Prime Time: Why has communism failed to shine in India?

[@adhdmc7936]

As a guy from Poland I can say to Indians If you love your country don't even think to become a communist country. The cultural and civil price to pay for that system is immense.

[@adhdmc7936]

So little to late, but economic, mental, civil and moral recovery from it takes decades, and It will always lead sooner or later to tyranny. The communist are promising equality and abolition of the classes. In reality they will end up as a ruling class, and will take unlimited options for their career, and closing that door for people that weren't the members of the communist party .

[@CA.EBITDA]

@Akmal Ahmad jo kuch aaj bharat ka roop bacha hai vo iske spiritual aur "backward culture" ki vajah se toh bacha hai...aap logon se toh koi aasha hai hi nahi hamein.....

[@bread_bender5150]

@Akmal Ahmad The only reason why such economic polarity has not given way to civil war in India is because people are spiritually enhanced. Why do you think they are living in their villages peacefully ,if all they cared for money give me one reason why they should not immoraly attack the billionaires for their wealth . The amount of importance of wealth a man gives depends on his choices , you can choose to live in a big apartment paying more than 3-4 lakhs per month and be happy. At the same time you can choose to live a spiritual life in a village living happily in a small hut and farming for your basic needs. A man chooses either his life or his miseries.

[@bread_bender5150]

@Akmal Ahmad Ask yourself this , (don't accept anyone else's authority just question it until you arrive at a conclusion) why do people want to take what they can't earn by thrashing .Tell me if I'm wrong are people that which they earned by spending 18+ hours a day will be content with sharing their wealth to people who on an average basis only spend 6-8 hours.

[@amshan7520]

Akmal Ahmad the government was always against private enterprises like Tata for example how they took Tata's airline and turned it into a government property ever since the government acquired it air India has been running on a loss.the anti capitalist bs from the socialist government is the reason why India faced economic difficulties when they went open market the Indian companies them self were not allowed to grow big till then so when big companies from outside began doing business in India the Indian businesses were affected

[@avinghosh]

As the British PM Mrs Margaret Thatcher once famously said, “The problem with communism is that eventually you run out of other people’s money”!

[@anindyamondal]

An Indian quoting a Brit's statement? Worried to see bootlickers of colonialism do exist in present India.

[@anindyamondal]

@MATHA NOSHTO-MAN Studying is different from idolizing dude . We also study about Hitler, but is it right to quote and idolizing that xenophobe.

[@rehanshaikh8710]

@@anindyamondal hi up to TX TV:-P;-):-D:-(=-O=-OB-):-$(╯3╰)(*´∇｀*)(￣へ￣)]🔇

[@rohitbhushan8855]

@@anindyamondal Well, nothing wrong with admiring an statement if its sensible.

[@pritlee]

@@anindyamondal and u r writing in colonial masters language but u r not a bootlicker???

[@MithunKumarc]

what has left in the left? west bengal has an answer for this question.

[@Saturn_foreveronly]

Mithun Kumar kerala. U feel the heat

[@siddhantsingh7606]

@@Saturn_foreveronly wahabbi funding through foreign remittance.

[@nagratna793]

Nowadays in India. Left means muslim..right means hindu..as simple as that

[@domainhub3322]

Champion1 0000 there is nothing centric in AAP. You can see that it on their politician's biased and hatemongering announcements. Like Tahir Hussain and Zafrul Islam Khan. Even top leaderships like Manish Sisodiya is too partial in many cases. Now don't argue that BJP members also do. Yes they do. They openly talks for Hindus. BJP never claim themselves as centric. So claiming and actually centric is different. So enough you tried to make yourself sickular and others fool. People aren't idiot now a days.

[@domainhub3322]

@@nagratna793 that's for India...because it's in left's blood to insult & diminish the culture of majority. In Bangladesh, you can verify from anyone that left are basically (minorities) Hindu s and free thinkers and right are the radical Islamists.

[@ashutoshnanda683]

Communism and democracy are two different system so communism will not be accepted in Indian democracy.

[@aman_insaan]

This was very very very superficial statement. If I claim that: to what you say democracy is actually a bourgiouse democracy; you will have any argument to argue.

[@arumba7345]

you guys need to change your government tho communism wouldnt work tho atleast in your country not for decades of change.

[@cob426]

@@aman_insaan and if I say that the common folks know nothing about ruling that they are better suited as they are currently and communism doesn't let you choose your leaders, then?

[@cob426]

@@crayneo6187 you know that is not possible, a class less society, classes are like levels in a food chain, society is a food web, to have a class less society we have to go back to the jungle

[@cob426]

@@crayneo6187 basic mentality? Open your eyes and see, even communist countries which ever it may be has classes, different levels of party officials, workers and soldiers

[@drooleybob]

question is - why does communism still exist in india?

[@jayant4732]

Becs 9 people= 65 crore..... Har roj log bhukhe mar rahe log... Amir garib ka khun chus rahe...ek din iquilab aaega....

[@jayant4732]

@@mukeshnegi007 bhai jab logic na ho to log ese hi isare aur jumle se bat kia krte...

