Seachem Tidal 55 Hang on Back Filter Long Term Review

Hello Everyone,
In this video we look at the pros and cons of the Seachem Tidal 55 hang on back filter after having it up and running for the last year.
If you are looking to buy this filter here is an Amazon affiliate link: amzn.to/2SdOKms
If you want to buy your own filter floss here is an Amazon affiliate link for that as well: amzn.to/34JeYQp
Want to see more hang on back filter reviews? Check these out!
Marineland Penguin Pro 375: • Marineland Penguin Pro...
Marineland Emperor Pro 450 Review: • Marineland Emperor Pro...
Marineland Penguin 350 Review: • Marineland Penguin Fil...
Seachem Tidal 35 Review: • Seachem Tidal 35 Hang ...
Aquaclear 70 Review: • Fluval Aquaclear 70 Un...
Aqueon 20 Quiet Flow Review: • Aqueon 20 Quiet Flow H...
Want some more information on how to breed bristlenose plecos? Check out this video: • Bristlenose Pleco Care...
If you want to see more behind the scenes stuff, exclusive videos and support the channel consider becoming a member! / @primetimeaquatics
Also, our new shirts can be found at: www.primetimea...
For the latest in the fish room check us out on Instagram primetime_aquatics
We would like to thank our channel sponsors for 2020: Flip Aquatics and Fritz Aquatics. For 2020 our fish are being fed Northfin Foods from flipaquatics.com! They help make what we do here possible and are worth checking out!
Thanks for watching!

[@forgetfulpriestiv14]

I just got my Seachem 55 and don't regret it at all. I am super happy with this filter and I personally think it's the best one you can get on the market at the moment. The fact the pump is in the tank cuts down on a lot of the noise. It also makes sure that when the power goes out that it won't have a problem self priming to get going again.

[@vadicus-tcp]

I placed a plastic mesh at the bottom of mine so the sponge does not get squished into the open holes and limit water intake. No overflow and much better filtration I have found. Full flow and no bypass. I use about 3 inches of course sponge. Half inch of filter floss, a bag of Seachem Matrix and a bag of Seachem Purigen. All fits with no restrictions. Crystal clear water.

[@FinsbyProductions]

This is a great Idea! I've found bypass happens super fast for me I will have to try this! You placed the mesh in the very bottom of the basket yes? Under the course sponge?

[@danielingalls8980]

Have been running this exact filter on my 40 breeder for ten months with no issue. Motor runs quiet and strong. Have modded the hell out of it with rubber bands and filter floss mesh. But that had solved the issue of any of my Platy fry that I have breed being sucked in. And it is still running as of the posting. Thanks for the video dude🎉

[@scotthopkins2235]

I like how he mentions the cost gently. I have looked at this aspect of the filter and found I can get an Aqua Clear 70 for the price of the Tidal 55. I also understand why he mentioned price gently because it's not really that big of a deal if you are seriously into the hobby. The topic of the space between the wall and the tank, that is something I have had a bad experience with. I started out wanting the tank as tight to the wall as the filters would allow. Only to find out running cords and tubes to be hassle not to mention trying to find cord or tube drips that can happen, in a very narrow space.

[@njric71]

I've used Aquaclears, and Quietflows and a couple of other miscellaneous brands. The Tidal 55 is by far the best HOB filter I've ever used.

[@123bizzyboy]

Definitely

[@blakeg4151]

Is the 55 enough for a 55gallon

[@mannyaraujo1]

the tital sucks, aqua clear is still the best,

[@you0nlylivetwice]

Just purchased mine today due to the great reviews and features, taking advantage of black friday

[@redfishray2505]

How could someone dislike this video?!?!? So informative. Keep up the great work. My go to guy for my fish needs!!!

[@PrimeTimeAquatics]

RedfishRay thank you! Appreciate you watching.

[@deborahjeanne2141]

I don’t get it either! The review wasn’t nasty in any way, and it was honest, based on his experience with it!! 🤷🏻‍♀️

[@shutitfukface]

That's the joy of being human, not everyone thinks the same lol. I completely agree though, love watching this channel!

[@TemuMuuMuu]

This is a great review! Convinced me on this hob.

