Producer Reacts to BTOB "Beautiful Pain"

Join PD for this lengthy and emotional breakdown in this reaction and review of "Beautiful Pain" by BTOB!
Help support Form of Therapy by subscribing to us on Patreon! / formoftherapy
Subscribe to Form of Therapy for more future Reaction videos & let us know in the comments down below what else you'd like to see!
#BTOB #Beautiful_Pain #Hour_Moment #비투비 #아름답고도_아프구나
Follow us & stay up to date
Facebook: / formoftherapy
Twitter: / formoftherapy
Instagram: / formoftherapy
Follow the cast
@formoftherapy

[@randoma6455]

Funniest thing is when Hyunsik barely finished his first line but you already scored it 10 out of 10. BTOB only produce masterpieces😉

[@choizuey8683]

Truly💙

[@humziahn6238]

3 seconds into music *"10 OUT OF 10"* Me at every BTOB's song

[@IllaLuna17]

That’s why Eunkwang said before, “We BTOB sells emotion, not albums. For the sake of dreams of these young people.”

[@alexryder8125]

you really want to make me cry. new melody here and I've been catching up with a lot, and I've just watched a bunch of Eunkwang related videos from his last concert before enlistment and as I watch i'm just bawling my eyes out and your comment now just... it's surprising just how much BTOB got to me. God, I am so head over heels for these beagles already!

[@IllaLuna17]

Alexandra-Ioana Rusu now let’s be faithful to our boys, it makes me sad how this guys slowly been going up and up. And now that they are doing better they have to enlist. Eunkwang just said that is his fear being forgotten by the fans because they won’t be together until after 5 years. Minhyuk is leaving in January or February to enlist, Changsub is next. Let’s wait faithfully for them! I know that last year and this year a lot of new fans have join the fandom the only thing I can say is WELCOME and please stay faithful to our guys. This guys deserve it! :(

[@khadijaennebly3678]

I ve became a melody a month now.I love them so much .

[@123melody]

New Melody here guys. Why am I so late :((((

[@amandaatenasgomes7803]

Prissy Meadows loved that

[@yna8125]

"That was a masterpiece." INDEED!! THIS IS ONE OF THE MOST GENUINE REACTION VIDEOS EVER. THANK YOU SO MUCH!

[@myssmind7106]

Me: Ok letsssgett- PD: **gives 10/10 in 31 sec of the music video** Me: ??!!

[@Yino_lemmon]

97Sasa Shades but I orally feel him

[@ashamaritzardellavista7395]

😂😂😂me to .that was like 😱

[@noragrace5926]

Nani?!!

[@1haniestan278]

The emotion expressed and shown through the words and facials is absolutely incredible. It is truly beautifully painful when it's painfully beautiful.

[@ZeneraKei]

I loved the song, but didn't even notice most of the things you mentioned in the MV, now I appreciate this MV so much more.

[@hanniefrei]

true.. thats why PDNim is truly the only KPOP reaction that matters. its honest and you learn about a lot of things that we usually missed or dont know about the MV.

[@고통아름다운]

btob they are not making music they are making art and that's the fact

[@kodzukent]

i love ur icon

[@MindOfMando]

The song is amazing. Haven’t watched your vid yet but I know this is about to be good 👌🏽. Edit: love learning new things and hearing about symbolism that I don’t catch on to from others. I expected nothing less from this review and was low key waiting for it 😅

[@lucianrochasanchez8774]

I was thinking about you!!! Did you hear that Changsub's going to launch a solo album? I hope you get excited as I did!!!!!

[@mariannedimla50]

Omg these two melodudes!

[@drewmelody5321]

Hey mando, i love all your reaction about btob too, waiting for changsub solo album, shall we?

[@MindOfMando]

@@drewmelody5321 but of course :]

[@shuchi281]

4:23 i always love ppl's reaction to this part lmao hyunsik's killer part leaves no survivors

[@fraiseaumiel9956]

Me too

[@flordeliz-joypansag7825]

Deym right!!

[@NathaliaSilva-lt2ki]

Thanks for the reaction. Btob is on another level, they are able to produce their own songs and sing perfectly. The genus BTOB is not Ballad, but rather BTOB.