[@jayant4732]

@UCWVmcEXKnTBsalE0WHGbCkg karde bhai.... Naxali na hu... Thode pdh lete to naxali aur vichardharaa ka pata chalta 😉😉😂😂😂😂😂 bhagat singh ka inquilab ki bat maine kari... Bhagat singh ki v vichardhara se hi mai prbhaabhit hu... Pdh lo unko tum taaaaaab smjh aeega kuch...

[@jayant4732]

@UCWVmcEXKnTBsalE0WHGbCkg aksar log agyanta ke karan ulul jalul bat karte..... Garibi sachai hai iski bat karunga... Economic equality ki bat karunga.... Mar jau to v gum nahi... 21 sal ki umar me 23 march ko koi mara tha usi ki vichardhara aage bdhani hai.... Bhagat singh wala inquilab aaega...

[@jayant4732]

@@mukeshnegi007 bache ne apni umar se dugni kitabe padh li hai.. Aur youtube me v faketi na dekhta is karan badbadane layk hu.... ###

[@domainhub3322]

Communism defines equality. According to communism, if we all can't become rich, then we all can become poor to get equality. 👏👏👏

[@soulStripper21]

Its the perfect way to send the country to the gallows and then broken up. The narcicst and self declared champions of poor are the ones who keep poor as they are. It is the same in any country, it is full of blood spilling. They can't get an orgasm until some 50-60 million people die

[@kushagrak960]

Hahahaha

[@ariaa8692]

Yes, Bjp's and other parties inequality plan would never work out if so

[@soulStripper21]

@dev gana Nothing washes away the sins of murderous communist regimes.

[@djdeto7382]

I can feel sarcasm

[@shivakumarv301]

Economic growth and international support is critical and important.

[@cvry2813]

I thought NDTV was communist

[@sarthaksrivastava2667]

That's because today everything is polarized either you are part this group or that group. We want to believe everyone and everything is black and white.

[@DonCorleone786]

Because you are modi-fied

[@arunsar7893]

@@DonCorleone786 Nah! .. NDTV has a deep communist DNA. Pronob Roy's wife is Bindra karat's sister and his cousin is the infamous Arundhati Roy, the one who is delusional enough to say Naxals are Gandhis with guns.

[@shivakumarv301]

Auditing the rich businessman in terms of how they improved compared with their employees and customers is necessary to see the growth in economic inequality.

[@svk2397]

Long live capitalist India

[@rameshkokatanur9866]

@Youthoob Gamer jealous?

[@amlanjyotisaikia9339]

@Youthoob Gamer india is not fully capatilist...its socialist

[@unitedbeast6614]

Jai democracy and freedom

[@karthikkarthik453]

Jai comrade

[@laba3423]

india jayada develop hua 90s ke baad jab capitalism increase hua still in pop media capitalism is villain

[@wesupportbjp9319]

socialism communism ek niradhar vichardara h

[@satyamrathod9958]

Matlab use adhar ki jaroorat hai🙏

[@satyamrathod9958]

@ẞà6àñ bà47à India is a socialist country

[@piyushsingh9334]

Socialism is our future ✊✊

[@satyamrathod9958]

@ẞà6àñ bà47à can you please explain..? Which principle is India following today? Capitalism? Fascism?

[@aksrivastava7384]

@@piyushsingh9334 No, mixed economy is our future.

[@DeepVerma728]

Communists leave out of India.

[@cosmicbeing6426]

+Deep Verma these commie bastards have to be kicked out,, they wont leave on their own. Maar --maar ke kick out karna padega

[@YPR4022]

First u should leave India u fool when we our India gonna develop with this ducking congress n bjp u know our biggest fault is our over democracy it's not useful for us it's time to need communist party to rule our nation.... If we Indians want development in short period then communists industrial policy better

[@YPR4022]

What about our Indians?? Avenues we too fighting about corruption money share, cows, buffoons, religious, n many else

[@FatJackedNerd]

Deep Verma say that to Bhagat Singh, Rajguru, Sukhdev and Ashfaqullah Khan...

[@jayant4732]

Garibi dur kar de bhai.... 9=65 crore khtm krba de communist khtm ho jaega.... Garibo ko bhaga doge india se ka??? pet bhara hai tumhara tab esa bkwas kroge hi.... Ideology kbhi bhgyi nhi jati... Bhagat singh lenin ke vicharo ko bhgna tumhri aukat nahi...

[@dipanjanmandal2217]

It is important to read communist manifesto first...Marx had written that communism would only come after full exploitation of capitalism..there is no doubt though that communist policies such as universal healthcare and education are always better as they give people a sense of equality and equal opportunities too

[@xiijinpingthesupremeleader1349]

These are nit communist policies. Many social democracies in Europe have these facilities and they are not in anyway communisitic.

[@shubhamkumarjha3426]

Every democracy now follow these even in America and Europe and they are not communist state and communist demen the personal growth of person on the name of equality we only socialism or only capitalism will not lead anywhere we should have mix of both socialism and capitalism and communist has no place for democracy so india will never accept communism

[@yeelanma9165]

National socialism is best

[@shatzco]

@@xiijinpingthesupremeleader1349 they proved by benefits by exploiting poor nation from Africa and east Asian cheap labour and not to mention indian doctors who work for less money in those countries you speak of. You are blinded by the red scare of US propoganda

[@shatzco]

@Clash Royale Montages ask that to your government why do they take tax money? Why can't they work hard and earn that money? Why doesn't Ambani adani work in their factories and port? Why do they take free money from the labour of hardworking people? 🤡 I guess you are the clown 🤡 to get scammed by the government.

