Pro Chef Reacts.. To Vincenzo's Plate SPAGHETTI CARBONARA!

We are finally going to see how @vincenzosplate makes his spaghetti carbonara the traditional way and he is making it in Rome! It is a very good video and recipe so if you have tried it then let me know in the comments!
My Cooking Course: james-makinson-s-school.teach...
Vincenzo's Video: • How to Make SPAGHETTI ...
Jamie's Carbonara: • Pro Chef Reacts... To ...
🙏 HELP SUPPORT MY CHANNEL
👉 Single Donations: paypal.me/chefmakinson
👉KZbin Memberships: / @chefjamesmakinson
👉Become a Patreon: / chefjamesmakinson
📱FOLLOW US ON:📱
▶ Facebook: / explorebcn
▶ Instagram: / chef_jamesmakinson
▶ Twitter: / explorebcn
🛒MY KITCHEN EQUIPMENT:🛒
KNIVES
▶WÜSTHOF Knife Set: amzn.to/3IS94TD
▶Paring Knives: (can never have too many!) amzn.to/2S5y6Ia
▶MIYABI 5000 MCD SANTOKU: amzn.to/499sbmM
▶MASAMOTO KS 240mm Gyuto: amzn.to/3VAPyCq
STONES
▶Shapton Whetstones 1k 5k 12k: amzn.to/3VCFSYf
▶KING Whetstone Set 1000/6000 Grit: amzn.to/3VBAa99
POT AND PANS
▶STAUB Cast Iron 5-qt Cocotte: amzn.to/4ah0KJ1
▶STAUB Braiser 28cm: amzn.to/3vmso8r
▶T-fal Nonstick Pan set: amzn.to/4cxs0Vc
▶HexClad Hybrid Wok 12-Inch: amzn.to/3TRRaqa
▶HexClad Frying Pan 12-Inch: amzn.to/4cxS8PQ
▶Paella Pan!: amzn.to/2UQWT3s
OTHERS
▶Le Repertoire De La Cuisine in English: amzn.to/44fh7Tv
▶BlackBoard Plate: (Pizarra): amzn.to/3dAi3JS
▶John Boos Maple Cutting Board: amzn.to/4cyMnkU
▶Pepper mil: amzn.to/3JKpSMb
▶Microplane Fine Grater: amzn.to/3FQOwcN
▶Flim for wrapping food: amzn.to/42ztQjv
🎥CAMERA EQUIPMENT 🎥
CAMERAS
▶GH5 Panasonic: amzn.to/3IU4g03
▶Sony Alpha 6700: amzn.to/3PHcg8m
▶Sony NPFZ100 Z Rechargeable Battery: amzn.to/3PHy9Ep
LENS
▶Sigma 18-50mm F2.8: amzn.to/3PFiSE4
▶Sigma 16mm F1.4: amzn.to/43AjzEA
▶PolarPro 67mm Peter McKinnon Variable ND Filter: amzn.to/3PESPgo
▶Gobe 67mm UV Lens Filter: amzn.to/3TSfkkv
▶Gobe 55mm UV Lens Filter: amzn.to/3TSrqKs
MICROPHONES
▶RODE Wireless PRO Microphone System: amzn.to/3xewNdZ
▶Rode Pro+ Shotgun Mic: amzn.to/3xf94ug
OTHER
▶NEEWER Camera Tripod Monopod: amzn.to/3xf9b9a
▶Elgato Key Light 2800 lumens: amzn.to/4ac2svi
▶SanDisk 128GB SD Card: amzn.to/3TzrPAc
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
DISCLAIMER: This description contains affiliate links, which means that if you click on a product link, I will receive a small commission. This helps to support my channel and allows us to continue making awesome videos like this. Thank you for your support!
#spaghetticarbonara #carbonara #vincenzosplate

[@ChefJamesMakinson]

Don't Forget to Subscribe and see Jamie's Carbonara next! kzbin.info/www/bejne/r6OyeH9pepyDl6c

[@buttholasaurus99]

What about the last egg? What do you crack it against?

[@BobbysCuisine]

@@buttholasaurus99 good one! hahaha your head, if you are a funny chef ;)

[@buttholasaurus99]

@@BobbysCuisine well, I was expecting a response, but my wife thought I was clever for 2 seconds and said “ another egg, only one is going to break and be used”

[@BobbysCuisine]

@@buttholasaurus99 hahahahahaha clever wife you have mate. LOL good one!

[@AnthonyLeighDunstan]

@@buttholasaurus99 kept seeing these ornate wooden or ceramic eggs being sold in these posh homewares stores. I thought they were pretentious decorations mindless people put in bowls alongside vases of glass beads and plastic orchards. Turns out this is exactly what they’re for - cracking actual eggs. I keep mine with the other eggs and use it everyday.

