Prokofjew: 2. Klavierkonzert ∙ hr-Sinfonieorchester ∙ Yulianna Avdeeva ∙ Andris Poga

[@endo1987]

Stunning performance. Dynamic, singing, mysterious. Superb work. Exceptionally difficult concerto. I wish it would be played more often and appreciated by any audience.

[@thepianocornertpc]

It's a popular concerto. Audiences are eagerly waiting for the astonishing climaxes all over the place. Fascinating stuff and more difficult than Rach 3. The cadenza requires a very organized mind and the pick-up of the orchestra after the cadenza is just ....soul scattering. Whenever this concerto is programmed tickets are sold out quickly.

[@dianadaher9870]

Uma das melhores pianistas que já ouvi na minha vida. Absolutamente encantada! Prokofiev com certeza se orgulharia de ouví-la❤

[@Chopinmusic]

Extremely good and musical. What an excellent sound. Especially from the grand piano. Everything excellently recorded.

[@alad5926]

An absolutely amazing performance of this magnificent concerto! What a great recording, thank you so much for posting this!

[@martinschulze5399]

that amount of time and effort that goes into learning to play such pieces is crazy... love it

[@LisaKTownsend]

She is spinning up a fabulous storm. Very talented! Thank you for posting.

[@carlosymabelsosa8760]

She is the best pianist of the world, and the universe too. Like to Argerich.

[@MultiRedskins12]

Have you listened to intergalactical pianists? How can you possibly say that a pianist on Mars or Uranus isn’t at least as good , if not better. It’s a big call to say the universe. Have you even looked outside the solar system?

[@rcai7774]

I believe this is now my favorite rendition of the 2nd Piano Concerto! Avdeeva is in complete control - every nuance in this piece, every jump and every trill is fully thought out. The overall quality of this recording is superb as well - hr-Sinfonieorchester may very well be my favorite for finding the best recordings.

[@michaelmainusch7237]

Einfach nur bewundernswert ❤

[@michaelmainusch7237]

Bewundernswert ❤

[@yondertz]

Avdeeva, i’v always been a fan!! You are great!!! Thank you!!! Also, this channel never fails me! Thank you!!

[@robertcohn8858]

I hate to use cliches, but this fantastic performance literally gave me goosebumps. What a talent! Thank you very much for posting.

[@staffanolofsson8201]

Cliches are often right to the point, even if many people use them. In fact, that so many people use them is a proof they are useful. So thank you this cliche.

[@Desireyso58]

WoW! Yulianna Avdeeva it's one of my favorite performers! So I'm going to came very often to hear this concerto. As many people, I Love the cadenza!

[@ultradmann2367]

I've just recently discovered this concerto after only really just hearing only the 3rd and just putting this one off....I wish I had listened to this WAAAAY sooner! The difficult writing is remarkably witty, snarking, sinster and even sweet. And Yulianna's playing captures alllllll of the adjectives that you could possibly want to set to this piece. Her ability to to switch characters with her fingers so wonderfully and her phrasing is just insane! The last cadenza at 28:11 is just paced and phrased almost like someone is legitimately singing from the keyboard. Awesome playing from the orchestra as always too! Thanks for this gem of a performance.

[@AdrianCameron123]

Listen to Yuja wang perform it.

[@asentoni]

Beautifully filmed, and impeccable audio! Stunningly performed all around! What an absolutely phenomenal video and performance. I appreciate that the music is allowed to be thoroughly enjoyed without any hysterical over-the-top hysterics from the pianist. A classy performance in every way. She allows her performance to be HEARD, and showcases and brings forward all of the internal lines within this composition -- I've rarely heard such an accomplishment in this monster of a piece. I'm so thankful to be able to see and hear this magnificent performance of one of my favorite concertos. Thank you!!

[@staffanolofsson8201]

And thank YOU for this comment, full of insight!

[@elenam5740]

Великая музыка и потрясающее исполнение!

[@radudeATL]

I wish I practiced my scales and arpeggios more. I’ve got the banging part down pretty good. 😂 Seriously, this is a stunning performance, a tour de force.

