnilkokamkar212]

Thanks for Video. Need to boost Navi Mumbai projects, NAINA project, Navi Mumbai Airport, Harbour line fast track train, International Corporate park at Kharghar also need to create Metro network in Navi Mumbai.

[@Cricketnerd45]

naina city seems hypothetical to me tbh

[@swapnilkokamkar212]

@@Cricketnerd45 Yes agreed with you, but really need of NAINA city in future. Already all projects are delayed.

[@pranavingale6850]

​@@Cricketnerd45tender is out for phase .....(i don't remember phase number sorry) infrastructure development! So sorry to disappoint you

[@arjuntyagi5860]

Maharashtra should focus on eastern and central Maharashtra that reduce burden on mumbai and development in Maharashtra Same karnataka should focus on central and North karnataka to reduce burden on banglore

[@Amoghavarsha.]

Agree 👍

[@sathvikraomp2006]

true and Northern politicians should develop their states. So that burden on South and Western India will be reduced

[@tomriddle4110]

we are, have u seen pune's growth in the last 7 years, now finally gov is building ring road/metro, then only airport is left for Pune to overtake hyderabad and banglore

[@mummy5490]

​@@sathvikraomp2006don't know about others..but UP is doing very much

[@yashkumar6701]

yeah if you remove mumbai from maharastra then maharastra is same as any other under developed state

[@Wanboy]

Mumbai: omg im going to be dying city! Kolkata: First time?

[@sathvikraomp2006]

Mumbai will reach saturation not decline. Those are two different things. Whereas kolkata declined due to stupid politics.

[@Nightcrawler81]

@@sathvikraomp2006 And you think politics in Mha is too good right now?

[@tomriddle4110]

mumbai isn't going to die! jai hind jai maharastra

[@sathvikraomp2006]

@@Nightcrawler81 Its not but that its only temporary and there are elections next year after which there will be stability . But unlike Kolkata no politician in Mumbai or Maharashtra are anti Industry

[@vatsal0075]

Mamta killed kolkata so bad it can never revive tmc needs to die for kolkata to live

[@luqman4426]

They gained control of Maharashtra by buying MLAs, shifted Mumbai's port resources to Gujarat, and favored Gujarat with multi-billion projects, neglecting Maharashtra's development. They exploited Mumbai's resources during their unlawful rule and misused income tax money by investing it in other regions instead of benefiting Maharashtra. They=?

[@internetzone165]

Y'all cry so much bjp literally snatched both narmada and tapti from us MPites despite nearing 20 years they haven't anything that I can count of atleast they give u some infra brothers stay happy with that negligence is what central India sees

[@luqman4426]

​@@internetzone165 Not at all surprised by you quick recognition of "They". If im not wrong these are rivers not projects built from our Income Tax money.

[@internetzone165]

@@luqman4426 narmada riverfront tapti riverfront sardar sarovar damn these aren't projects?

[@krunal_patel977]

Ports ko kaise shift karte hai??

[@sohamranadepersonal2733]

#AskPt: I feel Bengaluru is saturated, Noida and Gurgaon are avoided due to high-crime rates. Hyderabad is emerging but needs to develop further. Pune has terrible road conditions, grave public transport and conservative societal mindset. Do you think once Mumbai Metro 3 and MTHL are commissioned, Mumbai can gain an edge over other cities when it comes to ease of transit, and seamless exchange of various modes of public and private transport-convinient for local population as well as business travellers and tourists?

[@gauravbhagat1744]

Absolutely right sir

[@7001nikhil]

Pune has social conservative mindset? Lol you are being very funny. Mumbai and Pune both are growing. No doubt that Pune lacks road infrastructure but its bad in Bengaluru too.

[@samiuddinomer8154]

Hyderabad 😍 is the best city in india 🇮🇳 God bless hyderabad

[@Newage-ed7er]

​@@7001nikhilhe is TRUE abt pune having conservative mindset..

[@7001nikhil]

@@Newage-ed7er No one will buy that argument.

[@harshchheda6672]

Mumbai is New York and Los Angeles of India. No one can ever come close to aamchi Mumbai ❤

[@gauravbhagat1744]

U r absolutely right Mumbai city Maharashtra faar ahead of India

[@AnurajUpadhyay]

California of India in gurgaon and Bengaluru And DC of India is delhi Ofc

[@Amitabhs1000]

Zara si bhi sharam nahi aayi Mumbai ko New York se compare karte hue? Kaun sa maal phoonk ke comment kiye the bhai?

[@harshchheda6672]

@@Amitabhs1000 thoda bhi dimag lagata to pata chalta ke aisa kyu bola hai. Leave it.

