Prime Crime: The Young Mom and Her Deadly Night Out

[@anthony212459]

Being accused of a murder you didn't commit must be the ultimate nightmare.

[@tylermartin7245]

The real nightmare is spending time in prison for a crime you didn't commit. It's 10x worse when it's a bad charge, people don't even wanna think of that possibility.

[@tq2769]

I would say being accused of sexually molesting your own child when you didn't would have to be the ultimate nightmare.

[@SavitaS-h4k]

idd say guy paul Morins life is the ultimate nightmare. 20 yrs in prison for child assault and murder he didnt commit. Police investigations are trash.

[@Becki545]

Absolutely. I think Detri likely didn't completely flip out in part because of the support of his family and friend who knew him well.

[@Heathcoatman]

Pretty common, unfortunately. Once the police lock on to a suspect, they often dont see or dismiss anything that contradicts their 'hunch'. This channel blocks comments for really bizarre reasons. Plenty of crime channels that dont. Out.

[@jsab1270]

It’s ironic that when somebody calls the police for a missing report, they’re told by police they can’t do anything until after 24 hours. Here, police are suspicious the boyfriend didn’t call the police immediately.

[@pinkpugginz]

The 24 hour thing is not a law or true

[@charrielyn1231]

@@pinkpugginz Ahhh… yes it is! … or that’s how the police respond anyway, so what’s the difference - whether it’s the law or whether the police simply tell you they won’t until 24 hours has gone by?!

[@tracysamra1047]

The 24 hr thing is not a thing anymore

[@mollymelena6104]

I guarantee you if the BF had gone to police the next morning, they would have replied, "your GF is probably mad at you and wants you to worry. She'll come back eventually. Give it some time."

[@pinkpugginz]

@@mollymelena6104 that's not true. they asked why he didn't call the night before

[@Lala_B]

The Fitbit is what saved her boyfriend. I saw a report where they were able to corroborate his story literally to the step. The Fitbit recorded his resting heartbeat as he slept, the appropriate uptick and number of steps from his bed when he awoke to walk to tend to his crying baby, and on and on. That was a definitive timeline which could not be disputed. There was no time where he was shown walking as many steps as it would be to get to the vehicle, nor an increased heart rate as one would have coming upon the scene and bashing someone.

[@JinKazama92]

Google dashboard is what saved him.

[@redwatch.]

Excellent reminder. There must have been a great number of more false convictions before advanced technology came along.

[@DematriusWillrich]

@Lala_B I saw that one too

[@divinityomine6935]

​@@redwatch.Absolutely. I genuinely wonder how many people were wrongly incarcerated and how many people are murderers walking free

[@samstewart4807]

just because the boy friend was cleared does not mean someone else did not knock out the killer. This video did not show enough DNA evidence to show me he was the killer- is that because they want us to think the man convicted was not the killer? We have seen our vaunted media do this with other criminal cases. The fact the jury convicted him in 3 hours suggests that there was DNA evidence liking him to violent acts. I would like to know what he had been previously convicted of????? Again why not tell us that? Would his prior convictions cause us to see he had related previous convictions? IF in fact he did do it then he is the best lair I have ever seen. His body language etc is not consistent with that of a guilty man. But I think if that happened to me I would go to the police because I would know DNA would link me to her.

[@annazaman9657]

If it were the 1980's Doug would have been convicted on circumstances alone. Thank God for DNA and phone data

[@richardhoffman7572]

Scary to think how many people served prison time and were completely innocent.

[@zaneta3880]

Amen....

[@alexandrasymeon5893]

@@richardhoffman7572 There are thousands upon thousands of people doing prison time for crimes they did not commit. Even in this day and age. It's all about money and the corrupt justice system. No one cares.

[@7thHanuman]

The real masterminds of this crime are still out there. The origin of all negative thoughts and sins originate from those entities with the ability to manipulate our minds; entities of many names, examples are spirits/ghosts/demons. Those entities are the one roaming freely looking for the next opportunity to cause pain and suffering in Society.

[@steve10]

all because the defence want the win , and has zero integrity to know the story is absolute crap , and sells it to the jury ,, and he is sitting there being a part of this program trying to justify the lies he told the jury. im absolutely sickened by the defence lawyers response in this program

[@Ldogthe1nonly]

Holy crap I’m so happy for Matheu, way to stand up for yourself when you know you’re right

[@carltonwalton9819]

Agreed. Once cops start their belligerent bs, all are off! Talk to my lawyer.

[@williamhenry9705]

Those two cops are horrible people. They had him and Doug tried and convicted.

[@CrystaliaV]

​@@williamhenry9705no they weren't tried and convicted

[@GrammyDawe]

@@williamhenry9705 I agree that they had him tried and convicted in their minds; the response from @CrystaliaV does not make any sense.

