Pretty Little Liars: Alison, Mrs. D, Bethany & That Night

I really think I'm onto something. All these connections we have been given. Bethany and Radley play a much bigger role into it all then we think. Mrs. D was sketchy, and this video sort of shows what she would do just to save herself. Cece is also sketchy + working for Mrs. DiLaurentis in my opinion. Comment your thoughts and follow on Twitter, Instagram and Tumblr @PLLheadA

[@Candiexoce]

How many affairs has Mrs. D been in?! :0

[@ambercrosland6472]

1 that we know of Peter Hastings

[@girlsclub8078]

And Bethany’s dad

[@jailynbillings]

Girls Club So technically 2

[@VinnyPezzano]

Lmao enough to be rightfully called MRS. D heavy on the D lmfao

[@allfiredup93]

I didn't see anyone at the window but as Ali came out there was someone's shadow behind her!

[@faithbanrd6633]

Bvh VB bjbhu ex cxh I u vg j chug

[@lizzettefuentes8946]

allfiredup93 Same

[@11Doortje98]

Does anyone else here see Paige looking strange when Spencer is being arrested, but not saying ánything at all? 13:02 - 13:22

[@dianabot3050]

I did see that!! 😱😱

[@emilyblairmohr]

I think Bethany and Sara Harvey are the same person. Listen to Sara Harvey's voice in the show, then to Bethany's on the recording. They're eerily alike

[@imbryce6225]

No cc is bethany "Sarah harvey" is charles The real sarah harvey is the body in the grave its possible that cc used her dna and planted it in the body

[@hotpinkminisk1rts]

Sarah is NOT Charles, Charles is Cece/Charlotte.

[@hotpinkminisk1rts]

And Cece is Charlotte/Charles, Charles became a female.

[@hrts4pb]

yeah! i thought that when i heard the tape

[@alex_n215]

Kermit // i honestly think they just used her voice in that tape and that’s what led people to believe that sara was bethany.

[@shacks29]

Apart from the whole Bethany/Ali/Cece twin story,there is one thing that really bothers me the most...when Spencer and Alison had this fight outside the house,Cece and Melissa both separately watching them,after that Spencer went back to the barn and Alison went back to the house but here comes the error Melissa followed Spencer steady and "stumbled" over Bethany who was lying next to the excavated hole and the shovel thinking Spencer killed her seconds ago...So here is the Problem: Ali was hit and buried first at the same place!!! These things couldn´t occur simultaneously! Also there was no time for "in the meantime".

[@XENIAKESISOGLOU]

didn't see anyone watching from the window... :(

[@JacesunS]

The night Aly was leaving the house, Mrs.D was on the phone with someone, she kept saying "please send someone, hurry, I am very worried" and she kept looking out the window. And she told Aly that "you're not going out tonight, don't fight me on this, go upstairs and call it a night!". N again she says to the phone "please send someone, I am worried" while looking out the window. Must have been Charles? Bethany? Someone escape from Radley??

[@bilshunter5377]

Yeah we knew from season 6 that Cece escaped from Radley

[@melaniesabrina3823]

The shirt Ashely picked up was the same shirt cece was wearing

[@sydnitheromantictaylor112]

I don't get why Jessica D. would keep quiet about Spencer just because Peter was going to tell Kenneth about the affair, if I thought somebody killed my child idc what anybody threatens me with, it's going to the cops no matter what. I think it was easy to keep Jessica quiet because she knew Alison was NOT dead she knew it was Bethany.

[@Nikofetty]

What really got me was that she knew and was right there burying Ali while cece hit her on accident but just blame spencer like whar

[@lauren1182]

The yellow dresses made me think of the story Alison told Hanna and the boy Hanna was babysitting for Halloween in the Halloween flashback episode

[@shellydunnigan5387]

I'm pretty sure Bethany is still alive and it's Sarah Harvey in the grave. I think the sisters are Mrs D and Toby's mom Marion Cavanaugh. I think Bethany and Toby are twins and they are cousins with Ali. Maybe the little twin girls story happened between Ali and Bethany as kids and Mrs D being on the board of Radley got Bethany committed. Ali's dad wanted Jessica to have nothing to do with Bethany after the stabbing incident, but Mrs D felt guilty about her niece and would take her clothes and on trips. Marion went on a downward spiral after this and ended up in Radley herself. The night Toby's mom 'fell' from the roof, I think she was pushed by her sister Mrs D and Bethany having seen the whole thing, was made to cover it up, but vowed revenge. So that night, she escaped Radley, intent on murdering Ali and to make Mrs D pay for destroying her family.