[@OBEITOONilpPatel]

That's true that Mumbai is losing it's reputation day by day as other cities of India are growing ❤

[@Raja-xm5bc]

Bhava aamh maharashtrin he hame ladna atta he 😎🌟 We will definitely bounce back 🙏 Jay maharashtr 👑

[@atishparadkar3505]

Bhaiii nko ahe ladhan houde baki cities develop... Mumbai mdhe kachara zalay tasa pn to kmi hona garjech ahe

[@sameerbhalerao431]

We want 3-4 major cities in UP BIHAR side those ar most populated places which needs employment opportunity

[@KishanKumar-qz1kt]

In up yes lucknow kanpur region and noida greater noida region will become mega city by the mid of this century. For bihar villages are empty educated people have permanently migrated uneducated people go and come.

[@sameerbhalerao431]

@@KishanKumar-qz1kt we don't want cities with just mega infrastructure, cities need to have strong skilled based industry sector like one gujrat developed.

[@KishanKumar-qz1kt]

@@sameerbhalerao431 electronic and it industry are coming to noida. Kanpur has lost its industrial weight otherwise it was more industrialised than other city in India. It is regaining it's position within up. Mega projects will only improve it

[@Vkdm123]

In UP , Bihar , first thing to be done is a major education and safety drive , Bihar is one of the most illiterate state of India because of which it has almost no big industries whereas UP is solving that problem slowly by ensuring safety and avoiding vandalism that usually happens in North India

[@sameerbhalerao431]

@@Vkdm123 they get fake degree printed out there they can become illiterate to literate over night.

[@preet6095]

Global financial Centre index Ranking 2023- - CHINA 🇨🇳 {Total==13} Shanghai Rank-7 Shenzen-12 Beijing- 13 Guangzhau-34 Qingdao- 36 Busan- 37 Chengdu- 44 Dalian - 72 Nanjing -75 Tianjin - 79 Hangzhou- Ranking 80 Xi’an- 105 Wuhan- 111 INDIA 🇮🇳 (Total==3)only Mumbai Rank- 61 New Delhi - 65 GIFT City Gujarat - 67

[@miralam2582]

Its good that the economic factor is being shared with other cities... It wouldve been no benifits to indian economy, if there was a single economic city in india.... But no doubt mumbai is the only metropolitan city with large economy....

[@nileshthore1159]

No other city feels like mumbai❤

[@alijaan9340]

Yes

[@cinemaismywife]

which other cities have you been to dumbass lol

[@sadenb]

Because its a failed city

[@Global-Netizen]

Slum, overcrowding feel ♥️🤌

[@samiuddinomer8154]

Poop 💩 beaches ⛱️

[@realhumphreyappleby]

Why can't people accept that both facts are true - Did BJP push Foxconn-Vedanta to GJ due to the elections there? Quite possible. Did Maha Vinash Agadhi slow down developmental projects due to petty politics? Again yes.

[@Dattebayo3089]

Ask fadanvis why he joined ncp first? In late 90s when Sena and bjp won in alliance. Bjp also was at cm position when Sena got more seats. Now sena wanted same that they did in late 90s. Bt bjp and fadanvis lied and went with ncp. Hence sena joined congress

[@tomriddle4110]

thank god someone is awake😊.

[@tomriddle4110]

@@Dattebayo3089 aks why shiv sena got votes on modi's name and then switched over to congress? Also u are lying as sena in 1990s got cm post as sena had more seats. in 2019 bjp won 105/150 and sena won 56/120? why should sena get cm post. What uddhav should do now is quite UPA alliance and rejoin with Raj saheb, if he does this then I will vote for sena in 2024 but if he stays in alliance I will vote for bjp+dada

[@Dattebayo3089]

@@tomriddle4110 lol. Narayna rane was cm for 1.5 yrs in late 90s. That time sena had more seats bt still they have chance to bjp

[@tomriddle4110]

@@Dattebayo3089 rane was in shiv sena at the time, how stupid are u? He was also in ur congress for like 13 or so years so does that mean shiv sena gave cong post. Also if bjp had got post it would have only gone to Gopinath Munde who would have been a far better cm than either joshi or rane and may have won 1999 election

[@laoxianmodi]

Mumbai will rise again. Mumbai is next newyork. Textile is basic, IT services is lower middle, research based development upper middle and capital market is top. Mumbai is already in last leg, Bangalore moving from 2nd to 3rd. All small cities like Indore, kochi, pune etc etc will be next IT services centres.

[@sandeepkap3110]

Absolutely right

[@sunilkumar-ns5pl]

Mumbai is mumbai no other city can compete .

[@krunal_patel977]

No other city can compete mumbai in slums

[@I_am_a_Cunning_Linguist]

Mumbai is a coastal city and a major port. No way it will die.