[@vincenzosplate]

Ciao James, I always love watching your videos and every week I await to watch your reaction. This week I am surprised to see me making the original carbonara for you. Such a beautiful dish that doesn't stop evolving. It's funny because the old school carbonara has almost scrumbled eggs in it. In the last 20 years, Carbonara have been done just like this video you reacted to but in the last few years Carbonara evolved very quickly and it's even creamier. You should check out my 2021 carbonara version but be ready for my 2023 version because it will be the cremaiest one ever

[@mikeoxmaul837]

Can’t wait to see this year’s carbonara. how are you going to top the previous one?

[@lucatenkate3712]

Love your videos you've greatly improved my skills in the kitchen and my friends can agree with that for sure!

[@BigHalfSteps]

@@mikeoxmaul837 Just wait for the video.. I'm guessing he's going to show the technique of adding the rendered fat of guanciale to the bowl of egg pecorino mixture so it cooks the eggs that way, then add noodles. Adding the guanciale at the end as toppings. Pro: Creamiest version as of yet. Can be executed more easily. Lower risk of overcooking eggs / scrambling eggs. Contra: You have to use Guanciale/Pancetta. If you use Bacon you won't get nearly enough fat rendered to cook the egg mixture.

[@ChefJamesMakinson]

Hey Vincenzo! Thank you! I got a lot of requests to see this. haha I will have to check it out. I hope you are enjoying your time in Italy, I saw the video yesterday about the best cacio e pepe and the places you went to looked pretty good!

[@2sdd]

METAL ON NON STICK PAN? XD

[@a.v.y8331]

Vincenzo not only makes videos that demonstrates the most authentic italian techniques and ingredients, he also offers a bunch of alternatives and simplified methods for home cooking that deliver similar results. He's honestly great at both explaining the authentic version and possible home versions

[@ChefJamesMakinson]

Couldn't agree more!

[@lgninjalo]

You should have seen him at first. He toned it down a lot.

[@BeardedDanishViking]

Alternatives? An italian that can think outside the tradition box? Well that's a new one.

[@TheNuggzt3r]

However at the same time he complains about anyone who offers alternatives😅

[@peterbreis5407]

@@TheNuggzt3r Vincenzo shows sensible alternatives to achieve the real flavour not the random botch job most Americans do. They think they are "improving" the dish, instead they are just f@#king it up. Italian cooking is essentially very simple, the right ingredients and method are essential. You can play with it to a certain extent but it is really easy to screw it up with shortcuts and substitutions.

[@i_fuze_hostages6]

After all the bad it’s really nice to see someone like Vincenzo who is an absolute master of what he does

[@ChefJamesMakinson]

agreed!

[@itsmederek1]

He is not really a master. Italia Squisita has real masters, he is more of an enthousiast. Some recipes of his are more like a 7/10 rather than a 9 if you know what I mean. Still obviously a great guy with good content but he is no Luciano Monosillio, Ranveer Brar or Jaque Pepin of his field.

[@ruedelta]

@@itsmederek1 To be fair that is just the nature of KZbin as a platform. Even Wang Gang, who is cited a lot by other KZbin chefs for Chinese food, is actually just a good intermediate-level chef, with tens if not hundreds of thousands of chefs at his level. Masters are not likely to do videos - they are generally too busy for that. But I think that label is a bit unfair and unnecessary anyways. We will likely never be good enough to outgrow the tutelage of someone like Vincenzo.

[@dzhsck5310]

@@ruedelta That's not true. If you have an editor it makes the timing a lot easier. There are plenty of master chefs on KZbin, like Wang Gang. Vincenzo is a home-chef. His recipes are for traditional Italian cooking you or me can make at home. He definitely is not a master. KZbin itself has plenty of actual kitchen chefs that make videos.

[@itsmederek1]

@@ruedelta My point is exactly because this level of mastership is rare on youtube we should appreciate it when we can see it like in ranveer brar or Luciano monosillio and reserve that label for people like them. I am not saying that Vincenzo needs to be a master at all before we can properly appreciate him, he is a fantastic content creator with solid general knowledge of Italian cuisine. Your point about Wang Gang I do find to be a little bit non-representative though because China doesn't have youtube which highly restricts access to high level Sichuan cooking content limiting it to Chinese platforms. People like Jaque-Pepin, Marco-Pierre White and even James Makinso(Spanish Recipes) can be considered masters to an extent and there is tons of content on yt from them. To be clear I mostly agree with everything you say this is just my clarification of earlier statements

[@FyremaelGlittersparkle]

Having made carbonara based off Chef Vincenzo’s instructions from that video, I can attest to how well it turned out. My wife was raving about it after I made it, and said it might be her new favorite pasta dish. Vincenzo did such a good job explaining all that steps that I, who had never made this before, was moving so efficiently through the steps that my wife didn’t believe I was cooking it for the first time.