[@deborahjeanne2141]

All the pros you gave are the reasons I have 4 of them! They are so very quiet I’m always checking to see if they’re running! LOL! I had an Aquaclear that died after 2 months, and there was too much junk floating in the tank. It’s not overloaded - it has 15 guppies! I liked the Tidal 35 in my betta tank so much, I bought a Tidal 55 for my 20G - it’s a 20G tall and the Tidal 35 doesn’t have an intake flow tube, but the 55 does, so I opted for the bigger filter. The water clarity in all my Tidal tanks is extremely crystal clear, so I bought a Tidal 70 for the 55G I’m about to set up. I agree - the blue dials are annoying, but I’ve put plants in front of it so it’s not as noticeable. I also traced the shape of the filter floss on a piece of cardboard as a template, and it’s really no issue to cut out a piece of floss when it’s time to replace. Another pro is the huge basket - it allows you to put in additional filter floss such ammonia-grabbing filter floss or whatever you want. The Aquaclear basket is rather small without much leeway as to what you might want to use. I’ve only been doing this for 5 months, so it’s always nice to know that someone with your experience and knowledge agrees with me and the choice I made! Thanks for the update.

[@PrimeTimeAquatics]

Deborah Jeanne glad they are working well!

[@joet4030]

Another great review Jason! You have one of the best Aquatic channels on KZbin! Thank You!

[@PrimeTimeAquatics]

Thank you so much - appreciate it!

[@robanthony7937]

Another great review! I also bought the tidal 55 for a client's tank. It is really quiet and the way the media basket is designed that goes with the top lid during maintenance is just great so you won't have water dripping all over the place! And with the issue about the flow that bypasses when the sponge is clogged,its just a no brainer that whenever you see the maintenance indicator starts to pop up, you just need to service it right away to avoid the issue. Overall, the seachem tidal filter is great!

[@PrimeTimeAquatics]

Thanks for sharing!

[@pepperspa4655]

Loved your comment, "Maintain your filter properly". How often proper maintenance would resolve complaints about products. Thanks for your long term review.

[@PrimeTimeAquatics]

Thanks for watching!

[@pepperspa4655]

@@PrimeTimeAquatics Your welcome. Over the past one and one-half to two years I've probably watched all of your and Joanna's videos. I've learned a great deal and enjoyed what you've shared. Thanks for all the help you've provided to me.

[@etyrnal]

A WORD OF WARNING: Though i love everything about this filter, i have found one super annoying situation. I have neon blue dwarf goby. Three of them. These are GREAT little guys. Here's the problem. Wild caught. They are from areas of natural flowing water [think rivers/streams]... so, what's the problem/warning you ask? I keep finding them INSIDE my Tidal 55 HOB filters external water/media reservoir. That's right. They jump UPSTREAM. And they want to hang out INSIDE the HOB filter's reservoir. So, if your neon blue dwarf gobies (or any other wild caught dwarf gobies go missing for a few days... CHECK YOUR RESEVOIR TANK -- very carefully.

[@PrimeTimeAquatics]

Thanks for sharing!

[@halilhalil3993]

Happened to me as well!

[@divinelotus19]

I only have big fish so this, I don't care for.

[@Pepe-dq2ib]

doesnt this apply to all HOB filter and just "this filter"?

[@etyrnal]

@@Pepe-dq2ib you thought you were watching a review about ALL HOB filters?

[@thatonedog819]

I used to be a big fan of the aquaclear for many many years... Until I moves to a place where we had small, but frequent, power outages. Since the aquaclear isn't self priming, it would often run dry for hours once the power started back up before someone got home and it would destroy the filter and the cycle. I've been using sponge filters since. I think I'm going to give this one a try

[@TheOfficialSteelReign]

Thanks for the insights. Very valuable information for people looking to swap out what they have or for someone setting up a tank for the first time. Videos like this can help people determine which way they want to go.

[@PrimeTimeAquatics]

Thank you!

[@PrimeTimeAquatics]

If you want to buy your own filter floss here is an Amazon affiliate link for that as well: amzn.to/34JeYQp Want to see more hang on back filter reviews? Check these out! Marineland Penguin Pro 375: kzbin.info/www/bejne/gHKZk2WhqJKMgs0 Marineland Emperor Pro 450 Review: kzbin.info/www/bejne/mKbKnqpngZuKmJI Marineland Penguin 350 Review: kzbin.info/www/bejne/mZu8iZKGbMabr5Y Seachem Tidal 35 Review: kzbin.info/www/bejne/bYicY5ionq2efpI Aquaclear 70 Review: kzbin.info/www/bejne/o5mydJusqd2onZI Aqueon 20 Quiet Flow Review: kzbin.info/www/bejne/Z6PZmp2Flr57naM Want some more information on how to breed bristlenose plecos? Check out this video: kzbin.info/www/bejne/iIPXkKeghLCMbpY If you want to see more behind the scenes stuff, exclusive videos and support the channel consider becoming a member! kzbin.info/door/YVN7EN0ALL6CE4U7NpMUTAjoin Also, our new shirts can be found at: www.primetimeaquatics.com/merch For the latest in the fish room check us out on Instagram primetime_aquatics

[@paulone65]

i love that filter.and i love that it starts on its own

[@JoeNocella]

I just got a Tidal 55. I love the quality. They pretty much thought of everything and I respect that. You can tell they put a lot of thought into this filter. Sometimes it's worth it to pay a little more. I hate hard cheap plastic and parts that are hard to clean. This is the complete opposite. It's made of thick rugged plastic and well designed.