[@JoytvOfficial]

I totally agree with your theory. I though Marion looked a lot like Mrs D ... which kinda made me think the flashback of the two blondes was them. But I think it could have been AriA' s flashback. Because the stove oven in the background Is the sAme in the Montgomery house...and AriA wore the same shows the blonde girls had in the flashback. (Just food for thought) and in the Montgomery picture album there was a picture of twins. And as we all no there are no coincidences in ALL

[@Saucymikes]

I agree, whether Bethany is A or not is a matter to discuss, spoilers say that A is physcotic and their name has 7 letters. B-E-T-H-A-N-Y and Bethany was in Radley, this would explain a lot but it's still possible.

[@cheerluv0790]

Who is Sarah??

[@JoytvOfficial]

Cheerluv07 the blonde girl who acted like Alison, in the next town who went missing around the same time.

[@cheerluv0790]

***** what episode was that because I don't remember her??

[@akadarenaud2762]

I did not see anybody in the window

[@atheerdirectioner3290]

not in the window but look at when ali was running after spencer u can see someone behind her for a moment

[@stepdawk]

Definitely think Bethany hit Ali. I'm wondering if Cece is the one who then knocked out Bethany? Or perhaps Mrs. D knocked Bethany out before burying Alison, and during that time Melissa was burying Bethany. It may have also been Sarah in the grave, but she was maybe mistaken for Bethany? In another theory video, however, it was noted that Ali & Cece were seen in yellow tops. Bethany's letter mentions yellow clothing. If Sarah was there, what are the odds that she too was in a yellow top?

[@piepie4644]

Where is the person watching from the window at 9:45?

[@S0il9]

beths voice sounds so much like melissas voice

[@atheerdirectioner3290]

yeah it does

[@ellenn7]

i wish ali and her mum could've had a reunion, there was so much they hid from eachother

[@marcusbaker6339]

What if the dress was for Jason

[@lizzettefuentes8946]

Marcus Baker It was for CeCe Drake

[@stephobrien9773]

All the clues about bethany were actually all mainly about cece, makes more sense now

[@heidikessler6832]

Did anyone else notice that when spencer and aria are looking through Bethany's drawing book some of the the pictures have a letter that spells Alison's name. If you look really closely you will notice a few of the letters like an l, an i, and an o. Like if you noticed this too.

[@heidikessler6832]

And that in the drawing of a girl in the mirror, it represents Alison a little bit when she looked in the mirror and that there was a message from A.

[@julianapowell9042]

My theory is that Mona isn't dead she's alive and Mike has connection with her but he lied to aria so aria would go tell the girls everything and they would stop creeping in Mike's things. And the girl that was in Ali's grave was Sarah Harvey and the recording that is supposed to be "Bethany" is really CeCe Drake CeCe lied to the police and then pretty much disappeared I also think Kate is Big A cuz she definitely hates Hanna and her friends she could know a lot about the girls and maybe even lived near the girls the whole time ever since they were little Mrs D and Marion are sisters and Mrs D pushed Marion off the Building while Bethany sat and watched Toby knows everything and lied about not knowing how his mom died he also could have talked to Ali as she's in Jail and found out everything and is back working with A red coat is Bethany and Lucas working with her Melissa is in the barrel an Toby didn't tell any of the liars cuz they can't keep secrets my last thing is that there will actually be 8 seasons and the "BIG A REVEAL" is really just going to show some of the person and mysterious ways will still be in mind

[@Cat9985]

This is the best theory I've heard yet.

[@jazmineflemming2395]

Juliana Powell hey

[@FantageTV77]

You are wrong about one thing remember when they thought Toby was A? they saw his tattoo " 901 Free at least " then Spencer says : Thats the date that Ali went missing so she actually was missing on September 1st

[@TheFarah2b]

Chris RedField Well, didn't Alison disappear at night? That means she could've been gone September 1st, but could've disappeared the night before.