[@ChefJamesMakinson]

That is awesome!

[@stephanewantiez164]

@@ChefJamesMakinson same here, and it was perfect! :P I live in Montreal, and I can often find guancale and peccorino, otherwise I take some pancetta with a mix of peccorino and parmigiano - because with pancetta and only peccorino, it's too salty

[@AnnaWielguszewska-el4bm]

I was doing Carbonara from this recipe, but with the old video. No guanciale as I couldn't find it near me, so I've used pancietta. As a European, I was using a cream (please don't kill me guys🤣) before. Never again. I've made proper carbonara with Vincenzo's video and it ends up amazing and delicious. I've even send a photo of it to my Italian friend and he approved 😉

[@ChefJamesMakinson]

good to hear! :) haha

[@Twisted_Logic]

Vincenzo is always a joy to watch. His exuberance for authentic Italian cuisine is absolutely infectious

[@giusepperana6354]

I followed this exact video 2 times and it was amazing. Tastes nothing like any "Carbonara" I've ever eaten. Really made me think about how many meals I've eaten in my life that I haven't actually eaten because they were done entirely wrong. A bit like that Matrix scene where the kid goes "but how does the Matrix know what chicken tastes like? Maybe the matrix is doing it wrong".

[@ChefJamesMakinson]

I'm glad to hear that!

[@ayajade6683]

This dish is one that has region variations that causes so many fights I've legit watched my nona and her sil fight it out so many times

[@giusepperana6354]

@@ayajade6683 What kind of differences?

[@ayajade6683]

@@giusepperana6354 type of cheese where it's the same type just a different variety often a more common local variety last fight was over if Manchego Cheese and Grana Padano goes with the pecorin, type of egg used sil mentioned their area uses duck eggs as they were more common than chickens until recently, which fatty cut of pork gives it the best flavor Nona's region uses pork check and a small bit of pork belly, what extra spices goes in there,etc.

[@Vittrich]

@@ayajade6683 my aunts took the competition to another level and had bake offs around christmas every year for well over 20 years, while every year they made more and more different types of cookies, went up almost in the fifties. it went so bad that they actually started in november to top each other, using all 5 weeks of their vaccation time just for this. one day one of my uncles found about 50!!kg molded cookies in the basement from last christmas and he finally put a nail in the coffin, because of the food and money waste.

[@ConstanzeWeber]

I've had so many carbonara fails over the years, watched Vincenzo's video and I've never failed since!! It's a brilliant method!

[@MisterMaster4life]

Chef Vincenzo is the real deal. He's super kind, explains it perfectly well and I tried a lot of his dishes, they all are super authentic and super tasty. Nothing but love for Vincenzo👏

[@spenym14]

I really have to give Vincenzo a thank you because he really educated me on Italian cooking and of course Carbonara. It was perfect when I went to Italy last summer and knew about the different dishes and how they were prepared. The Carbonara I had in Modena was absolutely delicious

[@ronin47-ThorstenFrank]

What I love with Vincenzo is that he exactly knows what he is doing and explains it!

[@nonnamacdeah1950]

Dear Chef James: This is the first time I've seen one of your videos, and it was truly a pleasure to watch. Your voice, the delivery of remarks is gentle and incredibly kind. I always enjoy Chef Vincenzo's videos. Your clear understanding and respect for him warms my heart. I look forward to watching your other videos. I'm now a new subscriber. Much love and light to you and yours always from the beautiful east coast of Canada. ❤️🕊🇨🇦🕊❤️

[@ChefJamesMakinson]

Wow, thank you! it means a lot to hear that!

[@conaldeugenepeterson2147]

A collab between you two would be great. Vincenzo seems always down for collabs too. I think you guys would get along really well.

[@ChefJamesMakinson]

I think so too!

[@YouWillNeverKnowMan]

Yes, let's make it happen!

[@VerhoevenSimon]

I really love these reaction videos, there's so much more to learn from these than professionals reacting to Jack's cooking videos.

[@ChefJamesMakinson]

Glad you like them! :)

[@hugobranca]

I use two eggs per person, well one yolk and one whole. I also clean the guincale more, the outside have been exposed to a lot. But otherwise the exact technique.