[@PrimeTimeAquatics]

I agree - they did a great job with this filter.

[@duncandonuts5268]

I think the skimmer is nice if you've got an open aquascape going on. Keeps the surface clean and makes sure you have the tank properly filled, otherwise you will be hearing very loud noises.

[@Fatjohny100]

I have been planning on picking one up.. have not heard anything that would discourage that plan.. thanks for another good review video..

[@seannunes2041]

Very thorough review. Appreciate that you followed up a year later. Thank you.

[@PrimeTimeAquatics]

Thank you for watching!

[@Davidsmithisyourdad]

Been looking into this filter for my next tank. My current 40 gallon is running a canister. I like the fact that you can use biomedia and the basket removes for easy cleaning .

[@gm836]

I strongly believe the simple design is what made it such a reliable unit. It’s a beast of a HOB.

[@truthfactreality6814]

I own all the different Seachem tidals. For a few different tanks. They are absolute awesome filters. Canister killers

[@TheSwiftCreek2]

I bought a seachem HOB a while back since I was having some minor issues with my fluval HOB (partially due to my inexperience with HOB at the time). The price points were much closer than mentioned in this video at the time (3 months ago, slightly smaller models as well). Not needing to prime your pump, not drudging gunk from the bottom of the tank to fowl the motor, bringing water through all your media, and quiet operation (also great speed control) are just things that I feel like I could not do without in the future - if I continue to use HOB filters (only using the 1 HOB right now, along with a canister filter, 3 box filters, 1 sponge filter, and a circ pump for my 7 tanks). I noticed in Prime Time Aquatics last Marineland filter review the motor had been moved into the water. I think Seachem was the first to do this out of the mainstream HOB manufacturers. Why it wasn't done before blows my mind. Negatives: 1 by-pass: not an issue, I do good maintenance. 2) The color blue: I don't care, if it blended with the HOB would I be able to see it/understand it as well upon opening the box? 3) Skimmer: not good for small fish and shrimp, but usually I would use a box or sponge filter for these tanks. fairly big plus for tanks without, depending on how well it works.

[@PrimeTimeAquatics]

Robert Brown thanks for sharing!

[@gardeninginflorida6278]

Thanks great review ! Mine is on the way this week. I was sold from other reviews specifically the skimmer slots. I am starting a 55G dirted tank and will stock it with some smaller angles and other fish friendly with angels! Thanks again subscribed today too i have seen plenty of your videos already and you do a great job!

[@PrimeTimeAquatics]

Thanks for being here!

[@jerryross5423]

Great video. I have the 35 and will be buying the 55 for my other tank to replace a Marineland that was good, but kind of finicky to keep going.

[@mraquaticnews5676]

Thanks for the review Jason 👊🏽 recently found out your a very funny guy only seen when other channels check out your fish room

[@TJ-ht3jb]

Excellent review. I have the 110 on a 35 gallon and I have to agree the blue dials and the surface skimmer are the main 2 downsides. The 110 may be more filtration than a 35 gallon needs but it is better to go higher than lower. It is extremely quiet . The tank is in the living room and I can hardly ever hear it running. My other 3 tanks are all over 55 gallons and I use canister filters on all of these. If you are going to go with tanks under 45 gallons the Tidal HOBs are great.

[@PrimeTimeAquatics]

Appreciate you sharing your experience!

[@apaulmcdonough2170]

You're Ridiculous! I ran a 55 on a 37 USG, along with powerhead undergravel filtration. More than adequate.

