Prof. Subhash Kak on how Panini made Sanskrit powerful.

[@vijayalakshmiaacharya8644]

I'm a Sanskrit teacher and I'm totally disappointed the way parents want their children to study German, French... Schools also offer these foreign languages with great pride. Unfortunately there are just 2 periods to teach sanskrit in lower classes in majority of the schools. Both parents and students opt Sanskrit for studying just to increase their percentage. Right from basic things of life to the highest level where a human being would reach ie spirituality everything is there in Sanskrit. In this wide spectrum of knowledge comes all branches of Science and Maths. It would not be exaggeration if I told that we knew everything about aeronautics,shipbuilding, astronomy, plastic surgery, atomic power.... the list is unending. It has the power to cure various speech related problems. If I have to put it in nut shell without much delay study SANSKRIT. As Prof.Subhash rightly said there several thousands of text wherein lie the invaluable knowledge which has to be explored. Let us not waste time.

[@mojorisin08]

It is just Economics. Once America falls down, Samskrutam will spread rapidly

[@sukhjohal8998]

By all means learn as many languages but love your mother language and don't lose it

[@nnrchk1288]

Sir, Thanks for giving your views, as a Sanskrit teacher. Now in Jagruth Bharat, there is lot of rejuvenation happening to bring back the glory of Sanskrit. Sir ,be in touch with activities and add whatever contribution you can offer.

[@alkashrivastava1467]

@@mojorisin08 We should not wait for some body's decline so that we may rise .

[@mojorisin08]

@@alkashrivastava1467 no I think you are wrong there. All changes happen as a reaction to fill a void. As long as English fills that vacuum, there will be no « necessity » to learn Samskrutam. The void can be filled in two ways: eIther when America becomes economically irrelevant or when India decides to adopt Sanskrit as the sole official language of India as well as all the regional languages as official languages at the State level. The first option is more foreseeable than the second. Hence my comment.

[@vinayaktraders72]

Chinmaya International foundation CIF at veliyanad - Kerala preserves old manuscripts in the most scientific manner.

[@premalathakkunakat5388]

What's the use when majority look the otherside

[@premalathakkunakat5388]

@@mpramarao57 well said. We have to start thinking of our great culture. I am doing my best by telling everyone the greatness of our culture and to preserve our great environment. My heart bleeds when I see all the great temples deprived of maintenance our heritage. Our children don't even know any of these wonderful past. I hope and pray all like minded people help preserve this great scientific culture of HINDUISM. JAI SHRI RAM. JAI SHRI KRISHNA. PRANAMS TO ALL GREAT GURUS

[@theowleyes07]

M Menon I studied in one of the best Chinmaya Vidyalaya, Chinmaya BOKARO and I take pride what Swami Chinmayanand has done for the society. But sad to see the situation in Kerala where people are giving votes on the basis that they can eat Beef.

[@kshetragaur9191]

My infinite Sashtanga Dandvat Pranama to both Shree Iyer and Prof Subhash Kak for highlighting the importance of Sanskrit and Panini's grammar whch are suitable for computer use as a master language and not English. May Paramatma bless everyone with the knowledge of ancient and scientific language Sanskrit and its grammar by Maharishi Panini.

[@rajendrasinghbutola9217]

Very insightful and inspirational. संस्कृत भाषा is the core of Bharat. Without core, we are nothing. This beautiful language is finding respect now.

[@VaidyanathanPurushothaman]

This is what i have been advocating for over a decade now to utilize temple for higher purpose of advancing hindu faith, creative endeavors and advanced learning than using those for material purpose for shops. I also had the opportunity to meet Dr. Nagaswamy at Kanchi months ago and we chated for over two hours. He has the depth of knowledge.

[@devashishchauhan9857]

Sanskrit is language affects brain and heart with same intensity

[@RamKumar-kx3qj]

You right sir it's universal knowledge but world should also praise it's origin and talk about it

[@nnrchk1288]

I appreciate your concern. But this works starts,the source origin of is taken care automatically.

[@namrataverma3075]

Love professor Kak and Sree Iyer's conversations. Dhanyawadah to both of you 🙏🙏🙏

[@ca.smitapramanik3308]

The golden civilization on d earth is Hinduism

[@historian2]

Can a civilization be considered golden when a small fraction of its people mistreated majority of its people by labelling them as Shudras and untouchables? I don't think so. What is more perplexing that even in 21st century when such caste based oppression should have no place at all, this system of oppression still persists. Why?

