Prolific Singer/Writer On Creating A 70s Song So CREEPY It Got BANNED | Professor of Rock

[@ProfessorofRock]

Poll: What is your pick for the scariest song of all time? A song that left you completely petrified!

[@Ellfman]

Black Sabbath - Iron Man

[@nativepangea]

Excitable Boy.

[@SnarkNSass]

Jeremy 😳

[@clydevickers2684]

Bloodrock DOA

[@poetsdreamsatc]

For me it was “Helter Skelter” because of the Tate’s murders. That song truly terrified me just because of the ties to Charles Manson. It was 40 years before I could hear that song and really listen to the lyrics. Now I appreciate it as a Beatles song and not to Sharon Tate’s murder. That was a very scary time during the Manson family murders.

[@billkelly1197]

Great interview Adam! This is Bill Kelly, the singer on the hit Timothy. Those were wonderful memories to share with my friend Rupert. If you’d ever like to hear my perspective on those days let me know.

[@1978garfield]

You should totally have him on! I would love to hear what he thought about the song.

[@SilverJ56]

Wow!! Incredible!! I remember my thoughts from back then when I first heard "Timothy"... " Those guys are super cool for singing that song!" "What a bunch of great guys!" I was 15 years old. Thank you for singing it and thanks to Rupert for writing it! (Didn't know he had written it until this vid!). Thanks Adam!!!

[@kristencostello7042]

Hi Bill 😘

[@cruikshank]

Please interview him. I grew up in the Anthracite Region of Northeast PA close to the town of Sheppton PA where 3 men were trapped for several days 300 feet underground. 2 were rescued alive but one Lou Bova was Never Found. This happened in 1963 and made National news. Equipment from Howard Hughes was used to drill a shaft to rescue the men. When only 2 of the 3 were rescued the rumor mill started about them eating him to survive. The song by a local Anthracite Coal Region band just filed the rumor mill. There was always the alternative theory of miners eating a mine mule to survive. Miners treated the mules with respect since they were partners underground hauling the heavy coal out. Miners often named the mules so this theory wasn’t so far fetched. Excellent song, it will be in my head tonight and I’ll be downloading it to my iPhone play list. Thank you to Rupert and to the Buoys for such an awesome catchy tune. Bill Kelly, do you still play live in Central / Northeast PA? I’d love to catch you live. Dave in Reading but from Frackville, PA. Listened to the song on local AM radio WMBT Shenandoah and WPPA WPAM in Pottsville PA during the 60-70’s.

[@robertdillon9989]

You sound great !

[@clem0822]

OMG! That “ Timothy” story is outrageous. Rupert is a delight to hear from, this was a great episode. Bravo Professor!

[@newmanoutdoors1564]

Should have been# 1

[@MyXxx77]

Rupert Holmes is what is referred to as a "digger". He dug and scratched and thought out of the box to make a name for himself as well as a living. One of my favorite people in show business and always a great interview. Great job!

[@Frankie5Angels150]

I prefer the term “whore” to describe Mr. Holmes.

[@topenddean]

Rupert Holmes, I had no idea what an incredible and talented person he is. A very enlightening interview. Bravo to all involved!

[@s.jackman7684]

The Wreck Of The Edmund Fitzgerald...the haunting tone at times ethereal, when mixed with Lightfoot's equally haunting narrative of this true story, rife with fear and apprehension, sweeps over and draws in the listener. I was at a concert of his in 1983-84, and we heard him in a symphony hall, and when he played this, you could literally hear a PIN drop!! Mesmerizing!!

[@charilynn6647]

I went to a Gordon Lightfoot concert at that time also. When he got on stage he told the audience to keep quiet. He said even if you want to hum, Don't. So everyone was quiet. He's talented but his appeal to the audience is dubious.

[@s.jackman7684]

@@charilynn6647 I think he's just human, we have good das and bad. Maybe he day was important to him? Sorry you went through that. 😞

[@LeTrashPanda]

@@s.jackman7684 She's so wrong about him, he never chased fame however he DID have struggles with substance & his health, he's a humble soul nobody has ever talked bad about him in the music business, he made MANY famous besides himself. He probably has sensory issues (like an Autistic) he got the Hall of Fame award last year & truly deserved it. He has millions of adoring fans of all ages not just Boomers. kzbin.info/www/bejne/laaTh39uht2Ml5o

[@CarolStJohn-ev9ry]

That is an epic song. Even after hearing it all these years it will still draw me in with his story and the fabulous music that accompanies it.

[@carolkaye3512]

I grew up in Great Lakes area. It so describes the time, hearing on the local news of the ship being missing etc.

[@golflre7179]

“Finest song about cannibalism ever” 🤣 What a great guy - thanks for the interview, very fun.

[@gibsonstation1292]

Wow! I remember hearing "Timothy" on the radio in the 70s. Haven't heard the song in a very long time but I always liked it. Mr. Holmes is a fascinating person to listen to explaining how he did what he did in the industry that he chose. He is an American gift. Thanks for the History lesson, Professor!

[@teresafarrell6457]

I was very young in the 70's (born '71) and my youngest aunt and I loved 'They're Coming To Take Me Away' 🎶 Several people in the family thought it was "creepy".

[@bradbennett3967]

I would without fail listen to Casey Kasem and then Dr Demento, it was the highlight of every week entertainment wise where most everyone first heard this song hoho haha hee hee to the funny farm where life is happy...I miss Dr Demento so much r. i. p. good public radio

[@clawton123]

I was just going to add this song.