[@Tinkerbellstune]

@@CrystaliaVI’m pretty sure the person didn’t mean it literally 🤦🏼‍♀️🤦🏼‍♀️

[@snapmalloy5556]

A few detectives owe Doug's buddy a serious apology. They jumped to conclusions and tried to bully a bad confession from someone. That isnt detective work, that is just being a bully looking to pad his resume

[@7thHanuman]

His buddy is a good friend. He was honest and smart to walk out of there.

[@gliderider7077]

Well……if the victim is your sister would you care if they “bullied” a possible suspect?? I don’t … stop because you know what this slanted uninformed video showed you, educate yourself and look at the big picture

[@rowana2177]

Agreed. The way they spoke to him was inappropriate, and not only in retrospect.

[@cindyboyd375]

@@gliderider7077 if the victim is my sister, I want the right person behind bars. I don't want a coerced confession that's false and puts someone else in prison. So yes, I would ABSOLUTELY care if they bullied a POSSIBLE suspect.

[@JaneQPublic-q4f]

@@gliderider7077 Sorry but cops telling outsight lies to coerce a confession by any means necessary is not OK just because it's legal and encouraged does not make it OK - it's just plain lazy, pure laziness that has destroyed countless lives in the past and still continue to destroy innocent people every day

[@loudMouse11]

As women its a wonder as many of us survive the drunken stupidity of our youth... when my girls went through that stage, i spent a lot of sleepless nights thinking about all the near misses i had and the luck i walked away with. Peace to Nikki's loved ones. Jesse your the best..thank you for this fair & unpartial retelling of these events.

[@IanBailey666]

Yea but most men are decent and only a small amount are dirt.

[@January.]

*As a woman, *impartial *Jessie, you're the best!

[@January.]

​@@IanBailey666*Yeah, but a small number of men are dirt.

[@the.h.is.silent]

Janewairie, why is u so angree about how peeps be typing? 😅

[@pinkpugginz]

​@FightingIrish885 unfortunately statistics say otherwise

[@DJ-ct6so]

I live outside the US. This is the first time I've seen Prime Crime. Very impressed with Jesse Weber's style of presentation.

[@terrenceolivido741]

there are few comments like your's here. i agree completey. extremely well presented.

[@DavidLouisson]

Yeah, this is a decent crime documentary.

[@John-bu2xt]

I am happy to see more outside the US seeing the reality. instead of what they've heard from mainly propaganda pieces.

[@RoughJustice2k18]

Not AI generated crap with a ton of mistakes - this is real crime story presentation. Nice.

[@OfficiaIneo]

It's breathtaking.

[@dovilecollins8960]

It is unforgivable what the defense attorneys did. Winning was so important that they were going to send an innocent man to prison. Shame on them.

[@captainjackson6135]

but it is ok when a prosecutor does it?

[@kikibalser]

@@captainjackson6135 No...neither one is "ok". The difference is that the LE's arrested the boyfriend first and realized they had the wrong guy and let him go.

[@horacio-ho3bf]

It's literally their job.....and shows that science in 2000s prevails

[@conniemarschand8636]

That turned my stomach , I know he has to try & get his client off , but come on , DNA was all over her

[@Confessions089]

While the real killer is walking free and causing chaos.

[@sunnin1671]

Good on Matheu for NOT ALLOWING these bullies to rope him into something he could never get out of. If that happened they wouldn’t care who the REAL KILLER was - they would lie and cover to save face.

[@horaceball5418]

Have you seen Jane Fonda's face lift? She looks 21!

[@jimwerther]

They thought he was involved. Relax.

[@robintamihere4550]

@@horaceball5418 what does Jane Fonda's face lift have to do with this case?

[@rpc2112]

1000% The only correct answer to every question by cops is, "I don’t answer questions. I invoke my 5th amendment rights." Then go call and attorney. This answer is not legally allowed to be used against you in court.

[@GameChanger597]

​@@jimwertherThe issue is the partner is always the first suspect and guilty until proven innocent rather than innocent until proven guilty. They often assume right off the bat instead of looking for the real criminal. Cops have a tendency to do this- blaming the wrong person and wasting precious time to find the right one

[@tmarie648]

You never want your smile to brighten up a room 😢😢😢

[@charrielyn1231]

Apparently not…

[@js-de8vh]

They don’t care that she died because of the fact that they weren’t the ones. Knowing they could be .

[@pillowbug3006]

I'm glad mine doesn't because I was thinking the same thing.

[@js-de8vh]

@@pillowbug3006 Does the father of the child have a profile pic with his daughter?

[@LadyAngela678]

Dang right, I suck the life out of every room I walk in to. 😊

[@Timmeh_The_tyrant]

Imagine how many innocent people are locked up because of cops making assumptions

[@phillipwombacher9635]

Around 40% of murder suspects

[@Pitbulllover77-y3l]

So many 😢😢😢😢😢😢

[@frisc0strangler207]

A lot

[@analelevic1024]

Or reckless mistakes.

