Professional Singer Hears Taemin for the FIRST TIME! "Guilty" Reaction & Vocal ANALYSIS

[@PeterBarber]

Wow -- this music video blew my mind! One of my favorites I've seen in a long time. And Taemin? The talent is off the charts -- the singing, the dancing, the commitment, everything. What else else from Taemin should I react to and analyze?

[@-music-is-art-]

Ha, ha, maybe it means you haven't seen enough k-pop yet ;) still this one did go for my top 10 favorite k-pop MVs... it is one of the best. Every song and MV by Taemin is a work of art, but definitely "Advice" should be next :D

[@archwayportraits]

​@@-music-is-art-I second the recommendation for Advice, and add in Criminal. Taemin is an Artiste

[@universe986]

Criminal, Idea, Advice his performance on Killing Voice to hear more of his b-sides where his vocals truly shines

[@cricedeleon525]

Advice, The Rizzness or Night Away, Me and You, Move, Hypnosis ✨💎✨ OMG there are so many songs, he blows our minds with every single song, with every album. There's no bad song for real. Thanks for your appreciation 👍🏽✨.

[@russandols]

Thank you for checking out Taemin! This was very interesting, I've been listening to Guilty non-stop and thanks to you I noticed some things in the orchestration that flew over my head the first hundred times lmao I second everyone who recommended Criminal, it's really a masterpiece. Taemin has many gems in his solo discography, but above all I'd say Clockwork, Rise and Impressionable ;)

[@Seriphina]

Taemin is widely considered to be one of the best dancers in kpop. He is also a source of inspiration for many other idols. Some even refer to him as the king of kpop. It isn't hard to see why. He makes art.

[@panoramicdramatic]

Taemin makes art alright, not just any art though. The true haunting beauty of this particular MV has been nicely exposed in an explainer, GUILTY MV Explained

[@j2kay93]

he IS the best.

[@battarabbit8827]

I’m a singer and Ive been frustrated with reactions to this track. 80+ percent of Taemin’s fans only ever talk about being obsessed with his beauty and physical body… I mean, dancing. The reaction channels on KZbin are mostly people with little insight or knowledge and many don’t analyze a thing. When I say it’s a relief to find you, I hope it doesn’t seem like a small complement because your analysis is a total gift. Taemin’s been working as a dancer since his teens. He is a phenomenon. I think it’s because he’s also been a little bit of an outsider. He had to struggle to get his voice up to par to have a part in his band SHINee - if you don’t know them you’re in for a whole bunch of treats. It’s worth looking at his history. And you seem to be someone who will find lots of fresh musical elements in K-Pop. It is the cutting edge in so many ways. Thank you so very much. Glad I found you. So glad. Now I have to remember to spam you with K-Pop performances you might like and If you do, I might learn from. Do a collab with a Choreographer!!1!!

[@PeterBarber]

Thank you for this comment -- I love the idea of a collaboration with a dancer! I will look into that

[@marinal.]

that sounds cool too. @@PeterBarber But for sure do a collab with a producer or editor.

[@claudinecc2837]

You can not love Taemin only for his face or dance performance. His voice and his music are beautiful, that was my first choice, and i'm a fan of SHINee too!! Nevertheless it's pure beauty to see him dancing ❤ his artistic world is unique and he is today the Idol model for many young K-pop idol. I'm fully crazy of this complete artiste 😵‍💫❤😂

[@battarabbit8827]

@@soapwol You have a point. 80% might be a little high, but it's not a census, it's my experience. Is there somewhere you can turn me on to that explores Taemin's art in depth? Can you tell me something about Taemin's style, it's growth, the nature of the material he chooses and what kind of issues he finds worth exploring? Because you've been around longer than me so you know more. To say he's worked hard is something we all agree upon. And that he's gifted. I'm looking for insight into the artist and his expression. Shawols on fan sites do not tend to do this. It's not bad or good. It's just what I've found so far. And I unreservedly am in thrall to SHINee, Taemin, Key, All of them.

[@wendylwason3031]

Peter, you are one Great reactor.

[@petrichor2035]

Thank you for checking out Taemin. I really appreciate your reaction and analysis. Taemin is the main dancer, and he's phenomenal at it; many consider him the best dancer in K-pop currently. When he debuted at 14, he didn't have a single line. However, his dedication is evident in his growth in music and singing skills, making him one of the most successful male soloists. I hope you continue to explore both his Korean and Japanese discography.

[@masterofnothing2360]

That’s truly amazing, hearing his voice now I would never guess he wasn’t given vocals when he debuted 😮

[@jhennismarmontes8662]

TAEMIN IDOL OF IDOLS , and he have the bests concepts after 10 years solo work in the industry and 15 years whit his team SHINEE

[@mabellelotte4385]

Yes i learn about that and i amshoked when i learn he is a maknae😂

[@meemzzz]

You are in for a treat with Taemin! You're the only reactor that really gave great insightful commentary and analysis on the song structure and melody of Guilty. Seriously, thank you!

[@milindawilson9175]