[@ddz1375]

I was born in 67 and I remember listening to the Doctor Demento show and he would play that song every so often. Good stuff, good stuff. The woke people would find something offensive about it today. They would not see the humor.

[@eucliduschaumeau8813]

@@ddz1375 Woke people simply do not have a sense of humor. They're the biggest collection of easily offended, sociopathic and angry people ever known on earth. It's a shame for them, because decades ago, the music was what it was all about. The music was the soundtrack of our lives.

[@ddz1375]

@@eucliduschaumeau8813 indeed music was the language we spoke and what spoke for us. So much poetry has been lost so many songs are banned by these tone death and humorless persons. All expression seems to be banned as well. I miss Echo & the Bunnymen, Siouxsie and the Banshees, Velvet Underground, Black Flag, Grace Jones and so many other talented artists. Ot seems the cut off date for good lyrics was 2004.

[@thebullet7874]

Great video my first with you. I was 18-19 when Mr Holmes recorded Pina Colada and Him. I wasn’t flipping for the songs , thought they were sappy, yacht radio describes the style perfectly. Well, today I hear Mr Holmes music, I filled with nostalgia and fondness. I did not know you did so much so early. Congratulations and great tactic for getting Timothy played. I’m in awe of this. I’d love to sit with Mr Holmes what stories he tells. I’m now a subscriber. Thank you

[@slrnuttall]

That's why I love your show. I never knew that Rupert wrote Timothy. I grew up in the 70s and 80s listening to this and other songs on our major AM radio station. Always like the tune but never really paid any attention to lyrics unless I was trying to sing it. Timothy was not a song I would sing, just hum so I didn't make the cannibalism connection til just now. Awesome man!

[@carnacthemagnificent2498]

When you interview Brian Wilson or Nancy Wilson or Patti Smith or Sammy Hagar you know what you're getting and that it's going to be great. With Rupert Holmes I had no idea what was coming. Fascinating guy, seems like you could talk all night and just get a thousand interesting stories from him. Unexpectedly great interview!

[@nativepangea]

When I started working construction as a kid (named Tim) in 1980 a few of the older guys would sing "Timothy were has he gone" I had no idea about this song until today. Mystery solved.

[@NickNicometi]

42 YEARS!!! 😳

[@logan_e]

That's gotta be mind blowing! 😂

[@joefunsmith]

Love it. And now very confused. I distinctly remember being in Jr. High School (1973 to 1976) and going to school one day and several people saying how Brian Jones had died and they heard it in the news. It was MANY (25ish) years later, that I found out Brian Jones was not only a dead, former member of The Rolling Stones, but the founder. Never paid too much attention to his death date though. He died in 1969 when I lived in another state. Additionally, he died in July when I would have been enjoying Summer vacation. Either way, I am now very aware of who Brian Jones was.

[@ryohn5468]

Based on a mine disaster in Pennsylvania.

[@RayfordRaySiegel]

I guess that not knowing, at the time, saved you from being freaked out by your co-workers.

[@paulcarr5918]

I love Rupert Holmes. I remember when I was a kid and learned that he wrote You Got It All by the Jets. That made me start looking into him and he quickly became one of my favorites. I'm glad you've been able to bring us some interviews with him because his stories are endlessly entertaining.

[@RickBrenner-z4i]

“You Got It All” is one of my favorite songs of all time😊. Rupert Holmes is a great songwriter! My favorite part is: “Honey it’s true. There’s JUST you! You musta been heaven sent Hearing me call you when out On a limb.”

[@peterspitz2385]

Thanks for yet another great interview, Professor. Rupert Holmes is one of my favourite artists. One song that I really love and actually relate to (having worn glasses pretty much my whole life and now being legally blind) is "Nearsighted". The line "There's more to see than can be seen, more said than what is heard" are. in my humble opinion, pure genius.

[@mrtomalonzo]

This reminds me of the only mining tragedy song I know: The Bee Gees' "New York Mining Disaster 1941". A very tiny genre of music, indeed! Great interview with Rupert Holmes, Adam!

[@arribaficationwineho32]

Love that song! I preferred early BeeGees to their disco years.

[@livezero264]

It amazes me how there is so much more to things than meets the eye, or ear. Be it what a mechanic does or a chef or a barber, it doesn’t matter. Hearing Rupert explain the elements of his songwriting and realizing why it makes the listener feel the way it does is phenomenal. Thanks to the Professor for presenting this to us.

[@vnette9777]

I used to sing Timothy as a very young girl of 7years old.I had no idea what it was about then and I just now learned!How interesting!Thanks to Rupert and the Professor!

[@nopainlorraine1128]

One of my co-workers name is Timothy, and I just can't stop myself from singing the chorus when he comes in the shop.

[@TheCraig8754]

This is by far one of your best interviews. Of course like everyone else I had to pause it to listen to Timothy. Thank you so much for letting us behind the scenes into the real music world.

[@vjr5261]

By far one of the best interviews! Thank you Rupert! I remember singing along riding in the car with my mom in the 60s/70s listening to the LA AM radio station KHJ.

[@jameskeyes1131]

Really cool interview. Talented and creative guy. Timothy is one of my favorite songs, not for the creepiness but for the arrangement.