[@vsn1333]

@@historian2 oho there was varna vyavastha which was by deeds but not by birth go snd watch neeraj atri channel. He is exposing lies of ncert written by communists. U people are so pessimistic thst u can only see negatives in India. Truth us that whole world had this upper class lower class discrimination. Don't try to demean rhe great Indian civilization. Read true history nit the history written by clonial masters. In France there were many groups which they treated like untouchables and impure like that. But bcoz selective and cherry picking analysis u can blame ur own country. Every country has this problem. Get out from that slave mentality or Colonial mindset. Actually In the whole world some Indian people only try to defame their own culture bcoz of shitty colonial, distorted, Indian education system which brainwashed them to think india is bad or something.but the truth us totally opposite to it.which produces inferiority Complex in them which ur comment reflects. . And creates colonial puppets like u. Means ignorant, less informed people will only comment like that hadd hain yaar. Matlab seriously.

[@historian2]

@@vsn1333 The fact that 80% of your post is ad hominem attack,it means you don't have a cogent argument. You cite example of France and elsewhere as justification of oppression and exploitation of overwhelming majority of Hindus, 85% of them, at the hand of a small cabal of so called "upper caste", do you even know that France had to undergo a revolution, the "French Revolution", to purge itself of such oppressors and exploiters? India has still a long way to go. Even in 21st century on the average on daily basis 5 Dalit women are raped and 2 Dalit men are murdered.

[@vsn1333]

@@historian2 don't peddle fake news here. I think u follow some libtards and all. And in Islam also there is this problem. Earlier it was not like that go and watch neeraj atri channel. It was based on deeds not by birth. And what I said in earlier comment is truth. U pessimists can only see negatives in India whereas in USA there is a whole group of white supremacist. And a high level of racism is still going on. And I'm not brainwashed like u to abuse my own great culture. But what I said is bitter truth. Brainwashed people like u with slave mentality will only abuse our culture ur a perfect puppet of ur colonial masters. And I mentioned earlier it was not based on birth in ancient times. Some shameless Indians like u will always find a way to demean our culture. In many parts of the world that caste thing is still there And there was no ad hominem attack. If u look at it carefully my all arguments are a bitter truth. I think u got that. Brainwashed idiot. Hmm

[@vsn1333]

@@historian2 and my whole comment is a bitter truth u cannot digest it. That's y u are making excuses. And not justifying it. I'm saying by any means u people have to demean India. U judged me that I'm justifying it how do u know means seriously. Ok I r saying even in this time. Ok listen in USA there are many many white supremacist and racism on blacks even to this day u ignorant don't know thing u will write to show that ur correct. U should read once more what have I written. I'm again it applies on u and it's a bitter truth. U people are living in ur dreamworld nothing else foolish LOL

[@MrSirAussie]

MUST RECLAIM & RECORD IT SOON : Very in depth and fascinating analysis. Thanks.....unfortunately all has been lost, destroyed by the invaders and still being decimated by the brutal leftists and the brain washed radicals....... NEXT EPISODE...KOREAN ORIGINATED FROM TAMIL LANGUAGE ..Appreciate if you could please provide your thoughts on the fascinating similarities in language between Korean language and Tamil. There are over 2000 words similar in Korean spoken/written words and there traditional dance has an uncanny resemblance to Tamil dances.

[@mindfreakmovies9586]

I hope something positive is happening in our era and I wish, in my grandson's era they study in Sanskrit medium with modern subjects. Also, please understand the difference between Western and Modern. Science & Mathematics are not a gift of Western people, but it is the gift of modern human beings.

[@venkatraman7396]

Shree Iyer and Subash Kak - saadar pranaam! You have discussed a topic that is close to my heart! I believe that the arrangement of Maheshwara Sutras is such that it must have been of Divine origin. Soundarya Lahari says that the 64 tantras were caused to be brought to the earth by Shiva. No wonder many, many spiritual texts start as a conversation between Shiva and Shakthi. Many others like Natya Shastra owe its existence to Shiva. The more I study the more I am amazed at the blessings Shiva has poured on humanity - not the least of which is the Ganga from his matted locks. I belong to the Shrautha-Smartha tradition which considers Shiva and Vishnu as one. Shri Rama is my Ishta. But Shiva is no less my Ishta. Man's aesthetic sense, left to itself, would find a lowly pit as the water does. Shiva's direct blessings throughout the ages can be seen written large on any work that tries to uplift this to sublime levels.