Taemin has been in the industry for more than 15 years as part of the legendary 5-member Kpop group SHINee and he has been a solo artist since 2014. "Guilty" is his title track on his 4th mini Korean solo album. You may find this hard to believe, but when Taemin debuted as a member of SHINee way back in 2008, he didn't have a whole lot of lines in their songs. People even used to make fun of Taemin's singing and they would say that he was tone deaf and couldn't sing. However, it's sort of a misconception that Taemin "couldn't sing." it wasn't that he couldn't sing, it was just that he debuted when he was so young -- he was only 14 years old -- that his voice hadn't really developed yet and he didn't really have a good grasp of how to use his voice and produce the sounds he wanted with it. So, in the beginning, when he sang, he was often flat or his voice cracked or he was off key or out of tune, etc. And because he was being compared to the other members of SHINee who are all 2 to 4 years older than him, and the other members had such phenomenal voices to start out with, it really made Taemin sound like he was lacking. (SHINee are considered THE premier vocal group that everyone dreams of being as good as.) That's why in SHINee's first few songs he only has a few lines, and most of the time he was just given big solo dance breaks to fill the stage at his parts in the song. However, if he was really tone deaf, he never would have become an SM Idol trainee -- SM would have put him on the dance track and probably steered him toward becoming a backup dancer -- and he definitely would have never become the amazing singer that he is today. As you probably know, someone who is truly tone deaf is physically unable to hear the difference in the notes and is unable to carry a tune. Taemin is considered one of the greatest dancers of all time. He has literally been voted one of the top two BEST dancers in all of Kpop by his peers and industry experts. (Kai from EXO -- who happens to be Taemin's best friend since trainee days, and a fellow member of the Kpop supergroup SuperM -- is the other top dancer.) That is why he has been nicknamed the Korean Michael Jackson. Literally everyone in the Kpop industry looks up to Taemin and idolizes him. But Taemin really wanted to prove to everyone that he wasn't just a dancer, so he spent a lot of extra time concentrating on vocal lessons and the other SHINee members -- especially Onew and Jonghyun (two of the best vocalists in the industry) -- spent some serious time coaching and mentoring him until he learned what it took to match their vocal range and to use his voice. (For the first year or more after SHINee's debut Taemin spent hours in vocal lessons and he would push himself every day until his nose would bleed because he was so tired and worn out, etc. He practically lived in the training rooms at SM Entertainment.) The ONLY thing the members of SHINee are not good at is lip syncing, so Taemin, and all the members of SHINee, have specifically trained since their debut, to build stamina and endurance, in order to be able to sing live for 3+ hours straight in concert, all while performing these intense choreographies and still sound flawless. When you watch a live performance, you may be shocked because Taemin and SHINee sound so perfect live even though they are dancing so intensely, but that is why they are so highly respected by everyone. It's a running joke between fans and the members that you can tell when SHINee are lip syncing because they are so bad at it, that is why they avoid it at all costs. Therefore, when you hear SHINee sing, 95% of the time it will be live. Yes, over the years they have become better at lip syncing than they used to be, but now they have gained the reputation as the group that always sings live, so unless they are required to lip sync for a specific reason, what you will hear is live vocals. Other Idols and audio sound technicians, etc. who have witnessed the SHINee members performing live are always blown away, because in the parts of the song where most singers would take a break and rely on the backing track vocals to cover their voices so they can catch their breath and recover, this is where the SHINee members actually ramp it up and become their most powerful. Therefore, in Taemin's live performance you will discover that he sounds even better than in the recorded version, all while dancing full out. What makes SHINee so great is that even if they are singing a cappella while performing this high energy choreography, they sound just as amazing. That's why, even as rookies, senior artists would stop what they were doing to watch SHINee's rehearsals on music programs because SHINee's vocal talent is that impressive. When SHINee debuted, they were the first group to demonstrate how it was possible to sing live while performing complex choreography and still maintain stable vocals. Before SHINee, the thought within the industry was that it wasn't possible to sing live and also perform high intensity choreography at the same time. At that time, most groups would either sing live and have simple choreography, or they would have crazy cool choreography, but lip sync to their recorded vocals. SHINee completely changed the Kpop industry and upped the standard of what it meant to be an idol singer. Taemin -- and SHINee -- live is unmatched. It's literally referred to as the SHINee standard. It's the standard that all other groups strive to reach, and SHINee are the vocalists that all other artists try to emulate. I think "Guilty" is a continuation of the themes surrounding Taemin's previous releases. Particularly connected to his Never Gonna Dance Again album trilogy -- "2 Kids", "Criminal" and "Idea" -- and Advice album themes. As Taemin has explained, "Guilty" is about a lover who DOESN'T feel guilty about all the bad things they have done in the relationship and they feel no shame or remorse for the pain and suffering they may have caused the other person. Which, if you connect it to the messages from his previous MVs, this easily could be interpreted as a metaphor for everything Taemin has gone through in his career and life. As an idol, he has been manipulated and controlled his whole life. Debuting at 14 years old, Taemin has lived his entire life in the public eye under a microscope, he is expected to be flawless and perfect, and people are constantly telling him what to do and how he should act, etc. However, now that he has turned 30, I think he is embracing a new chapter in his life where he is saying he is no longer going to allow people to manipulate him and he is officially taking back control. In other words, he's not going to feel guilty any more for being himself and doing what makes him happy. With Taemin -- and all the members of SHINee -- you will never get the same thing twice. Everything he releases will be a new style and sound and, yet, it will still be very "Taemin". As SM Entertaiment's experimental boy group, SHINee are meant to be the first to do almost everything, and they are expected to come up with something new that no one has ever seen or heard before with every release of theirs. As Kpop's trendsetters, the members of SHINee reinvent the industry with every comeback. Taemin is literally the artist that everyone within the Kpop industry looks up to and respects. He has released at least one song or album -- most of the time way more than just one -- as part of SHINee, as a member of a project group, as a solo artist or as a member of SuperM every year since SHINee's debut. (Except for the past two years because he was on hiatus while he carried out his public service duties as part of his military requirements.) Therefore, including his full-length albums, mini albums, and singles, etc., as well as his Japanese albums, Taemin has more than a dozen solo albums. Not to mention the 2 albums he has as a member of SuperM. And on top of all that, SHINee currently has 14 full-length Korean and Japanese albums, just as many repackaged albums, numerous mini albums, etc. Plus he has held many solo concert tours, as well as a world tour as a mmber of SuperM, and SHINee has held more than 100 concerts within 6 world tours so far. You have a TON to catch up on. :D Now you need to check out Taemin's Killing Voice performance. I have a feeling when you watch his Killing Voice you will find that hearing him sing "Guilty," as well as his other songs, live that you will be even more impressed. Plus, you need to see one of his live performances of "Guilty" to see the complete choreography. There is a reason why Taemin is like none other.

[@coffeeintern9196]

I was literally scratching my head on how to condense how amazing Taemin and SHINee are, or at least influential, without rambling or going too long. You did wonders with this summary, if only today bits here and there that as a biased fan I'd be too quick to jump in with haha! I found myself nodding and feeling so proud with how you shone a light on it all while being concise and educative :))

[@Bajdunia_Kaminska]

I’m on your channel for the first time, I loved your reaction and I’m so happy you reacted to Taemin! Taemin is a royalty of Kpop, he’s a living legend of this industry! In my opinion he’s truly the best solo artist that has ever come out of South Korea - absolutely unique and unmatched in his artistry. As you can see he’s a truly fantastic vocalist with angelic, seductive voice and very unique tone. This breathiness in his voice is his signature mark, no one sings like him, he’s the king of sensuality. But as you can see he can belt perfectly, so this breathy sound is his stylistic choice, which I personally love. Taemin is also an incredible dancer - considered by many the best dancer in Kpop, which I agree. I just haven’t seen anyone with his skills, uniqueness and level of charisma. I would love a longer format of your videos with detailed analysis of the video, cause in terms of Taemin his MVs are visual and conceptual works of art! Please check out more of his music - Advice, Criminal, IDEA, Want, Move are some of his most famous title tracks with incredible MVs! You have a new subscriber here, thank you for excellent content!