[@davelowets]

NOT George...

[@AnhDonoi]

What a great endorsement for Fitbit. Saving your life in more ways than one

[@Comedybrand]

What a scary guy. If Doug wasn't wearing a fit bit, he would have been strung up by everyone.

[@John-bu2xt]

Facts

[@mabhulo2263]

Very scary! 😢

[@VioletJoy]

Everyone on social media for sure.

[@wimvhaastere7504]

@@Comedybrand im not sure, ofcourse the fitbit helped to have a New narratieve, but the case for him would have been weak as soon as the blood turned to be turkey blood, at least thats what i think.

[@emmagatewood3898]

This is the best possible ad for getting a fitbit 😳

[@savvageorge]

That fitbit paid for itself.

[@frankmacias7244]

Unless the Killer was wearing it!

[@LeanneRigby-iy7nx]

Fit bits are great if you’re innocent, problematic if you’re not lol

[@glitter7777]

Haha you ain’t never lied

[@krystagail8019]

Or to not get one …

[@veggietrish]

He murders her and then puts her family through this ridiculous story. What a vile human being.

[@Stinkychicken93]

That defence attorney has no soul .. you've got to be a certain kind of person to defend a murderer and try to send the victims partner to prison 🤮

[@jimwerther]

Detrie wouldn't have gone to prison though

[@scottcol23]

@@jimwerther Yeah, All he was trying to do was create doubt strong enough to force the jury to turn a not guilty verdict. You are right, it would not have sent Doug to prison.

[@Elzie-Nou]

@@scottcol23still takes a certain kind of person to willingly defend a murderer. It is said that psychopaths gravitate to LE, higher Corporate positions and medicine. I really think many are also to be found in law. Casey Anthony’s lawyer being a prime example.

[@777NCM]

Even the most vile are entitled to a fair trial because of the occasional innocent defendant that has been wrongly convicted in the court of public opinion.

[@jimwerther]

@@Elzie-Nou You sound like a jealous, bitter person. What a sad way to live.

[@Dragonfly657]

Think about the consequences before you do things out of anger. Don’t go with strangers !

[@Carolinagirl589]

Alcohol affects judgement - I doubt she would have done this sober.

[@wishIKnewHowToLove]

she was drunk! although i'm pretty sure it did not matter to the killer. however, when people are drunk their decisions are dumber.

[@darrenbaker6019]

@@Carolinagirl589think about the consequences of drinking then

[@ursodermatt8809]

50% of murder vicitims in the US are under the influence.

[@charlesterrizzi8311]

@@Carolinagirl589plan your drinking to be in safe company, it’s important

[@Alexandria87]

The size of that monster 😨😨😨 I get instant chills thinking about what Nikki went through that terrible night 😢😢 I'm so glad that the fitbit vindicated Doug. I'm glad the procesution was able to see right through his BS story of him being this helpless and unwilling accomplice that him and his defense team tried so hard to push.

[@lance_1612]

Never walk alone, you never know what monsters are out there among us.

[@daviddraper5627]

After three hours of deliberating guilty. They didn't believe a word he said

[@ememedem6476]

George thought he did something there…what a looser!

[@KandeShack]

Burch sucks! He really thought he could get away with it!!

[@faith3753]

Not.a.word.

[@reneesantiago6496]

Moral of the story………NOTHING good happens after midnight! Especially alcohol after midnight!

[@JustBreatheOkay]

very true, every single time i drank alone in my home, and after a few glasses of wine i went to liquor store to buy more, so on all of those trips in the recent month I've lost my debit card, my apple headphones and the silver bracelet. this is very embarrassing to even talk about it

[@reneesantiago6496]

@@JustBreatheOkay Well, I mean more if your drinking at the bar after midnight. I only drank for 8 yrs of my life and I’m 53, but I’d be EMBARRASSED and ASHAMED to say the crap I got myself into at the bar after midnight! 😂😂😂😂😂

[@JustBreatheOkay]

@@reneesantiago6496 what was your drink of choice?

[@reneesantiago6496]

@@JustBreatheOkay Well, as soon as I entered the bar I ordered either a straight shot of patron or jeager……and a beer with a water to chase the shot. Sometimes we did Fireball too. I had a very scary and horrible incident happen one night when I was drunk and I never drank again! I got out of it scott free, but that was just GOD🙏🏻🙏🏻 It could have been HORRENDOUS!!!😢😢

[@JustBreatheOkay]

@@reneesantiago6496 what happened?

[@kentuky1233]

By watching these videos I've learned that if you have a smile that would light up any room, the chances of being murdered incraese dramatically. That's why I'm always bitter and grumpy.

