Presidential vs Parliamentary Form of Government | CSS Current Affairs | Ep 26 | WTI

[@ipaduser7563]

Because of your video… I able to compile my notes. Thank you.

[@LifeFactts]

Can you please share your notes with me?

[@usmantarar2315]

Allam Inayt ullah Mashriqui proposed a formula of proportional representation in order to protect national solidarity and remove sense of depravation among the minorities or social classes. According to this, representation in parliament should be proportional to the percentage of a social class in society. Its mean 5 percent representation should go to elite class if it is 5% of the total population. Similarly, 60% representation in parliament should be granted to the middle class if it is 60% of the total population. This formula will strengthen the current parliamentary system of government which has lead to sense of depravation across the different regions of country like Balochistan. System can be modified in order to address the emerging social issues of society

[@Wanderer975]

If an MNA from middle class is corrupt and win election, will he let a honest man become PM of Pakistan? or will he join a corrupt group of politicians for monetary benefits?? Proportional representation is good. But it's not enough to bring radical positive change in Pakistani politics.

[@amikakitchen2692]

Class does not represent the minority groups of different religion, area and cultural background which defies the whole point of representation in parliament. Secondly, represention is good but not beyond the point that people of actual merit get ignored

[@sanamehmood690]

Allah bless you Ahmed Ali Naqvii

[@aqibqure123]

Ameen

[@tehzeebhafipoetryofficial5318]

Masha Allah Great ..

[@hasnainAli-cg8fs]

Ali naqvi is my janu...great teacher

[@MPCupdate]

Teacher ko janu nhi bolty be respectful

[@tehminafareed4469]

Thank you so much sir for such beneficial video lecture for us

[@sanamehmood690]

I have collected materials on this topic. Thank God dear sir.. hot topic for css-22

[@desiduniya5649]

Please share your collected material

[@greatImranKhan461]

Would you mind sharing ma'am?

[@mohammadkhaleel3531]

Thank you Naqvi Sahb. It is requested that a video may also be prepared with your vast vision regarding Provisional Provincial Set-up of Gilgit Baltistan in context to BRI may be prepared.

[@ramishchaudhary1221]

Was desperately waiting for this topic. Thanks a lot.

[@aqxworld1005]

You are the best Sir ...... Well done

[@19471873]

Your information was conceived with super knowledge . super keep it up

[@kamranjagirani8110]

Thank you dear sir for this most productive lecture

[@abubakkarkhan2155]

Thank you Sir for sharing your vast vision with us..

[@maqsoodahmed4404]

Well elucidiation the forms of govt.

[@amaraf1519]

Very informative sir. May Allah bless you with more success

[@muhmmmadwaseem5466]

Zabrdast, Sir

[@laraibtariq2980]

Thanx, it is highly informative.

[@usamatariq8715]

Very well elaborated. But as He himself said at the beginning that both the systems have their own pros and cons but didn’t talk about a single possible benefit of Presidential system. Anyways, we should first get a genuine democratic system! Not a puppet hybrid democracy

[@thesoulfulllife21]

yes because he is teaching this to us for CSS exam, and we have to keep certain things in mind. On such topics you usually go for options that already exist in your country. open debate may then we can talk about both.

[@missioncss6429]

This is very awesome discussion

[@ElectricBurgers]

Good presentation. Well explained

[@SohailKhan-xx3hg]

Presidential system favours Pakistan. Because we vote to matriculated beacuse of thier influence in derived constituency. We vote on the basis of class, colour, and language etcetera. Parliamentarians are not competent to provide relief to public in true sense. Affluent people participate in election process while poor and competent mass remain absent in representation. After election, Prime Minister is blackmailed in different ways to get entry to cabinet. According to reports 250 parliamentarians, elected in 2013 election, were holding fake degrees. Just imagine! How will such illiterate parliamentarians will bring changes in system and society. On the other hand, presidential system will at least have well educated technocrats. Institutions will be workings under sops and in their ambit. Importantly, we haven't experienced presidential system so far, the one which is discussed widely was Ayoub era, he was not elected but took over the system. In presidential system president is selected by the people vote. President can't challenge institutions the way today's cabinet and parliamentary bodies are doing. Parliament supremacy, in parliamentary system, is actually considered prophetic politics. Everything and institutions are paralyzed by parliament. NAB, SBP, ECP, COAS, and other important positions are under the PM. What is the role of Cabinet, just suggestive or consultancy body. Whatever the PM want is done either by parliamentary process if can't than ordinance is the best way to bypass parliamentarians. In short, it is high time to adopt presidential system for the national development and public interest.