[@poetsdreamsatc]

I remember when this song came out. I heard my friends talking about “Timothy” and was shocked when I found out what this song was about. It definitely creeped me out. But then the movie “Alive” came out about Uruguay's rugby team crashing in the Andes Mountains. Your perspective changes when it’s life or death. Timothy prepared me for real life stories.

[@ProfessorofRock]

Scary stuff for sure.

[@oldschoolrr6077]

When I was living in L.A. as a teenager, I remember hearing "Timothy" on 1110 KRLA-AM a couple times in the Spring of 1971. The #1 Rock station at the time, 93 KHJ-AM Boss Radio had banned the song and to my knowledge, never played it.

[@poetsdreamsatc]

@@oldschoolrr6077 Now that you mentioned it I remember it was played a handful of times then our radio stations in Texas quit playing Timothy as well. I can’t even remember when I last heard Timothy on the radio.

[@5roundsrapid263]

What’s ironic, is that the actual plane crash was roughly about the same time. 1972, I think. The rugby team was racked with guilt, but eventually were forgiven by the Pope himself.

[@mjgrogan1315]

Rupert is such a cool guy. Fantastic interview Professor. You need to talk to him again, so much more to hear

[@baneverything5580]

This man should be BANNED!

[@nopainlorraine1128]

@@baneverything5580 HaHaHa 😆

[@hallacar]

I had never heard of the Buoys until this past October when I was looking for songs for a Halloween party and did some KZbin searching. The story of Rupert Holmes' idea hit me as funny and the song reminded me of "Big Bad John" taking a very bad turn. Excellent video, sir.

[@ProfessorofRock]

Thanks for watching my friend!

[@HOTTIUSMAXIMUS]

@@ProfessorofRock So Professor, after seeing that I was not the first nor only subscriber to nominate “D.O.A.” by Bloodrock for creepiest rock song, I must ask--would you please do a story on that particular song and Bloodrock?

[@QBAN2010]

Check out a band called Dakota! The group formed out of The Buoys. They had an amazing lp in the 80s. Check out the track by Dakota called Runaway….same lead singer, Bill Kelly! Awesome!!!

[@HOTTIUSMAXIMUS]

@@QBAN2010 “Crazy Love” by Dakota is one of my favorites from that era. For years I searched for it (pre-internet ) but most searches got me Poco, Allman, or Van Morrison. All good songs but not what I was looking for. When I eventually connected to the web on a Q&A site, I finally discovered that it was Dakota that recorded the song I had been searching for all those years! Here it is!kzbin.info/www/bejne/jIe0lZ-wp8plipI

[@ZOSO900]

I first discovered this song a couple years ago when Todd in the Shadows reviewed it for Halloween. Great episode.

[@MerryMoonDesigns70]

This was a great interview! The creepiest song of all time for me is Angie Baby by Helen Reddy. That is an F'd up song!

[@donniegombel]

As a child of the 50's I watch so much of these things unfold. Imagine what he may know of other people's stories. A 6 hr. rap session wouldn't dent what he knows. Fabulous!!!

[@cleoldbagtraallsorts3380]

Agreed, it's very creepy. But I love it.

[@fvrrljr]

creepy !? always loved that song, a month ago i played it for my preteen daughter. she too liked it

[@cleoldbagtraallsorts3380]

@@fvrrljr Have you listened to the lyrics? It's creepy but a great song. 😀

[@fvrrljr]

@@cleoldbagtraallsorts3380 i grew up listening to it back in '74. also The Night When The Light Went Out In Georgia by Vicky Lawrence (not Rebba's versions) "favorite line is "little sister don't miss when she aims her gun" Ode to Billy Joe, Harper Valley PTA, Delta Dawn, I Am Woman, At Seventeen, One Tin Soldier, Big Bad John, Don't Mess Around With Jim, American Pie... love story telling songs 👍👍👍i could go on 🤣🤣🤣 edit: here's a film of Angie Baby kzbin.info/www/bejne/gJaklJ2IgbGdpNk

[@PierreLelong-v5j]

I was an AM Top 40 jock when the song was released. We used Billboard and Radio & Records as reporterships. The record started moving up the charts and we jumped on it and put it on the air to many requests. Hell, it was a good song. I started singing it in the jock control room and the words began to make sense but I kept the secret to myself. However, word started getting out and rumors of bannings started circulating among the jock and radio world. We'd been playing it for quite some time when the management's order to pull it came down. The music director pulled it from the rotation and stashed all our copies in the record library. I kept getting requests. A lot of them. I had top ratings in my time slot, 6-10 pm. I'm not disappointing my listeners, I thought. I snuck a single copy of Timothy out and played it a number of times over the course of a week and a half. Then, the hammer came down...I was suspended for two days. Lol! It was worth it.

[@petemeade]

I heard that after the bans started, a story was started that Timothy was their burrow! Is that true?

[@bshade8547]

“Him” by Mr. Holmes is hands down one of my favorite songs of the late 70’s.

[@DDKaraokeOutlaw]

I like it as well.

[@chrisgdyer]

I agree!

[@uhdudewhy7980]

Yes, great song.

[@krisgreenwood5173]

Agree. It's one of my favorites.

[@ceceliadenny3542]

“Him” is definitely on my favorites playlist.

[@Undertaker67203]

Every time I see an interview with Rupert, I like him even more. He must be a joy to talk too.