[@definitionjoint]

As a game developer, I can say i see the similarity between c# and Sanskrit.. not exactly Sanskrit but my language konkani that uses a lot of Sanskrit grammar and it's very similar so I could make my first game (as a test) within 15days and even publish on play store.. it's called Bharat circus biker.. Also Subhash sir has a very infectious smile/laugh 🙏🙏☺️❤️

[@riyasawant7173]

Are u Goan

[@GTR-93]

I'M KONKANI TOO FROM KARWAR

[@rmnair90]

Did you write the game in C#? Or was it Konkani?

[@sanathanadharmama]

Hi buddy cani talk to u

[@definitionjoint]

@@sanathanadharmama do you mean me? If so, yea you can 👍

[@srinivasangokul300]

Temple as a community center concept is easy to understand. Try to spend at least one hour soaking in the temple, instead of “Jarigandi fast track” darshan. Talk to the archakas and kainkaryatharas, you will be surprised at their knowledge. Reviving community programs in temples is again easy. E.g have a couple of baratanatyam dance programs in Kapaliswarar temple instead of TTK academy and Karnatic music concerts at Parthasarathy temple instead of Naradha Gaana Sabha. Moot point WILL HRCE ALLOW?

[@premalathakkunakat5388]

Well thought

[@premalathakkunakat5388]

@Bubbly Srinath srinivasan sir pl

[@diashetty7919]

It's so enlightening and enriching to watch such videos on our past Indian history. As well as brings a pride in us.

[@digitalnomad5643]

I was computer science student and a non-Indian. Wished I knew about this and had the opportunity to learn Sanskrit when I was in the undergraduate days.

[@swaroopramakrishna6894]

@SreeIyer1 excellent work again from PGURUS. The quality of audio and video are much improved now. Temple like you mentioned were much more than just puja sthala, in addition go to the things you already sighted they were many other things taking place in temples. Sanjeev Sanyal has also written books on it and Srijan foundation talks are available too. Temples functioned as banks, trade finance including shipping was done, chola kings used to provide seed money and guilds were stored in temples. There are samples of copper guilds found during excavation. This one evidence shows how advanced we were in 1. Trade. 2. Finance 3.sea faring 4. state craft (especially at keeping state money and Kings segregated). Temples were also a natural community shelter at the time of war, famine or any natural disasters, records of Vijayanagara empire prove this. There is much more to be proud of our past that what Romula Thapur would have us believe. Jai Ramji Ki

[@bujgavna]

Thank you for the great work and extremely expensive knowledge.

[@ajkumar6013]

My family is from Bihar, now settled in Mumbai - our children are exposed to Marathi, and i can say with practical experience that modern Marathi is very close to Sanskrit in grammar, script, pronunciation as compared to any Indian language.

[@MarjorieBakre]

Panini's work on Sanskrit grammar is remarkable for its perfection in terms of coverage of the enormously diverse Skt vocabulary which is based on a relatively small number of "roots" (dhaatu-s). It is such a work that the rules of the grammar are described or presented according to such a grand design that knowledge of these rules is undoubtedly a big attraction for all devoted to the advancement of computer programming. For this reason it may not be quite precise to call Panini's work (ASHTAADHYAAYEE) with a restrictive name as grammar. (These rules, by the way were employed with ease and great power by, ever so many Indian thinkers and philosophers in various fields through centuries to communicate their profound thoughts or to produce great literature).. By contrast there is no match to Panini's masterpiece and concepts and their succinct formulation in any other language, of tge world, ancient or modern. Of course, as Dr Kak says, Panini creatively draws upon some earlier allied works such as Nirukta of Yaska. It is a great leap forward from all works that can be categorised with some justice along with Panini. We owe a deep debt of gratitude with our sincere appreciation to Dr Kak (and the interviewer) for enabling the right understanding of this topic with his lucid exposition.

[@suryaprakash5992]

Spreading the knowledge of Sanskrit through pathshalas are already in practice at various MATTHA's in south India by many many Swamijis. viz TTD, SHANKARA MATTHA & Baba Ramdev etc etc. It is truly not gaining the desired pace & publicity due to poor political will by the Govt authorities to propagate the same. However i must place on record Sri Siddharth Kak has given some very good insight about root of PANINI GRAMMAR in Sanskrit . I wish this channel of Pgurus to have some more lecture series to know about the SUTRAS & some more interesting episodes. There is a village near SHIMOGA called "mathhur" Hosahalli on the banks of river Thunga where 100% sanskrit is spoken in their daily life by all students & teachers & others.

[@12440jayjay]

Revival of Hindu mind and spirit is in making. It may take some time but surly we will break the shackles of colonial mind and rejuvenate the our glory of the past. I pray you all to join this valiant efforts lead by several prominent scholars and help the cause.