[@FantageTV77]

+TheFarah2b yeah the night of september 1st which is why they call it "that night"

[@abbimae4195]

Can u do one and circle the person in the window

[@briannamejia1897]

At 9:47 I didn't see anyone watching from the window? 😩

[@XENIAKESISOGLOU]

what if Mrs D is Bethany's mother? and she had made a promise to Bethany that she would get her out of Radley for good? Maybe, what Bethany is heard saying "who to believe in that family" refers to Mrs D's broken promise? Maybe Alison (who we now know knew Bethany) kept renewing Bethany's dream of being free saying the same things as Mrs D? Young could be an imagined surname - we do not really know who her father is - the Liars assume that Mrs D was having an affair. What if Bethany's father is Alison's father who, after the stabbing incident, decided he wanted no more relation with his deranged (?) daughter and, who, was threatening Mrs D with a divorce should she kept her communication with Bethany??? What if, the clothing item Bethany received was the same yellow top she had bought Alison (despite their argument). Remember how she had bought two identical yellow dresses (xmas episode)? What do you think? it is getting all the more confusing...

[@amandasmith12]

Yeah, does anyone have any idea who Bethany's parents are?

[@FantageTV77]

XENIA KESISOGLOU Maybe her parents are the Montgomery's that's why there were 2 little girls in the picture remember?

[@breannaconway9961]

My favorite movie is pretty little liars every day

[@isshumav3554]

I love your theory lol I think Bethany is Ceces' twin idk lol I've been thinking that as soon as Wilde was dead , Mrs.D had to come back to Rosewood to enact her plan. My theory is that A or someone even Wilden was blackmailing her about Bethany. She needed to protect herself by framing Spencer. I think she knew since the day she found out Ali & Spencer had problems, she was like " this is perfect I can use this for the events that were to come "Alis' death"/Bethanys' "arrival." Mrs.D knew she would be exposed so she needed to get to the finish line first before someone pulled the smoking gun. She hired someone to Kill Bethany because she was going to blow the lid on everything. But They saw Ali thinking it was Bethany and hit Ali. Mrs.D definitely knows who A is !

[@JoytvOfficial]

Bethany is Charles .

[@daijataylor3741]

***** Andrew is Bethany.

[@JoytvOfficial]

Exactly . Andrew is Charles lol

[@milkodube7129]

***** What

[@genevevekiingley5103]

***** Charles Dilaurentis is obviously Jason's twin.

[@racheljagielski5517]

Geneveve Kiingley why obviously? I mean, how are you so sure? Im not being rude, i'd just like you to share your thoughts and opinions :)

[@anejapasalic4148]

dress was for Charles=Charlotte=Cece

[@okayyanna9353]

This is the only theory that I've read that actually makes sense!!!!!

[@Emmac12364]

That night was truly chaotic

[@1992Fabulous]

Riiight? Sooo much happening in just one night? Geeeeesh

[@stephaniemichelle1143]

1:38 is the same Mona said when she was in Radley...

[@ilovecandy2468]

i love your videos :)

[@shoniquerahming2451]

hii every one i think bethany young is alive i think that her voice she is alive she met fake her dead

[@gabberzlovesScreamox]

this has to tie in to Aria. I think her dad had an affair with Mrs D. They are both known for affairs.

[@felicianagy5096]

5:22 is it toby who is carried by the monster?

[@ErikaHernandez-cy8lq]

seeing this video again i started wondering, Peter hasting wanted Jessica not to tell the police about spencer but he didnt use wilden, he used tobys mother case! That's what toby wanted to say. Maybe even peter hasting told him before hand and that why he drop the issue that quickly o maybe he jus started to realize that. The question is why wilden was protecting spencer?

[@rachelxxx4350]

Wait so was it Bethany that mrs d saw hit Alison with a rock?

[@ellenn7]

i literally saw no one in the window????

[@danielmoultrie]

What if Rhonda is A?

[@katerinelopez2042]

What if Honda is A? 8 Hola 7 Nsmms.smwmmmmsmnsmsmwmsmd Smd.sms.sksmsns.snsmmsmsme.een.sne Sne.mwmw Katy - A Msmsmsmssm. Sms Sms. Smwsmw. Snenenw Msmsmsmw Nmsndmmsmsnmnsksms.. Kskmsmwjisnekkw Skmsjkjwkw. Skwkw

[@shacks29]

I just realized that Jason is Spencers Brother and Cousin lol

[@theprincess857]

but why would Cece go with the plan of helping Jessica frame Spencer knowing that it's not true ? unless she's doing it to protect or benefit herself as well , i have a theory that bethany is Cece's twin , and the one who Jason saw with melissa wearing the same clothes as Ali is actualy bethany not Cece , because Alison didn't mention anything about seing Cece that night .