[@ianrobinson4200]

I never got into Rupert's music too much, but he sure makes for a great interview. One of the best interviewees on the channel for sure

[@prehensiledale1215]

This is lovely. Seeing Rupert Holmes today is such a treat. Thank you, Professor!

[@dowadiddy2002]

Ah, as a kid of the 70's I remember the Pina Colada Song so well and it was such a huge hit. Everyone was singing it and enjoying it. Such a great sing-along song. Great video!

[@robster7316]

Great interview, Adam! Rupert is the master of catchy, clever lyrics and lyrical plot twists. What a tune Timothy was. Loved playing it for others and watching the penny drop!

[@gretchenlittle6817]

Never knew that Rupert Holmes was involved with "Timothy" -- I remember the song well, especially the violin notes after they sing the name. This was in rural PA, and all we had to listen to was AM radio (mostly from larger cities -- WLS from Chicago had a super-strong signal that came in very clearly at night.)

[@5roundsrapid263]

WLS still goes all the way down to the Gulf Coast at night. My mother-in-law grew up listening to it in Mississippi.

[@jamessotherden5909]

WLS . Man, I live in Syracuse Ny and as a teen back in the 70's I loved listening to that station at night.

[@ricksunderland1421]

The furthest away I ever heard WLS was Freeport Bahamas. Fleetwood Mac’s “Tusk”, when it was new. I was that shocked that I remember. RIP Uncle Lar. You are missed.

[@greyeaglem]

I used to listen to WLS late at night when I was a kid. WWL in New Orleans too. Never heard the station Wolfman Jack was on though. I either couldn't pick it up or didn't know to look for it. I grew up in MN, so it might have been too far away. There used to be a guy on one of those strong stations that called himself Ruby's Husband. He used to have ads from all over the place. He'd advertise a tire sale in one state and something else in a completely different state halfway across the country. He's always say "Tell 'em Ruby's husband sent ya.'

[@ricksunderland1421]

@@greyeaglem Radio skips in weird ways. You'd think that the 100k watt Mexican rock stations Wolfman Jack was on would've reached you if 50k watt WLS did. Everyone loved Wolfman Jack, but growing up literally within sight of the Sears Tower Larry Lujack was my man.

[@philf4086]

Another great episode! Really liking the behind-the-scenes stories by Rupert. This story about The Buoys is almost like the plot of "The Producers" and the play "Springtime for Hitler".

[@johnnada1222]

I thought the exact same thing .

[@BrayTube]

@@johnnada1222 Except 'Springtime for Hitler' was a desperate attempt at failure, while 'Timothy' was a desperate attempt at success.

[@rwk1013]

Awesome interview!!! If he hasn't he should write a book about his life experiences in the music industry.

[@patriciariddle2997]

What an awesome interview! I had no idea he wrote Timothy. I love that song and still listen to it. It's great to hear the story behind it. I love that he did whatever it took to succeed. No job was too small. He is a man to be admired.

[@sidiov]

I remember listening to Timothy on the Dr Demento show on my shortwave radio at night as a kid. Love it, never even knew that was Rupert. Thanks Prof.

[@jeffnicholas6342]

My Dad recorded old 60's or 70's Dr. Demento broadcasts on tape in Akron, OH and made his own compilation which he played for me and my sister as we were growing up in 80's!! We loved it! There was a track by some random band that was 'Stairway to Heaven' but all the lyrics were replaced with the 'Gilligan's Island' theme.

[@theshermer]

I did remember seeing the song Timothy on one of Dr Demento’s CD’s!

[@andylucyshyn]

Fascinating interview! Love the channel and the backstories behind the music. Honestly, the Escape song has never been my favorite - but hearing how the song came to life brings a whole new appreciation for the song and will forever change how I hear it. The extra eighth note made all the difference!

[@tanyanoakes3612]

I think this was your best interview yet Professor of Rock! Such an interesting artist! My favourite creepy songs are “ Hot child in the City” by Nick Gilder and “People are Strange” by the Doors.

[@MrTaxiRob]

what's creepy about Hot Child In The City?

[@atomiccritter6492]

I would say Billion Dollar Babies by Alice Cooper is creepy

[@MrTaxiRob]

@@atomiccritter6492 The Air That I Breathe by The Hollies is pretty creepy

[@atomiccritter6492]

@@MrTaxiRob I see what you did there

[@MrTaxiRob]

@@atomiccritter6492 the entire Virgin Suicides soundtrack is creepy

[@Ontir]

I've been listening to Timothy, a lot, since watching this episode. The other day, Escape was playing, in the wild, and I found myself singing, "If you like piña coladas... and eating friends in a cave..." It garnered odd looks on the sidewalk. Grateful for CA's mask mandate.🤣

[@DonyaLane]

Very clever! I know Rupert would appreciate that! LOL

[@jimmymelendez1836]

Man, have me rolling with that little ditty you've concocted.😂👍

[@julieporter7805]

Is that where they are going on their date after they drink Pina coladas, get caught in the rain, and make love on the dunes of the cape? Go to the cave and eat their friends!😱

[@michellbrown4862]

😂

[@gummodude]

Awesome story. Never knew much about Rupert other than the hit song but he seems like a great guy and more prolific than I could imagine.

[@LuneyTune72]

Creepiest song of the 70s is hands down “DOA” by Bloodrock. Second would be “Years Ago” or “Steven” by Alice Cooper.

[@rroades]

I was scanning comments because DOA just HAD to get mentioned, but was that 60’s?