[@Saddlemomma]

Taemin confirmed that he had a 30-piece orchestra play for this music. This song was a contender for his 2021, mini-album "Advice". He ultimately went with "Advice" for the title song (which you should definitely check out), but he kept this song in his pocket while going off to serve for his mandatory military duty. He said he needed to rework the song quite a bit to update it for this new mini-album to continue the storyline of his 2020 full-length, 2-part album, "Never Gonna Dance Again" (NGDA), of which "Advice" we thought was the epilogue. However, now it seems that "Advice" and "Guilty" are a continuation of that wonderful storyline. The other songs involved in that storyline are "2 Kids" (NGDA, Act 1 Prologue); "Criminal" (NGDA, Act 1); and "IDEA" (NGDA, Act 2). Taemin debuted with SHINee at the tender age of 14 (Intl. age) as their main dancer. He was chosen by SM through the historically difficult SM open Saturday auditions. Only 8 other idols have ever passed this audition attended by thousands each time. Taemin didn't expect to pass because he didn't know how to sing. He was a self-taught dancer who began at the age of 9/10 by watching his favorite artists, like MJ, Usher, and Rain, and then practicing their moves in his mirror. Subsequently, he was a street dancer before auditioning with SM. Because Taemin is not locked into any one specific, trained genre, he fluidly integrates any other style he learns into his own personal style blending them together seamlessly. This is what makes Taemin distinct as a dancer. Additionally, Taemin regularly adjusts or alters his choreo on the fly per performance to embody how he feels at the moment and according to, as he says, the "character" he is playing. Add all this to his natural fluidity and extreme body control and you get who the industry says is the best dancer in Kpop: kzbin.info/www/bejne/h6CUaX9plLCWZrs This is just a small sample of his insane body control and mastery at popping, locking, and isolations. Singing, however, was another issue. Taemin couldn't sing at debut due to immature vocal cords. When it did come time to sing, he didn't have a clue. Thankfully, Taemin had two things in his favor that helped him develop into the phenomenal vocalist he is today: 1) his SHINee brothers, Jonghyun and Onew are two of the most powerful singers in Kpop. They stepped up and tutored Taemin until SM finally allowed him to access vocal coaches. 2) His almost obsessive drive to succeed and being a well-known workaholic. His work ethic is famous among his peers. He said he would practice singing long after curfew, all night long. When his throat refused to sing any more, he would stop and switch to dancing and back again. He did this so much that he would get nosebleeds during the day and fell asleep once during regular practice with SHINee. When Taemin finally started working with vocal coaches, one told him that he would never be a singer and to just stick with dancing. I'm sure this lit a fire under him. By 2010, he worked hard enough to start getting more lines in SHINee songs. In 2014, rather than Jonghyun or Onew, Taemin became the first-ever SM idol from an active boy group to debut as a soloist and also debut three times in multiple generations: 2nd gen (SHINee); 3rd gen (Soloist); 4th gen (SuperM). Now he is one of the most legendary soloists in the industry. Makes me wonder what that vocal coach who told him to stick with dancing thinks now. Lastly, don't be fooled by the lyrics in Taemin's songs. Sure, you can take them at face value, but Taemin/SHINee fans ("Jjakkoongs" = partners & SHAWOLs = SHINee World) know that Taemin can have anywhere from two to three deeper levels of meaning to those lyrics. It's part of his mystique. You must dig through all the symbolism of the MVs (because everything means something), know his history, and be familiar with his Christian worldview (he's a devout Catholic) to get to the heart of many of those lyrics. Adding to all that, Taemin is very into philosophy which also plays a major part in his stories. For instance, some of his concepts in the last few years include: Stockholm syndrome ("Criminal"); Plato's Theory of Forms ("IDEA"); and, for this particular MV, delving into French philosopher, Georges Bataille's book, "L'erostisme" in which he argues that eroticism is "a psychological quest not alien to death." In addition, the SHINee brothers, who are all soloists, will often link their solo work together, as well as their SHINee MVs. For instance, SHINee's 15th anniversary album, "Hard" (2023) links their title song of the same name to primarily Taemin's 2021 title song "Advice" and also Onew's "Circle", as well as some of Key's work, especially with a scene actually taken from Key's song "Hate That". To make matters even more complicated, their collective work may also be connected to SM's Universe storyline, "Kwangya". There's A LOT to unpack with each MV. So there you go, and while this is a long intro., it's really just a brief peek because there is a lot of personal history with Taemin and his other struggles that influence his music as well, like reconciling his faith with his celebrity status which creates a duality of egos (HINT: "Press Your Number", "Want", "Famous", "Criminal", "IDEA", and now "Guilty"). However, all THAT is what makes Taemin and SHINee legendary as well as special and unique. We get to really know who they are as regular people through their music and their strong familial bond. BTW: Taemin also did the show, "Killing Voice" where he sings several snippets of his songs live. He mostly did his b-side ballads that he wishes more people would listen to. They might be interesting for you. Plus, a phenomenal live performance of his song "Rise" with a snippet of "Soldier" can be found here: kzbin.info/www/bejne/eJ3NeKVthMyUhc0 Lots of beautiful belting with this one! Enjoy!

[@milindawilson9175]

Prior to becoming a trainee at the age of 11, Taemin had no formal dance training. He started out as a self-taught popper and locker who learned to dance by copying dancers on TV, and, even then, as a trainee it was clear his skills as a dancer went far beyond the average dancer. He said he thought dancers like Kpop solo artist Bi Rain and Michael Jackson were cool, so he would try and copy their moves. He debuted as the main dancer of SHINee in 2008 at the age of 14 -- so he had about 3 years of training as a dancer once he became a trainee. Therefore, most of what you see is just natural talent and an unbelievable amount of dedication. Taemin has put in a lot of effort to become the magnificent and unique performer and person that we know him as today. But there really is no one that pushes him or holds him to a higher standard than himself. He has said that he really has never taken a true vacation since he was a trainee and he doesn't know what to do if he isn't constantly working and training. It's said that if Taemin's dance looks easy then it's actually really difficult and if it looks extremely difficult then it's even harder than you imagine. No one moves the way he does and even his backup dancers struggle to keep up with him. Choreographers say he is constantly asking them to make the choreography more difficult and he is never satisfied until the difficulty level is off the charts. As Taemin has said, there has never been anything that has come easy to him and he has only gotten to where he is today because he has worked hard to accomplish everything. He is constantly pushing himself to become the best of the best in everything he does. Taemin has said, he has worked his entire career to create a style of dance that is unlike anything in the Kpop industry. And I would argue that that now extends to the entire industry of dance. He's also one of the only idols who have debuted in 3 different Kpop generations -- second generation with SHINee in 2008, third generation as a solo artist in 2014 and now fourth generation as a member of SuperM in 2019. You should watch some of Taemin's concert documentaries to see just how hard he trains and works. If you search KZbin you will find 2 or 3 from his solo concerts, as well as documentaries/behind the scenes of SHINee's concerts. Taemin doesn't have to try to grab your attention, he just exudes command of the stage. That is what makes him one of the top performers and why he is so popular. Yes, he has literally been voted one of the top two BEST dancers in all of Kpop by his peers and industry experts. That is why he has been nicknamed the Korean Michael Jackson. Literally everyone in the Kpop industry looks up to Taemin and idolizes him. He is the idol that most choreographers dream of getting the chance to work with. Taemin's talents are one reason why SHINee are one of the top groups in the industry and why they have such legendary status. SHINee is made up of some of the absolute best singers, dancers and performers in the entire industry. Not only is Taemin an amazing dancer but, as you just heard -- because he is a member of SHINee -- he is also a top tier vocalist, who can sing live while performing intricate choreography like this and sound even better live than the studio recording. With more than 15 years since their debut, they still command one of the top spots and are all active as a group and as soloists.

[@mashitaali8481]

Taemin is freaking talented artist. Love your review.Guilty is phenomenal.!!!

