Producer Reacts to Jennie "SOLO"

[@-EchoesIntoEternity-]

i was waiting for Jennie at the end to just hold a perfume bottle and whisper, "Solo, by Chanel"

[@TM-bf2pr]

😂

[@livchuu541]

actually, she wrote the lyrics, had a part on the choreo and kinda helped to make the MV. She took the outfits etc herself. So that doesn't make sense honestly, if you want to hate because you're jealous cause she's the first, then just go.

[@carol8434]

Livrey리브 girl what? They weren’t hating on it, but it does look like a perfume ad, that’s the only thing they were pointing out...

[@livchuu541]

Carol - it is hating.

[@pink_kpop709]

💀

[@tzutozaki]

To be honest i feel like they wanted to play it safe with jennie i mean she was the first member to go solo and yes she's popular enough to succeed with whatever concept or style they choose but that was probably it, just in case perhaps. Personally, i'm glad they did, whatever this was it worked, but it's probably just jennie's effect. She'll be a great soloist.

[@savanna4623]

you know Jennie never left black pink

[@savanna4623]

Plus didn't you listen to to the lyrics it was like a breakup song

[@Mika-od2hz]

@@savanna4623 nobody said that...

[@Kata_Rin]

Savanna Wong they never said she left blackpink, they just said she went solo, which means she made a debut as a soloist. Also, concept in terms of what PD was talking about does not completely mean the lyrics, but rather the visuals in the clothing and MV, and the style of the song. PD was also talking about independence though, which is related to breakup, as one is independent after a breakup.

[@XxwalaweixX]

@@savanna4623 *sigh~*

[@parsastrife6629]

Wait, is that really a webcam? WTH if you never told me I'd think that's a proper camera lmao!

[@Sajirah]

I know. I thought he was just using some other older camera model or something. I'm impressed.

[@solskynn]

I thought the same. I actually want to know what webcam it is!

[@justapotato99]

Same

[@RoggieSantos]

Maybe it's the Logitech Webcam C920. The most popular and cool ass webcam streamers used.

[@mimimicamica]

my biggest complain is that the mv looks more like publicity for a perfume at the begining than a mv, right at the ending I feel more what it's communicating but at the begining there's something laking, it's so emotionless. although, it's understandable knowing that yg made them do more publicity campaigns than songs

[@mimimicamica]

it goes without saying that jennie is amazing, super talented, my complain goes more to the people that directed the mv I guess

[@LexyBach]

Yes! At the end with the lipstick feels like something chanel would do

[@jadeshepherd8627]

The rose petal scene reminded me a lot of a perfume ad.

[@Daniel-wt3bf]

The beginning is suppoused to represent the sadness after a break up. She's sad and trapped in that luxury mansion and when she breaks the pink bracelet it means she has had enough and wants to break free. The pool represents the tears and she's throwing pages of the diary into it (the diary is her love story. She wants to forget about it). So that's basically the beginning. Then she finally evolves (the washing machine scene) and becomes independet.

[@ribonette_]

Go look for the lyrics, and then come back and watch again.

[@very_cherryx]

I like the song but I was very confused as to why this is such a vocal heavy song. Jennie is blackpinks main rapper yet her company has been treating her like a sub rapper lead vocal

[@LoveMe-yg7iv]

Peyten Ratzlaff she’s main rapper and lead vocalist but true 💀

[@iSawYouLookin]

because she doesn't belong in a box like that...she can sing and rap so it doesn't matter if she's doing a solo song...

[@azamamin5988]

Shes a rapper yes but lots of YGs main rapper does this, just like gd, mino and bobbys solos. Actually YGE just love her strong voice so much,(or just love her individually,)YG did not treat her like a sub rapper. If you hear bp songs, shes got the most rap lines and also lots of vocal parts. Its more like lead vocal lead rapper actually.

[@parkhae-il9211]

Think on the bright side, many rappers can sing actually and vocalists can rap surprisingly

[@joonoho]

it’s funny bc lisa is better at rapping and jisoo is a better singer imo 💀 still impressive that she can do both

[@zachoo7765]

My thoughts were exactly same when it ended...just when it got really good , I was like what...is it over?? I like the the song though it's pretty good

[@Nikki-jh1qf]

Jennie’s song was good, but I wish it was longer and she had another rap verse before the song ended with the dance break.