[@riderZ873]

Awesome filter. Except for it being almost impossible to make em safe for shrimps and fry without turning it into Frankensteins monster. I bought it, but I ended up using a simple Aquaclear cause it so simple to add a intake sponge and make it safe for everything. I REALLY LOVE the Tidal filters and hope future versions will take the intakes into consideration :)

[@rickgrimezz3942]

I tested Tidal 110, 75, 55. All three have the same issue. Water takes the path of least resistance. This filter is poorly designed. If you add a pre-filter to the unit...so your shrimp do not get pulled into the filter. The water just takes the path of least resistance and gets pulled from the surface skimmer. So no filtration occurs from near the bottom of the tank. So basically you bought a real nice surface skimmer... that really doesn't filter the bottom of the water column in the tank. Also, the extension tube that you can raise and lower. The unit pulls water in from the clamping mechanism as well. So it's not even a water-tight seal to secure proper suction by the pump. Overall this filter is one of the worst designed filters I have ever seen. The only other filter worse than this at these price points... are the Top Fin Pro series filters. Those are utterly worthless as well. Aquaclear 110 is the best HOB filter because it doesn't have any of those issues at all. Also, I have my fish tanks on UPS (Uninterruptable Power Supply) battery backup. So I never lose power to my tanks. So the pump in the water argument is completely worthless to the conversation because everything you value should be on some sort of battery backup so power outages do not destroy your sensitive equipment, gaming computers... TVs... and more. Hands down... I would NEVER recommend Tidal filtration to anyone. Its snake oil at best!

[@scotthopkins2235]

I don't have this filter, but I assume there is a way to silicone a black plastic plate over the skimmer vents either from the inside or less appealing outside. I would venture to guess that a really crafty person could make a sliding door over the vents so they could be closed and opened at will.

[@WOLFE221]

I really enjoyed my Seachem Tidal75 until this morning when the motor died. AC fanboys can gloat now, but my Aquaclear died only after 4 months of use. >Junk< I replaced my Tidal75 with Marineland Penguin Pro 375 and so far I find it to be the best HOB on the market in the $50-60 US dollar range. The 375 is far and above better than the Marineland 350 we're all used to. I was pleasantly surprised regarding the features... Submerged motor, comes with polishing cartridges, adjustable flow, biowheels, and a hinged lid. Heck, even the intake strainer basket opens to accept media. And it's quieter than my Tidal75. If you haven't already reviewed the Penguin Pro 375, I recommend you check it out.

[@PrimeTimeAquatics]

I actually have reviewed it and have a few of those too! :-)

[@brucekent7442]

Not in this league Ofcourse, but I have my Sobo WP 408 H it has all of these..but its slimmer and ofcourse has less capacity 680L/hr still as I have only a 20 Gallon tank it does an awesome job and is way way way cheaper. Infact i am new to keeping fish I lost 3red caps and 1bala all small ones.. i😭😭😭. I pulled up my socks..Changed my filter and also add something called Ozpolish Biocure..which has 8 types of benificial bacteria in millions..and now thank God my fishes are happy and I haven't lost any. Finally having said that I would like to beg you to check internal power filters as they are most ineffective only stress the fish unless its a huge tank like yours and do a video on that pls🙏 and going forward with all you people's blessings I am aiming to get a bigger tank and better filteration 🙏

[@Matagot90]

You can paint over the blue dials with black. I just got my Seachem Tidal today. Thanks for the video.

[@guppy9713]

Yeah I'm curious about that too.

[@circe604]

Hi StrangeArrangements I'm planning to do just that but I haven't find yet any black paint that could be used without being toxic for the life in the tank, any luck with that? pleaseeeee 🙏

[@circe604]

@@jdamommio Thanks for the tip 😉 bless Bob Fenner just one year after his death 🙏 RIP

[@Maggie13513]

sea Cem Tidel filters love them.I have two 110s absolutely adore the way they filter my aquarium crystal clear also have internal filters for a bonus filter

[@gamegurl564]

I totally agree with you about the blue buttons. They are an eyesore.

[@ZombifiedWatermelon]

The skimmer makes them clog more often, pay attention to that little blue pop-up tab, but the ease pf cleaning and the submerged water pump more than makes up tor it. I have (2) Tidal 110's on a overstocked 60 breeder. I clean them once a week, takes me about 20 minutes, and unlike the AC line I don't have to worry about if my filter will start working again after a power outage.

[@Strongerthandirt8695]

Having kept Seachem Tidal 55s for a couple of years now, I only have one complaint: Trying to get into the impeller housingto clean it is very difficult. Because I have several planted tanks, the impeller can sometimes get clogged with old pieces of plants or an old piece of plant root here and there. Getting the housing open to clean is a chore....it takes all my strength to open. Then, after cleaning, trying to get the housing put back on the way it WAS (with the big fat wire in the way) was cumbersome and tiring. Then, after all that, the impeller can be a tad "off" and starts making a loud noise once turned back on.