[@opietwoep1247]

‘I'm a little boy No, I'm a great big man No, let's be a little boy For a little while longer Maybe an hour?’ Greatest lyrics to hear for the first time with headphones

[@LuneyTune72]

@@rroades 1970-1971 They were ahead of their time.

[@1tulip]

@@rroades Same.

[@mikeroland2133]

Came here to say the same thing. DOA is uncomfortable to sit through.

[@grene1955]

I was in a band that opened for the Buoys way back when. They were a really good band, and really nice guys!

[@bethshadid2087]

Awesome memory 🕊️

[@smokeyplaces2go]

What was your band?

[@subs4794]

Did you see Bill Kelly replied in another comment a day after yours...

[@epiphonium]

Awesome !

[@fumedrummer]

I heard an urban legend that "Timothy" was a horse/mule that was down in the mine with the two guys. There was no cannibalism. This interview blows that out of the water. Thanks.

[@5roundsrapid263]

Supposedly the record label said that after it became a hit, and they realized what it was about.

[@scotthutchens1203]

I heard the song in the early 70’s. By the time I heard it, maybe a year or two after it came out, radio stations or some other media outlet put out the cover story of the mule because my friend and I were talking about it. I rarely listened to lyrics back then anyway.

[@scotthutchens1203]

@@5roundsrapid263 That’s what I heard happened. By the time my friends and we’re talking about the song we heard it was about the mule.

[@patrickross9681]

I believe the single had a full picture jacket with the band and a mule with mining ⛏️ gear on it. I heard the same story that Timothy was a Mule and that the other two had to kill and eat it until they were rescued. The photo on the single jacket was supposed to be a clue as to what supposedly happened to Timothy.

[@jamessotherden5909]

@@patrickross9681 Yes I remember seeing that record jacket myself. But I think that was after all the hullabaloo about when the song first came out.

[@Starsk25]

Oh yeah, 'Timothy'!! Catchy tune. First heard it when I was a little kid, and it stuck in my head all of these years.

[@cynhanrahan4012]

OMG I remember Timothy! It was awesome. And I remember it from the radio, but I don't remember it being banned. That makes it even better. Cannibalism. Great song topic. Seriously amazing from the same guy who wrote the pina colada song.

[@mysterbear]

Played this gem for one of my classes a couple years ago, just to give them a sense of how broad, strange and wonderful radio was, back in the day. Their eyes popped. It was hilarious.

[@kxrv6629]

You’ve outdone yourself Adam! Timothy is my favorite quirky song of all time. I had no idea Rupert Holmes was so multi-talented and diverse. How is it even possible that the composer of the Pina Colada song wrote Timothy? I remember spending hours calling the radio station in 1971 requesting Timothy. When I finally got through the DJ would try to talk me into requesting a different song- like Santa trying to talk Ralphie into a football instead a Red Ryder BB gun in a Christmas Story. “You’ll eat your eye out!”

[@MrUnderdog-vn3zf]

There's been a few videos you've posted that didn't necessarily pique my interest, but after watching, I found them very interesting, informative and entertaining! Thank you Professor! ✌🏻😎👍🏻

[@ProfessorofRock]

Glad you like them! We try to find interesting stories, even if the song or artist isn't in the classic rock wheelhouse!

[@TrishTruitt]

I never really cared for the Pina Colada song, but I found this interview about the process, his early success in the music business, fascinating. No matter what my musical taste, this composer is definitely a creative talent.

[@DytchWytch]

i liked the pina colada song until i actually listened to the lyrics. people plotting to cheat on each other, basically, then they laugh about it, when they figure it out. you know that's not how that sh*t would play out. that would likely be a long, quiet, awkward car ride home from that bar.

[@niapaulino3310]

Grew up to the pina colada song...never listened to the lyrics...only listened to the lyrics like 10yrs ago and was truly amazed! Still got the Him song on my Ipod.

[@MomLAU]

Back in the '80s I dated a guy who was good at writing parody songs, and he came up with "If you like Pia Zadora..." It was pretty clever.

[@rushv825]

As a young kid, This song was talked about all the time in “71”. We had great conversations. Rumors spread about Timothy being a Donkey. Could you believe that…..

[@georgeedward1226]

I must say I am impressed with the reliability of your channel. You are very punctual with your posts. You must work on these 24/7 it seems like.

[@vnette9777]

I agree.

[@ProfessorofRock]

We do. WE love what we do.

[@RBS_]

...WHO YOU TELLIN'!?? ...I get my coffee, and I'm refreashin' Prof's channel until the new post pops UP! ...and, I'm supposed to be WORKIN'! ...ha-HAAA!!

[@stephenbrown4211]

Yes I wait for 4pm (UK)to see what Adam comes up with next

[@ianrobinson4200]

@@ProfessorofRock You are very fortunate, the majority of us can't stand our jobs believe me but having videos like this every day can make things more bearable

[@cwize]

A couple of things - first off, Rupert Holmes is an absolute delight. Great sense of humor about himself, humble and always engaging. I always thought “Escape” was a cheesy song, but no one can argue with its success. Finding out about his early arranging career was eye-opening. Second - never heard of “Timothy” or The Buoys before today! I’ll have to go give it a listen. Now, for another creepy song to feature - I would love to hear an interview with someone from Bloodrock about their dark and scary “D.O.A.” A friend of my older sister brought that 45 to our house (slumber party I think) in one of those cylindrical carriers with the little handle on top. Plenty of pop records but then BAM. They put on D.O.A. and I had nightmares for a year.