[@hayatcreation2837]

Well said man👏

[@mustahsinabbas3764]

Very well shah sahib

[@rehankhanme3477]

GREAT SIR, YOU NAILED IT.

[@sportshighlights1048]

Absolutely brilliant sir! 👍

[@englishworld7792]

Both are better with quality implementation...

[@kamranmalik2808]

Ma Sha Allah Great Love you Sir.

[@junaidjadoon361]

really good

[@raiheerani5460]

So much informative

[@salmanfarooq6552]

Very well explained

[@ElectricBurgers]

Make more provinces, better administration and development. And better control.

[@tariquehafeezbughio1579]

Such a wonderful explanation

[@dailyrecipewithurooj1715]

Due to your video now I'm able to make my assignment

[@abidhussain.c]

Sir Ali is best ❤️

[@testerreviewer3256]

excellent

[@sadiarashid5546]

Sir do make a video about pak us relations after the statement " Pakistan still a strategic partner" Because there must be some hidden motives of US behind this statement

[@amikakitchen2692]

✨China✨

[@tahirkorejo8750]

Excellent..

[@yaseenhussainofficial9151]

🇵🇰 پاکستان زندہ باد 🇵🇰

[@saifkhan6188]

A.O.A sir..! I was keenly waiting for the current hot debate of presidential or parliamentary system of govt and pakistan .. Very well explained but one thing is missing ,advantages of presidential system in the context of pakistan .. One thing more , as said by well known lawyer of SC , Aitezaz Ahsan that it is a useless discussion that pakistan should opted for presidential system bz it is and it will considered to be nullifying the 1973 constitution , which is based on parliamentary form of government .. Need your answer

[@Wanderer975]

Ahtazaz ahsan belong to PPP. and PPP is not in favour of Presidential system because they fear that they will not get enough votes to win in presidential system. A System is created for welfare of people. It's not a word of God that can not be changed.

[@shezalrose6986]

Yes it will, in order to implement presidential system in Pakistan, the country will need to frame and adopt a new constitution based on presidential system.

[@amirmuhammad60]

Highly appreciated ....sir

[@alabrar2779]

Nice keep going

[@usairashahbaz7889]

Impressive sir

[@munazzajabeen7134]

Great explanation 👍

[@e-quranlearning8575]

your argument on east asia valid argument....

[@AmjadAli-fz3nx]

Good effort sir.

[@mtufailsafi7736]

Extremly well elaborated...

[@waqaschishti3344]

Thank you sir❤

[@llearnquran]

well said country adopt system what suits them as their culture and history. keen to see your video on Khilafat system in contrast with these 2.

[@reez1728]

There is no such thing as a "Khilafah" system as it was just Muslim colonial rule and as with other imperial powers it was kicked out. The closest you can get to a "Khilafah" is to have a customs, currency, trade union, etc with other Muslim majority countries and implement something similar to EU or South American countries.

[@amiriqbal2084]

Please make one video on SAPs and IMF

[@shaneali2212]

Nice video sir concept is clear

[@ElectricBurgers]

What's our biggest need. Stability prosperity. We need value system society. Development, economy.

[@TheKnowledgehub621]

Thank you so much Sir! 👏🏾👏🏾

[@syedafaryal3883]

Please add subtitles. Sometimes I don't understand what you said. The words don't come out clearly sometimes.

[@abdulsaboorkhan8337]

Some modifications in the presidential system that suits our under privileged areas would favour Pakistan a lot. Parliamentary system is over experienced, & is nothing more than a deteriorating dead body.

[@politicalscientist3980]

V good sir g

[@randomstuff9850]

Agr hum provincial system hi khtm kr dein or pakistan ma one unit state system ho to phr apki kya raye ha k presidential system kesay work kray ga?? Kya aesa possible hota ha kisi b country ma?? I'm student of BS-IR so plz guide me in this regard. Thanks

[@nimrakamal7076]

Your lectures are very nice .. plz work on doing 1 lecture a weak .. thank you

[@nidaaslam8367]

Thank you! sir.

