PRODUCERS REACT - SB19 Pablo ??? Question Mark Reaction

[@xeanluxcrille6847]

Yes, Pablo has TONS of beautiful unreleased songs. This is just one of them. He even sang one during their first full concert, titled "Kumunoy" (eng: Quicksand) which talks about how one gets overwhelmed by life, struggles and tall dreams, paralyzed as their emotions swallow them up like quicksand. He also has written "Kelan" (a personal favorite of mine), and "Salamangka" (eng: Sorcery, but it's also a wordplay for the phrase "Sa Lamang Ka" which means "Where You're Better Off"/"Where You Fare Better"). All of those songs so far are largely EMOTIONAL and DEEP. Why do we know this? Because sometimes, man just drops clips of him singing these pieces out of nowhere. He RARELY uses social media, that's why his group of fans (the Hotdogs) are said to stay in the "Freezer" because we be freezing out here waiting for his crumbs which come out once in a blue moon if we're lucky--it's actually far less frequent. 😅 His posts are rarer than the rarest pokemon that it's literally a miracle. But the "house" of fans for every SB19 member happen to have unique qualities/attitudes. Pablo's freezer contains hotdogs that don't mind freezing forever. They're also very serious and academically-oriented: they write long essays, infographics, analyses and theses. (By now you would have already guessed which house I belong to.) And when Pablo drops crumbs, it's always more than worth it. You sometimes get to see him drop his unreleased songs which would always go viral among A'TIN. In fact, Pablo didn't put out posts to promote La Luna, he just posted cryptic yet ordinarily-written tweets. THIS VIDEO (???) in particular just dropped out of nowhere. Imagine my surprise when I suddenly saw the random channel named "Pablo" and I was wondering if it was him--indeed it was! MAN NEVER SAID ANYTHING! The channel only had one video--THIS ONE. And in true Pablo fashion he titled it "???". He was the only one who'd do that so everybody knew immediately it was him. He's notorious for his earliest tweet containing merely a period ".", he also had a tweet containing only a semicolon ";" (admittedly, that was because he was very new to twitter, but come on, it's so adorable 😊). When this video was released we then found out it was a teaser and that the date and time on the clock were SUSPECTED to be the release date for a solo song. Yes, "suspected" because there was no official announcement ever. 😅 We just thought it must be release date because it was a few more dates later than the day when the ??? video was made public. People just patiently waited for the date to roll around, and seeing as his teaser was heartbreaking & emotional, we really were expecting something similar. Remember, Pablo really has a great voice and he can reach fairly high notes so we were expecting he'd release something similar. Imagine our surprise when he released the hard-hitting La Luna instead. Man really trolled us hard. 😂 But I love La Luna. Being an anime addict who drowned myself in epic anime OSTs, Gento, La Luna and Determinado are just the type of songs that I prefer the most.

[@xeanluxcrille6847]

​@@ii-ll7ho Ganun talaga basta hotdog! The cold never bothered us anyway! 😂

[@abidesuyo]

Lol! Rarest Pokémon but almost always worth the wait.

[@Mebs5683]

A'Tin doesn't really disappoint in explaining everything. This is an epic piece kaps!.. All we need to do is do the second-motion. You got me with the "rarest pokemon" reference. Hahaha!.. I'm a hotdog but sometimes I get to question if I really belong to the freezer. Hahaha My bias is a genius, and my fellow hotdogs, like you, are badass smart pipz.

[@treg-samson]

So fun to read this comment 😉 and I agree 💯 ❤ 🌭 rules. I love them all but just a tad bit more for Pablo

[@treg-samson]

@@iamgagab the April Boy Regino reference is killing me .. this was my first impression of him ( even his looks resembles the dude) . I have never brought it up . But it has always been in my mind like a dirty secret that i only should know lol . Wow ! Hotdogs trully are kindered spirits 😉 but i have fallen in love and now an avid fan . Never have I ever stan any group . I did not know BTS until recently . BSB comes next but at a far greater distance 😃 . Nice to meet y'all hotdogs 🌭

[@yurimaxwell]

This song is good. But it hits different for someone who has suffered depression. Josh's right, Pablo was able to capture what happens during that battle in your head at the end of the day when you are alone with your thoughts. Pablo is an amazing song writer. Kudos too for whoever did the captions for this. I can imagine that it's not an easy translation. Great reaction!