[@bismarck9938]

Look at Kolkata

[@Lozzymee]

​@@bismarck9938Mumbai is dreaming to become New york or shanghai of india and other states are dreaming to become Mumbai.. ❤ and u are giving example of Kolkata 😂

[@AshishSawant-mt5bv]

Everyone is using Mumbai as a " Milking Cow " and don't have a sense of belonging and that according to me ,is one of the major reason for its downfall. Mumbai has been sustaining until now against all odds because of Blessings of Goddess Mumbadevi.

[@Lozzymee]

True 🙏 jab tak mumbadevi hai tab tak Mumbai ka koi nhi bigad sakta ❤

[@biswalashis123]

If Reliance industries at all leaves Mumbai, that will be final nail on city's coffin.

[@krunal_patel977]

Very soon

[@Lozzymee]

Le adani - may I come in?🗿

[@SudershanK]

I have a slightly tangential opinion on this matter - Mumbai no doubt is losing its monopoly in certain sectors and I feel that's good for the city. Let me explain, monopoly somewhat stagnates growth and competition so if we get more cities competing for our businesses we will be forced to better our game with better infrastructure, better policies, better financial schemes and so on. Furthermore, on a larger scale we will see growth of country as whole rather than growth of single city which will help distribute the strain on resources and help optimal utilization of opportunities and resources.

[@Roman19926]

Agreed!

[@Lozzymee]

Mumbai is dreaming to become New york or shanghai of india and other states are dreaming to become Mumbai ❤

[@SudershanK]

@@Lozzymee true that’s the way ahead…

[@luqman4426]

In an attempt to gain control of Maharashtra, they resorted to purchasing MLAs. Furthermore, they orchestrated the relocation of Mumbai's port resources to Gujarat, favoring one state over the other. Additionally, they allocated multi-billion projects to Gujarat, neglecting the development of Maharashtra. Aware of the educated electorate in Mumbai and Maharashtra, they understood that their chances of being elected were slim. Consequently, they have exploited Mumbai to the fullest during their unlawful governance, taking advantage of their time in power to plunder the city's resources. (NOTE: Everyone knows who "they" are)

[@OBEITOONilpPatel]

Gujarat is getting development due to stable government

[@realbh4rgav]

Bas dusre states ko he blame krte raho aur apni shortcomings ko ignore Karo jaisa tum log har baar krte ho

[@krunal_patel977]

​@@realbh4rgavkaise gaand jal rahi hai in sabki 😂

[@Abhilashsatpute]

I hope Patna grows faster, at least these people stops coming to overpopulate our land

[@Lozzymee]

Exactly..

[@swayamsantosh8869]

Mumbai's finance and business activities runs by Gujarati businessmen. Now they are moving to gujrat due to the high operation cost of production in mumbai. Marathi community is not a business community. They are the consumers and employee mentality community. North Indian crowd gradually moving to Noida and Gurugram cities. Their state especially UP is developing. And moreover anything, high land cost, slum and chawls are the curse for mumbai.. So the future of mumbai seems to be dark. Mumbai is already reached its peak point and now starts declining..

[@Motivational_life12811]

Mumbai is dying because of north Indians and bihari beggars

[@atulnayak5715]

Mumbai is dying when outdated citizens with no advanced skills or qualifications are devoid of problem solving, innovation and further skills re-investment. The same is true for Paris, France and Detroit, USA. Too many poorly skilled labour classes!

[@Lozzymee]

Mumbai is dreaming to become New york or shanghai of india and other states are dreaming to become Mumbai ❤

[@NikkhilSarvankar]

Being a Mumbaikar i would say Its better for Mumbai if other cities develop as well. Mumbai is facing lot of overcrowding. Mumbai will always remain a city of dreams no matter how many more cities develop.... Mumbai ka jalwa hi alag hai 😊❤

[@Lozzymee]

Mumbai will be the new york of India ❤😊

[@biswalashis123]

Mumbai is a stagnant city like Kolkata. It has historical banking headquarters, Bollywood, stock markets. But no tech industry, poorly maintained airpor‌t, overpriced rent, traffic jam, higher cost of living are some flaws.

[@Pravinphadnis0]

lol poorly maintained airport? Mumbai airport is one of the best in India and World

[@Lozzymee]

We are Mumbaikars bro. We will come back

[@evilkai3777]

GIFT city is not in Ahmedabad it is in Gandhi nagar

[@dipenkansara1418]

😂But Gandhinagar is part of Ahmedabad.

[@evilkai3777]

@@dipenkansara1418 bhai it was a part 😅

[@DannycageGhostrider]

​@@dipenkansara1418your geography is low

[@getlost..2842]

​​@@dipenkansara1418ot at All They are just close together Both have Own Different Districts & Different Municipal Corporation Gandhinagar Is Well Planned Capital City Like Chandigarh With No Conjunction As well 100 time better Drainage sys than A'bad Ahemdabad is overcrowded city.