[@musicsk613]

Solo isn't a bad song, I think it's decent. I would listen to it for a few weeks before getting bored of it. Honestly, I wish that Solo had included more of Jennie rapping because I think her rapping is just as good if not better than her singing. It really does seem like YG is playing it safe with this song.... P.S. - I'm pretty sure the MV was shot in London, but correct me if I'm wrong.

[@bertiewooles3093]

A Tired ARMY/ReVeluv/Stay As someone from the UK, the car is British so it’s shot in the UK if not London exactly

[@gengo0]

I wish her rapping was korean in the 2nd verse. I understand that they’re trying to appeal more to western audiences these days but it just sounded off to me and I think it would be better in korean.

[@dowoonsdanceudanceu2007]

@@bertiewooles3093 looool it was shot in Hayes, London, 2 mins away from where I live... And I had no idea... You can just about imagine how I felt when I found out...

[@christabuki5459]

Sarah Tate I would cry wauw that reallyyyyy sucks

[@satella5509]

@@dowoonsdanceudanceu2007 i'll run down just to meet her no matter wht happens.

[@aviannapeacecraft]

Please check out EXID 'I love you'

[@jungkookwillbethedeathofme]

Avia Schelts-Brown YES

[@Cris-cx3kv]

Yes please !

[@amy-zo7mo]

he doesn't take requests, but I'll be surprised if he doesn't check it out

[@eriso8119]

I really hope for it.

[@huegyu5423]

YESSS

[@don9718]

Tbh it feels like a rehashed/unfinished Sunmi track, which actually could be true considering Teddy is the producer of Gashina, Heroine and also this song. He's not famous for being creative so i can see this being some discarded/unfinished track he had hanging there. This doesn't mean the song is bad, i like the song, however it feels lazy and unimpressive.

[@kindDictator]

Thats what i said, it reminded me so much of a tacky gashina and Jennie is not strong on her own and needs to stay in the group until she can grow more on her own and can perfome without all those dancers especially live.

[@bronymon08]

Pfft as lazy as her performances lately lmao

[@eatinglegocandy]

d-ARtenshi she has motion sickness, I love when people make fun of her health problems. You thought u did something with this huh

[@kirstyharrington7587]

Rei H how come her motion sickness didn’t effect her performance in 2016 and 17 tho ??

[@Kuname-pp3hq]

Rei in my opinion, motion sickness is not an excuse for lazy performances. She used to work hard on the stage with the other members but now I find it a bit disappointing and you can see how much she doesn’t seem to care.

[@stephanie061201]

it definitely took a while for the song to grow on me

[@youarespecialjustlikeevery1670]

i only liked the bitch now I'm solo part at first 😂😂😂😂

[@cindy9697]

I loved the verses but disliked the chorus.

[@mischievous6820]

Same here

[@youarespecialjustlikeevery1670]

@@cindy9697 same

[@satella5509]

i like the dance break part tho lol

[@audreyaudreyha9551]

I feel like they definately been able to do more with it. To me it was kind of average and basic but people can have their own opinions. She is definately talent and so beautiful tho

[@cupidream9702]

jeongin’s braces Reminds me a lot of Gashina

[@cupidream9702]

Can’t wait for people to tell me my opinion is wrong💀

[@audreyaudreyha9551]

mina’s universe oh yes a little bit. I feel like gashina had more dimension to it

[@MunkeeFWRrng]

@@audreyaudreyha9551 It does. This sounds like the demo or recycled version of the song. Or a bad kareokie (idk the spelling) version.

[@LoveMe-yg7iv]

mina’s universe both were produced by Teddy and he has def his distinctive style. I mean after you listen to some songs produced by him you can almost always tell if the song has his touch or not so yeah

[@25AGrace]

I agree I thought they would be showcasing her as more of a bad ass rapper, but I like the chic independent style they went with in the end. I wish it was at least 30 seconds longer. I really wanna see blackpink attack a hardass song, DDD was just the tip of the iceberg

[@Kata_Rin]

25AGrace ahhh you meant ddu du ddu du of BP! I first was a little confused because I thought of DDD by EXID when you mentioned DDD

[@25AGrace]

@@Kata_Rin Ah omg i didn't even think of that 😅 I was just being lazy. That's a great girl group song too 😄

[@Mhochul]

Watching this in 2020 looking at the comments it's so absurd. Blackpink might receive hate now but I completely forgot how bad it was in 2018

[@user10837]

You mean Jennie

[@crimsonrain143]

“It’s all white people.” Lmao

[@XDmiao]

All I can ever say about this song is.....it's fine.....I don't get why they gave her such an eh song

[@ellcally508]

Why? Because its YG and Teddy. They take Blackpink for granted.