[@sebaseven7220]

I use tidal 110 and I am very pleased. very good equipment. I recommend 👍

[@drewswanson8142]

thanks. I believe I have found my new filter. i want something with an adjustable flow rate and was looking at the fluval/aqua clear, but I believe I will be going with the tidal.

[@PrimeTimeAquatics]

These are very solid filters!

[@mariaz9538]

I have one of these on my 75 gal acrylic rainbow tank and I love it and I agree with everything you have said! 👍

[@PrimeTimeAquatics]

Good to hear!

[@VIDEOHEREBOB]

May I just say, now,10 years later, my discontinued API Superclean HOB has been amazing. Why it got discontinued? API said because of weak sales. Go figure.

[@ericmcginnis9413]

The cheap old filter that came Wii my 30 gallon tank set up that I got for $20 including stand light decorations air pumps the whole 9, it came with adjustable flow feature built into the filter ! Score!! Whatever my filter is it's old ! I have it for at least 5 years!

[@budiawan1784]

This products review make clear to me considering HOB i'll be using. Well done Sir Thankyou Best regards, budiawan

[@bilbofr4ggins646]

I run two 110’s (bought them right when they dropped to consumers ) on my 90 discus tank big fan has saved me $ to delay on a sump until the fish get bigger.

[@DaniKenAquatics]

I have two of these on my 135 I have bigger versions I love them the only complaint would be if you have floating plant the intake skimmer goes suck the plants In and make alot of noise when this happens thanks for the Information!!

[@PrimeTimeAquatics]

DaniKen Aquatics never thought about that!

[@glenncordova4027]

Could you eliminate the skimmer by blocking it with silicone caulk? Permanent solution?

[@frankschindler7073]

Great video 👍. I own 3 of them ( 110 Tidal ). Thank you for the tip on the pre filter material I will definitely try that. How do you block the skimmer? I do have a breeding colony of bristle nose plecos in my tank . You nailed this review thank you for sharing 🇨🇦

[@PrimeTimeAquatics]

Thank you so much. As for the skimmer - you could try cutting the net meshing out of a fish net and super gluing it to the filter over the skimmer intake?

[@frankschindler7073]

@@PrimeTimeAquatics Thanks. I will definitely try that. Your videos are always so good. Keep up the good work and stay safe 🇨🇦👍

[@Maggie13513]

@@PrimeTimeAquatics 70

[@michaelmathes1991]

I run the 55 and it is quiet . Great review,

[@karenwilliam9207]

Great video man! Love from Malaysia ♥

[@DJ_Ebike_enthusiasts]

I use two on my 55-gal. They are silent. I use pre-filters on the intakes and at the surface skimmer intake. They have been running for over a year with no issues.

[@PrimeTimeAquatics]

Doyle Riggan good to hear!

[@SeGdb]

I'm surprised that some people might have a difficult time to cut their own sponge to fit in the basket... use the original as a template, voila!

[@mikefisher4834]

I have this exact pump on a standard 20 gallon This thing is so quiet it’s got me checking to see if it’s still working💯😂💙🔥

[@PrimeTimeAquatics]

I was doing the same thing. Haha

[@AQUAGUYUK]

Great review do you think the quoted figures are accurate i love the way you pop the floss in and also agree about the skimmer

[@PrimeTimeAquatics]

I think so

[@AQUAGUYUK]

@@PrimeTimeAquatics Thank you

[@audrisampson]

I got my 110 right around the time you got yours. I needed to get really creative with filter media. I ended up using an Aquaclear 110 foam block and got a sheet of this carbon and floss and cut to size.

[@bernandoturner4840]

These Filters are Great.. I seen one in Action,in A planet tank.. gunked up bad.. but Worked great..great video👻

[@markhunter2244]

Sounds like a good filter for bedroom tanks.

[@PrimeTimeAquatics]

Mark Hunter based on their low noise I would think so.

[@OregonOutdoorsChris]

I'm running the 75 and love it, other than the skimmer. If they just omitted the skimmer this filter would have been darn near perfect.

[@PrimeTimeAquatics]

OregonOutdoorsChris I really wish they had a sliding cover for it.

[@shutitfukface]

@@PrimeTimeAquatics 🤔 legit best comment I've read here! That's genius and so simple I never even thought of that! As if Seachem didn't think of that 😲 definitely a huge miss 🤦🏼‍♂️.

[@QueAquatics]

this one is on my bucket list, thank you

[@PrimeTimeAquatics]

QueAquatics that list keeps growing doesn’t it? Haha

[@QueAquatics]

Hahahah yes it does

[@mariaz9538]

QueAquatics go for it Que...I have one on my 75 gal rainbow tank and it works great

[@johnwood738]

Another great learning video thank you Professor fish! Didn’t find a long fin super red pleco the other day at LFS but am on the list at three places.I did get plants and more Pea Puffers .