[@Zoboomafoobar]

If you're talking about August the Duck, I think that also has its place. When you learned to drive, you didn't do it in a Lamborghini! Sure, it's pandering to the masses but it's not necessarily a bad thing. Chacun à son goût! 👊🏽

[@VerhoevenSimon]

@@Zoboomafoobar more in the sense of: pointing out things to adapt in a Jack video is like shooting fish in a barrel.

[@vhfgamer]

Vincenzo is one of the good ones. I'm glad you listened to my suggestion and gave one of his videos a try. He's inspired me to do all sorts of neat novel things in my kitchen that I wouldn't have ever done before.

[@pjacklam]

Your tips, tricks and humour adds so much value! Thanks! There are so many youtubers whose reaction videos are just stupid faces and comments. Yours is in a totally different league - so educational!

[@ChefJamesMakinson]

Thank you Peter!

[@wl9663]

This was the first carbonara recipe I learned that produced consistent results each time, and results that were consistent with what one expects from an authentic carbonara. Consistency between cooks seems like a silly thing to note, but prior to this video, I had some pre-KZbin cookbooks whose recipes just never got the correct taste/aroma/appearance, and certainly not the same ones every trial. I also really love the traditional take on this, partially because I find historical recipes fascinating and partially because I’m from Asia where traditional recipes are still prominent in the house. It’s great that he acknowledges that there’s no right answer with the eggs, given that- as you obviously know as an accomplished chef yourself 😂 restaurants now use specific proportions of whole eggs to egg yolks for a certain level of creaminess to heaviness of the sauce. Glad you reacted to this one! 😊

[@axiomist4488]

I dont mind your frequent interruptions, because they are made to teach and in a soft tone of voice. Theyre never annoying, unlike somebody else we know ! You dont put people down, just state your corrections. Very nice . The carbonara looks delicious. I can see why people think it contains cream. It's amazing what can be done with just eggs and cheese !!!

[@darrenaquilina1403]

Vincenzo is the best, such a humble, honest and passionate guy. Respect to him!

[@stevieg4201]

Hello James, Vincenzo is an excellent chef in my opinion, as you know to Italians everywhere, Carbonara is a staple to Italian food, Vincenzo has shown many people the proper way to do many things, he’s also no afraid to critique his own work, once he went to Bologna to see how they make Bolognese traditionally, he made a video with David Berti on a proper Bolognese, he learned a few things himself, so I guess what I’m saying is he’s not full of himself, he too is always ready to learn. Great chef. And anyone who adds cream to Carbonara shouldn’t be cooking Carbonara, call it something else if you’re going to do these things, these recipes are important, god bless. 🙏🏽

[@MorrigaMay]

I always learn so much from your videos. I really get a lot out of both your reaction and recipe videos. Thank you so much for sharing your knowledge with us. 🙂

[@ChefJamesMakinson]

Glad you like them!

[@KuldarJ]

I tried Vincenzo's carbonara recipe and I have to say it came out really good, it actually was the first time I'd ever eaten carbonara in my life, so I decided to compare it to a carbonara from a local restaurant, I honestly couldn't eat it, from the first bite I wanted to throw up, it just felt like I was eating heavy cream with some spaghetti.

[@Cr4z33_YT]

I remember my childhood in Switzerland in the 80's where Carbonara was tagliatelle with smoked ham, cream and grated cheese on top... lol what a crap!

[@ohger1]

@@Cr4z33_YT Sounds like something Olive Garden would make..

[@texasstadium]

All I can say is that I follow Vincenzo's instructions on many dishes and they turn out perfect. He explains things in simple terms and uses the classic ingredients. This old Sicilian appreciates learning new tricks.

[@markaiwa]

Followed this recipe a few times now and it’s just fantastic! And I’m always keen to see the comments and tips from James to make these recipes even more successful. Thanks guys.

[@Balkirat_Singh]

I really appreciate the video. Love the insight and your views on the recipe. Would love to see both you and Vincenzo collab. Maybe even a friendly cook-off?!

[@ChefJamesMakinson]

Maybe one day! :)

[@1dgram]

Insight, we're not inciting violence here!

[@Nesot]

@@1dgram was about the same thing

[@1dgram]

@@Nesot it's fixed now

[@IronHead42]

We love Vincenzo and his cooking. Simple and elegant. I'm currently doing his authentic Bolognese sauce and it's only one hour into the reducing stage. Damn I'm hungry...

[@andronovm]

Thanks for your reaction video to Vincenzo carbonara. Out of many recipes of carbonara on youtube , this recipe and video is one of the best . It’s easy to follow , Vincenzo gives a lot of tips and it’s quite authentic . Your commentary added value to this video indeed . So kudos, Chef .