[@kish9836]

It really is a good and relatable song...

[@breakout4347]

I'm back in this channel again, for more of PABLO! :) THIS GUY IS A GEM! I love all five but this guy is the gem of SB19 because wherever group he ends up, he will make music that will do justice to talents of the members, every singer will shine because of his music! SB19 is SB19 not only because oft he power vocals but because of THIS GUY! PABLO IS A GEM IN PPOP!

[@JecilleChiongson]

AMEN

[@ninaduke4759]

Pablo is one of a kind, so precious, so talented, a genius 💎🫶🔥🤘💙

[@hannaampo2151]

This is the song that made him my bias, it also hit me, I cried a lot.

[@amaykulot4352]

I can see that Josh has soft spot when it comes to depression and mental health. Not all people understand what others are going through. It's good to see people that are so caring..

[@FanMum4595]

This is why I stan Pablo, when he write song and sing it, is like digging to the “soul”. I feel every word and every sound, every beat 💙💙💙💙💙Mahalima

[@vickyrimpola5554]

Up

[@eniarralakire]

Pablo's ??? takes me back to the worst of my depression but ironically, it also heals me just because he sang what I couldn't, still cannot say.

[@julietacastillo2485]

Pablo is phenomenal. His brain works differently when it comes to music. He is always in the zone. His song and his voice can pierce one's heart.. He is awesome

[@stalepotatoes]

I agree with you👍Pablo is one of a kind.

[@vickyrimpola5554]

Up

[@JecilleChiongson]

I Agree. He's one of a kind!

[@aqua3128]

I love mahalima but what cathes me the most is the voice of Pablo..it hypnotised me.everytime he sing seems like I'm fallen deeper and deeper..his catching my soul..❤❤❤

[@breakout4347]

Pablo is an amazing singer and composer❤❤

[@maxb6570]

This song made me like Pablo A LOT. Thanks for reacting to this.

[@yaoche4761]

Pablo is a music genius! We are proud that we have him in this generation. His songs really inspired and respresent different lives and emotions. Thank you Josh and Lucas for undying support with the Filipino artists specially with SB19. The Filipinos loves you! By the way, love you shirt Josh! 🇵🇭♥️

[@angelchannel3279]

This song made me cry so hard. Idk why but there's something to pablo's voice it's amazing. I hope he will release this song.

[@roselynnel5176]

🍓🌝 Pablo is such a gifted writer. Thanks for this RV! I'm glad you reacted to this unreleased composition of his. His personal struggles had led him to write beautiful songs that were able to touch the hearts of many.

[@cherrydionesohejde3736]

Every chord, every word hits! Soooo emotional. Thank you for this RV. 😍😭Pablo 😍😍😍

[@SUNFLOWER-ei4tt]

Every time Pablo is asked if he will ever have a proper title other than “???” or release it, his usual answer is “Let’s see”. Honestly, I like it the way it is. The song is probably very personal that he’d rather keep it untitled and unreleased.

[@Eva_Reyes]

For me, it's okay even if Pablo keeps it untitled, it adds to the character of the song. But please please *please*, don't make it unreleased. I wanna add it to my spotify playlist so bad 😭

[@Mebs5683]

I like it how Pablo titled it this way. It adds to the uniqueness and character of the song.. And it is very much PABLO. Though, I'm hoping it would be one of his released singles.

[@imdreamingofawhite]

Did you notice that the clock was glitching and didn't change the whole time the song was sung? That was the set time for when he drops La Luna. So most folks were expecting La Luna to be a ballad based on this teaser and were thrown for a loop when La Luna was released.

[@mariguerre]

I loved this song since I first heard it. But your explanation about the “warping noise” you hear in your head when suffering from depression is new to me. I didn’t think I could appreciate this song more than I did. But learning how Pablo was able to capture that feeling musically, and visually too, amazes me even more.