[@dipenkansara1418]

@getlost..2842 I already know what is on paper but , as Ahmedabadi, we count gandhinagar as part of our city.

[@singh_abhijeet14p]

High time to develop more than 100 cities like mumbai & banglore specially kolkata and in bihar up itne high rents inflation

[@samiuddinomer8154]

No more slum cities please 🙏

[@theblackswordsman420]

fail is not the correct word, its actually good to see other cities developing who have potential like hyderabad (from where I am), mumbai will not stop developing as it is a stratergic location for India but other cities will be developing too

[@Hello-kh6bk]

You forgot about Bollywood. Noida Film City is trying to attract Bollywood. Mumbai will be left with nothing

[@Vkdm123]

Entertainment industry has made a base in Mumbai for more than 60 years , even if Noida completed its film city , Mumbai will still dominate by a huge gap because of many factors like safety, location , culture

[@redi6460]

Also lot of actors live here.

[@mypromopage4805]

Why you are so jealous😊

[@Lozzymee]

Mumbai will be left nothing?? Really 😱🤡.. 🤣

[@shreeveda]

Every state government in Maharashtra, is too Mumbai-centric and not Maharashtra-centric as they ought to be. Sad. To most, Mumbai is Maharashtra and Maharashtra is Mumbai. This must stop.

[@Lozzymee]

Yes pune , nagpur Must take burden now..

[@mandesa31]

True ! Mumbai is facing serious competition from other cities. But with right policies and visionary leadership, it can reinvent the way London and Shanghai have done to emerge as true world class cities. The big question is, do we have the aspiration to become one !

[@Lozzymee]

Sadly this politicians will not let happen that 😢

[@divitkarekar5803]

Great video as always, covered everything from history of Bombay to modern day issues like politics,other cities rising and investments

[@manishswami18]

It is good that economic power is evenly distributing among other cities. If we can develope the other cities on the line of mumbai then it will make india more investment friendly.

[@Officiallysane]

Other cities NEED to develop so that Mumbai can also develop. 1.2 Billion Indians cant survive depending only on Delhi and Mumbai. Mumbai will be the core finance capital and media capital.

[@mdsohailhaque8513]

Bro have you seen the amount of money being poured into Mumbai ,literally no other city in the country has so many huge projects that too planned and executed by their own municipal corporation and government in the pipeline . Mumbai is a great city ,but it's ultimate nail in the coffin will be the cost of ownership and renting of properties ,if that is solved it's going to be great place to live in

[@lolthunderstorm2344]

There is no land to expand that's the only problem mumbai will grow but eventually meet its limit while other cities can grow continuously.

[@mdsohailhaque8513]

@@lolthunderstorm2344 maybe ,or maybe not , considering slums pop in and out in the city ,occupying prime real estate

[@meghshah4969]

Monopoly in anything is not good. If mumbai has all financial center or everything then it create an issue as if mumbai stop everything will stop. The main issue in MH is thất government always focused on mumbai and pune but ignoring other city and village which is backward compare to ither state and cities

[@Vkdm123]

This happens in every single state, not only in India but in the US, for example even in Karnataka , I can only name 2 cities like Bangalore and Mangaluru, most of the ppl will only know Bangalore , same in Kerela

[@dasaritra007]

Bhai... finance mein GIFT City literally runs on PMO lobby... Mumbai has its inherent momentum...and it is difficult to get that HR of Mumbai to Ahmedabad... rhi baat Google taking space or Bank of America in GIFT city... those are token offices... fintech operations will still remain in Bangalore and Hyderabad...and core finance in Mumbai

[@DannycageGhostrider]

Pmo lobby break the Mumbai financial lobby which he mentioned earlier in this video😂 now cry your Monopoly in financial sector is end

[@pranavingale6850]

​​​@@DannycageGhostriderhe is right though, they are just token offices, it was even mentioned in i guess mint article, I am not sure and with an area of 3.5 sq km it's not going to a Singapore (789 sq km) and even in a country like china it took 50 years to develop Shenzhen and even after that it does not replace Shanghai, my dear cities ek din Mai ya ek decade mai bhi nai bante and with no alcohol oh my god!😅

[@AmishKumar-lc7zs]

​@@pranavingale6850What alcohol have to do with this man provided the case when gujrati business community itself are non alcoholic. That depends on lifestyle.

[@pranavingale6850]

@@AmishKumar-lc7zs gujarati community are not alcoholic, for this argument let's say yes, but the people they deal with, their customers, they sure are!

[@krunal_patel977]

Kolkata said same this type of backwass in past😂

[@bidyutmanna3900]

Abe chutio sab kuch Mumbai main hoga kya? 140 crores ka desh hai... We need atleast 7-8 cities similar to Mumbai...