[@attorneyrobert]

I learned so much from this video when it first came out. Vincenzo has a skill for easily explaining cooking concepts.

[@Sheilla357]

Carbonara is one of my family staples. It is ALWAYS worth the extra effort. I make mine with pepper bacon as Guanciale is difficult to get where I am. I'm trying to get my local smoke house to make it but they can't seem to understand the concept. The hickory smoked pepper bacon adds and extra depth to the dish and you don't have to worry about adding additional pepper to the mix. NOTE to home cooks, always add more pasta water than you think you should. The noodles really absorb the sauce and it can become very "dry" very quickly. That soup Vincenzo showed you is the right amount. Few things are worse than having a dry carbonara when the pasta water is right there for the addition.

[@NathanMN]

I've made carbonara based on a different Vincenzo's Plate video; he has at least 3 different carbonara videos. It turned out great, although I could find neither guanciale nor pecorino at the time. I recently found pecorino in a Whole Foods, so I'll be making carbonara again soon, albeit with pancetta.

[@hokudadog7637]

Thank you for this video! I enjoy both you and Vincenzo on KZbin, you both love the food and teaching

[@edjarrett3164]

Vincenzo’s cooking it is spot on. I grew up in Italy. I’ve spent time in Rome. His cooking technique and product is perfect. I’m a cook, so I embrace awesome cooks and their execution.

[@jeffg6479]

I followed Vincenzo's tutorial and for me it was a pleasure to see that my family liked it so much. Thanks for your valuable comments 😄

[@ChefJamesMakinson]

Great to hear!

[@RFGSwiss]

i really disliked carbonara for a long time. then i saw an italian chef make it on youtube some years ago - and tried it. to my surprise it was very good and i was confused why i disliked it for so long. then i ordered some in a restaurant and they mangled it with cream and parsley. this was the real eyeopening moment for me. it seems, in switzerland many middletier restaurants do it this way, especially for lunch, when they have to bang out 50 dishes at once. (this i learned from this video, thanks James!). carbonara is now a staple in my own kitchen. my kids dont like pecorino, maybe its to strong or its because its made of sheepmilk. i go with parmigiano reggiano (i know, Vincenzo wouldnt be pleased :-) but its still waaaayyyy better than all the premade stuff.

[@aingealtara1479]

.. This is the first time ever I've seen a Chef so calm, both in body and tone of voice, and even smiling too 😳☺️ how nice is that.. .. Thank you so very much for the explanations 🤗

[@ChefJamesMakinson]

Wow, thank you!

[@JavierGarcia-bd6kw]

Dude I just saw the clip of your food. And from one chef to another it looks so good❤! I've been doing intermittent fasting and I can't watch your videos on the days I fast all day. I see your plating and I can do it. Especially when I have your recipe on making it. Please take the compliment as it is. Your food is beautiful.

[@Therd23]

After following Vincenzo's recipe for carbonara once, I'm never doing it differently. Its amazing and buying guanciale and pecorino was Worth every penny

[@jimmyclement08]

I’ve followed a number of Vincenzo’s tutorials. They are great. This one is my favourite. Glad he’s led me to your channel.

[@gigey]

During covid lockdown I got the urge to cook so much from home! For a long time I stuck with a lot of Japanese cuisine, but then after, Vincenzo introduced me to Italian cuisine. Love his cooking and your reactions!

[@sigmablock]

You should do a pro chef reacts to Vincenzo's Carbonara series, he has done several different ones ever since this video, and has also done reaction vids so it will be interesting to hear your perspective. :)

[@ChefJamesMakinson]

Great suggestion!

[@thesausage351]

Vince is a really really nice guy, in the school holidays he goes around different supermarkets and teaches kids how to cook, my girls have cooked with him and they love him. He really is a genuinely nice dude.

[@user-kx6qw2nd8v]

I’m so glad you chose this video to react to - out of all the carbonara recipes I’ve made this is the best one ❤

[@brianmurphy4702]

You and Vincenzo my favorite chefs. You two are a delight to watch and so informative. Thank you.

[@LexioLTG]

Since I learned how to cook Carbonara, thanks to Vincenzo, It's been my absolute favorite dish to make and I constantly impress guests with it. I also love cooking it for my own, and I try to keep it different everytime, sometimes I use whole eggs, sometimes only yolks, sometimes I make it more delicate, others I go crazy with flavor. I've tried with spanish pancetta, which is very salty, etc. I just love that you can cook the sauce at the same time that the pasta is cooking, you don't have to spend hours doing it if you have the ingredients at hand. I can't thank Vincenzo enough, trully.

[@maximesteinebrunner9941]

vincenzo has the best italian cooking channel in the world by far!