[@mohanthomas3214]

Ultimately in the face of reality, only one system has stood the test of time. That is capitalism. It's been around for thousands of years. Communism is a good ideology but only on paper. It's impossible to implement in a practical way. And every country that has tried it has suffered the consequences. Every communist nation in the world is tyrannical and oppressive. China, North Korea, Cuba, Venezuela and the erstwhile Soviet Union are good examples of this. How many millions of people have died because of this? In fact communist Russia had killed more people than even the Nazis did. So what are these leftists snouting about?

[@prakharraj8674]

Communism is not even good on paper. Rather than relying on equality of opportunity, it relies on equality of outcome. It says "I owe you something because you breathe" Human beings, in fact the entire animal kingdom is unequal. No two people are equal in productivity, talent and skill. So in order to implement the need based resource distribution, you have to STEAL someone's labor to give it to the other. By its very nature it justifies punishment to productive and rewarding the less productive. It is by no accident that any nation that has implemented the communism/socialism doctrine has failed. Communism is incompatible with human nature. Why would a productive member of society will work for less productive rather for himself/herself. And the people who espouses this doctrine, no matter in which part of the world, are compassionate with other's money, other's labor and other's resources. The same people will never give their own resources for the less fortunate. So the moral of story communism is not moral. It is rather selfish and is destined to fail.

[@youknowwhoiam6484]

No communist can ever provide proper example of successful communism!

[@shatzco]

What about Cuba and Bolivia?

[@shatzco]

@@psk2266 i think you have not seen the news, they are sanctioned by capitalist USA and if a country is sanctioned and cannot buy resources they cannot grow yet Cuba has better health care and zero homeless people when we compare to our country. It's a shame on the part of Indians and the Indian government for not making food, housing and health care as basic human rights. Try to read and learn about communism not be brainwashed by US propoganda on the red scare. We indians see Hollywood movies and feel capitalism and usa is good, but the harash reality is that the middle class in usa live salary to salary and can anything end up on the streets

[@prathikshetty4340]

Reason is simply, communism is all about socialism , anti capitalist. But in India unfortunately Communist due to thier hate towards right wing politics has become anti national, anti arm forces and mainly anti Hinduism.

[@bitansana4721]

It's anti caste, anti religion anti oppression. Hindusm in India is a oppression entity where upper caste oppresses the lower caste

[@ushavns]

See Kolkata Get your answer

[@atrikroy9160]

its better and livable place than up which is runned by yogi cow

[@abduljafri8587]

They are extremists, exactly like they cry others are when they are in oppostion, but look kind of things they do in kerela.

[@ajithc157]

Communist party has done a lot of good things in kerala, but most of people there like to work n live in right wing ruled countries. Would anyone like to go to communist countries.

[@n8vckko515]

@- king- rights for dalits

[@n8vckko515]

@Aditya Rai appraising dalits is favourism lol

[@sanchitmehta6513]

@@ajithc157 what things FREE FREE FREE Are you a coward lazy

@@n8vckko515 That are already protected by constitution. What good do communists have done for dalits exclusively? Nothing.

[@noorulameen4578]

Communism never ends. Its living through my kerala... through their heart💓💓💓red salutes for my all indian comrades

[@noorulameen4578]

@Shaurya Joshi no medicine for ur jealous. We can see.... what will happen kerala.

[@abhinav1422]

Lal salam ❤

[@matiasdangelo1206]

@@noorulameen4578 🚁🚁 🤸🤸🤸 🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊🌊

[@arunreddy4778]

@@abhinav1422 Thank God Communism Decline In Ap Too

[@debarunbiswas607]

Long live the revolution

[@HumanBeing-hg2fl]

Communist party in India have record of mass murder in bengal. Communist are biggest hypocrite

[@derekobs9688]

Communism is the supreme and scientific form of any political ideology, not for the privileged

[@bipinjha2543]

Left means=== NAXALWAAD mowadi aatanwadi bombs blast Left kai karan hi USsR ko tora

[@anupforeal]

Aur right communal riots aur dangey! 😂

[@reubenpapang5803]

Communist ne USSR banaya bhai

[@nabhasvanchakravarty9292]

Bipin Jha kis ne apko yeh bataya hai ?

[@nabhasvanchakravarty9292]

Pehle janlo phir bolo.Asehi maat bolo . Andh Bhakto ka yehi problem hai GDP ,desh ka pragati iske alava inko sab acha lagta hai

[@bitansana4721]

History WhatsApp University se pada hei?

[@YPR4022]

If there were poor ppl across India definitely communist never gonna exit

[@HellBoy-tl8oc]

Yes

[@kumarrishabh9574]

#Communist don't support #jehadideology.... but in indianCommunist become #JehadistCommunist bengal and kerala is grt example if appeasement politics ... did anybody see china and russia supporting #Jehadist in thier states

[@FatJackedNerd]

kumar rishabh Well said, Leftist are anti-religious but todays Indian Leftist are all about Muslim-appeasemet. I am Socialist-Muslim, but I'm against Appeasement of Muslims and Jehadi-Ideologies of ISIS.