[@lovetobefamous1350]

Sir Balochistan parties and Afghanistan k regarding b elaborate Karen please

[@boldintra7108]

Thank you sir for detail information

[@knowledgeinspiration5306]

Suplendid lecture sir g

[@wpes862]

Thanks

[@muhammadbilal.1162]

Nice sir.

[@muhammadqavisalam4232]

Kindly elaborate history or profile of presidential and parliamentary form In pakistan ?

[@tranquility10]

Thank you

[@umarhayat6012]

Ideal

[@stealth9074]

Thanks sir

[@rahilarahim6768]

Commendable

[@CHHaroon-oc9xp]

Delegate OR Instructed representation theory ka marit merites and demerits bt Sir

[@SaraAli-gk3vu]

By the way, in both forms of government, we have failed to stabilize the country whether it is an economic, political, social, or technological sphere. We need a proper SYSTEM not a government to form long-term policymaking and ensure its execution as other developed countries are doing for the well-being of their people. Unfortunately, we always occupy the last place in every index of the world, especially HDI. Neither we can progress in Presidential nor Parliamentary forms of government unless we built a strong system that can benefit common people, not feudalists, capitalists, industrialists, politicians, major generals, and others.

[@MuhammadUmar-jl7mm]

Agree

[@Wanderer975]

When did we have a proper democratic Presidential system?

[@niazabbasi6019]

Perfect 💕

[@amikakitchen2692]

The main problem is that the system always manages to give power only few people in the top and our feeble minds are built for creating cults and mindlessly following these selfish elitists. Pakistani people have to learn their rights in order to put all these people accountable for that reason I supported IK but now that he's stared all this chaos knowing the state of our country idk what to say. I think Pakistan needs to invest more GDP on educational institutions rather than our military for a start!

[@himanshuyadav6672]

I am shocked to see why majority of Pakistani support Presidential System. Want to see Imran khan as President.. But if this happened,then Pakistan would face the consequences of it like as they faced in 1971

[@learnwithsamar1420]

Great

[@mariumsaleemi2037]

Sir 👍

[@HistoryxPolitics]

The argument that the presidential system would create political imbalance between Punjab and other provinces is flawed. The problem is more prevalent in the existing parliamentary system where the votes of the people of Balochistan rarely decide who gets to become PM. At least in a presidential system, they will have a direct role in choosing the executive.

[@ayazulhaq6040]

Moazzam sb please explain what is meant by concurrent list

[@faryalali4709]

V well interpreted!

[@usamaimtiaz2709]

Sir please give some information about legislation and executive under presidential form

[@salmanfarooq4483]

Thankew Sir @Ali_Naqvi for building my opinion & stance on parliamentary and presidential system debate!

[@bukhariiistudyplanet130]

Sir kindly Russia Vs Ukraine issue cover krain

[@AmeenShah76]

Thank you sir

[@farwamughal3564]

Can't we say thay that still federal harmony is being disturbed even in parliamentary system keeping in mind the situation of other provinces ?.

[@raheembux3978]

Is parliamentary system ne Pakistan ka Bera ghark kardiya he

[@AliRaza-vw7gi]

Sir, even in the current composition of Parliament, Punjab's share is overriding. If we move to presidential system, we can also change our voting system and devise some way to give smaller states more representation than their population. Like winner takes all in smaller states but not in Punjab.

[@ALFAREHMAN100]

Sir episod on curent affair of last page magzine work on it plz

[@maoozriaz6216]

Didn't do justice yo the topic. His tilt was towards parliamentary system. Even if you are pro-parlimentary system, atleast you should have told about pros of presidential system. However, the knowledge you shared is worth appreciating. Keep doing great work.

[@Wanderer975]

yes. He did not talk about the bad sides of Parliamentary system. He is saying that east Pakistan separated because of Presidential system. That is not true because yahya was a martial law administrator. He was not an elected president.

[@reez1728]

You do realise that even in a presidential system there's still a legislative body that will be elected through a similar system that is in place now? And in the event where the Presidency and Legislature are held by different parties (which happens quite often in America and other presidential system countries) there is a complete gridlock and nothing gets done. So neither system is a silver bullet to Pakistan's problems because the problem lies elsewhere.