[@jacobromeo1204]

This song has a special spot in my heart whenever I'm feeling down. Waiting for it to be released in Spotify :)

[@sheilamaebalitian6333]

Same! Hope Pablo's songs like Kumunoy and Salamangka will be released in Spotify too. ❤

[@jacobromeo1204]

@@sheilamaebalitian6333 Yes!!! I'm really hoping that he will release his amazing songs so the world will be able to discover how great those are.

[@sheilamaebalitian6333]

​@@jacobromeo1204 yeah, agreed! Kaya bias wrecker ko sya eh.

[@roselynnel5176]

​@@sheilamaebalitian6333 Same. Bias wrecker ko rin siya, lalo na nang mapanood ko sila sa interview with The Juans. Natouched ako sa stories of struggles nila pero mas naantig ako sa ikinuwento ni Pablo at doon sa love niya sa family niya.

[@wrider34]

I really think this is one of Pablo's best creation. Wish he would have released this with La Luna or at least added as an extra track with La Luna in the album so you could really feel and hear the duality/struggle of depression. That's why I'm always in awe of Pablo's creativity!❤

[@purplehatdog5796]

This and kumunoy are my personal fav. Those are my comfort songs years ago when I'm having a hard time.

[@wrider34]

@@purplehatdog5796 I haven't listened to kumunoy yet, I'll try it next time. HSH is still my fav song of them.

[@meetchona9578]

​@@wrider34 kumunoy is one of his best together with this ??? and kelan.

[@Gj-lk9ms]

This song made me choose Pablo as my bias.

[@mspatola]

🍇🌑 when Pablo's creation speaks for your own thought

[@EriTin1819]

Every time i feel lost, ill just listen to this masterpiece of pinuno and just cry like a river and after i feel like im ready to fight again❤

[@nievessalamida7086]

I love the way you annalize things and music

[@annalizkidz]

Beautifully sung👏 😍 I always love what Pablo does❤🎶. and GKD u...r... ennn..ougghh😁🎶😍

[@keunsnsn6095]

Why do i always find myself checking your uploads everyday haha

[@WonderingMando]

I would still cry over and over for that song. 😢

[@breakout4347]

When he sang accapella, wow! Thats raw emotion😢

[@fayem2187]

Im glad you guys found this Pablo's gento (gold) unreleased song. He's the genius OPM song writer of this generation.

[@mulancruz9028]

Pablo's soul on full display... i have never cried over a song but this one simply hits me.

[@jocelynflordeliza3299]

I did not notice, a tear was rolling down my cheek. That is how powerful this song was!

[@Rosh1989]

Im so glad you react to this teaser song…this is a Masterpiece song. Ive been crying over this song bcoz its just hit me in so many things!

[@pearlorient9972]

This song always hit something in my heart❤

[@Sofia-wx8ev]

This song hits hard. I don't know but it made me teary-eyed. You can feel the emotions deeply imbedded in the song. So sad😢

[@EclecticMoonBeam]

Love this song to the moon. I am conflicted as to whether it should be released or left as is. The raw quality of this recording just hits the spot and I'm hoping that quality would not diminish if ever Pablo chooses to complete the song and release it. ❤❤❤

[@stalepotatoes]

😢my heart just .... ❤ PABLO❤

[@luisablaya4497]

🍇 🌜 powerful song indeed. thank you josh, lucas, and the rest of the gkd team.

[@fridalatuwed1574]

👍🌛 thank you for checking guys 😊. He's really one of a kind, awesome ❤

[@ian_fanboy9818]

Kanta nya yan Ano title

[@fridalatuwed1574]

@@ian_fanboy9818 it's untittled song kaps. Ni-upload lang niya sa kanyang channel pero d niya nilagyan ng tittle. Search mo kaps, 2 lang naka-upload sa channel ni Pau, itong untittled (???)/unreleased song tsaka La Luna.

[@MichelleLopez-nu2fn]

Pablo is so much deeper so talented❤really admire this guy

[@febefebe7567]

That's how Alpha and powerful Pablo's music is❤❤

[@armyatinreacts]

Josh's interpretation is so spot on! 👌

[@ruelcostina9187]

🍇🌒Thank you for reacting to this song. It’s a highly emotional yet well thought out song for me. Very creative as well to stir up those emotions. Pablo’s a genius.