[@etherealbeautee]

I have been told all my life I have a million dollar smile 😂 But I have never been in harms way, ever. I have common sense. It has gotten me out of what could have been potentially dangerous situations. I just don't trust many people lol. I will be 40 years old next year.

[@evelynem4612]

@@kentuky1233 😂

[@KittyD859]

She looked like a dude, dude. She’s dead she’s not a martir or the discoverer of cures.

[@Kookoo347]

😂😂😂

[@mauriciolee7349]

This is an EXCELLENT true crime video. It has one of the MOST SURPRISING twists I've ever seen. It's like the one in a Hollywood movie. The video editing is fantastic. It makes me gaze at the screen because the flow is natural and the presentation is easy to understand. Its not choppy as another version of this story that I've seen on another channel Thank you Law&Crime Network for such a great job.

[@susanfisher4944]

Drinking alcohol always seems to play a big part in bad things happening.

[@icemachine79]

@HoneyHoops-ig9ws Jesus disagrees with you.

[@icemachine79]

And good things. It exacerbates whatever you're feeling. If you're having trouble in your relationship, it exacerbates that.

[@steveo3831]

There is no doubt!

[@jasonhansen8996]

@HoneyHoops-ig9ws My King James all 6 times I read it cover to cover would disagree.

[@jasonhansen8996]

Alcohol has helped a lot of UGLY people get lucky. Other than that - I completely agree. Alcohol seems to be a master key for unlocking terrible events.

[@CommonSenseIsNotCommon13]

The Police officer that was interviewing that friend of Doug’s? He should be kicked off the force. Absolutely disgusting. Classic example as to why, no matter how innocent I am I will NEVER talk to Police without a lawyer present.

[@rachaelleann9847]

100%

[@nurzrachit7133]

He is an arrogant scum bag, makes detectives look bad and not trustworthy.

[@robintamihere4550]

Police Interrogators are permitted to behave dishonestly that's the law.

[@ronniebots9225]

There is a saying If your guilty you want a laywer If your innocent you need a laywer To many cops try and match the evidence to their theory instead of investigating everything. Tunnelvision is a real thing.

[@davelowets]

YEP! MOST of the time you would encounter professionalism, BUT, when it comes to an innocent person's freedom, I would NOT take the chance that I will 100% encounter that professionalism. There ARE some bad investigators out there, JUST like you will find some "bad ones" in EVERY other job out there.

[@alanwatts7813]

He's a truly evil man, so obvious that he was lieing, and yet he chose to put her partner, family and friends through that disgusting ordeal, pure evil

[@FTBASTAR]

I hope the boyfriend sued the court and the convict.

[@chaddddd1251]

That George guy definitely has more body count to his name. He is a definition of a sociopath.

[@vickiekasafirek9096]

Burch is totally unbelievable.

[@ursulaoreilly3013]

As if she would have even looked at that disgusting great giant monster. Poor innocent girl. RIP

[@blacklivesmatter4918]

"This case SHOULD be a whole film!!!" 📽️📺📡 There were "SO MANY TWISTS & TURNS" that it kept me "on the EDGE of my seat" from start to finish!!! 😮 The"Fitbit" SAVED THIS MAN'S LIFE and it brought the"REAL KILLER" to justice!!! 💪🏼 "That's a BIG WIN in my opinion!!!" 🏆 "Thanks for the GREAT UPLOAD!!!" 👏🏼

[@scroogemcduckrich9705]

31:31 please this girl probably wasn’t attracted to this fool. he offered her a ride home then killed her

[@frisc0strangler207]

Yup, it’s pretty obviously simply exactly that’s what happened

[@scroogemcduckrich9705]

@@frisc0strangler207 💯. I get so tired of the lies

[@Adventures_in_AK]

That is exactly what I thought! There is no way that that woman would be interested in that man in any way.

[@kyleblakeman8726]

Why get in the car with some random guy though !?

[@undrwrldsk8fred]

@@kyleblakeman8726 after a night of drinking and arguing with her bf, I think it’s safe to say that her judgement was impaired.

[@dargful]

Makes me wonder how many innocents are still in prison thanks to inaccurate information.

[@GEOMETRICINK]

Exactly. I hate how cops lie, tell a person they have the evidence, 100% proof, say the another person is telling on them, you better tell first, blah blah blah. It elicits false confessions. Glad these two guys just told the truth and didn’t let police fck with them.

[@JonBlackstone]

I don’t know which is the more entertaining; listening to George Burch tell his rediculous story or his attorney pretending he believed it.

[@hankhill4542]

Why do people enjoy going to bars so much? Nothing but drama vomiting and headaches.

[@ocskywatch1]

loneliness, Bars are like sickly churches for the non religious

[@LifeisaHorrorMovie]

​@@ocskywatch1 Not necessarily, religious people go to bars too (at least I think they do).