[@XDmiao]

@@ellcally508 ah, makes sense

[@cupidream9702]

Ell Cally *All their artists. This is why YG is shit and people should stop auditioning for YG because he’s gonna take them for granted

[@XDmiao]

@@cupidream9702 honestly agree with you; I have never understood why kpop fans insist yg is somehow above the usual kpop company nonsense when the mistreatment and flat out ignoring of artists is just as rampant under 'papa yg' (blech) as anywhere else

[@amyydoung]

are you better director then YG and teddy? haha no.

[@lilacbp3908]

I had the same reaction you did, I listened to the the song and thought it was okay. by the second chorus I began getting use to it but then BAAM the break dance left me shook then the song ended and I was like??? Wtffff??

[@joannetute8445]

In all honesty I love the quality even though it’s from a webcam and you should use it a bit more as the comment said “we care more about your thoughts than the actual video quality”.

[@BluebeardsWifeR6]

Honestly I thought the song was pretty bad, seems rushed and unfinished. Even with the little intro and outro of the mv, the video is less than 3 minutes long

[@MunkeeFWRrng]

My exact thoughts.

[@azamamin5988]

Unfortunately there are more fans than haters, more people like it than hate it. Being no1 on lots of charts, even in the u.s, does not come just because the singer is famous or hyped.

[@MultiLovedrama]

In my opinion, i like the song and i think the beats are catchy and cool. So its a matter of preference, i guess.

[@claranguyen2738]

Bear if you don’t like it, just move on. No need to bring in haters on board. There’s enough negativity in the world.

[@azamamin5988]

@@claranguyen2738 sorry i was just against the comment and sayin lot of more people does not agree with this comment just by lookin at the charts which queen jendeuk slayed. im on Jennie's side here and im streaming solo like a robot cuz im addicted

[@KariHaruka]

The MV was filmed in locations within West London and the East End of London which is only a few miles away from where I live!

[@topkwon2594]

Looked like the same area GD's Crooked

[@KariHaruka]

@@topkwon2594 Shoreditch (in London's East End) does appear in both MVs.

[@archwayofcesar]

i get that blackpink doesnt release much but expecting to hear a blackpink song from jennie as a soloist seems like an unfair expectation. especially when shes just dipping her toes in the water literally. and those comparing this song to sunmis gashina must remember that gashina was a comeback and solo is a debut.

[@lazerNeo]

Gashina as a comeback and Solo being a debut has nothing to do with the comparisons they were making. Teddy was also the producer of Gashina and Heroine by Sunmi and this legit does feel like one of Teddy's scrapped works.

[@archwayofcesar]

a song is a song whether or not it was intended for someone else. we dont know how the song came into fruition. it seems ironic to fixate on this idea that has no basis in fact when there is so much that actually goes into a song. even if these two songs were produced by the same person. however teddy is a professional pop song writer. he knows a pop song formula that works and he sticks to it. there are countless pop songs that sound similiar and get remixed into mash ups and that never hurt anyone.

[@lisaoppa5784]

schmesar stop saying it’s unfair cause everyone of them is getting a solo lol

[@prilailiu]

@@lisaoppa5784 when he said it's "unfair" he didn't mean it's unfair that Jennie is solos and the others aren't. He meant the comparison... Read the whole comment.

[@managersejinstan1523]

What does Gashina being a comeback song have to do with anything? If it's a comeback, it can be a played a little safer, it doesn't have to make an impact (although it was insanely popular), Sunmi already had a fanbase. I would say SOLO being a debut validates all the criticism calling it lazy and overdone. Especially from Blackpink. They were pretty refreshing in a sea of cute group concepts, but a girl crush/sexy concept for a solo artist? That's nothing special.