[@Strawhat_Kal]

Also Ali never talked about Garrett and Jenna outback of her house.

[@theprincess857]

bethany was 17 at the time while Alison was 15 , and Cece is 2 year older than Ali , which makes Cece and bethany the same age , and im not just coming up with the twin theory thing , Sasha confirmed in an interview that Ali doesn't have a twin but someone else does , im just saying that it could be Cece , get your facts together mister before you talk .

[@theprincess857]

www.reddit.com/r/PrettyLittleLiars/comments/2etmpi/my_newest_theoryand_yes_of_course_it_included/ , that website could be wrong , the whole fandom knows that Cece is 2 years older than Ali .

[@theprincess857]

well its just a theory , it would just make sence why Jessica has gifted both of them clothes ,probably for the same reason .

[@shellydunnigan5387]

Cece is a good bit older than Bethany. When we first met Cece, we found out how she supposedly hated Ali for getting her kicked out of college. This obviously must have happened before Ali disappeared, so how was Cece in college at 17? Plus the only person we know of who is ages with Bethany is actually Toby. If she is anyone's twin, it must be Toby's. Besides, they have never confirmed anyone has a twin. What they said is Ali doesn't have a twin like in the books, but someone else might have a sister, not necessarily a twin.

[@toriaxx8741]

I didn't see anyone watching from the window...

[@kathleendiaz4022]

No Cece is Charles

[@RMMØ-z4x]

Wait, why did Cece do all this for Mrs.D. She already kinda got arrested so why couldn't she tell everything. What is up with her and Mrs.D. I think Cece IS Bethany but Cece is just her fake name. Bethany got out of Radley and pretended to be her long dead sister Cece Drake. On Halloween when Ali tells that story about the killing of the twins, I think that the parents who walked in were called the Drakes and that Bethany was sent of to another family so maybe they could fix her up and they were called the Youngs and then Bethanys 'fake' parents sent her to Radely and then Mrs.D came to tell EVERYTHING about the killings because Bethany had kinda lost her memory and to remember stuff she would record it on tape or draw it. Sorry this was long!

[@yanakacarova3729]

What if Jason and Bethany are btorher and sister? May be even twins? One of the Bethany's drawings was little girl and boy like the boy was taking away from their house... and we know that Ali's father is not the father of Jason! So Jason's father may be Bethany's father as well. ( Wired enough that makes Bethany and Spencer half-sisters =D ) May be Bethany was angry to call Mrs.D aunt, because she already knew that she is her mather...

[@karina61400]

Dang Mrs. D really got around the blocks didn’t she? Can’t imagine how many more kids she had out there… 🤦🏼‍♀️

[@haleyharris4178]

BETHANYS VOICE SOUNDS JUST LIKE SARAH HARVEY!!!!! They fakes Bathany's death and Sarah is really Bethany. Oh MY GODDDDDDDDD

[@411j422j]

yes i see a shadow behind the window

[@genevevekiingley5103]

12:54 nonononono. If anything, Spencer killing Bethany would score points with Alison, NOT because Alison "was jealous of Bethany," but because Alison's mother was having an affair with Bethany's father and Ali held a grudge for that. Duh.

[@nata7305]

Has everybody forgotten Claire from that other group of friends that were in rosewood?If you look closely she is in the christmas episode in the back when Ali comes in.Her voice is also the one On the tape recorder that was talking about mrs D.She could be A since she said that she wanted her other friend dead

[@PupppyxCrazzzy]

I think Bethany pushed Marion of the roof because she found out about the affair but she didn't mean to push Marion she meant to push Jessica D. Jessica saw this and kept it a secret.

[@kailyngale5527]

Who wAs watching Ali and spencer in the window I couldn't see

[@mikelaslater6109]

Okay So Boom I'm Rewatching The Seasons And I Believe Sarah Harvey Is Not Sarah Harvey .. She's Charles & The The Girl In Ali's Grave Is Not Bethany But She's Sarah Harvey The Real Sarah Harvey .. And CeCe Isn't CeCe She Is Bethany 🙃 Anyone Else Agree ? 💁 ..