[@alysslee5316]

You should hear all the side track on this special album.

[@afiqahazmir]

EXACTLY!

[@tikaa0916]

I really like Please!!!

[@bryama2129]

Yes...friend, butterfly and please are so amazing

[@anschy19]

please is the best out of all of the songs inside it

[@indrifebrianihartono4215]

I didn't realize I watch it all till the end (i usually closed it after the video reacting). I have never wrote a comment before, but this reaction makes me want to. First of all, I LOvE it when you nerd out about the MV (I rarely see you do that anyway). I stayed because I didn't actually pay attention when I watch the MV cz I'm too focused on the music, and with your reaction it gains me mOOOOOre respects towards BTOB. I really wish you could do more dive in video reaction (not only to the music).

[@fionarchive]

💙

[@kmbetito]

A clean and calm reaction .. love it

[@xcynder6000]

Like you, I don't like most of the ballads except when it's BTOB, they really have something special ! And I loved the acting when I watched the MV but I didn't realize there were so much symbolism and your video was really interesting I liked it !

[@AudroneFiodorenko]

even the Instrumental track of Beautiful Pain is so good.. I'm glad the company really invested into this video.. masterpiece song deserves masterpiece MV.

[@ericksonsouza6479]

Cube its finally doing a good job with their artists.

[@karen2586]

Why am I an emotional wreck??? I'm crazy crying over this reaction video!!! Everytime you say a word I was like, What the fudge! Same PD, SAME!!! Thank you for appreciating the quality of music BTOB has. Thank you for always making Melodies feel there is someone who understands why we love BTOB and why we are proud of them. Thank you so much! We are always grateful. Thanks for giving time reacting to their videos. Especially this song. You know this song, this comeback is a fucking Beautiful Pain!😭 Thanks PD!!!

[@myedelossantos9269]

That was a masterpiece. BTOB is a master class in the art of the ballad - Thank Youuuu!!!💙

[@andhiniretno3886]

FINALLY!!! I seriously thought you weren't going to react to this and im so happy like I just fangirled to a reaction video lmao, thank you so much for reacting to btob!!

[@kianayusthiakiran]

it’s delivered the emotion well all of the music, lyrics, and the mv to. And the emotion that given is stable even after watch it for the second and third and more . their vocal even without main vocal was exactly at main vocal rate, and the rap it’s really complete this. this is art! like you said this is 10/10 🙌🏻

[@jda7386]

It did not even feel lengthy to me. This review is so rich so informative... i watched the music video a lot and you still managed to surprise me with a lot of symbolism that was pointed out. Definitely my fave reaction video. This is the reaction video that actually touched on not just the song, but how the MV itself as been cleverly created to totally convey its message. Love love how you geeked out here. Lmao. 17mins is a short time srsly thank you soo much 💙

[@hanniefrei]

true.. 17mins is still short if its about people honestly praising our boys hardwork lol

[@nurizzati584]

have been waiting for your reaction video and YASSSSS YOUR REACTIONS ARE SOOOO LIKE MINE HAHAHAHA as expected, btob never disappoint people with their music 💙💙

[@melonnn233]

that back and forth transition from cold to warm lighting representing the past and the present in Changsub's scene is what I liked most about this MV, so I'm glad to see someone appreciating it. overall the MV was so well done and I can definitely say it became one of my favorite BTOB MVs so far, what's so exciting about being a BTOB fan is that they never fail to surprise you each comeback and that they've always got something new to show you.

[@МаринаТрайгель-м4с]

BTOB finally get recognition they deserve, what a time to be alive

[@sabrinania98]

Really agree with you... this song is soo deep. Its not only song but emotion. Btob's song is totally different than other kpop songs. Congrats to hyunsik for able to compose this kind of song. Same as to others member for able to write the meaningful lyrics together. Congrats to melodies too... for always supporting btob!! The fanchants is superb!!💙

[@Sehugoo]

PD has that power to change my mind about songs, the first time I saw this mv I like it, but it didn’t feel special, but guess what, watching this now I am literally in tears!!! WTH!!!

