Why Highways Worldclass, but City Roads Terrible || CASE STUDY ||

[@its.Sarthak101]

Simple because NHAI don't control urban roads

[@bhalkitoday8267]

IT Sarthak wha tera IQ 200+hye jo kisi ko bhi samjh nahi ayaa vo tujhe ayaa Salaam hye tere dimag ko🤷

[@nature.951]

😂😂😂😂sahi hai

[@nature.951]

Op bro😂

[@bhalkitoday8267]

@@nature.951 🙏

[@Wanboy]

Nam hi NHAI hai "National Highways Authority of India" naki "National Urban roads Authority of India".

[@Krunalbhuyar]

Low Quality and high level of corruption in Village road and bridges is also a major problem 🙏🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳

[@timewaste5189]

Write letter to local govt body .

[@Krunalbhuyar]

@@timewaste5189 local gov body itself involved in corruptions..need central agency to monitor village infrastructure .

[@kanishkbaheti932]

​@@Krunalbhuyar right said brother

[@Krunalbhuyar]

👉Not only city road but the road between villages are also in very poor condition.Low Quality and high level of corruption in roads and bridges is also a major problem 🇮🇳

[@HARS7IT]

Powertrain always delivers the video which I have in mind 😅. Good job with video 👍

[@Hey_rishuuu]

Yup 👍

[@anandsuralkar2947]

Bhai tu indore se hai kya?

[@gunjannagda6527]

Well i am from indore and i can say one thing that here local bodies have done such a grt work that we hardly see any potholes atleast when it comes to major roads , even roads connecting societies and local area are also in quite satisfactory condition, so in the end it all depends on local bodies if they want anything can happen.

[@dreadfulbodyguard7288]

Good to know a city itself can comment on youtube.

[@Balidan2412]

Bro's a whole fckin city💀

[@sankkham]

Their rain is not that much

[@srinivas8207]

I agree

[@parthkulkarni1126]

Indore Municipality is exceptional 🙌🏻

[@sussybaka6792]

Tendering process should be done through a centralised platform Not just tenders for construction project but also for another things like train manufacturing/maintenance, defence procurement, and all other stuff It will promote uniformity in tenders, less corruption and involment of small players

[@hello-il3fg]

Already being done through gem but after centralised platform the issue remains stagnant and still😂

[@bhai857]

Centralized platform also won't help if all contractors applying for tenders are relatives of politicians or politicians themselves.

[@pankajrana8006]

​@@hello-il3fgBhai urban roada NHAI k under nhi aate local government body k under aate hai.

[@eugene7989]

Good idea, but govt. officials still find ways to monetize these systems....corrupt officials always find ways to get what they want.

[@nknkannadiga9742]

Yes. And give every contract to North Indians

[@creativerse6447]

I had this question in mind since years, our highways are being made and they last for 5+ years smoothly toiling heavy traffic on them. But our own city and town roads once made, gets weakened before the onset of monsoon and after the rain has done its job, it's a hell out of a road. They hardly gets repaired and the condition worsens. Thanks a lot for addressing this issue to the public. I hope our city roads get better.

[@pratik6342]

There should one nation wide authority for constructing roads, be it expressways or local roads.

[@utkarshmangal6559]

foolish.

[@harshitsingharya5533]

Local issue need local governance. 😅

[@anujsethi7845]

You have zero idea about governance I guess?

[@ayushmankar4100]

​​@@harshitsingharya5533We know what kind of local Governance your local Municipality and local contractors are doing. "Pesa thuso governance " . 😂😂😂😂

[@kartikeydubey9010]

@@anujsethi7845 then change the entire system we are not bounded to follow this corrupted old age system of babus

[@SG003]

State government ke haat me kuchh achha nahi ho sakta hai, 1-2 state sayed exception hai

[@SaviourSword995]

Mai nai kafi state highways dekhe hai, they are actually good. Even village roads are better. Yeh sab cities Mai hi hota hai

[@mayankindian3750]

​@@SaviourSword995 bhai cities me drainage system to hota Nahi hai kachra bhar rakha hota hai paani rukta hai bhai

[@aksharpatel3760]

Which are exception?