[@wheatbread2028]

The other dress was for cece right?

[@yaraye16]

The dress was for Bethany

[@siobhanxxx100]

Bethany killed Jessica?

[@averykobs5462]

where did alison go after she disappeared?

[@newuser5773]

I know this is late, but Mona helped her hide, and Ali have her tips to become more popular. She was redcoat before Sarah started being redcoat. Ali put on the redcoat to keep an eye on her friends from whoever hit her in the head and buried her.

[@imanghomras7724]

Okay.. i need a full explanations of the entire show because i am so confused right now

[@allanahgonzalez9144]

Basically a group of 5 girls. One disappears and the rest group separated. A year later they all get together because her “death” brought them closer. Anywho they start to get Anonymous texts by a person that goes by “a” and “a” threatens them and they know all of the girls secrets. There is a lot more, but that’s the main jist

[@legendary2553]

@@allanahgonzalez9144 bad writing

[@zahraambari5552]

Pll is twisted...... the moment u think u kind ov know who A. It just happens thats not A....... can't wait 2 know who A is

[@TheFarah2b]

Zahra Ambari It should happen 6x10. Marlene said we will see a face, name, and have a story. I think it's a 2 hour episode.

[@ΜιχάληςΖολ]

Very good video!!!!

[@katjasjoberg750]

what season and which or what episode

[@rebeccadawber6811]

It was for cece

[@noek2438]

WHAT IF EZRAS LITTLE BROTHER IS CHARLES?

[@emilykossen1997]

yeah I think he was

[@sarasworld5824]

The only thing I'm confused about is if Ali killed Bethany due to jealousy, what was Ali jealous of? Was she jealous that her mom was giving Bethany more attention than Alison? We all know Ali loves to have everyone's attention?!

[@emelyisabeth8764]

Allison twin with Bethany I do not think so and that would not explain Hanna surprise when she read Bethany's letter. Someone has a twin but not Ali is probably the blonde girls who related or not. Toby's mom new something and that's why they got her out of the way

[@michelleh9226]

Mrs. Dilaurentis payed Cece to be quiet because She had an affair with Spencers father

[@PrettyDesiii]

I never seen nobody in a window

[@trainfire2008]

9:42 am I just dead tired because I don’t see anyone staring from any window⁉️

[@chichiibegbu6223]

So who’s Bethany father???!

[@lizzettefuentes8946]

Wait, but, Alison never met Bethany

[@brittanygonzalez7532]

Do you think that was charles

[@Pauli20]

I think that Charles could be Bethany, that means that he could be transgender 😏

[@mockingpink]

Do you think that Jess had Alison and not Bethany ? And who made the video off Charles story anyway? Is all this a made up that jess told ?

[@nikitagharat178]

I think Bethany didn't kill Marion, some other blonde girl did and Jessica wanted to protect her.

[@emilykossen1997]

Charlotte killed Marion

[@nikitagharat178]

@@emilykossen1997 Exactly but that's not what they showed. Besides the big plot hole was that Marion was alive when Toby was about to kiss Alison.

[@taytymnevaeh412]

beathney is alive

[@ambercrosland6472]

Time out CeCe was Mary Drakes daughter along with Spencer and Alex Jessica only had Jason with Peter Hastings

[@sophialucia2858]

I'm on season 4 episode 11 yooo couldn't help it this show is fucked up y'all 😂😂🙈

[@cheerluv0790]

Do you remember how MS.D had an affair with Spencer's dad.. Well MS.D also had an affair with Bethany's dad. Maybe spencer and Bethany have the same dad???

[@chichiibegbu6223]

Who’s their dad??

[@sarahreeves8387]

Spencer didn't kill Ali

[@kaitlinbowers2890]

just think A is Mary Darke

[@1234k907]

5:14 does that drawing not look like a pig to u guys?????

[@javierleonides9074]

This show was so dramatic and terrible

[@jasonmoukala8909]

Not terrible at all

[@dmsnickmoore]

I thank Bethany young kill Mrs D because she jealous of Ali she kill Mrs not A kill Mrs D Bethany kill Mrs D I love this show so much I miss you this

[@isshumav3554]

*wilden

[@paulosilverio4023]

ahahuauaua

[@vanekaharris310]

What if the dress was for Jason