[@millennialmind9507]

Yup, more like 20 to 25

[@bidyutmanna3900]

@@millennialmind9507 I meant to say the exist tire 1 cities can/should grow like Mumbai.

[@emotionalwibes7400]

So true bha. We need a gurgaon and noida like cities in Mumbai -NCR

[@Hbubera]

It will be beneficial for us to have other develop cities in our country also... Economical weight will reduce & mumbai become much more develop city in terms

[@its_not_the_Ishu]

1:13 small correction...its 1661 not 1961 Btw nice video❤

[@sadenb]

Mumbai has failed to raise the FSI . It cannot compete with Singapore, Shanghai or New York city ever.

[@nikhilPUD01]

😊

[@hasmukhsolanki1246]

Ahmedabad Gujarat vale like kro❤❤❤

[@Me7eOrmEmO1r2]

Kuch bhi video bana ke dal do. It's like saying that China has only Shangai, man China has multiple financial city centers like Beijing, Shenzhen, etc. So, as India develops, it should/must create other financial centers in the country. As far as Mumbai goes, it will lose nothing because of the pace at which India is growing, Mumbai will keep on growing, it will not reach saturation any time in the future. As Mills example goes here, usually the clothing industry moves to low-income regions so, there is no way mills can be operated in Mumbai. Mills anyway would have ceased as income level rises in Mumbai.

[@arjungurjar9104]

Major city in India Before: Kolkata Now: mumbai Future: banglore

[@rahulkopparthi9039]

most probably hyderabad. Water is a big issue in Bangalore

[@Mahaksh]

​@@rahulkopparthi9039probably ahmedabad

[@Vkdm123]

@@MahakshRarely Ahmedabad I think because IT is prominent in Southern states

[@Mahaksh]

@@Vkdm123 yup we don't know what the future holds

[@raviv3398]

Mumbai is over expensive and over hyped city. Due to lack of central government responsible infrastructure like airports connection to other cities, Mumbai has taken advantage. Example: Maharashtra’s most exported item is diamond, while Diamond is not even a business of Mumbai, it’s 100% of Gujarati business. It is business of Surat. But, Surati has to go to Mumbai, open an office there to trade & export Diamonds as it has to exported via air. Once Surat gets international connection to Antwerp, Belgium or Honkong, there is no role of Mumbai left in Diamond trading. Even with some flight connectivity started between Mumbai, Delhi & other big cities to Surat, many diamond trader moved back to Surat and close their offices in Mumbai. Mumbai diamond export will literally go down if Surat get direct connections to Antwerp or Hongkong.

[@APK81]

Central govt wants Mumbai to eventually die out as it wants ahemdabad to be the next financial capital. Surat the next commercial capital and Mundra the next port capital of India.

[@krunal_patel977]

Kash aisa ho jaye to maja aa jaye ga

[@krunal_patel977]

Mundra already no 1 port ban gaya hai

[@vinamrajha]

As an outsider and a start-up owner, I never even had a thought of opening our office over there. It just feels too conjusted and over-populated there's almost no place in Mumbai which develops a particular way you see a huge building and then beside it there's huge slum and it's just not attractive to Businesses. As much Mumbai seems developed from the top there's always a different story happening on the ground. Well I do understand the reasons and it can't be compared to newer cities, but as a Business owner places like Gurgaon is a lot more attractive as it's not just more developed but you can also find aspirational people all around specially in tech.

[@zackcarl7861]

Mumbai ,is working on Navi Mumbai , special economic zone , and that is in mainland india , so no space shortage I just hope , 🙏 political will wakes up and , to play the game against GIFT city , Mumbai must also make , tax free zone in Navi Mumbai Similarly, Pune must focus on IT and nagpur on manufacturing

[@bryan69in2002]

Horrible to travel within Mumbai. 2 bhk rent is 60k in Goregaon! 65 in Chembur! 4 hrs travel to and fro. Everything is costly, bad roads, no parking, road rage... Sick of this.

[@dreamypiscean6849]

I am a local and I want other cities to develop so that Mumbai doesn't have to bear the weight of everything. I seriously want this city to decongest and breath a little. I cant see my Mumbai dirty, overcrowded, overpriced. I love Mumbai and I want this city to rest a little. It's time for other cities to take the baton from Mumbai and make India proud the way Mumbai has.

[@sachinshirdavade1666]

Because of Political Turmoil of Maharashtra politics very soon Mumbai will lose its credibility and Tag of Financial Capital Of India😢😢

[@AmishKumar-lc7zs]

This is the best thing that could ever happen. They anyway hate other state people. Let some other city be the financial capital of India and Mumbai just financial centre for MH.