[@राहुलपांडेय्-ड2र]

Because in India Muslims will vote for anything against nationalists.. That's why they have to appease them to get votes

[@devilambro4401]

Communisam is not shine in india but it shine in the kerala and the world because kerala is the best state in india

[@abhijeetyadav7447]

Communism used to be shine in Bengal for more than 30 years and what happened eventually industrial hub of India had ruined

[@royal9063]

11:14 banaras koi peer ya majar ni h. Banaras Mahadev ki nagri h. Hame ye vardast ni ki Vanaras Ko koi kisi peer ya majar se jodhe. Mahadev ki nagri kashi Ka itihas Kisi mughal ya muslim akranta se suru ni hota. Kashi ka itihas or aaj mahadev se suru huya h or ant bhi usi me hoga. Har har mahadev.

[@devrajsingh-j7d]

comrade ravish ko laal salam

[@shubhmishra6977]

Worst ideology for India

[@shivakumarv301]

Grass root innovation and work can do magic.

[@anshumanjaiswal5787]

It failed because it wasn't real communism 😂😂😂

[@unsung.2770]

😂😂😂

[@anishadamane4179]

Jyoti Basu was born on July 8, 1914 in Calcutta. Like most Communist icons, he was male, upper caste and from a privileged family. From his kindergarten years, he attended schools such as Loreto and Xavier’s, run by British Burra Sahibs for their own and their camp followers. Then, he made the transition from British elite schools in India to elite colleges in England, becoming a barrister. Just after the 1962 war, Jyoti Basu proclaimed publicly at a rally that “China cannot be the aggressor.” In 1997, Bengal’s Home Minister admitted on the floor of the Assembly that 28,000 political murders had happened in West Bengal since the beginning of Jyoti Basu’s rule. Imagine what the real number was. His SPECIAL secret for his 23 year long continuous rule. Even the official figure of 28,000 murders did not cause a stir. It did not even scratch his legacy. Because the Communist leader had the historians and the intellectuals on his side. when the 1996 General Election threw up a badly hung Parliament, consensus had emerged among India’s secular parties that the “venerable” Jyoti Basu should take over as Prime Minister. It was Jyoti Basu’s enemies within his own party who stopped him. That’s how close India came to having a Prime Minister who had massacred refugees, systematically eliminated tens of thousands of dissenters and propagated China’s official line in the 1962 war. You’ve probably heard that Jyoti Basu’s economic policies led to business and industry fleeing the state. Did you know that’s just propaganda from “reactionary forces” opposed to the “people’s revolution”? Allow me to introduce you to Chandan Basu. That’s Jyoti babu’s son. To which country did Jyoti Babu send his son to continue the struggle for workers rights? Vietnam or Guatemala? Not exactly. Jyoti Basu’s son actually became an industrialist. He must have been a star in the world of business, recommended by banks for loans from agencies under the WB government and contracts from top corporates. Papa as Communist CM of West Bengal. Son as a big businessman who gets big loans from the West Bengal Financial Commission. Together they should have won a Padma Vibhushan for presenting a model of honesty to the nation. How did all this become possible? Because Jyoti Basu had the right people on his side. The journalist, intellectuals, poets, historians, everyone. Not like modern times where somebody throws a stone at a Navi Mumbai church and the next day the New York Times starts howling about “intolerance.” Killing and rape of Bangladeshi Hindu Refugee: In early 1979, around 40,000 hungry, starving and desperate Bengalis took shelter on the island of Marichjhapi in the Sunderbans of West Bengal. They were Hindu refugees who had fled persecution in East Pakistan, which had recently become Bangladesh. The Govt of West Bengal had refused to take any responsibility for them, forcing them to flee into the dense forest of the Sunderbans. Then, at the end of January 1979, they came. The West Bengal Police arrived in launch boats and took control of the network of waterways that made up the Hooghly river delta. The island was now completely surrounded. The 40,000 people on it had no way to access food or medicine. On the morning of Jan 31, the police opened fire on the starving Hindu refugees. Indiscriminately. They evacuated the island. Nobody knows how many human beings died that day. Because the Govt of West Bengal never published an official death toll. Who was the Chief Minister that ordered this atrocity? Jyoti Basu Killed Tribals: Recent research on the subject revealed cases of monstrous barbarities on the refugees who had come from Dandakaranya. Killed Hindu Monks and Hindu Nun:The lynching of two Sadhus at Palghar has shocked the entire nation. The brutal manner in which the Sadhus were lynched and the Police refused to help them has sent shock waves throughout the country. As brutal as the incident was and the sheer horror of it, it is not the first time that the country has been forced to confront such morbidity. There is another incident that occurred thirty-eight years ago that rivals the brutal Palghar lynching in its brutality, if not exceed it. Over the years, that incident has come to be known as the Bijon Setu Massacre. On the 30th of April, 1982, 16 monks and a nun of the Hindu organization Ananda Marga were murdered and set on fire in broad daylight near Ballygunge in Kolkata. They were dragged out of their taxis which was to take them to an educational conference at their headquarters in Tiljala, Kolkata. The killings occurred simultaneously at three different locations and are said to have been witnessed by thousands of people. And yet, not a single arrest has ever been made. Guess why they are slaughter and burned alive because of a land dispute with the Communists. Who was the Chief Minister at that time? Guess? Did anyone know Mihir Sen:The only man to swim the oceans of Five continents in a year. After his swimming career he established a factory for silk exports in Calcutta and transferred it into India’s second largest silk exporter. Then Jyoti Basu take oath as CM. He asked Mihir to complain for him in 1977 and Mihir refused to do so. But CPI win by killing Opposition and the and the personal vendetta of insane Jyoti Basu started. His goons sprayed graffiti outside his factory and shops he instigated repeated strikes on his factory bringing his production to zero. His exports burnt down. Police instead of help filed false cases against Mihir Sen. His house raided multiple times cash seized. Mihir was pushed into bankruptcy and the ace swimmer, recipient of Padma Shri and Padma Bhushan faced mental turmoil due to state sponsored humiliation. He developed dementia and died in penury. Killed UNICEF officers and sanctioned use of rape and murder as political tools: Thereafter the most significant incident to catch the headlines was the Bantala rape and murder. A senior lady officer of the UNICEF and another senior officer of the Government of India detected a case of huge embezzlement of UN funds by some CPI-M organisation within the South 24-Parganas district. When they were returning with a lot of incriminating evidence, their vehicle was waylaid at Bantala by the CPI-M goons. The vehicle was set on fire to destroy all documentary evidence. The driver, who tried to protect the two lady officers, was killed. Then the lady officers were raped and one of them murdered and her body without any cloth left on the open paddy field. When the then Chief Minister, Jyoti Basu, was informed of the incident, he quipped to the waiting mediamen: “Such incidents do happen, don’t they?” Thereby he put the official sanction to rape in addition to murder as an instrument of political aggression. Hypocrite and Insane:Being a true communist he destroyed an entire state he refused to provide a good healthcare to the state but used to go to London for his own treatment and yes with the OUR MONEY. He was a duplicate and deceitful power mad leader. Kam-rades feels sad that this parasite did not become PM of India. Its was good fortune that this parasite did not. Just image China and North-Korea