[@ryanchoate9146]

It’s loneliness! Some people don’t like drinking alone... I hate alcohol it is sooo much worse than marijuana

[@pipermccool]

🎵And the waitress is practicing politics As the businessmen slowly get stoned Yes, they're sharing a drink they call loneliness But it's better than drinkin' alone - Billy Joel

[@MissHannah2036]

live bands, celebration, entertainment, socializing, alcohol. The majority of people go home safely after a night out. And then there are more sinister reasons like as in what happened to poor Nicole.

[@Mr.imjussayn]

This was a well put together video and a captivating story. May Nicole rest in peace 🕊️ 🙏🏾

[@brendaloose1718]

Awesome story. Very sad and very scary but I’m glad justice was served.

[@Cobi7]

man this channel always got me at the edge of my seat!!!

[@iamwinningrightnow]

This monster is a piece of work. And these defense lawyers, shame on them. SIP Nicole.

[@frisc0strangler207]

RIP*

[@Ilovetheskunk]

​@frisc0strangler207 stay in prayer

[@bauerj3398]

Shame on them for what? For literally doing their job, a job that is Constitutionally protected, and which they literally take an oath? Shame on you for being so emotional and ignorant.

[@skylerjirtle8841]

@@bauerj3398 there job is to show that their guy didnt do it. Instead, they fabricated a whole lie trying to get an innocent guy that trust me they knew was innocent into prison to win a case. Its unethical

[@bauerj3398]

@@skylerjirtle8841 It is not unethical in any way. Their job is to represent their client to the utmost of their ability. Doing anything other than that WOULD BE UNETHICAL. Period. Putting forth potential other culprits is not unethical. The alternative perpetrator defense is firmly established in U.S. legal system, and is constitutionally accepted (Chambers v Mississippi, U.S. v Scheffer, etc.). And there is exactly 0% chance that them posing that possibility would result in the other person going to jail. The other person is NOT on trial, and cannot be held legally culpable, especially based on something as fragile as a speculative hypothesis in court proceedings that he/she is not involved.

[@TheSybil47]

When one of the defense attorneys were questioning the lying monster, the attorney to his right was so red in his face. He knew the story was BS, and apparently ashamed of it. It was so nice to listen to the prosecutor, tearing that story apart. Thanks to the jury for getting this one right. R.I.P. Nicole. Your children will never trust anyone. It's just so sad that they had to learn the hardest way possible. I hate what that monster did to you, and hope he rots away slowly, and painfully in his cage. My heart goes out to the boyfriend, family, and friends, who suffer every day of their lives, because of that evil, selfish monster. Hope the pain will get more tolerable with time, but I know it won't ever go away, unfortunately.

[@7thHanuman]

The real masterminds of this crime are still out there. The origin of all negative thoughts and sins originate from those entities with the ability to manipulate our minds; entities of many names, examples are spirits/ghosts/demons. Those entities are the one roaming freely looking for the next opportunity to cause pain and suffering in Society.

[@steve10]

The defense attorney in this program should hold his head in shame , absolutely disgraceful , despicable behaviour , he was quite happy to send an innocent man to prison just to get the win , no wonder justice is often not got , im sitting watching this and watching the defence try and fit up the poor Boyfriend , then speak on this program trying to justify these despicable lies and im fuming i really am

[@TheSybil47]

@@steve10 I totally understand your anger, and I share that with you.

[@Sarasarah3]

On a side note, the defense attorney felt no shame and his face is naturally red with rosacea

[@TJsGang]

Imagine losing your partner under suspicious circumstances and being absolutely devastated by her disappearance. Now imagine you are sorted by police while being heartbroken over losing your partner. That must be the ultimate emotional roller-coaster ride.

[@Kyra-qn3nh]

I'm absolutely sickened by these defense attorneys.

[@gaynorberry5759]

R.I.P. Nicole. Glad Doug was proven innocent 🙏🏻❤️ how sad for their kids to lose their mother in such a horrific way. So lucky they got the DNA & phone trace on that creep!!

[@dianaveronicakambanis9690]

Mother should not been drinking. Bad behaviour, never see the queen sitting in a bar ok

[@dianaveronicakambanis9690]

Woman coming out of bars. 3 am disgusting. Lady just does not behave that way.the reason three children are now without a mother. 😮😮

[@susanyamini]

That was amazing in a bad way. I just love it love how you put the story together. Brilliant thanks Jesse.

[@susanhughan2198]

Thank you so @Law&Crime , I’ve wondered about this case since it was first covered (Dateline or 48 hours) I’m so glad that the jury didn’t fall for this Monsters BS !! Sending comfort to her family, Doug & her children 🙏🏼 Rest In Peace Nicole

[@seeker884]

Our world has become So much Evil. God help us.