[@carollinetampubolon2772]

They are masterpiece... Totally "YES" 💙

[@bryama2129]

BTOB is 'a masterclass in the art of the ballad'...yes... I learn a lot of new things from the mv...thanks to you. You really are so great finding the words to describe the essence of this mv...yes this song is about 'the cycle of love'...thats the words!

[@vadidudaa230]

I love BtoB. And I hope eungkwan is doing fine 😊🙂😔

[@allitadram]

vadidu daa he is fine! We got his new pic today ^^

[@carollinetampubolon2772]

He is totally fine.. Don't worry.. Our leader fine..

[@hanniefrei]

the new pic is making me crazy though.. from sweet innocent angel, its like he is transforming to a slighty buffed manlier hot guy!

[@Laura-pq3uh]

Every BTOB song can awake a certaint emotion in you, thats why their music is special and not many groups are capable of that. They deserve all the support and love ♡♡♡

[@queeniebayot7259]

I've been waiting for this video. What I love on your videos was that they are all informative. I love that you really strips the music video and explain us what you think. This is great. You're great. BTOB fighting! PS. I also love Guitar. Have you already listened to their "재발"? That also one of their saddest song. 💙

[@MrsHS-cj9sj]

BTOB_Hyunsik - Dear Love reaction Please producer🙏

[@miahoang3212]

My fav is Guitar too!!! I hope you will listen to Minhyuk’s song in this album, calls “Climax/Please”.. its also good enough to be the tittle song 🙏🏻

[@FelicityMayunami]

i was so excited when i saw this in my feed! the moment i saw the music video i wanted to see your reaction to it because i knew you'd love it. seventeen is my ult group but i think btob's taking over soon and i'm just a little scared

[@hanniefrei]

Love seventeen too. they are the same type of crazy. I LOVE highlight before, thought they will be my only one but after watching BTOB funny videos (which is almost all show they are in) and their live performance, I decided to have 2 biases.. my wallet is crying lol

[@btobclasseu]

Thank you so much for reacting to BTOB's Beautiful Pain! And for liking the song and MV as well. I wonder what you think about the whole Hour Moment album 💙 I just wanna know if you liked Friend, Like It, 나비 and 제발 as well ㅋㅋㅋ

[@CS-sf7jp]

I've been waiting for PD's reaction since BTOB release this song lol. I am glad that you eventually did this reaction and gave this song such a high evaluation. To be honest, I love how PD analysis context of the music seriously and professionally which barely happens in other channels. Thanks for PD's reaction and like you said, BTOB produces masterpieces. BTOB will never disappoint me. Btw, Changsub is going to come back with his first solo album in the middle of December. Please show more support to him!!

[@xxnightmare1317xx]

And for the cinematography we could thank the new director they worked with, he's a canadian, if memory from beatcom serves me right. Couldn't agree more that we need more music videos like this! 😆 Of course, BTOB that never disappoints when it comes to musicality and vocals coupled with a great video is all we need for one damn great masterpiece!

[@rammez]

You got to listen to this album's sidetracks!! All of them are amazing as well. Personally I recommend "Friend" and "Butterfly." The lyrics of "Friend" is very meaningful. Spoiler alert: You'll be surprised in the middle of "Butterfly" by Ilhoon's rapping part and Changsub's heavenly voice!

[@majaobradovic2569]

I was listening to this song when the notification came

[@seagizem]

I can always trust BTOB for quality music. And yeah not your typical ballads, this is Btob genre ;)

[@despasco1739]

LISTENING PARTY TO HOUR MOMENT OR DIVING DEEPER TO BTOB, PLEASE PDnim 😭💙💙💙💙💙

[@magdalenejoanne9438]

I love your review!! The way you catch on all the symbols to how it links to the song is so amazing! Never seeing this MV the same way again.. And BTOB is just BTOB! I can't begin to start on how amazing BTOB is! Thank you for the genuine reaction video and your reviews just makes me love them more!! The lengthy & emotional breakdown video is totally okayyyy. We fans totally appreciate it!