[@davidlane256]

A rock station in San Antonio used to play it every Halloween. I always looked forward to it.

[@TUSK1157]

I first heard it on FM100 in Memphis. I think, I was 12 or 13. I had seen some bad car accidents in our family travels. Every time I heard it, I would have flashbacks of those. Maybe, subconsciously, I pushed that song out of catalog of preferred listening. Lol

[@HOTTIUSMAXIMUS]

I agree--hopefully our Good Professor will profile the infamous“D.O.A.” and Bloodrock

[@jimleech2364]

I had an alarm radio in the 70's. I had a habit of accidently setting the radio to go on in the middle of the night. One time DOA played.

[@HOTTIUSMAXIMUS]

@@jimleech2364 Yoooouuuu Remember…

[@musicandfiction]

I love this guy. Rupert seems to have a irreverent streak about him, and he sounds like a great guy to hear stories from. I absolutely love how he had the right mindset for selling a record (The Forbidden Fruit premise), and it actually worked. Rupert's done a lot, and I'm glad he's as well spoken about it as he is.

[@ProfessorofRock]

Couldn't agree more!

[@ronconrad2867]

Phenomenal story teller! No wonder he was a great songwriter!

[@quoamerica]

Love the behind the song stories like this.

[@dovegrey1]

I had the FEELING it would be about "Timothy"! It came out when I was around nine, and my schoolmates talked about it incessantly! Some people were convinced in was about cannibalism, others said no way. Years ago, I read it was about a duck....what? Who in their right minds would bring a duck to a mine? LOL This man is so interesting....makes the Pina Colada song really fascinating again (I got so sick of it when it was a hit, haha) and then I found out he did the Edwind Drood B'way show, and I was amazed and remembered the lyrics to that late 70's song and how well constructed it was. Thank you so much for this!

[@MrPhilm00r]

Never was a fan of the music, but, I could listen to him talk and tell stories all day. Great interview.

[@Panhead49EL]

My siblings were a decade older, so the music I connected to was older than other kids my age. Timothy is one of those songs that really stuck in my memory. Others were My Ding-a-ling, no explanation needed, and Love Rollercoaster because of the murderous scream. Fascinating interview.

[@Tpanther775]

I knew you had mentioned this story was coming from Rupert. Glad to finally here what he had to say. Heard this song in my 20's. It was never played on any oldies station when I was growing up. I always loved the song, even with the lyrics. Great job, Adam!

[@ProfessorofRock]

Thanks for listening Kyle! Fellow chart lover an AT40 fan!

[@Tpanther775]

@@ProfessorofRock You welcome! Also i'm glad Rupert finally set the record straight on the name The Buoys. Casey always would call the group, The Boys on the AT40's when they charted in 1971.

[@NebesaDS]

Rupert Holmes "Partners in Crime" album is one of my all time favourite albums. To this day it is still in regular rotation on my streaming player. Ten tracks, all of them catchy. Rupert is a prolific story teller and should rank as one of the all time greats, however, he never did seem to get the attention that he deserved. Thanks, Adam, for bringing this story to the masses.

[@billmers3219]

That was an awesome interview! I was a young man when the pina colada song came out! I love to hear the stories behind the music, Mr. Holmes is an interesting man. My favorite creep song... They're coming to take me away.. to the funny farm. That song freaked me out as a young boy!! Thanks again! Loved the interview

[@jaakpotts]

This channel (IMO) is the highest quality and best content on the KZbin ❤️ I never get tired listening and I know I’ll always be entertained.

[@MrJlhaynes]

Love Escape. I remember when it came out and I would crank up the radio. My wife asks me why I play it off and on and I tell her I love the story. I love a good story. Thank you for the interview.

[@Rayezor2112]

In 1971, when I was 11 years old, I heard Timothy and loved it. I bought the Album for that one song. It had some other good music on it, so I played it a lot. Bravo, Rupert!

[@Halpin2006]

"Dust In The Wind" by Kansas is truly the most haunting song of all time, for it tells of how short humanity's time on Earth is compared to the overall scientific history of the world. In 100,000 years, existing beings won't know who Apple Inc was. But they will know that ancient creatures buried nuclear waste which still pollute the land today! "Just a drop of water in an endless sea / All we do / Crumbles to the ground though we refuse to see"

[@labratamber]

A song played at many a funeral

[@mazterford]

I love the guitar on this song

[@anthonymorton4050]

No doa by blood rock kicks dust in the wind to the curb

[@Soggy-In-Seattle]

What a great interview. He has great presence and pacing in his story telling.

[@pdmullgirl]

I love this guy! Ya know it took me getting older before I realized just how talented he is. I had no idea when I would listen to “Escape” that he wasn’t just a one hit wonder. No idea. He’s a true gem. Enjoyed the video! ❤️💜💚

[@curlyhairsoprano]

I've performed two songs from his musical The Mystery of Edwin Drood. So much respect for his diverse talent. His music is complex and challenging.

[@NorthernWiner]

The song "Into the Night" by Benny Mardones always seemed creepy to me. He was 33 when he wrote about a 16 year old girl, singing "I'd take you into the night and show you a love like you've never seen." Whenever it came on the radio, I couldn't change the station fast enough.