[@itsannph-Ener-G]

One thing I love about Pablo....hes really a good song writer 💙 Thanks again 👍

[@jeffgray8122]

I've said many times, I wish he would expand on this song. It's so good and his vocals are so emotional. It's kinda perfect in it's message.

[@lunecelesterosier]

This song is a masterpiece. Hits hard personally 💙

[@MuhammadIbrahimHashir]

Pablo has always been my bias❤🤗 I wanna give him a hug eveytime I see this. I feel you Pau, I do😢

[@mariajhane9849]

Sana marealease na tong kanta na to.super ganda

[@iAmsyoJ]

This song hits different from a person who has been there and is still there. The darkness, helplessness, not feeling and feeling everything at once. Pablo is such a gift for having feelings of those who suffered depression into words.

[@riaconradt2554]

When this came out as a teaser, I was already wondering how his single could even top this because I just loved this song and how it was presented in this “MV”. That it remains untitled and unreleased in music streaming platforms is such a pity.

[@bluebutterfly6991]

yeah, sometimes we just feel heavy inside that we don't know why, so no one can understand when that feelings reflects in our actions..

[@BingeYoutube777]

The song all throughout sounds like you're under water, until on the last word of the song, it's like you've suddenly surfaced from the water.

[@jacobromeo1204]

I hope you can also react to Pablo and Ken's cover to AKALA originally by Josue and Pablo :) also their NSYNC medley performance, Finesse cover

[@emmacampos7484]

Pablo suffered depression just before SB19…. he said “ I did unspeakable things”… hoping he would release a single of ??? … more power to your KZbin channel!

[@Helloyalaella]

It reminds me of Pablo's "Kumunoy" song.

[@jhodaveofficial5774]

thank you sir your amazing touching reaction video for PABLO.pablo is a genius guys very talented that's why pablo my ultimate bias.A'tin Fan here in Spain🌭🍓🇪🇦

[@ariadnemaun8408]

Great explanation regarding depression and how it was shown on the video. I can really relate to the message of the song that pablo wants to relay to all the listeners. And you’re right, this song is so powerful it can move mountains. Really love #sb19_pablo ❤

[@harvestmoon123]

Sir! You really is a musician interpreting every piece Pablo offers....every details, now i understand it very well...

[@nikatan312]

our PABLO ❤️❤️he's going to be a coach soon in the voice generation. . the biggest tv network here in the Philippines

[@rogerbaisac6357]

The song was so touching and it's very emotional

[@shasong4970]

This song triggers depression but at the same time it is helping the person to overcome it

[@navamaynd]

This song and "kumunoy" trigger depression, just my personal opinion. Even one reactor triggers his emotional battle when he hears kumunoy. Worst is, he reacted to it in the middle of the night that he almost not able to finish his reaction vid and cried. Pablo is an amazing and exceptional song writer and arrist.

[@shasong4970]

@@navamaynd yeah kumunoy..grabeh c pablo ilalabas nya ung inner self mo,..pati nyebe pg firstime mo xa marinig or ur in blue lalo n pg ofw k mapapabaluktot at iyak k nlang s gilid eh

[@ariesrobdiamond1794]

This song makes me cry always . It penetrates my heart.

[@ms.aime2023]

beautiful, like when you're in there and no words can come out because you're tired of not being heard....and this song of Pablo just speak on your behalf🥺,❤💛💚💯

[@franbungatosmith5462]

I watched this yesterday and loved your reaction to it. I came back on here to say that I wish Pablo would put out a longer version of this song as a single release, because I love this style, his voice and the guitar. Pablo is a musical genius!

[@KueenG27]

Cute so colorful this time, nice hair and shirts😊

[@RoseJavier-p4d]

pablo super amazing💪💪🙌🙌❤

[@ChaChai-vd3qu]

That three minutes and one sec open up all may kept emotions half of my life.

[@yayangmanix2758]

Omg Pablo of S 19! I feel the emotions, interpretation and so raw song! I wanna cry but in a good way that he express himself! And I love the song!❤❤❤

[@SeendyLao]

I still remember when he suddenly changed his profile in all his social media accts. We thought something bad happened, but then he dropped this, and everyone went wild. Goosebumps, I was so emotional that time 😭🫶 really loved this song so much. I can't wait for Pablo to release his other songs.