[@PrimeTimeAquatics]

John Wood awesome man!

[@richardcolligon4277]

I would still buy a title filter today. You can buy the precut filter sponge's off of Amazon for a few buck's, and if you have prime shipping that part's free.

[@kerrypitt9789]

I've been using Aquaclear filters, the only problem I have had is that the impeller can foul up and need cleaning every few months. I will try one of these next on a larger tank. Checking on Amazon Canada, there is little differences in the price let alone prices in Canada are stupid, you would expect that the price difference would be reflected in our dollar difference but sadly not.

[@rcjk1]

I have this filter on my 55g. The only complaint I have is the SKIMMER gets algae/plant leaves in it and then it makes a LOT of noise.

[@ROQ1111]

i read alot of member seal the skimmer away and use separate skimmers instead, they put some silicone sealant on it

[@DJ_Ebike_enthusiasts]

Use a pre-filter at the intake. I use zip ties to affix a small piece of filter media to the intake.

[@rcjk1]

!Thanks

[@robroy4137]

Doyle Riggan I’m sorry you lost me but I’m intrigued because I want to start an aquarium and I want to have it planted with plants so that is a problem but you suggested use a pre-filter was that the white filter or was that the black filter at the bottom Seattle even know the language yet thank you because I would wanna block the skimmer as well

[@DJ_Ebike_enthusiasts]

Robin4137 Watch the video at the 10:30 mark. You will see the intake for the skimmer. I tie a 2”square piece of filter media against the intake to catch some of the debris that comes from inside the tank. I use two pre-filter cylinders on the intake tubes that reach down into the tank. They help to catch debris and also provide surface area for beneficial bacteria. If you are setting up a new tank, watch videos on cycling a new aquarium and one on how to set up a planted tank. It’s best to use plants that don’t require lots of light or CO2 if you are just getting started.

[@StruggleBus07]

Mahalo for the great review!

[@aprilowens160]

Thank you! This extremely hopeful!

[@gamegurl564]

I am sorry to say that after having this filter for just over 24 hours I will be returning it. The bummer is that skimmer, it takes all the intake power away from the drop down intake tube, hardly any suction there. I wish you had mentioned that in your review. If I had wanted all my suction at the top I would have bought the 35. The main reason I was so excited about this filter was the drop down intake which is at a great level for my 29 tank, kind of a tall tank. Anyway I don't want to have to *fix* my brand new $60. filter, so back it's going to go.

[@PrimeTimeAquatics]

I've never had that issue.

[@dynestis2875]

I use a Tidal 35 on a 14 gallon long tank, used the filter media that came in the box and added 100g purigen. Amazing little machine! Very easy to install and maintain, can't hear it at work at all!

[@joannecavan1213]

thanks for the video, i have 2 tidal 55 and 1 100 or 110 cant remember , they do a great job with my sponge filters. i agree with the blue dials.....why

[@PrimeTimeAquatics]

Thanks for sharing your experience!

[@glenncordova4027]

Could you paint the dials with black nail polish without hurting the fish? It might not be permanent?

[@emmanuelgutierrez8616]

I still like the width of the aquaclear for more media, and I dont put my filters on the long sides, I put them on the short side in the corner to induce circulating flow.

[@gregghorner9107]

Nice design but it has flaws. The overflow is a constant problem if you try to add some finer floss or extra media, and the flow adjustment on mine just does not do anything.

[@apaulmcdonough2170]

Sometimes the Shaft on the Flow Adjustment can be bent. Pop the Blue Slider that holds the Media Basket in place Off. Then you can pry off the small square that is inside, below the Flow Adjustment Wheel. Run Hot Tap Water over the Shaft first and then gently Straighten the Shaft to have the plate at the Bottom of the Shaft in its proper position.

[@davidsamsell2031]

Jason, I think you need more tanks. 😛 Would like to build a nice fish room some day like yours. Very nice. 👍😁 The Seachem is not a bad design but I Iike my aquaclears though. Never had a restart problem with my A.C. 110, yet.... Thanks for the nice video.

[@PrimeTimeAquatics]

David Samsell were adding tanks as we speak. Haha

[@crw31399]

Was thinking about upgrading to tidal 55 for heavily stocked 29 gallon..any other suggestions.tidal 55 overall seems to be the winner as I search.

[@PrimeTimeAquatics]

EIther that or a Marineland 375. Both are very solid.