[@fatalblue]

Taemin is considered one of the best dancers among kpop idols/korean prefomers (some even consider him the best). He isn't classically trained but orginally self taught before getting more formal training by his agency. Foundationally speaking, his style is street based but over the course of his career, he's became interested in more classical forms of dance and incorporated elements of it into his style as well. One of the most outstanding things abt Taemin tho is that he's not a natural born singer if you will. He started out as solely the main dancer of his group, SHINee, and didn't even have lines in the group's debut song. His growth as a vocalist is more or less legendary within the scene. I will end by recommending you check out more stuff by his group SHINee! Especially Jonghyun and Onew! They are the groups main vocals and have been pretty pivotal in Taemin's own growth as a singer.

[@ethelralte1024]

Taemin is art. I'll like to see advice, move and so many more.

[@aketa6774]

Love your reaction about his voice. Taemin is known for his dancing skills and he’s worked very hard on his vocals over the years and it’s nice to hear great things about it cause it is amazing. Fun fact when he first started in 2008 people used to tell him he didn’t have a singing voice. He worked extra hard to prove them wrong

[@sjames1955]

Taemin is from Shinee who are one of the greatest Kpop groups of all time and are known as the Princes of Kpop. He's often been referred to as the MJ of Korea. All of the Shinee members are incredibly talented and very accomplished.

[@ena11ais]

Best professional review about Guilty by Taemin music ! [my day was blest today😇 ] . Peter you are a rare gem among the reactors , u know that ? Glad to find you . Pls when u have time , do more reaction and analysis for Taemins music and SHINee( his group ) and for all the 5 members of SHINee : Taemin , Onew , Jonghyun , Key and Minho . as a professional musician you will definitely find some rare "diamonds", I'm sure.

[@taylala8881]

Taemin is phenomenal, thank you for the reaction😃

[@StarElementalDancer]

Kpop loves its pre-choruses. Some of the best ever are here. Thank you for the vocal and musical analyses. Welcome and we hope you enjoy your stay. Taemin is definitely one of the best as everyone has said and his last album is epic and really shows his growth.

[@heartsamessgaultier8562]

This analysis of Taemin's voice and singing choices feels to me like having successfully defended his talent as an artist and performer. He debuted 16 years ago with SHINee as their youngest member at 14 years, the other boys practically raised him and a lot of people ridiculed him, saying he can't sing, he's just a pretty face etc. He worked hard on his journey to becoming the King of Kpop, so many lessons in voice, piano, dance and so forth, he proved all the nay-sayers wrong. Some of my other favorites from him are Criminal, Want, Move, Slave and Thirsty (yes, there is a definite pattern here of one word titles.) You also pretty quickly honed in on his unique MV concept and dancing, he is a definite all rounder, somewhat of a unicorn in this cookie cutter world. Edit: LMAO, why don't I remember posting this comment? AU or what?

[@azuazu4734]

Oh wow okay, I’ve been too starstruck with Taemin’s comeback that I can’t believe I missed so much… musically. Thanks for this! I was able to appreciate some of the sections more

[@looloo3607]

Thankyou. I've been waiting for someone to really appreciate the modern sound Taemin gave to this track and the use of his vocals. I would recommend Onew - Circle next

[@Trashtienda]

I already loved this song but your analysis made me appreciate it so much more! Thanks for your video!

[@Saddlemomma]

Now, if you're talking about SHINee, that's a whole other rabbit trail. They, along with Taemin are just phenomenal legends. They are the trendsetters of Kpop and no genre is off limits, including Opera for Onew. For them, I would suggest the following live performances because it's ALWAYS best to react to them live: "Sherlock" live: kzbin.info/www/bejne/g2XTeoGXnaeiiLs "Excuse Me Miss": kzbin.info/www/bejne/g5_XooF8Zq6JZpI "Romeo & Juliet": kzbin.info/www/bejne/f2Sto6mcYrRprZY "SHINee Unplugged Medley": kzbin.info/www/bejne/q6aoaIWsipuEoc0 Just to start...lol.

[@doloresbrown5269]

Thanks for checking out Taemin. He recently did Killing Voice, where he sung snippets of some of his songs throughout his solo career. That might interest you. Also if you like Taemin, you might be interested in the group he comes from, SHINee. SHINee is a 2nd generation kpop group, that are known for their singing and dancing. They really are the idols idol. There are 5 members in SHINee, and each of them have their own solo careers as well. If I were to suggest a SHINee song, I’d probably start with their debut song “Replay”…again thank you for checking out Taemin.

[@universe986]

thanks for your reaction! Taemin is a phenomenal artist. yes, he's one of the top dancers in kpop he recently did a Killing Voice where he sung some snippets from his b-sides, i think it would be interesting to react to for you as a singer among title tracks i recommend Criminal, from b-sides Clockwork is amazing his group SHINee is also known for amazing vocals and performances

[@mariapaulas199]

I think you are the first to talk about the whispering and distorted voice. It was one of the things that I loved how it was incorporated, given that Taemin is representing a deity that is considered a god of good and evil. The first time is when Taemin appears to be fighting a possession. The part of the 'rap' with the distorted voice was like an entity was speaking alongside him. So cool. Taemin has different songs with different styles, he doesn't stick to one fixed style because he likes to experiment. It's a matter of exploring. Its bsides are fantastic too. Thanks for the reaction I loved it!

[@efkaservicegirl]

Loved this deep dive! A lot of people are reacting to this one, which I love to see, but not very many that I've seen are truly diving into the musicality of it like you do. Taemin is absolutely an Artist. I don't see it in the comments yet so I'm going to recommend Advice. It was his lead single on his last mini album and it has a beautiful piano melody that just underscores the whole song. Really though you can't go wrong with Taemin. He has no skips. I also seriously recommend checking out some of his B-sides. They're gorgeous.

[@Lenaas.rkivee]

Taemin is one of the best dancers in kpop if not the best. And personally he has one of my favorite vocals. Taemin has said that he started dancing around ten years old after seeing Michael Jackson’s ‘lean forward’ move in smooth criminal. Taemins mom actually encouraged him to audition at SM (his company) because she knew how much he loved to dance. Now look at him, he is one of the biggest kpop soloists, and he’s also been apart of a group for 15 years.

[@eyxiacassie7298]

YES PLEASE PLEASE DO MORE OF TAEMIN'S MUSIC PLEASSSE!!

[@cricedeleon525]

You know you could check Taemin on "The Killing Voice" too, He sang there recently a great compilation of his songs and for almost every of those songs he has a MV. So it's a great idea for have a general idea of his voice.