[@leightoncooke]

Vincenzo is one of the very best Italian chefs who makes videos in English. This is a really good carbonara recipe that I have tried and tested. Thanks for adding some very useful commentary., and yes folks, please don’t add cream!

[@Kevin-qo1zx]

Great video as always, Chef James. I follow Vincenzo’s carbonara recipe at home. I love it every time. Guancale is quite difficult to get where I live so I’ve always used pancetta, but I managed to get a hold of some last week and can’t wait to try it with that.

[@jackdorsey4850]

As long as you keep showing chefs of a high caliber I will love to watch thank you chef

[@KamilazWarszawy]

I came here to your channel just because I'm following Vincenzo's channel and I enjoyed so much his reaction to your reaction to his mushroom risotto video that I had to see some of your other videos. I appreciate soooooo muuuuch the way you explain in detail everything! It's amazing! I see a lot of other chefs or "chefs" on you tube that do a really average and inaccurate job but you are so calm, precise, on point with everything you say that's a pleasure to listen to you. I'm Polish but I'm living in Italy since I was a child and I really know Italian food and how Italians really care about the "correct" way to prepare their traditional recepies. I am too very into the traditional way of making the original recipes, I prepare the ragù bolognese according to the authentic recipe that has been registered in 1982 at the Camera di commercio in Bologna, for example, and I love on the other hand making the authentic Polish dishes that I've learned from my granny (I was "employed" in her kitchen, even before being able to reach the countertop, as her "sous chef"). Now I really appreciate your professional and very nice to listen explanation of how to do many things in a "pro chef" way. Really good job. I can't wait to see more.

[@ChefJamesMakinson]

I hope you enjoy the rest of my content! :)

[@LuigiChirco]

I like your reactions because they are always honest and they way you explain the cooking techniques are precious and well explain. Hugs from Italy 🇮🇹

[@ChefJamesMakinson]

Thank you Luigi!

[@aaronvincentlee3490]

I love both your content and Vincenzo's!! Keep up the good work, Chef James! I learn so much from both of you!!

[@ChefJamesMakinson]

Awesome! Thank you!

[@syx3s]

been watching vincenzo for years. when someone loves something as much as he loves cooking pasta (and everything to do with cooking pasta) it's easy to have the utmost faith in the end product.

[@Fernando-ox5mo]

Very nice video. Vincenzo was great and your thoughtful comments really added value to the experience.

[@akira_ariga]

This is so wholesome, I love this Vincenzo reminds me of my uncle a lot, too 😊

[@NeoclassicalRadagast]

James, you're really objective and it's nice to see someone who clearly knows his stuff being that way.

[@ChefJamesMakinson]

Thank you Nick!

[@ruffshots]

After a few days of watching both you and Vincenzo reacting to some less than stellar cooking, I'm now watching back to back, Vincenzo reacting to Luciano Monosilio's carbonara, and now you reacting to Vincenzo's own carbonara, and it's refreshing to see proper techniques and the respect it generates. I will say for Vincenzo, both in this video and his own reactions to Luciano's carbonara that he may not quite understand tempering, or doesn't explain it particularly well. Luciano uses a double boiler method (bain-marie), which I hadn't seen before, but seems to be more foolproof. Also, I'd add that pasta water into the egg mix a bit at a time too, but I'm very excited to try this, assuming I can find some decent guanciale around me.

[@jamesyamamoto5155]

I use this recipe to make carbonara about once a month, and I've made it for friends and family several times. It's by far the best and most authentic recipe I've found, and it tastes fantastic. I've also made several of his other recipes, and they're all delicious.

[@brainfreeze1925]

It's fun to watch a chef add commentary to another chef's creations. Thanks for the video James.

[@ChefJamesMakinson]

My pleasure

[@CRB9000]

We've followed Vincenzo's tutorials for a number of dishes, Bolognese sauce, putanesca, and several others. They have all turned out wonderful.

[@jerquake943]

Using the right ingredients and controlling the heat. That's what an around 80 years old real Italian nonna taught me in the 70's. Today, I am still following her recipe.Only use the yolk, Vicenzo had it wrong there. During WW2 they'd use the entire egg because there won't be a waste that time. But, the time I learned it, WW2 was over, So only the yolk was used, and with the remaining egg white they made a dessert.

[@polkhigh2317]

love James and Vincenzo's channels I have learned sooo much from you both

[@ChefJamesMakinson]

I'm glad to hear!