[@sonjas6481]

Lol😅😂

[@evi_kyriazidou]

What an amazing sound is that!!! Kudos to the sound engineer!!

[@thomask1424]

Very fine performance.

[@keithcooper6715]

Excellent Delivery' !

[@jadeaficionado5335]

I have just come across this amazing Proko performed by my favorite Julanna Avdeeva❗It is euphoric, dynamic and fantastic to be able to listen and watch your performance. No words can express my appreciation ❗❗❗ Sending LOVE from Tokyo💐💐

[@claudioparrella183]

Yulianna sei magnifica

[@BWV846]

BRAVO

[@Salatstrunk]

Phantastisch, atemberaubend. Tausend Dank!

[@MarkFarago]

Phenomenal!

[@theostibhawin2513]

c'est prodigieux de folie et de beauté !!! 2 écoutes dans la journée !! La Russie dans tous ses éclats !! Et une concentration hors norme qui nous embarque ! Chapeau bas !!!!

[@liuervin]

The buildup in the first movement... just amazing...

[@manuel-et4he]

The best!!

[@StringBoi]

Amazing job as always Yulianna, look forward to your next performance!

[@andre1214g]

The cadenza of this Concerto has never been so well interpreted as by Yulianna Avdeeva, a great virtuose. Bravo!

[@prometheusrex1]

Disagree. Try Gutierrez.

[@stephanworm8470]

Yuja Wang plays the Cadenz also brilliant.

[@stevenmccarthy7039]

As a Prokofiev (esp Piano Concertos and sonatas) fan since late 70s when I first came across and bought Ashkenazy's recordings of the 5 concertos on vinyl it is so exciting to see the 2nd becoming maybe more well-known nowadays with more younger pianists tackling this extra-ordinary, thrilling and in places very beautiful concerto. What a fantastic recording. Thank you for making it available and what brilliant and sensitive playing. Thank you.

[@staffanolofsson8201]

I am sure also Ashkenazy´s version is very good! But, as you say, all that can let this second consert be more popular is good. And I am sure Yuliannas playing is very good. Thank you.

[@bubffm]

Das war ein sensationelles Konzert! Nun endlich auch online.

[@maartenvanderlek8955]

For me, Yulianna's interpretation is so shocking, I can't say it in words. So how she unterstands this piece ist unique!!! So much despair! And yet we should perceive the positive in our world! 💚🧡

[@JuanDcl]

I like it but i like even more evgeny kissin's interpretation in 2009 or yuja wang's in berlin 2015. Check them out too

[@maartenvanderlek8955]

@@JuanDcl Thanks for the tip. But I don't compare.

[@prometheusrex1]

Try Gutierrez. No one better.

[@thepianocornertpc]

@@JuanDcl I did, and I like Juliana better. Not because I compare, like you do, but because Juliana's rendering speaks to my heart. My heart.

[@olivierbeltrami]

Wow !!!

[@guaguaboy79]

Aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaah!!! So goooooooooooooooooooooood!!!!

[@valentinoortolani494]

meravigliosa interpretazione

[@ernest_asa_iii]

Julianna Avdeeva é tecnicamente una pianista meravigliosa. Se sei a Londra Maurizio Pollini ha in programma un piano recital il 17 marzo 2023 al Royal Festival Hall.

[@staffanolofsson8201]

Another wonderful version of this piano consert on KZbin. Thank you for exquisite playing, Yulianna Avdeeva! One of the best versions I ever heard with also a great sound.

[@staffanolofsson8201]

When I say "another" Im refering to Anna Vinnitskaja. They are both super-good in making this something you dont forget so easily, but I will of course not make any judgement. Just listen.

[@impromptube7111]

absolutely amazing 🥹🥹❤

[@Hussain_Eidani]

Very, very good performance 👏 ❤

[@kavalkid1]

She is the Judy Garland of the Concertos, never to be forgotten.

[@АлександрЖихор-н7п]

Очень тонко и аристократично Юлианна спасибо Вам!!!