[@Wanboy]

Yes

[@sahilbhardwaz4852]

@@aksharpatel3760 GUJRAT , TAMILNADU , NCR nd some other

[@vinodph834]

Another biggest problem is .. doing ground work by breaking good proper road ..and leaving it as it is.. 😮‍💨

[@Myxyzbright313]

Mere hisab se L&T,TATA .aur international company ko hi kaam Dena chahiye city rode

[@rohanrawat3264]

Adani ❤

[@i.ashisss]

​@@rohanrawat3264nope

[@prathamsoni4424]

@@i.ashisssbeta kbhi adani apne saare dhandhe bnd kr dena to desh dikt me aa jae abhi nhi samjhega adani ki importance

[@rvisingh5842]

​@@i.ashisssAmbani

[@rvisingh5842]

Abe road thodi na bnate hai vaise ye tata l&t adani Ambani

[@arjunraj823]

Kerala rural roads were in bad condition. But now so much improved. Even though roads are narrow, its well paved and given sign markings.

[@RigelVision]

Very true, I've seen it in vlogs its quite impressive what they've done

[@S_K_J]

Come to trivandrum habibi i will show you the condition of city roads.

[@sagarshetty3175]

No its not

[@jonathanalvinrays..7070]

But Kerala National Highways need lane extension... Most Highways are just 2 lanes which are very dangerous and accident prone... I went to Pallakad, the roads are risky... 2 lane highways ar very dangerous....

[@S_K_J]

@@jonathanalvinrays..7070 if you want to do any project, nxt day union labours will be there with flags.

[@akikmeshram8733]

nagpur: hold my glass😏

[@shivajimaharaj4065]

Pipeline dalna bhul jatte hai 80/100 for nagpur

[@खतरनाकइंसान]

3 ways Indian Cities conditions can be improved - 1) There should be an app to check the details of Road Conditons, Road Contractors, Road Contract, Road Complain and all the Financial Details. 2) The Transaction of Tender should only be done after the approval of 100 people of the Locality through app. 3) The branding of Road Contract Companies should be done on every road so that they can be encouraged to make more better roads and awarded if possible. 4) The Road Contractors who does corruption should be punished severely.

[@bhai857]

wishful thinking. who is going to punish the contractors? our courts? the ones that take centuries to solve one case?

[@manojyadav7942]

Last point is more than enough.

[@Tempo-Turbic-ir2030.]

Some of my friends went to become an architect ( B.Arch ) but maximum students from India thinks being architect is "mistri" work.

[@divitkarekar5803]

Great video,informative as always ❤️ Shouldn't the central government realise this and take even urban roads construction in their hands?as mentioned they don't have money problems so they should think about construction of urban roads as well,maybe take some funding from state govt collaborate and do it

[@aborigigaming4821]

No, CG can't do it because the powers, duties and jurisdiction of work is set up in the constitution and each state has a right to decide the working procedures and jurisdiction of each working department. CG can't intervene in these procedures as it is not their jurisdiction!

[@themonkeyman2790]

@@aborigigaming4821 too much democracy...

[@nishadgade]

In pune we have JM road, which is the only road made free from corruption, and you would not believe that for more than 20-25 years ,there is not even a single pothole there,isn't that amazing .

[@bindaswriter3316]

topic in my heart delivered by power train.Good Job bro keep it up.

[@newvlogger483]

Bmc municipality bahut rich hai but curruption ne mumbai ki bhi vaat laga di tax barabar lenge fir use kha jayenge

[@VALAR_Morgulis.]

Har ek state govt mak ek nithin gadkari nahi hotha na...

[@JaydipsinhParmar1]

Nhai vs municipality

[@sachinedit5209]

iss liye Modi Cabinet Kai ek Minister ne Ek podcast mein bola tha ki Unko bureaucracy & Municipality ka Power kam karna hai agle 5 saal mein kyunki Udhar jyada Corruption hota hain. Reality Mein Country Municipal Corporation hi chalata hain, Electricity Meter, Drainage, Road, School, Water, Bridge etc yeh sab Municipal corporation ka haath hota hain.