[@cecily8437]

Many Korean melodies think that they're dead and recalling and missing their girls as a "ghost" before they leave to the afterlife. The ambulance at the beginning shows that hyunsik is dead. Changsub died from an airplane crash and Ilhoon died from illness. It shows that minhyuk is dead from how the girlfriend dosent notice anything even tho hes right next to her and the dead trees represent the graveyard/death in sungjae's scene. This MVs the story before the Missing you MV where they accept the fact that they are dead and leave to go to the afterlife calmly. the ending scene of hyunsik connects to the beginning of missing you where he writes a song for his girl and leaves. *idk how to spell their names in English so if I'm wrong sorry :(

[@allitadram]

"This video gonna be long 9-10 minutes" And actually 17 min 😂😂😂 but I'm not complain. Thank you! 😆

[@zaidzubir3765]

Dang, ten out of ten right way! Thank you PD, thank you BTOB!

[@arianeflores6299]

THE MOST AWAITED REACTION FINALLY IS HERE! I THOUGHT YOU FORGET THEM BUT I'M WRONG. 😂 AS EXPECTED YOUR REACTION IS A MASTERPIECE TOO!! THANK YOU FOR REACTING TO BTOB'S BEAUTIFUL PAIN 💙 WE LOVE YOU PD-nim.

[@bobbiaparicio9804]

Best birthday gift...thanks PD 😊❤ P.S. I knew you'd love this song because it is as beautiful as you lol

[@SEK1]

Happy Birthday Melody 💙💙

[@bobbiaparicio9804]

@@SEK1 aww I don't know why but this made me want to cry. Thank you😊❤ Also I've never felt like I could call myself Melody...idk this made my heart warm 😄

[@matthew8829]

Well... I guess I found a new group to stan

[@aiai7037]

I know it's masterpiece. Thank you hyunsik for his beautiful low voice and beautiful song

[@normelizaabdulmaula1882]

I honestly waited for your reaction video for Beautiful Pain since last week haha thank you for this! I really enjoyed the things you mentioned regarding the music video, I guess I was just so mesmerized by the song itself to notice those things. Indeed a 10/10!

[@Sierrrrraaaaa]

Masterpiece is such an accurate word! I was desperately missing Eunkwang throughout this comeback but I know he would be so proud!!! The live stages are just as great! And of course you already know the other songs off the album are worth a listen for sure. Thank you for your review and reaction! We need more people to react to BTOB and the glory that is their ability to pull off this type of emotion and have the talent to back it up too. I am also not a fan of ballads so when I tell people that BTOB is my favorite group, they tend to question it. But their ballads are so special and so deep. They are one of a kind for sure 💙💙💙

[@lefro77]

Btob is a 10 out of 10

[@adaxiao2845]

Finally got your reaction!!! Love it!!! Recommend the whole album, all songs are awesome, particularly "climax", written by Minhyuk!!

[@shuchi281]

the instrumental for this song is sooo pretty, hyunsik rly is out there being the father of music

[@btobsmelody8938]

5:13-6:05 is a good way to describe BTOB's music 👍 BTOB has the power in producing songs that even listeners who are non-ballad lovers like their music. Their songs are ballad by nature but also has that kind of bop vibes into it, that makes it not boring to listen to. And vice versa, because before knowing BTOB (or KPoP for that matter) I am a ballad lover. I don't really like the rap parts or any song with fast tempo. (Before, I thought all Kpop songs are like that because the first Kpop group I know is 2NE1) but when I came to know Sungjae and learn about his group BTOB, the first song I listen to was BTOB's "It's Okay" and It really touches my heart. Even if there are strong rap parts into it, Ilhoon, Peniel and Minhyuk's voice really harmonize with the vocal parts and it just adds emotions to the song. Since then, I became a Kpop trash, although I only stan BTOB, I came to love and appreciate the Kpop industry (Ballad or Dance tracks and any other concepts) and all of other Kpop groups out there. So I really agree with the PD's comment that BTOB's songs are soulful and full of meaning. 💙 So please support BTOB, even if they are not complete right now, they can still produce good music individually. 💙 Thank you so much for this genuine reaction video, as a melody, we truly appreciate it. Fighting! 💙

[@apraillejunemonteras8798]

I keep coming back to this react and the emotions just keep coming back. It really is a beautiful pain that i want to feel over and over again. . GOSH. I love BTOB forever. Thank you PD.