[@Matthew-ft5ep]

So I've listened to this quite a few times now and I don't mind it but I feel her voice only really works with a group, she is a good singer but I believe she works much better in a group

[@MunkeeFWRrng]

Same here. She just doesn't seem like someone who can be a solo artist.

[@julianabiga7824]

Agreed

[@managersejinstan1523]

She's charismatic and has great stage presence, but I feel like there's something lacking. Artists like HyunA, or IU or even Chungha seem to have an it factor that's missing. But maybe it's just the mediocre song

[@MunkeeFWRrng]

@@managersejinstan1523 It's both the mediocre song and the fact that her voice when both rapping and "singing" doesn't stand out at all. She has no concept of vocal technique, if given proper training she could be something phenomenal to witness. But as is, she's basic (in terms of her voice). You could legit find a hundred of her (voice wise) on a street corner. She needs to develop her voice more. She has a pleasant tone, but it's being overridden by her shouting/breathing into the mic rather than actually singing. Training her voice will allow her voice to shine at its fullest potential. Until then she's going to be stuck having next to no range and completely limited vocals.

[@managersejinstan1523]

@@MunkeeFWRrng But we all know how good YG is about training their idols. He's single handedly ruined Daesung's, Bom's and Rosé's vocal health because of how he forces them to sing

[@youtubechannel7736]

I'm here to say that I'm still in love with this song.

[@Stefan-iz3ty]

Found the song underwhelming, but it's slowly growing on me. Won't listen to it on a regular though

[@MunkeeFWRrng]

Same here except I still hate it.

[@Stefan-iz3ty]

@@MunkeeFWRrng yeah, I've come to accepting it for what it is. That's about it. Jennie's been disappointing me recently, as well as Teddy. Hopefully it'll improve in the near future.

[@MunkeeFWRrng]

@@Stefan-iz3ty Same.

[@markjalandni5395]

U guys still disappoint?

[@earlgrey3067]

The teaser honestly betrayed what I thought it would sound like. I thought it would be a revolutionary, strong debut but instead, all I got was the regular instrumental beat drop for a chorus. The song definitely grew on me, but I just wish it had a stronger impact - something not too out there but definitely not just a song without an actual lyrical chorus.

[@tokyodoll7000]

earl grey same, and unfortunately a lot of teasers are misleading and serve as a hype for the song and video. Example, When I saw the very first teaser video for TWICE what is love, I thought I was gonna be an adorable & hard bop, and instead we got an soft pop-electro beat...the choreography was nice but still hated the song lol Idk if Solo is the only song Jennie has in her solo campaign but maybe her next one will be better.

[@managersejinstan1523]

It sounds like a song Sunmi said no to and for good reason

[@clueblue686]

Tea

[@MunkeeFWRrng]

Omg yes 😂👏

[@softgukktae595]

Tea

[@emmaedward3715]

Solo is a good song and it did really well and Teddy is a producer for blackpinks every single song so why would he offer a good song to sunmi before giving it to Jennie

[@joycejojobinha]

Omg HAHAHAHA true 👌

[@frontline327]

Anyone else think this Mv looks like a Marc Jacobs ad?

[@chuunaverse6093]

Make reaction to Mino - Fiancé! ((Actually I would like full album reaction since that album has so many bops and Fiancé isn’t the best of them))

[@Chago1997]

IsSungJinaBear ? Trigger is def a good one and hope bow wow too

[@lucynguyen4390]

He doesn't take requests (due to some requests being outside of copyright laws)

[@chuunaverse6093]

Lucy Nguyen Okay, nice to know that. I’m just hinting...

[@DulcisAbsentia]

SOLO is one of the baddest songs i've heard and the MV a whole masterpiece. To everyone their opinion 💁

[@autumn4000]

“It’s all white people” LMFAOO SAME Can’t wait till we can see some POC in some k-pop m/v atleast sometimes🙄😂

[@sup.2318]

Check Mamamoo out then honey

[@ParkJimin-nb8xi]

There are poc in kpop mvs lmfao- watch some bts stuff lol also there ain't anything wrong with havung white people in it

[@ednalheaibasco]

I'm sorry....but i was underwhelmed with this release.