[@jaymashelkar4554]

4:22 bro this is just so true What is the planning if you need to dig it up after just 4-5 years Near my school they just recently finished making a footpath 1-2 months ago And now they're opening the footpath to put some lines in

[@GiGaChadAF]

Even highways have a lot of potholes and uneven surfaces. It is not always about the flashy stuff

[@kennedyspace1159]

10:30 road near ambience mall, gurugram, New Delhi 😂😂😂 bachpan ka fav. road was so fasinated by its size

[@SunShine_747]

Corruption in tendering and lowest bidder clause

[@navnathsurvase3490]

Farmer sell row meterial in market/ industry ↓ Manufacturing of row of meterial in factory, →{ create employment} ↓ Create logestics and transportation demand →{ create employment) ↓ Retailers and vendor buy the product →{ create formal + lnformal employment} ↓ End Consumer purchase the products ↓ Consumer expenditure on product ↓ Consumer create demand for products ↓ Business/ industry create demand for row meterial ↓ Availablity of row meterial by farmer ↓ Increase PER CAPITA INCOME of FARMER - This is a cycle of health Economy.

[@wanderer8811]

This is so relevant. Every Indian faces this the moment we take our vehicles out! Good to know the reasons behind this

[@anittas224]

Cost Audit should become mandatory even for small contracts at local level otherwise this corruption will continue

[@soumyajitmaz6230]

Mumbai, Kolkata aisi cities hai jaha bhar bhar ke potholes, garbage, pollution dekhne ko milta hai, idhar rehne ka hi man nhi krta, Jab ki Guwahati ke roads isse ache hai

[@PanditThanos]

mumbai mai pollution hone ke bad bhi rehne ka mann karta hai.....chomu tu kabhi mumbai mai nahi raha hai.....aur bhai mumbai toh far better hai olkata se jo ab bhi 1950s mai atka hua hai

[@AbhaySharma-xu6jn]

Kolkata or west bengal ke bare me jitna kam bole achha hai...

[@evilkai3777]

SURAT is good in terms of roads also ❤

[@chintansolanki2852]

Amdavad, Mehsana Also

[@evilkai3777]

@@chintansolanki2852 ahmedabad bro

[@chintansolanki2852]

@@evilkai3777 aap kaha se ho, hum gujarati to Amdavad hi bolte hai.

[@evilkai3777]

@@chintansolanki2852 me UP se hu per me 11 saal se Gujrat me hu

[@chintansolanki2852]

@@evilkai3777 isiliye tumhe nahi pata bhai, Amdavad (अमदावाद) Bola Karo. Gujju logo ko accha lagega.

[@nitishgaikwad98]

Advanced congratulations 🎉 for 500k subscribers ❤

[@rajkiran1982]

@7:18 Idiots driving in wrong direction evn in such high traffic, high speed roads. and randomly some vehicle stalled on the road. Terrible!!

[@amannarwal8097]

Simple rule highways pe toll tax se paise wapas ajate h par local roads se nhi ate so no importance

[@anujsethi7845]

Gadkari said for contractors they should be credit system.

[@adityaneelkanth]

Har baat pe politicians ko blame karna sahi nahi... I think they are the only ones who fight elections every 5 years and can be held accountable... Baki ye bureaucrats and contractors se koi accountability nahi mangta. They are the biggest hurdle to our country remaining backward

[@PrakashVermaजी]

सड़कों की खराब होने का सबसे बड़ा कारण है पानी का रुकना। हाईवे पर पानी नहीं रुकता है क्योंकि उन्हें आसपास की जमीन से ऊंचा बनाया जाता है ।जबकि शहर की जो सड़के होती हैं उन पर हर सुबह आसपास के लोग घर धो कर गाड़ी धो कर पानी सड़क पर डाल देते है। जिससे सड़क की उम्र लंबी हो जाती है😂

[@kavishjain8742]

Bro u make videos on very current and relatable topics. Much appreciated

[@Real982ax]

Sare roads central ko hi control Karna Chahiye .

[@Ashoksingh-ie6wf]

Or barish aane k kuch din phele hi road pe sasta daamber daal ke rooler guma dete hai phir road wapas 5 dino mai vesa ka vesa ho jata hai

[@aviralsinghal1274]

I disagree that our highways are world class. Our highway length maybe more but they are far from world class. The highway engineering, geometric design, merge lane geometry, gradient and curve design and so many engineering parameters are not followed at all. Our IS codes have not been updated to modern technology. Now i am not expecting german autobahn level quality, but atleast have a bare minimum US level standard. My heart hurts when i see even the new expressways getting destroyed by simple geometric flaws.