[@zinam5795]

Для Пркфва эти эпитеты вовсе не обязательны, и главную тему 1ч.можно было бы проще , не так осторожно, а свободнее сыграть. Авдеева пианистка хорошая--все будет!

[@franferreira30]

Fantástico

[@MarshallArtz007]

Sergei Prokofiev (1891-1953) Piano Concerto No. 2 in G Minor, Op. 16 (1923) 00:04 I. *Andantino* 05:45 *cadenza* 10:51 *end of Mvt. 1* 12:29 II. *Scherzo. Vivace* 15:10 III. *Intermezzo. Allegro* *moderato* 22:01 IV. *Finale. Allegro tempestoso* 24:07 *meno mosso* 25:51 *[99]* 27:11 *Più mosso (Allegro)* 28:07 *cadenza* 30:18 *end of Mvt. 4* 33:43 *Applause* *Yulianna Avdeeva, piano* *Frankfurt Radio Symphony* *Andris Poga, conductor* _Alte Oper Frankfurt_ _Frankfurt, Germany 🇩🇪 January 20, 2023_

[@musicoscope]

womderful!!

[@fryk1810]

Yulianna continues with perseverance, absolute seriousness and exemplary sobriety her path of steady growth; she is the only living great pianist who reminds me of intellectual honesty that only until the last century was characteristic of great artists.

[@Termopsys]

Спасибо большое всем за исполнение одного из самого любимого фортепианного концерта Сергея Прокофьева. Обожаю всеми фибрами души!!!

[@antoinemariemillet6221]

34:35 ces b

[@antoinemariemillet6221]

C b

[@antoinemariemillet6221]

C b

[@silvio6646]

Superlativa interpretazione, modesta regia televisiva (non c'era solo la pianista...)

[@BrianPaick]

Cadenza: 5:53 "Colossale": 09:01 Recapitulation/Climax: 10:50

[@ernest_asa_iii]

5:50 Cadenza - Prokofiev: Piano Concerto No.2 🎹🎉 Next concert I'll attend, *Daniil Trifonov's* is playing Prokofiev: Piano Concerto No.3 with the London Philharmonic Orchestra. 15/3/23 What's your favourite recording of the 2nd Piano Concerto?

[@ChanceyWigglesworth]

I'll be seeing him play the Prokofiev 2 at the Kennedy Center next month!

[@Desireyso58]

Yuja Wang, Anastasia Nesterova y Anna Vinnitskaya.

[@dirkschneiderheinze]

Gutierezz is a classic

[@ronaldbwoodall2628]

What's my favorite recording of the Prokofiev 2nd? Good question! I've been trying to remember the artists on an RCA Victor LP long ago with a French orchestra and pianist (?) that has remained in my memory as the best I've yet heard. I'll be doing some research on that; meanwhile maybe someone knows which one I'm referring to, and can wake up my "little gray cells" regarding this.

[@staffanolofsson8201]

Yulianna Avdeeva and Anna Vinnitskaya. They are both favourites.

[@bondjames417]

最高です

[@ronl7131]

Very good Prokofiev vibe

[@klenaghanny]

I have watched dozens of performances of this impossible piece, and tried to play it myself. This is right up there with the greats (Bronfman, Yuja Wang, etc.) I think Argerich actually never played this concerto publicly, although she clearly mastered 1 and 3.

[@AndresFigari]

She is able to sing where many pianist just smash!

[@TeddyOn]

Умничка❤

[@andreasneumann]

10:51 pp might be - besides the charming beginnins - the greatest moment of this concert. Fabulous performance, maybe the best in history.

[@andreasneumann]

And 21:20 of course. So krass.

[@MarshallArtz007]

@@andreasneumann …And 25:51 where the bassoons take up that beautiful melody.

[@danyariv-weisbuch7543]

💜💜💜💜💜💜💜❣

[@notaire2]

Wunderschöne und detaillierte Aufführung dieses spätromantischen und perfekt komponierten Konzerts mit klarem doch elegantem Klang des unverleichlichen Soloklaviers sowie gut vereinigten und perfekt entsprechenden Tönen der anderen Instrumente. Der intelligente und geniale Dirigent leitet das ausgezeichnete Orchester im veränderlichen Tempo und mit künstlerisch kontrollierter Dynamik. Faszinierend vom Anfang bis zum Ende!