[@bea_hae_tae9392]

Taemin is unique, I am sure many people will suggest his music videos, but I also suggest you choose something from his concert performances, he is a different type of artist, you will always get something different, he is compared to MJ, because of his talent. When he is in the group SHINee, with which he debuted in 2008, he is different, but you can certainly see that he is simply hypnotizing on stage

[@jessieguo0088]

Thank you for analyzing Taemin’s new song from a vocal performance perspective. Taemin has always been recognized as the ultimate dancer in Kpop and many people would put emphasis on his movements in dancing when reacting to his work, which is totally fair. But I do believe after all these years his vocal skills has grown so much and this song demonstrated his phenomenal vocal abilities. As a longtime fan as many others, I’m so glad to see his efforts getting recognized ❤🎉🎉🎉

[@claudinecc2837]

Fully agree with you. He improved his voice year after year and Guilty shows the high level of this hard work. He deserves all the praise he had for this amazing song!! 👏🤩❤️🔥

[@diegopantoja566]

Taemin background in dancing: he is just the best dancer in kpop, named 1st by many people, idol of idols, example for maaaaaany idols debuted after him. the Michael Jackson of Kpop.

[@Diamante316]

Oh wooow. How about Taemin's member Onew who did Nessun Dorma? God I really wanted an opera singer to check that. LOL Thank you for this reaction.

[@SHINeeNAilee]

There has been an opera singer who has reacted to Onew's rendition of Nessun Dorma!

[@DarkHarlequin]

Onew has the most interesting beautiful singing voice I maybe ever heard on a singer. Like Onew is a great vocalist but there is many great vocalists. Onews voice though has such a unique quality I'd be really interested in hearing his analysis of that.

[@ninawilliams5676]

Subbed, liked and hit your bell for the God of kpop taemin. I would love your reaction to taemins band members onew and jonghyun singing please dont go. Both are known for the best singers of kpop and this ballad is heavenly. Thank you so much for this great reaction.

[@mulo8174]

Please check Taemin brother on the same group SHINee, his name is ONEW, title CIRCLE, you gonna love it also

[@g-malaigo1155]

Wow.... definitely gained appreciation for clicking onto your channel. I've watched many reactors & those who analyse ... I have to say, You are the 1st that has kept my attention of "Knowing Your Stuff". The details were eye opening and although I already appreciate, respect & admire young Taemin as an full fledge KPop Artist, hearing someone breakdown each aspect of what he hears & see's in the song & MV is refreshing to say the least. If you decide to look more into Young Taemin Artistic Background. You will find that he isn't someone that just does a MV... he does a MV with the Drama or Storyline behind the words. Just as you experienced it here. His understanding of words captures himself in each song he embraces... hence the Birth of his MV's. Thank you for the knowledge that you have shared. Take Care & Stay Amazing

[@talishiacowderoy3583]

Hi Peter.. I'm a SHINee Shawol and all of my kids are.. I showed them this vidoe and the was totally silence, I was almost like we stopped breathing then when it was over we could discriped how we felt as we loved it so much. The vibe is incredible..❤ SHINee and Taemin are all true artist ❤💎❤ check out live performance of Rizzness his b side so good.

[@jeanwangg]

He is really one of the best and creative artists in Kpop industry. He's also what I consider the best dancer as he has crazy control and isolation. I've seen him being able to master and dance to any type of genre.

[@justbeeyourself]

people call taemin the michael jackson of kpop, so you were right on with noticing his dancing! i'd suggest move, criminal, idea, and advice. and if you're interested in his dancing you can look up 'taemin dance practice' and see him doing the routines through completely, which is so cool to watch.

[@tidus_1135]

Loved your reaction and analysis of Taemin’s voice and the music. I really like the way you explain things and it really does help to make me appreciated the work and effort that goes into music like this one. Thank you to the patron who suggested it. Taemin has so many amazing songs. I would love to hear a complete analysis with other guests. He is also part of a group called SHINee. Taemin’s other work, Advice, Want, Criminal, Soldier, Heaven, Move. I would start with these. He’s been in the industry for 15 years with SHINee and 9 years as solo artist. Please check out Onew. He’s also part of that group and has an amazing singing voice.

[@mariposasabia]

I like how you broke down his music ability that gets greatly overlooked or glossed over. You should check out his group SHINee that is a group of main vocalists, Taemin evolved into a vocalist. This group's vocals are insane and the group all have their own musical solo career. Check em out! Thank you for the reaction.

[@MildaLelyte]

Thank you for checking out Taemin. I learned a lot about what is happening in vocal and instrumental-wise. I like your idea to make even more extensive videos.

[@sandcarad]

I really enjoyed your reaction! Taemin is such a phenomenal dancer that his vocals are often overlooked but he's such a talented singer. SHINee and all their members are all an aural treat to listen to. If you have time (on or off camera), I really recommend you check the group and their member's solo work out :)

[@santhysaroso6343]

That's a great idea. I'll be waiting for that kind of reaction on your channel.

[@Lartcenok]

beautiful vocals, strong charisma, personality, good data, I like everything he does, good work.

[@miyabihyatt]

Finding your channel at 5/6 am was the best thing that could've happen! I love how you clearly analysed Guilty in a vocal aspect as most reactors tended to just talk about the visual aspect of the MV. While of course the MV is very interesting enough to talk about it, same for the choreography, his vocals weren't talked enough for me! So thank you so much for analysing the music aspect, his voice which he found after years and years and years of practices. When he debuted he was just a dancer and was barely there in SHINee's tracks. His dedication towards music made him work hard every day and night to be able to sing amazingly and like no one else in this industry. Btw I also wanted to add he is a skilled pianist! Taemin has a lot of talents and it's a real treat to follow his journey as an artist. He is one of the kpop idol mentioned the most as role model by a full generation of kpop idols for good reasons.

[@lattelover5471]

Taemin is the idol of K-pop idols!

[@mochawilliams5996]

Taemin's mv's are art!

[@greeneyedxvampiress]

Thank you so much for analyzing Taemin’s beautiful vocals!! I’m so glad you loved Guilty! And I would very much love if you brought on a collaborator, a video editor or a choreographer, to react to more of Taemin’s work! His Killing Voice video is another great vocal performance you could react to- he has also just had a concert called Metamorph. I hope you react to Taemin again someday!

[@vyckygy6626]

oh wow, full audio and visual analysis would be so cool!! thank you very much for this video!

[@beccangavin]

I’m usually so focused on Taemin’s dancing and the overall composition of his songs that I don’t notice that he can also sing really well. I enjoyed this reaction! I did actually gain a new appreciation for Taemin.

[@AmalaFrequents]

I enjoyed your analysis a lot. Taemin is so cool. He recently did a singing performance show called Lee Mujin service (it's an amazing watch and a series you would probably enjoy in general, a lot of kpop artists go on and show different colours of their voice whilst being interviewed by Lee Mujin a well known singer). On the show he explained how he did not begin as a singer but studied and trained with a vocal coach after debut for many years and now his voice is so strong and stable. He's a bit of a legend in the kpop scene, he's a heck of a performer and this song is so good.