[@yooklimjung4171]

Yaaaaas. Thank you for all the good words. I really love how you explain some scenarios here. Always love your reaction. Hope you also do a first listen to their album "Hour Moment", all tracks are amazing.

[@annseobbie]

I don't know why I kept crying while you were watching the MV and reacting to it then talking about the song. It is a masterpiece indeed. Thank you for the great review. I feel so proud for BTOB as a Melody.

[@elieicban]

PD-nim! Please upload the listening party of BTOB. I didn't have the chance to watch it on sming. Thankyou!

[@filipefonseca6810]

The emotion portrayed by them is on another level. They deserve a lot more love ❤

[@kathduena]

Been lowkey waiting for this mv reaction. Funny thing is when i was watching this i kept looking at BTOB’s mv below. So i have to play this again to focus on PD’s reaction. 😂 Anyway, this mv reaction is what I’ve been waiting for. You really point out every key points in this mv. Totally amaze on how you describe every scene and its symbolisms. No doubt Minhyuk is an actor. Lol! And Hyunsik’s part the screaming part. It’s like breaking your heart. I love that too. As always BTOB as sentimental-dol. As what they always say “We don’t sell albums, we sell emotions”. They always convey emotions in every songs that they make. 💙 Cinematography ✔️ Color-grading ✔️ Storyline ✔️ Everything else ✔️ 😂

[@lovelyhades]

This is my favorite song of the year.

[@dashingangel20]

I actually zoned out for a minute after watching the MV, trying to process what just happened, then tears just came out. Your reactions and review are awesome

[@sundaesssssss]

He says it all There’s no need for us to actually tell how amazing this song is, and the music video also Thank you PD for this reaction video, we’ve been dying to wait for this one and you never failed us Thank you so much 😍🙏😊

[@Bonklesify]

Love how you gave it 10/10 right away 🤣 but I love how you appreciate btob 😁 as a fellow melody, it makes me happy seeing others love them as much as melodies do 💙 you made me notice a bit more of little things I didn't notice before which was nice and was nice that you went deep to reviewing the music video 💙

[@phenglefield]

btob have recently become my bias group and i couldn’t agree more.

[@ljgella05]

I do strongly agree on what the whole mv and song portrays. It such a powerful song.

[@lourdes-e6r]

yassss btob legends !!

[@angmelodies4443]

I'm screaming! you speak exactly what's in my mind about this being THE BEST MV of BTOB. And i love your description about this MV 💙💙💙

[@yuqi5335]

The album is called Hour Moment and that's why you see hourglass in the MV. Watched every second of this video and it's so engaging, I GOT EXCITED WITH U DURING THE VIDEO!!! THANK YOU FOR THIS! Also check out Climax by Minhyuk, you will prob like it since he composed Guitar too ^^

[@_anaflavia_]

This was one of my favorite reactions from you. The song is a true masterpiece, BTOB are real artists. I felt heartbroken while listening to this song and watching your professional vision into it was just great. Thank you!

[@SoulxLucifer]

I think the reoccuring theme of the hourglass also kind of symbolise how you're waiting for the time to pass as the sand falls, but then when someone turns the hourglass around, perhaps faltering your resolve to not turn back on a past romance, all your efforts to get over the relationship is wasted and in fact you "fall back" to where you came from. It's almost symbolising once you fall in love and fall out of love, you can never reach true closure.

[@mariafomina1773]

I liked this song, this video. Their performance is also so beautiful and emotional. I really like btob

[@ykarenfamilan2528]

im not also a fan of ballad songs until i listened to btob songs...its full of emotions dat u can also feel wat da song delivers..its not just all about singing,,its about touching ones heart, feelings and emotions..dats wat makes btob unique from other kpop group..its actually quality over quantity...i love btob!!!!😍😍😍

[@MrsHS-cj9sj]

BTOB_Hyunsik - Dear Love reaction Please producer🙏

[@pensub1095]

please react to Hour Moment album tho! it's a great masterpiece composed by BTOB members.