[@bitansana4721]

Story is nice, kahase copy kiya?

[@Gk-ws1pw]

भारत के टुकड़े कराने में कम्युनिस्टों का बहुत योगदान है

[@manurr10]

and modi won the elections.

[@trevormalappuram4928]

communism was created as a worldwide concept of togetherness...but now its nothing but like any other political party with statism as it's core concept...originally it was against the divide and rule policies but now doing exactly the same by supporting any idea of statism like in jammu..,northeast..,naxal belt...etc.

[@khalnayak9674]

Good point

[@atulagnihotri5454]

नास्तिक लोगों को भटका हुआ कहा गया है। 🤣🤣 बनारस की तो बात ही छोड़ दो केरल दोबारा से बनारस बन जायेगा। 🚩

[@justdoit7373]

Communism has failed because "A Communist is the one who read Marx and Lenin but an Anti-Communist is the one who understands Marx and Lenin" 🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@Kairox2003]

*correction an anti-communist is someone who claims to understand Marx and Lenin but has never laid their hands on their literature before because if they did...they'd slowly see themselves agreeing with everything they said!!

[@justdoit7373]

@@Kairox2003 says a Pseudo Communist living and enjoying all the perks of a Capitalist system🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@Kairox2003]

@@justdoit7373 Perks of capitalism? Name one ☺️....8 hour work day, weekends, social security, social safety nets, welfare, free education, healthcare and affordable and accessible housing...all these are perks fought for by Communist reformers for their implementation within capitalism. If it wasn't for communism you'd e working in a toothpaste factory somewhere for 16 hours a day for 6 days a week...and if you fell sick then that was the end for you since there were no paid sick leaves and even if there were your wages wouldn't be enough to cover the medical expenses.

[@apoorvmishra5554]

@@Kairox2003 you just want to rest and relax and use youtube while at work

[@bitansana4721]

@@apoorvmishra5554 America has free education. Its the result of Soviet union touch 🤣 they didn't even realise that they adopted the system of what communism says

[@Bhairav-Singh]

Communists talks nonsense..

[@playlistaashik8539]

Correct

[@dolphin6584]

Communism and secularism ka dalal....Ravish Kumar.

[@URL2356]

@@honeysauravladoo hahahahaha you owned him

[@mclovin510]

@@honeysauravladoo hahaha gaand hi maardi uski

[@jayant4732]

Fascism aur capitalist ka dalal bjp aur godi media...

[@shivakumarv301]

Education can be improved by KZbin , and other software instead of competing with rich few in brick and mortar University.

[@souvikganguly7104]

Bampantha aayega jaroor ✊.

[@pawanbhalerao7830]

उधार की मानसिकता, विचारो को भारत के नागरिक समझ गए हैं इसलिए वामपंथ का पतन हो रहा है

[@aman_insaan]

उधार की मानसिकता से मतलब क्या है? आपने जो फोन हाथ में पकड़ के comment किया है ना वह भी किसी बाहरी देश की खोज है..

[@aman_insaan]

इतनी संकुचित बुद्धि दृष्टि आकाश के विस्तार के लिए ठीक नही...

[@aman_insaan]

आप तत्वों पर बहस कीजिये मै हाजिर हूँ...

[@shivakumarv301]

Corruption, economic inequity should never be compromised.