[@prateekmahapatra1789]

agreed , better than used to but its def not world class

[@uditnautiyal2356]

Kitne world class highway per gye ho tum apne sher k bhar to aaj tak gye nhi honge😂😂😂

[@anewlife5846]

True, Bundelkhand expressway was washed away in its first week itself.

[@uditnautiyal2356]

​@@prateekmahapatra1789 Indian highway quality are better than italy and Poland and we are on 46 spot in the global road quality index and china is on 42 spot in term of highway quality just go and check

[@aviralsinghal1274]

@uditnautiyal2356 maine duniya bhar ke highway expressway dekhe hai. Be it german or other European or american or even japan and korea. And i am myself an engineer from top college in india so i understand these stuff.

[@Raj_ghy]

There are multiple point you missed....Flexible pavements(bituminous roads) or most urban roads lack proper drainage.... And water is the biggest enemy of bituminous mecadam. There are many factors to this problem and not just corruption and budget.. The fact that most of our cities are unplanned and have no/improper drainage is the major cause for damaged roads . Simultaneous design of road with drainage structure are not possible at all times due to budget constraints and space /load limitations also some roads designed for less axil load receive way more traffic ......elevation of highway Roads are such that no water logging occurs or atleast is minimised and also due to good budget and higher load design to support high load vehicles result in higher strength roads... Where as most city roads are often low laying and are often subjected to flooding during rains or even sewage overflow, renewal works are only limited to renewal of top layers only due to time constrain...also In nothern Urbanised cities , During summer temperature of road surfaces can reach very high resulting in numerous types of failurs when subjected to loading.... Also urban traffic jams and highload vehicles such as dumpers, trucks, transporters etc stuck in jams for prolonged periods on the same intersections, due to improper/unability to maintaining proper traffic regulationa due to overcrowded nature of our 1st tier cities, thus leads to creep failure of roads as not all small roads are capable of Sustaining such high loads for prolonged periods of time. To permanently fix this problem would be to overhaul the entire Road network at once by widening, removing underlayers and redesigning subgrade from the very base, employing rcc/rigid pavements on high traffic roads and implementing very strict traffic and building regulation around the roads..... But as you could imagin.... Overhauling the road from ground up instead of just renewing the top course is very difficult as it would put the road out of commission for undesirable amount of time,also The indian mentality of traffic flow and people with cargo using roads not ment for high loads, budget constraints, project delivery on time etc many such factors would come as challenge... And to be frank would be near impossible. Not all PWDs are corrupt as new legislation have these days curbed majority of the corruption... Although it happens in lower strata of the system it is almost negligible but the biggest challenge we face are the logistics and budget constraints.

[@jagadeeshe7226]

Jai Hind Vande Mataram ⚔️🙂🙏🚩

[@kashishkumar]

There should be a body like NHAI for all roads in metro cities directly controlled by central government.

[@issubr0]

As a contractor i know what is going in all the departments

[@mohammadbhojani6446]

You need to check Mumbai Ahmedabad Highway which is busiest Highway in India also it is 6 lane toll road and there are big potholes in whole highway, Last year in 2022 during monsoon more then 100 people died due to this highway, this is called corruption.

[@FakeAccount-wp5wv]

#askpt why central govt things either its collage(both engineering and medical) , or roads , or police , or agency , or just anything are better than state ?? I mean in any political party , institution of central govt are much better than state. Souther states are quite socialist with but their collage still can not competete will central govt collage ??

[@biswajeet9826]

Thanks a lot I was thinking about the same

[@prashantkumarmishra4388]

Nitin Gadkari sir plz bring city roads under your ministry as well. They are literally terrible needs transformation.

[@arghyaprotimhalder5592]

Welcome to Kolkata barnagar. One can't day it's road or river , You can swim in it .