[@iamjny]

remember Pablo saying on one of his vlog or interview that he has has a box full of unreleased songs, this is just one of them... sheeeshh! he's a gem.

[@anjagalan6905]

I really love this song. Every time I hear this, I become emotional. The mwlody, the lyrics, the video. 😢😢😢😢 ❤❤❤❤

[@shobe071592]

🍇🌘 Pablo did say in an interview(I forgot which one) that he didn't want a normal teaser for his solo. And then this was born... 😅😂

[@GKDLABELS]

Thank you so much for watching!

[@nilfalarido566]

I feel like crying!!!! It really hits my heart!

[@clarieberrychannel1819]

He created this song as a teaser. Knowing A'tin will guess the genre he's going to drop, he created a teaser that is opposite of Laluna so that when Laluna drops, we will be surprised and he succeeded. But this song hits the spot. We requested him to finish the song.❤❤❤❤❤

[@dzuliej18]

And he did it successfully, we are all shocked when we finally heard La Luna 😅

[@mork_skie5112]

Love this song, Pablo 💙

[@skyllercaitlyn2755]

This is so good and hits different ❤ I'm waiting for pablo to release this one...

[@dnmark09]

Still gives the chills and tears to my eyes.

[@iam_elaine]

I remember when in one of the live chats you had, you talked about your own bouts of depression and I suggested you check Pablo's ??? cause definitely you'll relate to it...I too had my own days to hurdle and indeed it resonates with me. Try to check Pablo's "Kumunoy" one of his unreleased songs also, many have commented and thanked Pablo for that song and it saved them. Thanks for the RV. You 2 are always great!

[@cookielumantas6814]

Thanks for the RV. This song pierces my heart every time I listen to it.

[@julietalwassia8142]

Oh my God! I can feel the pain. Whatever pain one is going through, it is worth sharing with people you love, you trust to lessen the burden. It is twice as hard when you are alone.

[@patzzyn77]

so true, Pablo described depression to the tee

[@divine14344]

This song always makes me cry... This hits so different..... This is my trigger song actually.... But you guys know what... This is where LA Luna will follow up... La Luna is my healing song 😁

[@luzesperanzatuquib9547]

Very emotional song, how deep! 😪🥺🤔😢

[@chimm7566]

Pablo 😮😮

[@CeciHarmonyRimando]

Goosebumps for real,whenever i hear this song.Makes me want to sit down in the corner and just cry😢

[@heididelosreyes6588]

😢This brought me to tears..😢😢😢♥️

[@reimicaiah1010]

i wish pablo will complete this song... i really like it

[@mitchlorenzana2569]

🍇🌚 Thanks for this review, definitely powerful how Pablo was able to deliver this so simply yet impacting. Glad you appreciate this Josh and Lucas

[@bronemz7082]

you will not imagine him being the main rapper of SB19..

[@chrys1146]

This hits hard. Also, I am still waiting for Kumunoy to be released.

[@CuteLass]

One of my top faves.

[@atinteachershiela6210]

This song of Pablo hits me diffrently. It ends me crying..😢

[@cagalliathla1201]

🍇 🌚 I have seen in my notifs that you finally reacted to this song but i didn't watched it right away and actually have no plan of watching it because i might tear up again but i was really curious what are your thoughts . Josh knows what is this all about and the exact feeling of being in that dark zone letting us know we are not alone in this battle and there are people who understands and care. Thank you for this rv ❤😊

[@sketchielab5687]

First time I listened to this I cried,,,He captured how it feels to be hopeless and feeling helpless

[@cyeshe1543]

Everytime i hear this song of Pablo my heart beats faster.

[@travelfunandbeyond]

I’m proud of Pablo! ❤

[@AQ8975]

❤❤❤Pablo ❤❤❤SB19

[@zackmm2358]

I was crying while listening the whole song, it deg up all my pain inside my heart, like i want someone to hug me 😢

[@nanetteromano6174]

yehey atlast you react on this Song ❤❤❤❤

[@rosemariesendin2102]

PABLOOOOO🥺🥺🔥🔥🔥💙💙

[@iam_bear05]

Pablo please release this song of yours. . . ❤