[@katyayansarkar3697]

True

[@me_nobody.]

This is an amazing content. We need to promote the study of Sanskrit and paanini's great works in schools and colleges so that our nation excels in the fields of science and understands our rich heritage. I strongly believe Sanskrit will be the future in science and technology. Thanks PGuru. 🙏

[@enjoyparents]

SIRJI ,it's a fantastic idea ( thasthu) that every temple in India STARTS MODERN gurukul or schools with the intention of the educating OUR NEW GENERATION of high self ESTEEM youths learning all streams of education ( modern n ancient) n as you said even virtual university parallel from that location of each temple where students from all over the world came together to learn n speard the fantastic knowledge which is NOT a monopoly or patent of just one person but belongs to whole humanity . It will also channalise the money or funds from temples which currently is going to one general POT where it goes to benifit minority religions n their BREAK INDIA agenda . Thanks to secret amendments made by Nehru / indra Gandhi family! The info u provided shows why Sanskrit texts from the best excepted language by computers as the software was already developed by scholars like panini ! Chinmaya mission university is clear example of this venture. Baba ram dev s university is one more but all these needs expansion . India rather BHARAT did this huge task of educating masses thro gurukul universities before 1500 yrs ago , now let's start that task again. It is our DUTY towards humanity .

[@varunp601]

Happy that Sri Dharam pal name came up, till now i had only heard in Sri Rajeev Dixit's speech

[@arunade1168]

Need to be revived as soon as possible for bright future of the Nation 🌹🙏🌹

[@ashalivarma4623]

Fascinating. We must introduce all such great people in our history books. We have been deprived by not knowing our great heritage. We need to teach this to future generations.

[@lajwantishahani1225]

One of the best discussions I have heard in a very long time!

[@shubhamsharma6001]

Subhash kak was wonderful telling brilliant stuff.

[@22051973jigu]

Very glad to learn more about our rich heritage.

[@DB-ji7pr]

We need Indian scholars who are Sanskrit and Computer learnt to start from basics and we start using in computers. This need to be done by Indians only.

[@DattaBurra]

I like the whole interview process and content. Pl keep this is style, like original dd interview use to be.

[@shivamumbai1]

Sanscruit is a very perfect language it explore the subject within own pure self, full of complate knowledge, like that of a Google search engine what you type, the related matter appear on screen.A famous mantra is very much popular as ' Yo vedadow swaro prokto vedantecha pratistitaha, tasya prakruti linasya ya parasya Maheshwara.' A journey from shabdha to Braman.

[@HackSparrrowakaSicario]

Just coming here after the puzzle was solved 🙏

[@laxtaparia]

THANKS TO PROF. SUBHASH KAK. Valuable information. No surprise, that Language Sanskrit has been selected as MOST COMPUTER FRIENDLY LANGUAGE after doing thorough research by NASA of USA with 200 languages of whole world during last 20 years. USA Govt. is at present giving liberal grants, now a days to Universities of America for spending on teaching SANSKRIT. Talking computer of TIME TO COME, is going to be with SANSKRIT LANGUAGE , is decision of NASA OF USA. What I foresee in coming times, is a severe un met demand for computer engineers, who know Sanskrit, as well. Problem which I foresee, is those who are masters in computer engineering, do not know Sanskrit. And those who know Sanskrit , do not know computer engineering.

[@GururajBN]

Laxminarayan Taparia - I have been hearing this bunkum for forty plus years. Yet to see a software developed in Sanskrit, the computer friendly language. Do you know any? Has anyone seen the so-called NASA research report?

[@sukhino4475]

Temples were not meant for religion alone. The philosophy of Indian life ,economic activities,distribution of income through avowed objectives of the people and their specialisation like sculptors, peasants, livestock keepers, musicians and other folk artists, specialists in carpentry relating to temple,cars,chariots,palanquin bearers, etc. Every one specialised in the intrinsic knowledge of the family trade, kula dharma,like gold smith,iron smith etc..Which was not written down but learnt under the tutlege of the teacher and the pupil, on the spot learning, explanation, experimental knowledge, prasnothara style asking and allowing freedom of expression history can reveal of the foreign invaders looted the land ,not only India but other countries like Vietnam, Arabia, Australia,Etc..For their selfish gratification, misplaced ideologies, unquestionable and unchallenged so called war policies and deployment. Even then we are measuring our intelligence,prosperity and Happiness index based on British or US equivalent, assassinating pur own strength of ancient wisdom, humanity...