[@Taropearis]

FINALLY I WAITED SO LONG FOR THIS. Thanks for this amazing reaction video😭😭😭😭

[@dhl7257]

Why does it look to me that even before PD heard the song, he's ready to say "10/10", but just decided to say it a bit "later"... Which is like 30 sec of the mv, and I like it 😂😂😂😂

[@jjrnmd7405]

Your reaction is basically accurate and we melodies felt same way during the mv release. I cried with that music vid (changsub part)

[@merlz13]

I stan BTOB and supports them because they always give their hearts and soul with their songs/music.. They are putting the cycles of life into songs.. I mean in all aspects... love, friendship, struggles and happy moments.. Thank you for supporting them too... I subscribed when I first saw your video of their brother act album when it was released and since then always watch your reactions coz your reactions are so spot on as what mist of us viewers/fans thoughtThank You! bless you..

[@sammyliaw4889]

3:18 I thought things were about to get SEXY too 😂

[@erikacasanova6035]

I have been waiting for this PD huhu. As usual you give out the best and most honest insights! The best!

[@jessiev2353]

i have a newly found appreciation for this MV, thanks to you!! Love your insight on the video and pointing out all the symbolisms that we would've probably just overlooked. Not a fan of ballads, as well, only BTOB made me! :)

[@lmf221]

I looooved this song and MV so much. I am so glad to see your reaction to this. btob is one of my absolute favorites and I'm astounded by their abilities musically. I saw some different symbolism with some scenes I saw death in a few of the members meanings personally but that was just my interpretation. Keep working on all these reactions, I'm eagerly watching them all!

[@rosesainisg]

Love your reaction video to BTOB “Beautiful Pain”. It is not lengthy at all. It really gave us a new perspective to music videos. It has also helped me appreciate BTOB to another level by knowing a little bit more about music, video-production and the making of it. Thank you again for sharing your knowledge and experience through your reaction videos. Looking forward to more!

[@Beyza-ml5qb]

pd you are such an intellectual....i love watching your videos even if im not a fan of the artist. im always learning something from you. thank you💜

[@melomarl]

as a film student who really likes kpop, I was like: FINALLY, SOMEONE UNDERSTANDS THE WAY I THINK WHEN IT COMES TO MUSIC VIDS. I'll definitely follow you from now on and please keep doing these vids 💙💙💙

[@nurhiks7436]

You should watch the live performance :) 10000/100 👍

[@bihaxxi8962]

PDnim the real melody.. Thanks for the details explanation of the mv. I appreciate it.

[@82popreaction90]

We react to BtoB songs:) We support BtoB!! Come please~~😊🙏🏻 멜로디 응원합니다!!

[@qb9294]

Yes, indeed a masterpiece!! Thank you for the good feedback💙

[@_illhooniie3995]

Thank you for this. Omg. I am glad you love it 💙

[@theartoftheunspoken2512]

Jesus, they always manage to captivate me and drown me in the emotions portrayed in the song. Amazing. Truly, a masterpiece.

[@masupayookieyookie]

Just saw a film nerd geek out! 😁 Thanks pd nim for a great and informative reaction video!

[@malvar2425]

They are definitely the definition of perfection💙💙Thanks for you reaction👏👏BTOB KINGS💙💙😘😘

[@Nicoleicole]

BTOB ballads never fail to make me tear up. This song and mv were so beautiful. You're right that it literally felt like a movie.

[@ASH-tw4jc]

"Oh shit it already sounds sad" well what else would you expect from a title like that lmao Edit: Minhyuk's and Hyunsik's parts are my favourites in this one, both for their voices and the acting. Also, Hyunsik's voice is one of my favourite voices in BtoB, he's so incredibly good at conveying emotions through his singing. Here it sounds like it's almost about to break at some points and just hearing him feels painful because the emotions seem so authentic and real. At least that's how I feel

[@BlueMeloRiz86]

Thank you so much for this 😍 I actually reacted the same as you at Hyunsik's part 😂

[@jaemgyuvin]

"10 out of 10" "THAT was a masterpiece." *same, pd. same.*

[@two5-yr1113]

thank you for your reaction. i waited it. it is so sharp and clever even though you are more focus on video. If you like the song guitar you should check out songs, blue moon and please(climax). those are masterpieces composed by minhyuk including guitar.

[@MarkMyWords02]

I love it. Thank you for recognizing my boys' talents. You're cool.

[@ljgella05]

PD your the best. The best reaction among all reaction.