[@deadinthewater218]

Yes Sir that is creepy

[@patriciahulett4411]

I agree with you on that song

[@MTCT942]

I agree. I was going to mention the same song. Very Creepy!!!

[@nancy9478]

I never gave it much thought at the time, but as I got older it became a disgusting song, something Epstien would like. Ewww.

[@christinaluna713]

Holy crap, I JUST heard that song, tonight, on my way home. I’ve heard it a gazillion times, over the years, but tonight it was like I was actually HEARING the lyrics for the first time. I thought, “Oh my god, what the hell is this creepster shit?! This would never fly, if it came out today!” How on earth it never struck me as creepy, before now, I have NO clue! But then I stumble across this video, totally at random… I don’t even watch the video, but just start scrolling the comments… and here you are, talking about just the thing I was thinking, an hour ago!! Weird, man… weird.

[@karenmoss8810]

I guessed it! I love this song. Haven't heard it in decades. Rupert is a genius.

[@dumodude]

Your channel's new to me and this is the 2nd video I've watched. Hearing Holmes' tell his story of these iconic songs is awesome! I grew up in the 70s and it's great to strike this sort of nostalgic chord in light my my now more mature appreciation of music, life, etc. Needless to say, I've subscribed and will look forward to more of your content. Keep it up!

[@otgenesis7410]

No way you just interviewed a legend like that. My respect for you has increased.

[@Vonlang001]

Oh I've been waiting for you to cover this song. I was in 6th grade when this song came out and I bought the 45. I still have it to. I had two friends with the name Tim and the teasing was epic. I also got into a big argument with a girl in my class because she said the lyrics were not what I said they were. But they were! Thanks Professor!

[@cupton01]

I really like interviews with Rupert. He has such interesting stories and such a great talent!!

[@davidhutchinson5233]

Man, he is really great to listen to and thank you for being patient and not interrupting him. One of the reasons I became a recent sub. Great job...and still, wow...Rupert Holmes.

[@Somethingaboutthat]

Absolutely incredible interview, incredible guest!

[@mza2195]

I like the Revelations series, getting a deeper look at the artists is interesting. Rupert Holmes is so mild mannered and looks so nice, you’d never expect him to be the one who’d push boundaries. I’d never heard Timothy before today and I thank you for introducing me to me to a new song. A banned song is brilliant! Cannibalism is the perfect thing to write about to a cheerful tune. Thanks for the fun! ~Mimi 💜

[@ProfessorofRock]

Thanks Mimi! I love Rupert, he's a good guy and a great storyteller for sure.

[@danielwendlick784]

Exactly why Roger Corman makes horror movies. And he even managed to pull off the greatest horror trick - he kept the monster off the screen.

[@eclecticentertainmentwithd9414]

And now "Birdbox" and "A Quiet Place" are vilified because you never see the monsters.

[@BryanM362]

Rupert seems very down to earth, like he could be your neighbor that just happens to have these great stories!

[@TheDianne888]

Good interview with Rupert! When I was nine, my seventeen year old sister owned the Timothy 45!

[@bheryla]

Great interview Adam! I was lucky to meet Rupert just as he released "Partners In Crime" and got a promo copy. My co-worker went to school and grew up with him. One of the nicest guys you would want to meet. Top to bottom, one of my all-time fave albums. An under rated singer songwriter in my opinion. When we were allowed to bring records to play during lunch in the 6th grade, one of my classmates brought in "Timothy" After our teacher had heard it for the first time, he said "What the hell is this?" We were all stunned as he took it off the turntable and said, "You'll be getting this back at the end of the school year."

[@WillieDuitt1]

Knowing what I Don't Like Mondays by Boomtown Rats was about and remembering the incident from the newspaper always kind of disturbing. I guess Into The Night by Bennie Mardones would be thought of being disturbing and probably wouldn't get airplay today.

[@dianevanderlinden3480]

Yeah always loved Into the Night and tried to ignore the real subject lol. But then Winger's song "Seventeen" has always creeped me out too. Kip Winger is as confusing as he is talented. At least the Into the Night guy didn't actually act on it, I don't think. But the guy in the Winger song did!

[@stevegallo8483]

Another song in the same subject area as "Into the Night" by Benny Mardones and "Seventeen" by Winger is "(She's) Sexy and 17" by the Stray Cats.

[@WillieDuitt1]

@@stevegallo8483 "Christine 16" by Kiss is another one.

[@dianevanderlinden3480]

@@stevegallo8483 yes forgot about that one. The thing about Into the Night is that the guy sounds genuinely conflicted and tormented. The other guys don't seem to care.

[@dianevanderlinden3480]

@@WillieDuitt1 super creepy

[@jeramybailey2381]

Billy Joel's Pressure video scared me as a kid (born in 78). I was watching a lot of Sesame Street at that time, so I felt a little singled out, combined with the intensity of the song.

[@chrisvitale2000]

Loved this episode. I would love for you to do an episode on the Glass Prism. I know they are very obscure but I'm glad you mentioned them because I am from and grew up in Scranton Pennsylvania and lived only blocks away from where they were formed and they are local Legends. Now I live about 10 minutes away from Wilkes-Barre Pennsylvania where the Buoys formed so they are also local Legends. So glad you shed some light on these lost bands from that era. Thanks

[@stratmaster5]

I love behind the scenes stories by the people who were there. This one is incredible!! Keep up the great work Professor of Rock!!