[@RahulKumar-on9co]

जितने भी हाईवे या expressway हैं वो NHAI के under आता है जबकि city roads PWD के under आता है

[@Akhil007PP]

PWD Kerala is doing phenomenal jobs in upgrading state highways and district highways, major works like coastal roadway and state hilly area roadway works are ongoing and extremely good. Many state highways are on an overhaul to better quality. . Still many urban roads in Kerala are not up to the mark..

[@forgive_me_for_being_unfunny]

Its the era of the internet and connectivity (also common knowledge ) If we as dutiful citizens just point out these mistakes on social media sites (apart from legal activities), along with following all traffic rules and not littering We can bring a change (although seems a huge task but better than doing nothing and ignoring) better footpaths, clean roads and robust drainages and all road signs would make India a better place no matter what city!

[@sajalpradeep6506]

In ranchi highway is also terrible.

[@kokushibo000]

atchee roads,infrastructures baan jayenge to politicans,dalal kab paisa kamayenge corruption jab tak hein tab tak INDIA ka kuch nehi hone wala

[@reaper8f]

Meri yahan colony me 12 sal se road repair nhi kiya aur ab toh road bachi nhi he

[@suyashsahu6505]

Mera yaha bani nahi hai.

[@ajayraut07]

Salute for this topic, you shown courage to show this

[@NexterB]

Many bureaucrats have died trying to stop this corruption.

[@-Tech-11]

Chhattisgarh me Bilaspur to Raigarh expressway bna aur 6 baar waps bna fir bhi itna kharab aur authority pass bhi kar diaa ,no cleaning

[@parikshitvyas3912]

Jab tak corruption ke khilaf strict law nahi banata tab tak ye sab chalate rahega

[@pranit77299]

But mumbai benglore national highway maintain by nhai have worst road as compare to mumbai pune expressway maintain by maharashtra state road department

[@user-jn7bq8wh1e]

New road built in Mumbai... Contractor: I will leave a bump in the middle of the road making it uneven and dangerous so cars/bikes/autos have to slow down or go around disrupting the already terrible road manners and lane discipline!!🌚 BMC: Wah kya world class idea he! Aur kisiko haraam ka Paisa khana he? Ya frustration nikalna he tax payers k upar jiski wajah se ye city chalta he to aa jao... Hum apke frustration ko Kam karenge..🌝

[@emotionalwibes7400]

Thanks for raising this issue. What is the solution for this ?

[@sanjaykrishna1806]

Shift all old markets, wholesale markets to ring roads where they can have larger space with godowns. Demolish that vacated area to build public transportation. Stop giving permissions for new constructions in inner city. Shift them to outskirts. But before that build a planned Greenfield city in outskirts

[@Mclovin96X]

i live in faridabad . it has one of the worst roads i have ever seen .

[@ganeshpopalbhat7487]

Very good explanation.

[@ahmed_0804]

Your content is unique

[@riseup2227]

New Chandigarh mai PR 7 road Kai salon se one side open hai aur jagah jagah pe tuta hua hai. And they call it green field smart city, utter bullshit!

[@BlackHawkTejas]

Here in Odisha the city & rural roads are in good condition. Mumbai is the worst!!

[@Gaurav_9339]

Bhai seedhi baat ki inherently ham India ke jyadatar log corrupt hai. To jab ham kisi service me jate hai to wahan bhi corruption karte hai. Koi bhi aisa nahi bol sakta ki mai corruption nahi karta agar mai is post pe hota to. Agar koi bol raha hai to wo corrupt ke saath jhootha bhi hai.

[@shrimaliketan135]

Visit Mumbai Nashik highway you will realise Highways are also in bad condition

[@hardikdave_]

Aajkal baarish mein road se nikalte hue darr lagta hai ki kahin puri road dhass naa jaaye.

[@muralikrishnanayyappan6513]

We need the PARLIAMENT to pass a LAW - Making Good Quality City Roads - A Basic Human Right !

[@vorrdegard2176]

We have put our roads in hands of the local bodies and they have failed us so now we should give big contractors a chance

[@theindianchennal.8009]

NHAI ko city roads bhi contract karwani chahiye.

[@dhulamul]

Why don't we start putting online/offline board with worst road maker. At least they all people know who contributed this road.