[@francoisrodewald9868]

Digga wieso schreibst du 1000 Mal den gleichen Kommentar? Das sagt nix aus und das Stück ist nichtmal spätromantisch

[@jeffgrigsbyjones]

The most impressive moment to me was the first page of the first-movement cadenza, where the sweep of Avdeeva's playing was so sumptuous that it felt like the orchestra was still playing, even though she was alone. She doesn't have the titanic command of the best players of this concerto, like Bronfman or Gutierrez, but the musical interpretation is first-rate.

[@АлексейФедин-с8ч]

Прокофьев мой любимый композитор. Спасибо.

[@thepianocornertpc]

Better than Wang. The breathing in the cadenza is phenomenal...not just showing technical proficiency but emphasizing sonority, phrasing ....just wonderful. My favourite pianist together with Zlata Chochieva.

[@charlesphelps2247]

I agree completely, they are currently my two favorite pianists. Check out Chochieva's new recording of this concerto. It's wonderful.

[@thepianocornertpc]

@@charlesphelps2247 I am familiar with all her work and recordings. Chochieva is an amazing , void of pretention pianist. Also check this 19 year young Russian winner of the Tchaikowski 2023 kzbin.info/www/bejne/aYmlZ52OiMiqqqc

[@sonjarice]

This is one of the most musically sensitive performances of the Prok 2 that I've ever heard. Most pianists bang their way through this piece and completely lose sight of the themes and phrasing in favor of showing off technical ability. Not so with this performance. Bravo.

[@ddd20120127]

한국 방문을 환영합니다.❤❤❤❤ 😊😊😊😊

[@Discovery_and_Change]

10:17 | 15:11 Tyrant entrance | 24:06 mysterious |

[@mathiashuth2284]

Ganz groß! Technisch perfekt, hochintellektuell, da kannst den Grobian Bronfman in der Pfeife rauchen!

[@АлександрЖихор-н7п]

Колоссально

[@강물처럼-s3d]

💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙

[@KarolKoechlin]

27:10 - 27:48 The tempest

[@robinmiller9865]

I have been a devotee of this majestic pianist since attending a recital she gave in London shortly after her supposedly 'controversial' win in the Chopin Piano Competition of 2010. Third placed was Daniil Trifonov so the form has been franked in no uncertain terms!

[@ВладимирУ-т3ц]

Человек, в умирающей империи, создаёт прекрасное произведение.

[@ВладимирУ-т3ц]

🤷

[@Dylonely_9274]

10:50

[@ronaldbwoodall2628]

All the drama and excitement in this score was fully evident in this performance, even if some of the wit and charm inherent in it may have been missing. It's a valid concept I suppose, but here some of the slower passages seemed to fall apart. I think some faster tempos might have helped the music's cause; other than that, it was a very enjoyable and effective rendition.

[@kelownapianoconsult5354]

There's nothing falling apart! This is a spiritual and highly sensitive rendition of this dark music, to which the pianist is eminently suited. Unfortunately, some piano athletes, male and female, have made it more of a competition. There is so much colour and subtlety in the piano part and in the orchestral score that begs for elucidation - which is given here in spades. This pianist has perhaps the most beautifully resonant sound you'll find anywhere. And the amazing thing is, she got the SAME SOUND on the Yamaha at the Chopin competition. It was the first time I was able to forget that the piano wasn't a Steinway. She's top shelf, artistically!

[@williamlandolfi2729]

⁠ This performance of the magnificent 2nd Prokofiev Concerto is superb!!! Yuliana is an amazing pianist,with extraordinary sensitivity, we were moved to tears listening to such an artist.Bravo,Yuliana,we love you!!!

[@eva9691]

No te olvides de Martha Argerich !!