[@Shriya-pp1vw]

Sanskrit should be the national language of india

[@nwstfd]

🙏🙏 Pranam Subhash Sir

[@nahushpise]

This information is so grand🙏🙏🙏🙏

[@rmnair90]

Prof Kak should define a programming language using Sanskrit grammar and Sanskrit words for reserved words.

[@ranganathabs8988]

Please do these discussions in local Indian language to help the locals as well

[@meenak3351]

This channel is English for every state to understand. Stop monopolizing it selfishly

[@ashoksharma31]

Sanskrit would cover our whole country simultaneously revive our ancient knowledge

[@naiyayika]

Your comment is as hollow as your initials in your name.

[@bish-jyag3371]

Panini was from Arghakhachi of Nepal

[@Jocjabes]

It would be splendid to have a technical discussion of ashtadhyayi and tolkappiyam noting specific features, similarities, differences and style. Thirukkural is also written in verses.

[@Arbutham-e6k]

Please buy the book "Tholkapyam and Ashtathyayi" by Dr. K Meenakshi. Published by international Institute of tamil. This book is extraordinary which compares the tamil and sanskrit Grammer sutra wise.

[@naiyayika]

@@Arbutham-e6k Who cares? Why in this video? Shameless toxic Timils bringing in a language that no one even knows. Sanskrit is respected worldwide, no one even knows Tanil, whereas sanskrit is taught in many universities in India and abroad and still spoken by 2 million people. What is Tinil? I don't know. "But it's still old.... Keezhadi..." LMAO

[@sanatanananta2100]

Quietly Sri Iyer tried pushing Tamil as the language created Shiva, where as no historian and archeologist were able to prove Tamil to be oldest and every evidence suggests Kannada to be old and Tamil is extract of Halegannada and Pali

[@swaroopramakrishna6894]

He did not push anything, anywhere. He merely sighted a common folklore. I am a kannadiga myself and live in TN for the past 10 years. There is a need for such messages as the hate for samskritam is rabit here and young minds are poisoned to hate our own past. So let us please be gratuitous in these little matters and not find faults with a handful of us who are actually doing something to improve the situation. He did not push it as a fact, so do not twist it as some hidden agenda.

[@Dharmicaction]

@@swaroopramakrishna6894 But, graciousness should not lead to adharma (untruth). Tamil and malayalam are the oldest "kaliyuga" language (originated after 4000 BC) Other vernaculars came later. Before 4000 BC, there was only sanskrit (as a spoken language) in the world. But of course, sanskrit also represents vibrations which created this universe. It is the reason why sanskrit mantras cannot be replaced by tamil or any other regional language mantras in hindu temples

[@Dharmicaction]

Tamil and Malayalam are the oldest "kaliyuga" language (originated after 4000 BC). Other vernaculars came later. Before 4000 BC, there was only sanskrit (as a spoken language) in the world. But of course, sanskrit also represents vibrations which created this universe. It is the reason why sanskrit mantras cannot be replaced by tamil or any other regional language mantras in hindu temples

[@swaroopramakrishna6894]

No one is debating those points, @SreeIyer1 did not say any such thing. He merely mentioned a folklore.

[@braveindian4870]

Bharatiya Rashtrabhasha should be Sanskrit

[@ugc1784]

We indians as well as the British administrators were the people who must be held responsible for wrapping up our treasure trove heritage with a red cloth and tuck it somewhere it does see the light of the sun. Just see what scholars, who very often were not favourably disposed towards Indian cultural heritage but at the same time could not help admiring it's deep esoteric knowledge say about Panini & his works: "Whatever people may say, no one knows Sanskrit, who does not know Panini".-------Max Müller "The descriptive grammar of Sanskrit, which Pāṇini brought to its perfection, is one of the greatest monuments of human intelligence and an indispensable model for the description of languages".-----Leonard Bloomfield, 1929 "The Grammatical system elaborated by native (ancient) Grammarians, is in itself most perfect, and those who have tested Panini's work will readily admit, that there is no Grammar in any language, that could vie with the wonderful mechanism of his eight books of Grammatical rules"-------Max Müller

[@JuztMeMe]

It would be great if we could revive the Temple tradition! 🙏🏽

[@rajeshbs946]

Thanks for providing good knowledge.

[@Truthwilltriumph01]

amazing, thanks a lot.

[@ashoksharma31]

Sanskrit teaching and our traditional and cultural programs to be organized by temple's

[@singularsink]

@pGurus which tempe in the Bay Area? Will really appreciate if you can please share the details...