[@MrRocrma]

Roads should be minimum under State. Not below that like pwd or municipal councils. NH and SH that’s it. Things will be auto maintained

[@SurenderSingh-xx8xs]

may uttarpradesh ke loni area mayvl rehta hoo hamne to nagatpalika se rcc road ki jgh interlock tiles road banane ko kga ...interlock tiles ki wajh se unhe reoair karna easy hota hai ....

[@JaiD0427]

There's a solution for this: TenderSure-model roads for all main roads.

[@mrmahekvasaniya8529]

Compared to other cities in India, Surat has the best roads in India

[@newvlogger483]

Currupt government ke log hi hai bina ghus ke kuch kaam hone hi nhi dete

[@akshya88]

Highways are built by private players and tolls are collected. In case of other government will to use busget from tax where there is corruption.

[@tejeswar]

Corruption happens in all countries, but that happens at the top level where it is not directly visible to the public and it doesn't impact the daily lives of the people. But in India the rampant corruption at the low level is the worst things ever which directly impact to the daily lives of the people and create a bad image of the country, because it is visible.

[@Randomuser866]

Bhai aap thoda thumbnail me Hindi me likho kyuki views jyada milsakenge

[@vinodph834]

There is no quality check of roads after certain durations... its major reasons for accident.

[@Naturelife5550]

I don’t think so ki ye sare state eshe hai I live in Gujarat Mehsana mere around ke jitne bhi state highway hai all are in good condition even city road bhi kafi achee hai phele se

[@shaikhasif9534]

Mumbai Agra Highway sab se worst highway hai...kitne saalo se waha kaam nhi hota hai...chor hai sab k sab politicians

[@adeshgupta9587]

Roads are Cash cows for Bureaucrats, Officials and contractors. It will never be of good quality in India!

[@robinsingh3992]

monsoon aagaya hai.. aab road repair ke naam pe khanapoorti hogi..

[@atulkumar943]

4:04 bhai ne roast mar diya 😂

[@erpapun4227]

humare desh may har ek state ek independent country ki tarah kam karta hai

[@siddivinayak428]

Bhiwandi mai bahut zyada corruption hai compared to other cities

[@Ravikumar_Sharma]

Simple, because highway ek lamba stretch of road hai and camera mei Jo dekhta hai woh bikta hai

[@DipenRai949]

Prdhan mantri gram sadak yojana road quality 5 to 6mm road 😢 Bike cycle chor k kuch or chalane ki kosis ki toh 6months bhi nahi chalta road

[@ayushmankar4100]

Matlab UPSC walon ka corruption karte hein urban road development mein

[@vinayaknpn]

Not all highways are world-class in INdia but only a few Expressways. A highway doesn't become a world-class road just because it doesn't have any pits or potholes in it. It has to be even and your vehicle shouldn't shake while you are driving on it. It has to be so smooth that you should be able to have a cup of tea while sitting in the moving vehicle without spilling it. It should also have a proper drainage system and water shouldn't stay on the road even after heavy rains. I don't want to talk about City roads here because their quality is so so bad that there is no standard for them. Our PM is calling India as a Vishwaguru but I don't think we are even close to being a developed nation so forget about being a Vishwaguru

[@pritamsamanta3391]

Kangress ke jamane mai highways bhi patholes se bhare hote the bhai.

[@prembagui7104]

I don't think centralization is the solution here but the main solution is political awareness and excessive involvement of Bureaucrats of PWD department, we are a democracy there is no need for a bureaucrat to always approve the money for a product which people will use, I have a house in the suburban municipality area which is at the boundary of the municipality, If you see most of the roads in the municipality area they are just terrible all year around, where as the roads at the end of municipality near the panchayat region is well maintained by the panchayat all the year around but there is no permanent officer posted at those panchayat region, yes there is corruption on the pricing but the Roads and drains are better maintained due to the pressure from the public and the politicians can be heavily corrupt but those persons know if they don't deliver they are not going to sustain it for long and their source of Income will dry up but where as the officer who are working in contract knows the person can also be fired any day and stop the persons income, the corruption occurs because there are parts of government who doesn't have incentives or consequences for the delivery of the required services.

[@protograde2723]

City roads have slow moving traffic. Because of that, the wear and tear is high.

[@teju-adihegde1597]

But now goverment is concretising roads in thane