[@اميرمادرا]

I agree with you

[@lewistoao6858]

No such thing as

[@deescott8312]

Yes very depressing how evil people are

[@douglasd327]

learn to speak proper English

[@michellebarron1987]

God have mercy on our souls. Amen.

[@babyjane87]

14:35 when people say an innocent person wouldn’t act like that when being arrested they would go mad shouting they are innocent WELL this man did and he is innocent so you never know how people will react everyone is different 🤷🏻‍♀️

[@Bountie75]

Stil his actions and reactions are SUS AF...

[@michellediaz4832]

I watch a lot of true crime and I must say this case was very intriguing and the video very well put together. It’s the only case where I actually had some doubts initially as to who the murderer was. Glad they convicted the right person in the end. It could have gone either way if it wasn’t for the cell data and DNA.

[@Criminalsinhistory]

Holy crap I’m so happy for Matheu, way to stand up for yourself when you know you’re right

[@jamegumm]

Props to the defense attorney for not laughing when explaining his client’s story

[@carleneevans8768]

Maybe he laughed when he got in his car

[@freedomofreligion3248]

Well told story. My deep condolences to Dylan, her two other children, Dylan's siblings as they shared a home and a Momma, for Doug, Nikki's mom + dad and family, all of Nikki's beloveds, for their huge, huge loss.

[@Rosebudlola]

Amazing video. It was great to be kept guessing as the audience and my mind changed about 1000 times. Didn't trust the spouse, but in the end the other story just didn't compute. Good job jury!

[@reneesantiago6496]

I’m not sure on this one.

[@NoFrictionZone]

As soon as the cop told him about the warrant on his house, I knew he was innocent.

[@thedudeabides2531]

The dude is 6’7” tall. That’s a big dude. There’s no way he was knocked out by Doug. 😂

[@harthooft]

The moment I saw the boyfriend crying I said "he didn't do it". I could tell from here that it was a genuine cry, so surely the detectives felt the same. Interesting how they had to sidestep their instinct when the evidence initially pointed to him.

[@xlovexaxlotx1626]

I saw him cry thought 'thats a real cry, he didnt do it' and teared up myself, then they said well they found blood on shoes and the garage and thought 'oh im a terrible judge apparently' but glad to see it wasnt him and you could see right through the real murderers story

[@curtf9813]

That really shouldn’t mean anything tho…you shouldn’t make any opinions off of how a person reacts. If he’s not a cryer, and he didn’t cry, that shouldn’t incriminate him either. The fact of the matter is that there was no evidence on him at all. He had an alibi because he was with his friend, his Fitbit showed that he didn’t leave his house after getting home, her Progressive car insurance was monitoring her vehicle and that showed that her vehicle never left. All they had against him was that he got in a fight with her and he had turkey blood on a shoe in his house. Everything else is irrelevant

[@xlovexaxlotx1626]

@@curtf9813 Don't know if you're talking to me or the original comment but people very often think they are good at reading a person and often people are good at manipulating so when we saw him cry and it felt real to us, then there was suspicion and in the end he turned out to be innocent it felt like 'hey maybe I wont be fooled by a murderer in my own life' and that's comforting even if its not true. But in a case with very little evidence and also at the start of every case you have to go off how people act. The police have to look at a suspects body language as well as what they are saying, if someone cries and then laughs and then cries and then laughs its odd, it might not make you the killer but its odd so it will get you some level of suspicion. Understanding body language is a very important part of interrogating a suspect and also talking to witnesses. I'm not a detective but I would say nothing is irrelevant in any case, we have the luxury of knowing everything having watched the whole video but the police at the time had to go with where the evidence pointed, and the victims partner is always the first to be written off.

[@carleyjxoxo]

As soon as I heard his voice when he asked “What do you mean similar features” or whatever. I just knew he was hoping the detective wouldn’t start describing Nichole.

[@Bountie75]

Cry? He sniffed a couple of times, that's it... I vries harder when my cat went missing. They tell him his gf is dead, and his just sniffs a bit... Also he didn't report her missing for several hours, nor did he look for her... Yeah, nice guy

[@jannater28]

I cannot believe he testified and boldly lied about everything. Glad the jury saw through it.

[@LavishTrotter]

and to arrest Doug so quickly in front of his neighbours and family is just pure evil.

[@Batman-wv5ng]

How could criminal come up with this story and think that jury would believe him.Those defence attorneys are same as him .

[@saraa1741]

6'7? 260lbs 😮 Thats a big man. She stood no chance.

[@terrenceolivido741]

and women genrally love " hunky men. " so alcoholism etc., she may have been attracted to him. i do not assume that meant she wanted to have any intimacy with him at that time.

[@gomahklawm4446]

And she trusted him instead of her live in boyfriend. Western women are so lost. Thanks femi.nism!

[@thomasmcavoy2278]

That story is the most ridiculous story i've ever heard. If someone points a gun at you and makes you kill somebody, The first thing you're going to do if you get away is call the police!