[@nagarajankrishnaswamy1044]

Forget doing anything in Tamil Nadu, it is a state which is totally against anything in Sanskrit

[@LK30j]

Amazing!!

[@canarese]

He should have used terms such as "Compiler" which is the base of processing programming language.

[@Shivam-kf6mj]

Southern ricebags must see this video

[@theifclips]

Ricebags ?🤔

[@manojkothwal3586]

#Free_Hindu_Temples Bháráthà will emerge like a Megalith.

[@braveindian4870]

Aryasamaj claims they were hiding Viman Shastra. They also claim to be in possession of unadulterated versions of Brahmanas Arayanakad, etc.

[@eartherian]

Great topic and great personality but only a little time was spent talking about Panini and majority was about other topics.

[@kparag01]

Kak is expert on this

[@stonethelifetoo3542]

My friend is from attock birth place of panini in KPK and Punjab border on the bank of Indus river, now destroyed and only few ruins are left out as per him. So we almost lost Sanskrit and hard intelligent work of panini. Which new gen people know about all these. Our own people destroyed our history culture and values. Thanks for identifying and debating on this topic

[@HariMahadevanKoovapady]

Excellent session, though I would've liked the Prof to go a little deep into how the made the connection between Panini's works and Turing machine. Perhaps that's for another session, exclusively for the nerdy audience! I have one question, assuming that @pgurus or Prof.Kak follows these comments: I have read about the secret society of nine men setup by Emperor Asoka to accumulate and preserve the know-how of the times for future generations. Is this a myth? What are the chances that some of the original Sanskrit works are still with the present-day families of these men? Thank you!

[@krishnakumar-uh3gu]

Professor Yamuna Kachru of linguistics was also from Kashmir.

[@sidhunp]

Govt is not going to do anything. If you want cultural revival and reverse conversions, temples and priests should start more outreach to community without thinking on jati. One main reason evangelists are successful is the image of great community support around churches, which is lost in temples

[@KathaaSagar]

On Patanjali, were there 2 of them? There seems to be Patanjali constrained poetry related to chidambaram.

[@lokeeb1486]

Watch ex KGP employee saying how he manipulated indian history with help of academician, n bollywood.... Yuri Benzo with Edward g Griffin

[@rajeshroshan2877]

This was a bit disappointing, I would've appreciated if they had gone into a little bit of light theory to explain the connection between Sanskrit and computer science.

[@rajeshkumarsanghai]

Basudev Sharan Agrawal's " Panini Kalin Bharatvarsha " ofcoures in Hindi is to be read .

[@advaitanundoo3587]

Vedic Knowledge and devnagari Sanskrit and its slight variance called Vedic Sanskrit existed since the beginning of creation. Srila Krsna Dvaipayana Vyasadeva put all the scriptures in written form in the Dvapara Yuga about 5500 years ago. The western viewpoint has dominated the Indian educational , political and social system and destroyed our rich timeless culture....

[@vimalkantdave1060]

Fourteen sutras came out of Damru. These encompass all the vowels and consonants in groups, designed such that all grammatical rules govern any group or their specific combinations .

[@rachelgeorge6294]

Vimal Kant Dave Is it true that Tamil Pali language is the origin of all languages

[@Arbutham-e6k]

Tamil is one of the six oldest language existed before five BC. Languages originated from tamil are kannada, malayalam and telugu.

[@naiyayika]

@@Arbutham-e6k Who cares? Why in this video? Shameless toxic Timils bringing in a language that no one even knows. Sanskrit is respected worldwide, no one even knows Tanil, whereas sanskrit is taught in many universities in India and abroad and still spoken by 2 million people. What is Tinil? I don't know. "But it's still old.... Keezhadi..." LMAO

[@GururajBN]

Dear viewers, Are you any the wiser about Panini, after listening to this prattle? These people with computer science degree and doctorates think that they have The Tool for analysing everything in Sanskrit. They are amateurs dabbling in Sanskrit. The interviewer seemed even less prepared to ask the right questions. There’s one such US-returned computer scientist in Bengaluru who has been translating Vedas to English.his translations are incomprehensible, as he has abandoned traditional interpretation in favour of his own reading of Vedas, supposedly based also on Sri Aurobindo’s views on the Vedas. Little wonder that these amateurs are ridiculed and mocked by western Sanskrit scholars like Michael Wetzel, Wendy Donniger, and Sheldon Pollock. Much as one may dislike their views, they have deep Sanskrit scholarship which they are using for polemics against India, especially the Hindus.