[@Gk-ws1pw]

लेफ्ट वाली शहर में रहकर गांव को सुधारना चाहते हैं अंग्रेजी में बात करते हैं हिंदी को जो जानते नहीं हैं स्थानीय भाषाओं को महत्व ही नहीं देते यही इन के बिनाश का मुख्य कारण है

[@athulchala8932]

We are always left communism can chage the future of india lalsalam

[@anupkpandey13]

गांव में एक रुसन बाबा होते है, जो बात बात पे रूस के गांव के बहार अलग थलक बैठ जाते है और सभी आने जाने वाले को पकड़ पकड़ के अपनी पीड़ा एंवम ज्ञान साझा करते है। शहर में उन्हें बामपंथी कहते है।

[@mukhindustani391]

How does this guy find group of students like this? Very basic issues are not discussed. Nothing on economic issues, nothing on development, no talks on real socialism, communism, or capitalism.

[@sumitkumar-py7my]

Ye communist synonym means deshdrohi hai aur kuch nhi hai

[@suryanarayana5531]

It is against hindus

[@मयंकयादव-थ7ठ]

It's against india's culture

[@karthikkarthik453]

All religions are man made

[@titasdutta6206]

I think media is one of the reasons Communism hasn't really got momentum. Media is mainly run by Capitalist businessman who don't really like Marxist idea. I mean if anyone looks at why Marx said it is pretty amazing. The main idea of communism is about "Community" and helping each other -- it does not say that nobody should be a millionaire ( as many people think), it says that everybody should have a decent life. You need great hearts to build a real communist society -- everybody needs to sacrifice a little for the sake of whole society -- it shouldn't be the case that someone can lead extravagant life while just round the corner millions are lacking food. It not about everyone living a low profile life rather it is about everyone having a great life. That's what Communism is.

[@ankit168]

+Titas Dutta read abt gangadhar adhikari, you will start hating from communist. communist are those who supported Jinna for pak before independence. communist are those who were helping British police in during independence and against congress. communist are those who told let China come to India in 1962. their ideology supported china in 1962

[@titasdutta6206]

ankit168 If u think Communists supported Jinnah, then there is no point of talking. You first need basic 8th grade history lesson. Communist are those who are helping British? Do u know any history at all? or, are u fucking kidding me?(wait,Is it sarcasm?) Bhagat Singh, Rajkuru, Khudiram were communist.(Anushilon smaity or later jugantor dal were communists) Are you idiot or what? Read from historians Irfan Habib, Romila thapar and learn basic history. There is a writing today(23.2.16) about partition of India by Irfan Habib and explaining who were actually behind it. It was actually RSS. Do me a favor, name a RSS freedom fighter. Communist told china to come to India?? Do u ever read anything or, did u ever go to school. Wow!! How ignorant u can be?? I'm overwhelmed by ur ignorance. WOW!!

[@swaliulHaque]

theoretically Communism is good but practically it is not possible to achieve means it is failed , see what happened to bengal prior 1960 calcutta was highest gdp in country but now it even can't provide job to locals, they are moving out of state , even now gdp & industry in lucknow and ranchi is better kolkata (Kolkata has currently whatever gdp is only due to port but what would public benefitted by this , no way ) So , stop communalism

[@Arpan1412]

S Waliul Haque in Calcutta, there is TMC in power since 2011 and the worst pary. They had killed 23 people in panchayat election 10 of them are cpim supporters

[@ritwikchattopadhyay3543]

Marx actually didn't start communism. Marx was German socio-ecnomic analyst & writer. Communism evolved in Russia during Lenin's revolt & rule. Communism is a dictatorship which grabbed Marx's ideas to grab power.

[@vishalsangale3584]

Because communist forgot equality and gain hypocrisy

[@AnkushKumar-nt5ry]

Such a journalist needs for strong indian democracy is most necessary

[@GP-il4de]

Rubbish Saar campaigning for leftists

[@ananyasrivastava6099]

One correction -: Communism failed in the whole world. (Except north korea, chilli, jnu and media)

[@unknownfather6509]

It's north Korea and that too is not considered communist Kim and family refer it to as Juche state.

[@ananyasrivastava6099]

@@unknownfather6509 okay so only at jnu and media per say?

[@unknownfather6509]

@@ananyasrivastava6099 there actually has never been a real communist country all so called communist countries are socialist. And the thing in jnu is called anti-india sentiment.

[@ashishchauhan9671]

@@unknownfather6509 JNU is anti india?What is anti India sir?If you feel objectively criticizing the faults of one's nation is equal to promoting hatred against one country then you are, I'm sorry to say, paragon of wrong understanding.

[@mukulsanatan5937]

& kerala

[@sheebau1659]

Because of anti communism in India , Indias 50 per cent of wealth is with 1 per cent population (like ambanis and upper caste).

[@shauryasahu6062]

Wealth is owned by people who generate it. If i launch jio , them i will become rich like ambani. See venezuela for failure of socialism and see ussr for failure of communism.

[@arc8116]

where else has communism ever shined xDD

[@nagratna793]

21.44..he just pointed a fact. Appeasement politics is now a new Trend

[@jtgamer2987]

Communism ideology is very creative and effective but in reality it's very hard to implement it in populated countries like India....