[@CarolynnMc01]

I have this HOB filter, and while I like it, it's been impossible for me to turn down the flow because the knob at the top isn't working properly. I discovered the plastic extension "rod" connected to the knob is probably bent. It used to be the lid to that housing was removeable, but it seems like that design was changed,. Can't remove it.. So I'm stuck with max flow. I'm not sure how to remedy this, and the issue drives me crazy sometimes! Otherwise, the filter does a great job.

[@miked6335]

I don't know if it's a design flaw or I'm just unlucky but I've twice had a problem with overflow coming out of those top vents along the back. I've had this filter since June 2021 and the problem first occurred a couple of month ago. Then again last night after I had serviced the media. Think I lost about a half gallon which didn't do the floor any good. The flow has always been set to full blast so I'll have to dial it down. I'll see how that works out. Not sure I can trust this filter anymore if I'm away on vacation. I also have a couple of 35s which haven't had this problem yet.

[@PrimeTimeAquatics]

If the media gets clogged that can happen.

[@sharronmiller451]

Love your reviews!!

[@timothysprinkle3052]

When the water level is all the way up to the top the filter is quiet, but if the level drops enough to not cover the surface skimmer 100% then it becomes the noisiest filter I have. Constant popping and clicking. Really annoying. The other thing is it can get clogged quickly if you have plecos and plants. If you put an intake filter on the bottom intake that helps some, but then baby plecos and plant debris suck straight into the skimmer. Even with periodic maintenance these issues pop up constantly. I modified the skimmer intakes with a water safe mesh material. This is the second one I bought. I thought that would solve everything, but again a little drop in water level, and here comes the popping and clicking again.

[@PrimeTimeAquatics]

Ya, definitely important to keep the tank filled with these.

[@gordonchristensen8143]

If any of you guys are concerned about the intake tube length even fully extended like I was on my 65gal. (I have two 55s on it) I have the solution. PA1240 marineland extension tube for the old PFE3 hood filters fit tidal 55 perfectly. I have 4 tidal 55s running with this setup.

[@Strongerthandirt8695]

Thank you!

[@johnnyaguilarjr.9920]

Will this also work on the 110

[@gordonchristensen8143]

Yes,it will. Same size as the 55.

[@TableTopBiker]

Gave me a lot to think about. May try one out.

[@timrussell89]

I'm torn between the Tidal 110 and the Aquaclear 110. I prefer the self priming tidal and the basket on the tidal but I really don't like the surface skimmer idea. Does it get clogged with plant material? If not for the skimmer I'd buy the Tidal all day over the Aquaclear because everything else about it seems perfect.

[@PrimeTimeAquatics]

I haven't had too much of an issue with the skimmer getting clogged, but I also don't have a lot of plant material dying off?

[@timrussell89]

@@PrimeTimeAquatics thank you for the reply. Im trying to decide on what to get as Im in the planning stage of building a heavily planted, heavily stocked 55 gallon. Im really wanting to do a valisneria jungle and a lot of small schooling fish.

[@scoth2455]

Did you have any issues with food getting sucked into the skimmer before fish could eat it?

[@josediegoist]

Yes

[@apaulmcdonough2170]

Turn the Upper Wheel Left to reduce the Filtration Rate just before Feeding and then Return to your Normal Flow Rate, a few minutes later.

[@etyrnal]

...has this little blue dot that shows you when you need to clean your filter. we don't really need it because we clean our... 2:44 -- blue dot popped up -- went past filter cleaning indicator. LOL

[@etyrnal]

i enjoy Your videos... i was just poking lighthearted fun at the irony =)

[@rrjohn5]

I have to replace my current filter because it is struggling- Marineland penguin 200. I was hesitant to buy that one a year ago because it seemed Marineland filters have gone down in quality. I was not wrong. After 1 yr, and regular tank maintenance, it struggles to keep its prime. So, against my better judgement, I tried the penguin pro 275. Out of the box it was missing the part that keeps the filter level against the tank.... so I called the company. They can't send the part to me. 😡 Buh-bye Marineland. I just ordered the Tidal 55. I'm a convert. Thanks for the helpful info!

[@PrimeTimeAquatics]

That really stinks they can't send the part to you. Seems like such an easy solution.

[@Borogerst32697]

how the heck do you get INSIDE the skimmer box to clean it? my only issue with this filter otherwise I THINK IT IS THE BEST ONE OUT THERE. thanks for your help!

[@PrimeTimeAquatics]

I usually just take a brush of some type and remove anything from the intake.

[@johnnycruz9690]

Hi there! I just got mine yesterday. A Tidal 55 and so far I like it. The only concern I have is the humming sound of the motor. That is normal?

