Private Investigator Guesses Who's Lying: Travel Stories

[@darkceptor44]

5:07 kelsey was like "i was an acting major" and the dude was like "hmmmmm interesting"

[@rosiesaikaly1178]

Yea i thought she was lying cause what would an acting major study abroad lol. Its usually for physics or language classes. Not acting

[@tutsuyaki]

Well she’s a good actress then if she tried to add some like lies movement or anything to make it a little lie

[@moriahmiller7259]

I thought she was lying because earlier I thought she had said first semester, so I was assuming fall trip, and then she said spring break.

[@ioncekilledamanwithmyshoe]

No One I don’t think she was smart enough to do that convincingly, let alone if she was even ALLOWED to act like she was suspicious because then that would throw everything off.

[@curlyactress]

Rosie Saikaly I studied acting in college, and we had the option to study abroad in London junior year for our Shakespeare unit

[@elizabethregnes4225]

The editor in this LMFAO. "I was an acting major" **zooms in on John's face**

[@twincherry4958]

And Kelsey's fingers...and her touching her hair and neck when asked questions.

[@ioncekilledamanwithmyshoe]

twin cherry the editors were trying to throw them off.

[@LuckyOwI777]

@@ioncekilledamanwithmyshoe throw "them" off? Who do you mean by them?

[@jovanbudiman7201]

What a very misleading evidence

[@tyrincarroll4225]

lol i died when that happened

[@BrittanyGanzow]

AS SOON as he asked her what year she was born...GOTCHA! 😂😂 She was so mad.

[@arinarain9535]

yeah thats true, i watching her hands like--tell us that she organize the story and it could be lying.

[@moriahmiller7259]

When you are scared to read the comments because of potential spoilers

[@Xeribus]

All the time for Movie Reviews

[@brenda_mart]

I'm glad this comment was on top cuz it didn't spoil it from the new yt update

[@eutony30]

Kate looked like she was about to cry near the end

[@crazypig129]

fr though lol, she looked so ashamed and like heartbroken that he caught her out, I literally started laughing

[@kelseymdo]

𝐼 𝐿𝐼𝐾𝐸 𝑇𝑅𝐴𝐼𝑁𝑆

[@drac3264]

*Plot twist* :they all lying including the investigators

[@callmecolby]

are they really private investigators🤔

[@lexiadair5450]

Me: *OMG* *o.O*

[@thequevin]

@@callmecolby I just found out they're both actors... The lying, the DECEIT! Look them up on their socials and on the credits....

[@AnGel-tf9wg]

Wait what

[@otdtyh]

But where was the shark???

[@recoil53]

Came here for this. As long as I see John, I'm going to remember the shark.

[@elizabethregnes4225]

LOL

[@akankshakaith2545]

😂😂😂

[@nucamaisuradze6267]

😂😂😂😂😂i was hoping to see this comment

[@ebwbau8036]

**snort** **snort**

[@jewelandloreeshow]

Kelsey said fall of junior year, but said she was there for spring break???

[@Sara-zt4cb]

ahh ha 😮

[@reignkimberly]

she said first semester junior year, not every first semester starts at fall...

[@somnia97]

Yes! And she was studying in London and I don't think spring break is a thing in Britain

[@Ninipatiu]

@@somnia97 it's "easter break"

[@somnia97]

@@Ninipatiu yes, that is what I though as well. We have that were I live

[@thirza_]

Jennifer: I almost got kidnapped John: So where was the SHARK?!

[@mariaelenaguzman-cota106]

“ He was probably trying to kidnap you also “ 😂😂

[@rdsx463724]

My guess was Kate from the introduction. She had way too many details. It felt like she thought way too hard about her list of lies and you could tell she wanted to make sure to get through the whole thing.

[@totallytubulartay]

In this one: THEY ALL SEEMED LIKE LIARS TO ME!?!?

[@semiboom]

“hi this is john quinones why did you pick her?”

[@LoEaston]

The fact that I just came here from a what would you do video, I-

[@semiboom]

Lo Easton that’s so weird 😂

[@angelinap.7207]

@@LoEaston yes

[@sofialepe7380]

@@LoEaston SAME

[@anxngel618]

Lo Easton SAME

[@mee-nz9vy]

I'm a simple person, I see John, *I click*

[@applebean-8350]

“don’t know why u need to know my birthday but okay” ends up using her birthday to win

[@cezarab5236]

9:11 John's face is everything. He was being humble to not make Elizabeth feel bad, but he was prooooud!

[@joelnicholl172]

As soon as she said the Olympics was 2012 I knew she was lying

[@bluelambo5]

I live in vancouver I was a little mind fucked like wait what... I thought it was 2010, I remember all the mittens with 2010... WTF HAPPENED IN 2010 THEN

[@bananawammabama]

It seemed like a good strategy to establish the year based on the fact that right before her, they were grilling Kelsey on the years of everything, but she obviously didn't have enough time to think that strategy through lol.