[@yashpandey3.3.3]

Why India is not communist. Because in communism : darr ka mahaul hai

[@parthshah9863]

This ravish kumar is leftist

[@aman_insaan]

Google it what it means to be a leftist...

[@rahulv2265]

@@aman_insaan jhat ka baal is leftist just googled it

[@dholuSingh-mw8uz]

Actually NDTV is leftist

[@rahulv2265]

@@dholuSingh-mw8uz you are right ravish is ultra leftist

[@kumar-jatin-2000]

Good.

[@tusharagrawal7560]

Communism is the worst thing happened to Humanity after Democracy. Note- Communism has a better alternative. Democracy doesn't.

[@shubhamsaxena2419]

What is the better alternative to communism ?

[@yeelanma9165]

@@shubhamsaxena2419 capitalism

[@shubhamsaxena2419]

@@yeelanma9165 but you don't support BJP then how can it come without her being in power ?

[@bitansana4721]

@@yeelanma9165 capitalism 🤣

[@abhinav1422]

I think these people didn't see what is communism and what they can do. Welcome to Kerala ❤ No 1 state in india 🇮🇳

[@darko8894]

Commies ruled bengal more than kerala then why isn't Bengal No:1 kerala had a littrecy rate of 50% in 51 itself thanks to regional stability go learn your history and shove propoganda to morons.

[@LOGAN-et1cx]

Onnu podo

[@SH-mn5hg]

Lol best state giving most no. of corona cases nowadays.

[@matiasdangelo1206]

Jajajaja, do You really believe that kerala is a socialist state???. Kerala is a capitalist state, like all of the Indian states. Please bro, first of all try to understand what promote the socialism and try to difference then from the socialdemocracy.

[@world_conquerer]

Why communism failed because of chrony capitalism in the name of caste system.

[@weirdofreak]

Lal salaam

[@tlpranav6668]

Ait least communism is better than imperialism

[@DrewKane]

Why are the title and description in English, but the video not?

[@nikhilchand6128]

because the is a English news channel and they are covering the heart of Hindi speaking area where local people speak hindi

[@DrewKane]

Nikhil Chand Thank you for replying.

[@flaminmongrel6955]

They are assholes

[@amanjackson9826]

Socialism and capitalism cannot make any country rich its depend on the people

[@pjrkalyan5480]

communism and socialism is two sides of one Coin..! India is a socailst Country from the birth hail socialism Socialist Youth🇻🇳

[@nargiskhan1399]

NDTV is a "DESHDROHI" channel, no more comments is expected or required. Shame on these PRESTITUTES.

[@AnilKumar-sl7xd]

Prestitutes are advancing towards disturbing and destroying the society

[@akhtarkhan9318]

रविश सर जिन्दाबाद

[@shivakumarv301]

Is economic inequality increased in past thirty years?

[@rajivsharma2274]

Archive of fine journalism.

[@basedtsar9440]

Cuz communism always falis

[@jatinrana8217]

ban lal salam terrists

[@nabhasvanchakravarty9292]

Andh Bhakt Murdabad

[@nabhasvanchakravarty9292]

@debjit bhowmick abbe, pehli baat main tmc ko support nehi karta hoon . Tum logo jaise chutiyo example hi to hum central aur UP ka dekh rahe hai . Chai wala(Modi) Murdabad , Mota bhai Murdabad.

[@nabhasvanchakravarty9292]

Ban chai wala (modi)

[@aman_insaan]

Jatin ji aap hamare capitalists and centre ki increasing centralising tendency ke bare kya kehna chahenge.

[@nargiskhan1399]

उसूल के पक्के है रविश भाई, कॉंग्रेस को कभी गाली नाही देंगे, आखिर पैसा तो सोनियासे खाते है, उसूल भी कोई चीज है !!

[@AnilKumar-sl7xd]

कांग्रेस के टुकड़ों पर पालनेवाला कुत्ता है

[@FatJackedNerd]

Uttar-Bhartiyo ki language bohot meethi hai. Bohot achha lgta hai Hindi-Bhashiyo ko sunne me...

[@B--SiddharthParikh]

Ravish Kumar = journalism

[@sateeshpatil5298]

Communism and democracy are contradictory words

[@Marcos-rf5ui]

Communism is a economic system while democracy is a political system, they can't really be contradictory

[@rohitbhushan8855]

@@Marcos-rf5ui Communism is also a political and social system and it is contradictory to democracy and let's talk about the economic aspect, do you think communism is good for economy ? Cuz I don't think it is.

[@Marcos-rf5ui]

@@rohitbhushan8855 Well, communism is a political system which could consist of many theories, like anarcho-communism for example

[@rohitbhushan8855]

@@Marcos-rf5ui Is it good for economy ?

[@Marcos-rf5ui]

@@rohitbhushan8855 Depends, a system like that has never been tried except for Revolutionary Catalonia

[@allok898]

Left is best but Indian never understand it

[@pawandalvi6465]

Rabisshh kumar 🙄

[@aakash26159]

communism could not survive , even after so much extensive propoganda against capitalism by soviet at that time..how it can survive now..

[@dhpradeep]

just for curiousity sake....if the leftists upgrade their ideology to be in sync (contra-position) to the dominant political atmosphere in India, then will the leftist not split into some kind of 'purists (is conservative left unimagonable??) and alledged 'revisionists'?