[@TheGuruNetOn]

It doesn't make strategic or logistical sense to accumulate everything in one place. Anything happens or is made to happen will effect India adversely. It makes sense to have regional or state wise growth of cities to spread out development across the whole country.

[@falltooth4415]

Despite all this its a face that Mumbai will always be one of the biggest city in India an Mumbai has bollywood too. Mumbai still can be the first indian city to hit 1 trillion dollar gdp.

[@harshduttpandey]

Bhai next video on indore city development and future plans. ❤❤

[@HemantPingolia-db2jg]

Please make a video on Vasai Virar area especially Virar. What is the future of growth of this region and good things, problems, infra, upcoming projects, administration etc.

[@bidyutmanna3900]

Mumbai cant be a dying city. Last kolkata dying video also many people were focusing in the word Dying".... See, these videos are analytical vidoes, the cities from a fast growing nation cant be a dying city.... Some are growing faster some aren't so this shouldnt offend anyone.

[@SHUBHAMSG]

Its natural for Mumbai and Kolkata to stagnate .. Coz they are just too crowded and too Ancient to compete with modern cities in India .. We have seen Kolkata stagnate in the past 60 years .. Now its the same for Mumbai .. Primarily due to them being saturated

[@bidyutmanna3900]

@@SHUBHAMSG Still Mumbai looks most modern than any city in India. Read my comment carefully... And kolkata is not stagnate its just growing not too fast like Mumbai MR, Hyderabad, NCR, and other high class urban area... GDP of kolkata is still 3rd highest and I doubt any city can cross kolkata in some recent years. So stay quite!

[@debraj2075]

Kolkata will remain 3rd and will go rapidly now. Mumbai will also grow. But Delhi I think will slow down a little bit as that is not very favourable for IT industries as NCR they are focusing now.

[@shinvlogs8200]

People make cities.. Kolkata coudnt progress cz people were ok with not doing much.. Mumbai people must united and say yes to better living.. Roads buildings infrastructure needs a big push.. Cleanliness and smell in Mumbai needs to be solved.. Hoping we will be able to make a dubai out of Mumbai..

[@Nightcrawler81]

How will you decongest population? Dubai was a deserted city to begin with.

[@shivathealmighty]

Mumbai's house rent is insane. A comfortable 1 bhk rent in Mumbai is out of reach for middle class today. In poor country like India, this is just scam!! Its weather is horrendous!! When it rains, it feels like it will never stop. Mumbaikars don't know what winter is!! You can not survive with family here with comfortable life if your family income is below Rs 200000/-. Anything below this is just compromise... Its transport system is a torture.. It is true that your salary can reach anything in this city and if your business grows here you earn in crores. But your struggle for space, comfort, pressure of frequent change of rented apartment, transport will keep on haunt you through out your life. It is necessary to find alternative of this city..

[@patildada]

Past mai travelling, connectivity aur resources Kam the toh Mumbai jaise bade tier1 city develop ho gayi taki ye problem na aaye. Lekin ab Mumbai jaise city mai bahut crowd ho gaya hai, pollution bad gaya hai. Quality of life gir gaya hai. Ab toh connectivity resources bad Gaye hai toh tier 2 se bhi hum job kar sakte hai. Aur ek bade city ka disadvantage hai ki corona jaisi bimari, war aur earthquake, cyclone jaise natural disaster aaye toh pure city ka nuksan hota hai aur GDP PE bhi effect ho jata hai. Iske badle agar 4-5 tier2 city hogi toh ye nuksan Kam ho jayega aur GDP PE jyada effect nahi hoga. Future mai natural disasters aur bimari badne Vali hai. Isliye tier 2 ka development jaruri hai.

[@greenworld5587]

Noida extension growing rapidly 🔥

[@crafttechindia]

As an mumbaikar i can just say that my grand father purchased some property in altamount at around 6 crores in 1980 something. Now they worth more than 110 crores. The only benefit is that who have properties in Mumbai they will be in benefit coz the rent here in mumbai is average 15000 for 1bhk and if you go at locality like slum then 10K and if you say little good locality then the rent is more than 30 to 40k for 1 bhk and 3 bhk above 1 lakh

[@manojpoddar7555]

Last days of Mumbai. Already many people are leaving Mumbai and shifting other cities

[@pranavingale6850]

People depopulating Mumbai!?.......Happy happy happy 🎉🎉

[@manojpoddar7555]

@@pranavingale6850 many moving to Navi Mumbai, pune and Bangalore like cities

[@pranavingale6850]

@@manojpoddar7555 that's what happiness man, which part you didn't understand

[@SahirMomin111]

No way. If other cities are developing, then this will ease congestion in Mumbai. Good for Mumbai.