[@MunkeeFWRrng]

Same here

[@JesusXina]

Personally thought the song was boring and sounded like a typical Teddy song

[@strawb1428]

I feel like she doesn't have a unique enough voice to be a solo artist. Like she has talent and is obviously a good singer but it just doesn't stand out to me enough.

[@Momotenzin]

only you sis

[@risayoung]

It's so weird, because I think she has unique sound to her voice for me even compared to other kpop artists in the industry, even tho she doesn't have the best technique. Her live is quite stable tho, imo. But I do think the choreo is too simple and she doesn't have enough stage presence (again, imo) which is probably why u also find she doesn't stand out so much.

[@keke3897]

i agree,, her vocals aren’t that unique or strong to be a solo artist. if she was actually solo and not pretty, no one would pay much attention to her

[@julianabiga7824]

Yeah I used to think her voice was unique but that was until this and hearing her voice by herself, I think she is better in a group

[@managersejinstan1523]

@@risayoung I think the opposite actually. In my opinion she has great stage presence but her voice is very lead vocal. The person that backs up the main vocal, the one that fills in gaps instead of driving the chorus. I can't name another person with Jennie's voice, but that might just be it. It seems very ordinary. Completely my opinion though and it's nice seeing things from other people's perspective

[@blackpinkjjang9116]

I hope that this means the remaining members of Blackpink get their “SOLO” too!

[@demetria12121]

They will!

[@sabitonics5436]

Rosé’s solo is next

[@NoxturnalMoth]

Solo is not BAD but it's not GOOD. It is just pretty boring. The song is p nice but not THAT good. It seems nice on the moment but becomes boring and annoying with time because the music is just pieces of many songs we've heard before a little bit of Gashina, Heroine and so on and bam you get Solo. And the MV isn't well organized it's all over the place, sometimes it looks good but here it is pretty patchy and the transitions could've been way better. Plus the fact that Jennie's voice isn't that original when she sings I think she should've rapped more and in Korean. Her voice isn't bad, it's just not something we have never heard before. YG should've done better. He doesn't put enough work on his artists for them to be different and more original than 2NE1 and BIG BANG he just does them over and over again because they worked. I am sad that YG's quality downed. iKon deserve better, and even if I despise Blackpink I gotta admit that even them deserve better. YG played way too safe with that song and it's sad he doesn't show Jennie's full potential.

[@hernanvillafane799]

Welcome back PD! I missed you!

[@somijeon9311]

If actually they gave her a rap song was better but until now SOLO achieved so much to bp and jennie and I’m proud of it

[@aliana246]

I swear Jennie had like 14 outfits in this mv it was crazy lol. YG will always have a *budget*

[@hoangdiu8224]

Simon says - NCT 127 , plsss

[@rumesarazi5742]

It's out now!

[@kaciamatthieu8138]

YES

[@natty15529]

Btw have you seen stray kids did the ‘Adore you’ of seventeen? It’s stray kids X seventeen!!!! You couldn’t miss that

[@toadwi]

i recognise a lot of it as london (i'm from just south of london) like the shot on the rooftop, the street, the tunnel, even the house they used. we love the promo lol

[@masuma3433]

I honestly think they should have gave Jennie a song which showcases her rap rather than her singing because I really dislike her singing in “solo”. Her singing is her basically shouting the lyrics. “Love StoRAYYY”. But overall the song is just another track teddy half heartedly made and had it laying around. Also the music video I couldnt help but cringe, it felt like a commercial and her just staring at the camera acting like she’s too good by rolling her eyes etc. nothing genuine.

[@choizuey8683]

exactly what i think

[@buenastardes5240]

I normally don't like songs with this type of chorus but I LOVED solo at first listen.

[@YoItsSharkWeekMangs]

weird how jennie's the one with the first solo considering shes been the one putting in the least effort recently in their concerts lmao

[@An-eb8uk]

Tea

[@laurat7707]

She's YG's princess, what do you expect. I just hope the same amount of effort is given to the other girls' solo releases and promotions

[@LoveMe-yg7iv]

Laura T she's not sweetie but she's the most popular member in SK and "SOLO" shows that on charts also her solo being first is going to be good to stabilise BP's popularity in SK and increase curiosity about other members solos in the future.

[@Alex-xz1mf]

She’s literally the most famous one out of all of Blackpink in korea so it makes perfect sense why she is the first solo.