[@shroudjr3705]

Sir how to get prevent elite capture in case of parliamentary system of governance?

[@suyyammunir]

Sir it was highly biased discussion, because you didn’t point out the flaws of parliamentary system that Pakistan has been facing….you pointed out loopholes of presidential system in the context of Pakistan but that hung-parliament couldn’t deliver is not mentioned..there are many positives of presidential system in context of Pakistan which l..

[@sanaqau1]

Dear really thankful for frank review of my talk. I would rather call my talk one dimensional and focused on fundamental thesis that parliamentary form suites pakistan. If you listen to my conclusion, first line of it, you will find me clearly stating that parliamentary system is not perfectly suited but only better. I fundamentally agree with what you are trying to say. Thank you

[@muneebafzaal7789]

True.. By just discussing the flaws of Presidential system and recommending a system on basis of weak analysis. Is Presidential system just resp for East Pak seperation. Wt abt elections and Tum udr Hum idr mindset.. Pak greatly progressed in 1960s during Presidential system. Should we give authority of our future decisions in the hands of Current Rubbish political leaders?

[@Wanderer975]

@@sanaqau1 parliamentary system is not good for Pakistan. That's why Pakistan suffered tremendously in last 30 years.

[@abdulmakeen5701]

Kindly show the full map of Pakistan sir pls

[@JuniorAnalyst]

Let’s divide 4 provinces into 100+ provinces & then bring presidential system?

[@shahryarmughal4620]

Sir but we also see some great and successful exemples of presidential system in world isn't it

[@sanaqau1]

Thats true. My whole argument is it is not system but political culture that determines which system suites pakistan

[@shahryarmughal4620]

@@sanaqau1 sir , how about analysing failures of Western capitalist democracy against socialist system in our region . We need to know about it . Shall be grateful?

[@Wanderer975]

@@sanaqau1 Sir, how can only political culture bring positive change to Pakistan?? System is crucial for progress of a country. Compare China & india. They were at the same level 30 years ago. System matters a lot.

[@abdulrafy8847]

don't it look parliamentary system has failed in Pakistan? Please also share your ideas on this topic. Much obliged!

[@Ukmahi]

What we achieved in 76 years by implementing Parlimentry or Presidential Govt Actually we had gotten confused by someone we totally ignore the Ideology of Pakistan the Basic Resolution of Pakistan Allah Almighty sent Us for what purpose and What we do in 76 years Westren Models wow is this is our identity or we are someone else can anyone imagine how 90 caror ppl gives sacrifices to creat Pak for what Ideology , those who fight almost 45 years for only one govt The Islamic Sharia (Afghnistan) three times they impliment Sharia Law and what we do in 76 years i feel much abashed living in Islamic State of Pak by Name that is what IDENITITY CRISES (Ghulam Qoom) that what Alama Iqbal Said

[@Wanderer975]

There were never 90 crores Muslims in whole subcontinent. Presidential system was created in the west by taking inspiration from caliphate system. You should watch dr israr Ahmed on Presidential System to clear your mind.

[@Ukmahi]

@@Wanderer975 bro i know they are insprie from Caliphate system but i will talked about todays Presidential system i think Presidential system itself abashed from todays so called Presidential

[@womensclub5426]

👍

[@ahmadahmad-v7d4v]

اسلامک صدارتی نظام

[@ahmad3832]

Hmm

[@khansher5411]

Sir bhot hi behtreen video iss topic par... lekin ANI ka side par clip lagaya apne... ANI indian establishment ka mouthpiece hy... you should avoid it

[@ElectricBurgers]

The kind of presidential system we had was under military rules, which is not representation.

[@AliRaza-vw7gi]

Secondly, why are we basing our hypothesis that governance will be strongly centralised.

[@ElectricBurgers]

Wrong argument, Pakistan didn't have true presidential system.. However Pakistan saw huge development in those Martial law presidential rules, but doesn't support democratic model.

[@mudassirabdulghaffar5233]

❤🔥❤

[@raotabishaleem292]

In America like model all provinces will have equal opportunity to select president.. Keeping senators vote in view I think... There may be difference in popular vote as in case of trump and Hillary Clinton