[@pinkseonghwa]

Welcome to Taemin! He debuted in 2008 with the band SHINee at the tender age of 14, but have also had a separate solo career for 9 years. As for the question about his dancing, he’s often considered the best dancer of the entire industry, and if not the best, then at least top 3 along Kai and Ten who happen to be his labelmates. He’s an expert in popping and locking and have some INSANE muscle control. You just gotta watch live stages and dance practises to see it all. His solo stuff definetly have a more sexy side than Shinee’s stuff are, but it’s also less sexy and more to the sultry, eerie, fluid sexuality and breaking gender stereotypes with a catholic guilt and trauma from debuting at 14 touch over it all-way. Another common theme in his songs and mvs are a toxic relationship vibe, again usually relating to how being in the public eye since 14 mentally fucked him up for life in some ways. It’s great 😀👍🏻 (no fr it is great stuff) For some other songs of his: Criminal is my favourite song of his, IDEA is a part 2 to Criminal, Want is my favourite mv and Move is his most famous song. All have dance practises as well which I HIGHLY recommend to check out to see his dancing full force.

[@leydarachadey465]

Gracias por reaccionar a TAEMIN Tienes nueva seguidora Eres un maravilloso profesional .En lo personal el mejor artista del KPOP .Cada MV ÁLBUM es ARTE .El se preparo toda su vida para hacer musica Toca el piano por oído desde los 11 años Esta en la industria desde los 11 . Tiene maestria en música y cine En una de las universidades de mas importante de Corea Es un maravilloso cantante con unos matices vocales únicos hermosos .Siempre participa en la ejecución de todas sus canciones y MV .Sus conciertos son los mejores Lo comparan con MJ ..Entrar al mundo de TAEMIN no tiene regreso .EXCELENTE ARTISTA .ÍDOLO DE IDOLOS .Te recomiendo CRIMINAL IDEA ADVICE. Y Su álbum Act1 .Para comenzar .su maravillosa discografía Que la tiene en COREANO y JAPONES .EL no hace musica comercial hace arte .Siempre con un instrumental maravilloso .

[@Eileen_in_Vegas]

Awesome r&A, as always. Always something new to learn.

[@karinaspak4230]

TAEMIN did a "killing voice" episode for this comeback.......it would be amazing if you react to that.

[@jay_vali]

I'm here for the first time because I love to see genuine reactions to Taemin and his talents instead of all these people obsessing over his looks only. You should check out his song Advice. That's a good one too and I really love it. Or Heaven. Or Sayonara Hitori. He has so many good songs. Now that I'm here I'll definitely stay and watch some of your Dimash reactions too.

[@loulouwillis5648]

Just started listening to him again since 2014 from SHINEE days he sounds amazing!!

[@blackeveryseason]

Taemin is absolutely amazing, been in the kpop scene for like 15 years, since he was 14, with his group SHINee. I highly recommend their work, theyre known as "Princes of Kpop." One of their members, Onew, actually did a cover of "Nessun Dorma" on one of their earlier tours, itd be fun to see your reaction for someone who isn't trained for opera. Onew has such a unique voice in the kpop scene, no one sounds like him haha.

[@ingyinnkyaw8943]

Next should be "Taemin - Advice" (both MV and Dance Practice). You will see his different vocal and dance style (still being Taemin in his own unique style). Then "Criminal", one of my favourite. "Move" is also an iconic song of his which will blow your mind again ^^~...

[@sofiiivvv9868]

Taemin es un artista completo él rey del Kpop ! , ídolo de los ídolos ! increíblemente extraordinario , sus performance son únicas !

[@mindywiese7610]

I love that your new camera. And yes I like Taemin, haven't listened to before. Very talented! And your goatee is slick! Looking good.....think I covered my random thoughts! 🥰 And yes longer analysis videos to cover video choreography/designs etc would be amazing!

[@rookim1271]

It was so informative and nice to learn small details of sound and vocal technic from professional perspective! I like Taemin’s both vocal and dance..and his music brings satisfaction.

[@ShawolOT5]

💎 What can we say other than THE KING IS BACK!? I absolutely love how deep Taemin’s songs and MVs are…they aren’t just entertainment or for clicks/views, but he tells a story. He wants to make people THINK and question and reflect. This isn’t something one can watch and then move on. His concepts are intellectual and personal. 💎 Regarding the song itself, his haunting whispers with the beautiful runs on top give me chills…the rap section was unexpected, but fit perfectly and suited the song more than I’d have imagined. I loved how the song switched gears in unexpected ways…there are certain formulas that most kpop songs follow, but this moved in ways I’d never imagined it would and it’s perfect. 💎 As far as the choreography…holy freaking moly. I KNEW it would blow my mind…of course it would-it’s Taemin! With that said, I can’t help but wonder if this isn’t some of his best work to date. It’s provocative without being slutty. Not only that, but you can SEE him being jerked around without any hands on him at all. Around the tenth time watching the video, I happened to notice some of what the background dancers were doing (it’s hard to peel my eyes from Taemin!). There are some genius moves that add to the overall look of the stage…some possibly inspired by breakdancing and some quite acrobatic. I can’t wait to see how it plays out on stage! 💎 All I can really say besides the King has returned is, if loving Taemin is a crime, I’m “G-U-I-L-T-Y … Who's gonna punish me?” 💎 Some info on our KING: Taemin became a trainee under SM at age 11 as a self-taught dancer. He was one of three selected out of thousands the day he auditioned, but he caught their eye with his pop-locking skills, the fact he crossed the line when he wasn’t supposed to (on purpose), and his cheekiness. Though he didn’t feel ready, he debuted with SHINee as the maknae (youngest member) and main dancer at age 14. Though he didn’t get any vocal lines at first (many stated he was tone-deaf, but he was going through puberty), Taemin worked his butt off to improve-so much so he was getting frequent nosebleeds and passed out a few times. His hyungs (basically a term for older “brothers”/close males) helped him develop his voice, especially Onew (Leader of SHINee and also helped coach SM trainees) and Jonghyun (widely regarded as the best vocalist of KPOP), to the point he was the first SM idol to go solo whilst active in his group (2014, at 21 years old). He’s now known for being an exceptional vocalist and is a main vocalist for SHINee and SuperM. In 2014, Taemin had his solo debut (the first artist to ever do so while also active in a group) as the ACE of SM Entertainment (the best of the best in all areas)-Ace is the name of his first solo album and he was the first to receive that title. Now he has gained even more titles: he is the Idols’ Idol (most idols today will say the reason they became an idol and the person they most look up to/aspire to be is Taemin and/or SHINee), he is also a Prince of KPOP (which is a title granted to SHINee), Golden Maknae of SM that’s talented in all areas (besides the fact everyone loves him-not only is he talented, but he’s a wonderful human), Legendary Solo Man (역솔남-near as I can tell, it’s a title bestowed on those similar to “Diva”, given to artists such as Aretha, Dolly, Cher, etc), 탬또롤 (Taemddorol, meaning 'Taemin, once again, a role model'), and the Michael Jackson of South Korea (he’s also known as one of the best dancers in South Korea, if not the best). His backup dance teams are the best in the business and are comprised of multiple famous choreographers (with that said, it’s still difficult (if not impossible) to see anyone BUT Taemin when he’s dancing). It’s no surprise that he’s very well-respected amongst choreographers: his friend (infamous choreographer) Koharu Sugawara nicknamed him “Dancer Killer”. In 2019, SM collaborated with Capitol Records, USA, and assembled a group of seven of the best artists in KPOP to debut in the USA: SuperM. In fact, they even collaborated with Marvel after having been dubbed the Avengers of KPOP. Of course, Taemin was the first chosen and helped pick the other six members. Though not the eldest member, he is the senior member of the group due to the length of time he’s been in the industry. As such, he would have been leader, but he deferred that task to Baekhyun of the group EXO (who’s slightly older than Taemin). Taemin has been the maknae of SHINee his entire career and didn’t feel he would be best suited to lead the others. However, he is the center of the group and they ALL (including Baekhyun) defer to his experience and take his advice to heart. He is very caring towards his dongsaengs (juniors) and was nicknamed Taemresa (inspired by Mother Teresa). Baekhyun is an incredible leader, by the way…don’t want anyone to misunderstand my intentions behind what I’ve said. With the debut in SuperM, Taemin became the first idol to ever debut in three generations: 2nd with SHINee, 3rd as a solo artist, and 4th Gen with SuperM. The second (and only other) artist to achieve this did so almost two years ago, Taeyeon of Girls Generation. (Continued in the reply to this comment…)