[@PrimeTimeAquatics]

That’s not something I normally hear? Really important with these that the water level is covering the surface skimmer.

[@edwardwells5864]

The only reason I would buy this filter over a AquaClear is the fact it can surface skim and get the oil slick off my waters surface for better oxygen exchange and more efficient use of my light on the tank so I can maximize PAR reaching the bottom of the tank as opposed to acting as a light defuser.

[@jimberence]

Hob filter is good only to the small tank, less than 35 gallon tank.

[@PrimeTimeAquatics]

I would disagree - I’ve run them up to 150 gallons and they do a great job. My cut off is probably anything over 180 gallons

[@larchsama9773]

The overflow is a big problem with the Tidal filters. I had a Aquaclear 110 and a Tidal 55. I had to clean my Tidal every week because the slightest amount of dirt would cause it to start overflowing. While my Aquaclear 110 would go months without needing a cleaning and didn't overflow at all. The fact that you need to clean a HOB filter every single week is a pretty big downside for me.

[@علیاکبرزارعی-ز4ض]

❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@brandonellis4422]

Could you do a video on how to keep a hospital/quarantine tank ready to go (all the time)? Or at least one that could be cycled really quick for new/sick fish?

[@PrimeTimeAquatics]

Good idea!

[@gm836]

Doesn’t it annoy the fish then if the sound is contained within the water.

[@PrimeTimeAquatics]

Good question! The short answer is - I haven't seen any change in behavior or length of life.

[@pawpotsRS]

I'm using it in my nano saltwater tank this is far better than shiruba x305 that is rated for 20g which is the flow was not looking 20g rated.

[@greenthumbaquariums1185]

This follow-up is great. And thanks for the nod to the path that water is intended to flow for those of us that are interested in such things.

[@TheBrandonJ1984]

wait for it....maintain your filter properly....brilliant.

[@jp-us9rq]

I just got mine yesterday I like it only thing it noisy im ready to send it back Waiting a fiew days see if it settles down

[@PrimeTimeAquatics]

Is the water filled all the way up to the rim? Sometimes if it's low the filter will make a little noise.

[@jp-us9rq]

@@PrimeTimeAquatics yea it filled up its starting to quiet down maybe it just has to break in

[@jp-us9rq]

@@PrimeTimeAquatics I really like it though the water seems to be clearer then usual lol

[@soggyfries4347]

The Penn Plax Cascade 300 has been doing an immaculate job on 33 long. Dead silent $25.

[@PrimeTimeAquatics]

Very cool!

[@kkdeveauxgue2784]

I have a 35 in a 20 gallon but it's not doing the job,time for a 55tidal

[@rickrodriguez6675]

Jason agree on all the points you mentioned about this filter. I did purchase the 75 gallon ☝️, but was not sold on it. Again this my opinion due to my experience with this filter. Thanks for the video 😎👍

[@yournamehere3071]

Paint the blue dials with a black Sharpie

[@robroy4137]

Up to how many gallons will this filtration system clean thank you I’m novice and trying to get into this hobby I love it I love your videos very informativete

[@PrimeTimeAquatics]

This particular filter is good for about 55 gallons. They make smaller ones for smaller tanks and larger ones too.

[@D.W.G.]

Hows the brand Aqueon? Just bought the quietflow canister filter 400 with 3 year warranty just incase it breaksdown then I'll just put in more cash get another fX6

[@PrimeTimeAquatics]

I have used the quiet flow HOBs and liked them as well. They ran well and were definitely quiet.

[@johnglenham4099]

You say about the blue controls on the filter making the filter stand out but surly any hang on filter stands out like a sore thumb.when will t shirt be available in the uk.keep up the good work.

[@PrimeTimeAquatics]

That's true. I think Joanna was checking on that and Ill ask her. : -)

[@gamegurl564]

Question rather than comment. I just got my new Tidal 55, I think I love it so far but wondered about the intake control dial. It seems to have two positions and I am unsure which I should be using? Would you be able to advise me? It's on a 29 gallon tank with a super low load at this time. I will be adding some more fish in the future. Thanks in advance.

[@PrimeTimeAquatics]

I adjust it so it takes the maximum from the intake tube.

[@gamegurl564]

@@PrimeTimeAquatics Yes, that's what I want. I think clicked all the way to the right is wide open? I held some debris in front of the intake and far right seemed stronger. Thanks again

[@sparkygirl37064]

Thanks for the very thorough review! :-)

[@PrimeTimeAquatics]

Tiffany White thanks! 😀