[@LH74]

I'm glad the boyfriend and best friend were cleared. I bet 20 years ago these poor guys would have both been sent to the electric chair.

[@Mr..Roboto]

I swear this story used by defendant is something being used by criminals. There was another case Prime Crime did and the guy said that someone hit him on the head and next thing you know he woke up in the trunk with body then was told to bury body and was then locked back in the trunk and the killers left him there alive. He was found guilty…. I was happy that the jury stuck to the facts. So sorry for the victim’s family and hope they find peace and give all the love the victim’s kids will be needing.

[@genomic_]

Yeah, I remember that case. Her name was Molly I think

[@ms.demeanors]

Yep. Molly Tibbetts.​@@genomic_ The guy was Cristhian Bahena Rivera

[@ikaikamaleko8370]

That story was so lame, his attorneys actually allowed him to go up and tell that, the nerve, clowns.🤡🤡

[@thekill2509]

Just a more complicated version of the old ghetto Mark 1 Mod 0 "that's not my weed, these aren't my pants, I have no idea how that happened".

[@ray5195]

Mr weber you are one of the best investigators in the world , we love you all and appreciate your hard work

[@lindaholtzhausen1539]

I am 74 years old and never saw the inside of a bar!!! It is totally beneath me, thankyou! There is definitely much more decent places to go to!

[@JulieRushworth]

Beneath you! Wow you are judgemental, not everyone who goes to a bar is out to get wasted

[@downieduck2414]

well aren/t you just wonderful

[@Kookoo347]

Here…let me polish that halo for you 🙄

[@Jenjen2021]

Horrible investigators; no wonder they convict so many innocent people

[@Julia28532]

True

[@Julia28532]

They just accused someone and done

[@Alandforman]

Thank goodness for that prosecutor.

[@Viiaa277]

Scary how they were ready to arrest the wrong man

[@Charlathejournalingjunky]

What a liar blaming another man but u don’t ring police okeeyyyy 😂😂😂😂

[@RockmasterVideos]

Exactly!

[@louisaklimentos7583]

I am glad that Doug and his friend never went to prison for murder . The real killer looks so rough and how could he brutally murder this beautiful woman . RIP Nicole 🙏😇

[@shahulhameed401]

This is very tragic. Be face guys. Don’t ever have contact with strangers when you are drunk. It will leads so many problems even the death

[@meekomio]

Imagine how many innocent people these 2 incompetent detecives have put away with their stupidity and tunnel vision. Bullying people into false confessions. Smh i would be terrified to have them as detectives in my town. 2 bullies with tunnel vision... arrogant ignorance letting the real killers get away with murder. How do they sleep at night???

[@denisemezynski8014]

So, when I hear many complain why is it taking so long to make an arrest in murder cases .......this is why! WE dont want detectives assuming they have the Right person!

[@fluffyfour]

This is a perfect example of why our UK caution (rights) now says 'It may harm your defence if you fail to mention, when questioned, something you later rely on in court'.

[@pmccoy8924]

Detectives shouldn’t have impunity to lie to put someone behind bars. I realize it helps them and it’s our horrific people behind bars but even one person gets locked up for lying it’s an injustice.

[@alexandrasymeon5893]

Lying should be illegal.

[@VioletJoy]

Imagine a guy of that size overpowering you. How terrifying!! It's better to stick together and be safe than to risk harm. What a tragedy.

[@Noblesix84]

Ah, the return of the Mysterious Gunman in Dark Clothes. Should be on FBIs most wanted with how often he shows up.

[@RedeyedJedi00]

You were 'obstructed' to stand by the back of the vehicle? Then 'obstructed' to pick up the body? 😂😂😂

[@deathvalleybro9320]

instructed.

[@dallynutkat3252]

​@@deathvalleybro9320Yes, WE know that, but he doesn't. He said he was "obstructed" instead of "instructed" to do something, over and over. Just shows how dense he is, apart from being an evil p.o.s.

[@jameskim62]

EXCELLENT WORK TO EVERYONE INCLUDING LAW & CRIME !!!!!~~~~~

[@TherealJimDunsworth]

As a law student, a defence team represents the only line of defence for an accused against the entire state - zealous advocacy requires stepping in the shoes of your client and if that is the story the accused gives the attorneys, they are duty bound to defend it or otherwise sever ties. What i do find unrespectable is how the accused would know any of the salatious arguments between Greg and the deceased. That would only have come after discovery. Which would have been after the lawyer had already been given an explanation. Thus, if the client is guilty, they tailored the story, either knowignly or were willfully blind to the truth

[@paranoid_android33]

A few years later on a date: "have you ever been arrested?" "yes" "for what?" "murder, but I didn't do it" *runs away*

[@meleascott6490]

I bet it wasn't his first time... hopefully they check to see. Brutal, rage and anger.