[@deccankothrud5731]

Mumbai is packed. New cities needed. Cannot keep ruining Mumbai

[@ShivanshPandey15]

Mumbai have to develop the metro lines and keep cleaniness

[@dipikeshpatil7021]

Our Mumbai is next to New York Love you Maharashtra

[@nv_musicvibes0201]

In terms of population, yeh newyork se bhi aage hoga😂

[@krunal_patel977]

😂😂😂

[@Video.Creations]

Please make a Video on the capital city of Assam, Guwahati

[@anonymousz8973]

Assam capital is dispur isn't it

[@Video.Creations]

@@anonymousz8973 Dispur is a part of Guwahati city

[@harshadborade380]

MUMBAI is the NEW YORK city of INDIA it will be more better in future will redevelop slums too❤❤❤

[@krunal_patel977]

New York ❌ Slum city✅

[@bharatparmar8430]

Mumbai is slum City 😂😂

[@sadenb]

Indian cities are unplanned . I don't think even 1 city of India will reach global standard in 30 years time. There is no equivalent of Wall street in Mumbai.

[@anshgala5443]

Mumbai people wanting more other cities to develop 🤝 other states people wanting more cities to develop.

[@ashokpatel9902]

Don't forget Trans Harbor Bridge and Delhi - Mumbai Express Way (up to JNPT Port) ..... Wait .... There is Another Big Future International Level Mumbai under developing.

[@alwaysinmoney3538]

Mumbai will likely be Kolkata 2.0, living in it's old glory

[@athenaStates]

The biggest threat to Mumbai is Modi being from Gujarat as a local it feels like colonisation all our institutions are compromised by Jain's and Kachi's etc they are deliberately destroying Mumbai one cut at a time

[@ranaharsh7556]

U idiot it was jain parsi gujarati who built mumbai. Ask any marathi when they came to mumbai they will say 60 years ago or 30 years ago ask any Gujarati when did they came they will tell u 200 years ago their family came to mumbai. Literally all old gujarati news paper, gujarati literature came from mumbai. Gujarati cinema was based in mumbai and u are telling us that we came to mumbai, it was marathis who came as migrant in mumbai not Gujarati.

[@AmishKumar-lc7zs]

So compete with them. Why're you crying 😭😭

[@athenaStates]

@@AmishKumar-lc7zs Say that to Native Americans. My problem is not competing but not able to compete on same terms coming from deserted lands They dont have any morals to speak off you never know when they will backstab you for pennies their word has no weight unlike in Konkani culture where word in something you would die for They would sell their own mother if need comes thats their identity

[@krunal_patel977]

Tum bhi institution compromise karo kar sako to

[@7001nikhil]

Bengaluru has infrastructure issues, Delhi has safety issues. With this Mumbai is still a best bet for businesses in India. Also, looking at infrastructure projects going in Mumbai especially Navi Mumbai airport, there will be boom for businesses in Navi Mumbai. This city will only flourish.

[@zoroaster_india]

But flats are too expensive. At the price of 1bhk in Mumbai, I can get spacious luxury 2bhk in other cities

[@bharatparmar8430]

Mumbai has no future. You think like this because you are emotional about your State.and jobb mentality😂.but reality is different.ajki date me koi bhi Naya startup Mumbai ko choos nahi karta...MH government ko pure Maharastra centric sochna chahiye rather than focus only Mumbai

[@7001nikhil]

@@bharatparmar8430 Come back after 5 yrs and say same thing again. I am not emotional but practical person. Amount of infra update Mumbai is getting, it will remain prominent city in India for unprecedented time. Mumbai is still third largest unicorn hub of India. Second largest city like Pune is equal to Hyderabad & Chennai. Third largest city Nagpur becoming another IT/services hub. Nashik & A’bad are already manufacturing hubs & getting many investments. Even cities like Amravati & Kolhapur getting good amount of industries.

[@GaneshSawant007]

Bengaluru is not planned, it is worse and Mumbai is in top 5 in IT industry.

[@MrKumail123]

Indeed Bengaluru is not planned but city can be extended horizontally but with Mumbai you can’t.

[@GodBlessYouAll3.16]

I m mumbaikar. ...but I like hyderabad infrastructure 🎉

[@millennialmind9507]

​@@GodBlessYouAll3.16weather wise you will love Bangalore and Pune compared to Mumbai and Hyderabad 😅, and I am a marathi guy

[@GodBlessYouAll3.16]

@@millennialmind9507 Kya phark padta hai mumbai walon ko Hyderabad walon ko aadat ho gayi is climate ka

[@millennialmind9507]

@@GodBlessYouAll3.16 me bahar ke logon ko bol raha hoon

[@C-RiyaAmberkar]