[@An-eb8uk]

Laura T And on top of that, her solo was very flimsy and .....very unpolished. Classic Teddy. Also, I wish she would put even an ounce of the energy she had performing Solo when she performs with BlackPink.

[@kiwikiwi9789]

At 4:00 turn your captions on thank me later

[@silviaamm]

Please react to Fiancé - MINO

[@Mictlantecuhtli]

FINALLY SOMEBODY SAID ALOUD THE SONG AND PRODUCTION IS LACKING. I love you.

[@sunflowerbloomsbeautifully1042]

I just loved her outfit .But the song looks like unfinished.

[@gumworms5199]

The song could have been better. The MV is very nice though.

[@ImmunePi3]

I was so disappointed by this song

[@MunkeeFWRrng]

Same

[@zwei2576]

Yep, even the background music was just poor, especially the chorus

[@vivianvelasquez9409]

I have been waiting for this omg

[@painteater]

SAME

[@k.thongbam6815]

Came here to say SOLO it's still ageing like a fine Wine

[@penisfarts7611]

The transition into the chorus was so abrupt and out of place. If she wasn’t Jennie from Blackpink, this song would’ve flopped, and I don’t think I would’ve been mad. Meh song

[@rafaelchagas98]

girl you talk like you were some kinda of expert lmao shut the fuck up

[@penisfarts7611]

Rafael Chagas Lmao the immaturity. Work on making valid points instead of insulting others. Absolute trash.

[@lbll4185]

Can you do a reaction to 'Not that Type' from Gugudan ?

[@slylover123]

I found it lackluster The song didn't highlight her talents enough The video was generic and forgettable and the song didn't take any risks in regard to it's sound. I just don't think it distingushes her from other artists-thank goodness she has blackpink

[@MunkeeFWRrng]

My thoughts exactly.

[@Athena-17Caratzen]

Yeah, her voice (especially in the first part of the song) sounded a bit forced (idk how to explain this). I wished she just used her normal voice, without an effort to sound almost, lazy (just the tone, not the person). The song is catchy though, but I think it was far from enough.

[@Planet_Bebe]

This is why I watch PD-nim! Because of his honesty! He didn’t like it, but critiqued it in an intelligent, constructive way! I 💯 agree. I felt like this song had so much potential because the track has a cool sound (thank you, Teddy!) but it honestly felt incomplete, & like a first draft vs. a final product.

[@niconiconick]

I literally agree with you on everything and this was shot in london because at this time Jennie was doing some over sea things with Chanel i believe

[@amy_ambrosio]

Actually, I really liked Jennie's song, it's pretty solid. Maybe in the future (when the members would become more confident in themselves), they'll take more risks or get out of their comfort zone (a little more). I really want to see them working with another producer or other people, you know? They're not rookies and they don't need that pamper anymore. The girls have so much talent and I think they should be pushed to a point where they could take everything they can, at least until they get mature enough to compose their own songs. Still, I feel really happy that Jennie has this opportunity, my bias is so talented (":. It would be good to see more activities from the whole Black Pink tho.

[@MoisaJWroy]

I agree, I can't wait for the other members releases, I heard Rose's solo is confirmed, so I'm assuming hers will come when Jennie's release dies down a bit! Jennie is also my bias! I agree with PD, a rap bridge before that dance break at the end would have probably pushed it a little more though!

[@kennethsoshi03]

*Clearly this is Teddy's leftovers from sessions with Sunmi. This sounds like Gashina 2.0 but yeah.*

[@formoftherapy]

OOF

[@user10837]

Jennie solo was experimental song as if she did great the others would too can’t wait for her album I just know she has so much to offer

[@jodi3094]

React to exid “i love you”!!!