[@recoil53]

John double checked her age at the time to make sure she just didn't say it wrong. A person might say the year wrong or her age at the time wrong, but both is doubtful.

[@archo1768]

I knew she was lying since the first minute. She just looked at the other girls and acted like this was not me.

[@DancerMusicanActress]

Same. I was like ummmmm. It was 2010...... Check yo facts girl

[@gerardoluevano3167]

To me it was really easy to spot that the first one was telling the truth because she had direct eye contact and the other two kept looking away to remember there stories

[@editazilinskyte3681]

I disagree completely on that one. Remembering the story is something a person does. If you have experienced something years back it likely you will forget some stuff and will have to think to remember. A liar would have been planning their story for the last few days aswell as trying to not see suspicious. The ones making CONSTANT eye contact seemed suspicious because they are trying to hard. People that look at the floor to think are just trying together what happend.

[@TheCriminalViolin]

Did you know they've proven multiple times now that those kinds of eye contact, gaze directions, head tilts and other body language is actually typically untrue? Plus you also have to consider, many people out there, including myself, have a really hard time maintaining eye contact as it makes us feel uncomfortable, and often anxious, as we're just different socially in terms of functionality.

[@Raquel96]

Ah this was awesome!! The little smile after he guessed it right, I love it

[@gaellecalmet2627]

doesn’t anyone else see how the investigator looks SO much like jennifer annistooonn

[@lavernmbutura9558]

Wow...i see it now

[@princessonuoha79]

@@lavernmbutura9558 And Colbie Caillat

[@ggoodd32503]

Was just saying that too

[@imaggienative]

But Jennifer Aniston does not have a beard

[@gaellecalmet2627]

Mag Gie hahahahahahahahaha

[@xandrav]

when kelsey is so good at acting she can act like she's lying

[@christianmolina5891]

Bruh I knew it was kate because of her behavior but I was blown when John pieced together that crap 😱

[@xVancha]

Weirdly, I was totally with the first two girls as they told their story, visualising the experience they were describing, whereas my imagination was far less co-operative with number 3...I actively had to try and picture the story she was describing. It's like her storytelling had a rhythm that wasn't compatible with recalling information, but felt more like she was reading off a list of events. Maybe I just got lucky, but I wonder if there's anything to that...

[@eliebarbar403]

No one: Elizabeth: I spent a little of time/I know a little about (enter location)

[@sydneycross9080]

You can tell that Kate is lying at 8:55. She shows a micro expression, which is common for people to do when they are lying.

[@pngs]

Yeah, but, that's after John cast his vote.

[@Btotheblaze]

John reminds me of a mix of Dexter and Jim Hopper. Diggin it

[@destinyUGC]

The Joker omg so true and weird

[@GalaxyStars]

Elizabeth reminds me of Jennifer Aniston from the sideview!

[@TheFiddler69]

John reminds me of Jim Hopper from Stranger Things!

[@jayceemlekush3083]

Why did that girl look all pissed? I mean she was lying anyway 🙄

[@BrittneyBay8]

Jaycee Mlekush I was wondering the same thing 😂 she looked so upset at the end

[@jayceemlekush3083]

@@BrittneyBay8 it almost looked like she was going to cry bc she couldn't lie good enough 😢🤣🤣🤣

[@Young_buck2423]

Yup

[@sb6079]

she don't like lying but that was her role

[@jvojugg7561]

@@jayceemlekush3083 liars typically think long nd hard on the perfect story nd im sure that was the best she could do so when john poked so many holes in her lie its like calling her a bad liar and it give me a courtroom type feel

[@eurekify1563]

Guy walks up to her to offer his help *Hi I'm Jennifer and I almost got kidnapped in China*

[@fukzy2852]

Eurekify! This is actually a thing. A Thai man took pics of my 15yo sister and followed her around. My parents scolded him and he ran away scared. Turned out there was a pedophile ring active there.

[@eurekify1563]

@@fukzy2852 I'm not saying that I do not believe her story, just that it seemed like she was exaggerating... a lot. Plus, tell me if I'm wrong, but Buzzfeed is known for doing that. I hope your sister was ok.

[@fukzy2852]

Eurekify! I understand. No worries. My comment was not meant to be taken personally. She was fine, thanks for asking! Have a nice day!

[@reallylikeyaoioyeah4308]

Fukzy on behalf of thai people , I have to apologize. Did you have great time in Thailand that time?