[@eduardobeserra]

3:00

[@philippebrun5182]

Yulianna come from space

[@Ylleeelle]

Юлианна браво 👏🏻 Вы прекрасный профессионал, очень чистая красивая музыка

[@josephnoelsolina982]

27:08 - 27:10

[@ddd20120127]

👀

[@Desireyso58]

I can't translate that! So, excuse me sir!

[@sminpark5113]

radiant intelligence and passion

[@RechtsstaatBRD]

Ich wette, dass die meißten die am Ende so frenetisch jubeln während des Werkes sich eher gefragt haben: Warum habe ich nur dafür Konzertkarten gekauft und nicht für einen Mozart, oder Was ist das eigentlich für Lärm, oder Wo bin icih hier eigentlich. Immer dieses inflationär gewordene Herumgröhlen nach Konzerten. Aber mir hats ziemlich gefallen 🙂

[@bubffm]

Hä?

[@felixalbrecht4197]

Jo niemand versteht musik, nur du bist hyperintelligent und einfach besser als die anderen

[@RechtsstaatBRD]

@@felixalbrecht4197 hab ich das irgendwo behauptet?

[@felixalbrecht4197]

@@RechtsstaatBRD ja

[@RechtsstaatBRD]

@@felixalbrecht4197 Bitte mit Zitat belgegen!

[@poturbg8698]

A pianist I generally admire, but this is technically right at the edge for her. Try a performance by someone like Bronfman and you will hear the difference.

[@bubffm]

Bronfman?? Ya, heard him on this live a few years ago. He mushed over it all. Not even close to the level of clarity and detail on display here 👍

[@Joe1935429]

@@bubffm Agreed! Technical brilliance quite worthy of Prokofiev.

[@bubffm]

@Friedpoor Clietzsche Completely agree 👍

[@JasonSiaPiano]

I adored Bronfman's sublime performance.

[@gianni4955]

Talent and skill have nothing to do with kilograms.

[@TreasureX7]

Скерцо слишком замедленно. Я так тоже потяну . Звучит как этюд Черни, сыгранно без блеска, тускловато. Такое впечатление, что это пересказ какого-то выдающегося исполнения.Студентка-отличница , не больше, но молодец, раскрутилась и много работает конечно, это не шутка, поддерживать форму, пополнять репертуар. В общем молодец, также по такому исполнению хорошо разучивать произведение.

[@galinaparfenova9187]

Да, громко!!!Только это утомляет,слушаю как человек,который не знает и не играет сам концерт С.Прокофьева.Она хочет извлечь звук такой мощности ,который не соответствует ее натуре...Зачем?Не спорю,что она хорошая пианистка,но что касается души.....Ее победа была спорной !!!и навсегда останется таковой!!! Дальнейшая карьера Д.Трифонова это подтверждает!!! Не слышала,чтобы Ю.Авдеева пользовалась такой популярностью,как Д.Трифонов.Одно дело играть С.Прокофьева и другое дело играть И. С.Баха,С .Рахманинова,Ф.Шопена...С.Прокофьев-это другая специфика и соответствует натуре Ю.Авдеевой.

[@danutagrossmannova4205]

На мой взгляд, Прокофьев - это ее "сказка". Oна играет убедительно, трогательно и на высоком техническом уровне. Y нее есть темперамент на эту музыку! Сегодня она играет Шопена, прекрасно понимая его стиль и показала свой потенциал на конкурсе 2010 года. Сравнение карьеры пианистов не всегда отражает уровень их игры, потомy как карьера складывается из многих обстоятельств в том числе и немузыкальных. Авдеева и Трифонов - два великих пианиста, но они разные и просто некрасиво так писать об Авдеевой, потому что ваши критические замечания не имеют под собой никаких оснований. PS kzbin.info/www/bejne/f6OaZaSjgLFjZtU Осталось ли у Вас мнение после такого концерта?

[@nickw-dt7jz]

not good

[@TreasureX7]

Some what

[@johnvalentine4720]

What not good? The music? The performance? Either ways you're taking the piss I presume.

[@sashan2764]

средненько, оркестры че то в европке скатились. видно по трансегендерной квоте набирали и поддержке либеральной повестки, Юлька зря старалась