[@the-chillian]

This was the video I learned how to make carbonara from, and now you've reminded me of it I remember I haven't actually made any in awhile. Maybe tonight. It's pretty easy to find pecorino around here, but I haven't seen guanciale anywhere so I've always ended up using pancetta. I found it very easy to follow this as a tutorial, and not to brag but it came out perfectly the first time just by doing what he says. I think it was for the sake of this recipe that I finally went and bought a microplane so I could grate the pecorino fresh.

[@ChefJamesMakinson]

I'm very glad to hear that! carbonara made well is delicious! :)

[@arnoschaefer28]

The instructions are really on point, it makes it easy to get the texture just right. I was surprised that it did not taste like I was expecting. Both the guanciale and the pecorino are relatively mild. I assume I had "carbonara" with bacon before, and that has a much more pronounced flavor. I like this recipe and will be making it again.

[@marksimpson2321]

Absolutely brilliant content! This is what KZbin is perfect for! James introduced me to Vincenzo and his comments really contributed to understanding cooking and Carbonara!

[@ChefJamesMakinson]

Thank you Mark!

[@amanacatandhisdog8836]

Thanks chef James. I love how both you and Vincenzo are so passionate about food and techniques. Great job as always. Vincenzo has some great authentic Italian pizzas if you care to react to them. I really enjoy your reactions and background info.

[@ChefJamesMakinson]

Glad you enjoy it! :)

[@user-ll6ne6zd6s]

I have made this carbonara many times and served it to true Italian guests with excellent reception . I have used pancetta in a pinch, but really really recommend guanciale if you can find it. It is hard to find in my market: Denver, Colorado, USA. The best part of this video is Vincenzo as he is animated, entertaining and great at what he does.

[@ChefJamesMakinson]

yes he did do a great job! sometimes it is not easy to get the exact ingredients

[@Profetorum]

Great vid as always. Just a thing: adding salt to water increases its concentration leading to more heat needed to heat. The boiling temp is still 100°C, it just needs more heat to increase temp!

[@pedro3131]

One of the first cooking videos I watched on YT, cool to see a pros reaction. Have tried this at home and it's delicious and pretty easy to pull off.

[@ChefJamesMakinson]

good to hear! :)

[@trucid2]

Looks delicious! I've been making a lot of egg custard as a dessert, and the pecorino egg sauce follows a similar process: temper it then cook until it thickens. I'll give it a try using ingredients I have, like anchovies or bacon.

[@mareneaufrance5096]

I like that James allows the reviewed chef to explain how he cooks, then James adds to the explanation and returns to the video. James might like to watch "Gordon is left flustered after a Greek grandma criticizes his food."

[@ChefJamesMakinson]

Thank you! Haha that sounds like a funny video!😂

[@MrVvulf]

That sounds amazing. Anything that backfoots Gordon promises to be fun.

[@CrabBaskets]

Came across your channel today with the reaction video to Alex's Paella, and have checked out several of your other videos and really enjoying them all! I am learning so much from your commentary and really loving the content! ❤

[@ChefJamesMakinson]

I'm so glad to hear! :)

[@m0shman]

Hey James, watching your videos for a while now. Learned a lot! thanks for that. love your vidoes, keep it up!

[@ChefJamesMakinson]

Awesome, thank you!

[@jean-claudelaurin4180]

I'm not a cook at all. But I watched this video of Vincenzo's plate and did the recipe with pancetta because I can't find guanciale where I live. And it was quite a success. Vincenzo is a very good teacher and his enthusiasm is contagious.

[@alwin9616]

I stopped watching other chefs when it comes to Italian recipes. Vincenzo is a gift that keeps on giving

[@countryboy8870]

Def added value to the video, for someone like me who only cooks because of my love for eating, occasionally the 'why?' they do things makes me wonder, the way that you explained it brings huge clarity. I have cooked this one though used the instructions from Grandma Gina (Buon-A-Petitti on youtube) a while ago. I absolutely love it with the Romano cheese, however being in Australia i find they dumb it down with cream a lot .... mabee for the reasons you mention ... also may be because it is quite strong and unusual for that sort of cheese to be tasted here, i am not sure. I have it per the above recipe (but use bacon :D because its easier here) and also my mum loves like this so we serve ours first, then i have to add cream to 'thin' it for my wife and dad as it is to strong for them. Thanks for what you do mate.

[@BruceRylan]

I really enjoyed this video this is the way to learn! *Fabulous.👏*

[@ChefJamesMakinson]

I'm glad to hear!

[@igordasunddas3377]

Thank you! It was a great review, not just funny, but helpful.