[@ShawolOT5]

Taemin recently discharged from his mandatory military service 04 Apr 2023. Taemin is one of the most active members on SNS: he messages on Bubble (text, pix, and voice…including him playing piano and singing to us), frequently goes live on IG, posts pics, and resumed his unofficial job of SHINee’s Spoiler Fairy. He’s also the member who mostly treats his fans like we’re in a parasocial relationship-acting and talking as though we’re his significant other. Taeminnie calls his fans Jjakgoongs (a name meaning best friends/buddies/partners) and Taemints (Taemints being the name of his Shawol fans, based on the fact SHINee was a total secret and not marketed at all before their debut so Taemin would hand out mints and candies to tempt people to listen to their music and attend their debut-which not even their families were aware they were debuting until they were on stage in front of them). Another important thing to know regarding Taemin has to do with his beloved hyung, Jonghyun, whom we tragically lost in 2017. Jonghyun was Taemin’s biggest fan and supporter, even rescheduling his own concert to attend Taemin’s. They were inseparable. Considering SHINee was back on the stage less than two months after his passing, the group did not have very long to grieve. (They returned after much consideration and at the behest of Jjong’s mom and sister.) Taemin is a well-known workaholic…he never takes breaks and hasn’t since he was a child. He’s in the studio every single day-not even taking off for Christmas. In fact, he went live on the day of his military discharge from the practice room and was renting dance studios while he was enlisted because he HAS to dance…it’s part of him. His jump from nonstop working and perfecting his abilities into military life, plus dealing with depression and anxiety, truly hit him hard. Thankfully, he appears to be doing much better now. He looks and sounds happy and healthy, which is honestly all I could ever hope for. Taemin and SHINee are all fluent in Japanese and release just as many Japanese albums as Korean. They are so popular in Japan, many do not consider them foreign artists (which is testament to the love and respect the Japanese people have for them). They even have an entirely separate crew of dancers and staff in Japan. Most artists have to request to hold concerts at Tokyo Dome (it’s an unspoken rule you need to be able to sell out the 55,000-seat arena to perform), but they actually reach out and request SHINee and Taemin because they know they’ll sell out in seconds (whether as a group or Taemin as a solo artist) and have to host multiple days to accommodate. The guys host the entire concert in Japanese and do not need translators. I mentioned SHINee being trendsetters-that includes Taemin, of course. Besides introducing new music styles and breaking boundaries with his concepts, he has also worked to break other boundaries, as well. Early in his career, SM took advantage of his prettiness and exaggerated it-he was often mistaken as a female (especially during the long-hair era) and would frequently clear his throat to “discreetly” let others know he’s male. He absolutely hated it, and understandably so-he was a teenager. Later, he embraced some of the socially-viewed “feminine” qualities and has worked hard to showcase that music has no gender. Taemin made waves with his song, “Move”, which he performs with his Girl Gang (all-female backup dancers). The choreography blends masculine and feminine energy like no one but Taemin can do (so many tried to imitate it, it was dubbed “Move Disease”, but none come close). He also lends that androgynous aspect to his fashion choices. Taemin has many facets to him-when the camera is on (filming MVs, music shows, etc), he is a true professional. With his SHINee hyungs, he’s a mischievous crackhead who lives to torment them. They raised him, so they spoil him, but don’t misunderstand-his love for them is unmatched and it goes both ways. With SuperM, he’s silly, but caring-he took them under his wings and is their mentor. He also has his Padding Squad (friend group consisting of Kai from EXO, Jimin from BTS, Ravi from VIXX, Timoteo of HotShot, WannaOne/HotShot’s Sungwoon, and a non-celebrity friend). They’re named the Padding Squad, or Padding Friends, because Taemin bought and designed matching customized jackets with their own unique logo. For me, personally, I can appreciate someone’s musical abilities…but to become a true fan (or “stan”), they have to be really special and have qualities setting them apart besides simple talent. Taemin, SHINee as a group, and the other SHINee members as soloists have my utmost devotion (they’re all five incredible soloists-in fact, SHINee is the ONLY group in which ALL members have hit #1 on the Worldwide iTunes Chart as soloists). They’re incredibly talented in ways far beyond musical abilities and are kind, fun, and caring humans. TAEMIN’S BACK!!! SHINee’s BACK!!!

[@kimlee9322]

Gosh! Luvvv your reaction to Taemin's Guilty. I absolutely love this song 'cos of his vocal and the choreo.

[@KazandraBrock]

Love this analysis!!!

[@Jjongler]

Thank you for reacting to Taemin! I really, really enjoyed your reaction

[@curse0126]

19:28 most definitely interested. Would be even more grateful if you do one of Taemin's other songs too. (Criminal comes to mind specifically) Dude has a degree in film, so he has a lot of opinions when filming music videos, talks with the directors a lot so that the message he's trying to say really gets to the audience. So, yes PLEASE, I would love to see something like that.

[@AuntIssa]

Peter, I was so thrilled to see you were analyzing Taemin! Immediately clicked on it! I have watched many of your videos before (Home free, Pentatonix, dimash, you yourself and others) so I knew you would give a professional, educated review based on the Voice. I was not disappointed. Thank you. My recommendation for Taemin is Black Rose. Oh, and a couple of other 5HINee member songs: Onew’s ‘Circle’ and Jonghyun’s ‘Y si fuera Ella’

[@ashleysasscer]

loved this analysis so much, smiled the whole time seeing how much you appreciate Taemin

[@Lupita311]

Taemin did a killing voice... I love your reaction and I love ❤❤❤Taemin

[@mariacabral1218]

TAEMIN IS solo artist amazing dancer plus he started with the group SHINEE while they were in the army he joined another group SUPERM while still doing his solo stuff when you dig in its hard to come out THANK YOU FOR DOING THE REATION

[@kristinejxxv]

This is such a wonderful analysis. It makes me so much prouder of taemin. Thank you!