[@SaurabhSharma-uo6np]

This channel is very informative and very good . But I doubt most of the Indians would not be able to follow this level of intellectual conversation. Mass follow simple conversations. Our ancient scriptures are full of knowledge but difficult to read and understand . Also it is not taught in school , colleges. There are 2 things 1) there should be school and college for this knowledge 2) conversation should be addressed to masses.

[@prakashhegde8920]

shivbaba is the Godfather who is practically transforming this patit bhrastachari narka into Pawan shresrachari Devta heavenly world the divine work is going this the peak time written in Bhagwat Geeta that Godfather descends on earth on Dharma glani

[@swarnamohanty3121]

If Panini started Sanskrit in 6th century BC., then Ramayan and Mohabharat were written after 6th century BC.

[@b.m.5068]

Sanskrit wasn't started in 6th century It was long back He gave the linguistics foundation for classical Sanskrit Before that Vedic Sanskrit was into use

[@Arbutham-e6k]

Before panini therewhere nine school of Grammer. Ramayana and mahabaratha were written with Grammer. Anjaneya is also called Navavyagarana panditha. Pannini unified various grammer sect into one system. Now we srudy ramayana with panini grammer and some minor variation were observed.

[@sharmishthamukherjee9820]

That is Maheshwar sutra,came out of damaroo played by shiva.

[@reetakamath6418]

Wonderful insights into our power

[@haritham4495]

Panini from Kashmir,, really we must laugh to this ,at this point of Indian history....nice information sir...

[@HokageMihir]

Not Panini, Patanjali

[@drirrinkis]

Sir first thing is to have proper sublitile i think google is killing it

[@agentravi00007]

I have read in ncert books.temple architecture have been popular in 9 th centuries. As per my knowledge there is no idol worship in vedic period. May be you are right but most of the history books are derived from the discovery of india jawharlal nehru book. Some time we get confused every one is interpreted own personal belief and faith. It is difficult to believe who is right and wrong

[@anon-tp4ns]

You are reading History book manufactured by Socialist leftist commies , whose main purpose was to demolish the greatness of Indian culture. Nehru a fraud Hindu was big hater if Hinduism and darling of British , his entire clan has damaged Indian education system. Go and research who is historian writing your history book , their background .You will know what is truth. Go watch KGB video where they explain how they demolished Indian history . Hi and read about Maccaully education system. Irony of India is that Computer scientist and Engineers have to talk about research in language in History while our dumb low IQ history and art student are gulping Western fraud in name of Education.

[@satheeshkumar6865]

🙏🙏🙏

[@KK-gc5lj]

Human language can be used to influence the behavior. Thats why the westerners are having a violent mindset compared to desi mindset.

[@mdkumarz]

4:67 onwards for the subject of the title

[@AJ-fo3hp]

If they teach panini there is no laboratory where you can appreciate what you learnt. Don't underestimate present higher technical education(degree and above) system, evaluation technology should be step by step with proof(without proof blind belief will not survive for long time like sun rises in east,set in west but proof says sun never rise or set sun position is fixed, earth rotate) As in wikipedia "Kak has argued that there are limits to artificial intelligence and that it cannot equate the biological equivalent." Do you agree with this argument.if you agree his statement then no value for research because if wright brothers thought that there is no element which thinner than air which could lift, they would not developed If Shubash Kak talks hours togther without his actual work of proof it would be beating around the bush People are telling there is viman vidya( Aeroplane technology) in yajurveda why our matth ( मठ) didn't tried this, why learner in matth ( मठ) are not able to extract ancient vehicles like pushpak viman may be thier thinking ability restricted by memorizing by chanting without knowing the meaning ( probably older generations think if veda teach or learnt with meaning it would've difficult to remember the vast vedas' in short life time they may started by teaching without meaning, they found another means of teaching as Krama pata Jata pata Ghana pata) In engineering technology (degree and above) teach the subject with applied mathematics there is no remember

[@JuztMeMe]

🙏🏽🙏🏽

[@srinathtk86]

Agreed. But for most of the Indians the fundamental problem is Rozi roti Kapada makan... today they are learning English French and German coz they are desperate to migrate . In the coming years Indians will be running around to learn Chinese because China is going to overtake the west and USA. Can’t blame Indians at all because that’s our system and our system shows our culture 😂

[@vinodrawat6160]

🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏

[@robinsonekka3528]

Subhash Kak is genius but while during talk aa aaaa Aaee too much of pause distracts the flow of concentrate.