[@ayanjoemusic]

yes they will, and will also lead into infighting.

[@rakeshsarvabhotla4998]

Communism does not consider clinical science-"Human psycology"

[@arshutsav9773]

I support dictatorship, but not communism.

[@MandeepKaur-pk5tq]

Because of low literacy rates and people struggle to even eat. They can’t think about politics, only the next meal

[@saikatbiswas8616]

first know communism then speak anything about it. read communist manifesto, das kapital, lenin biography, trotsky biography, che guavera, fidel castro and obviously karl mark.

[@neel9137]

saikat biswas just keep reading, but don't see its effects in real world, in every country where communism was tried has failed. So I say to you first read those facts and see what communism does then speak anything about it.

[@theepiccommenter5894]

@@neel9137 communism didn't fail due to time but because there is a scarcity of true communist

[@HueTube365]

Raveesh u were not allowing anyone to finish their point. You were giving chance to everyone but not allowing them to conclude. This video is senseless.

[@kumarpurush2296]

communism is best ideology ..... i love communism

[@liedetector114]

Ye democracy china mein kyon nhi hai

[@unsung.2770]

😂😂😂

[@GloomyGlue]

Socialism and communism are not inherently authoritian. Read the original marx socialism, it talks about democracy even at that time when monarchial system was popular.

[@sharadjamdagni3233]

Days when ravish did some good work

[@KingKong-jo3pn]

Still does

[@arjunk4324]

I am party member of CPIM lot of people have a misunderstanding view about communist the religious politics is threat to our country

[@naiyayika]

മാവോ, സ്റ്റാലിൻ, ചെ ഗുവേര, പോൾ പോട്ട് എന്നിവർ പ്രാകൃതരാണ്. അവർ വെറുക്കപ്പെടാനും പൈശാചികവൽക്കരിക്കപ്പെടാനും അർഹരാണ്. കമ്മ്യൂണിസം മരിക്കും. മരിക്കും.

[@xiijinpingthesupremeleader1349]

Yeah and our examples should pbe Mao , Pol pot , Stalin😂😂

[@Aryavarta225]

Native religion is the identity of any country my brother you failed to understand this simple thing regardless of whether the religion is true or not

[@Bhataktiatma007]

biggset joke of the century democracy left ne hi bacha rakhi hai ....🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 pehle khud ko bacha lo ....is hisab se to abhi tk desh me rajtantra aaa chuka hota

[@souhardyaadhikari7822]

Bhaii... Tum log democracy kisko mante ho? University k students pe hamla, hindu-muslim.. Kya ye democracy hai? Kerala is the most educated state which has applied a Communist govt...... But it's true that some of leaders are wrong, But it does not mean that it is a bad ideology. Every scientific thoughts are contained by the Left. And communist leaders have much less criminal records than other parties like BJP, TMC, INC etc... Indians should study history first.. They would see that communist ideology unites the human race.... India is a democracy... So every party would comes in power... But it is not true that communism would extinct completely from India....

[@rishisaini5269]

@@souhardyaadhikari7822 Communist Govt. to Bengal me bhee thi?Vaha kyu nahi chali?Aur crime records ki to baat karo mat?Aaj Tak Communisto se jyada political murders India me kisi bhee party ne nahi karwaey aur ye fact hai.Jake Bengal ki Communist history dekh lena.Sab pata chal jaega.Aur Communist bhee to Hinduo ko hee gaali dete rehte hai vo nahi dikhta aur humesha Islamophobia chillate rehte hai aur Communist yaha ki democracy se itna hee pyaar karte aaey hai to 1962 me Chinese invasion ko support kyu kiya?

[@bivhas]

Did communism not failed everywhere? Can you give one example of success🤣

[@kashettyavp]

China

[@Papa-ur3ju]

@@kashettyavpFascist state

[@nknkannadiga9742]

@@kashettyavp china is capitalist state. Thats why u can see lot of private companies.

[@abhishekbanerjee8101]

I was looking at this beautiful girl, holding the mic😍

[@sheebau1659]

Because of anti communism india , India is the only country to have most millionaires and highest number of Poor's (not a coincidence).

[@ghanashyampayeng2310]

Politics ko samjhna h, to left ko janne bina agge nahin bar sakte aap.🙏🏻

[@historitical6737]

True 🙏🙏🙏🙏

[@arnabbhattacharya6579]

Where has communist government succeeded 😂

[@kaushalendrarajput6230]

Communism is good if it sticks to what it promises minus violence but the problem is once its enforced completely its hard keep a check on it.

[@whythelongface64]

The lack of violence is the very reason the communist movement hasn't succeeded yet. It is a fault of the Sino-soviet split, really; if you think about it. The main force of the movement was usurped by the upper classes, and turned into social democracy

[@sreerag3354]

U ask like it shined in all other places around the world

[@dharmrajkumar5858]

Ndtv hero ravish sir

[@emperor4770]

😂😂😂 ka bat kar rahe ho.

[@sharvanlakhara8542]

प्रशांत भाई अब पत्रकार बनें हुए है lallantop मै

[@nitinjoshi2440]

Independent voice ravish bhai

[@priyer74]

10 years on, most people have internet access in India. Digital economy has got a big boost with UPI initiated by PM Modi govt.