[@azuazu4734]

I think you’d enjoy the lore behind Guilty as well (but might be a lil bit difficult to understand without knowing the rest of his discography too) but you could check out the trailer to Guilty too. Gives more impact to the song (his delivery and such) 😊 Edit: I actually caught that “distorted voice” the first time I heard Guilty and I really believe it was a genius addition. I don’t think I can explain it well but it’s part of Taemin’s story telling in this particular art

[@MorikoKumori]

My first time seeing one of your videos and I loved it. After a lifetime as a rock fan, I recently branched out and fell in love with KPop, mostly due to Stray Kids (hopefully you can cover them). I've also become a fan of Taemin, and am fascinated by his dancing and vocals. I've become addicted to "Guilty" but your analysis opens up a whole new dimension of appreciation and understanding. I know what I like but always wonder why and your technical analysis really helps. I am really looking forward to watching more of your videos!

[@raprilc2]

I love when people first discover Taemin

[@sindahat7451]

His most famous song is Move-I would say mostly for the phenomenal choreography. Otherwise for voice, I’d rec the ones recommended above ^

[@amaliar5735]

As a classical musician and singer who is also a huge Taemin fan, I loved your reaction looking at this video through this lens! I would love if you checked out more music of his, maybe Advice and/or Criminal? And it’s just a b-side (so no mv) but his song Rise is one of my favorites of his from a vocal standpoint so I’d love to know what you’d think of it.

[@babeh9999]

Thanks 🙏🏽 so much for your professional reaction to TAEMIN’s vocal performance! Because we as fans of TAEMIN love TAEMIN for his amazing vocals and we are proud of his hardwork and dedication to his art! He continues to grow and amaze us with his endless talent and passion! Please 🙏🏽 react to my favourite song by TAEMIN ~ ADVICE! Thanks so much again! ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️

[@amandasalern0811]

You have no idea how many times I have watched and listened to this song. Every time I always hear something else and I literally want to scream at how good it is

[@harriettholmes539]

Taemin said the song and video concept came from a 1957 book 'L 'Erotisme by French philosopher George Bataille expressed his desire instrest to explore complex emotions.

[@orangetaemint]

I love your in-depth vocal analysis! It’s probably already been recommended but I would love to get your analysis of Taemin’s Killing Voice episode where he sings short snippets of his dance and ballad songs. He said his voice wasn’t in the best condition when he had to record that episode but I’d like to get a professional’s opinion on how he did. He’s also a part of a group called Shinee and his bandmate Onew sang opera at one of their concerts and it would be amazing to get your reaction to how he did!

[@djjkhsnejje]

KING TAEMIN

[@tsiyaama4244]

Another note: Another member of his kpop group SHINee has performed opera, his name is Onew. For more Taemin artistry I suggest Advice. Any more indepth analysis I'd be up for. Producers would be a possibility as well as they see all the angles of the sound.

[@PhantamSam]

I am certain others mentioned SHINee at this point, the group that Taemin is a part of. They are all incredible artists and vocalists, I would love for you to check them out individually or as group. They have one of the largest discographies in kpop, so narrowing down recommendations is not exactly easy (I am sorry other Shawols) but I will stick to 1 recommendation per member and 1 for the group: SHINee (This was very hard for me to pick, but I wanted a song that highlighted all 5 of their vocals, was between this choice and my personal favorite "View)- Tell Me What To Do Onew (The leader of the group, and an absolutely stellar vocalist)- O (Circle) Jonghyun (Main Vocalist of SHINee and considered to be one of the greatest vocalists in Kpop)- Y si fuera Ella (live performance) or Shinin' (If you want a music video) Key (Lead Rapper of Shinee, but the man has serious vocal chops, and charisma out the a**)- Hate That... ft Taeyeon (another incredible vocalist who just dropped her latest album today as I am writing this) Minho (Main Rapper- Deeply underappreciated for his rich baritone, something that tends to be undervalued in Kpop)- Heartbreak Taemin (Main Dancer- fun fact, he was considered to be tone deaf when he debuted with SHINee. He has come an incredibly long way)- Criminal

[@TheScotgal71]

Enjoyed your reaction so much. Taemin is a special artist - truly a once in a generation talent. For future recommendations I would suggest idea, criminal, want which are all to the tracks. For b sides I would suggest heaven and rise.

[@shawnacover]

Thank you for doing this reaction, i love how you try to analyze things here and there, cuz it's interesting to hear more about his vocals and thr music itself ♡ looking forward to your next reaction video of taemin or maybe you want to check shinee's video too, taemin is the member and the other member got Amazing voices too esp live performance is insane! Haha

[@mrmsftr8841]

Thank you for your reaction and positive comments 🫶

[@practicallypj]

I love Taemins voice, of course his dancing is incredible as well. He is an amazing artist and performer that never fails to deliver magic.

[@mabellelotte4385]

He is so lovely artist i Love him

[@caseyallan7772]

You should react to Taemin's group Shinee, they're often considered as some of the best singers in Kpop!

[@seleneklarelee930]

2 minutes in this reaction, I'm already liking it, aside from Taemin, I like how you're explaining not just the instrumental in the song but also the notes Taemin himself is hitting with his vocals. I get quite dissapointed when people don't comment enough about his voice as they do his dancing so thank you. Really, this comeback of his made me smirk at people getting shocked at his vocals cuz now finally they'll gonna have to keep in mind he's that good in singing too (they never really did checked his b-sides)... I might really consider subscribing if I see more reactions on Taemin and other artists I know in your channel...

[@nualaseamus]

Taemin song is a earworm - it will invade your mind. The video is awesome and I enjoyed your breakdowns. Don't know about anyone else, but I'm always down for a longer video when it has people who know about singing, video production, dancing, etc... giving interesting feedback and breakdowns.

[@gabriellahuszti5855]

Taemin💯❤️‍🔥

[@sw33tm3]

I was mesmerized by his expressive performance. As someone with no musical background, the best way I can describe Taemin’s voice is it feels like butter, very smooth.

[@ultrainthemilkyway5090]

Thank you!!!Finally a precise,informative professional review of Taemin's work. There are TONS of "reaction" videos, but this is not one of them,I'm so happy to say! I love the depth and knowledge you helped give your audience while reviewing this MV. I can appreciate 'GUILTY' even more now. Thank you so much ❤🔥❤Please seek out Taemin again. It will be worth you time.

[@MonicalovesTAEMIN]

Thank you so much for reacting to TAEMIN. He’s the Idol of Idols in the Kpop world. He’s a solo artist and is also a member of the Kpop group SHINee. As I read in the comments and I agree with them, TAEMIN is a true artist. He sings, dances, is very creative, and he also acts. Please react to his other mvs (Advice, criminal, move, want, idea, or any other video), and please react to SHINee. Again, thank you for your honest and knowledgeable reaction, and I’ll be checking to see if you post more reactions to TAEMIN or SHINee.

[@kasiachm]

Enjoyed your reaction! Taemin is such a great dancer that sometimes his vocals don't get enough praise. He worked so hard to be this good and they kept telling him he was tone deaf and would never be a singer.

[@wonwon5992]

YESS MORE TAEMIN PLEASE