[@yashthakare2059]

Why don't you mention that he was awarded Padma Shree m

[@जिज्ञासुऔरज्ञानानंद]

tell me something how I can make a compiler in the Sanskrit language

[@rohitmishra8745]

Learn ANTL4 parser generator(which allows UTF characters) where you can specify the grammar rules. Use LLVM for compiler backend. It generates for ARM, x86, PowerPC etc.

[@lokeshmohan__I_am__]

I think these guys do not know about the pundits of Mithila Or deliberately ignoring this glorious tradition of knowledge.

[@GTR-93]

AFTER 20-30 YRS WE'LL SEE SANSKRIT IN U.S SCHOOLS. BUT INDIA WILL BE THE SAME FUCKED COUNTRY

[@shankarcg786]

In South India in vaithieeswaran temple there is script's for Nadi astrology are still written in Palm leaves with a iron pen known as "yadu aani" in tamil There is one Vishnu temple "kachan kurchi" in kollengode palghat, kerala which is named after rishi kashyapa. Wherein he did penance in the mountains. The rajas of kollengode were the patrons of the temple for 1000s of years.

[@naiyayika]

Who cares? Why in this video? Shameless toxic Timils bringing in a language that no one even knows. Sanskrit is respected worldwide, no one even knows Tanil, whereas sanskrit is taught in many universities in India and abroad and still spoken by 2 million people. What is Tinil? I don't know. "But it's still old.... Keezhadi..." LMAO

[@ilalalit5863]

Please these people who r give grand Hindu sermon on Hindu culture in the u tube ... r living a broad if anyone destroyed the Hindu cultures is the Hindus them selves

[@ningskieph6120]

This great content i support u keep safe stay connected hope u do the same

[@akshayabatdasguru6414]

कृपया हिंदी भाषा में समझाए ।

[@DipakBose-bq1vv]

Panini was not the inventor of computer. It is streaching too far.

[@Dharmicaction]

Computer hardware invented by our white masters. But the root ideas for software development came directly from vedas through panini, pingala and others

[@CD-123]

🤣🤣🤣🤣 don't argue with these illiterate minions.... They r just dumb

[@CD-123]

@@DipakBose-bq1vv 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 why you are so brutal.....why u break their heart so bad 😁😁😁😁😂

[@The3181954]

పాణిని ప్రపంచ మేధావుల లో ముందు వరుసలో ఉంటారు. అష్టాధ్యాయి ఒక్కటి చాలు.భారతదేశాన్ని జగద్గురు స్థానం లో అభిషేకించటానికి.

[@RohitSharma-mi8gt]

Tamizh chauvinists Pose Tamizh as equal to sanskrit !

[@naiyayika]

It's not equal, it's nothing. Who cares? Why in this video? Shameless toxic Timils bringing in a language that no one even knows. Sanskrit is respected worldwide, no one even knows Tanil, whereas sanskrit is taught in many universities in India and abroad and still spoken by 2 million people. What is Tinil? I don't know. "But it's still old.... Keezhadi..." LMAO

[@omkarthorat8993]

Hindi me bolneme dukta hai ka

[@mailsrinivas81]

Sir Why are you having a monument in the background denotes the glory of Thamizh language, when talking about Sanskrit?

[@ImmortalBharat]

It's just a background. Don't think too much :)

[@Dharmicaction]

Tamil and malayalam are the oldest "kaliyuga" language. (originated after 4000 BC)

[@vish2553]

Srinivasan Kalidass get a life and come out of this Tamil and Sanskrit rivalry which was non existent in the past. The Tamil parochialism was started by the DK, DMK mob and you are totally immersed into that idiotic ideology. There were no Aryans and Dravidians. The whole India and it’s culture is based on Vedas. Read the book by the eminent scholar Dr Nagaswamy “ Tamil Nadu the land of Vedas”. Facts from primary sources unlike the EVR gangs.

[@naiyayika]

Who cares? Why in this video? Shameless toxic Timils bringing in a language that no one even knows. Sanskrit is respected worldwide, no one even knows Tanil, whereas sanskrit is taught in many universities in India and abroad and still spoken by 2 million people. What is Tinil? I don't know. "But it's still old.... Keezhadi..." LMAO

[@lalitha8021]

Gurukuls were abolished but madrasas are funded at the cost of tax payers.

[@DipakBose-bq1vv]

Gurukuls were only for the Brahmins. Non-Brahmins were not allowed to enter there.

[@lalitha8021]

@@DipakBose-bq1vv It is a misconception. God Ram was a kshatriya, he went to gurukul. God Krishna was a yadav, he also went to gurukul. We must understand that the misunderstandings and rivalry were purposefully fanned and developed.