[@fukzy2852]

reallylikeyaoi oyeah No worries, one creep does not define a whole nationality. It was lovely and many Thai people were extremely friendly. ❤️

[@Bryan-wj4hz]

Like for Private Investigators investigate Private Investigators(not a typo)

[@chrissyb9137]

When someone is telling a story they pause say umm or look up cause they have to actively try to remember the real event. If someone says everything clearly and confidently its usually cause they rehearsed it. Plus the way the last girl spoke was like she was writing a book not saying a real life event

[@editazilinskyte3681]

Yeah this also happens with people that say the same story a lot tho. They have rehearsed it in a way. Like the first girl clearly does she could be a story time youtuber lol.

[@camdenwyeth316]

@@editazilinskyte3681 Yeah it can go both ways

[@Hi-pf2sg]

I knew she was lying because she directly specified which year after hearing the investigator question the girl before her about years

[@angelarolph8367]

As soon as she said 2012 I knew it was over 🤣

[@lydianoell]

Kelsey said it was first semester junior year then said spring break

[@Zarrea]

Spring break occurs during the first semester-

[@rebeccaabrams3079]

Zarrea not in US colleges... fall semester has thanksgiving break, then you have winter break between semesters, then spring semester has spring break

[@nyashachingono1872]

@@rebeccaabrams3079 But she was going to school abroad so maybe she did have spring break in her first semester

[@mariaah3073]

@@rebeccaabrams3079 she wasn't in the US tho

[@ivanichianus]

Guy: Hey Jennifer: WOW CAN YOU STOP TRYING TO KIDNAP ME!!??? GET AWAY

[@legolas4457]

Guy: *continues to follow her after she said no*

[@katysteinhauer3489]

How to kidnap Jennifer: dress like a nerd

[@eirene5117]

Kate looks angry in the thumbnail and throughout the video

[@sajakamal2587]

Not really 😞

[@vivineon]

Yeah ikr

[@iBurnedaHouse]

Ok without looking at comments I'm gonna say that Kate is lying. Edit:YES I WAS RIGHT. In the first 58 secs if the video when Kate first says her experience she looks down and away from the investigators and when she finishes her sentence she blinks down which is an indicator that shes trying to remember her lie.

[@abraamgirgis9564]

Jon is insanely good at this... like i want to hire him for my life.

[@daisyromero7351]

I knew she was lying since the start. She took forever to title her story

[@uglyanimal5445]

Bruh, the Vancouver Olympics were in 2010 not 2012 5:56

[@azesh239]

Busted !

[@katiepowell3939]

That’s why he asked her DOB

[@stephaniephan9574]

Why is Kate so angry throughout the whole video lol

[@emab3376]

Something very similar happened to me when I was in China! It was me and three other blonde girlfriends, and we were walking through this back road to a market at sunset to meet the rest of our group. This big white van with three guys pulls over to the wrong side of the road to us and yells out that they’ll give us a ride. We said no SO many times before they drove off, and then they swung back around a few times to repeat the offer we refused and ended it by saying, “GO AWAY. We do NOT want a ride.” It was honestly so terrifying.

[@Phamsterdam]

2012 Vancouver Olympics 👀

[@tatamimi14]

Elizabeth looks like Jennifer Aniston and Drew Barrymore

[@freshavacado9984]

YES

[@aamahoney99]

I thought the middle one was lying bc she said it was her first semester of junior year which is aug/sept to dec in the US but then said she went to italy for spring break, which is in march

[@kpopstan8053]

3:27 haha i love how the background sounds changeddd too fit their stories😭😂😂

[@scoliosisqueen]

*investigators not investigator’s for the thumbnail.

[@cmoore6131]

Thank you.

[@heatherh]

THANK YOU.

[@Snowflake3981]

OMG RIGHT?!

[@camilakeller5256]

They changed it!! Haha

[@theasian24601]

When he said he has to disagree and go with Kate , it looks like she flashed disgust on her face. I don't think she likes him

[@zincsulfide8001]

Looook, I’m not saying there’s no kidnappers in Beijing, and I’m not saying she should go with them, but according to the way she described it, I’m pretty sure the people following her were not kidnappers, only illegal taxi drivers trying to get customers.

[@nesseihtgnay9419]

the dude was actually taking notes. Great on him guy power! 😆

[@narutotard100]

I've been binge watching these and have yet to see the blond haired P.I get a single one right lol Also, I thought the liar was the middle girl cause she said she travelled for her study abroad program and then later said she was an acting major and it didn't add up to me at first watch lol

[@redblue6836]

Just think that person who told a lie had to remember it all and just make it all natural...

[@madelewithluv]

sis said she was 22 in 2012 and then said she was born in 1986... girl you were 22 in 2008 LOLLL

[@zarisharshad6880]

Im a simple person. I see kelsey i click

[@heart0511]

i knew it was kate, she was over telling the story

[@TheCriminalViolin]

Yeah as soon as Kate said 2012 and at the time was 22, but she was born in '86, instantly she gave it away, and it killed me inside too. How can you allow yourself to screw up that badly haha?