[@tarunmahesh4711]

eeeek 2018 blackpink hate was......something else

[@MonalisaReyna]

Personally, I felt the song was lacking a little bit and I agree with you about the ending feeling rushed and how it was just getting good. When I first heard it, I said “that’s it?” But then not gonna lie, it grew on me but I guess they played it super safe so that’s why? But the choreo wowed me more :)

[@korniceman3000]

I liked the MV. Seemed quite polished, wasn't controversial in any way, quite fitting for her style. However, I felt the song was a bit lacking and slightly disjointed and somewhat underwhelming. Sound production was top notch and well mixed. For me personally, I would have liked for a more vibrant chorus that didn't center on the word solo. The lead melody while very catchy and tropical felt better used as an intro/outro/bridge/break segment rather than a main chorus hook. A different chorus should have been used that featured a nice melodic hook and lyrics. The structure felt like it was a collaboration between multiple songwriters/composers from different locations who emailed their individual segments to a song producer who compiled and arranged the material into something resembling a song and not something that was planned and methodically processed. Then again, our opinions don't really matter to people within the industry as they follow a very specific formula when it comes to developing a Kpop artist and their music. It will only matter if we have some kind of name or status....

[@mrswhiddleberry]

I like the song but I didnt feel it had any replayability for me until that final dance break. Also please check out voisper's goodbye to goodbye🙆‍♀️

[@lasagnathan69420]

This song just really didn't do it for me. It felt like they couldn't decide if they wanted to showcase Jennie as a poppy vocalist or a chic rapper, so they mashed the two of them together and didn't manage to blend the styles particularly well. The first verse, the bridge, and the pre-choruses all feel like one song. Meanwhile, the choruses and the second verse feel like a completely different song. There's a huge disconnect between those two, at least to my ears. I really wanted to like it, but I just haven't been able to.

[@autumneagle]

Rose is my bias and Jennie did amazing in this song but I'm gonna be a little contrarian here and say I can't WAIT for a Jisoo solo, I'm really excited to see what she can do since she gets comparatively little play in their normal songs.

[@ashlynsequiera6820]

I remember someone telling that solo is basically gashina but for heteros and uxjejdx wHY CAN I SEE IT LIKE THAT

[@dasc0yne]

A month later and I'm still underwhelmed by the song and the concept. Conceptually there seems they're trying to push Jennie's sultry "Boombaya" persona. I think by now we know that Jennie is more than that.

[@puddingpudding4047]

I couldn't help but sometimes feel like YG is sleeping on BLACKPINK 's potentials to become one of the best in the industry . Oldest to the youngest_ Jisoo-Her visuals are needless to say,could even be considered as prettiest. Her base vocal is unique like Yuqi or Taehyung , deep echoed and with proper training,she have the capacity to get better role as a vocalist. Jennie_ As a blink, I somehow feels like she is shouting in some parts .Still,she is stable I guess.Her rap is charismatic yet lacks flow and intensity sometimes. Rosè_Nasal ....I am sorry but I have to agree .Bigbang Taeyang is also like that .Still fans love the emotions and colors she delivered through a song and that's somewhat a impressive characteristic of an artist so. Lisa_Her vocals are decent but really swag and good dancer .Still need to showcase more to claim the title of one of the best .

[@bookofdaisy9124]

I personally have grown to really like this song and have even had it on repeat a couple of times, but I gotta admit, right when I heard it the first time it reminded me sooo much of Gashina and it felt like YG was really trying to play it safe and on trend. Jennie is my bias in Blackpink and I think she shines and is strong in every area when she wants to be (vocals, rap, dance) but there could have been so much more done with this track and her talents. Her rap was particularly lackluster for me, it feels like YG knew people would be happy that she was rapping in english so that's all he went with, they didn't bother making it exceptional in any other way. And the dancing seemed pretty lazy as well, except for the end bit. Minimalistic choreo can work very well sometimes but this mostly just felt boring and, like I said, lazy (which I know is something that people complain a lot about with Jennie, she's gotten to be quite lazy with performing and I think that was showing here). I still really like the song and I thought the MV was shot very beautifully (although at times it seemed like a French perfume ad or something lmfao), and I really like Jennie's vocals in this, but they could have gone above and beyond with it and for some reason they chose not to.

[@boperadotto8703]

Waiting for Chaeng's solo. She has a really distinct and versatile voice for it. Hopefully it's not as restrained as this one.

[@aedlzvn]

Distinct for being nasally lol

[@stavros2644]

@@aedlzvn ...ok karen

[@raegandougan]

Please react to Nature "You'll Be Mine" and Dreamnote "Dream Note" !!!