[@felixbenvenutty1969]

hey Professor!!!! excellent video, great stories from rupert, and yes new generations and old are enjoying that legendary song. thanks a bunch!

[@randolfo1265]

I remember that song. It was well played on AM pop radio in its time. I had know idea later that the pina colada song was done by the same guy. What a full career. Sex Pistols got banned from the BBC, this guy invented the idea years before. True pioneer!

[@abcdeeeeedded]

Rupert Holmes is a great storyteller and an interesting guy. You should get him on as much as possible.

[@ProfessorofRock]

He is so great.

[@kermitefrog64]

This song was genius. He is a great guest to hear him detail the nuances of the song. Another song from that era that tells a fascinating story is Ariel by Dean Friedman.

[@briangray00]

Deep In The Bosom Of America.

[@shirleypena4133]

@Professor of Rock Well, I must congratulate you on your finally delivering the goods! This is the very first interview you have done in which I actually learned something new and interesting! I had absolutely no idea that-of all people- RUPERT HOLMES was not only a member of that infamous band The Buoys, but was the composer of what is arguably one of the creepiest songs in the history of Pop music: 'Timothy.' Well done, Sir!!

[@richardsmith4187]

Adam Your interview with Rupert Holmes was AWESOME !!! I could listen to you both talk for hours on end. He has some really amazing stories to tell and I hope you will do another interview with him. I have fond memories of the Pina Colada song and it puts your mind in another place in time. Thanks for all your hard work and Rock On !!

[@mochs3869]

It would've been interesting to have asked Rupert how the Buoys felt about the song - were they against it and reluctantly recorded it? Or did they get what he was trying to do and were all for it? Did they ever get any backlash themselves for recording it or playing it live, etc??

[@ProfessorofRock]

Good call. He had so many songs I wanted to discuss, I didn't get the time to go more in depth...

[@bethshadid2087]

Allegedly there is a post from the lead singer asking Adam to text I guess and he'd tell him stories 🤷

[@mochs3869]

@@bethshadid2087 cool!

[@doubleuplsst3149]

@@ProfessorofRock Please interview Bill Kelly. Thanks...

[@danielhickmott5800]

I didn’t realize Rupert Holmes had written Timothy. His career all makes sense now. It’s great to hear the back story on the Piña Colada song. My only question now is were the Bouys of Timothy the same group that sang the Gilligan’s Island theme. The Bouys are listed in the first season credits.

[@truegatorguyodonnell5092]

Don't know about WHO sang the song but I read somewhere recently that "Johnny Williams" (aka John Williams of "Star Wars" and "ET" fame) wrote the ORIGINAL theme song for the unaired pilot of Gilligan's Island

[@52hombre]

I remember this song well. Liked the chord progression and was great for playing guitar. Still can remember it. Never paid a lot of attention to the lyrics although I was aware. Never knew the history on it. Amazing!

[@davidjones4291]

Great interview with Rupert Holmes . Remember buying Escape and my mates all laughing at me. Such a great song/story . In my top ten of all time 😊

[@isabelleon3360]

Today, February 10, 2022, I'm 53 going on 54yrs and I just found out what the song Timothy was really about🙃 Get interview all news to me, remember the songs but I was very young when they came out... I love these kind of stories and getting the facts from the actual person it is about❤ Thank you for interviewing him🤗

[@Martin.Wilson]

One of the most disturbing songs I've ever heard was Arlo Guthrie's "1913 Massacre". It wounded my soul to listen to it and it still does. Somehow the fact that this actually happened really makes this one hit home.

[@blakkat4126]

I was a kid when "Timothy" came out. It played a lot on the radio in Wilkes-Barre, PA where I grew up. It was different but it told a story. Nobody freaked out over it. And I used to love the "Galloping Gourmet." He was funny as hell.

[@HOTTIUSMAXIMUS]

Fascinating story and I have to say that I’d never heard of that song “Timothy” but now I have to check it out. That said, when I think of creepy rock songs (other than “Hotel California” & “People Are Strange”), I immediately think of “D.O.A.” by Bloodrock. Truthfully before I listened to this episode, I assumed that the Bloodrock song would be discussed.

[@JamesJones-zt2yx]

"D.O.A." is a beautifully crafted song, everything in it is built around the notorious musical interval called the "tritone" aka "diabolus in musica". It's repeated on the organ, sounding like a European siren, and the intervals between the roots of the chords in the chord progression are tritones as well.

[@HOTTIUSMAXIMUS]

@@JamesJones-zt2yx spot on! Between this one and “Brain Damage” by Pink Floyd, I’m sure there were plenty of chilling nights listening to music during our youth

[@MIKERUPTION]

I had never heard DOA until now. I don't know if it inspired "Halloween" by the Misfits, but I wouldn't be surprised.

[@HOTTIUSMAXIMUS]

@@MIKERUPTION I hope you enjoyed it; that song was the stuff of nightmares back in the’70s

[@MIKERUPTION]

@@HOTTIUSMAXIMUS I did. Thank you for posting about it. I can imagine the song was a shocker. I just look at the Billboard top 100 for 1970 and there are songs like Close to You by the Carpenters and Raindrops Keep Falling on My Head. DOA could be the grandfather of the Horror Punk scene.

[@tracyneer4311]

Loved Rupert! A kid in 79, just discovering music and top 40 radio, the Pina colada song was so darn catchy! Him was my favorite song for a while. Thanks for this, it is very nice to go back.