[@virginiabalch6274]

It wasn't. He was convicted in Virginia and broke his parole by coming here to Wisconsin. That's how they matched his DNA from.

[@meleascott6490]

@@virginiabalch6274 SMH thanks for the update. Merry Christmas

[@Darcey-t4s]

I bet that's why he moved from VA to Wisconsin escaped his past. 👋

[@orlandomartinez545]

what a great episode, i was hanging from my seat the whole time, loved the twists. thank god Doug was wearing the fitbit.

[@bobby4500]

poor woman, but you should never go with a stranger!

[@JJones-zg7yz]

sloots will always sloot

[@Dino22440]

@@JJones-zg7yzYou’re a sloot

[@saravillareal6012]

How do you know she went with him

[@crazyaussie7054]

Great vid. Love your work Huge support from an Aussie fan ❤

[@RandomBogey]

I’ll never not get a kick out of the intensity of “Prime Crime” at the beginning. Lol

[@raptoranderson]

"On PROIM CROIM" lmao the pronunciation kills me

[@juanalazcano2882]

So glad life without parole was given!!!

[@TheRealBinaryCode]

Shame on those investigators! I guess it’s guilty until proven innocent!

[@xtscarfacem8255]

Relax, it's quite normal for them to use these tactics. It actually works differently on people who are guilty. Most try to talk themselves out of it, give false information etc.

[@Tryp-j9d]

The presumption of innocence does NOT begin….UNTIL a TRIAL STARTS!!!!

[@TheRealBinaryCode]

@@xtscarfacem8255 okay I will remove the exclamation marks 😂

[@Coplandcalm122]

When someone says "Honestly or To tell you the truth" always gives me the ick. It is a way to get more time to answer the question.

[@scroogemcduckrich9705]

dude probably a serial killer

[@elmerslick8700]

He has killed before, true

[@amccar27]

I can’t even imagine sitting in the court room listening to this monster lie like this! Those defense attorneys are almost as horrible of human beings as he is. I get that it’s their job but they were disgracing this poor woman’s memory. What a pathetic excuse for human beings… to not only cold blooded murder a woman but make up some crap like this….

[@mariejones3913]

Im so tired of these “detectives” they are just bullies and gas lighters! Do YOUR JOB & FIND REAL EVIDENCE!

[@CrimerJourney84]

The twists in this case are just unbelievable. It’s terrifying to think how trust can be betrayed in the worst possible way.

[@katiemary8075]

No way she went with that thing willingly.

[@Alandforman]

That prosecutor's got some powerful insightful skills and took that guy apart.

[@carewser]

The monster seems unusually confident and honest on the stand which is why i'm sure his lawyer got him to testify but it's also the sign of a real psychopath, too bad about the overwhelming evidence though

[@11bravo1789]

What got me was when you said “back in 2016”… as if that was a Long time ago. Jeez time flies.

[@jamesdove8021]

These are well done episodes.

[@lizbamford7848]

Its so sick hearing a killer tell such a horrible story. Clearly she fought for her life against that killer capturing his DNA in the process. In her death she declared his guilt

[@jaimhaas5170]

She also picked him up at a bar. Did you miss that part?

[@katherinespinelli-jones2816]

@@jaimhaas5170 I think she got a lift home with the guy, thinking her partner was there so she could turn the guy down without any issues once there but he wasn’t happy with that

[@jaimhaas5170]

@@katherinespinelli-jones2816 she put herself in that position correct? She was drunk too. Tell me her actions matter little?

[@lottoo5693]

@@katherinespinelli-jones2816 wrong she knew what she was doing. she saw her bf flirt with another man her first reaction is to sleep with another man.

[@TheCrimeChronicles]

​@@jaimhaas5170no her actions did not warrant her murder. How does that make sense to you? Victim blaming is not the answer here.

[@tpdircks]

Defense thought of everything except the fact that no one in their right mind would ever believe this guy would have a chance with an attractive woman. No matter how drunk she is.

[@bobbobertson7568]

Well he's tall, women like that. Seems like she was at least talking to him

[@sonlalguite3590]

Damn the defendant testimony is literally hilarious 🤣

[@seanm3226]

The former sheriff says law enforcement did an “excellent job”. The fact is law enforcement interrogated, handcuffed, arrested, fingerprinted, incarcerated and further traumatized the grieving boyfriend of the victim. That’s not lost on me.

[@jenbee4956]

@@seanm3226 And so quickly… I was surprised

[@jayterra2060]

Omg that FIT BIT saved the day

[@coleworld4385]

Worst detectives, worst interrogation of Matheu I have EVER witnessed. The goal is to let them talk, not yell over them.

[@HEYBESTFRIENDHEYYY]

The stuff that they found to connect him was MIND BLOWING When they say they’re gonna find something it could be something that your brain is not even thinking about