[@kayduff5676]

Asking when she was born was an excellent question

[@joshuagarcia1392]

why does John look Jim from the office😂

[@teslac2231]

When she said her birth date was 1986, I immediately thought of when she said she was 22 in 2012... didn’t make any sense.

[@fartyfat6539]

9:11 John is adorable

[@ItsMe-jd8ou]

John was so done with the other investigator. She was giving them suggestive questions

[@ManXBoy]

The last lady looked soooo upset. I was waiting for her to crack up but damn.

[@allisonallen4215]

Dang Kate was seemed pretty upset when he questioned her lol chill girl

[@kaitygirl123]

I knew Kelsey wasn't lying because I knew she went on an exchange to the UK but was so interested in hearing her story

[@noname-wo4uo]

Ok but that girl looked guilty since the beginning

[@Sam-ew3zd]

Of course Kate was lying don't the PI know about green screens nowadays hahahahaha

[@layabayaooga]

6:43 when your friend is about to get called by your teacher but doesn't know the answer

[@tavaniquebraxton9954]

When he asked "what year were you born in?" I was confused as to how that related to anything and than he started to explain and I was like damn, he got her lol

[@ladyfoxwf1075]

I have only watched their intros but Kelsey seems to be the one lying so far. I could be completely wrong, let’s see. I forgot to update my opinions throughout the thing. Damn. It felt like both those girls were lying, the only one I believed was the first girl.

[@chrismedina1478]

0:49 you can tell it was kate "i was uh ...*looks down* lost , no pro but already felt too scripted...

[@Laralove14927]

Omg I’m from whistler! I knew she was lying because if she got lost it would have been in the news😂

[@leahdingman3535]

i knew it right away when she said she was born in 1986. In my head i was dying it ask what her age was now then he finally asked what year she was born

[@savanahmorales2135]

I was highkey like "why is Jennifer Aniston and Shia LaBeouf interrogating people?"

[@harrymason666]

Damn, John could investigate about my life whenever he wants to, IYKWIM.

[@katied.1791]

My guess: Is all three of them. I’m so good at this.

[@josiahmcelhinney1673]

That was clever. That twitch when he said he thought it was her bought me too

[@yaren_]

Honestly, as soon as Kate told them what the story was going to be about, I knew she was lying. Something just didn't click.

[@PouryaBigonah]

David fincher directed this video.

[@wherearetheavocados4873]

Pourya Bigonah you’re everywhere

[@juliastinson2049]

I WAS THINKING THE SAME THING OMG HAHAHHAHA I WAS BOUTTA SAY I SEE THIS GUY EVERYWHERE

[@rheaminerva7329]

I just love Kelsey 💕 we need more and longer scared buddies ughh

[@monomo5830]

I should’ve have sit in one of those chair because I’m great at lying and I’m also great at making up stories as I speak.

[@clarabraun1105]

Kelsey: Hi I'm Kelsey and I was searched by the Italian police John: So tell me about the shark

[@tc7750]

Yeah I knew it was her the moment she said Vancouver 2012 Olympics

[@peachypeppa]

Kate is on the verge of tears bro 🤣🤣🤣 you can tell lying makes her uncomfortable loll

[@gabrielanagy4165]

8:31 - 8:47 is me in math class

[@bettyboopbish6314]

People who close their eyes while they're talking are *SO ANNOYING*

[@Cemarimoney]

I wouldn’t have gotten it had John not explained that the details weren’t all aligned.

[@bvnny1379]

That little smirk at the end, he felt good 💖

[@gassimendoza3901]

His face at the end is priceless. he was so proud of himself

[@lincreates8724]

Ya I knew it was Kate because I was thinking the same thing😂

[@rjamkatel]

Who thinks John and Ian from Smosh look similar?

[@pencil6965]

that didn't sound like an "almost got kidnapped," just a persistent, desperate border-line creepy tour guide (a lot of those everywhere in the region)

[@kristeenam130]

Kelsey couldn't look them in the eyes . Like at all

[@IonicH3art]

I don't agree, pulling your phone out in those scenarios can easily provoke them!

[@haywoodjahblomy8026]

I knew it was her when she started mumbling in the beginning..watch it again and watch her mumble when she first talks

[@elfo5856]

You’re telling me they’re not all lying?

[@oliviabaron8496]

The cuts to johns face😂😂

[@MoonbyulKim]

My guess : The investigators are lying! *K let's start the video now and see how I did* Edit: Oh well...more luck next time

[@crazypig129]

Kate looked so mad when john caught her out lmfao im wheezing

[@namehere5675]

The gal on the right added too many details. The other two were a bit more organic. They didn't feel like they were trying hard to make the story fit.