[@annisanurul2296]

I read it as naruto, damn whats wrong with my eyes

[@Marshmallox43]

agreed, visual was nice, locations were cool but the songs lacks a lot

[@Grinning_shark]

Im watching this 1.5 years in the future, and it physically hurt me when you said "all Blackpink members are gonna have solo songs in the future". 😭 Because I know what came out of THAT. 😥

[@nono-wc6gc]

she is such a sweetheart

[@bartle9190]

She used many different voices in this song. Soft Vocal, Strong Vocal, Sassy, and Rap. It’s like she’s a one-woman band. Independent... Solo.

[@evilmcmuffin5838]

I completely agree, I love the song and all but the M/V was quite disappointing. It was lacking a lot of art direction. If I hadn’t turned on the subs I wouldn’t really get it or had known beforehand what it was about. I think they wanted a lot of things happen in 2 mins and plus seconds that’s why it feels all over the place. And when you actually watch the behind the scenes of this m/v, I absolutely felt bad for all the wasted footage that didn’t make it into the cut. They shot a lottttt man.

[@ypox8744hb]

Carried by lit beat, not superior lyrics and rhyme.

[@shonx4877]

Please check out KEY's 'One of Those Nights' MV!!

[@sweet16_misery]

Can you please react to Highlight's Loved? This will be their last comeback as of the moment before they all enlist..thankyou!

[@nathanoloughlin1215]

Please do Pop/stars by K/DA!

[@aishwarryavp7435]

Please check out Key's solo "One of Those Nights" PD-nim

[@IGot7RevtinyArmyStayOnceBlink]

Idc what anyone else says I LOVE this song. It’s a bop and now I’m so excited for the other solos. I will say I was sad when it ended though, because that ending was lit and the most lit part. I do agree though it’s very minimalistic but if you see the live stage it goes together really good. I feel seeing the dancing and stuff adds something.

[@angelyce]

Noah fence, but the song is pretty lackluster and it’s really not that impressive. But I expect such from Teddy. Jennie is YG’s princess, and she’s been getting a lot of attention mainly because of ads and exposure with brands, specifically Chanel. I love BP, but lately she doesn’t put in much energy and I hope that YG isn’t too biased with the members because I would love to see their debuts. I think for a start this was ok, but this one was meh. I wonder if people liked it bc they Stan her, or if they liked the song. I also wish they would maybe give Teddy a break...??? Like, maybe he just needs his creative juices to flow bc this one wasn’t it.

[@Seungminne143]

Jennie Is so beautiful and gorgeous pretty 😍💜🖤

[@huh5590]

almost 3 years and jennie still hasn’t comeback as a soloist lol we’re stuck with solo, thank g its bop

[@kuyab9122]

Love Cherry Motion - Choerry/LOONA special mention :D

[@beannieswife1800]

PLS REACT TO ATEEZ- Pirate king!!!

[@shelbzzz]

I agree w/ a lot of your thoughts on this. I'd be really interested in seeing your reaction to Key's solo debut, One of Those Nights! I love your commentary and as a shawol, it'd be cool to see what you think of the song/album (:

[@LilJwalker12]

Good to see you back PD! I hope you had safe travels over the past few weeks! I 100% agree with your reaction. You should check out Mino's new music video Fiance, or a listening party to his whole new album. It's honestly wonderful, unique, and composed very well. There's also going to be a ton of comebacks this month and coming up here- can't wait to hear more from you!

[@joeybillig4820]

Still waiting for that K/DA POP/STAR reaction :(

[@amazonz8590]

I don't like the song. I find it repetitive. I only love the start of the song

[@allylandon221]

I think the visuals looks fine don't stress about it

[@Mordaine75]

I had the same reaction, was just getting into the last chorus and then it just ends. And I was also hoping for some harder rap from Jennie especially after she went all the way off on DDu-Du DDu-Du

[@sept09]

I think she got the 2nd place on unique listeners in korea with like 1,2m in 24h or something like that, the first place is obviously IU's.

[@m150ok]

Do check out exid i love you and btob beautiful pain thank you:)

[@minh8626]

I love *SOLO* I love *JENNIE* I love *BLACKPINK*

[@xXxIMNOTANGELxXx]

The only Blackpick song I can listen to..

[@rensilog1381]

Still waiting for your reaction to BtoB's Beautiful Pain.