Mumbai ka nam mumbadevi K nam se h so aap ko mumbai dying kahna nahi chaiye Mumbai no 1 p sirf yaha Bahar se aaye vyapari ki wajah se nahi thi yaha Nana shankar seth jaude kaie Marathi vyapari the jinone British government ko karj Diya tha yaha K likhepadhe skill labour the yaha K geography location kafi sare Pehloo h. Mumbai ka yeh Haal yaha Hardin anewale lakho log uss wajah se Khali jamin par zopadpatti bana K gandagi faila rahe h Aur curoupt politicians yeh rukna jaruri tha Accha h Desh k baki city's me development Ho rahe h. Logo ka Aana Kam Hoo Aur yaha rahne walo ko thodi khuli saans mile. Lekin development filhal sirf ek hi State me dikh raha h baki jagah bhi Hoo spl UP Bihar

[@Brand250]

Next mumbai ka successor hoga navi mumbai 🗿🔥

[@nitin1947]

British government brought Gujaratis, Parsis, Marwaris to Mumbai for trading. Britishers had more trust in Gujrati, Marwari, Parsis because they were loyal to British government and were helping british governmetn to loot India. Most of them were also initailly involved in business of Ganja.

[@PUNSHIBAROT]

Same way can be said of the army British created Maratha, Sikh and Gorkha regiment because it helped them fighting against locals and helped them in world war, all this regiments where created when there successive ruler lost against British,also 1857 revolt which proved non- martial caste where not loyal to British army so they focused more on hiring Maratha, Sikh, Gorkha which where loyal to them, so we can say Indians as such always loyal to there work, parsis , gujarati where good in business so they where hired for that same goes to army and other department

[@raviv3398]

Those community were running businesses, not looting. Far better than how congress has looted India after independence. Mumbai was far better during British Raj and most of those generation people would agree.

[@nitin1947]

@@raviv3398 those were British agents who helped British government loot India.

[@krunal_patel977]

​@@PUNSHIBAROTcorrect

[@apc6575]

So far, PM of Gujarat is the biggest threat to Mumbai

[@pankajpatil3600]

Mumbai never down.. just wait my friend.. it will stay forever number one ..

[@swagatsawant]

😎 Heyy @PowerTrain, Mumbai has 100 times more infra projects in development compared to any other city in India; but the biggest question is- *How much of threat is Mumbai under from Natural Calamities, due to its overflowing population?* Hope you make a video on such an important topic soon...

[@VishnuKamath]

I am a mumbaikar. Mumbai is Dying. Mumbai can turnaround but it needs to be Mumbai not the capital of Maharashtra. Move the capital of Maharashtra to Pune or Nagpur. Mumbai should be run by a CEO and not a Mayor. Merge Navi Mumbai, Thane, Virar Vasai into one Mega City

[@yashk4051]

i think with redevlopment of all slums there is large potential land which could be free for use of commerical n residential/public use i hope we carry it out asap btw i dont agree with blantant opinions in this video i hope nobody paid you to say this sounds propoganda to me.

[@baxterismyyoutubename5077]

Bengaluru modern part of the city is good but most part of the areas are pathetic and dirty same with Mumbai. I was surprised to see A glass skyscraper office in Mumbai, it's entrance were full of garbage on the side... I thought they would do something for this mess but nothing it's the same for over 3 years in my stay and it must be still dumping garbage on the road.. This is really annoying to see, atleast not in developed part in the city...

[@PPAWAR-xx6sr]

in maharashtra PUNE ,PIMPARI CHICHVAD ,NAGPUR city growth is faster

[@akashdhange2877]

They should focus on Navi Mumbai now

[@zackcarl7861]

NEWYORK , don't become irrelevant, just because, los angeles, Austin Texas , and Miami is growing Just like New York is an internal city ,Mumbai , Mumbai will find the way to fight , gift city in Navi Mumbai Only , political stability is needed

[@Lozzymee]

Mumbai is dreaming to become New york or shanghai of india and other states are dreaming to become Mumbai ❤

[@RoystonRogers]

The Union leader you mentioned is Dutta Samant, not Datta Sampath. Mumbai has the workforce, Mumbai has the money, it just needs political will and freedom from corruption. Too many people here hamper growth, a shift to growth mindset is required.

[@zoroaster_india]

Flats are too expensive

[@BJP500paar]

Because of Muslims

[@manus3702]

Many people including Maharashtrians dont understand that the most important reason of industries coming to maharashtra is that Maharashtra is the biggest consumer for these industries. No matter What other states do to snatch buisiness from maharashtra, consumption will always remain an important factor. Same thing applies to Bollywood.

[@AmishKumar-lc7zs]

Bollywood should be shifted from Mumbai to any Hindi city like Indore, Lucknow or Jaipur.

[@sureshpeshawaria347]

Other cities are developing = Mumbai dying...what kind of equation is this ???... Mumbai is still developing - fast...and will continue so...