[@allierod1366]

What a pleasure watching you cooking! My mom was Italian, born in Rome! ❤🎉

[@user-po5qy8jj1m]

My son and I make this recipe with half parmigiana and half pecorino and it is PERFECT! It’s our go to recipe for once a month family dinner ❤️

[@erwintimmerman6466]

I tried this exact recipe and apart from burning my first batch of guanciale (even on low heat) so I had to use the batch I had bought for the next meal, it went very well and everyone loved it! Still hard not to let it cool off too much though because when adding the cream you turn off the heat and it cools from there. If you then put it on cold plates then you're eating a lukewarm dish. I need to get me a plate warmer for this one.

[@FerrisFlyer]

I really like the use of the full egg here as well as the tempering step. Vincenzo seems like a cool cat too!

[@danishdude6750]

After I found Vincenzo's channel some years ago, I've always used his recipe for Carbonara as well as his recipe for Bucatini all'Amatriciana. Both are really good

[@user-lo6ge1uu1l]

Absolutely love Vincenzo’s Plate and your reviews for deeper insight on his specialty. Looking forward to future reviews on Vinenzo’s cooking!

[@ChefJamesMakinson]

More to come!

[@ryann8806]

oo just found this channel, instant fan. i cant get enough videos where the person breaks down the WHY of what is done

[@ChefJamesMakinson]

thank you!

[@bigboi980]

You are a gift to the world chef! Very nice video on onother one of my favorite chefs! Very well received my man!

[@ChefJamesMakinson]

I appreciate that!

[@ttpetio]

This tutorial by Vincenzo was the reason why I became so interested in Italian cuisine! 😇

[@ChefJamesMakinson]

Really?? Very nice!! Italian cuisine is delicious but not that many people fully understand Spanish cuisine both use a lot of olive oil but Italy is all about the pasta

[@chickensoup9869]

Keep it up. Love your explanations for every step. ❤

[@ChefJamesMakinson]

Thank you so much! 😀

[@joemcnealy8099]

Thanks for the sincere review of Vincenzo’s method. I have made both of Vincenzo’s versions of Carbonara. The only difference between the two is 3 yokes plus an 1 whole egg versus 4 whole eggs. I found that the 3 yoke version is much richer with more impactful flavors from the cheese, pepper and pancetta (never have I come across pig cheeks in New England). In addition the more textured the pasta is the far more efficient it is in absorbing the flavors from a pan made sauce.

[@SneakyMezz]

I'm cooking with this recipe for almost 2 years! Love it :)

[@ChefJamesMakinson]

That's awesome!

[@rrod8323]

I've made this recipe a few times and I love it. I've tried this dish with guanciale and pancetta. Guanciale is definitely the way to go, and I always go out of my way to buy the guanciale at a local Italian market. I highly recommend this recipe. As you can see in the video its super fast to make, basically a couple of minutes longer than it takes to cook the pasta.

[@ChefJamesMakinson]

Sounds great! :)

[@MiniatureMasterClass]

Vincenzo is a fantastic teacher. You follow his videos and end up serving authentic Italian food.

[@ChefJamesMakinson]

😉

[@flatophall]

excellent!! I love the format with Chef Jamie. If I were the hotel manager I would have said, "Get Out!!", terrible, but hand me the pan with the remainder of the carbonara." haha

[@bogdanmiinea6262]

I did try this recipe and now is my main Carbonara recipe.❤

[@anothervu]

This is one of the videos where I learned how to make Carbonara. Seeing it again now, I can see where I can improve my technique. Going to try to duplicate this today for lunch!

[@vsimileac]

I've tried Vincenzo's recipe and since do the pasta carbonara only this way. Actually, all my pasta recipes (amatriciana, putanesca, tuna and etc) are Vincenzo's recipes. Never failed. Also different plates like zucchini fritters, lamb shanks and etc. Vincenzo is an amazing cook and Italian kitchen ambassador.

[@JohnnyC10071959]

05:35 Boiling time. One issue that is rarely addressed in cooking videos is altitude. Distilled water boils at 212°F / 100°C at SEA LEVEL. I live just above 7200 feet (2195 meters) sea level and water boils at about 198°F / 92.5° - significantly cooler which extends the boiling time needed to achieve the same texture of the pasta. I enjoyed your comments video as the underlying video is the one I used to learn to make good carbonara.

[@bobpiazza4618]

James, you have become my absolute favorite chef! Keep up the wonderful videos!

[@ChefJamesMakinson]

Thank you! Will do!

[@iron_side5674]

There is actually some industrially made pasta that has the rougher texture. Usually labeled "Al Bronzo", supposedly made in bronze casts.

[@tylerprior5966]

@vincenzosplate is always a great source of entertainment and an education in Italian cuisine for home cooks. As always, James, your insight is always on point and thoughtful!

[@ChefJamesMakinson]

Thank you!